Siyamak sits down with John Moorlach, former California State Senator and Orange County Supervisor. He will talk about the latest report on how California counties and cities are doing financially, why the state is getting late on providing the reports and how it impacts.
"Based on what we found 55 out of 58 counties are right now upside down. We have close to $200 billion in unfunded or unrestricted net deficit. Yet the legislature and the governor are signing budgets without even having solid financial data on how their state is running."
Based on what you found, 55 out of 58 counties
are right now upside down.
You have close to 200 billion in unrestricted net deficit.
Some cities and counties have been really delinquent
in releasing their financial statements.
My guest today is John Morlock,
former state senator and county supervisor in Orange County.
He's been ranking California's cities and counties
and how they are doing financially
for the Epoch Times newspaper.
Today he's here to discuss with us his rankings
of the cities and counties in California.
Also, he's gonna tell us the challenges he's faced
on collecting this information.
My own profession as a CPA, I'm really disappointed
with the Government Accounting Standards Board
for not requiring these things earlier
because what it did is it allowed unions
who pretty much work on a philosophy
of getting more benefits, they could do it in the shadow
because all the elected leaders
that were voting for this, they wouldn't see it,
the accountant wouldn't come by and say,
hey, did you realize you just added $6 billion
to your balance sheet in debt?
I'm Siamak Khorrami, welcome to California Insider.
John, it's great to have you back on, welcome back.
It is an honor to be back with you, thank you, Siamak.
John, you have been doing this accounting work,
serious accounting work, going and analyzing
all of the counties in California
and a lot of the cities in California
and ranking them for us, for our newspaper, Epoch Times.
You've been publishing these articles
telling us how each county is doing
and you have found some really interesting examples
and things that are going on
that we would love our audience to know.
Can you tell us which counties are doing well
and which counties are not doing well
and what you have found?
We have 58 counties in California.
We look at the basic financial statements,
which usually comes right after the auditor's opinion
as you go through the pages
and then we look for the unrestricted net position
of the county or city or state.
So you divide the population
into the unrestricted net position
and you get a per capita
and that allows you to kind of rank.
You know, you should all be within a range
and it's supposed to be a positive number.
You're running a business,
if you have assets that are lower than your liabilities,
then you are a bankruptcy candidate.
When you look at the counties,
I think almost 55 of the 58
have unrestricted net deficits
as opposed to unrestricted net assets.
Somehow the county or the municipality agency
has run up debts that are greater than the assets
that they actually have on hand.
So they have less money than what they owe.
Correct.
And less, so essentially they're upside down.
They're upside down.
They could go under anytime.
You know, you've been really good
about having Jim Doty in your shows.
He's predicting a recession.
So a good recession will really,
as they say, kind of blow the sand off of everything
and you'll start to see that cities
will have a difficult time paying their liabilities,
especially because a good portion of those liabilities
are the defined benefit pension plan
that they're in with, say,
California Public Employee Retirement System,
call it CalPERS.
If the economy's down,
then their investment returns will be down,
which means that in the future,
the municipalities will have to make larger contributions
to catch up for the losses that were generated
in their overall diversified portfolios.
So then things get really, really interesting.
We've already had three cities in California
that have filed for Chapter 9 bankruptcy,
which is how municipalities file for bankruptcy.
A private sector would file Chapter 11
and that gives them a chance to go into a federal court
and work with a federal judge who says,
hey, welcome, contracts at the state level
don't matter here,
so you can reevaluate your retiree medical plan,
which we call other post-employment benefits,
and you can reevaluate
your defined benefit pension plan structure.
We can change all of that going forward if you want to.
And so that's what the city of, say, Stockton did.
It filed for Chapter 9, San Bernardino and Vallejo,
also for the same reasons.
But Stockton, what they did is they actually eliminated
the retiree medical plan altogether.
It had a liability of $500 million and they just canceled it.
So all the employees that were anticipating
lifetime medical benefits, gone, just gone.
But Stockton went from the bottom of the list
to near the top by just going through Chapter 9
and removing that one liability.
So John, based on what you found,
55 out of 58 counties are right now upside down.
Correct, correct.
And let's say Orange County School Districts, we have 28.
They're all upside down.
You know, the cities, we have 34,
about half are upside down.
So we have to start being concerned.
You know, what's going on?
What's the debt?
Can the municipalities actually maintain
their debt payment structure
and still provide public safety,
good roads, good personnel?
And out of the counties that you ranked,
which ones are the worst and which ones are the best?
