Exclusive
Safeguard Defenders: CCP’s Repression Exported Around the World | Laura Harth | Focus Talk

China Insights with Jenny
670 followers
2.7K Video Views·Oct 3, 2023
Laura Harth, campaign director at the European-based human rights NGO, Safeguard Defenders, raises awareness of the ripple effect of the CCP’s human rights violations committed around the world to forcefully bring back individuals it considers threats to its rule. Under the regime’s global fugitive-hunting Fox Hunt program, it uses all means necessary to harass, intimidate and outright kidnap its targets.
Hi, welcome to Focus Talk. On January 31st this year, the FBI Director Christopher Wray gave a
speech at Ronald Reagan Library and warned about the Chinese Communist Party's threats to U.S.
In the speech, he specifically talked about the foxhunt program by the CCP and said,
they target, capture, and repatriate former Chinese citizens living overseas whom it sees
Not so coincidentally, a report released by Safeguard Defender, a human rights NGO based
in Europe, gave a detailed account of the CCP's overseas fugitive hunting operations.
Today, we invite Laura Harth, Campaign Director at Safeguard Defender,
to explain to us what they have found out.
Hi Laura, thank you so much for coming on to our show.
Hi Jenny, thank you so much for having me and for paying attention to this issue.
So your report gives a comprehensive review of the CCP's global fugitive hunting to bring back
overseas Chinese back to China. Now, first, what made your organization recognize this issue?
Why did you decide to investigate it?
So the report is called Involuntary Returns, and it was published on January 18. I'm obviously
inviting all your viewers to go and take a look at it on our website. I think they'll find it very
interesting and incisive in documenting what is exactly going on. Now, how did we come to this?
I like to think about it as a bit of a ripple effect. Safeguard Defender is obviously
traditionally focused on human rights offenders, human rights violations
in the People's Republic of China, mostly on mainland China, very much focused also on
everything that has to do with judicial proceedings, where obviously we've seen an
exponential deterioration of the judicial system since Xi Jinping came to power. We've seen an
exponential increase in the abuses of enforced disappearances, of pretrial detention, torture,
forced confession. So those are issues that Safeguard Defender traditionally works on and
has been raising awareness about around the world. Now, the problem is when these kind of
violations go unchecked for a very long time, and with the CCP taking more and more this brazen tone
also in their global relations with other countries, they see there is no challenging
from the outside world. So they kind of become more aggressive. And so there is this kind of
ripple effect of human rights violations taking place in the mainland that slowly try to
grow and move into the wider world. And I think that's a very good way at looking what we see
happening. So we're seeing this repression at home increasingly being exported all around the world.
Skynet that was launched in 2015, that in 2018 moved under the guise of the National
Commission of Supervision, which incorporated also Fox Hunt in this so-called anti-corruption
campaign, which obviously we know is much less about actually fighting corruption among the CCP
than it is about consolidating the CCP's power and the top of the CCP's power. And so Skynet
is this international arm, we can say, of this repression at home, which obviously has the target
one of the greatly expanding Chinese community abroad. Official numbers from the UN
High Representative Office for Refugees tells us that the number of refugees from China has
gone up by 700% in the past years since Xi Jinping came to power. And so it says,
want to control them to ensure that CCP controls the minds of the people, not just at home,
but also abroad, and also to make sure that those people know that they are not safe anywhere.
And I'd like to add, again, because this has gotten challenged as well in many countries,
official numbers released by the CCDI last year speak of over 10,000 by the end of 2021,
over 10,000 people that have been returned through various means from 120 countries.
The vast majority of these cases have gone unchallenged, unreported, authorities have
not taken any measures to stop this. And again, this ripple effect, we see the spillover effect,
where now it's not even only exiled communities, it's no longer only the people that the CCP
considers its own nationals, maybe because of their grandparents or parents. This is now
happening also to UK citizens, Danish citizens, members of parliament that have been warned by
their authorities that they're at risk of, for example, extradition requests or warrants
through Interpol and what so on. Wow. Now, as far as I understand,
even though the CCP claimed it was an anti-corruption action, in many cases,
the targets they're chasing after are actually dissidents or human rights defenders, right?
Exactly. So I think when they talk about anti-corruption, we have to understand it from a
CCP, let's say, speak, double speak point of view. And the cases that we've documented, again,
we've documented 62 case studies in our report. Obviously, we're talking over 10,000 people.
