Prof Abhijit Pal Lec41

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
1 Video View·Oct 23, 2023
Hello, in this lecture we will prove that intersection of two quasi-convex subgroups
in a hyperbolic group is again a quasi-convex subgroup and using it we will prove that a
hyperbolic group cannot contain a an abelian subgroup of rank greater than equals to 2.
So, first let us prove this theorem, let H 1 and H 2 be two k quasi-convex subgroups
in a hyperbolic group G and let us take an element H in the intersection of this two
groups H 1 and H 2 and join this 1 and H by a geodesic of the group G.
So, what we will prove that if I take any vertex V of this geodesic joining 1 to H.
So, there exist a vertex V prime in H 1 intersection H 2 such that the distance between V and V
prime will be less than equals to some function which of this k and the hyperbolicity constraint
of the group G ok.
So, for each vertex V in the geodesic joining 1 to H. So, there exist vertices x belongs
to H 1, y belongs to H 2 such that the distance between V and x is less than equals to k and
the distance between V and y is less than equals to k.
So, this is because this H 1 and H 2 are k quasi-convex.
So, this will imply that the distance between 1 and V inverse x.
So, that is less than equals to k and the distance between 1 and V inverse y that is
less than equals to k.
Now, let us take this V not to be the number of elements in the ball of radius k around
1.
So, V 0 square it is equal to the number of elements in the Cartesian product of the of
these 2 balls B 1 k and now let us take S to be the generating set of the group G.
So, what will prove that if I take any vertex P in the geodesic joining 1 to H, the distance
between the P and H 1 intersection H 2 is less than equals to V 0 square.
So, this will prove that this H 1 intersection H 2 2 is a quasi-convex subgroup.
Let gamma be a geodesic word representing the geodesic 1 to P.
Now, let us consider this set.
So, let us define this set omega.
So, this is the collection of all words w belongs to the pregroup generated by S such
that gamma concatenated with w it belongs to H 1 intersection H 2 and for every prefix
V of w distance between gamma V and H i is less than equals to k where this i is equal
to 1, 1, 1, i is equal to 1 and 2.
So, let me draw a picture of it.
So, what is this set omega?
So, I have taken this H which belongs to H 1 intersection H 2.
So, join this 1 to H by a geodesic and now let us take an element P in this geodesic.
So, this geodesic path from 1 to P is labeled by gamma and so, what is this set omega?
So, you take all those words in the pregroup generated by S. So, w belongs to this pregroup
generated by S such that gamma followed by this w.
So, it will give you will get a vertex gamma w.
So, this land inside this H 1 intersection H 2 and if I take any vertex on this path.
So, which will be labeled by.
So, this sub word will be labeled by u, this vertex will be will be gamma u.
So, distance of gamma u to H 1 is less than equals to k and distance between gamma u to
H 2 is less than equals to k ok.
So, we have defined this set omega and this set omega is non-empty.
So, this is because so, if I take this if I take this geodesic path joining P and H,
suppose this is this geodesic work is labeled by w 1.
So, this w 1 will belong to omega because gamma w 1 is equal to H and which belongs
to this H 1 intersection H 2 and of course, because this H 1 and H 2 are quasi-convex
if I take any any vertex here.
So, distance of this vertex to H 1 or H 2 will be less than equals to k.
So, therefore, this set omega is non-empty ok.
So, therefore, the set omega so, this is non-empty and now let us take w naught to be an element
of this omega such that this word w naught of minimal length.
So, we can find an element of omega which is of minimal length.
The claim is length of this w naught so, w naught it is a word of minimal length in
omega.
So, length claim is length of w naught is less than equals to v naught square.
So, if you can prove this thing so, then we are done.
So, if possible let length of w naught is strictly get greater than v naught square.
So, then so, what we have so, this gamma w naught by the definition of omega gamma w
naught it belongs to your H 1 intersection H 2 and by pigeonhole principle so, we will
get two vertices gamma u gamma u prime belonging to this w naught such that distance of gamma
u to H 1 is equal to distance between gamma u prime H 1 and distance between gamma u H
2 is equal to distance between gamma u prime H 2.
So, why this is true?
