The Religions of Ancient Canaan and Phoenicia

ancient literature
168 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 22, 2023
The Religions of Ancient Canaan and Phoenicia
Welcome to the history of the world podcast. My name is Chris Hasler and
you're listening to volume 2 the ancient world. This is episode 10 the religion of
Canaan and Phoenicia. Our first job this week in one of the more difficult
podcasts that I've had to write is to explain El. El spelt E-L is a deity.
Deities have been mentioned many times in relation to Near East worship. Over
the course of these volume 2 episodes we can recognize that many ancient world
cultures had a number of gods and each of these gods would represent an aspect
of the world. In each culture there may be a god of crop fertility, there may be
a goddess of pregnancy, there may be a god of craftsmanship, there may be
goddesses of fruit or love, there may be gods of the moon and the sun. This was
the typical polytheistic nature of Near East worship. Often in cities there would
be a supreme deity. For example in Babylon the supreme deity was Marduk and
we know of Marduk because any time that Babylon was conquered the aggressors
would take the statue of Marduk which was a sacrilegious act designed to
spiritually weaken the city, at least in the minds of the second millennium BCE
Near East population. In Ur we find the supreme deity called Inanna who was
worshipped especially by Sargon of Akkad's daughter Enheduanna after Sargon
had conquered the city of Ur in the late third millennium BCE. Asur was the
national god of the Assyrians and was the supreme deity of the first capital
city of Assyria namely Assur. These are just some of the supreme deities that we
have stumbled across during our journey through the ancient Near East. But these
cultures of Babylonia, Sumeria and Assyria would have many other minor
deities too so the style of religion was very much polytheistic which means to
worship multiple gods. El was the name that many cultures gave to their supreme
deity so the name very likely represented a different spiritual
entity in each individual culture but essentially it was the name of the
supreme God. Although there are cognate words used throughout the Near East so
in some cases El is il and ilu among others depending on when and where in
the Near East you were. El is understood to be the word that Canaanites used for
their supreme deity. The list of other deities in any chosen religious worship
of any particular Near East culture could be described as its pantheon of
deities and in Canaan El was the leader of the pantheon of deities and Asura the
goddess of motherhood and fertility was his queen consort. Now Canaan differed
from Mesopotamia. In Mesopotamia there were the rivers of the Tigris and the
Euphrates and it was somewhat easy for the residents who lived on the banks of
these rivers to manipulate the flow of the rivers by building irrigation canals
and therefore aid in the fertility of the land to enhance the success of the
agricultural yield. Something vital for the survival of the large and advanced
societies of Mesopotamia especially when it came to having a surplus of harvest
to be able to trade with. In Canaan however this was not so easy and the
Canaanites relied heavily on rainfall to be able to assist with the success of
their own agriculture. Therefore it should come as no big surprise to learn
that the supreme Canaan deity El was the god of water.
Once again like the word El, Baal is also quite ambiguous when trying to give it a
specific meaning. In many Semitic languages Baal and its cognates across
the languages is the word given to a man of significant standing so it could be a
lord or a master or even a husband. In the eyes of the Canaanites and in respect
of their deities Baal would have been known as the god of rain or otherwise as
the rider of the clouds. We can see from excavation of scripts from Ugarit that
the local Levantine people of the 2nd millennium BCE regarded Baal as the god
of the weather in general. If you recall we spoke of Ugarit during episode 6
which was our late Bronze Age collapse episode. It was the city of the Levant
that was under the influence of the Hittite Empire at the beginning of the
12th century BCE and it appealed to the Alashia kingdom of Cyprus for help
against invaders. Sadly the appeal was to no avail as the city of Ugarit fell but
at least this does mean that we know that the worship of Baal existed in this
geographical area previous to 1200 BCE. One of the texts from Ugarit reads
Lo, also it is the time of his rain. Baal sets the season and gives forth his
voice from the clouds. He flashes lightning to the earth. How else would
ancient people interpret a violent thunderstorm as anything other than a
spiritual reaction by a higher power. Another god worshipped by the people of
Ugarit was the one called Mot. Mot was considered to be a son of El and also
the personification of death. Baal warned his messengers of the dangers of Mot but
Mot continually threatens Baal and it's not until a daughter of El and Asherah
the goddess of the Sun Shapash warns Mot that El will turn against him if he
continues to battle Baal that Mot concedes the battle. At one point during
the story Mot kills Baal and reigns supreme before Baal is brought back to
life to battle Mot. Could this have been symbolic to the Canaanites of periods of
droughts waiting for the weather deity Baal to come back to life and bring rain
to fertilize the land again. We will come back to Baal later in the podcast.
