【短視頻】再談中國大陸“翻牆”

安迪聲 採集民間言傳,展現真實世界
3946粉絲
29 次觀看·2023年10月9日
Recently, a legal science video of Lawyer He Jiepeng is quite popular.
It is a video explaining whether the firewall itself is legal to block Chinese netizens from connecting to the outside world.
This video summarizes Lawyer He's three points of opinion.
First, the official does not recognize the existence of the wall.
And the current effective implementation of the law has not mentioned the existence of the wall.
Since there is no direct authorization to build a wall,
according to the principles of the lawless authorization and prohibition of public power established by modern legal civilization,
the objective existence of the wall itself is already illegal.
Second, from the technical principle of the wall,
to achieve the filtering and blockade of internal and external information,
hackers must be used.
But hacking itself is prohibited by the law of our country.
Third, the wall should be legalized through legislation.
Later, a colleague of Lawyer He, Lawyer Penghua, further supplemented Lawyer He's point of view.
He pointed out that there is a request for opinion draft of the Internet Data Security Regulation
based on the so-called firewall law.
Article 41 of the draft stipulates that the country should establish a data cross-border security network
to block the spread of foreign illegal content into the country.
This network is actually the so-called wall.
The problem is that this regulation is still in a state of request for opinion.
It has not been implemented yet.
And it is not certain whether the information range that the wall really blocks
is the content prohibited by the law.
He also mentioned that there is an implementation method
for the temporary regulation of the Internet of Information,
the Internet of International Relations.
This method clearly stipulates that the international access channel refers to the physical channel.
But the firewall software is not a physical channel,
but a virtual channel.
So it is not illegal.
As a colleague, I admire and respect Mr. He and Ms. Peng's high opinion.
Very good.
But there is also a little bit of a hint to express my own different views.
The video I posted before,
the wall and equal rights,
this video seems to have been downloaded on several platforms.
In it, I made it clear that
it is a basic human right to go over the wall to see the outside world
or to get information from the outside world,
and mentioned relevant international agreements and declaration documents.
Therefore, I always believe that
the firewall that tries to build a comprehensive blockade and filter information from the outside world
is a development in the opposite direction of civilization,
and cannot be accepted by modern civilization and law.
Of course, I also realize that
it is very likely that this view of mine
has caused my video to be easily downloaded and blocked.
And Mr. He, who does not say these words,
does not have to worry too much.
Because one of his conclusions
is to make the firewall legal
that does not have sufficient legal basis at the moment.
But this is a conflict with my point of view.
I don't think that the legislation that violates the universal value of information freedom
can be understood and accepted.
Such legislative tendencies and actions themselves are questionable.
Of course, I know that my point of view
is destined not to be welcomed by the relevant parties.
It is destined to be blocked by all kinds of downloads and blockades.
But I will not bow down to them.
I will not go back on my words.
I will not praise the facts.
This may be a big drawback here.
But in a healthy civilized society,
it should be a basic common sense of being a human being.
