Taiwan is one of the most advanced democracies in terms of education, economy, and politics.
It is a country where people have a strong right to law and practice,
a system of justice that is based on justice.
But sometimes, it is questioned and challenged.
It was another ordinary day for Chen Longji,
a 44-year-old man who was hanging out with his friends at 1 a.m. at a Panit building.
The person in charge of the case that day was not my direct friend.
He was looking for my friend.
I happened to be there, so I stayed with them for a short while.
After a while, a woman contacted us.
Chen told us that he didn't like the atmosphere and what was about to happen,
so he asked for permission to go pick up his wife who was about to quit her job.
My wife got off work at 4 a.m.
I left for the race at 3 a.m.
I told my wife that I left work that day.
I gave the record to the court.
So you left at around 3 a.m.?
Yes, around 3 a.m.
The next morning, Chen was surprised and confused.
He was invited by the police to go to the park
before he was charged with assaulting a woman.
During the trial, both the primary court, Uthorn, and the court of law
denied that they were not involved in the crime.
The witness was the one who was at the scene.
Both men confessed that they assaulted a woman
and defended Chen that they were not involved in the crime.
Chen's wife testified that
the time of the incident was the same as the time Chen went to pick her up.
Therefore, it was impossible for him to join the investigation.
When he told me that he was going to convict me,
I didn't know how to answer him.
I kept telling him that there must be something wrong with the examination.
And everyone on the scene proved that I wasn't there.
They also proved that I didn't do anything illegal.
I made it very clear to them.
If they were going to sue me,
I really didn't know how to explain it to them.
The court did not give any weight to the testimony of Chen's wife and friend
because they were close friends.
Therefore, it may be beneficial to the suspect.
As for the victim, he lost his consciousness
and could not identify the perpetrator.
The only evidence that the court used as a guideline
to investigate Chen's imprisonment for 4 years
was the DNA test result.
The result was the same as the DNA on the victim's underwear.
While the witnesses were suspicious,
the witnesses of the object or the surrounding witnesses were predictable.
However, the use of the DNA test result
as evidence in the investigation process and the investigation of the case
was trusted in terms of accuracy according to the principles of science
and was able to help solve many cases.
For example, the decision to avoid arresting the police
after the court's ruling.
He asked for help from an organization
that does its job to help those who have been sentenced to prison
or life imprisonment without committing a crime.
What happens not often happens
when the prosecutor requests a new case,
even if Chen's case is the last one.
The two-year struggle
finally resulted in his acquittal.
The important evidence used in the fight
that led Chen to be acquitted
is the same evidence used to tie him up.
The DNA test result is the same evidence used to tie him up
as a criminal.
How is it possible?
DNA is the genetic code of all living things on this planet.
The structure has a double-wrapped pattern
that looks like a right-angled staircase.
Its miracle is that it is a unique code.
There is no living thing that has the same DNA set
except for the twins born from the same egg.
This unique DNA pattern is called DNA printing.
And the memory in each person's DNA
makes DNA a tool
to verify the identity of the person in the case.
Professor James Chung Lee,
a professor of the Department of Science
at Taiwan National University,
is one of the people involved in Chen's case.
He told us that the first DNA test was done
after the accident in 2012.
At that time, the Taiwan's evidence verification team
used a technique called
a male chromosome genetic test
to compare the DNA of 17 positions.
The result showed that
the number of DNA found on the underwear of the victim
and the DNA from Chen's body
were equal in all 17 positions.
This led to the conclusion that
it could not be determined by a suspect.
In Taiwan, we have 11,500 people
who share the same pattern.
So I told the lawyers,
if you say Mr. Chen is a suspect
or he's a donor,
you have a chance to lose your case.
Because it's most possible
it's not from him, but from other people,
but you don't know who.
That was the test in 2012.
When the case was investigated,
a new DNA test was done
using an advanced technology.
From 17 positions,
it increased to 23 positions.
So I said another choice is to ask them
to do more loci.
During that time,
actually the commercial kid
have 23 or 27.
So the judge said,
okay, go ahead to do another test.
So they did more tests for the six loci.
The more detailed DNA test
using advanced technology
showed that there was a difference.
According to the new DNA test,
the DNA from Atsuji
on Chen's underwear
and the DNA from Chen
had two different numbers.
This difference was the reason
he got out of the lawsuit.
This difference means
the DNA from Chen's underwear
didn't come from Chen.
