Averting the Crisis of Alzheimer's Disease, Part 1

UC Davis Academics
12 followers
8 Video Views·Oct 16, 2023
This is the first of two videos featuring Cordula Dick-Muehlke, director of education, at UC Irvine MIND. She addresses the multiple challenges that the growing epidemic of Alzheimer's disease presents to California and the nation. She highlights key elements of the California State Plan for Alzheimer's Disease, released to the state Legislature last year, and the National Plan to Address Alzheimer's Disease.
Thank you everyone for coming. My name is Bob Huffeldt. I'm the director of the UC Center in Sacramento.
And I'm happy to introduce Cardula Dekmulke from Irvine today to talk to us about Alzheimer's disease and public policy.
Thank you for coming, Cardula.
I'm happy to be here. Hi, everybody. I'm the director of education at the UCI Institute for Memory Impairments and Neurological Disorders.
And towards the end of the talk, I'll show you a little bit about what we specifically do at UCI Mind.
So I want to talk a little bit first about just the impact of Alzheimer's disease, how many people are affected.
And as you can see on the slide, that today in our country, someone develops Alzheimer's disease every 68 seconds.
By 2050, that will actually be once every 33 seconds.
It's a huge problem, and it has a huge societal cost, as you can see, of $200 billion.
And that's just direct costs.
That's not all the human indirect costs that are paid by family members.
Interestingly, as you can see, there are 5.4 million people today with Alzheimer's disease.
And look at the number of caregivers.
The number of caregivers has nearly tripled that at 15.2 million.
So it means for every one person with the disease, there are at least three close family members involved in care.
This disease doesn't leave anybody unaffected.
This is a collage of the many famous people who have been affected by Alzheimer's disease that you will, I'm sure, recognize.
Certainly not going to identify them all, but just point out currently still living Coach Pat Summit, and then Glen Campbell,
who was most recently announced that he has Alzheimer's disease as well.
So where is this disease going in terms of numbers?
Well, the projection is that by 2050, there will be anywhere from 13.5 million to 16 million people in the United States affected by Alzheimer's disease.
We have not made any further progress towards better treatments, ways to prevent or delay the disease.
Here in California, I want to particularly point out, there's some Orange County data specific to us,
but particularly point out that 10% of the people with Alzheimer's disease live in the state of California,
and it's the sixth leading cause of death in our state.
We'll come back to the other bullet as well.
That one in eight of us, baby boomers, people my age, will develop Alzheimer's disease.
One in six, some other form of dementia.
So the numbers here in the state of California will double.
This is people 55 and older, to 1.1 million by 2030, which is only 18 years away.
It's not very far away at all.
And remember what I said about three for one.
So what you have to take into consideration is there's another 3 million caregivers that you need to add to that number
to get a true number of how many people are going to be affected by this disease.
The yellow bars versus the blue bars show you that the vast majority of people with Alzheimer's disease in our state,
and across the nation, actually are 75 years and older.
So that means they're also dealing with a lot of other illnesses and issues as well.
Particularly important for our state is the fact that the number of people of Hispanic background and also of Asian background
are both going to triple by 2030.
And there, specifically, the number of Hispanics affected is going to grow to almost 300,000,
and of Asian Pacific Islanders is going to grow to almost 200,000 in the same time span.
So in terms of public policy and in terms of where we need to go with this disease,
we need to take the needs of diverse persons into consideration
and how we are going to meet those families' needs.
Well, there are a lot of risk factors for Alzheimer's disease,
but the number one risk factor is growth and old age.
And that's one of the reasons that you see the disease occurring more and more,
because a large generation of baby boomers is now reaching retirement age.
What this particular slide illustrates for you is just several studies that have been done.
But all of these studies, even though there are some variabilities in terms of the percentage of increase,
show that the older you get, the more at risk you are for Alzheimer's disease.
Essentially, the prevalence of Alzheimer's disease doubles every five years, beginning at 65.
So you can see here about 4 to 15 percent over age 75.
Some studies indicate that as many as one out of two people over age 85 are affected by the disease.
This particular information actually came out just yesterday in the LA Times.
It's actually from a JAMA article, Journal of the American Medical Association.
And this answers the question why we didn't see Alzheimer's disease so prevalent in past decades.
Look at that life expectancy and how it has changed in the last 68 years.
