Depuis l’aube des temps, le fait religieux est au cœur des péréquations humaines. Pour le pire ou pour le meilleur, les religions naissent, meurent, se succèdent, ou se transforment. Dans cette série de trois émissions, je vous propose de découvrir les subtilités de cette histoire complexe.
Dans ce dernier épisode, nous parlerons du déclin religieux et des différentes formes de spiritualité qui tente de les remplacer. En bien ou en mal, nous assistons à la naissance du New âgé, sorte de « religion à la carte » dans un monde ubériser. Nous tenterons de comprendre le conflit entre science et religion. De plus, ce sera l’occasion de comprendre le besoin de spiritualité qui survit à l’écroulement des dogmes.
- Massimo Introvigne, Le New Age des origines à nos jours - Marie-Jeanne Ferreux, Le New Age - Ritualités et mythologies contemporaines - George Henry Lewes, Spiritualisme et matérialisme - Helena Blavatsky, Clef de la Théosophie - Helena Blavatsky, La doctrine secrete - René Guénon, La crise du monde moderne - Les écrits de Alice Bailey - Paul le Cour, L’ère du Verseau - ou le retour de Ganymède - Marilyn Ferguson, Les Enfants du Verseau - Pour Un Nouveau Paradigme
Hello everyone, and welcome to this new episode of the Academia for the month of December 2020.
I also take this opportunity to wish you a happy holiday.
I hope it went well and that it is still going well, it is not over yet.
But for the moment, we are going to talk about history and theology,
but also anthropology, psychology and sociology.
We are going to finish today the cycle on the history of religions,
of which the first two episodes have already been released.
The first treaty of the so-called traditional religions,
a religious system that we will find mainly during prehistory, proto-history,
and to a certain extent during the period of Antiquity.
We found religious forms such as animism, pantheism or polytheism.
Then later, in the second episode, I told you about the so-called historical or revealed religions,
such as Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Zoroastrianism or Buddhism.
I also presented to you the principle that all historical or revealed religions
are actually evolutions, transformations of previous models,
i.e. traditional religions.
But in the same way as civilizations, societies and a whole bunch of other domains,
the domain of religion is not something immutable,
it is not something frozen in time.
It is in perpetual evolution.
If traditional religions have evolved into historical or revealed religions,
well the latter are still in the evolution scheme and will still transform.
Today we are going to address the subject of new spiritualities,
also known as New Age, a pejorative term,
but which aims to illustrate these new religious concepts
that are evolutions of what previously existed.
So let's not wait any longer and present the plan of the show.
First of all, an introduction that will be a little long.
We will talk about this concept, or at least this idea, this big question,
which is, will religions die?
Understand religions in the sense of the great historical or revealed religions
that make several millions or even billions of believers today.
Are they on the decline? Are they going to disappear and leave their place for something else?
Or conversely, are they going to subsist and all of a sudden regain their place
in modern society?
So a little long introduction, and then we will go into the first part
where we are going to tell the story of these new spiritualities,
the story of New Age, at least how the concept of New Age will be born
and what face it will take in the modern world.
Then a second part that will be a little faster,
where we will talk about the architecture of New Age and concretely answer the question
what is New Age?
What do New Age followers believe?
Do people claim this concept of New Age?
We are going to draw the picture of all this.
And then we will finish with a third part
that will be more in the form of an essay
where I will place quite personal hypotheses and theories on the question
of the definition of this New Age as a card-based spirituality
adapted to our modern world.
And then a conclusion, namely, is New Age the religion of tomorrow?
The religion of the future?
And then a little bibliography, of course, to find some sources
that inspired me to make this video or for those of you who would like to know more.
A few small notes before starting our subject.
I remind you that every time I address a religious subject,
my goal is not to bring you any revelation.
My goal is not to criticize certain religions,
nor even to promote them,
but simply to study the subject in its historical, anthropological, sociological, etc.
So again, to each his beliefs,
my goal is simply to make an objective state of the subject.
As much as doing this can, of course.
So, having said that, we can start our subject
with this introduction which, as I told you, will be a little long.
Are the current great religions,
including the great historical or current revealed religions,
condemned to disappear?
Are they on the decline?
Well, already, this first question is far from being simple in reality.
And we will be able to answer it in a few years, if I may.
