A vibrant portrait of an age when Arabic enlightenment anticipated and inspired the European Renaissance, illuminated by its guiding figures and rivals, Ibn Sina and Biruni.
In The Genius of their Age, S. Frederick Starr follows up his acclaimed Lost Enlightenment: Central Asia's Golden Age with a portrait of the Arab enlightenment and its key figures—Abu-Ali al-Husayn ibn-'Abdallah Ibn-Sina and Abu al-Rayhan Muhammad ibn Ahmad al-Biruni. A thousand years ago, these two intellectual giants—known as Ibn Sina and Biruni for short—achieved stunning breakthroughs in fields as diverse as medicine, astronomy, mathematics, philosophy, geography, and physics. Biruni measured the earth more precisely than anyone else down to the sixteenth century, pondered a heliocentric universe, and hypothesized the existence of North and South America as inhabited continents. Ibn Sina's writing on philosophy and metaphysics enriched the writings of countless European thinkers, including St. Thomas Aquinas, while Sina's grand synthesis of medical knowledge became the standard for the next six hundred years in Europe, the Middle East, and India. They both also commented extensively on the works of ancient Greeks and earlier Muslim thinkers, whose works they aspired to synthesize—and to transcend.
Contemporaries, Ibn Sina and Biruni were born within the borders of what is now Uzbekistan and spent their lives in Central Asia. They also became rivals, launching a correspondence and commentary that galvanized them despite sometimes bitter disagreement. Centuries before the West caught up with them, Ibn Sina and Biruni reflected their age's feats and its intellectual high point, persisting with their inquiries and their independence amid turmoil and rapid change.
Though scholars have long dissected the works of Ibn Sina and Biruni, S. Frederick Starr focuses also on their lives and the times in which they lived. By contextualizing their work and by making the age palpable to the reader, S. Frederick Starr gives the achievements of Ibn Sina and Biruni a holistic and unforgettably human dimension.
— CHAPTERS — 0:00 Intro 1:05 What is your book about? 4:47 Why did you write about two biographies in one book? 9:21 How did you decide what to write about? 14:42 What surprised you when researching for your book? 20:53 Outro
Hello and welcome to World History Encyclopedia.
My name is Kelly and today I am joined by author and academic Frederick Starr.
Frederick Starr is chairman of the Central Asia Caucasus Institute at the American Foreign Policy Council
and has written two dozen books and other writings focusing on the interaction of culture and politics.
Today we are chatting with Frederick all about his new book, The Genius of Their Age,
Ibn Sina, Birini, and The Lost Enlightenment, published by Oxford University Press,
which follows on from his earlier work, Lost Enlightenment, Central Asia's Golden Age,
all about the forgotten story of Central Asia's enlightenment, its rise, fall, and enduring legacy.
Well thank you so much for joining me today. I'm really excited to talk to you all about your new
book. So why don't we start off with what your book is all about.
It's a dual biography. It's the story of two men who lived a thousand years ago,
and so the argument of the book is these were the most prodigiously intelligent, innovative
thinkers between the time of the ancient Greeks and the Renaissance. One of them was named Birini,
the other was named Ibn Sina. Ibn Sina is vaguely known in the West as Avicenna.
Now these were absolute first class geniuses. They, just to summarize some of the things they
achieved, Avicenna basically codified and created the field of medicine,
that as it was practiced from his time, a thousand AD, down to the 17th century in Europe, in the
Middle East, and all the way clear to India. He wrote six huge, five huge volumes on medicine
that summarized everything known and put it all into a very accessible order. But beyond that,
Ibn Sina also was a great theologian and metaphysician, and his writings on those subjects
were so enduring and so important that much later Thomas Aquinas, St. Thomas Aquinas,
absolutely borrowed from this Muslim writer when he wrote his great Summa of All Knowledge.
So that's Ibn Sina. On the other hand you have Birini. Birini, think of this, he measured the
diameter of the earth more accurately than anyone down to the 17th century, and he did it with simple
equipment that you or I could make in an afternoon. The mathematics of it was anything but simple,
but he did. He also, he also predicted that there would be discovered new continents out in the
world sea, in other words the unknown half of the world, that these continents would be inhabited.
So he basically foretold the discovery of both North and South America as inhabited
continents. He did this on the basis of his very, very analytic studies, heavily laced with
mathematics, and he did it, he did it without ever having seen an ocean himself. Beyond that, he did
so many other things. He basically invented the field of modern anthropology and cultural
anthropology. He also created the world's first world clock, because up to that time, and calendar,
everyone operated, every culture operated on its own system. He went to the bottom of each,
each calendar system, figured out what the astronomy was that each was based upon,
and came up with his own system, so that for the first time there was world history.
