Lecture 02

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 22, 2023
So, coming to, Art and Craft.
That is an example, that I would like to use, to explain the difference between, Techne
and Episteme.
So, we have heard these two words together, almost taken, almost always together, Art
and Craft.
But, there is a difference between the two.
Craft is governed by techniques.
There is a way of doing it.
There are techniques of doing a piece of art, of craft.
But Art, on the other hand, has intuitive leaps.
So, you are particularly, or one must particularly be aware, or heard of, artists breaking moulds,
breaking techniques, and doing something new.
So, Art is not bound by techniques.
Because techniques that give us simplicity and clarity, can also be techniques that bind
us, that do not allow us to push the envelope.
So, when we want to do out of the box thinking, or we want to do something unusual, somebody
who is very technique driven, will find it difficult to push the envelope, or go beyond
techniques.
So, Art typically, Art and Craft together, is of course, always a subject in schools
and colleges.
But, they are two distinct methods of doing things.
Craft is about following a technique, and Art is about, not being limited by the technique,
and letting the intuitive process, take its own way.
So, now, summing up, let me read out, what Philosophy is.
Well, one, Philosophy deals with the most fundamental questions.
It is questioning the obvious, and what makes the obvious, obvious.
So, Philosophy is dealing with the most fundamental questions.
So, there can be Philosophy of Mathematics, Philosophy of Life, when we look at, especially,
let me take a lived experience example, that perhaps, many of us have had, in conversations,
when somebody has lost something, or is in a state of despair and defeat, one tends to
be philosophical.
What does it mean there, to be philosophical, so, to be philosophical about life.
So, to be philosophical about life is to look at, what is the point of life.
Is success the point of life?
Is victory the point of life, what is the point of playing the game.
So, whenever we ask, such existential questions, that are fundamental questions in human life.
So, being philosophical about life, is asking existential questions of life.
What is the point of life?
What is the point of fighting, not fighting, winning, losing, cheating, not cheating, point
of sticking to the rules.
So, when we ask these questions, we are also asking fundamental questions, and this is
in the domain of the human life.
The same questions, or the same fundamental question, can be asked in various domains.
So, in social sciences, in physics, in language, we all have, when philosophy of language looks
into the philosophical underpinnings of language, language as an life form.
Second, philosophy is a study of foundations of knowledge, and various knowledge endeavors.
Hence, philosophy is a second order study, that is, philosophy is a study of foundations
of knowledge.
So, what is peculiar, or when you want to look at, is this philosophical, or is this
not philosophical, the first filter that should come to your mind is, whether this is asking
a foundational question or not.
Asking a foundational question is very often a philosophical question.
Then, what is not a philosophical question, that might, again, be, well, if this seems
too widespread and exhaustive, what is it, what kind of questions are not philosophical
questions.
And here, philosophical questions are questions that are not empirically resolvable questions.
Although they are, they help, and are helped by empirical enquiries, but they are not empirically
resolvable questions.
So, if you look at, and here, you can see the commonality between theory and philosophy
is, when we look, say, going back to the example of the archaeologist, who has dug up certain
artefacts, well, those are empirical content, but those empirical content do not tell the
story of the way people were living their lives then.
That requires a theoretical leap, that requires a story, that requires an interpretation to
connect these empirical artefacts to what kind of life people were living then.
Philosophy attempts at articulating assumptions, making the implicit explicit.
Now, what does that mean?
Well, as a philosopher, when you wear the philosopher's cap, and I am wearing a cap
today, but this is not a philosopher's cap, just a cap, so, when you are a philosopher,
you are articulating assumptions, you are able to look at the assumptions of a position.
So, when somebody does something, or when there is a policy, or when there is a decision
made, you should be able to, or analyse, what is the value position, or what is the position
from which this decision is being made.
Say, a welfare state, where there is an increase in taxes.
So, you need to understand that, well, where is this coming from, perhaps the parliament
has debated, and the parliament, which equals the philosophy of the nation, is more inclined
to being a welfare state, and therefore justifies increasing taxes, or if a real politic explanation
that comes to be.
If you look at newspaper editorials, they are classical cases of philosophical pieces
connected to day-to-day life, say, sometimes they unearth the assumptions of decisions
made, and policies given.
So, making the implicit explicit, that means, everything that is understood, that we know
implicitly, we articulate it, and make it explicit, and in this process of making it
explicit, we understand it much better.
So if, those of you, perhaps, who are used to writing a life journal, or a life diary,
or your day-to-day reflecting and writing on your experiences in life, would understand
the value of making this implicit explicit.
We all go through life, right.
But then, when you think over your experiences of the day, and write it down, or make it
explicit, there is a newer understanding to yourself, that emerges.
That is when, you make the implicit explicit, and some knowledge is created.
That is more of an introspective self-knowledge, for your own self.
Philosophy is also the spirit, as a core motto of any project.
It articulates the fundamental values of the project.
So, when you say, a philosophy of a company, or a philosophy of an organisation, or a philosophy
of a nation, is what it means, that it is the abstract, it is the core, or the motto
of any project, or any, say, a school has a motto, the motto determines the philosophy
of the school.
So, philosophy articulates the fundamental values of the project, no matter what the
project be.
Philosophy as an ever self-correcting endeavour, and that is the property of knowledge too.