Many people will not come forward, are very afraid, rightfully so, either for themselves
or for their family and loved ones still in China. But what we've seen is that many of these cases
are either Uyghur people that have fled the country, Tibetans, activists, human rights
defenders, even people that maybe we wouldn't even say are traditional dissidents or have any
human rights activism, did anything like that in the past, but maybe send out a tweet of criticism
towards the CCP and thus become the target of these kind of operations.
Your report has a lot of detailed information. And like you just said,
it has a detailed 60-something cases. How long did it take for you to collect information?
Have you met difficulties or obstacles during the process?
Yes, definitely. So first of all, I really have to congratulate actually our research team
who have done the bulk of this work and who have done an amazing job at that, very meticulous. So
this is one focusing on involuntary returns, which actually is a bigger problem in terms of numbers
than extradition. So about a year, I think one of the main difficulties is, you know,
finding people willing to speak up, obviously finding the cases, because one of the big
issues and one of the things also that we ask governments is to actually start monitoring these
practices, to investigate these practices, because we get numbers and we know that the numbers that
we get from the Chinese side are very limited. They will only release the numbers of successful
returns. We know that the attempts are much bigger. For example, the 62 cases we documented,
50% of them were successful, 50% were not. So obviously these numbers do not show up. So that's
one of the big problems that official sources are very much lacking. Secondly, is finding people
that are willing to come forward, to share their story, even anonymously, because obviously they
live under fear. And that is exactly what the CCP wants. I mean, that's the whole purpose of this
operation, not only to have people return, but to make sure that the wider community remains in
silence. So speaking up about these practices, about being harassed, about having your family
members back home, harassed, maybe detained, punished, that's a very heavy burden, which
understandably many people do not want to risk. So tell us a bit more about the report, Laura.
What are the main methods used by the CCP to bring back these targets to China?
So in this, on the basis of the cases that we documented, the case studies of 62, we roughly see
three types of what we call involuntary returns. Obviously, the NSC, the CCP calls them voluntary
and likes to, you know, bring the people on TV and tout these cases as examples for the wider
community. But basically we have three types. The first one is working through, you know,
threatening family members back home, relatives, and trying to have them cooperate in coercing
the suspect, the victim abroad to come back voluntarily. So that's one method.
When that doesn't work, they are able also to actually send agents abroad, either in covert
operations, so without the agreement of the counterpart country, sometimes, you know,
in cooperation with the country, and actually trying to go harass, intimidate the victim
itself in the country where they are. In this part, we also have entrapment,
luring, so maybe intimidating these persons to a state where they don't feel safe,
maybe move to another country from where then it is easier for the CCP to repatriate them.
And the last one, obviously, the third type, which is the most
shocking, I mean, they're all very bad, the most extreme, is the use of kidnappings,
obviously totally illegal, sending people, agents abroad in a clandestine manner.
We've seen reports also, for example, in Australia, I mean, many of these happen,
most of the case of kidnappings, for example, happen in South Asia, this case in Myanmar,
Thailand, Cambodia, but also in Australia, for example, we've had reports of at least
nine cases of outright kidnappings where people were taken with a drug, put on a boat illegally
under cover and brought back to China. So this is happening around the world.
What about US? Has there any kidnapping happening here in US?
I don't have any account of outright kidnappings. We know that the US authorities are afraid that
this might be happening because they've seen that this has happened in other countries,
also allied countries. We've definitely seen all the other methods being employed in the US.
And I think it's very important to see that after the report was issued,
that the FBI director actually addressed it and recognized that this is a growing issue.
So can you give one or two specific cases, Laura, to show us how these methods,
different methods are used in these real life examples and how they're trying to use
these methods to bring back these specific individuals?
Well, there's a fairly, there's a fair amount of cases actually ongoing with various methods, again,
between the legal and the illegal. They often also mix them. If one method doesn't work,
they'll switch to another. A good example of such mixed methods is a fairly recent case of
a young boy, actually. I mean, he's just 19, 20 years old. He's now in the Netherlands and has
obtained asylum there fairly recently. His name is Wang Jingzhu. I think you might have heard of him.
Yeah, yeah. His case was widely reported, actually, the 19-year-old boy from Chongqing,
right? Sichuan, Chongqing. Exactly. So he left China in 2019. He left for the EU.
Again, this was not someone who was an activist, a human rights defender in any
traditional sense. I mean, just a young boy really trying to go into the wider world.
In February 21, he made some social media posts on questioning the CCP's official
account of the official death toll on the Chinese side in the border clashes with India.
