How much was lost when the Library of Alexandria burned?

ancient literature
168 followers
1 Video View·Oct 21, 2023
How much was lost when the Library of Alexandria burned?
According to a medieval legend, the library of Alexandria was destroyed on the orders
of the Caliph Omar.
There were so many books, the story goes, that the only way to dispose of them was to
use them as fuel in the city's four thousand bathhouses.
So into the furnaces they went, day after day, week after week.
The wit and wisdom of a thousand years going up in smoke, and bits of blackened books raining
on the weary rooftops of Alexandria.
It took six months to burn them all.
This never actually happened.
Even if the Caliph had wanted to destroy Alexandria's books, he would have found few left to burn.
By his time, the library had already vanished, and already become shrouded in mystery.
That mystery endures.
The library's site has never been discovered, and is unlikely to ever emerge from its concrete
tomb beneath the modern metropolis.
Many of the questions that surround it can never be answered.
But in this video, I hope to at least contextualize the significance of the library's loss.
The library of Alexandria was established around 300 BC by Ptolemy I.
Ptolemy, once a companion of Alexander the Great, had established himself as king of
Egypt, with the bustling seaside metropolis of Alexandria as his capital.
By assembling texts and intellectuals, Ptolemy hoped to burnish the reputation of his kingdom
and capital.
To those ends, he offered generous stipends to any scholar who would join his court, and
began aggressively acquiring books.
Ptolemy's library was part of the museon, a sort of proto-university that stood beside
the royal palace.
The museon seems to have consisted of a courtyard ringed by stoas and lecture halls, and included
a dining room where the resident scholars took meals.
The storerooms and reading rooms of the library were apparently attached to the museum complex.
Ptolemy's son and grandson expanded the library, sending scholars and agents to scour the markets
of the Greek world for new purchases.
Their bibliomania was so intense that ships arriving in Alexandria were compelled to surrender
all books on board for copying.
The library soon swelled to gargantuan proportions.
Some ancient authors claimed that it contained 700,000 books, books in this context meaning
papyrus scrolls.
We don't know the actual number, though it's often assumed that it was far lower.
Those inclined to minimize the size of the library, however, should keep in mind that
some ancient scholars were extremely prolific.
For example, the Alexandrian scholar Didymus, nicknamed Bronze Guts for his inhuman work
reportedly produced nearly 4,000 books over the course of his lifetime.
The scholars who worked in the library under the early Ptolemies became famous throughout
the Greek world.
It was in the library that the circumference of the earth was first calculated, that the
standard texts of the Homeric poems were established, and, fittingly, that the first library catalog
was devised.
Like tenured academics in every era, the scholars at the library also spent a great deal of
time and energy attacking one another on points of pedantry, a habit that earned the
musean the nickname Birdcage of the Muses.
The great library declined under the later Ptolemies, who had less money and less inclination
to spend that money on squabbling scholars.
But it wasn't 48 BC, and at the hands of Julius Caesar, that the library suffered its first
great disaster.
Caesar, fresh from his victory over Pompey, had become involved in a civil war that pitted
the famous Cleopatra against her brother, Ptolemy XIII.
When Ptolemy's forces tried to seize a fleet moored in Alexandria's harbor, Caesar ordered
the ships burnt to keep them out of enemy hands.
Unfortunately, the fire spread from the docks to the adjacent palace quarter.
According to some ancient authors, the flames destroyed the library.
Other authors claimed that only a portion of the collection was destroyed.
It's sometimes theorized that the burnt books were not in the main library, but in harbor
warehouses.
It seems most likely, however, that at least part of the library really was destroyed.
Only a few years later, Mark Antony is said to have given Cleopatra 200,000 books from
Pergamum.
A gift of this magnitude would only make sense if the Alexandria library had been depleted.
The library continued to operate during the Roman imperial era.
Though no longer a hotbed of original research, it seems to have remained accessible to scholars,
and was apparently subsidized by the Roman administration.
During the 3rd and 4th centuries AD, however, Alexandria experienced a massacre, an invasion,
a civil war, and a tsunami, any or all of which might have destroyed the library.
By the end of the 4th century, if not sooner, the palace quarter, in which the main library
was located, was mostly abandoned.
Ptolemy II had established a branch of the library, accessible to the public, in the
marble porticos surrounding the Temple of Serapis.
But in 391, amidst savage street warfare between Christian and pagan mobs, the temple was demolished.
The stoas that sheltered the library were not destroyed, and would in fact survive into
the Middle Ages.
But since we hear nothing more about the books, it's often assumed that they were damaged
or dispersed at this time.
We don't know, in short, exactly when the great library in the palace, and the branch
library in the Serapaeum, were destroyed.
But there is no clear evidence for large libraries after the 4th century, and by the time of
the Arab conquest, the library of Alexandria was likely no more than a distant memory.
Libraries must have destroyed many books.
But the greatest culprit was almost certainly simple decay.
The library of Alexandria was dependent on sustained elite patronage and investment.
When this dried up, and when the texts ceased to be cared for and recopied, the scrolls
of the library simply rotted away in Alexandria's humid air.
Before we continue, I would like to talk briefly about this video's sponsor, Blinkist.
Blinkist is an app that provides text and audio summaries of thousands of nonfiction books.
If you're interested in learning more on the go, check out the link in the description.
The first 100 people to click will get free and unlimited access to Blinkist for a week.
This trial can be canceled at any time without charge.
Back to our topic.
How much was lost with the library of Alexandria?
And how significant were these losses?
At the risk of making an obvious point, the library of Alexandria was not the only library
in the classical world.
There were hundreds of others, some very large.
Only the most obscure works in the library of Alexandria would have not been represented
by other copies elsewhere.
It's only because the library of Alexandria's decline was symptomatic of the more general
decline of classical culture.
Because, in other words, all the ancient world's libraries fell into decay at the same time
that so many works were lost in late antiquity.
It is sometimes said that the destruction of the library of Alexandria set civilization
back by centuries.
This is a wild exaggeration.
The scrolls in the library did not contain the bases, as is occasionally implied, for
great advances in science and technology.
Although there were certainly many works of mathematics and physics in the library,
the most important of these were widely disseminated elsewhere.
What perished with the library were, overwhelmingly, lesser-known works of literature and philosophy,
commentaries and monographs, all the residue and introspection of an extremely sophisticated
literary culture.
Such works would be a treasure beyond price for scholars of the classics.
But they were not the stuff of a foreclosed golden age.
If you enjoyed this video, please consider supporting Toledon Stone on Patreon.
Every donation helps me to continue making carefully researched videos about ancient
history.
You might also be interested in my book, Naked Statues, Fat Gladiators, and War Elephants.
Thanks for watching.
