How long to do EV batteries last_ Lets look at a 6 year old Renault Zoe 22kWh electric car

E-Moving
15 followers
Hi it's Matt here from Go Green Autos, so this is a Renault Zoe with a 22kWh battery
pack, it is a 2015 model so is now 6 years old and in this video I'm going to look at
the health of the battery pack with my diagnostic scanner down there.
So this car is 6 years and 2 months old and it has done 25,176 miles, so not many miles
for the age of the vehicle but what I tend to find is lower mileage cars will normally
have worse batteries than higher mileage cars because battery degradation tends to happen
the most when a car battery is left at 100% charged and not driven, so you tend to find
that's exactly what happens with low mileage cars, they get charged overnight and then
left for a few days and if that's done frequently over the life of the car then those battery
packs tend to be a little bit worse than high mileage vehicles that get driven everyday.
So there is this sort of general myth that high voltage batteries in electric cars need
changing every 5 years or so, obviously they do degrade a little bit, what I tend to find
is typically they degrade at about 1% a year or so and more like 3% in a Nissan just because
they don't have thermal management in their packs, but Renaults they do have good batteries
so with the help of the scanner here let's connect into the battery pack and see what
it reports. So the diagnostic port is under the mat in the little pocket there and I've
got the dongle plugged in there and that's wireless to the scanner here, so I've got
all the ECUs cooled up here and we want to go into the BMS which is the battery management
system effectively that's the ECU in the battery pack where you can look at all the stats and
what I'm going to do is look at the live data of the battery and we're going to look at
all signals. So the car is currently switched on and we are looking at all the information
that the BMS records. So we can see the battery cell voltages of every single cell and we
can see that they are all pretty much equal, it's in millivolts and we've got every single
cell and obviously we're looking at the live data of the battery so you would want to sort
of identify any that aren't the same voltage but they all are, we've got 35, 40, so 44
cells and they're all within 2 millivolts. Then we've got the temperatures of every module,
5 degrees, it is cold out there today, I'm just looking up here and it is 3 degrees on
the car but 5 degrees in the pack. Then we've got some more voltages, number 45 onwards,
50, 60, 65, 70 and again they are all the same voltage and we can see that they are
carrying on all the way to number 96 and then we've got some more temperatures, they're
all 5 degrees, one is 6 degrees but there are obviously no decimal places here so you
know that could be 5.9 and that could be 6.0, you never know. Here's the crucial thing that
we're interested in, the battery condition and it is currently at 98% state of health.
So minimal degradation on the pack, the batteries also record the mileage of the pack and that's
in kilometres, so 40,634 kilometres should match the 25,000 miles on the dash but I can't
do the maths at the moment. We've then got, I can't say that word, cumulative, cumulative
energy when discharged, 8,485 kilowatt hours. The traction battery state of charge now,
63.1% and if we look up there on the dash, yeah, it is at about 60% and then we go back
here, we've got computer supply voltage, 13.4 volts, traction battery current 0 because
it's not being driven I assume. So this is another important thing, lowest cell charge
status 62.5, highest cell charge status 63.6%. So we're looking at only 1% difference between
the highest and lowest cell in the pack, so that sounds okay to me. And then we've got
buzz bar voltages and they're all at 0.006 or 0.007 volts, all very similar. And then
we've got an open circuit voltage, I don't know what that is, 3.9 volts. Total capacity
70.6, I assume that is amp hours, so yeah I'm not seeing any more information on that
or a value either but I'll do a bit of maths on that one as well. So yeah, that's what
you can see when you look at the battery pack, that's the information that the BMS is providing.
