Critical Race Theory has become a hot topic in recent months, especially after Andrew Gutmann, the father of a 12-year-old girl, made public his letter to his daughter’s elite Manhattan prep school. In the letter he accused the school of trying to “brainwash” kids with woke philosophies rather than teaching them how to think on their own.
In this episode we invite another parent Yiatin Chu, mother of two, to share why CRT is such a controversy, its impacts on students, and what parents could do to fight against the communism ideology indoctrination happening at schools nowadays. Yiatin is also Co-chair of the NYC Chapter of FAIR, an organization founded just couple months ago to combat CRT in schools and promote “civil rights and liberties for all Americans”.
Hi, welcome to Focus Talk. Critical race theory has become a hot topic in recent months,
especially after Andrew Gutman, the father of a 12-year-old girl, made public his letter to
his daughter's elite Manhattan prep school. In the letter, he accused the school of trying to
brainwash kids with woke philosophies rather than teaching them how to think on their own.
Today we invite another parent, Yating Chu, mother of two, to talk about this issue with us. Yating
is also co-chair of the New York City Chapter of FAIR, an organization founded just a couple
months ago to combat CRT in school. Hi, Yating, great to see you. Great to see you.
Well, Yating, this is an important issue and it raised a lot of attention recently,
but a lot of people may not even know exactly what's going on in our school system. So first,
what is critical race theory? Why is this such a controversy?
Well, I try to make it a little bit easier for parents and the average person to understand,
you know, they talk about woke schools. I think in a nutshell, it's really about infusing
everything through, you know, in thinking about race as being really the dominant way of looking
at people, both in terms of race, gender, sexuality. Those are the ways in which people
are categorized and they really want people to look at the world and look at what is being taught,
systems and policies in terms of a racial view. I mean, I think that's probably the easiest way
for most people to understand it. I think the next level of how people talk about CRT is really
who is the person that is at the oppressor and a victim. So that's another way of looking at
it is who's on top, who's on the bottom. It's always kind of the struggle of, you know, someone
who is at a role of being in control and someone who is being subjected to that power. And a lot
of this is in terms of race. I mean, there are other ways in which, you know, people who believe
in this woke philosophy want to see the world, but I would say race is probably the most dominant way
of people looking at this. So are Asian students oppressor or victims according to this category?
Well, I think we've been called white adjacent. So that is a term. And being white in the CRT
world is, you know, it's really not good. They think of anyone who is white as someone who is
an oppressor, someone who is going to exert their privilege on other people. And how Asian
students and Asian families are seen in the CRT is that because of some of our success,
and specifically in education, we've been called white adjacent.
So the oppressors should be condemned. So basically, for example, are they teaching
kids that if you're white, if you're Asian, when you see, let's say, a black student,
should you apologize to them? Or like, do you need to feel guilty? Is that what they're teaching?
I think there is a lot of what they call white privilege, white privilege, or your privilege,
this type of talk. And it's just ridiculous, because a lot of Asian Americans, especially
in New York City, Asian Americans are the poorest community in New York City. And I think it's just
so misguided and, you know, really offensive, actually, to be called white adjacent. I live
close to Chinatown. And I see, I see the elderly, I see young mothers, I see children, many of these
are immigrants, and some of them have been living here for generations. I see bottle collectors
hauling bags of, you know, cans and bottles. And for me to think that we are being called
white adjacent is ridiculous. I mean, I actually take offense to the racism that not only are they
putting towards Asians, but they're putting towards whites. I mean, when did it become
acceptable to be racist to any race? You know, whether you're white or Asian or black or Hispanic?
You know, I came here in the 70s, and we're taught to really respect everyone, to really
judge people by who they are, and not based on their race. And now things are being turned around
to judge everyone by their race. Now, I was reading this report about Andrew Guttman's letter
and what's happening at Brary School, and there's this picture of the school, basically the
courses. And this whole page, I think, are related, like courses related to race. So could you give us
a couple examples? What are the courses? What are the name of the courses? Well, I think
I'm not as familiar with what was taught in Brary, but I can tell you something that I've heard
recently from public school parents. This parent was sharing how his child was in an AP calculus
class, and they spent, it's a 30-minute class, and they wanted to talk about the idea of motion
in calculus. That was what they were covering. So they brought in this New York Magazine article
about subways, New York City subways, and it turned into a whole discussion about how the
New York City subway system is racist, because there are more subway lines available in wealthier
white neighborhoods than there are in other communities. So here we go. They should be
learning about calculus, and they end up spending 23 minutes out of a 30-minute class on a detour
in talking about New York City subways and why it's racist. And maybe in another subject matter,
you may want to bring in some of these ideas, maybe in social studies,
but calculus, I mean, what you end up doing is talking about something else and not learning
calculus. Wow. There's just a lot of obsession with talking about race, talking about gender.
