🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
"Once the horns were dealt with on February the 7th, really what took place was peaceful, in our view lawful, and certainly didn't justify the imposition of emergency measures that were imposed at that time."
Lawrence Greenspon is a human rights lawyer representing Tamara Lich in her case against the Canadian Crown. Ms. Lich was an organizer and activist at the 2022 Freedom Convoy Protests, in which truckers converged on the capital of Ottawa to protest vaccine mandates and other pandemic restrictions.
"Tamara Lich and Chris Barber are charged with mischief and other related charges, the idea being that they counseled or encouraged truckers to come to Ottawa, stay in Ottawa, and to commit various unlawful acts. But so far, the evidence hasn't supported that Crown theory at all," says Mr. Greenspon.
Views expressed in this video are opinions of the host and the guest, and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
Tamar leech and Chris Barber are charged
with mischief and other related charges
uh the idea being that uh they uh
counseled or encouraged uh truckers to
uh to to come to Ottawa stay in Ottawa
and to commit un uh various unlawful
acts but so far the evidence hasn't
supported that Crown Theory at all and
the the challenge for the for the
prosecution it's it's up to them to to
of course prove the that case against
Tamar leech and Chris Barber Beyond a
reasonable doubt we have the same
standard in Canada as you have in the
United States courts what you're
describing and the mischief charge this
just doesn't square at all for me with
invoking the emergencies act what used
to you know newer variant of what used
to be called the war measures act back
in the day well it it doesn't it it
doesn't uh fit in at all all uh there
has been uh in Canada a separate
Commission of inquiry uh mandatory
Commission of inquiry any time the
emergency measures Act is uh invoked
they've had that Commission of inquiry
the conclusion there was that uh there
was uh some requirement or that the
requirements in order to invoke the
emergencies act uh were in place and had
been met uh that certainly doesn't
square with the fact that on February
the 14th 102 trucks were moved uh with
the cooperation of the protesters and
the police uh and that the the the real
problem the predicate problem of the
truckers in the downtown Corps impacting
on the residential uh uh neighborhoods
that that problem had uh already begun
to be solved and uh within 24 hours of
that the Prime Minister invoked the
emergency measures act and it's um
really a mystery to me as somebody who's
seing this evidence unfold uh how that
conclusion could have been reached but
uh according to the commissioner uh the
Prime Minister was uh justified in
invoking the emergency measures
certainly not uh not from what we're
hearing in this trial well but let's say
these2 I think I think it was 102
vehicles and 40 trucks if I recall
correctly even if those weren't moved uh
um and even if there was a lot of
honking I mean would that have Justified
uh the invocation of these this
emergencies act in my view no uh you
know this the the the emergency measures
Act was a was a replacement of the war
measures act which was invoked some 50
years
ago uh in in a case where uh a foreign a
foreign uh Diplomat had been kidnapped
uh Pier leaport was murdered
uh the flq was uh really put the country
into what uh Justin's father uh prime
minister pielot Trudeau described as a
state of apprehended Insurrection uh we
were light years from that on February
14
2022 uh and in fact you know once the
horns were dealt with on February the
7th uh really what took place was uh
peaceful uh in our view law
and certainly didn't justify the
imposition of emergency measures uh that
were that were imposed at that time so
if you were to compare other cases
you've done uh with I guess with M you
describe these as minor Chargers
Mischief does indeed sound like a like a
minor charge and I guess that's that
that's the general bucket category that
these six charges fit into um how does
it compare I guess with the I guess the
level of resources committed by the
government because it seem seems to be
like they're putting a lot of effort
into it to me that's why I'm asking you
know I represented the first Canadian
charge under our anti-terrorism laws uh
I've done murder trials uh done other
you know far more serious uh criminal
cases uh the the amount of uh energy and
resources that's being put into this um
is uh I mean we're going to have a the
freedom Convoy trial lasting longer than
the freedom Convoy itself um that I
think in and of itself that says
something you know early in the trial I
noticed that the the term kind of
occupation was used which I think you
you argued was a bit strong we did uh
the the Crown opening uh they referred
to the o to an occupation and uh
certainly anybody who's familiar uh with
what's going on in the Ukraine or at
historically what's been deemed an an
occupation uh would feel uh that this
was really uh U an exaggerated term uh
to suggest that the truckers who were in
Ottawa for uh for about three weeks and
uh the the traffic was was uh uh was was
difficult for people to get to and from
uh there were emergency land that were
maintained uh for the most part
according to the evidence uh in the
downtown core to try and uh refer to
that as an occupation uh is is at least
in my view an insult to the people in
the world who are uh genuinely suffering
under an occupation and um the the
result of our objection to it is that
the word the phrase has been rarely used
uh since the beginning of the trial
right well listen before we continue
just tell me a little bit about yourself
you know you're of course a human rights
lawyer um but uh you know how did you
come into this case give me a bit of
History here uh my my father was a uh
Survivor uh of owitz he was liberated by
the Americans uh he lost his parents and
his sister after whom my daughter is
named uh so from a young age uh we were
made aware very much of what happens
when state power goes unchecked
and uh it's been my privilege uh honor
to to work in this area for more than 40
years now um on in a human rights
capacity uh Canada we have uh
fundamental freedoms that are entrenched
in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms
and uh those include freedom of peaceful
assembly and freedom of
expression uh the charter does not
include uh the right to enjoyment of
property uh and and
uh this case is really one that uh where
the freedom of expression and freedom of
peaceful assembly is uh is uh in in my
view at risk and uh my certainly My Hope
Is that uh that right to Peaceful
assembly and freedom of expression will
prevail yeah and just to use a bit of
plain language a more plain language I
mean you're basically saying the freedom
of speech and assembly is more important
than the freedom of people to en enjoy
their that space I guess that's what
you're saying in in a in a cont as I
said at the beginning of the trial and a
contest between uh freedom of expression
and freedom of peaceful assembly and the
right to enjoyment of property there is
no contest you know we we imported some
of the language of the American
Constitution at the time of the charter
uh we imported some of the fundamental
freedoms freedom of expression freedom
of peaceful assembly but we specifically
did not U put into our constitution any
right to the enjoyment of property so
Lauren so during the trial um you
actually asked that I get if if I
understand correctly um the the idea was
to stop residents from of of the area
from testifying about the effect that
all of this had on
them what what we did is we brought a
motion uh the first thing we did is we
we proposed an admission uh the
admission was that uh there were
demonstrators in the downtown core area
and they interfered with some residents
uh enjoyment of property uh and as well
that there were certain businesses that
lost money as a result of the
demonstration in the core area over the
the 3-week period of time it was not
accepted by the crown but uh we made the
admission and then brought them an
application before the judge saying look
in light of this admission there's no
need to hear from the residents or the
businesses because all they're going to
tell you about is how the demonstration
impacted on their lives uh the judge uh
eventually ruled and said no uh the
crown uh can call these Witnesses if
they so desire but I I'm not interested
in what the impact was on their lives
I'm only interested in any observations
or things that they heard or saw during
the demonstration so their their
testimony was limited that way