When the culture that we primarily associate with the Phoenicians emerged
and by that I mean the seafaring traders then the city of Tyre emerged as
the powerhouse of Phoenician lands. Now for the sake of simplifying things I'm
going to make an assumption that the Phoenicians and the Canaanites are the
same peoples and that the Phoenicians actually referred to themselves as
Canaanites and that it was the Greeks who referred to these people as the
Phoenicians. In biblical writings we see them referred to as the Canaanites and
in Latin and Greek scripts we see them referred to as the Phoenicians. Tyre had
its own supreme deity just like many other cities as we have already
clarified. Tyre's deity was called Melkart and as the lead Phoenician city when it
came to their Mediterranean expansion Melkart would become an extremely
important Punic deity in general and there were temples built for him
throughout Punic lands. When we say Punic we refer to Phoenicians and
subsequently the Carthaginians all of whom share the same bloodlines as we
discovered in the last podcast. In the last podcast we mentioned the very
important Carthaginian trade colony based at the modern-day Spanish city of
Cardis and it was here that the Carthaginians would construct a temple
dedicated to Melkart. This temple would be one of the last places that Hannibal
would visit before his famous crossing of the Alps to confront the Romans.
Hannibal being a Carthaginian would be a faithful worshipper of Melkart and as
such would make the pilgrimage to Cardis before embarking on one of the
most highly regarded military journeys of history. Hannibal's achievements are
going to be saved for a future podcast but the purpose of this passage is to
discuss the deity of Melkart and the high esteem in which the Punic peoples
held him in. The 5th century Greek historian Herodotus travelled to Tyre
during his own lifetime to look for clues about the deity of Tyre but
throughout his writings he referred to the deity as Heracles. Now Heracles is
actually a character of Greek mythology who is a son of Zeus and a god or a hero
of athleticism. Herodotus clearly links the deity of Tyre to the Greek
mythological legend Heracles so we could assume that Melkart and Heracles are
thought of as being the same person just that each culture had a name in their
own language for him. Subsequently the Romans adopted Heracles into their own
stories of mythology and as such they renamed him Hercules. Now this is where
it gets interesting because in the last episode we spoke of the pillars of
Hercules which is the name given to the promontories which are either side of
the Strait of Gibraltar and what we mean by promontories are peaks of land that
act as an iconic gateway between the familiarity of the Mediterranean Sea and
the dangerous Atlantic Ocean. A gateway which it is suggested that only the
Phoenicians dared to breach in order to reach the metal-rich societies of the
British Isles and West Africa. According to legend the pillars of Hercules are so
named as the westernmost extent of the travels of Hercules during his 12
labours, a Greek mythological story. Could it therefore be pure coincidence that a
place where the Phoenicians dared to cross is possibly named after their own
deity Melkart because of this link even if it is somewhat tenuous. Tenuous links
can sometimes be all that we as historians have to go on especially when
it comes to the origins of religion and spirituality. The classical cultures of
Rome, Carthage and Greece seem to all have very similar polytheistic worship
practices where many different gods exist for many different things and this
can be traced back to the cultures of the ancient Near East who although had a
supreme city deity are still recorded as worshipping multiple gods and this
creation of gods for many different aspects of nature could even connect us
to the shamanistic animism of prehistory that could be the purpose of the
portable and parietal art of the Upper Paleolithic, something we explored way
back in volume 1.
The people of Cardis are very proud of their city and its heritage, especially its Punic links.
Cardis was founded by the Phoenicians and used as a base by the
Carthaginians while preparing for the Punic Wars against the Romans. We
mentioned that Hannibal went on pilgrimage to Cardis before setting off
across the Alps to meet the Romans. Strabo was a Greek historian that lived
from the 1st century BCE to the 1st century CE and he mentions the temple of
Tyrean Heracles which we may otherwise call Melkart in the city of Cardis.
