Did you miss the latest Ramsey Show episode? Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered! Get all the highlights you missed plus some of the best moments from the show. Watch entertaining calls, Dave Rants, guest interviews, and more!
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app.
Start budgeting for free today.
Mike's in Dayton, Ohio.
Hey, Mike, how are you?
Good, Dave and George.
I'll get right to my question.
I haven't heard, I've been calling you for about six months and we paid off all our credit
cards and now we're down to nothing but our mortgage, but I have two parent plus loans
for my daughters and they want to do that pay for play thing or whatever that's called
that extends them out, and I'm almost 59 and a half and I have $500,000 in 401k between
me and my wife and I also started a new job about five years ago and I was putting a lot
into that and I have about $125,000 in that and I was wondering if I should, when I get
59 and a half, if I should use that $125,000 and pay off them two parent plus loans.
How much are they?
One's $415,000 and the other one is $18,078.
I would.
Just pay them off?
Yeah.
Okay.
You are technically liable.
They are not.
I understand that.
They said they would pay them back, but.
But then they said they weren't.
Well, they're going to do that extended thing.
Well, that means they're never paid back.
You understand that?
Yes.
That's why I just wondered.
The extended plan is 30 years of not even making the principal payment.
Exactly.
Which means the principal is doubled.
No interest is paid and they don't even make a principal payment.
It goes backwards for 30 years.
I know.
I've been listening to you, yeah.
Yes.
Stupid government program.
The DMV visits finance class.
I mean, that's what this is, right?
Correct.
Oh God.
I mean, thank you, Joe Biden.
I mean, you can't string a sentence together and came up with this plan.
Oh my God.
It's horrible.
It's absolutely horrible.
No, no, no, no, no, no.
You're going to get stuck with it, dude.
That's what's going to happen.
So we might as well own that now and be done with it.
Did you have an agreement with the girls before they went to school that they were going to
pay these?
Yes.
And they paid on them, but they're going nowhere.
The $41,000 was originally $39,000 and the $18,000 was originally $16,000.
So they're going backwards on these already from when they took out the loan.
How long ago was that?
Oh, jeez.
One daughter is 30.
She graduated at 24 and she's 31.
Okay.
So we're coming up on a decade and what we've done is gone backwards.
So the way I analyze this is that pattern is probably going to go forward.
We just discussed that.
So how does that work out for Mike?
Well, that sucks is how that works out for Mike.
That's what I was wondering.
But you always say never take out your 401k, but I thought this might be a good time.
I don't take it out prior to retirement after 59 and a half, which you're talking about
where there's no penalty and you've got $500,000 or you've got $625,000.
We're going to pull $60,000 something out plus some taxes to cover these, right?
Well, I have my Roth.
I have most of it in a Roth.
So my Roth would be tax free.
I have about $44,000 in a Roth and the $18,000 would be, I would have about $15,000 I'd have
to take out of the standard 401k because yes, you know what I'm, the standard one.
Do you sense the cleanliness in your spirit of what I'm talking about?
Yes.
Because I just, I got my thousand, I paid off all my credit cards, which was 12,000
and now I'm stuck with, this is the only thing on my credit right now is this and my mortgage.
Obviously, I'm not worried about your credit, I'm worried about Mike and Mike's daughters
are not paying this.
That's what they announced.
We're going to not pay it.
We're going to pay it while not paying it.
That's what they announced because they signed up for stupid governments.
Trusting a 17 year old's good intentions to pay you back isn't going to cut it.
And so when parents sign on the dotted line for these, they don't understand what they're
doing.
They're potentially decapitating their retirement when they sign up for this and it's heartbreaking
to hear and, but Mike, this is a stupid tax that we just got to pay as we enter our golden
years and they're starting to look a little more silver and a little more bronze.
So what's the stupid new one called?
The SAVE?
The SAVE plan.
Which is absolutely the opposite.
Let's just stretch it out.
Yeah.
It's like the stay in debt plan.
They called, they nicknamed it SAVE, stands for some acronym, stupid, stupid asinine.
David can't say the second, yeah, there we go.
Stupid asinine.
Yeah.
I'm just, I'm thinking, oh God.
So, I mean, seriously, it's a 30 year plan and when they give you the thing based on
your income, it does not charge you any penalty or interest beyond what you're doing, but
it accumulates principle because you're not even covering the principle with the payment.
And you know, so you have to have a Dr. Phil moment with these stupid things and go, how's
that working for you?
You know, it's not, you know, you've been screwing around with a government plan since
you got out of school.
You're 31 years old.
It's gone backward $3,000 and you announced to your dad that the way you're going to help
him out and honor your word to him is that you're going to pay this, is not pay it again
and let it go backwards some more.
Now stick them with a higher balance than you started with.
Exactly.
Oh.
And that's the net, that's the net of this.
Now, these girls didn't know that.
They didn't think that through, but that's what happens when you believe in a stupid
butt plan coming out of Washington, DC.
God almighty.
We heard story after story.
So aggravating.
And the Borrowed Future podcast and the documentary of all of these people who were like, well,
the government's giving me such a gift to lower my payment based on my income.
Then they wake up 10, 20 years later and their principal has doubled.
And now they're really underwater and they're really screwed.
The guy in the other hours, he started with a hundred and something thousand, two hundred
something thousand now.
It just balloons.
Counting on the private or the public student loan forgiveness, the PSA, which is not good.
Oh, it's just, you're going to give Dave an aneurysm America.
Well, I just hate it for you guys because you're getting screwed by your own government.
The first way they screwed you was they put a student loan program in place for you to
get one hundred and fifty thousand dollars in debt to get a degree in left-handed puppetry
and told you that was the way to success.
And now you're a barista and you're screwed and it's just awful.
It's just awful.
And then they come out and go, we're going to forgive it.
Oh, no, we're not.
Yes, we are.
No, we're not.
No, we're.
Yes, we are.
And really, they don't intend to forgive it.
They want to keep you.
The second largest scam perpetrated on the American public by our government, mathematically
in history, the second largest scam was the genius that invented the idea that we take
your taxes out of your check before you see your check.
If they posted a tax guy inside your building and you had to walk out and hand him cash
out of every check, there would be a revolution in America, pitchforks, torches, because you
people would see how much of the money you earn you're giving to this government to misbehave.
You would see that.
But no, it's just kind of came out of my check.
I didn't notice it.
But tax collectors would be as reviled as they were.
We would name the guy Matthew.
After the biblical Matthew.
He'd be as reviled as they were in the Bible.
Post him inside your building, little Matthews, and they're collecting a check.
Him and Zacchaeus.
They're in there collecting your check.