Go to https://ground.news/ddw to see through biased reporting. Subscribe through my link for as little as $1 a month or get 30% off unlimited access before Nov 5.
I had an amazing conversation with @ColdCaseChristianity about the impact of Jesus on Civilization through Music, Education, Art, Literature & Science (M.E.A.L.S). Wallace shows that the impact of Jesus is unparalleled by anyone else in History by a massive margin. In the video, Wallace brings to light the extent of Jesus' influence on the world as well as what this all points the researcher to regarding the age of question of whether Jesus was a myth, a man, or, in fact, the Messiah. God with us. Emmanual.
I am a fan, in some ways, of the work of Jordan Peterson, and I see him following these same
breadcrumbs to Christ, but from a psychological perspective where he's looking at Carl Jung,
who he loves, and he's looking at this idea of archetypes.
But the Jews should have also seen, this is the guy.
He actually personifies all of the different parts of the archetypes in one person.
The same way he personifies all of the expectations of the pagans in one person.
Those similarities are not an evidence against Jesus.
They're an evidence for Jesus.
This is what Tolkien and C.S. Lewis knew this to be the case.
Today we are talking about your more recent book, Person of Interest.
This book, I think, is awesome because of its focus.
Well, you know what?
Rather than me going into it, can you tell us, what is the thesis of this book?
The thesis is, this book, along with Cold Case and God's Crime Scene, are really kind
of trace my journey into Christianity because I did these three lines of investigation at
the same time.
Of course, not to the level that are in these books because people want me to cite the citations
and all that.
That's a whole other level.
But when you're doing it for yourself, you just need to satisfy that that's true and
off to the next thing.
My skepticism about the Gospels was, why are there only four?
I understand it now, but at the time I was such a kind of mainline skeptic about these
things that I said, look, if this is God incarnate, wouldn't you expect there to be more than
these four little documents from the first century to record this?
I mean, it's like if I'm going to throw this stone in the water, I would expect there to
be a huge ripple if the stone's actually a boulder known as God incarnate.
I would expect there to be this cascade of stuff about Jesus in the first century.
I'm looking for impact.
Now, what I think is interesting is you could make a case for Jesus being who he said he
was even if you didn't have any of the New Testament.
I know a bold claim to make because let's face it, we only know what we know about Jesus
from the New Testament.
I'm not arguing with that.
We have that data.
But I'm just saying, what if some evil regime came in and destroyed every Christian document,
every ancient papyrus, everything, just destroyed any gospel that ever existed, any letter of
Paul or Peter or John or Jude or anyone, they're all destroyed.
Every Bible that's been printed, all destroyed.
If you can imagine that weird world, it turns out you'd still know everything that you need
to know about Jesus just from his impact.
And that presents us, I think, with an interesting dilemma.
Now, in the book, I try to give it to you the same way I work no-body murders.
In a no-body murder, you don't have any crime scene at all.
The crime scene is empty because sometimes this happens where a guy kills his wife and
he then waits a week, he gets rid of her body, he's quiet about it, says that she went out
for something, never came home, maybe went on a trip, never came back.
I don't know what happened to her.
Then he got breaks a week, he goes into the police department, goes to the front desk,
he files a missing persons report, it takes two days to get assigned to a detective.
Now we're behind the case 10, 12 days, he's had a chance to clean everything up.
And the first investigator is working out like a missing persons, by the time I get
it 30 years later, there's not a single piece of evidence in the property room.
And I've got to figure out what really happened.
It was never investigated as a murder, now I've got to start to open a case.
Well, how you make these no-body murders is you say, okay, on the day of the murder, if
it's a murder and a bomb went off, I mean, explosive temper or whatever happened, something
bad happened that day, but I don't have anything from that day.
There's no evidence of what happened the day the bomb went off, but every bomb has a fuse
and it has shrapnel fallout afterwards.
It turns out if you didn't know what happened on the day of the explosion, you could determine
it just from the fuse and the fallout and that's what we do in front of juries.
We show them everything that led up to the day she disappeared and then all the stupid
stuff he did afterwards.
And from the fuse and the fallout, we can demonstrate that not only was she murdered,
but he was the one who did it.
And so these are all what I call fuse and fallout cases.
Well, you could work the person that something happened in the first century.
We call it the first century for a reason, even though it's not the first century, and
we call it because something happened that was worthy of our attention.
If you didn't know what that was, because every New Testament had been destroyed, you
could still figure it out from the fuse and the fallout.
So this book, Person of Interest, is just my effort to show you that the impact of Jesus,
look, there's only three options for Jesus.
He's either just a dude, a man, he is a lie, a myth, or he is who they said he was, the
Messiah, man, myth, or Messiah.
My friend Bryce Brooks wrote a book on this called Man, Myth, or Messiah.
That's a good way to put it.
He's one of those three.
Which of those three explanations best accounts for the evidence of his impact?
That's the question.
And then, of course, the question becomes, well, what was his impact?
So I had to look at the areas that I would have, as an atheist, because that's what I
was when I did this investigation.
I was an atheist.
And the things that mattered to me, I was an atheist with an art degree.
I had a master's in architecture.
So I was somebody who was an architect before I became a police officer.
And the things that I valued as an atheist would have been art, music, literature, education,
science, those five things.
No one has had an impact on those five things like Christ Followers.
I've heard you say this once before.
Can I recommend an acronym to help people remember this?
MEALS.
Okay.
What do you need, right?