Strabo writes that there were two bronze pillars within the temple and that these
pillars were regarded by some to be the true pillars of Hercules. It is also
mentioned that Hannibal made sacrifices at this temple. Now this could refer to
animal sacrifice, something which we believe has been part of human society
for a very long time. Certainly we studied the cave paintings of the Upper
Paleolithic and one conclusion that we speculated on was that there must have
been some form of ritual in regards to nomadic hunting. When humans became
agricultural it may no longer have been necessary to carry out the same rituals
but there is very likely to have been some form of ritual to ensure a
successful harvest or production of fertile livestock and it is possible that
particular animals were sacrificed as an offering to the deities who would ensure
agricultural success in response. This might sound bizarre but would your
ancient society take the risk of not performing these rituals if it meant that
the weather gods would not bless your lands with rain or that they would grant
more favour to the next city who were competing with yours for the fertile
lands in between. Not honouring rituals was not worth the risk so these
sacrifices were necessary and this points us towards an even more grim
reality of ancient life, that being the sacrifice of humans. The best example
that we have given of this is the grave of Queen Puabi who was buried in the
Royal Cemetery of Ur in the 3rd millennium BCE. There humans and animals
were sacrificed probably to accompany her into the afterlife. At first glance
the entourage of humans may have willingly poisoned themselves however
closer examinations of the bodies indicate that some of them may have been
struck about the head to incapacitate them. Either way it would appear that
these sacrifices must have been seen as a necessity and the fear of not
sacrificing living beings must have outweighed the horror of doing it. The
Romans and Greeks would have us believe that the Phoenicians and Carthaginians
sacrificed their children to the gods but there are also historians that
oppose this saying that this is Greco-Roman propaganda. In my opinion
certainly human and animal sacrifice is very much a part of our history whether
we like it or not. It's probably not a case of where the sacrifice took place
as how much sacrifice did each particular culture carry out. The Bible
states that the Canaanites carried out gruesome sacrifice of children by
burning them alive so there is definitely an infanticide connection
there but all the sources were enemies of the Canaanites, Phoenicians and
Carthaginians so we may never know the entire truth.
The reported place of Canaanite child sacrifice according to the Hebrew Bible
was Tophet and one opponent of this practice was Yahweh. Yahweh is a name
given to the God of Iron Age Israel and Judah. Certainly around the time of the
siege of Lachish which was the subject of our podcasts episode 8. His name was
represented by four letters Y H W H. The reason for this is because the name was
being written in what we've referred to as an Abjad style of writing which is
when an alphabet with no vowels is being used. Arabic, Hebrew and Syriac alphabets
are a good modern example of Abjads. The most famous archaic Abjad is the
Phoenician alphabet which is something we mentioned in episode 9. The name Yahweh
was first written in Phoenician script by using four letters which have been
translated into the Latin script as Y H W H and the vowel sounds that need to
be inserted to make the name vocal have been a matter for much debate. Most
people will say the name as Yahweh but if we break down the name into its
four-letter form which is actually directly called the Tetragrammaton we
can turn Y H W H into the phonetic sounds Y H W H and by shifting the sounds which is a
common thing in language evolution we can suppose that the Y sound transformed
into a J sound and the W sound transformed into a V sound. So Y H W H transformed
into J H V H and this is the origin of the name Jehovah which we find most
commonly used for the Christian movement called Jehovah's Witnesses who are
literally God's public witnesses to the missionary work within their communities
that they are well known for. After the Babylonian destruction of Jerusalem in
the 6th century BCE Jewish people accepted Yahweh as their universal God
which claims the God of Israel to be supreme and refers to him as the Lord
due to his name Yahweh being deemed to be too divine to be uttered. However the
name Israel itself contains the word El which in this sense means God as we
mentioned right at the very beginning of the podcast. Biblical texts explain this
by stating that El and his queen consort Asherah had many sons one being Baal who
we spoke of earlier and another being Yahweh who was given the nation of
