It's being the oldest daughter of an Asian immigrant family the hardest position to have let's discuss
Yeah, let's play the clip from Francine Ng. Wow, Francine. Oh, they don't know you are like this. We didn't know
No, but this is going really viral. Shout out to Francine. She's actually a clinical
Psychology graduate student. So I guess this is the type of stuff that she thinks about shout out to her
Um, it sparked a lot of debate or at least a lot of like conversation a lot of people weighed in and agreed with her
Maybe some people are debating her. We'll see we'll go into the comment section
But please hit that like button and check out other episodes of the hot pot boys
Yeah
but what you know what's
Undebatable Andrew is the value of small a that you can pre-order right now at small a sauce calm from Sichuan to Sicily and amazing
Finishing oil and we have an older sister
She did ultimately live a different life than us being the eldest in the family
Also being a girl you almost not fully but you quasi become like a second mother. Yeah
She changed her diapers growing up
Yeah, I think a lot of Asian women can relate to that aspect of like if they're the eldest daughter
They were more probably expected to be probably more stable
You know, I mean, I think eldest sons for sure have responsibilities and expectations for sure, but they're just different, right?
Right, right, right and they usually and this is true for our other friends eldest sister
that was like the oldest kid in the family to usually they
Follow the traditional path and they don't be too rebellious or try to go against the parents wishes
Especially in what is traditionally viewed as a negative way
Yeah
I think that they probably on average I would bet argue with the parents and give pushback to the parents the least
I least um in the beginning
Yeah
And this is ultimately in my opinion and I'm sure in Francine Ings opinion to as well a function of traditional Asian society
Yeah, like this, you know the different positioning. It's just like do you think it's only Asian now? This is a question
I have do you think it only applies to Asians or even like just whatever a traditional?
American or European family may be like there's probably some similarity. Yeah, you know what it is
I just think that other like you said like for example, it might be the same
But just there's a higher percentage of Asian immigrants that are traditional than other groups, right?
There's other groups that may have moved more towards some sort of new
Two thousands way of doing yeah, I'm sure if you looked at
Let's just say like Eastern European immigrants in America or even Irish immigrants or Latino Latino, right? Yeah Latino immigrants
Their eldest daughters may still have that a similar position, right? Yeah, right, right. Anyway, let's get into the comment section Andrew
There was just a bunch of girls saying accurate. I feel seen the pain
Um, why do you think it's like so many people that I guess?
Nobody had ever really mentioned it before everybody kind of knew this but nobody had made a meme about it
So that's why this guy's millions of views on tick-tock between tick-tock and Instagram. Yeah, I mean, I think memes
This is what memes are meant for you
Just say one simple thing and you point it out and it's delivered, you know in a fun way
And it's easy to consume and yeah, I mean, I don't think this is the first time it's ever been said on the internet
I know that there's been like blog posts about this before but as far as people they don't like to read so they just want
To watch a tick-tock. So yes, I do think it hit a lot of people and yeah
A lot of Asian women are weighing in and being like, oh, yeah, this is definitely my family
Do you think it might possibly be more true for people who are even older like, you know
What I mean more towards their 30s and more towards their 40 because those immigrant family waves were even more traditional. Yeah
Yeah, I agree
David you remember the part of her tick-tock where she says like you think you're having a breakdown
But then she snaps out of it
Like what do you think that is is a bit like that the that the oldest daughter is meant to be super mentally tough like
Emotionally tough. Yeah, she doesn't get to be
She doesn't get to like weep in her like yeah
I actually think that that's what she's referring to because I
Think the reason why that people feel so seen is because from what I've seen the oldest
Child that is a daughter that is forced to be that secondary mother
They don't complain a lot almost much like an immigrant doesn't complain
They're they're expected to just to tough it out like snap out of it. Come on. Come on. Yeah. Oh, you're feeling sad
Well, well, you know what Francine you don't have time to feel sad, right? Right, right
They can't wallow in it for sure. Um, this next comment says I paved the way and fought for the rights
My siblings enjoyed growing up. Yeah. I mean, I think that that's natural, right?
You always have every kid is a pioneer for the next kid, right?
For sure for sure and and it can go like more and more each time
Somebody said I know this is supposed to be funny
But don't normalize Asian mental health issues if you are sad depressed get help
Do not just cram it down and somebody said I did this until adulthood now
I have anxiety and depression and other people said well, why not just cram it down and someone said nope
I never thought about you know getting help because that's weak
So basically there was still a debate which is classic within the Asian American community about
How much do we need to lean or not lean into mental health? Oh
Yeah, yeah
because I can see
Depending on what the trauma is or the struggle or the mental struggle that you're going through
You don't want to just keep cramming it down forever. No, cuz that can have some very very bad long-term
Don't a lot of us don't want to view ourselves as the weakest person either
So there's this balance where it's like yo, maybe we should have like a booklet maybe Francine Ng because she's in you know
The psychology field maybe she needs to put like a breakdown like hey if this is the trauma that you're going through
Definitely go seek help. And then maybe if this is what you're going through maybe
Maybe you can suck it up to some extent
But it also depends on who's around you who you could talk to who are your friends at the time, right?