Okay, education, art, literature, and science.
Oh, you little butthead.
You got it right.
That's good.
There you go.
And now, what does a culture feed off of?
It needs meals.
Oh, for crying out loud.
I have a friend who does this on our community, on our website.
He's going to be so upset that he didn't think of this acronym.
I can tell you right now.
But anyway, continue.
It's a good one.
Well, I mean, those things are important.
So I didn't mean to derail the train.
No, no, that's good.
That's good.
But I hadn't thought of that.
So yeah, I should have used it.
But I think sometimes if I use an acronym, it starts to feel like I'm just aiming at
the acronym rather than...
Exactly.
Are you fitting things?
Yeah.
And I was just so impressed by this impact.
For example, it's not as though there are no...
So I looked at the period of time, the earliest centuries of Christianity, or let's put it
this way, the earliest centuries of the common era.
And I used this.
I mean, I did a whole video sequence on this, where I used the BCE and CE.
And everyone writes to me constantly, why are you using those?
You should be BCAD.
But when I was first doing this, I didn't believe there was a BC and an AD.
So if I'm going to tell the story of how I examined this, you're going to have to start
off with my BCE, CE.
I would have said there's a common era, but why are we calling it the common era?
So I think for me, this is the best way to explain it, is that if you look at the first...
Now look, by the time Christianity becomes the religion of the largest empire on the
planet, the Roman Empire, I think the power corrupts.
And it often corrupts a lot of things, including your notions about God.
So I was only interested in the progress of Christianity up until Constantine.
Once it gets to Constantine, I'm like, yeah, who knows what...
All kinds of things can happen there.
What did the earliest people in the common era say about Jesus?
That was my most important and most interested focus.
So that meant I was stuck with those first three centuries.
And if you look at just the impact of Jesus, the number of documents in which somebody,
a voice, an ancient voice is recorded speaking about Jesus in the first 300 years,
there's a list of them in the book.
It's remarkable.
And just from the document, from the voices that are non-Christian voices,
if you didn't have any Christian voice recorded on manuscripts in the first 300 years,
but you did have the data that comes out of the mouth of a non-Christian,
you could reconstruct the Jesus story.
That's the kind of it.
And by the way, that cannot be said for any other historical figure,
but it can be said of Jesus.
Speaking of Jesus and speaking of culture,
you may or may not have heard about the sad story this past week,
where a man snapped the arms off of a Jesus statue outside of the historic Boston Cathedral.
The story obviously caught my attention.
I was curious about how various news sources would cover it.
You guys have heard me talk in the past about Ground News.
They're an app and website that combines news from local and international sources
around the world and offer a concise visual breakdown of the reporting outlets,
political bias, credibility, and ownership,
as well as who and how different stories are being covered.
So, for example, if you type in here, Jesus in the search bar,
you can see that 613 recent stories fit that search term, right?
At the top, you see this particular story about the man who desecrated a crucifix in Boston.
Interestingly, you can see that this story has been covered by 15 articles
and Ground News identifies that 48% of them were right,
another 48% center, and little to no coverage on the story from the left.
What I find particularly useful about Ground News is how you can easily compare coverage in one place
and start to see how narratives differ according to each source,
which can easily shape our understanding of that story.
So, for example, The Blaze headlines this story slightly differently than does NBC Boston,
also differently than The Boston Herald.
So, it's a very quick and easy way to understand the different emphases placed on a story
depending on the motives of a news source with additional context mainstream media doesn't show.
With Ground News, you can see this type of information for any story on any topic
so that you can think critically through these important issues
and can hopefully have a more productive cross aisle conversation in the process.
I encourage you to check it out at ground.news.ddw.
If you subscribe through my link in the description,
you can get 30% off unlimited access to all the features that I just showed you.
I really appreciate the support from Ground News as they share my goal
of understanding opposing perspectives.
So, go ahead and check them out.
The link is in the description.
Now, let's get back to my conversation with J. Werner Wallace.
No one, for example, has been written about historically in the last 2000 years
more than Jesus of Nazareth.
You can do that by a search, historical search.
You can do that at the Library of Congress,
which is the largest collection of printed volumes anywhere in the world.
You can do that by Google book search, which has now everything in it,
including self-published books.
And just take a look at who the people in history have, you know,
who's been writing about who.
What you're going to discover is that nobody has been written about more than Jesus of Nazareth.
And you can reconstruct his story from non-Christian voices
in the earliest centuries of the common era.
Now, of course, now, look, this is, be honest, if you wanted,
the earliest record of Jesus is the Gospels.
So, I'm just playing devil's advocate.
If I didn't trust the Gospels, what would I know about Jesus?
But I actually think you can trust the Gospels,
and that's what we already talked about from cold case Christianity.
But if you just play devil's advocate and you say, well, what's the impact?
Well, no one has impacted literature.
Nobody.
Not just, not just, now I'm talking about books that are written about Jesus.
But if you launch off into the theological principles
that come from a Christian worldview,
now you're really going to blow it out of the park.
So, I'm not counting those.
So, just know that this is a figure that you're going to have to account for
if you're looking at the history of literature, human literature.
But not just that, music is the same way.
Music is divided into historic genres and historic periods.
If you study music history, you'll see it divided.
And you'll see that there are leaders in each one of these
historic epic periods in music history.
And there are instruments that are invented,
and there's progress that is made in history.
And if you look at the top influencers in each historic period,
you'll be surprised to find they're Christians.
