All UK football road signs are wrong! Join the petition for geometric change!

Stand-up Maths
22 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 16, 2023
I am here on a busy British street and behind me is the official UK street sign for a football
stadium and that football is incorrect. That geometry will not work and so I've started a
petition to get the mathematics of that football corrected. The link is in the description below
The problem is that this football is made entirely out of hexagons. If you have a look at a proper
football it has pentagons. So while the street sign is light hexagons and dark
hexagons, a real football has light hexagons and dark pentagons. Not only do the UK street
signs not match reality they don't even match geometry. It is mathematically impossible to
make a nice closed compact ball shape without a hole through it using hexagons. Even crazy
distorted hexagons won't work and I can prove that because for any ball if you count the number
of faces and subtract the number of edges and then add the number of vertices you get the Euler
characteristic of that shape and for all balls it's always two. Grab a football or any kind of
ball count the faces edges vertices that will always give you two. Now if we have hexagons on
some mythical shape and we don't know how many there are we can still work out the maximum
possible Euler characteristic because if there are n hexagons then the number of faces is n.
The number of edges, well every single edge on the ball is made up of two faces meeting there and if
we have n hexagons then we have a total of 6n edges available. Divide that by 2 we know how
many edges there will be. Vertices are slightly more complicated because we don't know how many
of the faces meet at each vertex but we do know there has to be a minimum of three faces meeting
to give us a vertex. There could be more but there are three corners at an absolute minimum so
for the total 6n corners available if we divide that by three that is our maximum possible number
of vertices there could be and because it's a positive term that's going to give us the maximum
possible Euler characteristic of a ball made entirely out of hexagons. So this means for any
shape made entirely out of hexagons if we simplify that down equals zero. The maximum Euler
characteristic is zero it can never be two which means no assembly of hexagons will ever form a
ball. The street signs are geometrically impossible. All the other street signs get to match the reality
we live in. If you want to go see a castle you follow signs which look like an actual castle
that could exist in our reality it's not some Escher nightmare. If you go fishing you follow
signs that have an actual fish on them not a Lovecraftian monster from beyond our perception
and when you go to the zoo you get pictures of an elephant that's an actual elephant it wasn't just
someone going what's an elephant look like I don't know it's got like some legs and some trunks I
mean that's pretty that's pretty elephanty. No everything else looks like what it is. Why don't
But here's the thing. So what? Does it matter if the signs are wrong? Well I think it's a bit of a
national embarrassment because the UK has a long tradition in sport and it has a very proud
tradition in mathematics and science and with the government going well pentagons hexagons what's
the difference does it really matter that just feels like they don't really care about all the
mathematics our modern society is based on and maths and science is very important for the UK
society and economy. We really should fix this and if we do get a campaign going and if we do
get it fixed then that's just going to bring geometry into the public mind. People who've
never thought about the shapes that make up a football or a street sign will suddenly be engaged
in 3D geometry. That's going to be amazing. Now for the official details. This street sign was
most recently specified in 2016 in statutory instrument number 362. Within that in schedule 12
part 15 lies symbol 38. That image my official petition to the government is to update symbol 38
so instead of being dark hexagons they have dark pentagons and then all new street signs will be
done correctly. I appreciate that fixing all the old signs could be a misuse of taxpayer funds I
just want the new ones done correctly for no extra cost we can get the mathematics right on all future
signs. Now because this is an official parliamentary petition it can only be signed by people who are
either UK citizens or UK residents. If that's you please do sign it. If it's not you you can still
help. If you know anyone who's British get them to sign it and put it out on all your social media.
If we can raise some awareness and get 10,000 people to sign this petition the UK government
has to write to me and tell me what they're going to do about it. We will either get street signs
fixed or I will get a letter to frame from the UK government about why they don't care that their
signs don't match normal Euclidean geometry. Final admin thank you so much for watching the video
subscribe to the petition. I'm actually currently on tour around the UK with Festival of the Spoken
Nerd and in the show every night in front of hundreds of people I'm trying to get them to
join our petition so if you are in the UK and you want to come along please do. For all my Patreon
supporters if you send me an email I'll hook you up with some tickets I'll try if they're available
and the bonus footage for this video on Patreon is me opening the gift that Hugh Hunt gave me
which is football related and just in general thank you so much everyone who watches and
subscribes to these videos. Please do sign the petition. We have such a fantastic community of
people who watch mathematics videos on YouTube. Let's put that to good use. Together we can change
society for the better. For one very narrow definition of better.
