Lecture 05

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 22, 2023
Good afternoon everyone, welcome to yet another lecture of the advanced business decision
support system course under the NPTEL MOOCs from IIT Kanpur, I am Dr. Deepavali and along
with me in this course are Dr. Amandeep Singh Oberoi and Dr. Prabal Pratap Singh and all
three of us will be together teaching this course and we have been going through the
fundamentals of decision support system, as I said earlier this is an advanced course
of the previous version that was plotted in NPTEL MOOCs, so we have seen what the components
of a web based decision support system is, the major important aspects, different building
blocks etc. and now we are looking more into what we call as the business decision taxonomy,
how a business decision is made, in the previous course we had taken mostly looked into what
we call as a general decision, whereas today we are now in this course we are looking more
focused towards the business decision.
In the last class we are looking at what was a general decision process model and if you
look into the slides this is what we discussed in the last class, where we define the decision
problem and decide who will decide and collect information and iterate between identify and
evaluate alternatives, then you decide, then you implement and follow up and continue within
a cycle process.
So, in today's class we are going to do the refined decision process with the help of
DSS.
So, the general decision process model is done without a decision support system, what
happens when you actually implement it with a decision support system.
So, we can take it in the form of 7 steps, actually you can say it as a 7 step process
and step number 1 is identify the decision.
So, this part is the manager or the decision maker, the decision maker does this, it can
be either due to based on experience, feel etcetera or it can be based on specific requirement,
either one it can be either one of these.
So, the identification of the decision becomes the first part and lot of the time this part
literally happens with the help of DSS.
Second is the gather information, we do not need to decide who is going to the decision
maker because this is with help of DSS, you are gathering the information and this can
be based on internal external all those kind of things, what we seen it can be internal,
it can be external, it can be knowledge base all those kind of things, it can be with the
help of DSS.
And once you gather the information, the third step in this part is identify alternatives
the again with help of DSS and where you have multiple models and multiple options also.
So, earlier where when a group of people or individual had to sit and identify alternatives,
the DSS helps here to identify the alternatives.
The fourth step becomes weigh the evidence against each alternatives, again using DSS
like tools, like hypothesis testing, factorial all these kind of things comes into picture
right.
So, different tools you use response surface methodology etcetera or they you use multiple
tools to identify which alternative performs better, you may have different measures also
ok.
But anyway the DSS helps you in identifying or weighing the evidence against each the
alternatives.
Then comes the fifth step ok, choose among alternatives, make you can say compare and
contrast using DSS.
Again here what you will end up doing is you can think about multiple aspects, multiple
performance measure like maximum profit, yield, robustness etcetera.
Depending upon different objectives or different yardsticks or measuring or what you call as
measures of effectiveness, some people called as MOEs ok.
Minus different MOEs, you can decide which of the alternatives is you are going to end
up choosing.
Then the sixth one is you have to do is take action ok.
That means, here again using DSS ok, communicate and implement the decision.
So, you made your choice, now you have to communicate and implement the decision.
This means also communicate ways and means to measure or quantify the impact of the decision.
So, it is not just you are implementing the design or the decision, you are not just taking
action.
You are also telling people here is the action and there is how this action will be effectively
we will measure the or quantify the impact of the action or the decision.
Then review the decision again with help of DSS ok.
Here what you do is compare before and after data ok, check whether targets are met ok.
So, those kind of things are part of this one right.
So, with the DSS what actually happens is you can see that once the decision maker identifies
the decision right, in all the rest of the steps you have assistance DSS provides assistance.
So, the previous case where a human being was seriously involved or a group of human
beings were seriously involved, here you have a computer system which actually eliminates
lot of the mundane things like collecting the information, presenting the comparing
and presenting the alternatives, assisting you to weigh the evidences, choosing among
alternatives, ranking them according to the criteria that you specify.
And then taking the action which means choosing the alternative which also involves automation
automated communication of the decision to the stakeholders and also telling them how
will we measure the effectiveness of that current decision and reviewing your decision.
So, this decision process is can say the DSS with respect to a business.
So, we are discussing it with respect to a business in this regard.
So, sometimes people talk about decision making and problem solving ok, in the same breadth
ok.