This is the same friend who happens to be listening to his child's classes, because
a lot of New York City schools are doing remote. So that's one of the benefits, is parents can
actually listen to and sometimes see what is being actually taught in the classroom.
And in physics, there was a slide that the teacher was sharing that said that,
did you know that Newton is actually not just a regular straight man? Why is that important?
Why aren't we talking about the contribution of these great people instead of talking about
what race they are, what their sexual identification? I mean, it's kind of ridiculous.
I used to not like remote learning, putting kids at home for so long, but now I see the biggest
benefit of the remote learning. So that's how parents discover what's being taught at school.
Now, when did you find out that they're teaching this thing at school?
Well, I would say my introduction to CRT wasn't necessarily what was being taught in the
classroom. The way I came to really understand CRT was really at a very, I think, a simplistic way.
I stepped into education advocacy in talking about and advocating for the specialized high
school test, the SHSAT. And I was wondering, what's going on here? I'm a graduate of Bronx
High School Science. I took this test four years after coming to this country.
When I went to the school back in the 1980s, the early 1980s, it was a very diverse school. I mean,
we had Asians, we had Hispanics, we had black students, we had white students, really everyone.
And honestly, I wasn't really even paying attention to students' race back then. I think
now they've made it so, I don't know, like everyone's being judged. Everything is being
looked at. Every picture you look at, every classroom you look at, people are looking at
it by race. And it's just an awful thing to have to think this way. But getting back to how I came
to this, so a lot of the admissions at these selective schools, including New York City
specialized high schools, as well as some of the other exam schools around the country,
were being targeted for being racist. They saw disparities in terms of the student population,
and many of them are majority Asian, whether it's in Boston, New York City, in Fairfax, Virginia,
as well as in San Francisco. Many of these selective, nationally renowned high schools
do use tests as part of their way of admitting students. And all of these schools are being
targeted. And I didn't really understand why. But what they were trying to do is they didn't
like the fact that the outcomes of the admissions process gave disproportionate racial students to
majority Asians. And that is why all of these schools were being targeted. And I'm thinking,
well, what's so wrong about that? The admissions are fair. You're taking a test.
These are objective tests that really doesn't have any racial aspect to it.
But they were being targeted, really seriously targeted by national organizations. A lot of
people put a lot of energy into tearing and targeting these schools, lobbying with elected
officials in all of these states. And this year, many of these schools became lottery.
So for some of the parents that were just really in it about admissions, started to read a little
bit more and understood that what was going on right below the surface that were pushing these
policies was about critical race theory. It was about seeing the world through the outcomes of
disparate racial demographics. For supporters of CRT, they say it's about equity, it's about
justice. So some of the examples they give are number related. For example, in this ABC report,
they cited some data that shows that among eighth grade students, 44 percent of the white students
are deemed proficient in math, while only 14 percent of the black students
are deemed proficient in math. Then another study shows that black K-12 students are 3.8 times
more likely to receive suspensions than white students. Now, do these numbers tell you that
there is systematic racism in our education system? I think there are a lot of things behind
those numbers. First of all, it's really terrible that we're not educating our children in this
country. In New York City, half of our students are not at grade proficient, and there are really
significant disparities among the students by the student's race. So we're seeing that in New York
City, where 70 percent of the students in New York City who are black and Hispanic are not
proficient at grade level. Now, why is that? Is there racism? Of course there's racism in this
country. There's racism in New York. There's racism that we face every day. But to say that it's only
racism and nothing else is just not true. There are many things that go into why students are
not performing at grade level. There's definitely unequal curriculum, unequal schools,
unequal opportunities in New York City. You know, I can't speak for the rest of the country, but I do
know that access to accelerated opportunities, such as our gifted and talented programs, are not
equal across our school districts. There are school districts that have four or five gifted
and talented programs, and there are school districts where we have none. So if you don't
have these opportunities for students in predominantly black and Hispanic communities,
how are you going to be able to, you know, educate them and really take the ones that have the most
potential and be able to give them the challenges that they need to accelerate? So I think there are
a lot of reasons for that. Racism may be one of them, but I think, you know, there are other things
such as a supportive family, the home life. You know, let's not forget that while our kids are in
school for, you know, seven hours a day, the rest of the time they're, you know, they're at home.