The first, let's make an objective observation in the statistical sense.
Well, if we take the numbers of Christianity,
in all its forms, Catholicism, Protestantism, Orthodoxy, etc.
there is an increase in the number of believers.
If we take the numbers of Islam,
there is an increase in the number of believers.
If we look at Hinduism,
a traditional religion,
there is also an increase in the number of believers.
Etc, etc, etc.
It's the same with Buddhism, rather in stagnation,
but globally, there is no decline, if we can say.
This is an objective study of the numbers.
But if we specify a little more,
we realize that this analysis does not take the entirety of the elements.
If we are interested in the case of Christianity,
indeed, there is an increase in the number of believers.
In particular, there is still a very strong religiosity
in South America, in sub-Saharan Africa,
in some countries as well, in a certain way,
still in Europe, Italy, Spain, for example.
But conversely, if we are interested in other countries,
such as France, the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom,
Germany, Belgium, Denmark, etc.
We realize that, conversely, there is a decline in religion.
Of course, the increase in the population means that there is still a certain number of believers.
But globally, there is a decline.
There are more and more people
who do not claim to be of the Christian religion,
in all its forms, once again.
There are fewer and fewer people who claim to be,
but there are also fewer and fewer people who attend religious offices.
There are fewer and fewer people who are ordained priests, etc.
So, there is indeed a decline in the Christian religion
in some geographical areas,
but not so much in others.
But what is the nuance between these two areas?
This is what we will see a little later.
Let's take the case of Islam.
Islam is about the same as Christianity.
There is, globally, at the level of the figures,
an increase in the number of Muslim believers.
But if we specify the figures a little bit,
we realize that in most countries,
mostly Muslim,
there is an increase in the number of believers.
There is always a very high rate of religiosity
in the so-called Muslim countries.
Conversely, through the games of migration, etc.,
Islam also spreads a little bit elsewhere.
So, we could say, first of all,
that Islam is an expansionist religion
that spreads and is not on the decline.
Well, this is actually a slightly too fast answer,
and even totally erroneous.
I take only these two examples,
and you will have understood the overall mechanics.
Now, let's see a few small points
to explain that, yes,
historical religions are indeed on the decline.
First, the death of religions.
Are historical religions on the verge of disappearing
in the decades to come?
In the decades to come, probably not.
In the century or two centuries to come,
that's another question.
So, what are actually the causes
of the decline of these religions?
The first is of a sociological order,
linked to the development index of a country,
GDP, etc., wealth, new technologies, etc.,
compared to religiosity.
The second point is the critical mind,
the development of modern sciences,
which sometimes confront religions,
or at least put them in difficulty,
in terms of their dogma and their theology.
The third element is politics,
with the loss of influence of religious institutions.
But, a big minus,
I insist on this point,
the death of historical religions does not mean,
however, the death of the spiritual aspiration.
And this is the whole problem,
in reality, of our subject.
So, let's take the first point,
which is the sociological aspect,
the development index of religion,
the development index of religiosity.
We can see, in a very objective way,
whether we like it or not,
that the more countries are at the top of the table,
so-called developed countries,
these are relationships that can be subjective, I understand,
but overall, if we take the countries of the G7,
the United States, Japan, Germany, France, etc.,
these are countries where the rate of religiosity is in free fall.
Conversely, if you go to the bottom of the table,
i.e. religions, countries that are considered
as third world countries,
which have a relatively low development index,
a low threshold of wealth,
and therefore a society that is less developed
in the socio-economic sense, etc.,
we will not go into details,
well, we realize that the rate of religiosity is extremely high.
So, what can we say?
The observation is clear.
The richer and more developed a country is,
with modern science, technology, everything you want,
and the quality of life,
well, religion decreases, and conversely,
countries that are still in the third world,
religiosity is still strong.
But you will have understood that there are two possibilities.
If the developed country
goes back to the third world,
i.e. if there is a decline of a developed country,
as is the case of some,
concretely, well, we can see a return of religiosity.
And conversely,
if a third world country emerges,
a new emerging power,
well, there is, de facto, a decline of religiosity.
So, it's very simple.
The development index and religiosity
are like two opposing banners.
If religiosity returns,
this would mean, de facto,
that, in reality, the country is in decline.
Quite simply.
