Lecture 48

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 25, 2023
Hello everyone, I am Rajesh Shisengupta and we are continuing our discussion on Daily
Practice and Nationalism.
So after we have discussed that what was that some of the different approaches taken by
Aminata Tagore and Gandhi, now let us look into some of the aspects of colonial art education.
So in the 1850s during that time as I have already mentioned in the earlier week that
some of the art institutions that came into being.
So for example, the Government School of Art in Calcutta, Government School of Art in Madras
and then the J. J. School of Art in Bombay and Mayo School of Art in Lahore.
So what we find during this time that I mean the motivation for the colonial administration
to have these art institutions was to produce people who will primarily be the drafts people,
the draftsmen and then also like I mean the people who can actually you know get involved
into helping the colonial administration.
So they were not really interested in producing artists of Indian origin.
Primarily like people were there who established themselves as artist for example, as we have
you know mentioned few of the people in the earlier lecture like Bama Pado, Bandopadhyay
and then Annoda Prasad Bagchi and of course like I mean Ravi Verma as the self-taught
artist.
So these people were there but at the same time what we find that I mean the motive behind
the art school educated students or the people was to help the colonial administration for
different kind of documentation and of course like I mean the works related to draftsmanship.
So for that reason what we find during this time there was also this clear divide between
what is art, what is craft and the kind of things which were taught in the art institutions
were strictly European in their convention.
So for example, this single point perspectival view and then also like anatomy, scale, proportion
and then how to make the 3D modeling in the two-dimensional surface that means the use
of shading and also like I mean how the human figures relate to the architectural sites
and everything.
So those were some of the things we find that those were taught in the colonial art institutions.
Now in terms of the techniques as we know that there were you know oil painting was
given priority then marble casting at the same time like I mean slowly we also see that
I mean the plaster of Paris that could also become an important you know like I mean medium
in the later times.
So this kind of different you know practices which did not really have their roots in the
Indian subcontinent were taught to the people or the students in this colonial art institutions.
So here there are like I mean I just wanted to give some example that what kind of like
I mean drawings and everything was there.
So there is this fountain which was made in the Crawford market in 1868.
It was part of like I mean building the architectural projects like I mean you know part of building
various sites in southern Mumbai.
I mean that was the main metropolitan center of Bombay in the 19th century.
So we see that I mean how this kind of you know this architectural structures were erected
and then you know how those were also used for studying by you know like I mean by the
students in J.J.
School of Art.
So this kind of like I mean drawings one can think about that I mean their likeness to
the you know the actual site that was very important and that is something that this
evidential quality of this images was something that was prioritized more than capturing their
essence or more than seeing that what their relevance is in the public life.
So that was the kind of approach that we find in the you know like in the colonial art institutions.
Now from there we find that there was a shift and the shift was not something that was you
know that did not take place all over in the Indian subcontinent but it was something that
started with Rabindranath Tagore.
So we are going back to this prolific Tagore family in North Calcutta.
You know and it was the same house where we have already discussed there is this image
of Rabindranath Tagore and Kumaraswamy and many other this great minds where they are
already situated.
So during this time what we find that in the late 19th century and very early decade of
20th century the Rabindranath Tagore silently he established this school in Bolpur in the
Birbhum district of Bengal and so that time it was Bengal now it is West Bengal.
So then we see that in this particular area which then Tagore called as Shantiniketan
it is a war of peace and so that particular place.
So it was away from this colonial metropolis of Calcutta and you know it was a place which
was surrounded by greenery and rivers and the local Santal or the Adivasi population.
So what we find there that I mean Tagore when he established his school and eventually he
would go and establish this you know this entire university that is called Vishwavarti
where he imagined like the entire world would come.
So that marked a different path and that sort of showed people a different mode of education
which was you know different from the colonial mode of education.
So this is a path we can consider in the early 20th century as an alternative mode
of education from the mainstream mode which was already established in the Indian subcontinent
by the British.
So why this is important is because that I mean we see that I mean Tagore's position
in the nationalist movement was also something that was very interesting that we find that
Tagore was not necessarily aligning himself with either the violent or the nonviolent
movements.
But at the same time he was strongly critiquing the British government.
But in that way what he was interested in doing was to think about that how the growth
of a country, the growth of people is not something that is always related to the nationalist
politics.
The nationalist politics cannot just bring prosperity to everyone.
So for that reason he was interested in learning from different sources and bringing the world
to Shantiniketan.
And so this was a very different kind of educational approach that we find you know in Vishwavarti.
So this is you know I just have this aim and objects which was you know like I mean there
in terms of like I mean to understand that what all Tagore was thinking when he established
Vishwavarti.
Now in the left side of the screen we have a portrait of Tagore perhaps in Shantiniketan
and this gives us a sense of like what kind of landscape I am talking about that even
in the university campus where all the schools were situated we see that there were trees
and there were not really boundaries as such that will mark the space of the school from
nature.
So bringing nature, bringing the daily life to the education was something that Tagore
had strongly advocated for.