So, if I take this function so, let us consider this function.
So, function is defined from the vertex set of this w naught to this Cartesian product
of this two ball.
So, f of gamma u is equal to the distance of gamma u to H 1 and distance of gamma u
to H 2.
So, you take this ordered pair so, this first coordinate it will belong to this ball of
radius k around 1 because distance of gamma u to H 1 is less than equals to k and similarly
for the other coordinate also distance of gamma u to H 2 is less than equals to k.
Now, the cardinality of the domain is equal to equal to what so, it is equal to the length
of this w naught which is yeah cardinality of this just yeah.
So, the cardinality of this domain set it is equal to the length of this w naught and
what we have taken length of w naught to be greater than v naught square from here.
So, therefore so, we will get two elements in the vertex set of this w naught such that
f of gamma u will be equal to f of gamma u prime.
So, this follows from the pigeonhole principle.
The cardinality of the domain set is greater than the cardinality of the co-domain set
so, that is why we will get two vertices gamma u and gamma prime u in the vertex set
of this w naught such that f of gamma u is equal to f of gamma u prime.
So, therefore, what we have here so, there exist two vertices gamma u and gamma u prime
belongs to w naught such that the distance between gamma u H 1 is same as the distance
between gamma u prime H 1 and distance between gamma u H 2 is same as the distance between
gamma u prime H 2.
And we can take this sub words this u and u prime of this w naught such that the length
of this u is strictly less than the length of the sub word u prime ok.
So, therefore, so, there exist points x u x u prime belongs to H 1 y u y u prime belongs
to H 2 such that distance of this gamma u to x u distance of gamma u to x u and distance
of gamma u prime to x x u prime so, they are same.
So, this two geodesics are labeled by same word so, that is the thing I have written
here.
So, gamma u gamma u inverse x u is equal to gamma u prime inverse x u prime and distance
between gamma u to y u is same as the distance of gamma u prime to y u prime.
So, this x u it lie x u and x u prime it lies in H 1 y u and y u prime they lie in
H 2 and similarly gamma u inverse y u is equal to gamma u prime inverse y u prime.
So, this already I have said this thing.
So, we have this following picture.
So, this word is labeled by w naught.
So, gamma w naught it belongs to H 1 intersection H 2 w naught is the is the is the word of
minimal length which belongs to omega and we got this two vertices gamma u and gamma
u prime on this path such that distance of gamma u to x u is same as the distance of
gamma u prime to x u prime and distance of gamma u to y u is same as the distance between
gamma u prime and y u y u prime and this x u x u prime it belongs to H 1 y u and y u
prime they belong to H 2 ok.
So, now there exist sub words v and v prime of w naught such that this w naught is equal
to u v and w naught again it is equal to your u prime v prime.
So, if I again go back to this picture.
So, this path is labeled by w naught and so, this path is labeled by w naught.
So, w naught is equal to u concatenated with this geodesic.
So, which is labeled by v and again w naught is first this u prime and then concatenated
with this path which is which I have called it to be v prime yeah.
So, this gamma w naught.
So, now this is equal to gamma u v equal to gamma u prime v prime which is equal which
belongs to H 1 intersection H 2.
Now observe that from this from this equation so, from this equation so, x u x u prime inverse
is equal to y u y u prime inverse.
So, this will imply x u inverse y u is equal to x u prime inverse y u prime.
So, this tells that so, from this picture if I take the geodesic joining this x u and
y u.
So, the labeling of that geodesic will be same as the geodesic joining x u prime and
y u prime ok.
So, we have this observation and now let us take g to be an arbitrary element of the
group G.
Now, let us observe this thing.
So, distance between gamma u g to H 1 so, this is equal to the distance between g gamma
u inverse H 1.
So, which is same as the distance between g and gamma u inverse x u H 1 as x u belongs
to H 1.
Now from this equation start so, observe that distance between g gamma u prime inverse
x u prime.
So, this distance is same as the distance between g gamma u prime inverse x u prime
H 1.
So, this is because of this equality and this distance is same as the distance between gamma
u prime g H 1 and similarly distance between gamma u g H 2 is same as the distance between
gamma u prime g H 2.