And then, conversely, if a country emerges,
well, religiosity tends to decline,
to disappear, and to decrease.
This is why, in the great Christian historical countries,
where, for example, religion is sublime,
and, conversely, in Muslim countries,
which are still, for a large part, third world countries,
religiosity is still very strong.
But, inevitably,
when these countries emerge,
well, religiosity will begin to decline.
And why does it decline,
compared to the development index of civilization?
Well, because of our second factor,
which is that of science.
Today, in the historical religions revealed,
there are dogmas, with holy books,
teachings, a whole theological canon.
Yet, these different elements are considered,
as dogmas, an absolute,
non-contestable truth.
Yet, today, the advances of science,
biology, physics, astronomy, etc.,
make that some of these theological
affirmations are taken as default.
The fact that there is an original couple
under the name of Adam and Eve,
and that from there came all humanity,
today, on a scientific level,
can be largely contested,
which puts as default the texts of the Bible,
the texts of the Koran, etc.
No, these texts, these revealed dogmas,
are not absolute truth,
and so, people can possibly
deviate from the religious fact, etc.
I'm going relatively fast,
you will have understood the idea,
but a whole bunch of scientific elements
allow, today,
put as default the religions,
and if there is no evolution of the dogma,
the religions themselves
put themselves in difficulty.
So, inevitably, the more developed a country is,
the more people have access to culture,
to a certain level of instruction
in the scientific domain,
and so, the more they will ask themselves questions,
have a critical mind on certain elements of the dogma,
and be able to oppose this dogma,
or simply no longer adhere to it.
You will have understood the idea.
So, be careful, there are people who are
quite cultivated, quite intelligent, etc.,
and who have disbelief.
Myself, personally, I am not an atheist.
I do not believe in traditional historical religions,
but I am not, however, an atheist.
I do not consider myself, however,
to have made global patterns, if you will.
Globally, in a society,
the higher the level of instruction,
the weaker the religiosity.
That's it, that's the CQFD.
Whether we agree or not, it's a fact.
The third point is the political aspect.
And yes,
since, once upon a time,
in countries like, for example, France,
but we can mention others,
religion had power,
in the temporal and political sense.
There was a hand of religion, of the Church,
for teaching, instruction, etc.,
all that.
It could put you in a bad light, even condemned,
not to go to a religious office.
Today, you are no longer condemned if you do not go.
Therefore, there are people who do not go anymore.
Before, you were in a society where
it was normal, natural, culturally,
socially, etc.,
to adhere to the majority religion,
and therefore, to go to religious offices,
and therefore, to integrate yourself in this scheme.
Obviously, today, this is no longer the case.
The Church is separated from the State,
which means that today,
there is less religious weight, less impact,
and less political grip on people.
Therefore, this gives them
a possibility to emancipate themselves,
if they wish.
In the same way, you see that in the so-called
third world countries, religion is still
very present on the political level.
This was mainly the case in Muslim countries,
Saudi Arabia, Qatar, the Arab Emirates,
etc., everything you want.
These are countries where religion is very present politically.
Therefore, it still has a control,
a grip on the population.
But when society will evolve,
once again,
when there will possibly be a separation
between religion and politics,
in the same way, religions will tend to decline.
It is almost automatic
in the different schemes
that we can observe.
So, now,
there are reasons that can be
deeper for the disappearance
of these religions.
They will correlate with the different elements
but let's dwell on a few points.
The first element
is what I call the sociological observation.
Historical religions no longer respond
to the spiritual aspirations
of individuals.
Of course, we can debate about it,
we can disagree with this point of view.
Nevertheless, I expose you some elements.
Today,
and here I speak of the so-called countries
of Western Europe, America,
Japan, etc., the so-called developed countries,
the countries of the G7 or possibly the G20,
to a certain extent,
not all of them,
there is an evolution of morals,
an evolution of societies,
a certain liberation in the field of marriage,
of sexuality, and a whole bunch of other things.
Today, some of the postulates,
the dogmas of religions,
no longer respond to the social aspects of a society.
I take an example.
Today, contraception for women
is something to enter the morals,
something quite natural on the sociological level,
at least in the countries of the G7.
Obviously, in the context of religious readings,
this is not considered a good thing.
Therefore, there is a social aspiration
on one side, and a religious point of view
on the other, which opposes each other
and can lead to a conflict.