They're in after-school programs. They have the weekends with their family. All of that time needs
to be considered as to why certain students do better than others. So you're saying that,
okay, so in some cases there may be racism, but it does not equal to systematic racism.
I think that we have a, especially in New York City, you know, I don't know what it's like across
the country, but I would say, you know, being an immigrant here, you know, did I feel racism when I
first came here? Absolutely. I would say it was probably more egregious from other children just
because, you know, they don't know any better. These are young kids and kids can be mean.
But as a whole, going through the New York City public school system as an immigrant, as someone
who didn't even speak English when I first started, I would say it's actually a very good system,
a very caring and open system. I don't think that there are systematic racism built into our New
York City public schools. Now, will you have teachers that may have prejudice? Absolutely.
You're going to see that anywhere in this world. We're all humans. We come with some biases,
our lived experiences. And through education, I think people, you know, become, you know,
broader and more accepting and really kinder in terms of how they look at the world.
So I think there are things that we can improve on. But to say that, you know, students aren't
performing because our schools are racist is just, you know, it's just too blunt and not true.
Yeah. And if it's a system racism country, you won't have so many immigrants wanting to come
to this country. People don't come to a country where they know that there's this, you know,
wicked systematic racism in place. Right.
But on the other hand, well, let's talk a little bit about equity, this concept of equity.
Oh, my goodness. This word is so overused. I'm so tired of hearing this word.
I don't know. Yeah. I don't even know if sometimes when people use it, they really
they know what it means. You know, there are families, immigrant families, families that
are in extreme poverty that are going through a tough time, whether it's, you know, whether it's
a temporary thing, they need a little help. And, you know, for instance, this year,
our schools went remote. There are families that don't have multiple devices. They may have one
computer and they have a family with three kids. They don't have devices. Their Internet is a
little spotty. To me, equity would be making sure that everyone had access to the tools that they
need to be able to access remote learning. That to me is is one one way that I like to see equity
is is access to opportunities, access to basic needs. That's equal opportunity.
Yes. What you're providing is then an equal opportunity for the student to access,
you know, learning. And we as a a city that spends over thirty thousand dollars per student
should absolutely make sure that all of our students can access the education they need.
Now, what I don't like is equity being used in terms of, well, we don't like the fact that,
you know, specialized high schools are a majority Asian and we need to change that by
implementing policies that will, you know, cut Asian students in half and make sure that from
a racial standpoint, it reflects our entire city. Look at the as I said before, the the performance
and the great proficiency of our students are are not equal across the board. It turns out that I
think a lot of Asian families with a focus on education, a lot of them immigrants, know how
important the education is for their children to really as a stepping stone for social mobility.
They put a lot of emphasis on it. And if they don't think that the neighborhood school that
they send their children to is is not, you know, of the highest quality, they do supplement that
with going to tutoring programs. Yeah. A lot of it, you know, part of it is the lack of confidence
that the school is teaching them what they feel like they should know. And the other is, you know,
they know some of the schools and some of the neighborhoods are just not that great.
And to be able to be competitive later on, you know, with the rest of the city, with students
that may go through Catholic schools or private schools, they know that they need to do a little
bit more. And they do get some extra help outside of the public school hours. So, you know, it's
time. So they're putting extra efforts. It's almost like what Chinese says, no pain, no gain.
Yes. But then I hear a lot of people, actually a lot of immigrants, too, comparing what's going
on in the American education system to what's going on back in China during the Chinese Cultural
Revolution period. Andrew Guttman made that comparison. And then I heard another parent in
New York City, another Chinese-American, Dong Huizhang, you might know him, right? He's running for-
Yes, I do know him. Yeah. So he said the same thing. He said the plans for the school diversity
in New York City all focus on the outcome. And they sound too much like mouse policies to me.
