The Incredible Story Behind Mr and Mrs Andrews (Waldemar Januszczak Documentary) | Perspective

Thomas Gainsborough
4 followers
The English countryside is a deceptive terrain. It looks so sweet, so friendly, so innocent,
but it's none of those things. Anyone who's listened to a few episodes of The Archers
will already know that dark stuff happens in the English countryside. Sharp of tooth,
bed of claw, it's a deadly battleground. The great English painter Thomas Gainsborough
certainly knew this. He was a country boy, born and bred, a Suffolk lad. Gainsborough
recognised that beneath the deceptively innocent surfaces of outdoor England, unpleasantness
was thriving. Lives were being ruined. Greed was being shown. Voila, Gainsborough's masterpiece
of outdoor Englishness, his famous double portrait of Mr and Mrs Andrews. Summer corn
glistening in the sun, fluffy clouds scudding across the sky, English oaks dotting the horizon
and sitting in front of it all like a pair of giant spiders in the middle of a web, Mr
and Mrs Andrews. Him with his big gun and his nonchalance. She with the most puzzlingly
unpleasant expression in the whole of Gainsborough's art. If this woman invited me up to spend
the weekend at her big country house, I don't think I'd accept. Something's going on here.
It's a pretty scene, it's merry England, but something's going on here. This is Gainsborough's
town, Sudbury in Suffolk, where Mr Andrews and Gainsborough probably went to school together.
It's a tea and cakes town these days, somewhere ye olde on the tourist circuit, but when Gainsborough
was born here in 1727, this was a real slab of rural England, a cloth town in serious
decline. Daniel Defoe came and visited Sudbury quite early on in the century and thought
that it was a very, very poor place, and with one or two rich people, and all the poor people
were willing, the rich ones, he said. So it was quite a depressed town, and Sudbury
has always been an earthy little working town, and its main industry has been weaving, and
indeed the Gainsborough family were concerned with that, not only Gainsborough's father,
but also his, very much more successfully, his uncle, but it was quite a shaky business,
I think. They made velvet here, wool of course, Sudbury's surrounded by sheep, and interestingly,
this is Gainsborough's garden, and this beautiful old survivor is a mulberry tree, planted here
in 1610. It would have been handy for the Gainsboroughs to have a mulberry tree in the
garden, because mulberry trees are what silkworms feed on, and the Gainsboroughs were in the
cloth trade. Gainsborough's father was a trader in fine materials, and so, in a way, was his
son. If you ever get a chance to examine closely a portrait by Gainsborough in his prime, have
a good look at the clothes they're wearing. The silks, the satins, the brocades, the lace.
He had a genius for painting precious fabrics. He knew about them from birth, and loved them
dizzily, I think. Picture after picture, by Gainsborough at his best, is a glorious advert
for his father's calling. Even Mrs Andrews, the baddie in this picture, gets an outfit to die
for. Pale blue silk in an outrageous expanse, not what you'd usually wear if you're out killing
pheasants. I get the feeling in a lot of Gainsborough's pictures that he liked the clothes
more than he liked the people wearing them. He was notoriously unimpressed by his sitters. When
he was painting Sarah Siddons, the most celebrated actress of her times, the Elizabeth Hurley of the
Georgian age, he suddenly exploded, damn your nose, there's no end to it. And behind the backs
of his sitters, he was even more scathing. Yes, he was known to complain about his sitters, but I
think being a portraitist is really a considerable problem, that you have all these people who,
by definition, want to look better than they probably do. And that, having that day in,
day out of about eight people a day, must be a considerable problem. And most portraitists got
very, very bored with self-important people rushing through their studio all day. Gainsborough
hated doing fashionable portraits. The cursed face business, he called it. His tragedy was,
he was so damn good at it. They only have one part worth looking at, said Gainsborough, of the
fashionable types he painted, and that is their purse. So he sniffed the air and headed for where
the biggest purses were gathered. He moved to Bath, where all the celebrities of Georgian England
would visit to take the waters and to have their likeness done by Thomas Gainsborough, the Mario
Testino of his age. He ended up in London, naturally, the most fashionable portrait painter
in England, who was usually forgiven his little rudenesses because he captured a likeness better