This is what these, the sort of thing these two guys did. Now, why write their biographies together?
That was going to be my next question. No, your next question, it should be. Very simply, because they knew
each other, they were, it turns out, exact contemporaries. They knew each other, and they
detested each other. So here you have two mega geniuses who absolutely, fundamentally disagreed,
and they were being of the same age, and both very ambitious males. They really duked it out
in competition. Now, that is a reason to study them together, because fundamentally, their
disagreement was not just that they were two guys who discovered each other when they were both in
their 20s, and discovered that they really didn't like each other. No, much more important was the
fact that for Biruni, the only way to prove big statements about the world, about the universe,
was with mathematics. Whereas, Ibn Sina said, nope, the only way to establish truth is through the use
of logic and syllogisms. Totally different approach to what is true. So that made it very attractive.
Now, let me add one other element. They both lived, they were both born in what today we call Central
Asia, on the territory of Uzbekistan. They came together for about seven years on the territory of
what is now Turkmenistan, in a forgotten but then very hot intellectual center out in the middle of
nowhere. After that, they went, they were forced to go their separate ways. Biruni to Afghanistan,
Ibn Sina to Iran, and both of them lived terribly difficult lives. Neither had stable
employment, or if they had stable employment, it was under such nasty rulers that they were
totally insecure. Both of them, at one point in their career, were to be beheaded. Can you imagine
that? Now, hardly less striking is the fact that neither of them had what we would consider
solid, or reliable, or understanding patrons. They ended up working for a series of rather
distasteful autocrats and rulers who liked them because they were an adornment to their little
courts, but otherwise absolutely didn't understand what they were doing. And so they lived amidst
great instability, and yet they did what they did. And from the standpoint of modern scientists
in every field, who are accustomed to their grants, roll it over for another five years, sit comfortably
in my laboratory, blah, blah, blah. These lives are absolute chaos, what they endured. And yet,
and yet, they never stopped their work. They were so focused on big questions.
So that's what made it all very, very interesting to me. A lot has been known about each of these
people before now. There have been great scholars in many countries who have focused on various
pieces of their lives and their work. No one's told the whole story, let alone in relationship
to each other. And that sort of great competition of beginning as young males and then
continuing through a lifetime, and their fundamental disagreements over how you establish truth,
gives the story sort of spice, and drama, and excitement, and many unsolved questions also.
It's like this extra layer on top of your everyday biography of a person. So did you
decide to write it because no one had ever written it before? The way I came to this is
very circuitous. I can't claim that I've spent a lifetime studying Biruni and Ibn Sina. On the
contrary, there were discoveries to me. When I was writing an earlier book, much related to
the present genius of their age, the earlier book is entitled Lost Enlightenment,
Central Asia's Golden Age, which was back in the 10th to 14th century. In the course of writing
that book, which ended up in 23 translations, I think, in the course of writing it, I came across
this correspondence between Ibn Sina and Biruni. And I thought it was so, I mean, it seemed so
contemporary. They were both young when they learned about the other one, and they both wanted
to scope out who was the other guy, this genius up the road. So they carried on a correspondence,
must have extended for six months or so, and they probably, the letters may have been sent
back and forth by carrier pigeon, we don't know, or by fast courier in what is now Uzbekistan.
But I heard about this, that this correspondence was preserved. I thought, wow, this is a
look right into the middle of their worlds. Well, it turned out not to be quite that simple,
because only one side of the correspondence was, we have an initial letter from both of them.
After that, we only have the version that Ibn Sina's secretary kept. Biruni didn't have a
secretary. His original letters are, in some cases, missing. But this charged me up. I said,
wow, these two guys were real. Their feistiness, their argumentative personalities,
these are people we all know. And yet, they were geniuses. Their contributions, not just to their
world in Central Asia, the Muslim East, no, no, no, to the entire globe, their contribution was
immense. One of the big tasks that I had, after ferreting out what could be known about their
lives and their adventures and of their intellectual achievements, after ferreting all that out,
I then asked myself, well, okay, what happened to them? This was a thousand years ago. Well,
very simply, Biruni largely was forgotten. Much, much later, Copernicus picked up,
not directly using Biruni's work, but some of Biruni's later followers,
when Copernicus made his great discoveries about the universe, sitting up there in what is now
Poland. And Galileo also, of course, has a debt to them, but it's indirect.