So, I mean, obviously, yes, he was challenging an official account. But again, we're not talking
about something earth shattering here. But within half an hour of him doing that social media post,
police went to his parents' house, detained his parents, searched the house, took away computers,
took away anything that they thought might be useful. They told his family that he would
immediately be charged with picking quarrels and provoking troubles. Obviously, again,
this is the usual. But let's recall, these are national security crimes, so that's very heavy
talking, because he had slandered and belittled heroes and caused a negative social impact. So
we're talking about one social media post. His parents were detained and interrogated on
multiple occasions throughout February. They were first, the police asked them,
threatened them, pressured them to call him, to plead with him to return voluntarily to face
these charges. His family refused to do so. They kept obviously paying the brunt of this through
multiple harassment. At a certain point, his father managed to slip away during the night
out of the house and just give him a quick call to tell him, look, this is happening, be careful.
This actually kind of stopped because he talked to Voice of America, his story was published.
And so he lost all contact with his family after this. The lines were disconnected,
he couldn't no longer reach him. But then he also received emails directly from police officers
back home saying, threatening that he should return. He received other messages saying at
a certain point that his mother had been brought to the hospital. And in the end,
his father was detained and charged actually with quite a crime that didn't even make much
sense. Because the fact is that under torture, his father would have reported that some other
people were conspiring to go to Hong Kong to join the protest movement. And so he says,
this should actually be, I mean, the CCP, the police usually are happy if you report against
other people. So how do you end up being charged? But obviously, this was all part of a campaign
to get him to return. And so it's a very good example of the type one, you know, using the
family against you as leverage against you. But it doesn't end there. And this shows the
combination of methods used because at a certain point, he goes to the United Arab Emirates
on a trip, and upon arrival, is detained there by the border police at the airport.
So they tried to have him deported to China at a certain point, they charged him with the fact,
I think, if I recall correctly, that he may have insulted the Islam, which had not even happened.
So they kind of worked around this, but as international attention on this case was mounting,
because we were informed, media was informed. So in the end, there was enough pressure also,
again, from the US State Department, as to be said, and he was released, made it to the
United Arab Emirates. He has applied successfully for asylum. But let's not forget, his family is
still there. I don't know what is currently happening with his father. Is he still in prison?
So that's quite a heavy price to pay. I mean, he cannot be in touch with them. And all this,
again, over a social media post, which yes, was critical, but again, not earth shattering.
His story is unbelievable. And I'm really happy that he's now, hopefully he's now safe in
the Netherlands. And in his case, the only thing they didn't use was the direct kidnapping,
right? I guess if they could, they would. But do you have any example where the CCP
actually used the direct kidnapping to kidnap someone back to China?
Yes. So a good example was back in 2015. We were going to Southeast Asia, where we have some more
documentation on this. And it's the case of, again, someone who was not, who did not start
out as a rights activist. Obviously, that's quite common in mainland China. It's very hard to start
out as a rights activist there. For obvious, I mean, for obvious reasons. It's very hard to have
a community to have that kind of, there's no freedom of assembly manifestation. So it's also
hard for people to get into this. And it's dangerous. But he was an engineer.
So an engineer, he became a rights activist after battling the illegal demolition of his house in
Beijing back in 2014, which is quite a common way for people to get into this kind of activism,
because obviously, when something touches you yourself, you become aware of the wider issues.
And so he became involved with other human rights activists. And in October 2015,
helped to smuggle obviously famous human rights lawyer, Wang Yu's son, the son of Wang Yu,
Wang Yu who was in prison at the time, actually, in secret detention into Myanmar.
The idea was to, you know, bring the boy outside of the country. Wang Yu's son was 16 at the time,
so that he could, you know, get an education abroad. Obviously, he was not allowed to leave
China. So they smuggled him out of the country, made it to Myanmar, tried to hide there before
they could move on. Now, some things went wrong. Again, there's a longer account in our report if
people are interested. And they were found, they were trailed and found by Chinese police and by
local Myanmar police. The Chinese police was dressed in plain clothes. But so they were stopped,
detained, brought in for questioning in Myanmar, separated. But as he recounts,
this was a mere formality, because even the interrogations were done by the Myanmar and
Chinese police together. So there was a clear cooperation between authorities there. The
interrogation was very short. In Myanmar, the Myanmar police accompanied them to the border
and just handed them over in cuffs to the Chinese police across the border. Obviously,
from there, they were interrogated again. And actually, Tang Zhishun spent quite some time
in residential surveillance at a designated location, which are China's notorious black
prisons, where people are kept in solitary confinement, watched 24 seven,
you know, tortured mentally, psychologically interrogated, basically with the aim of
breaking them. He was released in December 2016. And again, there's a bit of a happy ending because
in August 21, he managed to make it to the US and get back to his family. So it's two cases
which have a happy ending. But again, the price to pay in between has been very, very heavy. And
again, it just shows how brazen they are in pursuing this and how they feel that they can
get away with it, evidently. Yeah, this is, you know, I think a lot of people are not aware of
this, and they will be shocked once they find out that the CCP agent actually do these kind of
operations on foreign soil. And I would imagine that these physical harassment and outright
kidnapping violate the laws of these host countries. So do these host countries realize
that these kind of operations are going on? So, I think on the one hand, there is a lack
of awareness. There is also a lack of reporting by the people that are the victim of this.