than anyone else. He had the gift, all right. Gainsborough had the fastest hands of any painter
this country's ever produced. He painted like an expert swordsman. Woosh, woosh, woosh. And the
rich have always been able to take a bit of rudeness from their artists in return for some
breathtaking immortality. He realised that he had to cover a vast amount of canvas in order to compete
with people. There are one or two records of head and shoulder portraits which he completed in one
hour 40 minutes, and that is going at sensational speed. There's records of him getting drunk for a
fortnight and then doing a skirt of a great full-length portrait in a night. So I think he
used that speed to good effect so that he could get drunk for a fortnight and also so that he could
get through the acreage of canvas and compete in a real way. Gainsborough was the youngest of nine
children. His father, the cloth merchant, fell on hard times and was bankrupt. Young Thomas wasn't
going to enter the cloth business. He had another talent, art. And according to a story, which I
don't quite believe, but I'll tell you anyway, when he was a boy he saw a man trying to steal
pears from his garden and drew him so convincingly that the neighbours recognised this scoundrel
immediately and nabbed him. Young Gainsborough was also naughty. Another story, which I do believe,
is that he used to forge his own sick notes for school and captured his parents' handwriting
perfectly. From his days of forging sick notes at school and throughout his life, Gainsborough was
a subtle subversive, always doing things on the sly. At the age of 18, he got married, in secret,
to the illegitimate daughter of a Duke. He'd got her pregnant. She brought in £200 a year,
which was very useful and which Gainsborough began to supplement busily by painting some of
the most memorable portraits in British art. This is the house that Gainsborough's lived in. It's
an estate agent's now, and no one seems to know what went on in which room. But it could be that
this is the spot in which Gainsborough painted Mr and Mrs Andrews. These days, the picture hangs
in the National Gallery and is famous the world over as Gainsborough's earliest masterpiece. But
until 50 years ago, no one outside the Andrews family even knew it existed. The National Gallery
didn't buy it until 1960. So here's an interesting question. Why was this painting kept so secret for
so long? Andrews inherited half of the estate from his father, Aubrey, as it was called. His wife
brought in the other half when they married in 1748. So although it wasn't, strictly speaking,
a marriage of convenience, it was certainly a most convenient marriage, which left both of them
twice as rich as they had been. So far, so normal. Here are two small-town moneybags celebrating the
union of two big-time purses. But something went wrong in the making of this much-moneyed wedding
portrait. I often watch people walking past this entertaining picture and enjoy it a lot. But it's
amazing how often they miss two crucial things about it. One is how frightening Mrs Andrews is,
but the second is that it's unfinished. If you look closely at that brown splodge in the middle
of her lap, something's missing. The picture is incomplete. Gainsborough never had his final say
in this painting. He meant to show something here, but never did. What was it? And why did he never put
it there? Why is Mr and Mrs Andrews unfinished? These are the questions that need to be asked.
Here you have a painting that's famous the world over as the perfect image of rural England. But
just as paradise had a snake in it, so Mrs Andrews had on her lap something that never got
painted. Something that someone somewhere didn't want us to see. And I'm sure I know what it is.
The single most aggressive and destructive act ever perpetrated by the government of Britain on
its rural folk was the long and drawn-out passing of the Enclosure Acts, which took the common land
away from the people, put a fence around it and gave it to the landlords. It was unforgivable. It
ruined the livings of so many country people. Gainsborough's heart always went out to them.
The poor had his sympathy, not the rich and the landed like Mr and Mrs Robert Andrews.
This is the exact spot on which Gainsborough painted his wonderful picture. You must
recognise that oak behind me, this big fat English oak, which is exactly the same tree although it's
thicker now than it was before. And over there of course is that beautiful slab of the English
countryside which is behind Mr and Mrs Andrews in the picture. Still I think really recognisable.
Now Mr Andrews is standing just about here. He's been out hunting so he's holding his shooting
rifle nonchalantly under his arm. Mrs Andrews, she's sitting here demurely with her legs crossed.
