'Simple question' would have prevented Liverpool VAR error says Dermot Gallagher

Sky Sports News
24 followers
Oct 4, 2023
Wow, absolutely astonishing, right let's bring in former Premier League referee
Dermot Gallagher who joins us now. Dermot, very good evening, how do you react to that?
Well, you've got to take the positives out of it, Mike, you know it's a terrible
mistake to make, we all acknowledge that, everybody's acknowledged that, it's the
biggest talking point of the season, let alone this weekend. What we've got to do,
we've got to, as Carvey said, it's got to be the process and I think one of the
processes that they will have to undertake from now is the first thing
the VAR says is, what is the on-field decision? Because I think if that little
question had been asked, what is the on-field decision and they said offside,
you've got a start point, once you've got a start point, you can then go forward.
Unfortunately, because that question wasn't asked, they were under the
impression the goal had been given on the field and that's where it all
unfolded. Do we need to change the laws of the game? I think it's easier, Mike, it's
just to get a process that everybody's comfortable with and everybody can work
to, you know, and as I say, that simple question, Mike, it might sound very, very
trivial but that simple question would have alleviated all that went on behind
because if you think, if I say to you, what's the on-field decision, Mike, you go
it's offside, I can then look, I'm checking for offside. He didn't check for
offside, what he was checking was the player not offside and that's how it
unfolded. Now, we heard someone called Ollie referred to there a lot, that's
Michael Oliver, the fourth official, we didn't hear his audio. Do we need to hear
his audio? Well, at the moment, Mike, you know, there's constraints, you can't, you
can't put everything publicly. It's brilliant, it's great they've been
transparent, they've come out, they've taken ownership of this mistake, you know,
that it's been admitted very, very quickly. Going forward, they've shown
they're transparent, everybody's aware of what happened. Whilst you might not like
what happened, at least you can understand how it happened, you know,
you've got to understand how that mistake was made and I think that's good
because once you understand how a mistake is made, you can then alleviate
that happening again and that's the big thing, Mike, isn't it? This must
never, never, never happen again. That's the learning point and that's the
learning point from today going forward. Dermot, can I just ask you, once they
realised that a mistake had been made, do you think they made the correct
decision not to stop the game? Because we heard in that audio them
repeatedly, somebody saying the game needs to be delayed, delayed, delayed,
delayed, but the VAR said, no, too late, there's nothing I can do. Do you
think he should have done something? Was there something he could do?
Akavio, unfortunately he can't, you know, the thing about football as a
referee, the minute you blow your whistle and stop the game, you've got
unlimited time, the time's your own, you can change your mind, you can talk
with your officials, you can gather as much information as you want, but once
you decide what decision you're going to make and that game restarts, there's
no going back, that's it, you've got to carry on. And that's what Darren
England realised, he realised then, you can just tell with the way he's
spoken, he's made a mistake, but there's nothing he can do, he cannot go back,
you know, that's the laws of the game. We heard all kinds of things on RefWatch
yesterday about ideas to combat it and what would be ethically correct, but
unfortunately the referee has to abide by the laws of the game, he can't pick
and choose which parts to apply.
Dermot, take us to the human side of this. As a referee, what will it have
done to those officials?
Mike, I tell you, we are the worst body in the world, Mike, for beating
ourselves up, honestly, you would not believe it. I mean, I just talk about
myself, you know, as you know, I don't like doing it, but I'm not
personalised as anybody else. If I made a mistake, I come off a field and
been told I made a mistake, I'm driving home, it actually contracts my life
because I just want to get home, I want to get to sleep, I want to wash it away,
I want to get up the next day, and I want to get my next match under my
belt because I want to wash it away. And that's what happens. These guys will
be absolutely beating themselves up. This is when their colleagues need to
be really, really strong, ring fence them, pick them up, support them, you
know, therefore, for the grace of God, go I type thing, and say, look, you
know, you're there because how good you are, you made one mistake, all
right, it was a big, big mistake, but it's how you come back from it. And
that's what they've got to do. They've got to ring fence their colleagues,
they've got to make them feel good about themselves again, so they get
back on the pitch and do the job that they were doing before, Mike.
Dermot, you're right, we have to remember they are human beings. Dermot,
thank you so much for listening, and for joining us. Thank you.
Pleasure.
Carvey, before we leave it, I think that's important, isn't it? We
remember, these are human beings, because they're getting hammered from
everywhere at the moment.
I think they are, you know, Pep Guardiola himself earlier today said
that he felt that the referees had taken centre stage too much, people
were talking about them too much. I'm not sure referees want to be in the
spotlight. They want to do their job. And they know that if we're not
talking about the referees, it pretty much means that they've done a good
job. They don't want to be the centre of attention. But with all the
technology that there is around now, they are under more and more
scrutiny. The thing that I keep coming back to from listening to that
audio tape is, they were in such a rush to make that decision. And I
think that's because we've put them under pressure to reach these
decisions really, really quickly. Because when VAR was first
introduced, and they were taking a long time to make these decisions,
everybody was complaining about the fact that it was taking too long. It
was ridiculous. The people in the stadiums didn't know what was going on
either. So I think that's why they've tried to speed up the decision making
process. But listening to that audio and watching the video, it's obvious
if you do anything at that speed, if you do anything that that's
complicated, and so many people are watching, and depending on your
decision making, and you're doing it that quickly, mistakes are going to
be made. And I think it's really important what we saw at the end of
that clip as well. PGMOL saying that the protocols are going to change,
lessons will be learned. And I know you said that a lot of people are
hammering the officials. I think we should make it clear that Liverpool
as a club are not hammering the officials. They're not blaming Darren
England, they're not blaming PGMOL. What Liverpool are saying is, look,
obviously a mistake was made. And in footballing terms, it was a serious,
significant mistake. What we want to do is make sure that this doesn't
happen again. And the processes and the protocols are improved to make
sure that mistakes like this are never happened again. Absolutely.
Kaveh Solakol, our chief reporter. Thank you, Kaveh.