Well, Little Alpine County is in last place,
which is unfortunate.
I just remember asking for Modoc County's
financial statements back in 2012
and their auditor controller wasn't available,
but I had to give the secretary a toll-free number back then
because they couldn't afford
to make long-distance phone calls.
So you can kind of see that there's something going on,
but San Mateo is at the top.
It's a pretty wealthy county
with a healthy assessed value for their property.
So, and for Orange County,
92% of the revenue that Orange County gets
is property tax-based.
So you want the real estate market to do well,
which it is right now.
When it starts to slow down for multiple years,
it'll start having some difficulty.
But I did it first in 2012.
I was gonna be chairman of the Board of Supervisors again.
We were gonna be going into major negotiations
with most of our bargaining units.
And we had lost $1.7 billion to Bob Citron back in 1994
when the county went bankrupt.
So it really took a dramatic toll
on the finances of the county.
So I kind of thought, well, where are we?
So when we did this range,
Orange County was number 46 out of 58 counties.
And so I had to message that and said,
okay, unions, you can come and we can negotiate,
but remember that we're still digging out.
We are near the bottom
and we have to start making changes.
So Orange County, unlike the other 57 counties,
made a major modification to the retiree medical plan.
We reduced an unfunded liability of $1.4 billion.
And with the agreement of the bargaining units,
we reduced it to $400 million.
And we reduced our annual required contribution
for that debt, which was $100 million.
We reduced that payment by $100 million a year.
So every year, the county had an extra $100 million
just by negotiating,
which would allow us then to get some raises.
We also made some pension reform changes in Orange County.
We tried to get new formulas for new hires,
something that Jerry Brown followed
a few years later in 2012.
We made some requirements that all employees
pay for their pension portion,
because it's a shared cost.
The employee should have some withholdings
and the employer should match.
So now, if you look at the list
that we just published in the Epoch Times,
Orange County's in 24th place.
So you can move up the rankings,
but you have to make some serious fiscal decisions.
And out of the big cities in bigger counties,
the more pronoun ones like San Francisco
and Los Angeles and San Diego, Sacramento,
how are these counties doing?
Well, Alameda, which is ironic,
is one of the top two counties.
So San Mateo and Alameda are the top two.
And then Napa.
But the city of Oakland is in Alameda County.
And Oakland, out of 482 cities, is near the bottom.
So when you land in Oakland and you rent a car,
the rental agent will tell you to not go to 7-Eleven
or not leave anything in your car.
Don't leave any valuables that are visible
through your window.
Now we're seeing so many cars being popped open,
and then they check the back window,
and then they pull the seat over
to see if you have luggage inside your trunk,
and then they pop that open.
And San Francisco, too, also near the bottom
of the list for county and cities.
And so you can see that they don't have
as robust a police force.
And so so much is happening because these entities
are spending so much money to pay for pensions
and for retiree medical.
And in terms of what you found,
so these financials that you were able to get
were old, right?
They were like a few years old, right?
Well, they're behind because some cities and counties
have been really delinquent
in releasing their financial statements.
We received Imperial's 2021 Annual Comprehensive
Financial Report in May of this year
because the predecessor auditor-controller
who's responsible for issuing county financial reports
actually was convicted of embezzling money from the county.
And so we lost that auditor-controller.
They fell behind.
Humboldt County was the last.
And Humboldt's at the very top of the state
with the city of Eureka on the coast.
Beautiful, beautiful county.
But their auditor-controller just sort of
just didn't do her job.
So it's kind of hard to believe that some accountant types,
because I am a certified public accountant by background,
that they would just not be focused
on the deadlines and the rest.
So we just finally issued the 2021 report.
We hope to get the 2022 for you in January,
which Humboldt will try and get their 22 done.
But 22 should have been done in December of 22.
Not here, we're almost December of 23.
So it's been very lax.
States are a little late.
Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico.
I just got New Mexico's.
But California has been dramatically late every year.
It's a national joke.
How late is California?
We won't probably see their 22 financial report
until April of 24.
So in two years almost.
Almost.
A year and a half.
And yet the legislature and the governor
are signing budgets without even having solid financial data
on how their state is running.
And California is 41st place out of 50.
So it's in the bottom 20% of states.
It's sort of a sad, sad story when you have
close to 200 billion in unfunded
or unrestricted net deficit.
Now, did you see any other strange things
when you were doing this auditing,
when you were looking at the audited financials?
Well, what I do in the last column I provide for you
is, what was the change?
Did they go up?
Or did they stay the same?