Definitely, for understandable reasons. And again, one of the things why we want to raise
awareness is, for example, also local police and local countries may not be aware of these
things happening, may not be very receptive. When people would come forward, people are afraid to
come forward, they do not feel protected. So one of the first things that we ask all countries is
to start investigating this, to expose this, to really monitor this, to make sure that the people
feel protected. Unfortunately, many countries actually, this might be diminishing a bit over
the past years, but many countries, and you would be shocked, also many Western democracies,
unwittingly or to some extent wittingly, do cooperate in some way, to some extent with
these operations, or do at least, how to say, make it easier for the CCP to carry them out.
And a lot of times, I think the governments are not fully aware of what they're doing,
and maybe they don't want to be aware. Some countries are working on this. Canada is
definitely more advancing on this. I think, especially in the European Union, we have a big
issue. Other countries, for example, there's a great example in the report of France,
where someone was a type two, where there was covered agents, came to France, intimidated a
person to have a return voluntarily. Now, this was exposed. And so the French ministry, actually,
the French government, they were quite shocked. They were quite angry, they stated, and they said
there will be severe consequences. But to the extent of our knowledge, nothing actually ever
happened. And we always go back to this ripple effect, the fact that all these violations are
never actually challenged. And so they just keep expanding to the point, as we said in the
introduction, to the point that now, you know, it is really impacting the enjoyment of fundamental
rights and freedoms that are guaranteed by the Constitution, international conventions,
European Convention for Human Rights, on European soil.
They need to realize that it's the citizens of these countries, you know, citizens in Australia,
in France, a lot of people who got the permanent residence right in these countries. If these
people that got targeted, and if they don't stop the CCP's attempts, their own citizens or citizens
from the other ethnicity will get targeted. And the thing is, I mean, your organization,
the founder of your organization, Mr. Peter Dahling, he was forced to do a TV confession
on Chinese TV. And he's European. I mean, the CCP doesn't stop. It doesn't stop there, basically.
Exactly. I fully agree. It doesn't stop there. And I mean, from my point of view,
it shouldn't arrive there for government to be an issue. Because, you know, it's anyone coming,
you know, coming from China, or maybe having Chinese grandparents or whatever, they're not
second class citizens. They're citizens just like anybody else. Let us go back to the sense of what
was the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. After the Second World War, countries came together,
understanding that either we protect human rights, like human rights are the way and universal human
rights are the way to preserve peace among peoples and among nations. Yep. That was the idea. And,
you know, people often say human rights, human rights, yes, it's nice. But you know, it's like
a side thought, because we have to think about business, we have to think about, you know, we
have big policy issues to think about, we have the Olympic Games, we have energy transition,
you know, all the big items and human rights. Yes, nice, important, but maybe no, the problem is,
they are what preserve the peace. And we're seeing it, well, we're seeing what's happening now,
with Russia, and Ukraine, and how that, again, it's a ripple effect. If you don't stop,
if you don't challenge every single human rights violation, when they start,
it's just growing and growing. And it's always going to spill over to other countries. And we're
seeing it. And the fact that we did not challenge the CCP when we could have when we should have,
and that we still do not stand up, because again, there is business, there is a lot of stuff,
it is, you know, putting an end effectively, we feel how the international rules based order
is under threat around the world, our way of life is collapsing, our way of life are,
you know, and it starts with human rights. Yeah, I think, in essence, the world is becoming
more dangerous and less safe place, and everyone, for everyone who lives in there.