And even if we see like I mean this aims and objects of Vishwavarti and there also there
is this you know strong you know argument for learning from different cultures and different
religion and assimilating them together to think about a future which will be much more
hospitable, which will also you know assure prosperity not only in terms of the material
growth but also prosperity of mind.
So those were some of the things that I mean Tagore had aspired to do through his new university.
So thinking about that what happens in terms of that the prosperity of the mind is it is
also something that was revolutionary in terms of thinking that how the colonial institutions
and if we consider the art institutions how they were definitely not concerned about prosperity
of mind but I mean it was concerned about you know this painstaking skill which will
eventually make people as you know fine drafts man and it was definitely not something about
the spiritual or internal growth, something that Tagore had prioritized.
Now if we also see that I mean what happened, so in 1919 we find that Tagore had established
this school of art which is called Kalabhavana.
So this Kalabhavana was established in 1919 and then Vishwavarti this you know this entire
a place where there were already like multiple school for learning you know for learning
art, for learning performance, learning religion, languages and various different things.
So all that became recognized as a university in 1921.
So Kalabhavana this school of art actually was established 2 years prior to Vishwavarti
gaining its status as a university.
So what happened in Kalabhavana we find that Tagore had appointed Nandlal Bose as the first
principal of this school.
Now one can also think that I mean Tagore was you know related to Abhinidhana Tagore.
So Abhinidhana Tagore is this prolific painter that we have already discussed.
So he was his nephew, Abhinidhana Tagore was nephew of Rabindranath Tagore.
But then why did he not choose Abhinidhana Tagore as the principal of this newly founded
school and that is perhaps because we can see that how Abhinidhana Tagore's point
of view, his attempt of reclaiming the past and which also feeds the nationalistic politics
was very different from what Rabindranath Tagore was thinking.
So Rabindranath Tagore was more open towards learning from the entire world and bringing
the world to the you know this site of Vishwavarti whereas Abhinidhana Tagore we can see that
I mean he had his specific focus on reclaiming the Indian past.
So perhaps those are the things we find that ideologically that how even though they were
in the same family and both of them were established in their own right but still how they were
different in their thought process.
Now what we find that I mean the way you know Rabindranath Tagore had envisioned this school
of art at the same time like the entire university, he modeled his idea on the idea of ashram
or you know the place where people would go or like I mean the young people would go and
be trained under a guru and many times in the depiction of the ashramas that we see
from the very from at least from the Vedic period that there are you know no boundary
in terms of like I mean where teacher teaches the students.
And that is the reason what we find that there are classes which held in the open air spaces
like just beneath a tree and not in the classroom, not in the formal classroom.
So this was a very conscious and careful attempt by Tagore that he denied the use of boundary,
he denied the specific spaces which can promote education but he wanted to bring education
close to nature, close to our life so that we do not consider education as something
that is separate from our daily lives.
So this is something and that is perhaps one of the reason why I wanted to bring Tagore's
contribution as part of our discussion today that daily life and even though this is not
related directly to nationalism but also like I mean to think about nationhood, to think
about like I mean our position in the world why all these things are you know relevant.
The other thing that Tagore had also sort of stressed upon is this idea of art education.
So he considered art education as an essential one in the university education.
Instead of having very specific and specialized skill among the students to only to be trained
in art, he considered that people should be free in terms of learning about the different
different modes of art making, artisanal practices and he did not believe in the boundaries as
I have already mentioned.
So it was a very different approach and he also said that I mean how art is something
that is excess.
So the excess is not something he considered I mean excess is something that he considered
as not quantifiable.
So it is not something that can be equated with like the material wealth but there is
always something that goes beyond that.
So he considered that art is also something that is essential for the growth of human
beings and internally.
So that is something that also reflected in his overall strategy of establishing the school
as well as promoting different kind of practices there.
Now the other thing we also find that how the local craft practices were not discouraged.
Something that we find that in the colonial art institutions there was a huge divide between
what was taught in the art schools and what was there around them.
So in a city like Calcutta there were already different kind of artisanal practices like
there can be wood block making, there were textile making, there were also of course
that I mean there were Kalighat paintings in the 19th century.
But we definitely see that I mean those practices were not brought into the within the institutional
fold.
So there was definitely this intended binary between what is considered as this formal
art education, what is considered as fine art and what is not considered as fine art.
Now when Tagore established his school then I mean by school I mean like I mean Kalabhawana
and in extension Vishwavarti University then he brought together the local artisanal practices.
And that is the reason we do not really see that the artist who were trained or like I
mean all the students who are trained in Shantiniketan they made a distinction at least in the early
stages they did not really make a distinction between something that is artisanal, something
that is part of our daily practices and something that is taught in the institution.
So these are some of the ways in which we find that Tagore's ideology and his approach
made a drastic difference in terms of how we perceive art today.
Now going with that I mean what else was happening.
So when we see that Tagore had appointed Nandlal Bose as the first principal of Kalabhawana
so who was Nandlal Bose?
Nandlal Bose is someone who was trained under Abhinav Tagore as well as E. B. Havel.
So these two figures from Calcutta who were essential for revitalizing the Indian artistic
anatomy and the pre-colonial modes of visual expressions.
