Lecture 15

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 21, 2023
Hello everyone, this is Rajshri Sengupta and we are here in the last segment of our discussion
on textiles and Mughal miniatures.
So here we will be talking more about the interrelations between courtly art and textile
practices beyond visual appearance.
I mean of course when we sort of start talking about this idea about the interrelations,
we cannot really go away from the visual appearance because all our discussions and
all our analysis they sort of start from the visual appearance.
However we also need to think that I mean there are certain things as we have already
started sort of uncovering that there are also certain aspects which are not strictly
visual but we need to think that I mean the relationship between like I mean this different
form of art practices are not really always like I mean the visual connections we can
draw but then there are much more deeper connections we can also see that is there
embedded in this very practice of making them and not just seeing them visually.
So this aspects we will see them and then we will start the discussion today with this
notion of landscape.
Now landscape is this idea that we see that I mean that is there in many of the paintings
that we have already seen and either and presence of an landscape or absence of a landscape
that we can see them there and both these cases we can consider that those are conscious
decisions made by the patrons as well as the artist or painters whoever were responsible
for them.
So in this case what happens with this notion of the landscape?
Now art historian Nuzat Kazmi has argued that how landscape and portraiture these two things
in the Mughal context are very closely intertwined.
So in a many of the portrait paintings we will find in which a lot of cases we see the
profile view of the rulers or like the royalties we find them to be there and a lot of times
we see them to be there on this landscape.
Sometime the landscape in which we see that it is almost like a neutral landscape in which
there is a small suggestion of greenery or like the green land and then on the top of
that there is open sky and in some cases we see that certain elements of like I mean garden
architecture or agricultural labors and so on they are also depicted in the landscape.
So in this case what happens that we see the idea of the landscape is something that is
very much there in the representational spaces and then all this notion of the landscape
is also something that is very much connected to the human figures those are depicted in
the in this miniature paintings.
Now in Sylvia Hautling's work we also find that there is something that she mentions
that is the landscape of cloth and by that she means that how there are different kinds
of cloth which were which was flooding the market of Agra or the metropolitan cities
of the Mughal Empire and then all different kind of cloth that sort of like I mean created
this huge diversity and also like a symbolic representation of the different regions that
the Mughals ruled under them.
So this is something we find that in both cases that this idea of the landscape whether
it is a visual representation of a landscape within a painting or like if you think about
this diversity of the artifacts and textiles that were accumulated and they also sort of
like I mean remained synonymous with particular regions or workshops.
So then like I mean bringing the land virtually to the Mughal court and that is how like the
idea of the landscape became important.
So in both cases like for the textiles as well as for this miniature paintings this
notion of the landscape sort of loomed in the background.
Now what we see them there that I mean when we sort of see the figural representations
and then like I mean the landscapes and when in this miniature paintings we see them what
Nuzat Kazmi also argues that they sort of represent certain correlation between them
and then perhaps like the affiliations like I mean if a particular courtly figure is depicted
then the land that is depicted with this courtly figure would have some kind of affiliation
with that figure.
So it is not something that is randomly selected or just selected to remove all the other details
and just to focus on this figure but the kind of land whether there is a presence of a landscape
whether there is a conscious absence of a landscape they speak something about the people
who are depicted there.
Now the other thing that we also find that there is that how the landscape is also something
that is usually used there to convey certain things which are also very hard to convey
in words.
So for example we see this miniature paintings today the way we see them as painting today
they were definitely not made for this kind of viewing experience we can see we can imagine
like I mean they were all associated with written words that I mean some kind of description
some kind of like literary works and then like this paintings would be there side by
side and they were also there for this private viewing experience that people would hold
them close to them hold them close to themselves and then like see them read them and then
put them back to from where they came from.
So this kind of like this experience that we are talking about there are many things
perhaps which are not very easy to express in words and those are the cases we see that
I mean how this visual symbols or like I mean the use of landscape was very much in favor
of sort of expressing certain things which are not really easily expressed.
So with those things what we also see that I mean in this case is that perhaps this intermedial
references that is there from like I mean how the landscape this notion of the landscape
that is there between like I mean the figural textiles and then like I mean perhaps the
land and the figure intertwined in the miniature paintings how those things are there this
also suggest a kind of intermedial cross referencing and this kind of referencing that we see them
there is much more than just to think in terms of like I mean how one person would be doing
something and another person would be copying that and implementing that in another medium.