So, before Christians started, about why?
Because this is a singing worldview.
Jesus sang with his disciples at the Lord's Supper
because he's coming out of a singing worldview called Judaism.
You know, Psalms are songs sung by David and other psalm writers.
Singing is a part of our religious tradition.
We're even commanded to sing hymns and spiritual songs.
And that's why, where else can you go in the world where every week
there is a singer on a stage performing or singing to an audience?
That's called the church.
So, why would you be surprised then when so many singers,
even in pop culture, started off singing in the church?
It gives people an avenue, if nothing else.
But it turns out, because we have been singing as a form of worship,
you'll see that innovations like, how about musical notation?
Until a Christian invented musical notation,
we had to kind of memorize how the melody went
and then pass that on person to person.
Now we've got musical notation, thanks.
We have musical harmonies, thanks to Christians.
We have minor scales and major scales, thanks to Christians.
Most of the instruments played even in pop music are thanks to Christians
because these were invented for purposes of worshiping.
And you see this in this.
So I traced that, of course, as a matter of fact, if you were to go
and look at the Billboard top 150 artists in the last 100 years
and look at the Rolling Stone and look at IMDb,
just look at those top artists.
And they're in every genre, from rappers to rockers to whatever,
Black Sabbath, all the way, you name your artist.
If they're in the top 150 now, they'll make that list.
So I took those three lists and I compiled a master list.
And then I went through the catalog of that master list
and all but two had sung a song about Jesus.
Some of them are quite pejorative.
Some of them are quite negative, but he provokes, he inspires.
He's on the lips of singers more than any other historical figure.
His followers have contributed to the discipline of music
more than any other historical figure.
And he's sung about more than any other historical figure.
But it's not just that.
The arts are the same way.
And that was my passion was in the arts before I became a police officer.
And art history is also divided into isms, genres, impressionism,
expressionism, dataism, popism, whatever the ism is.
And if you were to look at all the historic advances in the arts
and look at the top three masters in each ism,
surprisingly, they've all painted, sculpt, etched, or drawn Jesus of Nazareth,
even if they're not a Christ follower,
because he is the kind of figure that inspires.
And if all you had was the music from the first three centuries of the common era,
and you had the transcripts of what was being sung,
you could reconstruct the story of Jesus in its entirety.
If all you had was the art up till about the dark ages,
or the middle ages, we call this now, or the early middle ages,
you could reconstruct every episode of every gospel
because it's painted, etched, or sculpt somewhere in the world.
And you'd have to destroy those surfaces, by the way,
in order to get rid of the Jesus story.
Go ahead.
This is just a parenthetical.
The flow is amazing, and I ought not interrupt it,
but I just want to make this one observation,
that what these people who are creating this art,
Christian art, and who are composing these symphonies,
and who are even—I know you're going to get into some of the sciences too.
We'll get there in a second.
But I want to make this observation.
What Christians are saying today,
and have been saying for 2,000 years,
is not just, we believe that those stories that took place are true.
We believe those things,
and because this is a character in a book that we like,
we're going to write a song about him,
or we're going to paint this character in this book that we like.
That's not what it is.
The testimony of Christians is,
he has personally changed my life.
I believe with my head that he is risen from the dead,
but I experience with my entire life that I know him,
and that I was once lost, but now I'm found,
that I was once blind, but now I see.
And Christians have consistently said for 2,000 years,
Jesus is the person who changed my life.
And I just want to say, that's a crazy piece of evidence itself,
that you have a consistent personal attestation to the fact
that this allegedly risen person, Jesus,
millions and millions of people have said,
no, don't hear me out.
I'm saying for me personally, he has been the one who done it.
For me personally, I don't care about a character in a book.
I'm talking about my life.
And that, I just want to highlight,
that is the inspiration of the art and of the music.
It is the personal impact of Jesus on the individual.
Yeah, but the skeptic in me says, I don't care.
You might get that, Oprah Winfrey can change your life.
Doesn't mean she's God.
Here's my claim though, as the skeptic,
is that if you're saying, okay,
and keep this in mind as you listen to this,
that of the three options, you cannot imagine,
there's no other, you tell me who it is.
Who is the fictional character?
And we've only talked about the three things now, right?
Art, music, literature.
Who is the fictional character that has inspired this much,
has influenced art, music, literature, science,
and education like Jesus?
Tell me who it is, don't run out.
People say all the time, well, a fiction, but who then?
Give me an example somewhere in history
of a fictional character that's had this much impact
that the entire story of the fiction can be reconstructed
from literature, art, music, education, and science.
I'm still waiting for that.
So there's good reason to believe he's something
other than fiction if you can't imagine
how a fictional character could do such a thing.
And you have no example anywhere else
of any fictional character doing it.
But also, tell me who, what human,
what human has ever had this kind of impact?
And we'll talk about that more in a minute,
on literature, art, music, education, and science.
You won't find another human.
So there's good reason to believe
he's something other than human.
Of the three options, man, myth, or Messiah,
the evidence will show you he fits the third category
better than the first two.
And that's why I say this actually is part
of the larger overarching cumulative case.
This isn't the entire case.
The entire case rises and falls on the stuff I wrote
about in Cold Case Christianity.
Did the resurrection occur?
But if it did, I would expect him to have the kind of impact
that he had on history.
And that's the difference.
And I don't trust, look, here's why I don't trust.
People say, well, okay, people are inspired by Joseph Smith.
That's a lie.