Now I've seen this picture so many times in the National Gallery but it wasn't until I came here
and stood in this spot that I realised something incredibly interesting about it, which is that
behind Gainsborough in the painting, hidden from sight, is the house in which Mr and Mrs Andrews
actually lived. Now that's significant, not just because you didn't know it was there in the
painting but also because it explains one of the great mysteries of Mr and Mrs Andrews, which is
why she is dressed in this flamboyant outfit of flowing pale blue silk while he is wearing his
scruffy shooting gear. Obviously what's happened is that he's been out doing the shooting while she
has been waiting for him indoors and has now come out to meet him just a few hundred feet away from
the house to sit on this bench. The biggest change in the landscape of course is this huge
row of trees behind me. There's a forest down there now that isn't in the Gainsborough picture.
Now that was planted deliberately by one of the later owners of the house. Apparently they built
a council estate at the bottom of the hill so the owner decided to try and mask it and he planted
this huge forest in between it and him. The corn's gone of course, it's all been grassed over now,
but if you look carefully you can actually still see the echoes of these furrows. There's little
bits of them left and what's interesting about the furrows is that they're what's left over
from this revolutionary new use of an implement called the seed drill. Now this seed drill was
the very latest in agrarian technology. It made harvesting the corn so much easier and Mr Andrews
was very proud of being a pioneer in its use. The seed drill wasn't widely taken up initially.
Wealthy landowners were keen to use it as it was a public demonstration of how wealthy and how
advanced they were. It wasn't received widely by the majority, especially the farm workers in fact
that they could see with this change with mechanisation coming in that actually their
jobs would be a threat. Mr and Mrs Andrews, these newlyweds, are showing off the fruit of their union,
their land and their agricultural progressiveness. Of course there isn't a peasant in sight
and none of this was achieved by these two getting their hands dirty in any way.
What the painting shows to me is the importance of the new farming methods to him and there's a
real statement that he's actually you know a very wealthy powerful landowner and really accepting
all these new ideas and it's sort of really look at me I'm so you know really ahead of the game.
People say that Gainsborough was having a go at the rural rich in this picture.
I think that's right, he was. These are greedy people. They've snatched the land away from its
rightful owners and they're parading themselves in front of it while Gainsborough disapproves.
But there's something else going on here, something more personal. If Gainsborough really
did go to school with Mr Andrews, I think he rather liked him. Mr Andrews is sympathetically
painted. He's dim but nice, lounging around on his land with his gun and his dog. It's Mrs Andrews
who worries me. She's surely one of the least attractive women in Gainsborough's art, uptight,
clenched, stiff. She's only a teenager, 18 years old, but she already has the demeanour of a middle-aged
rural harridan. And what is that on her lap, that unfinished blob of canvas? I think there's only
one thing it can be. That must be a feather, the tail feather of a cock pheasant, I warrant.
And the rest of the bird is sitting on her knee. He's been out hunting, he's brought the bird back.
She's got it on her lap on a cloth so that it doesn't bleed into her beautiful blue dress.
But if that is a cock pheasant, what's it doing there? Is the dead bird an innocent avian corpse
brought back from the morning's hunt and no more? Or does it have another meaning, a deeper one,
a symbolic one? Gainsborough was a great admirer of Dutch art, and in Dutch art you often find women,
wenches, shop girls, wives, holding up dead birds, cocks, snipe, duck. Look at this buxom butcher's
maid, how fiercely she clutches that cock. Look at her unsmiling determination. Does it remind you
of anyone? The fact is that most dead birds in Dutch art represent a man who's fallen into the
clutches of a determined woman. The bird in the hand of a buxom Dutch woman is invariably intended
as a warning to us guys not to let ourselves be grabbed where it hurts, and all the naughty
double entendres involving the word cock are entirely intentional. Gainsborough, a countryman,
would have known all about these low country readings, and he would, I suggest, have been after
just such a double entendre in his picture before it was censored. I think that he didn't like Mrs
Andrews much, that he was warning Mr Andrews of the fate of the cock pheasant that's fallen into
her lap and been grabbed. Just before this picture was finished, I think its secret meaning was
spotted, and that Mrs Andrews realized all too clearly how unflattering a portrait of her was
being painted here. The picture was never finished because the sitters finally realized what Gainsborough
was saying about them, and didn't like it. Ah yes, the English countryside, the corn in the field,
the larks in the sky, and the poison in the hearts of the people. Mr and Mrs Andrews is a great
masterpiece of Gainsborough's early work, but if only he'd been allowed to complete it, it would
have been greater still. There are a million stories in the world of art, this has been just one of them.