But it is kind of like I mean all of them we need to imagine them to be working under
this same with this shared visual vocabulary from which like I mean they would borrow certain
motifs and then like I mean perhaps we can see that I mean similar kind of not only just
like I mean similar kind of images are there but the same life vitality will be seeing
them in across media and that is something which goes beyond the visual appearance.
But it is much more about like I mean how we think about the life of this motifs and
how we see them being depicted either on the textiles or in the paintings.
So if we kind of like I mean consider this and sort of also take this kind of examples
to understand certain larger patterns in the Mughal Empire we can see that I mean this
knowledge circulation across media was something that was very much prominent and knowledge
circulation by that I mean that I mean if you are thinking in terms of like using a
shared visual vocabulary between the miniature painters and then the carpet makers, brocade
makers and then of course like I mean you know that the embroiderers.
So we can imagine that I mean all of these peoples a lot of times they were not really
present in the same place as I have already mentioned in the earlier lectures that when
we say that Mughal textiles or textiles came from the Mughal Empire we are not really talking
about textiles that came from this small region but we are actually thinking in terms of this
entire Indian subcontinent from the western frontier to the eastern frontier.
So the embroiderers, the Mochi embroiderers they were perhaps been based in Gujarat in
Ahmedabad or somewhere and then the brocade makers were perhaps in Gujarat some were perhaps
in other parts of the northern Indian plain like Agra, Banaras and places like that and
then definitely like muslin that came from eastern India from Bengal.
So like I mean we are definitely not thinking that this knowledge circulation across media
is happening within a close proximity but then we are thinking in terms of this expansive
geographical travel that either this objects were doing or like the artisans who were associated
with them they were able to like I mean travel from one place to another.
The other possibility that also comes up and which will also come up in our next module
is the use of reference drawings or reference material and how those reference material
can interconnect certain kind of practices that I mean perhaps one practice that is happening
in one region and then if the regional artisans are not able to travel or if the regional
artisans they do not have the exposure what is happening in the other parts of the Indian
subcontinent perhaps like I mean bringing all those kind of reference drawings or those
resource material that help or like I mean that sort of enabled this kind of knowledge
exchanges and this knowledge exchanges is happening not only in one particular medium
like we are not talking about just miniature painting to miniature painting but we are
talking about a diverse range of media.
So in one hand if you are thinking in terms of drawing things with a brush on a paper
then on the other hand we are thinking in terms of making knots with silk yarn on or
like or pashmina yarn on a carpet and then we are also thinking in terms of making brocade
textiles in which there is this highly complex jala is then put in this draw loom structure
for making the brocaded patterns on the fabric.
So this different kind of techniques we are talking about here and then the knowledge
exchange with circulation was happening between them.
So that makes it much more complicated to understand that I mean what kind of knowledge
exchange we are talking about here that it is not something that is simplistic not only
just on the level of the surface but it needs to have this much more deeper understanding
of how each and every motif or like I mean the color gradation variation tonality arrangement
compositional organization all these things work in one medium and how to sort of implement
that in some other cases.
So this kind of aspects we certainly see that to be there in like I mean in this visual
material that we are discussing here.
Now in the last segment of our discussion we will be sort of talking about the one another
kind of textiles and that is the tent and tents are something we find that to be there
very much closely related to the formation of the Mughal dynasty and then like their
travels and also like I mean how they have arrived in the Indian subcontinent.
So what we see there in the king of this tents so the Central Asian connection is something
that is comes at the forefront that how the Mughal emperors like I mean starting with
Patsha Babur we see them that I mean how Babur was sort of like I mean when he was there
in the Central Asian plains and a large part of his life even though he was only alive
for like 38 to 40 years but like a large part of his life he had spent on the fields and
then like I mean in the fields with like I mean and then like I mean this tent structures
were something which survived him and his family.
So we see this huge enclosures were made when he was traveling from one place to another
and there was not really a stable place for him to be rooted for a long period of time
before he sort of won over Kabul and then eventually sort of like I mean attacked the
Lodis in Agra.
So what we see there that I mean this idea of tent being this movable architectural form
is something that is there with the Mughals from very early period.
Now the tents were something we also see in the Sultanate period and all but then of
course that during the Mughal period with like I mean this idea of the tent being a
movable habitable space that sort of became much more expansive and with this we also
see that I mean this idea of this movable habitable space it was not just there in terms
of just a living space but there are descriptions in which we find that when this entire
entourage would travel from one place to another and that in those times we will find
that the tents were sort of put up and it is almost like an entire movable city would
be there with this tent structures.