I'm sorry, folks.
Mormonism is not true.
You can be changed by something that's not true.
And that's why I don't trust anyone
who provides their testimony that's not attached
to the evidence for why they think
that's what really happened.
I'm more skeptical than that.
And I think most of us as Christians are too.
So let's just continue for a second.
If all you did was visit the top 10 universities
in the world today, because they're on a list,
there's several lists you can type in,
top universities in the world.
You get secular lists of the top universities.
Oh, unsurprisingly, they were all founded by Christians
because the modern university as you know it,
where you have a resident faculty that sees visiting,
you know, attending students who are then awarded a diploma
when they complete a certain course of instruction
for certain degrees.
That is a Christian invention at Bologna, Oxford, and Paris.
Yes, the ancients had other ways to educate themselves,
but the way you think of the modern university,
because if you've attended a modern university,
that's Christian.
And that turns out, by the way,
that's why the top 10 universities in the world today
were all founded by Christians.
You could take every other group
and look at all the universities and colleges
of higher education founded by Christians
and compare them to the number founded
by every other group, whether they're atheist or Hindu
or Buddhist or Jewish or whatever it is,
we will outnumber them tenfold.
We've closed more Christian universities
than the other groups have opened.
We have owned education because this is a teaching,
like it's a singing worldview,
it's also a teaching worldview.
Jesus said, not go and make converts,
go and make disciples doing what?
Teaching them all that I've taught.
Oh, that means we got to start by teaching?
Yep, you just inaugurated a teaching worldview.
In which you're gonna have to figure out
how to teach the masses.
And that meant often to preach the gospel,
you had to give them a language in which to preach it.
You had to invent an alphabet in order to write it.
You had to educate people.
And then eventually, pretty quickly,
that included work skills
as well as just biblical knowledge.
And then you've got the modern university
came out of the cathedral schools
and the monasteries and the Christian movement.
And if all you did was visit those 10
or all the top universities,
I think 75 of the top 100 are all Christian.
The other ones don't have any stated original purpose.
But those, if you go to their charters
and look at the charters
and read the words in their charters,
if you go to their buildings
and look at their buildings
and see whose images are image on those buildings
and what verses are on those buildings,
you could construct the story of Jesus
just from the buildings
in the top universities in the world.
Because that's the kind of impact he had.
And I also talk about in the book,
all the other secondary
and primary educational developments
that are a part of the Christian historical tradition.
No one has had more impact on education
than Christ through a Christian worldview
teaching the world.
Last thing, sciences.
All the, I mean,
we have a tendency to think
that Christians are all anti-science
and it's true that today,
a lot of folks are not Christians
who are doing science, clearly.
And I think that's a shame.
It's a shame on us
because it wasn't that way.
It doesn't need to be that way today.
The, all the science fathers,
the people who initiated
the major modern disciplines of science
from astronomy to chemistry to quantum mechanics,
believe it or not, I've got a list of them.
I think over 900,
almost a thousand scientists in this book listed
that are Christ followers.
And they founded the,
every major discipline in science
has been founded by a Christian
and we don't even know it.
More Nobel laureates in the sciences
are Christ followers
than all the other groups combined.
Yet we have a tendency to think
that there is no Christian doing science.
You know, you had James Tour on your show.
So, you know, that's just not true.
You can hold, these folks held to the story,
the view of Jesus,
of the divine view of Jesus
that's on the pages of the New Testament.
They believed in miracles.
They believed in his deity.
They believed in his resurrection.
And if all you had was the personal writing,
I'm talking about all the way,
just up to the scientific revolution,
going to late modernity,
going to the current days.
If you take the writings of Christians
who are leading in the sciences
or have led in the sciences
and look at their personal journals
and letters to one another,
they are writing about more than science.
They're writing about Jesus.
And if all you had was the personal writings
of the science fathers,
you could learn more about Jesus
than you can from the church fathers.
And I demonstrate that in the book.
Here's my point.
No one, it turns out that Christianity
opened up a certain way of looking at the world
with an orderly, rational God
who governs yet is distinct from his creation.
This view of God
changed the way people saw the natural realm
and opened the door to the sciences.
It was a catalyst for the sciences.
This is why the sciences
in the scientific revolution
emerged in Christian Europe.
Why?
That wasn't the largest body of people
by any means.
It wasn't the oldest
and most historic culture.
Why didn't the sciences leap off
in a greater way in Persia
or in Egypt or in Asia?
Why?
It happens because there's a worldview in place
that catalyzes the investigation of science
as a way of writing into the book of nature
as a way of examining.
And by the way,
Muslims had a huge impact on the sciences also,
but it stopped 12th, 13th century.
The momentum which they picked up is stopped
and largely because of Muslim leaders
who took a view that if it's not in the Quran,
there's no point in investigating.
But that hasn't been our view as Christians.
We believe there's a book of special revelation
in scripture
and a book of natural revelation.
These two things are never going to contradict.
And if they do seem to be at contradiction,
we're either misunderstanding something
we're seeing in the natural realm
or we've been misreading something
we've been seeing in scripture.
And our willingness, for example,
to say, yeah, the sun's not actually rising.
That word sunrise is an anthropomorphism
from our perspective.
It's not that the sun is rising.
It's that the earth is turning
and we can read it differently.
Even though NASA today still records as sunrise,
NASA knows the sun's not rising.
This is an expression that's still used today,
even by people who know better.
Well, that was happening in the New Testament
and the Old Testament.