So these two differences saved his life.
Yes, yes.
I say he's very lucky
because the DNA was still in that forensic lab.
If you want to exclude a person,
only one marker mismatch is good enough.
Chen became innocent.
Not only Chen's case,
but many people believe
he was sentenced to jail or death
without any mistake.
The most shocking case
is the case of a soldier
who was accused of raping a 5-year-old girl.
Which life sentence did he get?
Until many years later,
there's no evidence confirming
that he's innocent.
There's no exact number
on how many people were accused
and sentenced for crimes
that they didn't commit.
But according to the number of cases
that the accused asked for help
from the organization
in this room,
it may be more than every year.
So this is the important room?
Yes, it's 2016 and 2015.
So this is for this year?
Yes, last year, 2016.
Now it's seven.
200 cases?
Yes, about 209, 210, 211.
So, and it's 2015, also 200.
So you told me that all the cases
which is in this room is about 800
is already final.
They're either in detention center
or in jail.
Yes, or maybe they are just get out.
Get out from the prison.
They are free now,
but they still can, they are innocent.
The cases range from
unintentional and intentional
to retaliation.
All the cases that were sent
are the cases that the court
has already given the highest sentence.
The person who didn't commit a crime
but was found guilty
usually tries to find a way
to prove his innocence.
Especially in Taiwan,
it's even more serious
because there is still a life sentence.
One of the people who is fighting
for the life sentence is Chen Seung-je.
He is a wanted man.
He has fought for three cases,
both the first, the second, and the third.
All three cases have the same
life sentence.
He has been in jail for 14 years.
Last year, the police asked for a new case
because there was evidence that
he was tortured to confess.
Due to the softness of the case,
we only found his lawyer.
The cause of death is in the bar with his friend.
The cause of death is in the karaoke room.
The police arrested him.
There was a gunfight between them.
The police killed him.
Even though Chen's position
didn't cause the gunshot
to kill the police,
he confessed to being the shooter.
Chen Seung-je is innocent.
But when the police made a report,
he was tortured.
He was electrocuted and beaten.
At that time, he didn't have a lawyer.
Under the circumstances of the police,
Chen made a false confession.
He admitted that he fired a gun.
But in fact, he didn't fire a gun.
Of course, it's not normal.
It's also forbidden.
According to Taiwan's regulations,
if the defendant's confession
is not out of free will,
but was forced by the outside force,
the confession can't be used as evidence.
The law makes it clear.
But the case was a murder case.
It was a sensitive case.
Was the police killed
by the gunman
because of the case?
Was the police killed
because of the case?
Was the police killed
because of the case?
Generally, if the defendant has a scar
during the investigation,
the confession can't be used as evidence.
But in Chen's case,
the law made it clear
that he was tortured
because the confession
was made
by the police and the prosecutor.
During the interrogation,
Chen admitted that he was tortured
even though he could return the confession
because he wasn't tortured.
Under the circumstances of the police,
the psychological pressure
was still there.
So when the prosecutor asked him
if his confession was correct,
he didn't dare to say no.
In the end, he could only tell the prosecutor
to check the gun for him.
He used this method
to tell the prosecutor
that as long as he checked the gun,
he would know that he didn't shoot.
He told him in a very gentle way.
He didn't dare to tell the prosecutor
in the circumstances of the police
that his confession was wrong
because of the psychological pressure.
It's very likely that the accused
will be pressured both physically
and mentally
by the accused.
Even though he knew
that he didn't do anything wrong,
some people who have been physically
and mentally abused
may be confused
and give up.
According to Mr. Chen,
he has been sent to somewhere
he didn't know that.
But he used a towel
to cover his eyes
to be punched
and to be electrocuted
and to be poured
into the water.
Something like that.
Two hours later,
we have some video
and he began
to write a confession
at seven o'clock.
In the videotape,
we can see
that his left eye
is kind of bruised
and his eyes are just red.
But it's a gunshot case.
There's no fighting scene
at that time.
But after the two hours
missing,
he showed up again
and you can see
that his left eye
is just bruised.
According to Mr. Chen,
the accused
For Mr. Chen's case,
it's the first case
that has the same evidence
which is DNA
from an innocent person.
His case is a part
of an interesting change
of the justice system here.
Last year,
the Taiwan Parliament
passed a new law.
The purpose of this new law
is to allow the accused
to re-examine
his DNA
without waiting for a request
from the judge like in my case.