Now let us take so, g to be v prime.
So, we have taken this g to be an arbitrary element so, we can in particular we can take
this g to be v prime.
So, therefore, distance between gamma u v prime H 1 which is equal to distance between
gamma u prime v prime H 1 and because this thing it belongs to H 1 so, therefore, this
distance will be equal to 0 yeah.
So, if I put g equals to v prime so, we will if I put g equals to v prime in this equation
so, we will get this equality and this distance is equal to 0 so, this will imply that gamma
u v prime belongs to H 1.
And similarly gamma u v prime it belongs to H 2 so, this will imply that so, both so,
this element belongs to both this H 1 and H 2 so, therefore, gamma u v prime it belongs
to H 1 intersection H 2 and this proves that u v prime it belongs to omega.
So, now, what we have here from this picture so, so, this part you can pull it back to
here.
So, u followed by this v prime so, u followed by some v prime so, this belongs to omega
so, u v prime it belongs to omega and the length of this u v prime it is strictly less
than the length of w naught.
So, this contradicts the minimality of length of w naught.
So, therefore, so, length of w naught is less than equals to v naught square and P w naught
it belongs to H 1 intersection H 2 and distance between P and P w naught is less than equals
to v naught square.
So, therefore, we have proved that this H 1 intersection H 2 is a quasi convex subgroup.
And now so, as a corollary we have the following things.
So, let us take G to be a hyperbolic group with an element G such that order of that
element G is infinite.
So, first observation is if I take this map from z to G n goes to G to the power n.
So, this map is a quasi isometric embedding and the second thing so, this requires a proof
if I take the subgroup generated by G. So, this is an infinite cyclic subgroup.
So, the subgroup has finite index in its centralizer.
So, in particular a hyperbolic group it cannot contain this z cross z.
If it contains z cross z so, then if I take the generator of suppose this z so, that will
be an element of infinite order and if I take a centralizer the centralizer will contain
z cross z.
So, this can so, this property will be violated if G contains z cross z.
So, the centralizer because it contains z cross z the index of that cyclic subgroup
will not be of finite index in the centralizer.
So, therefore so, this hyperbolic group G it cannot contain z cross z ok.
So, let us first prove the first thing that this map z to G n goes to G to the power n
it is a quasi isometric embedding.
So, we already have seen this thing that this centralizer of an element is quasi convex
and hence it will be a finitely generated group and it will be also hyperbolic.
So, let us take C G to be generated by this A 1 A k.
So, first claim is the center of this centralizer it is the intersection of the centralizer
of A i.
So, A i is the generating set of this centralizer.
So, how do you prove this thing?
So, let us take x to be in the center of the centralizer of G.
So, this means that it will commute with every element of the centralizer.
So, in particular x A i will be equal to A i x.
So, x belongs to C i C A i for all i 1 to k.
So, therefore, center of the centralizer of G is contained in this intersection and now
converse part if I take any element in the in this intersection.
So, y A i equal to A i y for all i equals to 1 to k and now let us take any element
x belongs to G. So, x can be written as this product of this A i's and if I take x y.
So, which is equal to this thing and y commutes with every generators A i's.
So, therefore, this element will be equal to this element and which is equal to y x.
So, therefore, x belongs to the center of the centralizer ok.
So, now, every centralizer of this generator is a quasi convex subgroup of the hyperbolic
group and the center of the centralizer it is the finite intersection of quasi convex
subgroups.
So, therefore, this will be again a quasi convex subgroup of G and hence it is a hyperbolic
group ok.
So, this is an exercise one can show that if I take any abelian group which is hyperbolic
then it will be virtually cyclic, virtually cyclic means it has a it has a cyclic subgroup
of finite index that is the meaning of virtually cyclic and the converse is obviously true
ok.
So, therefore, this group because it is an abelian group and we have proved that it is
a hyperbolic group and from this exercise.
So, this will be a virtually cyclic group that is there exist a cyclic subgroup of finite
index in the in the center of the centralizer.
So, this will imply that this index of this infinite cyclic subgroup in the center of
the centralizer is finite.
So, and this will imply that this cyclic subgroup is quasi convex in the center of the centralizer.