In the last 68 years, the average life expectancy across men and women for African Americans
has gone from 33 years to 74.1 years.
That's 125 percent increase.
And for Caucasians, from 47.3 years in 1940 to 78.7 years, which is a 66 percent increase.
So we are now living into the age when we become most at risk for Alzheimer's disease.
So just briefly, I wanted to share with you what the progression of Alzheimer's disease is.
And we now recognize that Alzheimer's disease starts in your brain decades before you ever show clinical symptoms.
So there is a long, silent period of the disease where your brain is being affected,
but you don't show any outward signs of the disease.
And that's the preclinical part of the disease.
At some point, however, you start to become aware that there are some difficulties happening.
And perhaps someone that's close to you starts to notice some difficulties as well.
These are subtle changes, and you move into a phase called mild cognitive impairment.
When you or someone you love notices there's a problem, it is significant.
When you're tested with cognitive tests, it's significant versus other people your age.
But basically, you're still able to function in your daily life.
You're still able to do your everyday activities with relatively no problem.
The reason this line happens severe often three ways is because mild cognitive impairment greatly increases your risk for advancing Alzheimer's disease.
However, it is not a fait accompli, and some people remain stable, and a few, for reasons we don't know right now, actually get better.
But as I said, it greatly increases your risk.
And if those brain changes continue to worsen, you will develop a full-blown dementia.
And a full-blown dementia is characterized by three features.
A loss of intellectual ability, affecting your memory, plus one or more other cognitive abilities.
So it might be language, reasoning, judgment.
And that impairment is so severe, it interferes with your ability to do your everyday activities, to carry out your work life, your social life,
eventually to take care of even your most basic needs.
Now, there are a lot of causes for cognitive impairment and dementia, and this slide summarizes the various causes.
We won't go into all these various causes, but basically it's to communicate that there are a variety of causes,
and they basically fall into three categories, which is causes that are reversible, which can be corrected and treated, and your cognition comes back to normal.
And in fact, the most common reversible cause of cognitive problems in the elderly are medication side effects.
Now, the reversible causes only account for about 10 to 15% of all cases of dementia.
There are non-progressive types of dementia.
Those might be like a traumatic head injury, such as in the news a lot, football injury, repeated football injuries, concussions.
Excuse me, that's an incorrect example.
A traumatic head injury more like a traumatic head injury that you would have in an auto accident where you would remain stable,
you would have some cognitive impairment, but there would not be a progressive change.
And then the progressive types of dementia, which actually account for about 80, 85% or more of the dementias,
with Alzheimer's disease being the most common.
And there are other types of dementia that you may have heard about.
Vascular dementias related to stroke, dementia with Lewy bodies, dementia related to Parkinson's disease.
But the number one cause of dementia is Alzheimer's disease far and away.
So this slide illustrates that for you.
Over half of all dementias, the primary cause is Alzheimer's disease.
You can see dementia with Lewy bodies, which has some features similar to Parkinson's disease,
but it's not Parkinson's disease and has progressive declines.
It's the second most common cause, followed by vascular dementias.
What's very interesting though is when a patient goes to brain autopsy,
people in these categories here, very, very often Alzheimer's disease is also present in the brain
in addition to the dementia with Lewy bodies or the vascular changes.
So basically Alzheimer's disease is the primary or a secondary cause of dementia in 75% of all cases.
So what is this progression like once you cross that threshold of mild cognitive impairment to Alzheimer's disease?
Well, it lasts anywhere from 8 to 20 years.
The average lifespan is approximately 9 years after diagnosis.
The person is becoming progressively worse with cognition, not just memory,
but all other cognitive abilities, language, reasoning, judgment, their visual-spatial abilities,
their abilities to find their way around the world.
But it's not just a disease that affects you cognitively.
It also affects your behaviors and personality.
So you see people becoming more apathetic and depressed and irritable or having personality changes
and then exhibiting difficult behaviors, aggressiveness, wandering, tremendously difficult behaviors to manage.
And in fact, one of the major causes of institutionalization is these behaviors that are so difficult to manage.
Into the severe stages, the person loses the capacity to do even the most simple things for themselves.
Dressing, grooming, ultimately bathing, toileting, and becomes eventually bedridden,
with most often the cause of death being that the person succumbs to an infection such as pneumonia.
So Alzheimer's disease has this tremendous financial cost.
These are the direct costs, as you can see, with Medicare being the largest proportion right now.