Many people will reject religion
because there is a social element
that religion opposes
and which is inconceivable
for people.
We could talk about the union, for example,
of homosexual people, etc.
These are things where religions sometimes have
quite strict rules, and therefore
the aspirations of more modern societies
create a gap and
once again, some religions
no longer respond to the sociological aspirations,
to the individual aspirations
of people.
We could go a little further,
for example, on the path of salvation.
Some religions have aspects that can
sometimes be quite austere.
The fact of certain privations, certain restrictions,
food restrictions, for example.
Well, these restrictions can
also conflict with aspirations,
a certain hedonistic desire
in society,
which makes us want to enjoy, to eat
bad things, we want comfort,
and a whole bunch of other elements,
which makes us conflict
with the austere aspect,
the strict aspect
of historical religions.
And so, people can move away from the religious model,
considering it as a prison too
confining, and will want to seek
to emancipate themselves.
Quite obvious,
if I may say so, but we could go on
a whole bunch of other little points,
other little theological elements,
which makes that,
in my opinion,
historical religions no longer respond
to the aspirations of individuals
in the context of the most developed countries.
Japan, United States,
France, England, etc.
This is not yet the case in some other countries,
or, since religion
has a political power,
it can have a grip on individuals,
and can impose its dogmatic model
as an absolute truth,
which cannot be questioned,
so the freedom of the individual
has not yet taken the ascendant
in relation to the political power of the religious,
if you see the idea.
But let's go on a second point,
which is just as essential,
the scientific fact.
Today, great historical religions
sometimes offer answers
on the origin of the world,
I take a few examples,
I mentioned them earlier,
it's the idea of the Garden of Eden,
with Adam and Eve,
the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil,
then the fall into matter,
after their condemnation, etc.,
the original sin.
Today, sociologically,
I can understand that many people
say to themselves, look,
we focus on female sin,
in a society today,
we fight for gender equality,
it can be seen as outdated,
so on the sociological aspect,
we can already make a difference
with the region,
but on a biological-scientific aspect,
we can say to ourselves,
two men created the woman
from the tail of Adam,
there is a biological side
that is nonsense,
on the scientific point of view,
so people will say to themselves,
no, what the Bible tells us
is not factual on a scientific level,
of course, the resurrection of Christ
can be debated on a scientific level,
we will talk, for example,
about the flight of Mahomet
on a horse,
to reach heaven, etc.,
a lot of stories,
where, once again, in the Koran,
the idea is that it is God himself
who brings the Koran,
and that it is not Mahomet who composes it,
a lot of theological debates,
so people will say,
no, I can't agree with
the evidence that attests to the exodus of the Hebrews,
we don't find historical evidence
that attests to the existence of Moses,
the existence of Solomon,
the existence of King David,
the existence of the Temple of Solomon,
and I will give you the details, of course.
So, a whole bunch of elements
that make that, historically,
scientifically, archaeologically,
religions are in trouble.
Then, to retort,
it is the principle of faith.
Someone who has faith
says, I adhere to this,
I adhere to the dogma,
but this is a personal freedom.
And since the political power of the religious
disappears,
well, this imposition of faith,
of belief, is no longer there.
Now, we sometimes adhere voluntarily,
and sometimes no longer by
collective social phenomena, if I may say so.
So, in a way,
on the good side,
we can say that people, when they adhere to a religion,
nowadays, in developed countries,
they do it in an honest way.
Someone in France, in 2022,
who is authentically Christian,
who goes authentically to Mass,
and who has a completely normal instruction,
well, he adheres with a real faith,
and not at all with an imposed faith,
we could say. And in a way,
we could say that it is for the best.
There, I give a hypothesis,
a sociological reflection, of course.
You may not agree, and you can show me in the comments
if you want to.
So, now, once we see that these religions
are on the decline,
in developed countries,
and so, fatally,
they will be, when other countries
will be so-called developed,
what can we do
as a conclusion
of all this?
Well, in fact, there are quite simple things.
There have been religions
since the dawn of time,
since prehistory, proto-history,
since man and man, with a capital H,
there has always been a certain aspiration,
a form of belief, a religion,
to put it simply.
Obviously, if we make this observation, we say, well, yes,
but in the modern world, in fact, all this religious aspect will disappear,
since science, since this, since that.