Or did they go down?
And we kind of look at, or I look at something.
If it moved like five places or more, what actually happened?
City of Tustin actually sold some land and got a lot of cash.
City of Mammoth Lakes recently, or in the last go-around
I'm looking at, had just a really good year.
And they spent a whole lot less.
I mean, they stayed with their budget,
but they must have had a lot more skiers show up,
or who knows what.
Because this season was really good, right?
Probably dramatic.
But this is two years ago, right?
Right.
This is 2021.
Yeah.
So we're trying to catch them up as quickly as we can.
Hopefully, as the Epoch Times publishes the lists,
and it says 2021, that maybe some people will call Humboldt
and say, you know, you're embarrassing us
by not getting your financial reports out in time.
We have a new state controller, Ms. Cohen.
You would kind of hope that maybe the first thing she would do
is get these things done sooner.
You know, I contacted Arizona and Nevada,
and they both kind of apologized that some
of their departments haven't gotten all their stuff
to the auditor yet.
The Government Accounting Standards Board,
unlike the Financial Accounting Standards Board
that all the publicly traded companies
and all the private sector has to report to,
the Government Accounting Standards Board
did not require putting pension debt liabilities
on the balance sheet until 2015.
So all of a sudden, in the 2016 report, 2015 report,
you see these big liabilities pop up.
The California State University system, and all of a sudden,
you look at 2012, 2013, 2014, positive numbers.
2015, boom, underwater, and by like $6 billion
that they didn't put on their liability section
of their balance sheet.
But in 2018, they had to report their unfunded retiree
medical.
And I think that popped up to another $13 billion.
And all of a sudden, you can see the chart.
If you did a chart, you didn't have a chart,
you could see a dramatic drop.
And so my own profession as a CPA,
I'm really disappointed with the Government Accounting Standards
Board for not requiring these things earlier.
Because what it did is it allowed
unions who pretty much work on a philosophy of getting
more benefits, they could do it in the shadow.
Because all the elected leaders that were voting for this,
they wouldn't see it.
The accountant wouldn't come by and say, hey,
did you realize you just added $6 billion
to your balance sheet in debt?
And this is how we're going to have to structure it.
Folks, you've probably been hearing me talk about WireEFI
for a while now.
WireEFI has been getting a ton of phone calls from you.
And I thank you for supporting an investment that
actually helps people.
A lot of people are talking about this investment.
And I like to review the basics with you.
First off, yes, it's true.
You can earn up to 10.25% fixed rate of return.
That's not correlated to the stock market or to the Fed.
You can turn your income on or off,
compound it, whatever you choose.
And there are absolutely no fees.
There are no restrictions on your principal
if you ever need your money back.
And you'll get your monthly statement with no surprises.
If you are not sure if you can trust this economy,
this secure collateralized portfolio
may be a very good option for you.
Just go to investwirefi.com.
That's invest, the letter Y, then refi.com.
Folks, I take my endorsements very seriously.
If you're looking for a solid investment that helps people,
contact my friends at Wirefi,
and then tell them CMI Karami sent you.
Now let's go back to the interview.
And now, based on what you saw,
was there some strange cases of fraud or embezzlement
and things like that as you were doing,
as you were looking at these?
Sometimes I call and they go, who are you?
Why do you even want to know?
And it's sort of like, really, really, you know,
you have to ask me who I am.
You should have this stuff on your websites
so your residents can figure it out.
And you say, okay, do I want to buy a commercial building?
Or do I want to buy a home?
And you look at the price and you say, okay,
if I buy a $1,000,000.2 home,
are you going to pay $1,000 a month
just in Prop 13 property taxes, right?
1%.
And if the city's not functioning properly,
you buy an expensive home, but don't get police backup.
No one's watching Chilean gangs or whatever,
you know, could be affecting a neighborhood.
You're not going to feel comfortable
going to the shopping center
because there's homeless people kind of harassing you
or whatever it could be.
I mean, that doesn't seem, you know, to make sense.
What about the LA area?
How are the cities doing in the LA area?
Did you, you did an audit of-
Yeah, you've got 88 cities.
We have one that still doesn't have their 2020
financial statements audited yet.
They're still in process.
Called them again this morning.
Which city is that?
That's Huntington Park.
And, you know, trying to do a little research,
it's hard to find a lot of news on Huntington Park,
but talking to my friends in LA, they said,
oh, that city has been corrupt for years.
You even go onto their website and there's a assemblyman,
Reginald Sawyer Jones, who's asked the state auditor
to come in and do an audit of Huntington Park.