So I think in the end,
our willingness to see the two forms of revelation,
the book of scripture, the book of nature,
and work to see the revelation of God in both
has kept us in the sciences.
And we can decide now for political reasons
or cultural reasons,
because we're mad at scientists
and we're mad about the vaccine or blah, blah, blah.
We can decide if we want to step away from all of it
and just say it's another area of exploration
that we don't trust.
Or we could encourage our kids
to do what generations of Christians have done,
which is to lead in the sciences.
And that's what we need to do.
Now, the point is,
if you look at,
and I don't even talk about this stuff as an atheist.
I was not concerned about how Jesus impacted
other theistic worldviews,
but that's another category I look at.
Everyone has embraced Jesus.
Everyone loves them some Jesus, okay?
If you're a Hindu, your leaders love Jesus.
If you're a Buddhist, your leaders love Jesus.
Baha'u'llah love Jesus.
If you're a Baha'i,
you can go to all of these systems,
these theistic systems,
they make room for Jesus.
Islam makes room for Jesus,
but Jesus doesn't return the favor.
That's interesting to me,
is that it's because Jesus says,
I'm the only way to the father,
except through me, no one comes to the father.
And that would make sense, right?
If there's a cure for tuberculosis and it's isoniazid,
you might think it's Tylenol or NyQuil or Advil.
But if there's one true cure for what's killing you,
then it makes sense that the other ones would just be,
we could sincerely believe in them,
we can sincerely want them to be true.
But typically, and this is a good example of that,
there's one cure for what's killing you spiritually.
And as much as you may want to use the other cures,
if they're, and by the way,
these contradict each other.
The claims of Advil are not the same as claims as isoniazid.
They have completely different claims.
So none of this stuff may cure TB,
or one of these things might cure TB,
but they can't all cure TB.
So the same thing is true here.
These make opposing claims.
One of them could be true, or they could all be false,
but you cannot say they're all equally true.
And Jesus knew that.
And so he made the claim because it was true.
He spoke as God.
He didn't speak for God.
He actually spoke barely, barely.
I say to you, he doesn't say the Lord,
your God says, or Lord Almighty says,
no, he says, I say, because he's speaking as God.
He claims to have the power of God, the authority of God,
the ability to forgive sins,
the ability to judge the living from the dead.
He makes these claims because he claims to be something
other than a man or a myth.
The third option, Messiah,
makes the best sense of his impact
and the best sense of his claims.
One thing that I think is really interesting is
if you trace all of what you just laid out
in terms of art, science, literature,
like all of those meals, if you will,
if you trace those things back upstream,
or I guess to use your metaphor,
the ripples back towards the origin source
of that rock falling into the pond,
the rock of offense, the cornerstone,
and you look at what he actually said was going to happen
and what he predicted would happen
in the record of history,
that is pretty wild because he basically talks about
the kingdom of heaven in his parables,
and he talks about the smallest little thing
becoming the biggest tree that the, you know,
even the birds of the air come and rest their branches in.
He tells them to go out into the world
and to preach the gospel,
to go to, you know, Judea and Samaria
and to the ends of the earth.
He casts this vision for the spreading,
flowering kingdom of heaven,
and we have that vision that we can read
from 2,000 years ago,
and then we can actually trace, like you said,
and see those ripple effects.
And we can actually see,
and it's a lot more than that too,
because we haven't really talked about actually
like the missionary movements,
even the improvements in terms of like sanitation
and basic things like that,
or the gentling of the barbarians with St. Patrick,
or when David Livingstone went into Africa.
There's so many threads that you could follow
that show the whole,
the like all-encompassing positive benefit
of people who have been imagers of Christ
and believers in Christ that have gone out.
Well, let me say something about that
because you're absolutely right.
I didn't trace a bunch of stuff for a reason.
I traced only the stuff that I thought
he had an impact on, right?
Then from which I could reconstruct his story.
That's the thing that's interesting about this.
Got it.
It's not just that he impacted art, literature,
music, education, and science in the world religions.
It's that he impacted a lot more.
He impacted medicine, for example.
The entire medical movement we have in the world today
is largely from the people who are most willing
to touch a leper in the first century.
Those were Christians.
But here's the problem with that
is that libraries and schools don't change.
If you're at a university,
you want to preserve your oldest buildings
to show how antique you are
and how authoritative your ancient school is, right?
The older and more antique these buildings are,
the more kind of gravitas it gives your school.
So they retain those buildings.
But if you're building hospitals,
you're tearing those things down every 10 years
and building the latest technology.
So I can't go back.
I cannot go back to a hospital from the first century
and recover the information about Jesus
because that thing has been replaced
for scientific, for technology reasons
over and over and over again.
But yes, there's a bunch of stuff.
But I was just interested in kind of the stuff
that's in the fallout of a criminal trial,
a criminal investigation.
I'm looking for the stuff that the killer
left evidence in that fallout.
And there's some things
he might've destroyed altogether.
I can't use that,
but I can look for what he's left the evidence in.
So there's a bunch of stuff we didn't talk about
because yes, Jesus had tremendous impact on those areas,
but there's not a remaining artifact
that I could look at to reassemble his story.
And that's what I was trying to do in this book
because the argument is,
there's no one else in history of people
for whom you could say
that if the primary documents recording his life
were all utterly destroyed,
you could still reconstruct his story robustly
from his impact.
That's the thing that's interesting about Jesus.