Ok.
So, this is a quasi convex subgroup of the center of the centralizer.
So, therefore, by a previous theorem so, the embedding of this cyclic subgroup in the center
of the centralizer will be the will be a quasi asymmetric embedding.
This again we have proved it is a quasi convex subgroup of the centralizer.
So, this embedding will be quasi asymmetric embedding centralizer of an element is a quasi
convex subgroup.
So, therefore, this embedding will be quasi asymmetric embedding.
So, therefore, what we have proved that this infinite cyclic subgroup is quasi asymmetrically
embedded in the in the hyperbolic group G.
So, therefore, so, we have proved this fact that the map from Z to G n goes to g to the
power n it is a quasi asymmetric embedding ok.
And next what we want to prove that so, this subgroup infinite subgroup has finite index
in the centralizer.
So, that we want to prove ok.
So, first we show this thing.
So, if g to the power p is equal to this conjugate T g to the power q T inverse.
So, then mod of p is equal to mod of q ok.
So, suppose T inverse g p T is equal to g cube.
So, this will imply that T inverse g m p T is equal to g m cube and this embeddings this
embeddings just now we proved that these are quasi asymmetric embeddings.
So, this we have proved ok.
Also observe this thing.
So, T to the power minus m g p to the power m times T to the power m is equal to g to
the power q to the power m.
So, observe this thing.
So, this is an exercise ok.
So, now let us assume mod of q to be strictly greater than mod of p ok.
So, there exist k greater than equals to 1 epsilon greater than equals to 0 such that
1 by k mod q to the power m minus epsilon is less than equals to distance between 1
to g cube to the power m less than equals to 2 m distance between 1 to T plus distance
between 1 g p to the power m ok.
And this thing again less than equals to 2 m distance between 1 to T plus k times mod
p to the power m plus epsilon ok.
So, this inequality here it follows from the fact that this embedding is k epsilon quasi
asymmetric embedding and what about this inequality?
So, g cube to the power m is equal to T to the power minus m g p to the power m T to
the power m.
So, therefore, distance between 1 to g cube to the power m will be less than equals to
will be less than equal to the length of this word and which is equal to this thing.
And now again distance between 1 to T to the power p to the power m is less than equals
to k times mod p to the power m plus epsilon this follows from again the fact that that
the embedding z to g m goes to g to the power m p it is a quasi asymmetric embedding k we
can take it to be k epsilon quasi asymmetric embedding.
So, therefore, what we have now?
So, 1 by k times mod q to the power m minus k times mod p to the power m is less than
equals to 2 m distance 1 to T plus 2 epsilon and also note that p belongs to z and p not
equal to 0.
So, this will imply that mod of p is greater than equals to 1.
Now from here so what we have so 1 by k mod q by p to the power m minus k is less than
equals to 2 m times distance 1 T plus 2 epsilon because mod of p is greater than equals to
1.
The left hand side of the inequality is exponential.
So, we have taken mod of q to be greater than p.
So, left hand side it is an exponential and the right hand side it is linear.
So, there is a contradiction so contradiction because of this fact.
So, similarly we can prove that mod of q is not less than equals to mod of p.
So, therefore, mod of p is equal to mod of q we have shown.
So, this will imply that positive powers of g have distinct conjugacy class.
So, this will follow from this thing.
So, we have shown that 0 to the power p if I if it is equal to T 0 to the power q T inverse.
So, this will imply mod of q is equal to mod of q yeah.
So, if I take p and q to be positive so they cannot be and if they are distinct so they
cannot be conjugate to each other.
So, this implies positive powers of g have distinct conjugacy class.
So, therefore, by taking suitable powers of g we can assume g is not conjugate to
any element of the ball of radius 4 delta with center 1 ok.
So, now next claim is if I take any element x belongs to the centralizer.
So, distance of x to the cyclic subgroup generated by g is will be less than equals
to twice distance between 1 to g plus 4 delta.
So, we want to prove that the index of the cyclic subgroup generated by g is finite in
the centralizer of this element g ok.
So, suppose this claim is not true.