So there's been a fiscal mismanagement there.
There's interesting cities.
We've had Bell in LA County that had a city manager
that said, hey, if I'm going to get a pension on my salary,
then I need to raise my salary
because that's part of the formula.
And he was able, through various funds,
to crank up his salary to $900,000 a year.
You know, so that he could retire
and make a million a year just not working.
But, you know, look at Los Angeles.
It's near the bottom, but it has, you know,
at least it's not really close to the bottom.
They're working real well.
But say school districts, LA Unified School District,
it has unfunded liabilities for retired medical
of $15 billion.
There's a district that's near the bottom
of some 940 school districts.
So that's one, you know, that you'll want to watch.
The irony is, is that their average value per parcel
is very high.
And who is supposed to oversee
these cities and counties' financials?
Is it the state auditor that's going to,
has to overlook all of this, or?
They're supposed to receive the reports.
The controller is.
The state auditor, actually,
after I started doing my rankings,
started doing something similar.
So they have a dashboard,
and they don't have all the cities either.
So I think they kind of gave up
on trying to get information from a lot of the cities,
which I haven't given up.
But it just delays me on getting things out.
But the other entity that should be watching
is the credit rating agencies.
So they should be monitoring,
should the city or county or state
have significant amounts of debt,
because they get rated,
and bondholders, they want to know,
you know, how's it going?
Am I going to get paid?
And so, for us average residents,
is there a reason for us to worry
about our city or our county?
Well, first, it's nice that The Epoch Times
provides these rankings.
It gives citizens something to look at.
But it's important,
because it eventually has an impact.
And one of the things that The Epoch Times
is doing by providing these rankings
is that no one should be surprised.
You know, if your city starts to say,
hey, we're having financial trouble,
we need to reduce, you know, police and fire or something,
you say, oh, look, look what's happened, look how,
you know, but it's important,
especially if you're going to make
some major financial decisions.
Real estate is a major financial decision.
But if you want to move there,
buy real estate, buy commercial real estate,
you have to pay attention to this.
Yeah, because you don't want to be surprised
by a parcel tax on top of your
1,000 a month in property taxes.
And you had San Francisco ranked near the bottom.
And San Francisco is struggling.
And they're already short on the police force,
but they're a rich city.
What are your thoughts on San Francisco?
Do you have any thoughts?
They're not a rich city.
Their balance sheet's upside down.
It's awful.
And now they've got a migration out.
Businesses are leaving.
Residents are leaving.
And so, let's say, next year,
they realize how bad it is,
and they file for chapter nine bankruptcy.
Will everybody be surprised?
Probably, but not you and I.
Because we always said, look where they're ranking.
Look how they're performing.
We call it media risk.
Look at the articles that are coming out of that city.
So that's why we do the rankings.
You have a little bit of a barometer.
They don't have a lot of staying power.
And so they're gonna have to rely on maybe borrowing.
That's what happened to the city of Anaheim.
They're in 33rd place out of 34 cities.
In Orange County, right?
In Orange County.
So you would think that Disneyland
should be like such a shot in the arm.
Cash, money, yeah.
All the, we call it transient occupancy tax
or hotel tax revenues.
It's a big chunk of change.
But when COVID hit,
Anaheim borrowed some $160 million
to keep operating through that mess.
And so they've got some real issues
on how to pay down all these liabilities
that have accumulated.
Sometimes you wonder whether Disneyland is a help
or it's a parasite.
Because it kind of controls the city council composition.
They're very involved politically.
But if there were any attempt
to raise a ticket sale tax or something,
they'd be there in a heartbeat to squash it.
But they're probably a big component
of the sad situation that that city's in.
So in each city, these special interests,
they have a big impact on that city.
Whether it's unions, whether it's developers,
whether it's some big businesses
that have a lot of influence over the city.
That's how it is.
Hawaiian Gardens, their biggest revenue source
is their card club.
Every city is a little different.
But yeah, who's calling the shots?
Now, in terms of how it is today,
versus you're an accountant,
you've been in this profession for many years.
Was it like this 30 years ago?
You almost have to go back almost 24 years ago.
In 1999, there was a bill, Senate Bill 400.
It was voted on at the very last minute
of the close of session that year.
And it was sort of mislabeled,
but it was the California Highway Patrol.
And they wanted to change their formula.
The stock market had done really well in 97, 98, 99.
We had the dot-com boom.
And so the pension system, CalPERS, was fully funded,
even a little overfunded.