And problem solving it can be one thing you have to understand is that it can be in a
business, but not limited to.
The problem solving happens everywhere you can solving a research problem or other kind
of things.
So, there is some subtle differences the major steps here are the major steps of the actual
problem solving are the step 1 is felt a difficulty something starts bothering.
So, if it is a researcher you feel like this why is this happening?
This does not seems right there is something wrong going on here I need to investigate
this more.
And similarly with the case of a decision maker a business decision maker the performance
of this particular line is not up to the mark there is something wrong with this.
So, I need to investigate right.
So, that is the one part.
So, we can say it as business decision maker draws from experience.
So, I usually tell people that this felt a difficulty I will explain it slightly below,
but let me give this the major steps the 5 steps as part of this.
Step 2 is what we call as the define the character of the difficulty.
So, you basically is like convert the intuition into a problem statement.
And the third one is we will talk about this in a particular fashion third one is suggest
possible solutions and where you basically using data find causes and address those causes.
Then fourth one is evaluate the suggested solutions you can basically say that objectively
compare and choose the best fit whatever you think is the best fit then you choose
that.
And then the last one is what we call as the continue observation and experimentation leading
to acceptance or rejection of the suggested solution.
So, what you doing is you continue the observation and experimentation.
So, in a way how this happens is you can physically think about it as there are multiple models
the VW and nominee models about this, but one way to think about it is there is something
called as you know level of thought or what we call as the intelligence.
And there is something called as a level of data or you can call it as reality.
So, and you have time that is going on under the x axis and almost all the felt the difficulty
the felt starts here it starts somewhere here you feeling the difficulty right here ok.
This is the feeling or felt the difficulty.
It always happens in the level of thought and as time progresses this feeling bothers
you and after some point of time what you have to do is you have to you it becomes so
much that you have to address with it.
So, from there you move to the plane of the data or reality and what you are actually
trying to do here is you are trying to formalize the statement.
So, for that what you are doing is you are collecting data here is data collect it can
be quantitative qualitative whatever it is right.
And in this process using that data you will spend some time and this is where you will
let us call it as data 1 ok.
You collect the data and from with the help of the data you go back to the plane of thought
and this is where you are for some time you think about it and you will actually have
the definition define the character right.
And after the defining the character or define the problem then you will go back again you
will spend some more time here and you will go back again down to this one where you are
actually trying to do is you are collect going to collect more data.
And this data is basically depending upon your definition you are trying to collect
you can call it as data 2 and the idea of this data 2 is that it is supposed to help
you in identify the solutions.
So, with this data you go back up again and then you start look for solution.
So, you keep on alternating you always alternate go back and forth between these the thought
and the or the intelligence and the reality field.
So, you come collect data go back thing come collect more data go back and think and then
after some point of time you will come back to this and you alternate like this in reality
and that is how the actual problem solving happens ok.
A lot of the time this what decision support system can actually do for you is it can help
you in these portions.
So, DSS can assist and DSS can also assist in these areas ok.
So, while the feeling the difficulty is usually outside DSS these things can be within DSS.
So, this is in another way you can think about how the actual problem solving process and
the how a DSS can integrate in both these aspects.
Now, how does the actual decision process happens in organizations?
So, we just talked about the problem solving in the general problem solving or the actual
problem solving approach this can be individual, can be organization, it can be research R
E S E A R C H etcetera.
So, this problem solving can be applied all across, but when you talk about an organization
or when you talk about a business organization how does this process happens ok, how does
the actual decision process happens there.
We can make it in the form of broadly 3 steps.
So, step number 1 finding occasions for making a decision ok or in another way people call
it as look for problem.
The newer term is the fancy term, the management term one another management fad is look for
opportunities anyway.
So, this one generally the fancy term for this is what they call it as intelligence,
you can call whatever you want I do not care, but the idea is that you are trying to find
an occasion to make a decision or you trying to find an opportunity where you can do something
ok.
The second step is this is broadly how the organizations do it actually, finding possible
course of actions ok and this is what we call as a the general word is propose solution.
The fancy term for is this is people do whatever the crap it is re-engineer or re-innovate
you can put whatever ok as part of this.