Israel by his father El. According to biblical texts it was the king of Judah
called Josiah who proclaimed that Yahweh should be worshipped exclusively by the
Jews. So there is a serious danger of us getting lost in detail and trying to
describe things which are ambiguous and contentious if we are trying to
literally translate and understand every script. Many Phoenician scripts have been
lost due to the fact that they like to use parchment which doesn't stand the
test of time like clay tablets but we do believe that some of the works of Hebrew
texts such as those written in the Hebrew Bible derive from Phoenician
writings. In essence we can talk about peoples and we can talk about the
evolution of God as a concept so let's firstly tackle the peoples. We can say
that the most likely conclusions of all that we have studied is to say that the
Canaanite people lived in the Levant for as long as we care to believe so
potentially from the dawn of ancient times five thousand years ago. There
appears to be no evidence of supplanting cultures just subjugation. So we can say
that from the Canaanites we get the Phoenicians and the Carthaginians. It is
feasible to say that they are all one and the same bloodline just referred to
by different names according to the source of the name and the period that
we're talking about. These Levantine peoples are probably comparatively
closely related to the original people of the first kingdoms of Israel and
Judah and as such as the first peoples who we may refer to as Hebrew and
ultimately what the Greco-Romans would attribute as synonymous to the Jewish
people in general. In today's world we refer to the Semitic speaking Israelites
as Hebrew. All Israelites are biblically believed to be descendants of Abraham
who is the patriarch of Judaism as well as Christianity and Islam and who may
have been born in the Mesopotamian city of Ur. The tribe of Benjamin was one of
the twelve tribes of Israel mentioned in the Hebrew Bible. One of the members of
this tribe was called Saul and it was he who would become the first king of the
United Monarchy of Israel. It is suggested that all of this happened in
the 11th century BCE. As the king of Israel Saul falls out of favor with God
and this is when David takes a prominent place in the story of the birth of
Judaism. According to the Hebrew Bible God favored the young Israelite called
David who was a humble shepherd with a reputation for fighting off wild animals
in the duty of protecting his flock. During the war with the Philistines the
mightiest Philistine warrior called Goliath would call out the strongest
Israelite to meet him on the battlefield. Goliath was so huge that he struck fear
into the hearts of the Israelites but when David overheard Goliath's challenge
despite not being an Israelite soldier he asked King Saul to let him face
Goliath believing that God was with him. Saul obliged and David met Goliath on
the battlefield. This legendary battle between the mightiest mountain of a man
the Philistine Goliath and the humble young Israelites shepherd David echoes
down to modern day. With the shot of a sling David defeated Goliath winning the
Israelites the unlikeliest victory over the Philistines in the most legendary
underdog victory. David's popularity within Israel would soar and Saul would
realize how out of favor he had become by comparison to David. When David
ultimately became the king of the Israelites he would take Jerusalem from
the Jebusites who occupied it. He would then go on to rule Israel for 40 years
before being replaced by his son Solomon. King Solomon would be the last
king of the united monarchy of Israel as the country would be split into two
after Solomon's death. The kingdom of Israel would emerge from the north while
the kingdom of Judah would emerge from the south. Jerusalem would become the
capital city of the kingdom of Judah and a temple dedicated to Solomon was
completed in 953 BCE at Mount Zion in the capital city itself. The temple's
deity was Yahweh and such was its beauty that many would travel great distances
to see it. The Ark of the Covenant containing stone tablets of the Ten
Commandments would find a permanent home here. Those Hebrew men of the lands
of Israel were encouraged to make regular pilgrimages to the temple to
affirm their worship of Yahweh, the true God. Any worship taking place at other
temples and shrines would be considered to be idolatry. Idolatry is the worship
of idols or false gods. In another sense it is the worship of anyone other than
Yahweh, the Almighty God of the lands of Israel. It is this version of monotheism
that led to the birth of the great monotheistic faiths of the modern world
namely Judaism, Christianity and Islam otherwise known as the Abrahamic
religions. After Solomon's death the kingdom of Israel would split.
