Bill Self, Kansas dodge major penalties as NCAA issues ruling in infractions case | CBS Sports

CBS Sports News
1 follower
2 Video Views·Oct 12, 2023
Let's bring in Matt Norlander, who's been following this thing since it began many,
many years ago. Matt, what is your overarching reaction to what we found out today,
which was no surprise, I think, to a lot of college basketball fans. I don't think there
were many who thought that Kansas was actually going to get hit with anything that would really
hurt it. I agree. In fact, you mentioned that right off the top, Chris. I remember doing an
HQ hit with you from the courthouse like five years ago when the first of two cases actually
finished up in the nascent days of CBS Sports HQ. This is not surprising, although I will say Bill
Self mentioned that he was not surprised by losing the 2018 Final Four in an official capacity. That
banner is going to come down. The trophies and the hardware associated with it will be removed
from behind glass cases at Kansas' facilities. That's not something that was really in the wind,
behind the scenes in the industry. So while Self might be able to say that after the fact,
and that might in fact be true, while Silvio D'Souza was ruled ineligible after the fact,
one thing that Kansas fans have been kind of crying about a bit, and understandably so,
is that D'Souza was cleared on two separate occasions by the NCAA to be eligible to play.
But this case was not ruled by the NCAA and its Committee on Infractions. This was the IARP
process. The final one in an ill-fated, offshoot, independent legislative endeavor that was brought
upon by former NCAA President Mark Emmert. A lot of people have basically mocked and laughed off
what the IARP became. I guess we'll let that for history to decide, but you see some of the schools
here? All of these schools went through the IARP process. None of them received significant
sanctions. I don't think it's nothing that Kansas loses its Final Four banner in 2018. I mean,
it is something, although they got absolutely housed by Villanova in that game. So Kansas fans
have been long, quick to try and forget that game as is. Here's a key distinction. I talked about
this earlier on Wednesday on the ION College Basketball Podcast with my co-host Gary Parish.
Those schools that you see on the screen there, they opted to go the IARP route because
history had been clear that if you had gone the NCAA route with the Committee on Infractions,
like Oklahoma State did, and Oklahoma State got a postseason ban controversially,
they were probably set up for a losing battle. Had Kansas gone to the NCAA, had Louisville gone to
the NCAA, had Arizona gone to the NCAA with the Committee on Infractions, those schools probably
would have received significant punishments, if not show causes or lengthy suspensions for their
coaches. But they went the IARP route. And why? Those people, highly esteemed people, lawyers,
former judges, all sorts of people that are highly acclaimed in other fields, they don't
live, they haven't lived in the NCAA world on a day-to-day, week-to-week, month-to-month basis.
They had fresher eyes. And because Kansas was able to litigate this over years and years,
even if it didn't want it, it proved to be a winning strategy. Because at the end of the day,
Bill Self was able to get out from five Level 1, that's the most severe,
allegations from the NCAA. They took it to the IARP instead. Yes, he got taken off the road in
2022 to recruit. Yes, he had a four-game suspension. But they downgraded five Level 1s against him in
one Level 3 violation. I can't ever recall a head coach at a power conference program
in football or college basketball ever getting away that unscathed the way that Bill Self did.
So yes, even though Self said it wasn't a day to celebrate, Kansas fans were long awaiting and
hoping, holding your breath. And lo and behold, they get off easy, just like every other program
that went through this IARP process did. So now that it's all over, and this was a
five-year process, is it fair to say that there was a lot of wasted time and a lot of
wasted resources? It's mandatory to say it. It's beyond fair. When you think about all of,
congrats to all the attorneys that made plenty of money by helping adjudicate this on all,
from all ends and all sides. Ultimately, this is another stain on Mark Emmert's reputation.
And I'll try and be relatively quick here with this. But in a weird way, this FBI case,
which broke in September of 2017, and birthed the Rice Commission, and birthed the IARP,
and had all these schools involved, and sure, it led to some punishments here or there.
I actually think it helped accelerate us into the NIL era that we are in in 2023,
but really got introduced in 2021. Not to say that we wouldn't have gotten there eventually,
but I almost wonder if we got there on an overdue yet hastier timeline because of
the melodrama, the saga that was this case with all of these schools, Chris.
And so because of that, ironically, had name, image, and likeness rules been in place in 2014,
15, 16, 17, I would argue that the FBI's investigation into corruption and bribery
in college basketball might not have been on good ground to even get off the ground,
period. It might not have even come to pass, come to be. But because it wasn't,
we saw these schools go through all of this nonsense. And yes, the IARP, for the most part,
was a huge waste of time, took way too long to resolve. And now finally, it's unreal that this
took more than six years from that fateful late September afternoon when federal investigators
got up in front of the media, held this big, splashy press conference, and proclaimed,
we have your playbook. In the end, yeah, Rick Pitino got fired from Louisville. Sean Miller
eventually got moved on from Arizona. He's back at Xavier Pitino's at St. John's. There have been
some parts that have been moved. Some schools had some self-imposed bans. But ultimately,
this was not the catastrophic, world-shifting event that I think some people thought it was
back in 2017. Yeah, it was funny. Somebody asked Bill Self about that banner and what's the process
going to be. And he goes, I don't know. I guess maintenance will go up there and take it down.
That's really the only thing that's going to change here. That and his record will change
a little bit with 15 or so games, 15 or so wins taken off of that 2017-18 season when they went
to the Final Four. Matt Norlander with us here as Kansas escapes any major penalties from the NCAA's
independent accountability review process. Kansas is the odds-on favorite to win the title going
into this season. We're having college basketball media days all over the country right now. It is
getting geared up and ready to go. And Bill Self, you can see the look on his face today,
a lot of smiles because he's just happy to finally put this in the rear view. Eye on
College Basketball podcast, getting you geared up for the season. They will absolutely have an
episode on today's ruling coming down that Kansas will get no postseason ban and there will be no
more penalties for Bill Self.