So for example in Rubilal's discussion of Empress Nur Jahan who was the co-sovereign
with Emperor Jahangir.
So we see a lot of this times we find that this extensive travels that Jahangir made
and in many of the travels when Nur Jahan associated him we find that I mean there are
those detailed description about how their entourage would stop in one place and then
the end those those tents would be sort of put up and there would be enclosures and enclosures
and it's almost like replicating an entire palace complex or palace and bazaars and everything
within those tent structures.
So this is something for us to understand that when we are talking about tent we are
not just talking about a small tent structure that is to give us security and safety but
we are actually talking about having all possible capacities of leading a life that that someone
would have in a palace or within a royal enclosure and all those kind of facilities
would be available within a tent structure.
So this is something we are talking about here when we talk about this particular Mughal
tents.
So in this case what we see that I mean the one tent that we have here and this is perhaps
like I mean this one surviving like I mean Mughal tent ensemble that is there which is
known as Lal Dehra and this tent came from 17th late 17th to early 18th century and
it was during the Mughal conquest of the Marwar and Jodhpur region and so this tent like I
mean this entire this tent ensemble that we see on screen is there with the Mehrangarh
fort museum.
So this is something we find here that this Lal Dehra tent that has been made and it was
made entirely of red velvet and as we have like I mean very briefly sort of address that
I mean velvet making is this warp pile weave that is again a very complicated way of doing
fabric making and that is done on the draw loom.
So that is the technique that is used here for making the entire tent that we have here
and then on the top of that we also have that how the the intricate embroidered motifs are
been made.
So the embroidery is done with silk and zari threads and then on the top of the velvet
fabric.
So what we see in this tent structure it is essentially it is a square tent structure
here and it is of course like I mean we can see the enclosure and then like on the top
of that there is a roof so that that to give protection to like I mean to the people and
then we also see that I mean what is there in terms of like I mean there is this central
space which is there for a royalty for the royalty to sit and also perhaps like I mean
have a session with the other courtyards and then we also have this covered colonnade or
like I mean this covered a corridor like spaces around it.
So and that is how like the entire structure of this square structure of the tent is made.
So this is something we find it there and then this arch colonnade that we see there
at this arches if we see them closely it is very much sort of like I mean reminder of
the Mughal arches that we see in the Mughal architecture.
So we see this thin columns and then those arches this cusped arch in which like I mean
we see this cusped motif is there all across in this arches.
So this is something we find that to be prominently there in the Mughal palace complexes in this
open sort of like I mean this structures and then that is there in this tent structure
as well this thin columns and then also like I mean this cusped arch gateways, archways
and even like I mean the kind of motifs we find that to be there on the archways that
I mean the continuation of this pillars or like I mean you know this vertical strips
of this fabric that is there and then here in this triangular space we have like I mean
the floral motifs and decoration very much in alignment with the kind of decorations
we will find in the actual architectural spaces.
And then we can also imagine that I mean how this idea about tent being a movable city
itself like I mean it is not just like this much of tent but we are talking about like
the entire like I mean all the other tents and the entire enclosure being a movable city.
So we see that I mean there is a meticulous effort towards sort of making a correlation
between the Mughal architecture and the Mughal textile and that is the reason we find that
there is this attention towards sort of almost like resonating certain aspects of Mughal
architecture within this tent structure.
And of course like I mean you know we have poles underneath this fabric structure which
would support the roof and that is that will like I mean hold the structure together.
So this is how like I mean the tent structures we find them to be there and then like I mean
this particular Lal Dehra was also was displayed in this Houston Art Museum in 2018 in this
one particular exhibition and in which like I mean part of Lal Dehra and then like this
entire installation sort of like I mean took place within the museum space and that also
sort of gives us a sense of what kind of space the tent actually created.
If you think about it that how there is a roof and then there is this open structure
of this arches and then with this thin columns that we have here it is very much like the
kind of like I mean the architectural structures that we have in the Mughal metropolitan, the
metropolitan cities.
So for example this Diwan-e-Kha structure that we see here in the left side of the screen
and it is entirely made of marble and in this one we also see this kind of this formation
in which this squarish or rectangular formation of this structure is there and then we have
those cusped arch gateways or the archways and then those seemingly thin columns.
