Lecture 07

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 22, 2023
Hello everyone, this is Rajesh Shisan Gupta and we are in the week 2 of our course and
then we will be as as we have sort of gotten into the discussion about the the simple weaving
and then like I mean much more fairly complicated ones .
So, we will continue our discussion on the the Brocade of Varanasi . So, what happens
in this case that I mean as as I have mentioned that I mean there are the silk threads as
well as like I mean this gold or the metal wrapped silk threads are used which is also
called Zari that we have already a sort of noted in the earlier lectures .
So, in this case what happens we see that I mean in some of the cases the Zari is used
as a base and on the top of that the motifs are created with the silk threads and which
sort of like I mean creates almost like a 3D effect and in which we can see that almost
like a tactile quality that that if one like I mean sort of like I mean passes their fingers
through the fabric one can see the up and down and then like I mean this this slightly
3D quality that is achieved in this motifs those are also created and it is not just
about the technique, but also like I mean this variation of the material that I mean
one is just silk thread and the other is just the the other one is like I mean metal
wrapped silk thread or Zari . So, the differences between them and that
that sort of like I mean enables this kind of interplay . So, this is this is also something
we needs to we need to take in account that how this this the diversity or like I mean
all those intricacies are achieved in this complicated weaving styles and not just about
how it is woven, but it is also ingrained in the kind of materials which are used in
it . Now, the other thing that we find here in
case of like I mean the brocade weaving is that there are certain terms and at least
like I mean for the Varnasi brocade we find that there are many architectural terms which
are used and if we pay close attention to the image that we have on screen even though
it is pretty shiny for that reason that I mean the kind of like the horizontal and the
vertical the crisscrossing is very hard to sort of like I mean register, but if you see
that there are those parallel horizontal lines which sort of like I mean run across the entire
piece of fabric and then there are also like I mean the vertical grids in some cases like
I mean you know how we find that to be also with dividing the entire space into this grid
like form a graph paper like form and in this what also happens that I mean we find that
in many brocade weaving I mean of course, in all brocade weaving we have that there
needs to be a paper or like I mean an already made drawing or a piece of reference which
needs to be followed when this weaving sort of like I mean takes place and since weaving
is something that is constituted of like this vertical warp and then horizontal weft
for that reason the drawing also needs to be conveyed through a form which would probably
be sort of like I mean corresponding to this kind of like I mean this boxes.
So, if I am thinking in terms of a diagonal line like this that needs to be sort of imagined
by how many boxes it will pass through.
So, this is something that we find that to be there for any motifs which would be created
in the brocade weaving or in any kind of extra weft weaving or like in the tapestry weaving.
So, this is something that remains at the heart of it that how the motifs are created
or any kind of like I mean patterns that we find which are not just there for the arrangement
of the warp or the weft threads.
So, all the other patterns how they are created now for those reasons as I have already mentioned
that I mean the draw person like I mean who is also called as a draw boy who would sit
on an elevated level and would like I mean sort of raise a set of like I mean this threads
for inserting the weft thread into it.
But so, that was also replaced by you know the punch cards and that we find in the in
the 19th century France and that is how this jacquard loom technology was also brought
in the Indian subcontinent and then we find that I mean how the jacquard loom technique
in which like instead of a person who is sitting there and sort of like I mean raising this
set of threads punch cards are used for sort of like I mean passing those particular set
of threads and those punch cards are also created keeping this reference drawings in
mind in which the entire drawing is sort of divided into this in this grid like format.
So, this particular kind of grid like format that we find which remains at the heart of
of course, like any form of weaving that is the simple weave, brocade weaving or whatever
it is, but also at the same time making all the kind of patterns which would appear on
a on a brocade weaving on any kind of extra weft weaving.
So, in this cases what we find here is that this jacquard loom technique that that sort
of like I mean draws on the existing technology of sort of like I mean working on this silk
weaving technique and then sort of like I mean makes it much more weaver friendly in
certain ways when when this this punch cards are introduced, but however, like I mean even
though today we find in many of the silk weaving centers this punch cards are extensively used
there are also places for example, in Varanasi and and few other places in Gujarat and so
on and and of course, like I mean and in the other few of the other pockets of of in in
India as well in the Deccan India and so on.
So, in those cases we find that I mean still the the manual work in which like I mean a
draw person would sit on the top of this this elevated ground and then would sort of like
I mean raise this set of yarn for weaving is something that is continued.
So, with those things what we also find that I mean in this kind of weaving and not just
this kind of weaving, but like I mean in many other like all weaving there are certain
architectural terms which are used in the weaving styles.