Obviously not to the driver or to the user of the car because you need a scanner or software
to read this information but this is typically obviously for a workshop technician to use
to diagnose any faults with the pack. So the other thing to bear in mind here is when you're
looking at that battery information, you're just looking at a snapshot in time, it's
not absolute. So when looking at that capacity figure there's a lot of factors which can
vary that and indeed the battery capacity does fluctuate. So in this case this car has
been sat unused for probably two weeks now because we've had the Christmas break and
it is very cold in the workshop. Obviously at the moment it's 3 degrees but yesterday
it was minus 3 in here. So that battery pack is cold and we all know that when batteries
are cold they're less efficient and they can store less energy. So what the capacity we're
looking at now is just what it currently is. When the weather warms up or this car is back
into use and the battery gets charged, the battery is going to warm up and it's going
to have a greater storage capacity. So when looking at this you've just got to take all
those factors into consideration and you're only looking at a snapshot in time and you've
got to consider all these other factors such as temperature and state of charge and all
things like that. So a lot of people do seem to get very upset when I post videos like
this showing that battery packs just aren't degrading as people assume they are. Obviously
with a battery pack you have a usable capacity and a total capacity. So while these cars
are called the ZE22 and referred to as the 22kWh battery pack, they've actually got a
total capacity of 25.92kWh, so roughly 26kWh and the usable capacity apparently is 23.3kWh,
so again more than Renault claim or state as the model number. So that's great because
a lot of manufacturers they only tell you the full capacity and don't tell you actually
what the usable capacity is. So obviously with electric batteries the usable capacity
is smaller than the greater capacity because they build in a buffer, a little bit of a
buffer at the top and the bottom of the pack. So when you charge the car to 100% the battery
really isn't at 100% it's at something like, without doing the maths, 95%. So the battery
doesn't get stressed when it's fully charged and again if you were to drain the battery
down to zero and the car goes flat, the battery isn't actually flat. Again it keeps a little
bit of a buffer there so the battery doesn't get stressed. So typically on average sort
of 5% or a bit more at the top and sort of 5% again at the bottom, something like that.
It's all to maintain the life of the battery so that usable capacity, in this case 23kWh,
is maintained for as long as possible. So when I post these videos some people seem
to get very upset over it and claim that that just cannot be right but the reality is batteries
just don't degrade as much as people assume and I'm seeing lots of second hand electric
vehicles and the range on the majority of them just isn't degrading at the sort of amounts
people think and you could drive this and get exactly the same sort of range as you
would have done when it was new. Obviously batteries do degrade a little bit but at the
sort of percentage this has degraded, you just don't notice the difference in range.
Your day to day driving, whether it's rainy, cold, you drive fast, you've got the heating
on, there's all these sort of factors which makes the car use more energy and your driving
efficiency drops and that varies more than let's say the 1% a year that the battery might
have degraded. So obviously over a long time, over many, many years, you're not going to
notice the difference. The reality is when the battery pack has got less capacity it
is going to result in less range but in the real world year by year you hardly notice
any difference at all and obviously these battery packs are going to last a very long
time and typically I really do think the batteries will outlast the cars.
So it is a little bit of a different story with the generation 1 Nissan Leafs but battery
chemistry and battery design has improved and on these Renault Zoe's, even the very
earliest cars which are now 2013 vehicles, you will often see that the battery is still
at the low 90% state of health and the drop in range is absolutely minimal. However, there
is a bug in the BMS software and if your car hasn't had a BMS update since it was new,
then you are going to see a poorer pack but this car has had the BMS update and that's
why we're not seeing any difference. But yeah, cars that haven't had that software update
you often will see that the battery is down to older cars, down to about 73-74% something
like that. I think I've seen one at about 60% at worst. But yes, if you can get the
BMS update that completely resolves the issue and fixes all the bugs in that original code.
So that's it for this video and on the channel are plenty of other videos on battery packs,
on used electric vehicles. I'm posting EV videos at least every week and I'll see you
on the next video.
Thank you for watching the video. This channel gets small viewing numbers so to get the video
noticed in people's feeds, YouTube favours videos with what they term engagement and
that basically means comments. So please do comment on the video, do ask me questions,
tell me what you want to see next. Also hit the little thumbs up button if you found the
video useful or you liked it. Do subscribe to the channel by clicking the subscribe button
and then press the bell to be notified when new videos get uploaded. Also have a look
at the back catalogue of videos. There are literally hundreds and hundreds of videos on the
channel already and also use the search function to find videos that you might find interesting.
Thank you very much.