I mean of course for an architecture the columns need to be much more thicker because
of like I mean stability but here for the textile the columns can also be thin because
they only need to support the poles which are going sort of like I mean through them.
So but overall we can certainly see that there are certain kind of resemblances we can find
and this particular kind of open structures that we find that there are arches, there
are columns but then there are no specific walls which would sort of like I mean encompass
the entire space but in this cases we find that there were textiles which were hung from
the top of them and that is the reason in this architectural structures we have like
I mean those iron nails or like I mean arrangements for like I mean hanging textiles with them.
So this kind of arrangement that make us think that I mean how architecture and textile in
the Mughal context was very much interrelated and then like I mean the openness in the architecture
is something that is there to be filled with textile and then in this case with this tent
structure that we find it here that it almost sort of like I mean replicates this openness
of the architecture because it is already there within an enclosure.
Like here we can see that there is a another enclosure that sort of like I mean goes around
this tent that makes us think that I mean yes there are already like I mean those chicks
or like I mean other enclosures which are around this tent that would eventually make
this place as a closed space.
So this relationship between textile and architecture we find that to be there very much that I
mean we cannot really say that I mean it is just the textiles like I mean this tent textile
is something that is borrowing from the architecture but if we consider those aspects of openness
and closeness we find that I mean even the this the marble architecture or this stable
architecture is also dependent on the textiles to be made into this enclosed space.
Without the textiles this structure of Diwan-e-Khas cannot be an enclosed space as we can imagine.
Now the other thing we also see that I mean in the description of this Lal Dehra or this
Khanat from the Mehrangarh Museum collection we see them that I mean it has been considered
that it was perhaps been used for a private audience hall I mean or like I mean this kind
of private meetings and it is not something that we can imagine that was there for a public
meeting for the emperors or the royals.
So and that way we can see that I mean this particular architectural structure which this
tent that also sort of reminded us of is of Diwan-e-Khas and Diwan-e-Khas is also a hall
of private audience and not of public audience.
So this kind of resemblances we see that I mean this this interrelation between like
architecture and textile in the Mughal context is something that is very much contextual.
We cannot really see that I mean one was just sheepishly copying the other but there are
many other layers in which we need to understand that what kind of correlations were made and
that is the reason we find that this idea of like I mean this multi-level narratives
which are sort of like I mean being built into it whether we are actually looking at
figurative narratives or not but this levels of narratives which we see them there are
actually created through this cross references across media.
Now to with that I mean I sort of like I mean like to conclude this discussion saying
that I mean how when we see the architectural motifs and when we also see that the textiles
together and then what all like I mean similarities differences we can think of.
Now here in the left side of the screen we have this monument that is tomb of Itimad-ud-Daulah
and that is Nur Jahan's parents and of course like I mean Itimad-ud-Daulah was Nur Jahan's
father but then Nur Jahan's mother was also buried there and in this particular tomb that
we find it is again it has this square format with like I mean this four minarets corners
and in the center we see that there is this one pavilion on the top of the roof.
So in this monument that we find that I mean it this marble made monument it has this tremendous
work of Pietra Dura or the Parchinkari in which we see that I mean how there were the
different kind of stone fragments which are used and then like I mean they were sort of
like inlaid into the marble for making different kind of colorful motifs.
And this is something we see that I mean how the flavor of like I mean perhaps that I mean
making carpets or like I mean the hanging textiles which would we can imagine as like
those chicks which would be like I mean covering the open area between two columns in a Mughal
court. So those kind of things perhaps are then reminded of and then they are perhaps been sort
of like I mean replicated in the or not replicated perhaps like I mean you know
their essence is sort of like I mean brought into the marble structure of this building.
And this building as we can see that I mean it is much more of a closed surface it's not
as those characteristic open spaces of like Diwan-e-Am or Diwan-e-Khas.
And in this case like I mean it almost seems that how the textiles those richly decorated
ornamental textiles which would be like I mean hanging from the roof to the floor
something that is almost like being resonated in the Pietra Dura work that is there all across the
walls of this monument. So this is something we can imagine that I mean whether something we can
see that this idea about like the exchanges those to take place between textile and architectural
motives are something that is not really just once not really single directional.
But there are always like this cross references those happened between them and perhaps that I
mean combination of the knowledge that came from all these different aspects had encouraged the
artisans for doing this tremendous experimentations also achieving the kind of skill that is still
considered as wonder today. Thank you.