The general of all of this is what we can call it as the design, design the solution
or design your action right.
So, that is the intelligence then the second part is the design and then the third one
is what we can call it as the other two case is finding, the third one is choosing, choosing
among the various courses of action ok.
So, you propose a solution and here you are doing is pick a solution, you want to do a
fancy term I mean I do not know the fancy term for this, but management people may have
some fancy term for this obviously.
So, maybe we can give a fancy term also, we can also call it as semi management.
So, fancy term might be what would that be it would be something like identify best fit
ok.
So, something like that and I am becoming a management best fit all right.
So, this portion is called what we call as the choice, the intelligence design and choice
part of it right.
So, these are the three aspects that broadly happens in industry and various phases software
helps does not help that is the part of that right.
So, let us look into all the three phases separately now and go from there.
So, the decision making process let us talk about the intelligence ok, what we talking
about as part of the intelligence.
And two broad phases can call whatever you want, but we can break it into two major parts
ok, two major phases as part of this.
Phase number 1 or yes number 1, we call it as decision recognition is the broad term
for this ok.
And how do one way to think about is the problems and opportunities are identified are identified
in ambiguous and largely verbal data.
So, I remember my supervisor doctor at Mooney as part of this, once when I was trying to
move back from US to India, I complained that oh India so many problems.
So, I had always used to say you can think about as a problem or you can think about
as an opportunity to do something.
So, these problems and opportunities are usually identified ok, the decision recognition you
identify in ambiguous, ambiguous means they are vague, they are not very clear and largely
verbal data ok.
So, somebody will come up with a very fancy statement you know it is like if you ask someone
who is going to get married, you will ask them what type of person or lady that you
are going to marry.
The person will say should be tall, should be fair, good look like this, long hair, this
that.
So, that will all be very very vague statements verbal data, but you would not be able to
put a face or a individual to that data.
So, that is an ambiguous, that is the one way of the recognition, the idea is that ok
I want to get married kind of a thing ok.
So, step 2 diagnosis.
So, if you broadly explain in the terms of Dr. Mooney again, you can say it as tapping
existing information channels, existing information channels and or open opening new ones to clarify
and define the issues.
So, either you tap the existing information channels, use whatever you have or you try
to open it.
So, if I go to a doctor and say I have a headache, doctor checks my BP and all those kind of
things and find these like did you go to the rain as I got a little bit rain in my head
yesterday, it looks like a common cold go take a steam inhalation.
So, that is a doctor basically recognizing that I have a headache and I might be a problem
and from my verbal data he gets into an idea and then he explored the existing channel
of the patient in front of him and then he says ok fine go do that, but sometimes he
may suspect or he may have a sinus infection.
So, he says I suspect a sinus infection.
So, I want you to go to a lab and test your nasal swab and etcetera, but he may suspect
COVID and say I want you to go do an RT-PCR.
So, that would be tapping a new channel as part of this right.
So, these two steps the decision recognition and the diagnosis forms the creates what you
call as the intelligence, the organizational decision making intelligence step.
The second step is what we call as the design remember that is where the second aspect.
So, remember we talked about this intelligence design and choice the possible course of action.
So, in finding the possible course of action we can say there are again two routines of
design, there are two routines associated with this.
So, the first one we call it as the general word is search ok search everybody know search
and rescue kind of a thing and the broader sense we can call it as aims at finding ready
made solutions ok.
In an organization remember when this design aspect if somebody says I am searching for
a solution usually means that I am trying to find an existing solution that can fit
to this right.
So, a ready made already available.
So, this is like finding an existing solution that can fit ok this is the idea ok, but number
2 the design routine.
So, in the design routine the idea is that you searched and you did not find a ready
made solution.
So, now, you develop or develops a new solution or modify ready made ones ok.
So, the idea here is that you may have to come up with a completely new solution ok
this may be a new approach and new solution ok the process and the output outcome can
be different.
In this case what you are doing is ok you are tweaking or you are what you call as the
other word to this is augmenting.
So, there is an existing ready made solution you tweak it or you augment it fit the problem.
So, whatever is the problem that you identified you are trying to fit the solution or the
augment the ready made solution to fit what a decision is.