Judaism. The kings of Israel and Judah after Solomon were, as one might expect,
differing in their degrees of piety in regards to the worship of the deity of
Solomon's temple at Jerusalem, namely Yahweh. Prophets who represented God's
Word would warn peoples of the kingdom of Israel and Judah that they may
attract their ultimate destruction should they not change their ways. As
such and as we learned earlier in the podcast series, the Assyrians would come
to the Levantine lands and they would take Israel and destroy Judah. We
concentrated quite closely on this during episode 8 on the siege of Lachish
which took place in 701 BCE. What we do know is that Jerusalem was spared as the
king Hezekiah may have come to terms with the Assyrians and spared the
capital city as a consequence. After the fall of the Assyrian Empire the
Babylonians would become the dominant power of the Near East. Biblical texts
state that prophets continued to warn the people of Judah to remain faithful
to their covenant with God but this was in vain to some degree as is stated to
be the reason for the destruction of Jerusalem by the Babylonians. The
Babylonians were so enraged with the rebelliousness of the Judeans that they
destroyed Solomon's temple and deported all of the elite class of Judeans. It
would not be until the Babylonians were defeated by the Achaemenid Persians that
the Judeans were permitted to return to Judah and a second temple was constructed
on Temple Mount in Jerusalem to replace Solomon's temple which we mentioned had
been destroyed. A date of 516 BCE is offered as the beginning of worship at
this new temple. During their exile the Jewish people decided that the
existence of any God other than Yahweh should be denied, taking things one step
further than the movement against idolatry and cementing monotheism as a
recognized attribute of the Jewish people. So what happened to El and Baal? El was
really no longer spoken of in the monotheistic world and there was no room
for talk of Baal and any talk of Baal was viewed as a thing of shame. However
some do interpret that Baal and Yahweh are in fact one and the same thing. So
there is no real concluding evidence of how these names really came and went and
how they related to each other and it's very likely that different
interpretations of information existed between different tribes so it's pretty
much impossible to find a definitive story. In fact the Canaanite God Baal is a
associated with a Philistine God, the Lord of the Flies, Baal Zebub, who has
been since regarded in Abrahamic religions as a major demon and whose
name in the Christian Church is more widely known as Beelzebub, which is
another name for the devil. Next time we're going to wrap up our story of the
ancient Near East by bringing you another one of our summary episodes
before we make the geographical move to Egypt where we will go back in time and
pick up the story from the end of the prehistoric volume. Thank you very much
for engaging with this week's podcast, a bit of a diversion from the normal
chronology of history but really I think these episodes are important to gain an
understanding of the spiritual beliefs of the people of these areas and
potentially why they went about their day-to-day lives in the way that they
did because some of the rituals and day-to-day behaviors seem quite bizarre
to us so I think it's quite important for us to visit the mindsets of these
people and their ritualistic behavior. I think it opens a door to us in the way
that we can maybe view their behaviors. I received a message from one of our
Patreons Karen Pleszczycznik who said thanks for taking on such an ambitious
podcast subject I'm still in the early episodes great job on sound quality in
those early days it usually takes podcasts a while to get that right
looking forward to all the podcasts I have to catch up on thanks to the good
sound quality I can listen while driving. Thanks very much Karen that's a really
valuable message for me. The podcast was criticized recently for the sound
quality I sort of re-listened I thought I can't really see that it's too bad but I
did try and open it up to see if anyone else would criticize it and nobody has
actually and Karen I think you've affirmed that the sound quality is quite
good hopefully if it isn't or if there is anything sort of defective about the
podcast quality you'll be kind enough to let me know there's no shame in being
critical it's the way that things get better so please bring it on if you're
struggling in any way at all with the podcast. I think I mentioned possibly in
the last podcast that I developed a bibliography page for the website so
please visit that there I'm also developing a couple of other pages one
of them will be a page to to direct you towards links that have been useful in
the creation of the podcast so all the links that were ever posted on social
media I'm hoping to gather them all up and put them on one page because if you
maybe listen to the the sixth episode of volume one then you'll know that there
was reference to Washoe the chimpanzees videos on YouTube and now that they've
gone so far down the Facebook page they're almost irretrievable so what I
would like to do is put them in a permanent place so that anyone visiting
the podcast for the first time can then go and discover these links it also
gives somewhere to go to have a little play about with some of the interactive
websites that have been quite fun to play with and also those web links that
have been sent in by fans of the podcast who found things that have astonished me
and have entertained me so I'd like to share those with you so we're working on
that the other page that we're looking to create is a list of podcasts that we
are familiar with and podcasts that we promote so generally speaking I mean