So that totals $200 billion.
Families are paying or spending $33.8 billion straight out of pocket.
So it's an untenable societal burden.
If you think about the growth in the number of individuals affected by Alzheimer's disease,
this is something that's going to break our bank in terms of health care.
And people with dementia, clearly, health care costs are much greater for them than for people without dementia.
So overall, as you can see, this is Medicare spending, 65 and older.
Overall, all categories together, health care costs for people with dementia are four times as high.
If you take a person with dementia that they don't have any other coexisting medical conditions,
you can see that the costs are 10 times as high.
If that person has one or two other illnesses, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease,
congestive heart failure, diabetes, the cost is three times as high.
And if they have three or more coexisting conditions, the cost is actually twice as high.
And most people with dementia, with Alzheimer's disease, remember I said are 75 and older,
most of those people have multiple coexisting health problems that they're dealing with.
But right now, I think we need to recognize that our society is escaping even further costs
because we rely on families. Families are the foundation of long-term care.
And this is the most recent data from the Alzheimer's disease facts and figures report
that the Alzheimer's Association puts out every year.
Look at those numbers in terms of, I didn't correct the slide, I'm sorry.
I looked at this last night and saw I put dollar signs here and that's not correct.
Hours of unpaid care, look at that.
In California, one billion, 716 million.
In the United States as a whole, 17 billion hours of unpaid care calculated out
here in the state of California, $21 billion nearly of unpaid care.
I'm going to get back to this in terms of the health care issues that caregivers have
because health care costs are also greater for them.
I just pointed out to you the excess health care costs for people with dementia.
Well, caregivers also have health issues that are directly related to the task of caregiving
that then increase also their health care costs.
So I wanted to speak a little bit specifically about caregivers
because that's the foundation that we rely on and we aren't sustaining our foundation
when it comes to the kinds of things one might be concerned about from a public policy perspective.
So there are lots of studies on caregiving and I think it's really important to,
when you look at those studies, to look at whether they're lumping all caregivers together
or they're specifically looking at caregivers of people with Alzheimer's or another dementia.
And so like this study did, they compared those groups and you can see one of the impacts
is that caregiving for people with dementia is considerably longer.
So the blue bars being those caregivers.
43% caring for four or more years, 32% for five or more years.
It's a long duration of caregiving.
So what are the costs of caregiving?
The human costs, you can see some studies in these two.
In one case was comparing caregivers of people with Alzheimer's
to caregivers of people who are physically disabled and that's on the left.
And you can see that the additional impact of having someone have cognitive limitations
really increases the stress and increases the impact of having to make changes
to one's personal life and one's work life.
Then on the right, in another study that compared caregivers of people with Alzheimer's
as compared to non-caregivers, you can see the mental health issues that are coming up.
33% of caregivers at least experience depression.
61% of caregivers that were surveyed by the Alzheimer's Association recently
reported their stress as being high to very high.
And similarly, a similar percentage, 53%, rated the financial impact as high to very high.
The literature clearly has demonstrated that to be a dementia caregiver
is the most stressful type of caregiving.
And it has health consequences, significant health consequences that are listed here.
You know, people are expressing more stress hormones,
which then places them at greater risk for diseases, cardiovascular disease, diabetes.
They're having more difficulty in terms of immune functioning.
If you're 75 and you're a caregiver, you're already at risk as an older adult
for greater susceptibility to the flu or other illnesses,
and this further weakens your immune system.
Caregivers themselves are at increased risk for more cognitive decline.
They have higher levels of coronary disease.
And one study showed that caregivers who report being under strain
are at a 63% greater risk for death.
And I've worked with families for a long time,
and I have seen caregivers pre-decease their loved ones because of the challenges of care.
So in this particular study that was done by the University of Pittsburgh,
I think there's a couple things to point out.
Again, these were specifically Alzheimer's caregivers.
In terms of caregivers across the United States who are caring for a variety of people,
whether it might be a child or an adult with a different type of illness,
the average age is somewhere in the 40s generally.
Here we're talking about, again, an older caregiver, 61 years old.
Look at that, 83% women.
This is a women's disease.
It affects women more.
Women are at slightly greater risk,
and women are the majority of caregivers in our society.
These particular care recipients have a moderate to severe level of dementia.
In terms of the point here about health, there was a significant decline.