Now comes the third one choice ok this is again I remember please remember this we are
going through this you finding the occasion and finding the possible course of actions
we gone through the intelligence and design.
Now we are the last phase choosing among various course of action ok.
So, the choice one in this regard if you look into this it broadly have three routines other
two hard only two to each, but now we have three in this ok number one is the screen
screen routine.
So, it does not mean that all the three will be used every time this is in general sense
this is used when search generates more ready made more ready made alternatives that can
be intensively evaluated.
So, what happens is you did a search and you came up with many ready made solutions and
you came up with.
So, many of these ready made alternatives it is very difficult for you to that means,
there are so many alternatives which implies too much time commitment time and resource
commitment.
So, hence the cost of the decision will go up.
So, in screen means you are like I am going to narrow this down ok.
So, people use some.
So, something like 80 20 rule or these kind of things are all used for such kind of screening
ok.
Number two is the evaluation choice the second routine ok.
So, what happens here is this is where the actual choice between the alternatives ok
whatever the alternatives that you have decided this is where you are doing the actual choice
between right and I would say there are three modes to this again ok and the three modes
of this can be intuitive judgment ok you are using your intuition to make the judgment
number two is bargaining you are bargaining with whoever it is number three is analysis
ok.
So, one is you use your intuition to evaluate the choice your judgment second one is you
debate bargain ok if this when this and this is a committee type decision and the last
one is the analysis ok analysis is you actually look into data and all those kind of stuff
and then from there you make a data driven choice.
The third one is authorization and what is authorization?
The authorization is the approval of the selected solution approval of the selected solution
from higher ups in the hierarchy in the organizational hierarchy.
When you are a researcher you may not need the authorization you are self authorized
you check by yourself and stuff like that, but in a business one you have higher ups
you have organizational hierarchy if you are a manager you have a general manager above
you if you are general manager you may have a vice president above you vice president
that is a CEO above you if you are a CEO that is a board above you ok.
So, if you are a board then you have a shareholders which are the public.
So, you go through the higher ups to get the approval of the and that is where you get
the decision authorized in a corporate world or in a business organization ok.
So, then the last question that we have is usually because if we look into this we have
said there is you are making a choice and these choices need not be optimal.
So, the question is we had made this discussion why are decisions suboptimal what drives or
what causes the decisions to be suboptimal the three main reasons for this ok.
So, the first one is you can say it as decision is a result is a result of decision making
process ok.
It is a result of a decision making process where a decision strategy is applied to the
information ok.
So, let us instead of calling it as one let us call it as the fact.
So, the decision is a result of the decision making process we have seen what the decision
making process the general one the organizational one the individual we seen all of those right.
So, in what happens a strategy is applied to the information.
So, therefore, suboptimal decisions hence be attributed to one suboptimal strategy or
two suboptimal information can cause either suboptimal strategy or suboptimal information
either one of them can drive the suboptimal decision ok.
So, these are the two main causes.
Now, there is one more thing that you can think about which is called as the human cognitive
capability ok which means the information processing capability of human beings are
limited ok.
Even if you have perfect strategy and perfect information still you may be limited by the
cognitive capability because the individual or the human being cannot process the information
in the best possible way and because of that you can end up having a suboptimal decision
or sub.
So, when somebody talks to you about suboptimal decision it is either due to the suboptimal
strategy or it is to the suboptimal information or it is to the human cognitive capabilities.
So, these three are the major causes of the or things that drive the decisions to be suboptimal
ok.
So, drivers of suboptimal decisions are 1 and or 2 and or 3 ok.
So, it can be all the 3, it can be 1 or 2 of them, it can be something else as part
of that.
So, with this we conclude today's lecture and we hope that you can you had a clear understanding
of how organizational decisions gets made and how the business decision the terms that
are used and the major phases and aspects of it.
So, that when we get into the business decision support system you are easily able to recognize
the 3 phases the intelligence, the choice, the design etcetera and also you are able
to identify different aspects of whether the intuitive decisions a bargaining decision
whether it is a analytical decision all those aspects that you will end up seeing and you
will understand how this moves back and forth as part of that.
So, thank you for your patient hearing and hope that you have enjoyed the lecture and
we will see you soon in the next session.
Thank you very much.