I've always said it one of my big favorites is the Rex factor that I've
just entered into series 3 which I've been anticipating for a long time so I'm
looking forward to getting my teeth into series 3 of Rex factor if you like your
English and British history then I highly recommend that one it's a very
good laid-back good humored podcast and it's very well worth a listen you might
well become addicted to it another one of the podcasts which I always recommend
is the history of ancient Greece by Ryan Stitt who tirelessly promotes the work
of others including my work so he deserves all the promotion that we give
him in return and it's a really good high-quality podcast so I strongly
recommend that one going off on a bit of a tangent I was invited by one of our
listeners Joel McKinnon to listen to his rock opera podcast which I was a little
bit hesitant about listening to at first because I'm often listening to history
narratives and and reading history books so I don't often give myself a lot of
time for such entertainment however I was embarking on a long drive during the
week and I decided I'm gonna give this a go and find out what it's all about and
I was actually really hooked to it and I listened to it from start to finish in
one go and I really really enjoyed it so I'm gonna recommend it to the history of
the world podcast listening public so if you want to give it a try you might find
it's very enjoyable I thought it was an absolute quality job he enlisted the
help of Doug Metzger who does the literature and history podcast and I
mentioned him previously in reference to his work on the epic of Gilgamesh and
how he brought that to life during one of his podcasts Doug Metzger is a really
really skilled narrator and he really does justice to Joel McKinnon's work so
give it a go you might just love it I know that I did I was really blown away
and pleasantly surprised by how great it was and really it was such an engaging
project and you know you can do it in three hours the whole thing in three
hours and and I recommend it give it a go you might enjoy it it's called planet
and sky and it's by Joel McKinnon I shall post a link on the social media
pages now talking of social media if you're not following me on Twitter what
are you waiting for follow me on Twitter it's at hot world podcast hot being HOT
history of the world podcast hot world podcast follow me on Twitter there's a
lot of useful stuff going backwards and forwards a lot of link sharing as well
so we're really getting the history of the world listeners community
interacting with each other which is really my wish that I think that that is
what it's all about promoting history interacting sharing ideas this is really
what educates all of us together so come and join in with the interaction on
Twitter okay so now before we sign off for the week we're going to introduce a
new feature and this is called the patreon question time so what we do at
this point we invite our patreons the ones that contribute more than $10 to
the show and you can do that by visiting the patreon website so you can find
links on social media website and through the history of the world
podcast.com website you can contribute towards the show's running costs
obviously we've got the website we've got the the podcast hosting platform and
not to mention all the the books and materials that we have to buy to keep
the show going so if you go to the patreon page and donate to us and if you
accrue more than $10 in donations you get to ask a question and this is
exactly what Matty Yokimo has done he's written in and says I'd like to know how
do the Empire's borders come to be defined like the Roman Empire they
didn't have maps per se did they like we have how did they know where their
borders were was it just because all the hostile were put to the sword and there
was no more rebellions that region became part of the Empire or did they
even consider it like that is the whole maps borders of Empire much more of a
modern thing did scholars ponder where the borders were decided or guess where
the limits were one ended and yeah and the other Empire started so there how
did our definition of Empire borders happen it's an excellent question is no
straightforward answer to this but it's such a good question and something that
I thought about in the past when reading about history the nature of borders and
and how it differs from one society to another and from one time to another I'm
going to attempt to answer the question I'm gonna try and pinpoint six examples
of borders that I can see throughout history and see if it sort of educates
us a bit more about the nature of Empire and kingdom and country borders so the
first example I'm going to talk about is when we go back to ancient times and
something we've touched upon when the Battle of Kadesh took place between
the Hittites and the Egyptians in the 13th century BCE where were the borders
well there was no real treaty that we know of before this happened so we can
only assume that the borders were where the nearest military units said the
borders were so if you were living in that area and there when there was a
Hittite military unit who said listen you answer to me then you probably
answered to that military unit so until the Egyptians came along and kicked the
Hittites out and made you subject to them made you pay tribute to them then
the border would shift and you would be on the other side of it so the borders
would not have been a politically agreed line I don't think during ancient times
it would have actually been whoever was the one bullying you the most is where
you were in terms of the border of the Empire if we fast forward to the Roman
Empire certainly where I live in Great Britain we can see evidence of a border