Not looking for an eternal absolute answer, but rather the best possible answer, under
the current situation.
It accepts the fallibility of knowledge.
So, philosophy as a self-correcting endeavour.
So, and that is true also for knowledge, that knowledge has to be falsifiable, it has to
be revisable.
That means, we are not looking at eternal knowledge claims, but we are looking at knowledge
claims, that fit the bill now, say.
And if you look at the history of knowledge, knowledge claims have always been revised,
in various disciplines, that you look at.
Say, at one time, the world was supposed to be geocentric, then heliocentric, look at
biology, when we looked at milk as the most nutritious food available.
Now, we look at, or the tendency is to understand milk, as not a very suitable food for, nutrition
source for humans.
So, that knowledge is revisable, is epitomized in philosophy, that we are open to revision,
that is an ever-correcting endeavour.
And then, the question, why philosophize?
Now, the question to why philosophize is, let me counter question, why climb the Everest?
Now, those people who are climbing the Everest, or any mountain peak, or in any adventure,
there is always an easier way to reach there, right.
You can take a helicopter ride to that place, or you can watch a film, the details of that
place.
So, what is it, that powers this sense of adventure, in people, who are undertake these
tasks, for which there is a very safe, comfortable, alternative path to reach, well, curiosity,
and the experience.
So, philosophizing, like many Greek philosophers would have it, is something, which we are
embedded with, just by virtue of being human.
Curiosity, making sense of the world, and oneself, as an individual, a community, and
species.
So, curiosity, yes, that is a fundamental drive for philosophy, at the existential level,
it is to make sense of the world, and to make sense of one's own self, both independently,
and within the world.
But if that is not enough, and we should pay heed to, how it affects the world out
there, lest, this sounds too esoteric, and unconnected to the world we inhabit, to philosophize
is to reach, and articulate the axioms, of any knowledge endeavour, and having a better
understanding of the foundations, one can know better.
So, the whole point of articulating, what is foundational, this process leads to, more
accurate description of knowledge, and lays the foundations for a revision, whenever that
is required.
Fallibility of knowledge, what we talked about is, a philosophical outlook, that strongly
resists dogmatism.
Dogmatism is unquestioned belief.
And what we just talked about is, knowledge being fallible, being revisable, it is ever
open to revision, when presented with better, and more compelling evidence.
This is fallibility of knowledge, that is a crux of philosophical method.
Conflicts often occur, when dogma prevails.
With fallibility of knowledge, as a background, conflicts lessen, and knowledge enhances.
So, this is, if we are looking for, we are looking for a practical takeaway, from doing
philosophy is, societies, which are less philosophical, or companies, or organisations, or families,
which are less philosophical, tend to have more dissatisfaction.
Because, dogma prevails, and one fights for one's dogma, without being open to understand,
or the other's position, or to revise one's position, in light of new knowledge.
So, conflicts often occur, when dogma prevails.
With the fallibility of knowledge, as a background, conflicts lessen, and knowledge enhances.
So, knowledge has a see-saw history, see-sawing between paradigms, or what many of you may
have heard of, as paradigm shifts.
It results from a perceptual, a perpetual conceptual examination.
So, there are paradigm shifts, in the story of knowledge, and every, in history, that
we see, that where, at one point, one paradigm was held as extreme, and there was a paradigm
that we change.
So, when one, and this is why history is important, to make sense of the world, is when one looks
at the way, ideas have see-sawed, all through the history, once losing, once gaining enormous
prominence, and at one other time, being condemned, and then again, coming back into vogue.
So, to look at this see-sawing nature of knowledge, is also, promotes a perpetual conceptual examination,
that philosophy, as a discipline, moves to.
Now, as a student of philosophy, what should you be doing, or as a budding philosopher,
not just as an academic philosopher, but a philosopher in spirit.
You should be able to, and this will also be, hopefully, the take-away, the learning
outcomes from this course, you should be able, one, to identify foundational philosophical
positions, in the most empirical of all questions.
So, to identify assumptions, that is going to be your fundamental question, then unearth
the foundational assumptions of any claim, and become aware of the limitations, owing
to the assumptions, connected to the previous claim, that once we arrive at the foundational
assumptions, then we can aware, be aware of the limitations, owing from these assumptions.
And what does this ultimately do, three, finally, is debate better, and more importantly, gain
from debate.
So, now, before I end, I would share, the wisdom of philosophy, and wisdom is a word
used in philosophy, Wisdom Studies is a part of philosophy, to look at debate, not as a
platform, to only advocate for the views one holds, but also as a learning platform.
Until there is debate, and I can understand, there will be a lot of disappointment, and
impatience with debate, because debate delays processes, very often, or sometimes, does
not get resolved, and leads to a standstill.
But, if you look at the option of, the alternative to debate, it is coercion, it is force.
So, that is where, debate sounds better, and that is where, debate is a better method of
engaging with differing opinions.
And to be philosophical, is to be able to debate, and debate, not just in arguing for
what one is convinced of, but being open to revise, what one has earlier, held as
convincing.
So, with this, I invite you all, into a journey of philosophy, and hope, it is useful, and
self-revealing to you, to make sense of the positions, that you hold, and to understand
others, and to exercise your intellect, and spirit, to make sense of the world of values,
that we inhabit.
Thank you.