Across the 18 months these people were studied, these caregivers were studied,
there was a significant decline in health.
And look at that, 25% increase in use of all types of health care services,
as they're listed here, from doctor's visits to emergency rooms.
I believe emergency room use was twice as high,
and doctor's visits were approximately three times as high.
They estimated the increased cost of the health care for caregivers was $5,000 annually.
Caregiving also affects your employment status.
Again, these are all places where public policy can definitely have an impact.
Hopefully you can read that because there were so many categories.
It's a little bit small, but 65%, two-thirds of caregivers are saying they have to go in late,
leave early, take time off, adjust their work schedule.
A fifth of them are taking a leave of absence.
A lot of them are changing their work schedule to part-time,
giving up a promotion or taking a less demanding job.
Giving up working entirely.
One out of ten caregivers give up work entirely to take care of someone.
Almost lost job benefits, probably because they changed their work status,
and almost suffered a dismissal.
Again, close to one out of ten are choosing early retirement.
These are significant impacts to the caregiver,
whether one takes it from one's perspective of self-esteem or one's status in the world,
to give up a job to the financial impact that that has on the family.
The problem we face, and I think a problem that has to be paid attention to
in terms of public policy, is are the baby boomers going to be willing to be these caregivers?
What do we know about that?
There was an interesting study that just came out earlier this year
in the Gerontologist about baby boomer caregivers.
These were baby boomer caregivers in Quebec.
Researchers did interviews with these 39 caregivers.
They were structured interviews, and then they did thematic analyses.
It was really very, very interesting findings
that people my age are more resistant to being caregivers
in the way that my mom was a caregiver,
or that the current generation are being caregivers.
Baby boomers wanted to be much more circumscribed.
They don't want to have to sacrifice their lives for the caregiver.
They don't want to lose their identity.
For these caregivers, services were really important
because they wanted to delegate the personal tasks.
They weren't about to take care of their parents' toileting needs
or personal care needs.
They wanted to be able to delegate that.
Interestingly enough, though, what was also important to these baby boomers
was not just that these services provide this kind of basic care,
but that the services also enhanced quality of life for their loved ones,
that they provided stimulation, rehabilitation,
that there was a quality-of-life element.
They really viewed their roles as caregivers very differently
than caregivers of previous generations
in the sense that their job was to manage care and to improve quality of life.
It wasn't to be there to do the care,
but it was to be there to make sure that the care
that somebody else was providing was good care.
That's a really different perspective
because then there's an expectation that somewhere in society
there's these people or care providers or services
that they're going to delegate this to.
It was also interesting that these baby boomers also expected
that there would be venues for them to get support themselves,
as well as this idea that you're a caregiver
and you're a caregiver because you're part of a family
and you should just do it out of the goodness of your heart and do it for free.
Many of the people in these interviews talked about
that somehow society should compensate caregivers for doing this.
I think that's really interesting in light of the current challenges
we're having to our in-home supportive services in this state
in this budget cycle and in previous budget cycles
that really cuts back the opportunity for caregivers
who are of low financial means to get any reimbursement
for their care.
Caregiving is no longer this normative thing that you do
because the new normal, as expressed by these baby boomers,
was it's important to have a professional life,
it's important to have a social life,
it's important to keep active,
it's important to fulfill myself as well as to do my caregiving.
The attitudes towards caregiving are very much imbued
by baby boomer values of autonomy and also self-actualization.
Interestingly also, the boomer caregivers were more willing
to use the label caregiver because they wanted it recognized
that they were doing something over and above
what they thought should be expected of a child or a spouse.
I'm not sure from a public policy perspective
we've thought about that in terms of, well,
maybe this source that we've been relying on for long-term care
is just going to exist forever.
Additionally, baby boomers are a generation that's unprepared,
unprepared for their own aging,
and this particular study showed that two-thirds of us worry about
if we're going to be able to care or pay for long-term care,
and nearly everyone does not have long-term care insurance.
Fifty-eight percent feel financially unprepared,
and this is really scary.
Sixty-eight percent of these, if I remember correctly,
it was around 1,300 California voters that were surveyed.
Sixty-eight percent of them said they couldn't afford
three months of care in a nursing home.
Sixty-nine percent, excuse me,
and similarly 57 percent couldn't afford three months of in-home care.
They also looked at how many said that they could afford one month of care.
It was right around 32 percent.
A third of us said we couldn't afford one month of care.
