Waste Not Wood Ash Part 3

Agriculture
95 followers
NCDA, this is the report that you'll get for free or for $5 from NCDA, and it will give
you a soil pH.
So my front lawn soil is actually pretty acidic, so adding something alkaline is going to help
out quite a bit.
It's going to help the grass grow.
And they give me direct applications for putting on agricultural lime.
They say, put on 15 pounds per 1,000 square feet.
And this is my nutrient analysis.
Very high in potassium, off the charts.
So I need to be real careful about adding more potassium to my soil.
Phosphorus is just like, you know, on the other end of the spectrum.
That's why I'm going to add that soft rock phosphate at the same time.
Here's what I'm going to do.
Looking at my stove ash sample, I sent a sample in at the same time that I sent the regular
stove ash sample.
I sent one in of a sample that I had already passed water through, right?
So I passed water through it once, and I got what is soluble out of it.
At least I thought I got what is soluble out of it.
And you can see that there's still quite a bit of potassium left behind, okay?
So it's still, it's 2.8% potassium now.
I think it was somewhere around five before.
So I got roughly half the potassium out on the first soak.
And calcium actually went up just, you know, by nature of other things going out.
And then they give you the calcium carbonate equivalent.
Calcium carbonate is your agricultural lime, or it's straight lime.
Agricultural lime has some magnesium mixed in with it.
And then this is the agricultural lime equivalent.
So if they're recommending that I put out 15 pounds per thousand square feet, I'm going
to multiply that 15 by 1.07 to get my equivalent in terms of liming effect on the soil.
So if my front lawn is 1,500 square feet, then I'm going to add another factor of 1.5.
So 15 times 1.5, if I was to add straight agricultural lime, I would put 22.5 pounds.
But since I'm putting in wood ash, I'm going to put in 24 pounds of the previously rinsed ash.
Now what's really important here is that if I'm going to weigh it, that I don't weigh
the moisture at the same time, right?
So you got to, you have to remove the moisture.
But you can kind of get a ballpark here.
You can say, I mean, really the difference between 22 pounds, 24 pounds, pretty negligible.
I was kind of surprised that I only leached out about half of the potassium.
And I set up a few trials to see if I could do a little better than that.
But first we need to talk about ash water.
And this is really fundamental to everything else that we're going to talk about tonight.
All right.
Sodium hydroxide, NaOH, that OH is your hydroxide, remember that?
So it's hydroxide sodium salt and a potassium sodium salt sold as lye.
This is not lye.
You're going to get online and you're going to read about what do I do with my wood ashes?
And everybody's going to say, you can make lye with it.
This is an example of my ash water, not lye, that I made by soaking ashes in something
very simple like this.
I put ashes in my bucket, measure them out if you want to.
In this case, I put in about a gallon of ashes and then I put in about a gallon of water
and I stir it up real good and let that water sit until it clarifies on top.
And then I punch little tiny holes in the bottom of it.
And then you're just going to let that sit for one day, maybe three days, and you're
going to let it just drip out until the water really just stops dripping.
That stuff that comes out is ash water.
That's what we're calling it.
I'm not going to call it lye.
And that ash water can do a number of different things.
It can later be concentrated, so it's going to come out pretty weak, still strong enough
to burn your eyes.
So you always need to be wearing glasses when working with this stuff.
This has been concentrated from what was roughly very slightly more than one gram per milliliter.
So one gram per milliliter is pure water.
So this was slightly more than pure water.
And it got concentrated down to 1.1 grams per milliliter.
I don't remember what concentrate this is.
This is probably around one gallon reduced to a quart, okay?
This is getting strong enough to start doing things with.
If I was to take that and boil it down completely, then I'm going to end up with this.
That is potash.
It's a very impure potash, but potash nonetheless with some other stuff mixed in.
That other stuff mixed in is some of those non-alkalized salts.
We'll get into that if we've got some time.
So solubility increases with hot water.