So, then there exists an element x belongs to the centralizer such that the distance
between x to the cyclic subgroup is strictly greater than twice distance between 1 to g
plus 4 delta.
Let us take this to be k this quantity to be k.
So, distance between x and the cyclic subgroup so it is equal to again the distance between
1 and x inverse the x inverse the group generated by g.
So, therefore, there will exist y belongs to x inverse this cyclic subgroup g such that
the this distance is equal to distance between 1 y ok.
So, we have taken this x to be in x to be in the centralizer g also it lies in the centralizer
of this element g.
And so, this will imply that so this y it also belongs to the centralizer of the g.
So, x belongs to the centralizer of the g so and y it belongs to x inverse the cyclic
subgroup generated by g.
So, therefore, y it will belong to the centralizer of it follows from this one ok.
So, therefore, yg will be equal to gy and now consider this in fact, it is not quadrilateral
it is rectangle.
So, join 1 to y by a geodesic join 1g by a geodesic y and gy by a geodesic so gy is equal
to yg.
So, this geodesic it will be leveled by again by the word g and join g and gy again by a
geodesic.
So, length of this geodesic will be same as the length of this geodesic joining 1 and
y because g commutes with y and also we have taken y such a way.
So, in fact, this distance is greater than k.
So, which is equal to the distance between 1 and y.
So, distance between 1 and y is greater than k.
So, therefore, what we can do?
So, we can take two points P and Q belonging to this geodesic joining 1 and y such that
distance of 1 to P is k by 2 and distance between k and distance between Q and y is
k by 2.
And now let us take y t to be the midpoint joining this P and Q and let us take this
distance between y and y t that is equal to t ok.
So, now, observe that there exist g y t prime in the geodesic joining g and gy such that
the distance of y t to g y t prime is less than equals to 2 delta.
So, how you can do this thing?
So, you can join this 1 and gy by a geodesic and if I take this point y t, so I will get
either a point here or here such that the distance of those distance of y 2 to this
either this point or this point is less than equals to delta.
So, I am taking this triangle 1 y gy and this triangle we know it to be delta slip.
So, either this distance will be less than equals to delta or this distance will be less
than equals to delta.
Now suppose this distance if it is less than equals to delta, so then distance between
y t and y, so this will be less than delta plus distance between y and g.
So, yeah, so then distance between y and y t it will be less than k by, so where what
is this k?
So, k is twice distance between 1 g plus 4 delta.
If I take k by 2, it is k by 2 is equal to distance 1 g plus 2 delta, so we will have
a contradiction.
So, we will have a contradiction if this distance of y t to this side is less than equals to
delta.
So, therefore, we will get a point here such that the distance will be less than equals
to delta and similarly by the same reason there will exist a point here which I have
called it to be gy t prime.
So, this distance will be again less than equals to delta.
So, there exist a point gy t prime the geodesic joining g and gy such that distance between
y t and gy t prime is less than equals to 2 delta and also observe that distance between
y and y t prime, so this will be equal to t prime.
So, distance between g and gy t prime is equal to t prime, so therefore, and that distance
is equal to distance between y and y t prime, so therefore, distance between y t and y t
prime is equal to t prime, ok.
So again, so I have done it here, so from here, so what you can show that distance between
y t and gy t is less than equals to 4 delta, so this I am not doing, so here I have set
a reason.
So, this will imply the distance between y t inverse gy t, so this is less than equals
to 4 delta.
So, thus a conjugate of g lie in the pole of radius 4 delta around 1, so this is a contradiction
because what we have assumed that, so we can assume that the any conjugate of g does
not belong to this pole.
So, because of that thing, so what we have distance of x to this cyclic subgroup is less
than equals to twice distance of 1 to g plus 4 delta and this true for all x belongs to
the centralizer of this element g.
So, this will imply that this index, so this is finite and the next theorem is says that,
so I will not prove it, you can I have given the proof, you can read it from here, so it
says the following.
So, if I take, so if I take an infinite hyperbolic group G and n to be an infinite normal subgroup
of G, if n is quasi convex in G, then n has finite index in G, so that is the quotient
group G mod n is a finite group, so the proof is written here, you can read the proof from
here, ok.
So, I will stop here.