Also, 70 percent, and this really reflects the need for education,
incorrectly believe that Medicare is going to take care of one's long-term care needs.
And from a public policy perspective,
two-thirds said long-term care is an important priority for policy.
This survey was done in 2010, I think, yeah.
Saving lives, saving money.
How do we save lives?
How do we save money?
Well, in terms of the state of affairs today with Alzheimer's treatment,
we only have treatments today, medications that are what we call symptomatic,
and what I mean by that is they can improve your symptoms,
but they can't change the course of the disease.
So today we don't have any way to delay the onset, to slow the progression,
and so what's happening is we're seeing that more people are dying of Alzheimer's disease
while less people are dying from other major diseases
because we've made more progress in terms of treatments and cures for some of these diseases.
So you can see this percentage change over that period of time
where the number of deaths to Alzheimer's disease has increased by 66 percent
versus, for example, HIV, which has decreased by 30 percent.
So we're not making the progress that we need to be making.
So just to explain the impact of what would happen if we had a better treatment,
a way to delay, prevent the disease,
the Alzheimer's Association did an interesting study called
the Changing Trajectory of Alzheimer's Disease.
So here you can see that, and this was done in 2010,
so the number's a little lower than today,
but in 2010 about 59 percent, about 60 percent of people with Alzheimer's disease
were in the moderate to severe stages,
so that's when they start to become more difficult to care for.
If everything stays the same as today, in 2050, again,
we'll have just over 50 percent that are going to be in the moderate to severe stages.
So what would happen if we had effective treatments by 2050?
How would this change our projections in terms of numbers
and also the distribution of people at these various stages of the disease?
So first of all, if we were able to push back the onset of the disease by only 5 years,
it would have a huge impact.
It would reduce the number affected from 13.5 million to 7.7 million.
That's just a huge impact from a human perspective and from a financial perspective.
Now, it would look a little bit different if we slowed the progression.
If we slowed the progression, we actually would have more people
because all we're doing is slowing the progression,
but what we're doing if we slow the progression is we're maintaining quality of life
because here, 60 percent of the people are in the early stages.
So both of those are very important goals to push off the onset,
keep people healthy and cognitively functioning longer,
and then if they get Alzheimer's disease, slow the progression
so they can stay in the early, most functional stages as long as possible.
There was an earlier study that was done, and it was from 2004,
but I still think it's a valuable illustration.
If we could do both of those things, if we could slow the progression and delay the onset,
this projected that instead of having 13.5 million people,
we'd have 8.1 million people with Alzheimer's disease in 2050.
So a decrease of 40 percent.
So what does that mean?
It means we need an investment in research.
Today, the NIH spends about $500 million a year on Alzheimer's disease,
and everyone in our field is so pleased that President Obama
increased funding for Alzheimer's disease by $130 million recently
related to the national plan for Alzheimer's disease,
but I think we still have to look at that relative to the amount our country spends on other diseases,
about $6 billion on cancer, about $3 billion on AIDS.
So $500 million for a disease that affects so many people is a drop in the bucket,
and we need to change that.
If we're going to make progress.
So some of the public policy themes I think came out, or I was trying to express,
are definitely if we're going to avert this crisis, both human crisis and financial crisis,
we have to invest in research.
Our state has done some great things, like with the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine,
which is working on these kinds of problems now, but we need much more.
We also can't take the family for granted anymore as being the bedrock of care in our society,
and we have to be thinking about the availability of services for caregivers.
Again, I would point out that this year our state is eliminating, right at this point,
the budget is not signed, but it's eliminating the caregiver resource centers
that provide resources for families and for caregivers all over the state of California.
That doesn't make sense in this environment with this level of need.
When services aren't available, and when caregivers don't get support,
and when baby boomers say, yeah, I really don't want to do this the way my mom did,
well, guess what?
Then the older adult is also at risk for elder abuse.
Cognitively, there are people who are unable to remember the abuse,
or unable to remember that they signed over their home to someone,
are at huge risk for abuse.
We also need to really work on caregiver-friendly employment practices,
whether that's benefits, flexible work hours, wellness programs.
There's a lot that can be done there.
I was really pleased to serve on the California Alzheimer's Disease State Plan Task Force in 2011.
March of 2011, California legislature received this plan.
You have the brief summary of the plan.
I brought that for you, the main goals of that plan.