We know that salt water holds more salt if it's hot.
Sugar water holds more sugar if it's hot.
So you're going to get more of the soluble salts out of this if you preheat the water
before passing it through.
And a lot of sources, a lot of the old-timers, say like Foxfire type sources online, are
going to tell you to set up stone and a layer of straw and filter your stuff as it comes through.
I'd say forget it.
There's no need to do that.
I did it both ways.
And honestly, I think the ash water comes out darker if you add straw to it.
I don't think that's helping at all.
Yeah?
When you came from that bucket with the hole in the bottom, I would expect a lot more sediment
in there.
So did you clarify somehow?
It's just a really small hole.
Just big enough for a drop to go through.
Yeah, so there are methods for clarifying, though.
One of them is just, oh, here's the example of two different ashes here, too.
This is talking about the, I should have put this on earlier when I was talking about the
carbon content of the ashes.
That's just to kind of show you the strong difference here between what you can get when
you go through this process.
This process is called, and it's written on your paper, lixiviate, I think is how you
would say that word.
That would be, I think, the chemical engineer's term for what we're doing here, taking a solid
and removing the solubles out of that solid mix.
So again, let me recap here.
Keep it simple.
You don't need to do a complicated straw filter or anything like that.
I have not seen any benefits from that in my work.
Does that process make sense to everybody?
It's kind of fundamental for this.
What's that?
One thing I wonder about is the interaction of the salts with the plastic, and are you
pulling anything from the plastic out while you're doing this?
I think you're pretty good.
HDPE is pretty benign.
There's definitely some plastics you can use.
I mentioned that earlier.
Number two is going to be your best plastic for this.
Polypropylene is going to be okay.
I would generally stay away from the other ones.
You want your container to be, again, stainless steel or the enamel-coated iron.
Stay away from that aluminum pot.
Just don't forget about it.
If you can't tell the difference between aluminum pot and stainless, aluminum pots are going
to scratch really easily, and they're going to feel really lightweight, too.
That is potash.
It's as simple as that.
It's taking that lye water and boiling it down to crystals.
Interestingly, when I first did this with my really high organic ash water, it really
smelled terrible, smelled really bad.
When I did it with my more pure stuff that I've been collecting lately, it kind of has
a nice, almost vanilla aroma to it.
Still nothing you want to be sticking your nose over, though.
Stay downwind of it.
Wear a mask if you need to when doing this.
Do it outside.
I've got a little gas stove that I use for those kind of things.
We've got little biochar-producing stoves, too, that are nice for this.
I'll talk about refining potash here in a second.
Going back to that sample that I had sent to the lab where it said that I still had
about four and a half percent potassium left over, I wanted to see how effective I could
be at getting that potassium out through multiple soaks on the same ash.
I set up this bucket right here, and I put in three quarts, a little less than a gallon
of old ash, and then three quarts of distilled water and drilled some little tiny holes.
It drained in about 24 hours, and then kept samples of each water.
This is the water from the first one, and it gets subsequently a little bit lighter
each time I add it.
That water is going to get, when you start to boil it down, it's going to start to get
a little bit darker in color.
pH was 11.2 the first time I did it, and it slowly starts to taper off.
Interestingly, the density was quite a bit higher on the first time I did it, and then
the second time, measuring density, I got basically the same density as pure water.
I boiled down each one of those samples independently of the other.
The first time, I got about, out of one quart, I got 41 grams of potash.
Out of another quart the second time, I got 21 grams, and the third time I got 12.
You're kind of seeing a trend here, it's starting to dip off.
Depending on what you're trying to do, it may be worth it to boil down and get extra
potash, kind of depending on how much ash you're generating.
If you just got a little campfire and you want to play around with ash, you want to
be leaching as much potash out as you can.
Here's the number that we want to see.
The total expected yield, say that I took all of that water that I collected and boiled
it all down, I should expect about 122 grams of this solid, impure potash.