Right, and we've seen the macro statistics Asian Americans are actually the group least likely to seek mental therapy
100% you could also argue
I'm not saying for sure that some people in America in 2023 are over diagnosing it
They're over seeking mental. But but I guess like as long as mental health
Is help is available then I guess it's not wrong in seeking it like if you just have that inkling, right?
It's not wrong to go do that. But I do think there's times where you can
Suck it up and then there's times that you just can't you gotta get help, right?
Somebody said what is worse being the only daughter or the oldest daughter and then this oldest daughter came through and said, of course
No comparison. I'm not trying to make this a trauma competition
But being the eldest daughter not only do you have the responsibility of parents
But then you have the responsibility of being like a child to your parents
But also a second parent to the other siblings and then you know
She just goes down a list of like, you know
Especially if there's family is dysfunctional then you almost become the parent parent
People's like roles drop off. You got a fill-in. Yeah. Yeah, you know what it is
I think there's different types of pressure of being a single child from what I've been told being a single child because too much focuses
On you and you get all the pressure, right?
It's not spread apart. So then that pressure can build up and mess with you
but yeah
if you're the eldest daughter of a family and you have a lot of younger siblings that you have to take care of and then
Especially if mom and dad have whatever troubles, you know, they don't speak English
Yeah, translate all the letters
even if they don't speak English or they have trouble finding work or it's a broken family then your
Responsibilities are like times five
So, yeah, I mean I definitely know families like that so shout out to all the responsible
Older sisters out there older siblings in general, but older sisters, especially somebody said I used to be really bad at managing my emotions
But these days I pretty much just go nonverbal and numb once I feel a mental breakdown is coming. Somebody said same
I'm just quiet AF
This is this is uh, you know, like I'm not saying this is the best way to deal with it
But it it's probably better than having a mental freakout and having your brain go ultra frenetic
Yeah, but I think doesn't how you deal with mental health or like stress and trauma
It doesn't also kind of depend on your personality
Like if you're an extrovert and you talk about it with friends
You're probably more likely to express it with other friends
If you have them versus if you're an introvert
I can see that making it even tougher because you already don't love talking to people
Yeah, I did notice that especially like, you know, I don't want to say but like, you know
Even witnessing my older sister. It's like she had sometimes you have so many responsibilities
That when life gets frustrating you can't fight everything like you can't fight every battle, right?
You know what? I mean? Like sometimes you just gotta like like this person said where you just like you just go
Okay, that's how we're doing it, right? Yeah. I mean, I think that's everybody but I think that I think about the oldest
sibling
Like just talking about our family, I guess like, you know, our oldest sister
She didn't have to pick up like the financial burden of our family, right?
But she does she did pick up the I would say the traditional list
Aspect of our family because she's only going to good schools getting really good
She went to a good school has a husband has a family has cute little kids
Has a house now that you know, our parents can visit, you know
I mean so has a whole life that she maybe I don't know if she felt it as part of her
Duty which I'll ask her after this video whether to have kids or not
But you know, maybe she already felt but I also think it was in her personality as well
Like so it does depend heavily on your personality on how you handle
Yeah, for sure
This is not gonna be true for like a hundred out of a hundred Asian families
But it sure seems like a trend that is easily observable in my own life as well as some of my you know
What it is. I think it's slightly true for like all
Oldest sisters on different levels. It's all like a little bit true though
At least somebody said last but not least shout out to my older sister
I got to stay out late AF when I was a teenager while she just had to study for the SATs
Yo, you you got to be a boy
Leaving this comment Chuni be this has to be a guy's comment
How different is the situation between boys and girls in traditional Asian families? Yeah, it's pretty different
I mean, it's different
I mean, I think being a boy in a family period versus a girl is different and then I think
But it is true maybe in traditional cultures, let's just say the more newly arrived from different worlds
Let's just say the in recent 1970s Asians and Latin American Latinos
Like maybe the way they treat boys and girls is even bigger. There's even a bigger despair possibly. I don't know
Yeah, I think that's debatable. But yeah, definitely. I mean it's makes sense
You know because they're coming from a traditional background and the old world. Yeah
Anyways guys you let me know in the comments down below what you think about this tik-tok
I I guess does it relate to you?
Does it relate to your family relate to your friends that you know, I would say overall it's fairly true
Yeah, I mean, you know what? This is the dope thing. Like you said earlier about social media. There have probably been
Psychological or like, you know academic papers written for decades about this
But unless you're in that sphere, it's not even gonna reach you at all or unless you're super well read
This tik-tok Andrew it brings something so relatable. It's so easily consumable to the masses
So it really is like allowing these ideas and allowing people to feel seen so as much as I enter everybody
This is tik-tok. Shout out to Francine Ng. Hey Francine
Great tik-tok me and your mommy are so proud of you for making such a
interesting and
Conversation thought-provoking tik-tok. Okay. Thank you Francine. What a great starter piece
Anyway, guys, let us know what you guys think in the comment section below. Do you agree disagree? What are your own personal anecdotes?
Until next time we hop our boys we out