And if you think there is,
then tell me who it is.
And you're gonna find somebody
who maybe had some impact on one of those areas.
But these are very diverse areas.
Literature, art, music, education, and science,
and then world religions.
How much different can you be?
Yet every one of these areas,
the stuff that as an atheist
that you probably love and respect the most,
literature, art, music, education, and science,
you wouldn't know them today
the way you know them today
if it hadn't been for Christ followers
who took them from zero to 50.
And so I think in the end,
that to me is something you have to account for.
Now, is it evidence by itself?
No.
But when you put it in with a larger case,
you know, the next book I'm writing
is just from biblical anthropology.
It turns out there's evidence
in the way you and I behave
that demonstrates that Christianity is true.
But I think a lot of that
is just part of a larger cumulative case.
It's like Lewis says,
that once you have your scene through this lens,
everything you see starts to make sense
because you now have the proper foundation.
You understand why it is the way it is,
not just that it is.
Speaking of Lewis,
Lewis and Tolkien,
their depth of knowledge about myth
and the epiphany that they had collectively,
I guess individually,
but they talked often about this in The Inklings,
that when humans sit down to write a fairy story,
as Tolkien put it, or a myth,
regardless of century or regardless of culture,
we will generate these common themes.
We're not sharing notes.
We're not looking at the person next to us
to get the right answer to the test.
Human beings generate everlasting love,
a hero who lays down his life for the many.
And Tolkien, in an essay called On Fairy Stories,
elucidates these common themes.
And the zeitgeist documentaries
that were popular 10 or 15 years ago
look at these same predictive expectations
about what would happen
to dying and rising savior and this and that.
That is in the milieu of that time period.
And I remember when I was in high school thinking,
oh my goodness,
Christianity is a copycat of other religions.
And then I remember-
How many times has that been said?
Yeah.
And how many times has that been said?
But then I remember studying Tolkien and Lewis
and realizing, oh my goodness,
God has planted the true story
into our imagination and into our hearts.
And when we write imaginatively
or with no strings attached,
we write a fairy story, if you will,
out of our soul comes the true story of the Christ
who would become flesh and walk among us.
And to me, that is one of the deepest things,
one of the most interesting things.
And I've heard you talk about this idea
of when the expectation is met by the expector.
So I'm leading you into that,
and I want to get to that.
But you hit Lewis,
and I thought that there's the thread to take us there.
Like most of the stuff that we talk about,
Lewis already said it better.
He wrote a better book.
He said it better.
A lot of the quotes that people will attribute to me
are me quoting Lewis in my books.
It's really frustrating, right?
You cannot outdo this guy.
That's just how smart he was.
But the reality of it is I felt the same way.
It never struck me as an evidence against Christianity.
It never did.
It struck me as an evidence for Christianity.
Here's my point is that, yes, even today,
if somebody says, well, I don't believe in your God,
but I believe there's a higher power.
Okay, well, tell me what's he like?
He's going to give you a list
of what he thinks that God is like
based on his expectations for God,
his understanding of who he is as a limited creature,
and who God might be as an unlimited creature.
And he's going to say things like,
he's probably all powerful.
He probably works miracles.
He can break the bonds of science
or the bonds of naturalism.
He probably shows up in the world
in some supernatural miraculous way.
He's going to be like a just,
like he's going to have,
everything's going to be on the maximum, right?
He's going to be the most just creature.
He's going to be like a king
or like royalty.
All of the features that you see,
he's going to be able to defeat death.
He's probably somebody who can help us defeat death.
Okay, these are the common attributes of anyone,
whether ancient or modern,
who is thinking about a higher power,
even if it's undefined,
even if it's just a higher power.
And so you see these throughout the centuries.
I went back to all of the mythologies.
I read through all of them.
I assembled a list of 15 commonalities.
I could have done 20,
but it gets to be where you're really
trying to stretch to get some of these.
So for example,
of the common mythologies that are used,
they only share at the most about 10
of these 15 attributes.
And there are slightly different
combinations of the 15.
And some only share as many as four.
So how many more do I want to add?
15 is probably a good number.
Well, so if you look at these 15 common expectations,
and I described them,
and then you look who possesses what?
Buddha possesses just as many as Osiris.
Some of the exact same ones.
No one's saying that Buddha
is a recreation of Osiris.
Because they recognize that,
although they may have come into the world
in a supernatural way,
they're not very similar
in how they came into the world.
They may have defeated death,
but some guys do, some guys don't,
but they haven't defeated death
in a way that is very similar.
But there's an expectation that if there's a God,
he probably can defeat death.
So if you look at all these through history,
only one being possesses
all 15 expectations
that moderns and ancients have about God.
That is Jesus of Nazareth.
He's the only being who has all of those.
So the question becomes,
well, isn't that interesting?
And Lewis puts it this way,
is that the ancient stories,
the ancient myths are humans,
poets' myths,
poets' stories about God.
Jesus is God's story about God,
because it's the real story about God.
Those are the invention of poets.
This is from the mind of God.
And if you see Paul
and kind of think that through
and have that in your mind,
as you read through his speech on Mars Hill,
oh, it kind of makes sense.
He says, you people are very religious.
You got all these monuments to all these gods.
Like he gets it.
Paul's like, yeah,
you're going to guess something's right.
But we saw God.
Let me tell you,
let me reveal to you who he really is.
And I think you could blow people away
in that climate,
because all of your expectations about God
are met in their perfection.