And they said, instead of getting 2% at age 50
when we retire, we want to get 3% at 50.
And so a lot of Republicans voted for the bill
because middle of the night, they came back
and they didn't really read it and no one warned them.
And so they approved this new formula.
So because CalPERS can't really do math,
they didn't make it effective that day.
They made it retroactive to the day to hire.
So if you were going to retire the next year
and you had worked for 25 years
and you were making $100,000,
you would have gotten 2% of the 100,000 times 25 years,
would have given you $50,000 a year in retirement.
But because of this pension plan change,
it now gave you $75,000 a year.
And that 100% funded pension plan now became 2 3rds funded
because you added another 50% of debt.
So that's when we started going down a strange road.
Now, people are just children in adult bodies.
And so everyone else that worked for government said,
it's not fair.
We should have the same formula or something similar.
You can't always treat public safety great.
You also got to do the same thing
for general employees.
And so they did.
So now if you look at CalPERS,
even today, all these years later,
we're still just 71% funded.
They have not been able to catch it up.
Why are so many people leaving California?
It wasn't long ago, people from everywhere
wanted to move to the Golden State to enjoy a better life.
Sadly, the standard of living
has been dropping in the past decade.
Are you like me and wonder why this is happening?
I'm Siamak Khorrami, host of California Insider.
In our film, Leaving California, The Untold Story,
I take you an intimate journey of love, loss, tragedy,
and hope as residents face the prospect
of leaving their beloved state.
Everyday people like you tell their stories
about why they have to move out of the state,
even though they don't want to.
Experts and policymakers also give insights
about what's happening behind the scenes.
Together, we get to the root cause of this exodus.
Go to leavingcalifornia.com
to view the first 15 minutes of the film for free.
By watching Leaving California,
you can be part of the solution.
Again, go to leavingcalifornia.com.
Do you think we, there was a,
you mentioned it's going back to the 90s, late 90s.
Before that, would the unions and the government leaders,
was their working relationship better?
Yeah, yeah.
What was it like?
Well, you know, when you look before 1999,
when SB 400 was approved, everyone worked diligently
to meet their pension obligations for their employees.
And the formulas were reasonable.
They didn't exceed anything that you would see
perhaps in the private sector.
And it didn't force municipalities to,
or pension plans to get very aggressive
in investing in the stock market
or other higher risk investment vehicles.
You'll be looking at these financial statements.
Can you show us what they look like?
And I think your reporting has made it
inside some of these financial statements, right?
Yeah, yeah.
Thank you, Simeka.
It's a big document.
If you want to review your city's financial statements,
you're looking at a half inch thick bedtime read.
And it provides the financial statements,
a lot of management analysis, a lot of data on your city.
You can probably pick one up from your city.
This is the city of Cyprus, where I actually
lived when I was a child.
I lived on the dairy across the street
from what is now the Civic Center for Cyprus,
which was a dairy that I used to play on as a kid.
But they've done really well in managing their city.
And they were in first place for a couple of years.
In Orange County.
In Orange County, the 34 cities in Orange County.
And because they were in first place,
and I had mentioned that in the Epoch Times,
they gave me a little kudos, saying, hey, we were number one
in this ranking.
Now, a little story about Cyprus that, if we can fit it in,
a little business in Costa Mesa left Costa Mesa
and moved to Cyprus.
What no one really realized is that this little warehouse
was generating an enormous amount of sales tax.
And so that sales tax left Costa Mesa
and went to Cyprus, which I think
is what has really helped Cyprus improve
its financial standing, obviously more revenues.
But you know the company is Mary Kay Cosmetics.
And so it was selling all over the county,
but the sales were all reported in Costa Mesa
until they moved to Cyprus.
This is an interesting issue.
There's a lot of warehouses out in the Inland Empire
that are generating a lot of sales tax
for cities in the Inland Empire, like the city of Paris,
which was almost in bankruptcy.
And now they're doing much better
because of these warehouses that collect all the sales tax.
So just another little side story,
which is what you learn from analyzing these reports.
John Morlock, columnist for Epoch Times
and former state senator and former county supervisor
from Orange County.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
My pleasure, CIMAC.
Thanks for having me.
If you haven't checked out CaliforniaInsider.com,
we highly recommend you do that now,
because we're going to have a lot of news
and videos there.
And on top of what we have there right now,
we are building a really big platform
to cover what's happening in California.
So you can be informed.
We're going to have more shows, more videos
from all aspects of life in California.
Go to CaliforniaInsider.com and we'll see you there.