After the case,
you're the final
convict person
and you should explain
why you want to do
the DNA re-test
or in your case,
we haven't done the DNA test.
Maybe you should explain
the necessity
of the DNA re-test
and give you
the reason
and you file a re-test
petition
to the court
and the court might be
do the test.
The justice system in Taiwan
started from the police
to the court
is being called to change
or re-examine.
For example,
the evidence
is needed
to prove the DNA
in the future
instead of destroying it.
Once the technology is developed,
the DNA can be re-examined
in detail.
The accused
might not be the wrongdoer.
During that time,
they don't think
it's possible to have
a wrong conviction
and it's impossible
to test it.
But right now, we know
it's possible.
Nothing is impossible.
So for you, it's better
to spend a little bit more money
and preserve the evidence
than put someone
who is innocent in jail.
Right.
So we have to do more work
to preserve this evidence
and also protect
the human rights.
Because we know that
the prosecutor's office
will destroy the evidence
after the case is final.
We can see in the Innocence Movement
in the United States,
the first time they passed
the post-conviction DNA test
and the second step
would be to amend
the preservation
of evidence.
And just like the same
in Taiwan,
we will focus on the preservation
of evidence since we have the bill
but we don't have the things to be tested.
So it's very important
because they destroy
evidence every day.
It's very hard
to build a system
to let the people
have the chance to test
the evidence again.
Otherwise, they destroy it
because they saw
the Mr. Chang's case.
They always said
if they don't want to get in trouble,
it's a better way
to destroy all the cases
and the evidences.
Mr. Chang's case in the Innocence Movement
affected not only the victims
but also his family
and relatives.
For Mr. Chang's case,
he was sentenced to 4 years in prison
and he decided to
take care of his family.
The restaurant was closed
so I ran away
because I was wanted.
I ran away
with my wife and kids
because I had nothing
and I didn't know
how long I would live.
So I wanted to spend
a day with them
because I didn't know
what would happen next.
In Taiwan,
there would be
a bad ending
so I wanted to
spend a day with them
as long as possible.
If I go to jail,
I won't be able to be with them.
Chen and his family
had to live in secrecy
for more than 2 years.
Their lives and their loved ones
were destroyed because of
their own mistakes.
I wasn't angry
because I was helpless.
I was sad and didn't know
what to do.
I felt like there was no hope
in my life.
I felt helpless.
I couldn't be angry
because I knew
that I couldn't
solve the problem.
I felt like I was forced
so I felt helpless.
As long as there are
people with DNA evidence
as well as a broad mind
of the officials
to investigate the case,
it's a good thing.
This is a scientific investigation.
It's our model.
We can use DNA
to prove this guy.
It's a suspect.
But they don't think
this evidence
only excludes
not the positive
identified him.
So the interpretation is very important.
After this case,
you don't believe DNA evidence.
You have to test it.
You have to question
the evidence.
It really tells this person
if he's a suspect or not.
The movement and the call
after Chen's case
wasn't to destroy the credibility
of the scientific investigation.
But to lead to the development
to close the VO channel
and make the DNA
a part of justice.
After the heart-wrenching case
of the soldier executed
and Chen's case,
many people hope that
the VO channel of the justice system
will be reduced and the practice
will be changed during the investigation.
The trial of the suspect
won't happen because
there must be an interrogation.
The new law allows the suspect
to ask for a DNA test.
But there's still a challenge
and it may take time.
The final decision is final.
It's done.
All is done.
I believe that most judges
would think that
the decision should be correct.
So if he reopens the case,
which means that
the decision
might be wrong.
And usually,
they won't say
other judges' decision
is wrong.
So,
it's kind of...
Losing faith?
Losing faith
or some dignity
of the judicial system
and some
cultural things,
some culture in the judges
or in the prosecutors.
I would call that a miracle.
Because it's very...
So it's not happening every day?
Not happening every day
because we have some cases
just not so lucky as Mr. Chen.
The old cases
with the highest jury
have been reopened
not only for the innocent.
On the other hand,
it reflects the mistakes
that might happen in the judicial system.
The fraud
or mistakes
that might happen
with the scientific evidence
that is very credible like DNA.
This is not the first time
that someone has been punished.
And of course,
Taiwan is not the first.
There are many other countries
that have developed
and haven't developed yet.
For Mr. Chen,
this is a miracle.
But the miracle
doesn't happen every time
and to everyone.