So, do you feel that the publishing of your report will help to raise the public awareness,
and in turn will add more pressure to the government, to these hosting host countries,
governments, to force them to do more on this end? So we do, I have to say, the report has
been received very well. We were very happy, obviously, that it received so much attention
and continues to receive attention, that people that journalists see the importance of this,
I think, obviously, many journalists, because they've been so heavily targeted in China,
both foreign journalists, and even worse, obviously, the Chinese national journalists,
they've been very, very, you know, receiving of this report. And so that is very important,
because that helps in pushing for policy changes. We have had some positive signals,
as in the past of certain governments, we've obviously seen the statements of the FBI director
in Canada, there's members of parliament around the world, for example, through the
Interparliamentary Alliance on China, but also others that have been raising these kinds of
issues all the time. We've seen the European Parliament in resolutions, you know, over the
past years, taking a very firm and clear stance. So we are hopeful. Making governments move,
that is a bit more difficult, especially, I would say, in the European Union.
It's not something they like to address. But so we will continue pushing this,
raising awareness, and asking for some very clear and short-term goals, starting with the
suspension of extradition treaties within the European Union, which we think it's high time
that that happens. Yeah, very, very much needed. And there's one more thing I wanted to ask you.
I read the full statement by the FBI director Christopher Wray. He did mention that the CCP's
foxhound often starts with issuing red notices through Interpol. So he said issuing red notices
for political purposes is an abuse of the program. I hope Interpol is aware of this.
Oh, they are aware. They're not acting on it. Yeah, Interpol is a huge issue. Just last week,
actually, the European Parliament published a study, again, looking into the abuses,
politically motivated abuse of Interpol red notices and pushing for reform. Now,
let's remember, the Western countries are the biggest donors of Interpol. But for some reason,
that does not translate into real changes. Now, we have a very recent example, an ongoing case,
a tragic case of an Uyghur citizen who was living in Turkey with his family since years,
his wife and three kids, who is a human rights defender, has been recognized as such,
who traveled to Morocco, was detained on an Interpol red notice that had been out there since
2017. He was not aware, he was detained last summer. He is still in prison in Morocco,
he risks being there for a long time. We managed to stop the extradition because the
UN Committee Against Torture issued interim measures. But you know, he is to all effects,
blocked and away from his family since months now. And actually, Interpol, what they did,
because as soon as we became aware of the case, we raised the issue in Parliament with media and so
on. So it became a huge case. That's when Interpol went to review it. That's when they suspended the
red notice. And just a couple of weeks after they said, oh, this red notice is not compliant,
which means it's in violation of the Interpol rules, because it's politically motivated.
But they never replied to us. But they replied to the Moroccan government,
saying that, yes, so this red notice is not compliant, it's in violation. But given that
this case has now passed under the bilateral extradition agreement that you have with China,
it's in your court now. So you do not, the fact that we canceled the red notice does not change
the fact that your arrest of this person is legitimate. It's a good example of what's
happening and what continues to happen. And unfortunately, we've been trying to get some
actions there in as well, some preventive notices, which is not a real instrument, but just, you know,
having people, for example, people that have been threatened by Hong Kong authorities of being
targeted with red notices to inform Interpol that if any request comes in, that these will
be politically motivated requests. But that keeps going on. And it's not just red notices,
because the issue is even worse when we look at the instrument of diffusions, which to all effect
and purposes have the same effect. But Interpol does not even have an obligation to review deals
prior to their circulation. There's many things going on. And it all starts with the lack of
awareness. And I think our task is to make sure that they have the awareness. And once there is
the awareness, obviously, it also becomes easier to hold them to account. Because once you cannot
fake that you do not know, it's easier to hold them to account under our constitutions, our rules,
international obligations, and make sure that, you know, the CCP cannot violate
our rules at home with the cooperation of our law enforcement agencies.
Yeah. And maybe it has something to do with the fact that just a few years ago,
the head of Interpol was actually a Chinese person, right? And he later was, he went back
to China and actually, ironically, was detained by CCP. But he was the head of the Interpol for
a few years. So I think that kind of tells you the infiltration and how the CCP in these
international organizations. Yeah, exactly. And it's not only Interpol,
obviously, it's an issue that we've seen over many international organizations.
It's something that's happened, I think. We were not paying attention, evidently,
the world was not paying attention. They've been very successful in doing this.
In silently climbing and entering those organizations, I mean, the top positions,
they hold more top positions in UN bodies than any other nation state. You know, silently
getting those positions, biding their time. And once they were there, they showed their true colors.
Yeah. Well, thank you so much, Laura, for coming today to share these important information. I
think it's, like you said, it's very important for people to be aware of that these things are
going on. And I hope your report will trigger more actions on that end.
Thank you so much. And thank you so much, really, for taking so much time to talk about it.
Well, thank you for watching Focus Talk. We'll see you next time.