Remember, we were saying that ash water should be about 5 to 10%.
Mine was measured at about 5, and this material is about 10% of the parent material.
That's telling me that it's about half not potash.
Does that make sense?
It's kind of a mouthful of figures there.
It's telling me that my stuff's quite a bit impure.
It's also telling me that I should expect about 10% of my ash to be soluble materials
after soaking it three times, and that I should expect about 5% of my ash the first time.
How do we refine it?
Caveman Chemistry talks a lot about refining potash.
He's got a really nice way of talking about it.
You do want to refine it before you start using it in food products.
Take a look at this solubility chart.
This comes out of his book.
These are the six salts that you should expect to see in your ash water.
As we've proven with the green water, you're going to see quite a bit more.
These are the six main ones.
Potassium carbonate is your big player.
Calcium chloride, sodium chloride, potassium chloride, sodium carbonate, calcium carbonate.
Potassium carbonate is the only one here that we're calling potash.
It's the only one that we want.
If we're trying to remove all these other ones, then we can first let the ash water
settle and decant off anything that is still soluble.
All of those solids that fall to the bottom of just your regular ash water, like you were
talking about, then you can remove those solids by basically pulling the liquid off.
Cool that water until it's about half of your water.
By doing that, your chlorides are going to drop out.
Notice your solubility here.
Potassium carbonate is about twice as soluble as calcium chloride.
Just by removing half of the water, a lot of this stuff should start to drop out.
After cooling, notice the difference here.
It's sodium carbonate.
See how much more soluble it is when you heat the water up versus this?
It's one of the least soluble with cold water, but it's one of the most soluble with hot water.
That stuff is still going to be soluble if you boil it.
Basically you're just going to let it cool off at that point, and your sodium carbonate
will fall down to the bottom, at which point you can pull the liquid portion off, boil
that down to powder, and then you've got pure potash.
That would be the process that, say, in colonial times, they would have been using to produce
food-grade potassium carbonate that was referred to as pearl ash at the time.
Potassium carbonate, interestingly, Pat, you may have something to add to this, too.
I just learned this.
It's really common in a lot of German baking.
Yeah, it's an alternative to sodium carbonate.
Yeah.
A lot of people think it's better for you.
I want to know how to make it because it's available all the time.
I mean, I heat both my houses with wood.
Yeah, you know what we should do is all gather our wood stub ashes again this winter and
just do this on a much larger scale.
Get the big 40-gallon stainless pot going, and we'll just boil out a lot of it.
Again, the book that I just came across here at the very last minute, How to Bake Without
Baking Powder, has some really interesting pearl ash substitutes, recipes that are based
off of old colonial recipes.
She went back and dug through old cookbooks from the 1700s, and a lot of them refer to
using potassium carbonate.
You really do want to get it nice and pure, though, or you're going to get those really
kind of soapy flavors.
Did you say soapy?
Soapy.
Yeah.
It, by the way, also is an important fungicide for powdery mildew and powdery mildew.
Yeah, yeah, pure potash is definitely going to have some garden applications, yeah, definitely.
Here's something.
You guys have already seen this.
I kind of butchered it the first time I talked about it.
This is how we're getting into carbonates forming hydroxides and how we're getting our
alkali water when we add wood ash to water and why it turns alkaline.
In stronger acid solutions, those bicarbonates that we created by adding carbonate to an
acid water are going to bond with extra hydrogens, and they're going to form carbonic acid.
Carbonic acid is going to decompose into carbon dioxide and water, and that's what's happening
with your baking powder.
That's how your bread is rising as you cook it.
I think you basically hit a threshold temperature, and that breaks down.
That's why baking powders, off-the-shelf baking powders, are going to include an acid
element and then an alkaline element.
If you want to just use baking soda, then you've got to come up with your own acid.
If you're going to use potash, then you need to be trying to maybe start by following a
recipe.
Make sure you've got your acid element there, or you're going to end up with biscuits that
taste like soap.