What are your thoughts on this end? Well, I have to say, you know, I didn't actually learn
so much about Asian or even Chinese history, having been educated here really for most of my
adult life. I received most of my education here, so I can't really. But I do hear that from
from my friends who, you know, lived in China, are now in the United States,
or friends that are very well-read about Chinese history. I'm not probably the best well-read on
Chinese history. But they do compare it in terms of some of the indoctrination
that we're seeing in schools, you know, pushing a narrative and also shutting people down that
is very much what they describe as what they've seen in the Chinese Cultural Revolution,
in other parts of the world where such things, you know, exist. So I have heard that comparison.
Yeah. Yeah. Back in the Cultural Revolution time period, even nowadays, you know, the Communist
Party, often what they do, one common tactic they do is to separate people in different groups.
And some groups are oppressors. And some groups, and the rest of them, then the rest of the crowd
can do whatever they want to that oppressor group. So that's how persecution starts,
you know, starting. First they said, oh, the wealthy farmers were the oppressors. Then they
said, oh, businessmen were the oppressors. Then intellectuals were the oppressors. So that's
how they actually stir people up and to pit one group against the other.
Yes, absolutely. I think, you know, the whole, what I find really just really sad about this
whole thing is, you know, these are neighbors, these are colleagues, these are classmates,
and people are really forced to look at each other purely based on their race.
You know, growing up in New York City, I have friends of all nationalities, of all races,
we create relationships, we, you know, relationships are built on just, you know,
the time we spent together. And if I had to look at everyone, based on whether, you know,
whether it's a black colleague or a white colleague, it would just create a lot of
anxiety, I think, for me to always be so, you know, thoughtful about the race issue and not about,
you know, what was going on between us. And I really don't like that. I think people need
to really be treated as individuals, as opposed to really being judged and looked at purely by,
you know, what they're born as. We can't change, you know, our heritage and what we look like.
But we can certainly, you know, be educated and be kind and speak to each other and respect each
other as equals. Yeah. And what happened to Martin Luther King's spirit, right? You judge
people based on the content of their characters. Absolutely. That's the foundation of FAIR. I mean,
FAIR, if you go to our website, the Foundation Against Intolerance and Racism, it is about
being pro-human. It's about looking at each person and going really, you know, as you said,
you know, what Martin Luther King wanted for everyone is to be able to be judged by the
content of their character and not the color of their skin. And, you know, all of, you know,
what you showed is our board of advisors. These are great leaders in each of their fields who
have stood out and spoke up against what is happening. And we're hoping that will attract
more members, parents that are seeing this happening in their schools and be able to
know that they have, we have each other to depend on and to create resources so that we can fight
back. Yeah. So what is, what is your organization plan to accomplish? Well, I think, you know,
we're just starting out. We have a lot of very prolific members that are able to write and share
this information. And as you can see, there is more and more information being shared out in
mass media. I think a couple of years ago was really more in the academic world that people
know what it is. Now it's being translated. People are seeing it taking place in their schools,
in their workplace. So, you know, this affair was launched just a couple of months ago.
The New York chapter, we're working hard and planning our first event so that we can bring
everyone together. And we have some things and some tools that we like to share with specifically
with parents, public school parents, that they can do to make sure that they understand what's
going on in their schools. You know, we're going to start with transparency. You know, you need to
know, you should be, you should be asking your school to let you know what is being taught in
your child's classroom. I think that's the first step. And I know that a lot of parents are very
fearful of speaking out. They're often called racist for being, actually being not racist,
right? I know. This word doesn't mean much nowadays anymore, because it's used. You're
placed anywhere, anything, basically. And you can just toss it out. You know,
oh, you're racist. And people just back off and not want to do anything. It takes very little
for people to just call you that. And it's very hurtful. It's not grounded in anything real.