Biruni was largely forgotten until the 19th century, when a couple of manuscripts,
books of his, turned up. And a very enterprising German scholar translated, first he edited them,
and then he translated them both into English and into German. Can you imagine?
Brilliant.
That serious. Ibn Sina, by contrast, his medical tomes were always known, and many of his
philosophical writings were also picked up during the European Renaissance.
So they had very different fates. Today, both are becoming known again, and we discover that these
are giants, giants, on almost the same plane as Aristotle and the great classical scientists,
and certainly on the same plane as those of geniuses of the Renaissance. And you know what's
most striking is the sheer breadth of their interests. This isn't unusual in science and
learning. I mean, look at Newton. Isaac Newton had deep philosophical and theological interests,
which he wrote about voluminously. Well, they are his antecedents in this respect,
and that they really were interested in everything.
Incredible. It's incredible that you have correspondence from these people.
Having things that, or maybe that they actually physically wrote, I think adds that extra spice
to the whole, just to everything. That's awesome. I was going to say, so since you said that you
haven't spent your whole life researching these people, whilst you were researching for your book,
was there one thing in particular that surprised you or fascinated you about these people?
I think their sheer breadth. You know, we're all told you've got to excel at something.
You know, choose your major, and then you go to graduate study in your major. And you know
a lot about something and nothing about everything else. They grew up in a world where it was not
only possible, but considered essential for the educated few, and they were few, only few,
for the educated few to know, be acquainted with everything. All of nature, theology,
science, mathematics, you name it. And they were. They had the, this was maybe not the last time,
but getting close to the last time when the idea of encompassing all knowledge
could be entertained by a single human being. And there's something exciting about that. And by the
way, they both, that's what they were competing over. What should be the basis of our knowing
everything? Well, says Ibn Sina, you've got to have the logic right. You've got to have
the syllogisms there. You, that's, there are rules and laws of reason that reveal and expose and
confirm truth. Whereas, bitterly, nope. If it ain't mathematically provable, it doesn't exist.
Now this is one of the great divides, and if you walk into the modern university,
anywhere, you will see the Biruni-Ibn Sina divide alive and well. Check your average
English major, history major, you name it, philosophy major. Check how much mathematics
they know. And reverse. But these guys, they lived in a different world. They both aspired to know
it all. Incredible. I could never imagine needing to know everything. It's just inconceivable.
Let me note again that they did this under extremely adverse circumstances.
Both of them grew up in this Persianate world. They weren't Persians any more than
a, someone from Denmark or Holland. They may speak a Germanic language, but they're not Germans.
They spoke, now largely lost, Persianate languages in Central Asia. But they wrote in Arabic.
Why? Because it was like writing in Latin in the West. This was, if you wanted your stuff to get
around, that's what you did. Now what I really want to stress is that while both came from very
privileged backgrounds, I mean really so, they're beautifully educated, their lives were terrible.
They suffered. They never knew what the future would hold at any point. And what so deeply
impresses me about both of them is they persisted. And so you see both of them as 60-year-old men
still chewing over problems that they first encountered when they were 20.
And this, this, and both of them did this. And this tenacity, this sheer focus and intensity,
you know, this is, in a way, this is what it is to be alive. And that's why these two lives of
forgotten men from forgotten places are so important to us today. They were both, by the way,
very pious in their way. They, they were, they both were Muslims, but they both
embraced this in the very broadest sense that was open fully to all the religions of the book.
And, and both of them were very critical of, of narrowness of some religious belief.
But in the end, both of them affirmed that ultimately the entire system under which we
exist in this universe traced to, to God's initiative, who didn't then give up and say,
okay, I've done my job, I'm out of here. No, who, in ways, both of them spelled out
meticulous care, continued to, to play a role in, in human affairs. That tension
between their scientific, if you will, observations and their theological affirmations,
it's not, not fair to call it a tension, but that interaction is one of the constants of their
lives. Again, all this makes them very modern. Yeah, absolutely. I think that's probably a
perfect place to leave off. Thank you so much for joining me today, Fred. It's been a pleasure
talking to you about your new book. If you're looking to purchase the book, you can find a link
down below for Oxford University Press. Thank you so much for joining me. Thank you. What a pleasure.
This video was brought to you by World History Encyclopedia. For more great articles and
interactive content, head to our website via the link below. If you like my sweater, you can find
this design and a bunch more in our shop at worldhistory.store, or you can find a link for it
down below. Thank you so much for watching, and we will see you soon with another video.