I mean I will start by discussing some of the terms that we find in the in the Varanasi
brocades.
So, for example, some of the names which would be like Jali, Ashrafi and and so on like I
mean some of them might also refer to like I mean the stars or the moons and so on and
as as I also have been documented by the Museum of Art and Photography in in Bangalore.
We find that I mean this this this kind of terms are something that that also refers
to the architectural structures and if we can think about like I mean some of the architectural
structures in the Mughal context and Jali is something that is made of stone which is
there as a perforated stone structure which is used either as lattice window particular
kind of viewing experience or this is also used for the warmer summer climate where air
can pass through the structures much more uninterruptedly.
So, this is this is something we find that there are certain architectural terms in in
brocade weaving as well as like I mean all different forms of weaving and perhaps I will
also extend that by saying that there are architectural terms in in all sort of textiles
we find.
So, now what does that signify like I mean do we do we think about like I mean this this
things to be something that the architecture came first and that is how like I mean the
textiles also sort of got influenced by it.
So, I use the term influence very cautiously here because there can also be certain issues
or problems with terms like influence because when we talk about influence and we we find
that I mean of course, like I mean this this this term and it is it is significance has
also been addressed by Rebecca Brown and Deborah Hutton in terms of like I mean when we talk
about influence it sort of signifies that there is a source from which like influence
travels and then there are recipients who sort of receive this influence.
So, there is already a kind of hierarchy that is set in this relationship.
So, for that reason what happens we cannot when we use the term influence we cannot really
see this thing as a transmission of knowledge between two stakeholders, but we always try
to understand that influence is a thing in which like there is a already inherent hierarchy
and there is a point from which influence starts and then like there are recipients
which receives the influence and then it sort of like I mean gets modeled further.
Now what if we do not really think that there is a particular kind of influence, but there
is a conversation or the there are like I mean transmission of knowledge if you think
in this terms.
So, then what happens?
So, what we find in this case that there are in this case we can we can also kind of like
I mean perhaps like I mean flip the question that if we see that there are certain established
architectural terms which are there in the textiles, does that always have to mean that
the textiles always receive this architectural terms or can it also be the other way?
Can there be a possibility that this textiles actually existed before the architecture came
into being and then like I mean somehow the terms which are used in the architecture were
also used same way in textiles instead of like textiles borrowing the architectural
terms can it be possible that this terms already existed and it is part of like a shared vocabulary
and in from which like the architects also have received this terms and also the textile
makers utilize this terms, can it be a possibility?
So, this is a particular question that we will be probably like I mean addressing little
more with more examples.
Now when we talk about brocade we should not think that I mean brocade is something that
is just there reserved for silk and zari, but it can also happen with cotton fabric
and so this is actually an example of a fabric here it is a Jamdani sari that we have from
undivided Bengal and in this case what we find here is that there is the continuous
warp, the continuous weft and then on the top of the weft we have the extra weft which
are usually inserted.
So for Jamdani weaving for the this meticulous work that we have on screen we usually have
that the needle or like I mean small tools which would like I mean hold the web threads
those will be inserted only like I mean with this meticulous calculation through this warp
threads and then like I mean it is not something that is continuous.
So this is something we find in this Jamdani weaving.
Now the term Jamdani people have also sort of argued that I mean how the term came into
being of course it has its Persian origin and Jamdani sometimes it might mean that a
flower vase and some people have also noted that I mean whether Jamdani the word Jam came
from Jama and Dhani means like some kind of a container which seem to be not making much
sense however Jamdani as a flower vase can also have its significance since we are looking
at many of these motifs which are flowering or blossoming into the entire fabric.
So in this case what we find that the Jamdani weaving which also comes very close to the
brocade weaving was ah something that was preferred in terms of ah many people who were
not comfortable wearing silk.
So for example, in a number of Muslim societies we find that the direct use of silk was not
encouraged and for that reason we find either things like this kind of cotton fabric in
which we have the it is not made of silk and of course like I mean for silk there are issues
around that I mean whether the silkworms are killed or not and perhaps like I mean this
issues which are associated with violence is something that remains as a determining
fact for many religious sects for either using or not using silk.
So in this case what we find that I mean if the kind of material is something that
was prioritized for making particular kind of this fabric which would be used by either
a particular community or it can also be suited for particular regions such as in eastern
India in Bengal for the climatic condition and everything cotton is something that is
been understood as the most suited ah fiber and that is the reason we find that this kind
of incredible ah diversity of motifs or experiments have been done on cotton.