there where the Romans built a border built a wall which signified the border
of the extent of their Empire basically so the Romans decided to build a border
and that was where the border was who's going to argue with a with a stone wall
that's fortified thanks very much that is the border so that was how the Romans
dealt with it they actually built the border and this would in turn lead to
maybe a division between England and Scotland ultimately there always seemed
to be that traditional boundary between the English and the Scottish over the
course of the the history of the British Isles we can certainly see that
there was a lot of disputes between where the border lied between England
and Scotland and it really was just a case of military action pushing the
border one way or the other so depend on where your army stuck their flag
basically so if for example King Edward the first decided to march north and
move the border between England and Scotland another 50 miles north then he
could effectively do that through conquest certainly then there had to be
sort of legal documents as well to determine what would happen if someone
committed a crime on the opposite side of the board so if an Englishman
committed a crime on Scottish turf where would he then go to be tried for his
crime and and under whose law so there would be a lot of treaties so there was
very much a legal reason for defining the borders certainly medieval times and
in different parts of the world so there would maybe be a legal understanding
that was written into a legal document or a treaty to determine where the
border was certainly then if we go forward into the modern world and
probably the period of colonialization when maybe the European powers
subjugated most of Africa to themselves so they basically carved up the map of
Africa and if you look at the modern map of Africa you will see a lot of
straight-line borders and this is a very very unnatural thing this is where
Europeans sat down with a map of Africa and a ruler and a pen and basically said
there we go draw a line Germany's territory is one side of the border and
English territory is the other side of the border so very very clinical
treatment of the map of Africa and as such this would mean displacement of
people the ethnicities of people so so the modern countries of Africa today do
not reflect the ethnicities of Africa that were historical then so like we
basically as Europeans we created the countries of Africa and they're not
abundant they're not really accurate according to the ethnicities and to the
kingdoms and the local tribes kingdoms and ethnicities of Africa are not
recognized by these country borders similar thing happened when India and
Pakistan were divided in the 20th century by the British Empire as it was
then before they went fully independent as nations there was really a lot of
displaced people by this border and it was you know if you're going to draw a
border and you're going to divide cultures by by means of one line
through the middle of a country then you are going to get an awful lot of
displaced people and it's very very raw feelings attached to that to that period
of history to that episode in the division of the old Indian Raj in the
modern world we see that certainly with the Crimean Peninsula where you know
where is the border in terms of how many countries of the world look at the
Crimean Peninsula it belongs to the Ukraine however following the the unrest
of 2014 the Russians would tell you that the Crimea belongs to them so where is
the actual border and it is really the lesson we learn is the border is really
where you decide it is so unless two countries can agree on where a border is
if they can put it on paper then fine if you can actually put a line in the in
the sand or or actually build a border then that's quite categorical but then
also if two parties can't agree where the border is then the border really
only exists in the imagination of both of those countries so borders are really
not real things they're only real if humans can agree where they belong and
that's really what the nature of borders is and in most cases in a peace in a
peace-chasing world countries do agree on where the borders exist and in most
cases they're not disputed but in some cases they very much still are I mean
you only have to look at maybe the border between Ethiopia and Somalia to
see that it's incomplete so there you go that really is what borders is they're
an imaginary line at the end of the day essentially it's an imaginary line and
it's only any good if both parties either side of that border honor it what
a fantastic question Matty Joachim I hope I've managed to get near to the
answer for you and I'm sure there are historians and scholars out there that
could give you a much more competent answer but I did promise I would answer
your question and and therefore I've done my best to do that so hopefully
hopefully that was at least interesting and a bit insightful well that's it for
this week and next week we will be rounding off the Near East the ancient
Near East will bring it all to a close in readiness to move on to our next set
of podcasts which will be about ancient Egypt so that will be in two weeks time
so I'd really like to thank you for listening to the podcast hope you
enjoyed it and we look forward to meeting up with each other again one
week from now the history of the world podcast is available on many different
podcast platforms so please don't forget to write and review us wherever you find
us visit our website at history of the world podcast comm and email us at
history of the world podcast at mail.com support the podcast at patreon by
clicking the support the podcast link at our website and join us on social media
at Facebook Twitter and tumblr