It's not just the non-Jews,
the pagans and their pagan mythologies
that are set the table of expectations
for the coming God.
It's that the Jews had a series
of patriarchal archetypes.
If I was to describe certain elements
of the Moses story,
you'd think I was talking about Jesus
or the David story or the Jonah story
or the Joshua story.
You'd think I was talking about Jesus
because the typing,
the Jews should have also seen,
this is the guy.
He actually personifies
all of the different parts
of the archetypes in one person.
The same way he personifies
all of the expectations of the pagans
in one person.
Those similarities are not
an evidence against Jesus.
Right.
They're an evidence for Jesus.
Yes.
This is what Tolkien and C.S. Lewis
knew this to be the case.
It's interesting because you can come
at this too from a psychological perspective.
And I am a fan,
in some ways,
of the work of Jordan Peterson.
And I see him following
these same breadcrumbs to Christ,
but from a psychological perspective
where he's looking at Carl Jung,
who he loves,
and he's looking at this idea of archetypes.
And he's seeing these archetypes reflected
also in the person of Jesus.
And I don't know if you're familiar
with the interview where he actually cries.
And he's like,
this is a horrifying thought.
If the myth,
if God put on flesh,
if the Logos put on flesh
he begins to cry.
He says,
this is horrifying
because it would mean
that we would actually have to reckon
with the words of God.
It would take God out of the realm of the abstract,
and it would make his words
words that we have to reckon with
and actually live by.
And I really see Dr. Peterson
as being like Lewis was
in the few year period
before his conversion.
And I hope,
and I pray in Jesus' name right now,
that that does happen for Dr. Peterson,
because I would love to see that happen.
But it's interesting
because you can get it
from that psychological vantage point.
Also, I'm sure you're familiar
with Joseph Campbell
and the hero with a thousand faces.
And that's another angle
into the same idea, though,
of it can be repackaged and repurposed,
but human beings will get back
to this Christ-shaped hero.
And I just think it's fascinating.
Yeah, you're absolutely right.
And I think that part of the problem, too,
is like we talked about in the past,
you and I,
that the first step into this direction
is in the first step of any learning.
If you look at the studies
that have been done on people
who are really good learners,
they learn quickly,
they get great grades,
and they can easily distinguish
between a good argument
and a bad argument.
Well, there's one attribute
that opens the door
to that level of understanding,
and it's an attribute
that is pretty ancient.
But only in the last 35 years or so,
they've done studies on this,
and it's called humility.
That attribute of humility
is what produces the...
Because if you're going to learn something,
that means you've got to admit
that you don't know the answer.
Like, I don't know this,
so I'm open to learning it.
That's an act of humility.
So here's what it's going to take
for any of these folks
that you talk about
who are in the secular world
or who are in the world
who are talking about these issues.
We have to pray for humility.
And you can kind of tell
when you listen to some people talk
that that is the biggest obstacle they have
is that they think they know everything.
And if you think you know everything,
there's nothing new I can tell you,
even something new about Jesus or about God.
You can actually kind of
become your own source of authority for everything.
And so what we have to actually be praying for
is that at some point,
people will realize
that if there is an infinite God,
he is infinitely wise,
and he might know something more than we do.
And we have to be open to the possibility
we don't know everything.
And so that's what the first step
that Christianity requires.
That's fantastic.
Are there any ripples rippling out from the rock
that we haven't hit yet with our remaining time?
Well, I think those are the big ones.
Now, we didn't, like you said,
we didn't talk about those ones.
We can't trace like things
like just the studies that have been done
in terms of generosity and charity and service
and volunteerism and a lot of other things
that the Christian worldview has impacted dramatically.
And so I think that we don't talk about those
because I cannot then go back and find the artifact
I can trace back to Jesus in terms of content, right?
Because I wanted to be able to do that for this book.
So again, here's what I would say to people.
We have to ask the question,
which of the three options, man, myth or Messiah
best explains the impact that Jesus has had on culture.
And that just becomes one piece
of the larger circumstantial case.
So again, we have to at least be willing.
You'll get a thousand people,
a thousand ways to reject the truth.
And that's what I think is interesting.
We talked about last time about God.
He would allow us the freedom to reject him.
And that's just something you have to do
because it's logically impossible to create a world
in which love can emerge without free agency.
Free agency is the dangerous prerequisite
that must be created so that you can genuinely love.
And if there is a God who is love,
according to the New Testament, he is love.
Not that he can love, not that he can create love
or he can enable love, that he is love.
That kind of God is going to create a world
in which love emerges, but you gotta be careful.
That kind of world is dangerous
and it can even be dangerous for you
because it allows you the free agency
to say, nope, not for me.
I'd rather think this.
And so we have to at least recognize the fact
that sometimes the thing that's stopping us
from the truth is not the truth
or the lack of evidence for the truth.
It's the fact that we are free
to chase whatever we wanna chase.
And so last thing, the gospel, it turns out,
fixes every kind of stupid you can think of.
It fixes educational stupid and marriage stupid
and parenting stupid and cultural stupid
and national, international conflict stupid.
Any kind of stupid you can think of,
it's addressed by the gospel.
We simply have to be willing
to allow the gospel to do its work.
And so sometimes what you and I are doing
in a show like this or on a channel like this
is we are simply trying to knock down the obstacles
that are standing between people
and the truth of the gospel.
Can we unpack that idea just a little bit?