Now the other place where we also find a similar kind of Jamdani technique that was ah practiced
is in that is in Tanda in Uttar Pradesh in which we find that again this extra weft is
inserted however instead of like I mean having the extra weft with ah different color in
Tanda we find usually like I mean the the all the weft and the warp to be in the same
color usually white or unbleached cotton for that reason there is always this white on
white ah kind of motifs the set of motifs which are which we find in this this kind
of fabric.
For Jamdani weaving the other thing that we find usually is that the warp and the weft
would also be if we are using like I mean super fine ah ah cotton like 120 count cotton
or 100 count cotton then the warp and the weft can be one 100 or 120 count cotton, but
then the extra weft that is inserted on in for making the motifs are usually much thicker
compared to the regular weft and that is how we find this motifs wherever this motifs
are created they are usually much more sort of like I mean ah much more stable or like
I mean at the same time a bit stiff compared to the body of the fabric or the cloth.
So, with all these discussions that we have and already as I have mentioned that I mean
there are some of the issues we see around how this aspects of the architecture textile
all of them this sort of like I mean whether they come together or not and then when we
see certain aspects around like how what kind of materials are used.
If we think about the brocade weaving in which the zeri threads are used as base and then
like if the silk the plain silk thread is used for making the motif then like I mean
this kind of this light 3D effect that it is sort of like I mean creates is something
that also sort of makes us think about the structure of it and then like I mean how the
material combination with the particular kind of technique can lead us towards particular
results and the same thing we can think about in terms of the Jamdani sarees in which if
there are a particular thread count is maintained for the warp and the weft threads and then
we have the extra weft which would be much more thicker.
So, it adds to the stability of the textile in a different way.
So, all this minute things about the stability of the textile, the durability, the appearance
and everything else that make us think that the motifs which we have on the on this ah
you know on this fabrics, the sarees whatever they are they are not something that is disconnected
from the structure of it.
So, the structure and ornamentation are not something disconnected.
Again it might go back to like I mean some of the primary concerns we had that how technology
or like I mean this this techniques of doing this ah this this weaving is something that
is not disconnected from its intellectual aspects.
Now when we think about textiles and its correlation with architecture and and artifacts then then
we also might have to go back to some of the ah art historical theories that I mean how
they have ah shaped this this concepts and also like I mean how they paved the ways for
us to sort of comprehend these issues in new light.
So, one of the aspects that sort of like I mean came up and that that started with the
very warp and the weft that I mean how there are horizontal like I mean horizontal weft
and then like the vertical warp and then the the combination of them it sort of like I
mean gives textile the required or the needed stability.
Now if we think about that that I mean what kind of warp I mean what kind of horizontal
and vertical ah components are there in an architecture we can think about it the the
most simple form of architecture in which there can be a pillar and a bar and which
would sort of like I mean give the basic of many I mean all architectural form that I
mean something that is vertical and something that is horizontal and that is how like I
mean the bars would support the roof and that is how the enclosure can be made and then
without a pillar without this raising like I mean a raised surface like I mean it cannot
have an enclosed space which is the basis of any architecture I mean well like I mean
not an enclosed space for as such, but like I mean a space which can accommodate people
within it.
So, if there is no raised area then it cannot really accommodate anyone within it.
So, those those things what we find here that this particular concerns that sort of like
I mean came up in many of the theories, but perhaps like one of the most ah important
ah art historical theories that that sort of addressed this this correlation between
ah architecture and textile that came from German art historian Gottfried Semper in the
ah mid 19th century and and Gottfried Semper was someone who had sort of like I mean worked
on mostly the ancient structures.
So, we find a lot of his work sort of concerned ah the the Greek structures and then how like
I mean the the Greek structures and the Assyrian structures would be there and his interest
in the Assyrian and the Mesopotamian ah structures we find that I mean that was that was sort
of like I mean ah spearheaded by his interest in domestic spaces.
So, a lot of times he had argued that how the the primary structures that we find from
the ancient times and ah if we are talking about India, if we are talking about Egypt
a lot of them we would find them to be associated with religion and whereas like I mean he was
someone who was also interested highly interested in the domestic spaces and for that reason
we find the Assyrian, the Mesopotamian ah structures in which like I mean the palace
complexes and so on are are found at least in the ruins.
So, those are the ones we would find that I mean Semper was highly interested in and
why he was interested in this kind of structures is because that he thought that I mean the
structure this architectural structures and the decorations that sort of like appeared
on this structures perhaps in form of the panel or the bas-relief and so on.