But in reality, these are only evolutions,
since if the current religious models
are in difficulty,
it does not change that individuals
can have an aspiration,
a question about
what awaits us after death?
Is there a creative force
at the origin of everything?
Is there an invisible entity
that populates the universe, etc.?
Nevertheless, despite these difficulties,
the questions are still there.
It's just that the current religions
don't necessarily answer anymore.
Maybe in the same way
that animist religions
didn't answer anymore
at the time of Antiquity.
And so, these traditional models
have evolved to become the models
of revealed historical religions,
and these same revealed historical models
if they want, respond to the aspirations
of the individuals of the 21st century.
So, in ancient times,
we had Osiris, Dionysus,
then Moses, then Jesus, etc.
The question is, what will we be tomorrow?
So, tomorrow,
the dominant religions to come,
or at least the new religious forms
that will take the lead
in our modern world,
understand it, I'm not talking about third world countries,
I'm not talking about developing countries,
I'm really talking about developed countries.
In reality,
there are three major prototypes
of religious forms that seem to appear.
The first one
is what we call the religion of transhumanism.
The religion of transhumanism,
the religion of the machine man, we could say,
is the idea that there is no life after death,
there is no divinity,
we are only biological organisms
governed by physical
and natural laws.
So, the only religion
that is valid,
is science,
the augmentation of technological power.
And here we come with Uchronians,
like in Battlestar Galactica,
with the Cylons, and a whole bunch of other things.
The idea of the human,
the machine man,
where technology will allow
physical immortality,
biological immortality, transferring consciousness
into another body,
a whole bunch of other possible theories,
is one of the currents
that will, in my opinion,
become very important in the years to come.
It is a new spirituality
that is purely materialistic,
purely
earthly,
purely scientific,
if we can call it the religion of transhumanism.
You can be for or against,
but it is a current
that will become very important
in the decades to come,
in my opinion.
On the other hand, you have an opposition,
with people who,
instead of looking for invisible gods
and theological concepts
found in the holy texts,
they will reuse this material,
they will reuse what exists
in traditional religions and historical religions,
to no longer see
a divinity
like God, Allah, or whatever name you want to give it,
no longer see ancient
pantheons of God
ruling over the villages, but they will see
simply extraterrestrials,
a civilization from elsewhere,
like what these very advanced beings,
very elevated, whatever you want,
would have created by genetic manipulation.
So, we are on horseback
with this religion of transhumanism,
and we take up the elements of traditional religions
and we make a kind of synthesis
between a neo-evangelical vision
where there is no more sacred, the sacred
becomes the extraterrestrial,
the entity from elsewhere,
or from an ancient civilization,
no matter, there are variables.
There is this idea of this religion
of the religiousness of the civilizing civilization
that it comes from the distant past
or that it comes from elsewhere.
A kind of archeological religion,
if you will.
And in the middle of all this, there is a third model
which is just as important,
it is what we will call
the New Age in its general form,
the new spiritualities, with a mystical aspect,
with a primordial spiritual aspect,
which, in general,
opposes the current of transhumanism
and can have
proximity with the current
that we will call ufological or archeological
of the past civilization.
The New Age model,
the new spiritualities of this movement,
takes up a good part of the elements
of traditional historical religions,
takes up a part of the elements, sometimes,
of even older traditional religions,
and will arrive at a new synthesis,
let's say,
to these new religions
of the 20th and 21st century.
This is precisely what we are going to see
with the first part.
I told you the introduction would be quite long,
but it was to be able to understand
the death mechanism of religions
and, above all, to see what will happen in the future.
But what will happen in the future
is not born overnight,
it is by a long maturation process
that these new spiritualities will be able to emerge
and they will be able to source
at least from the 18th century.
So, first part,
history or birth,
gestation of the New Age.
The premises of the 18th century,
then we will talk about spiritualism
and theosophism that we will find
in the 19th century.
Then we will talk concretely about the birth of the New Age,
what is there before is a kind of ancestor.
The birth of the New Age in the 20th century,
and then we will talk about the two concepts,
that of the age of the universe
and that of the children of the universe.
We will continue with the mystical nebula
of the end of the 20th, beginning of the 21st century,
and then we will talk
about the key concepts
that we find within these new spiritualities.