And I think, really, I think the main reason why they say that is to really shut you down
and shut you up, so that you won't speak out about, about what is really happening and what
is truly racist that's happening in our schools and in our, you know, in our organizations across
the board. Yeah. So you're one of those brave, one of those very few brave parents who spoke up
and stood up. Did you meet any efforts that try to silence you or even cancel you? And what do
you do when you face those? I would say probably every day. There's certainly been instances
throughout. I think when I started speaking up for the specialized high schools, for admissions,
even before really understanding, you know, CRT, you know, for speaking out about, you know,
rigorous education, opportunities for acceleration, because some of these programs,
you know, right now, not 20 years ago, right now are, are over quote, overrepresented in terms of
Asians and whites. You're being, you're being, you know, talked about as if you're supporting
some system of racism, which is absolutely not true. We want these opportunities to be available
for all students of all races. And if, if we're not happy about where the demographics are today,
we need to really look at solving the problem, which is about fixing our, fixing our schools,
making sure that all kids are reading and doing math at grade level. Let's start there.
Yeah. So for parents who are, who start to realize this issue, who are worried about it,
and who may even want to fight against this kind of indoctrination in school, what could they do?
Yeah. I think one is pay attention to what your kids are learning in school.
Depends on your bandwidth as a parent, you know, you have a lot on your plate,
you know, a lot of things with the pandemic has changed, but you know, what are you hearing?
Ask them during dinner, you know, what's your assignment? What did you talk about today?
You know, any projects? What's the theme of the project? What are you being asked to write about
the topics of some of the essays? I think through just those quick conversations,
you can at least understand what's going on. Some of the older students are probably a little bit
more up on this and some of them will tell their parents, I don't really feel comfortable about
writing on this topic. Or there are things, conversations going on among our peers that just,
it makes me really uncomfortable because they tend to really focus on, you know, different groups,
different racial groups and so forth. I don't really want to participate in that. So I would
say one thing is to pay attention. The second is to talk to other parents in your schools
and see what they think. Because while, you know, you as one parent may feel alone
in going to your principal, if you can identify three or five other parents that have similar
concerns, the five of you then can go to the principal. I think that's part of why we're
organizing is for parents to find each other, to find support, to know that you're not alone.
And then to share information, to say, this is what's being taught. Are you seeing the same
things? Yes, I'm seeing the same thing. And one of the things that we're trying to do at FAIR
that we're working on is giving parents a way to communicate with the school system in a way that
is just easier for them. You know, so we're working on those things. We're hoping to share
that when we officially launch sometime in June. So you're saying parents actually have power and
they need to realize that they have this power. Absolutely. Parents have power. And I would say
that if you love your school, you love your community, but you don't like what is being
injected, you need to find like-minded parents and speak up. Look, I would say that there are
going to be parents that are going to be reticent about speaking up about some of the social
pressures within their schools. You know, I've heard parents moving their kids out of schools
from one district to the next if they really want to stay in public schools. And then there are
parents who we know have taken their kids out of the school system completely.
So whether it's, you know, from one private school, moving them to a different state or from the public
school system, possibly to a Catholic school system where they think that there's less of this going on.
Yeah, I think staying silent is no longer an option. It's an issue about, you know, about the
education, about your kids, and also about the future of this country. Absolutely. I think that's
really true. It is a very dangerous thing to allow this to, you know, breed within our public
institutions. And I think the really sad thing is that for many Asian Americans, for our immigrant
communities, we rely on public schools more so than any other communities, right? I mean,
70% of the students in New York City public schools are considered, you know, low income.
And that is definitely the case with our Chinese community in New York. Many of them are
non-English speaking, are low income. They rely on these schools. And so they don't really have
that many options to just pick up and leave or being able to afford to move out of the public
school system. So I would say we do need to stand up together and fight this and make sure that
the education that's happening in our schools are free from racism, are free from indoctrinating our
kids to look at each other based on their race and to be judged by their race. It's a really
dangerous narrative right there. And I'm hoping that by speaking up, by being part of organizations
and leading organizations that are going to push back on this will create a way for other parents
to join us. Yeah, definitely. I think it will. And all the best with what you do, Yating.
I totally agree with what you just said. It's too important issue to ignore. And thank you so
much for coming on to our program to share it. Thank you for having me. It's been a pleasure.
Thank you, Yating. We'll see you next time. Okay. Thank you.
Okay, everyone. Thank you for watching Focus Talk. We'll see you next time.