So for Nandlal Bose what we find that in the early 1900s around 1910 or so then he
traveled with a group of archaeologists and historians to various cave sites.
So for example to Ajanta, to Bagh and others.
So this is an image that we have in the left side of the screen and where we see that there
is a copy of a mural from Bagh.
So as I have mentioned that in the 19th century we find that there were practices of documentation
that the minutest of the documentation of the murals and different kind of like I mean
the architectural remnants and everything from various parts of the Indian subcontinent.
So we can imagine that why the British historians and archaeologists needed the help of people
like the fine artists like Nandlal Bose in their trips to the sites of Ajanta to Bagh
and so on.
And photography certainly can do the purpose but if we can imagine the condition of Ajanta
and Bagh those are the places where the paintings are made in the richest areas.
So those are not really well lit.
So for having them in photograph is not very easy and that is the reason that the fine
artists were needed for having documentation of those murals which were already deteriorating.
So what we see in this image in the left side.
So this is actually you know made in very thin tracing paper perhaps this is like I
mean one can see that I mean how there are those small tracing papers those are added
here to make into this one giant piece and from that is added here for you know for tracing
this one image.
So this is something that we see that I mean in the Nandlal Bose was also involved in reconstructing
or like I mean making replicas of this murals in various different sites on paper also in
a few institutions.
So this kind of trace drawings must have been very important for him to you know continue
this work.
So this drawing also shows something about Nandlal Bose's skill.
So there are only few lines that we find that I mean only the entire image is translated
into the linear form.
So what we find that there are those broken lines which are used for depicting the overall
shape as well as the details of this face.
So and the lines that we see they are calligraphic in character.
So the lines are not uniform but some part of the line has greater depth than the others
and then that is how like I mean this particular way of drawing we find that is you know it
was there in the Ajanta murals when the contour lines of the body are drawn.
So those characters were something those were also learned and internalized by Nandlal Bose
and those are implemented in this drawing here as well.
Now the other thing that we also find that how line is used here for expression.
So this pensive mood of this woman that we find here with her drooping eyes and this
you know her overall expression in her face and her lowered you know lips and then of
course that I mean how she rests her face on to her left arm.
So everything that adds to the mood of this woman.
So the expression and different physiological features.
So this idea that how the draftsmanship or like I mean copying is not something that
is just involved in copying all the details of an image but perhaps to you know perhaps
to imbibe the essence of the image to understand the internal qualities of the image and express
it through the economy of lines.
So only few lines are used here it is not really all the details are done there is no
shading and all the different other details are avoided.
But even within that you know like I mean within those limitations we can see how he
had managed to skillfully portray the overall mood of this woman as well as this image.
So this understanding the internal qualities of the images or artworks as opposed to something
that is that focuses strictly on the scale proportion and you know like I mean the details
of a work like this.
So this marks as a difference in terms of that I mean it is not just a difference of
the east and the west but it is a difference in terms of how we understand that what is
essential is the form essential that we see outside or is there something that is that
is as part of the internal character of any images that is essential and that needs to
be captured and translated into the images.
So this kind of debates that we find that those came forward and these debates were
possible and nurtured because of like I mean this different kind of art education.
So and in the right side of the image we also have something another drawing of Nandlal
Bose and this is a drawing which was much later drawing it was done in 1955 and in this
one what we see is that there is a family of this dog and there are many you know like
I mean this of course like I mean there are many of her children that we find here they
are all gathered here and they are all sucking milk from you know their mother's breast.
But the thing is that I mean what we find is that this essential character that how
you know the muscles and the wrinkles in the body of the dog are been shown as a gesture
of the mother struggle and then how this mother still like I mean keeps her face up and then
also like I mean shelters all her children you know.
So this is something that we find that it is not just a drawing of this dog's family
but there are more things that can be gleaned from this images and this images as we can
see that I mean this is an image that is done perhaps on site.
So Nandlal Bose and you know had promoted this mode of drawing that I mean wherever
we go we do not really carry our easel and like all this elaborate setup for drawing
but we can just carry postcards or like I mean small books or notebooks where we can
do our sketching.
So then sketching and drawing that also becomes part of our daily practice.
It is not something that requires always an elaborate setup or all different kind of you
know equipments for making the making paintings.
So this is something what we also can understand that this philosophy of Rabindranath Tagore
how he imagined that art works need to be you know art works and any kind of this education
need to be closer to life as part of the daily life.
It is not something that is just restricted to the institutional space but it can be part
of our everyday life and just the way we breathe just the way we eat and you know continue
our life with.
So that is something that we find it was reflected in Nandlal Bose's lifelong practice.
It is not something that we find that was only restricted in his early career but like
I mean as we see that even in the later part of his career he still continued doing this
kind of sketches and drawings from the daily life as how you know this different objects
and different you know entities they become part of his understanding of life and also
his silent revolt against the colonial art education.
So we will continue on this aspects also some of the other aspects of Nandlal Bose's practice
and how that also contributed directly to the nationalist movement in the later lectures.
Thank you.