So, those things are not something to be ah thought about separately.
So, he actually thought something that decorations are actually the architectures organic life,
it is not something that the decorations are added on the top of the architecture, but
if we at least according to Semper he was also someone who had extensively reconstructed
a number of this architectural structures ah I mean like the reconstructed drawings
he did and with the Greek structures and so on and we find in his reconstruction a lot
of colours are used perhaps it was also an indication for going with the decorations
and not just thinking as like the structure is the thing that is the most important part.
So, what Semper in this case was suggesting was that how the decorations that we find
there on any of the structures if we study them closely, if we understand them closely
that might reveal something about the structure itself.
So, it is not really like the structure or the form is ah sort of like influencing the
decorations, but it is perhaps sometimes the opposite of it that if we start from the decorations
we might understand the structure in a new light and this is something that was understood
by Semper and perhaps this is this is a question that that we still sort of like I mean you
know argue about and ah in this case what happens is that ah he he understood that a
form an architectural form can only be understood when the like I mean can only be fully understood.
When the decorations are taken in account and with that thing what we also see that
I mean he would sort of like I mean extend his ah ah understanding of what he meant by
ornamentation and decoration to a lot of ah textiles and like I mean decorative items
that we have here and what he would say that I mean in terms of like I mean the foundation
for the architectural spaces there are four aspects he had sort of ah ah exemplified and
that is the of course, the the foundation and then like the enclosure, the roof and
then like I mean the hearth or the ah floor.
So, these are these are some of the aspects that we find that I mean how the architectural
spaces he had defined, but then he also said that I mean this idea of the enclosure is
something that is that was not inherent in all architecture perhaps there can be pillars,
but it is not really like the idea of the enclosure is something that was there in any
of the architectural forms, but it might have come from using textiles as tent.
So, for example, he would say that I mean the kind of curtains that we use which would
separate the outer world from the inner world right like I mean in the interior space from
the exterior space.
So, the curtain might become a signifier or like I mean the curtain might become a reminder
for us that I mean how an enclosure would be and that might have served for a base for
understanding how enclosure in the architectural term can come into being.
The same thing he had said about like the tent structures and then of course, like the
carpets, carpets and curtains are something that I mean he had put much stress into it
that I mean how carpet is something that that is there on the floor and it is sort of like
I mean makes us understand that it how this hearth or the floor is something that is an
essential part for habitation.
And why he sort of like I mean understood that there needs to be a correlation between
architecture and textiles is because that altogether architecture and textile they can
contribute to the understanding of a domestic space or something that we understand as home
something that is understand as like a habitable space.
So, he was very much interested in this aspect of human experience and that is the reason
he thought that I mean bringing textile and architecture not only as like I mean something
that we understand in terms of like I mean just the vertical horizontal structure the
technicalities, but also through like I mean how we experience this spaces and then like
I mean all those cross referencing between architecture and textiles all those things
can come together for us to understand that there are deep interrelation between architecture
and textiles.
So, on screen we have an image and that actually is something understood as chick and chick
is something which is usually sort of used as a separator in the palace settings.
So, it can work as a curtain it can also be like a separator between like the inner quarters
the outer quarters and so on.
And in this one what we have like I mean the bamboo strips are used and on the top of that
we have the silk threads the colored silk threads that we have here which are sort of
like I mean woven into this and that is how like I mean the entire structure is created.
So, it is again a reminder that I mean what all different kind of textiles that we find
around us and which can also be incorporated as part of the architecture and that can contribute
to the understanding of whether architecture comes from textile or textile comes from architecture.
Again like I mean as I have mentioned this that we have like I mean certain forms of
architecture and certain forms of textiles which are much more closely interconnected.
So, for example, here we have this chhatbandi or this canopy which is a silk velvet canopy
that we have with embroidered motifs onto it and this is something that we do not really
use them in the open spaces but this is very much part of like the stable the architectural
structures.
Like I mean this is perhaps like I mean been on the top of some important person if it
is about the king or like I mean the royal members or like I mean the figures of the
gods and goddesses that we have and what kind of like I mean a roof or like an a protected
space it might require.
These are some of the examples that we find and when we sort of connect it to like Zemper's
work that we find that I mean this cross references between architecture and textile is not something
we can understand in terms of a simple travel of influence from one source to another.
But we need to understand them much more as a conversation between these two.
So, we will continue this conversation about textile and architecture in the next lectures.
Thank you.