I know we're almost at the end of our time,
but just what you just said there,
the gospel, basically, what do you mean by that exactly?
Or can you give some examples of that?
So you're saying within marriage, within society,
how, I guess would be my question,
how does that play itself out?
A couple of ways.
Number one, the problem we have,
I hate to say it because no one wants to hear it,
it's a sin problem.
It's that our fallen nature is such
that we are our own worst enemy.
And the solution to sin is not for you to try harder
because trust me, your fallen nature is such
that every time you try harder,
you're just gonna create a whole new body of sins.
It's forgiveness.
It's forgiveness through the creator
in whose image you exist to begin with.
So part of it is that because the gospel addresses
the problem in each of us innately,
and then we are the problem in all those scenarios,
in our marriages, in our parenting,
and in all the international conflict.
We are the problem, it's pride.
Pride is behind every form of stupid you can think of.
And the antithesis of pride is humility.
And it's when you humbly embrace the forgiveness of God,
this changes the way you see yourself.
It changes the way you act in the world.
Because now we're the one worldview, theistic worldview.
Think about this, when we say,
hey, when you accept Jesus as savior,
he doesn't come alongside you and fight your battles.
He doesn't come alongside you.
No, the Holy Spirit resides in you
and becomes a change agent in how you view your spouse
and how you view the other.
You can try this on your own power.
That's not going to work for you.
Trust me on this, it's not going to work.
Let's put it this way.
Sometimes we think, well, just guidance.
If we had better guidance, we could guide ourselves.
Really?
Have you ever been someplace where you're lost
and you don't have your phones, not working?
You're in some foreign country.
And the guy says, yeah, just go down here, make a left,
two more rights to make another.
That's a one-way street, don't go the wrong way.
Make a U-turn there at the circle, come back up.
You're already lost.
I'm trying to get guidance,
but I can't remember everything you just said.
On the other hand, he could say,
you know what, I'm going there too.
Let me hop in the car with you.
And he hops in the car with you.
And now you're both going together.
When we get to that first left, he just tells you, make a left.
I don't even need to know what the next five turns are.
I don't care.
I'm not operating on guidance anymore.
I'm operating with the guide present.
So we have to move toward the guide
if we want to solve the problems that are in the world,
including the problems that are in our own marriages
and in our own lives.
So that's the first part.
The second part is identity.
Is that if when you're right now as men,
we are constantly trying to form our identity in our work.
Just forget about men or women.
All of us as humans are trying to form our identity,
usually in our achievements and our relationships
in our professions and how much money we're making
and how we see ourselves compared to others.
We are like Babel.
We are basically citizens of the city of Mam.
And we're trying to find our identity.
And we're just cat scratching each other
and trying to climb all over each other
to get to the top of that pinnacle.
Our identity is not in the right place.
And every time your identity, it takes a hit,
you will suffer trauma.
And every time you've suffered trauma,
your identity took a hit.
And if you put your identity in things that change
and are fluid,
you will always be on a rollercoaster of trauma
or a rollercoaster of challenge
or a rollercoaster of reinterpreting yourself.
If you put your identity in something
that's transcendent and unchanging,
then anything can hit you.
You can take any gut punch
and realize that my identity has not changed.
Oh, I used to see myself as somebody
who could run marathons.
Now I'm not that person anymore.
Well, if your identity isn't running marathons
or performing at a certain level,
then get ready to be disappointed pretty quickly.
You ever watch people retire from the NFL?
Not pretty.
We struggle with these things.
It's an identity issue.
But those who have put their identity in Christ
don't struggle nearly as much
because their identity isn't something that's unchanging.
So there's a way in which your identity in Christ
and accepting the forgiveness does two things.
We struggle, most of us, with guilt and shame.
Those are two different things.
Guilt is feeling bad about what you've done.
Shame is feeling bad about you.
Guilt should lead us to the savior who forgives.
Shame can lead us to the savior
who's willing to give you his identity.
Everything changes.
So I think in the end,
this worldview we offer
is not just a way of thinking academically,
it's life-changing.
And if all you wanted was your best potential life,
Christianity will lead you there.
That's fantastic.
I can't think of a better note to end on.
This has been awesome.
I really appreciate it.
And if people want to actually hear more from you,
well, first let me say this.
Folks, he's got two books.
They're great.
When I think about a conversation like this,
if you're listening to this,
I anticipate that there's questions
from what we've said that haven't gotten answered yet.
Even in how long have we been going?
An hour?
Even in an hour-long conversation,
you can only cover so much.
We've really just scratched the surface.
And so I highly recommend anyone still listening to this,
if you're listening this far into the video,
that means your attention was kept.
That means you're into it.
That's good.
Go check out his books
because they're going to go that much deeper
and probably address some of the gaps
in a conversation like this,
which is just free flowing.
But the books will give you something
in a more systematic way.
So I highly recommend that.
And then also, where can they find you on YouTube?
Okay, so coldcasechristianity.com
has got the links to all of our social media
and YouTube.
We're also just called Cold Case Christianity on YouTube.
But yeah, so that's the best place to find our work.
So coldcasechristianity.com
is the Christian worldview through a detective's lens.
We have a flip of that
because I do a lot of work with police officers.
If you're interested,
you're a cop and trying to figure out
how do I survive in a culture like this right now?
Well, the cop worldview,
the cop profession looked at
through a Christian worldview,
just the opposite,
is at thethinbluelife.com,
thethinbluelife.com.
Fantastic.
Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Appreciate you.