【ゆっくり解説】大河ドラマ『どうする家康』の嘘!

にっぽんぽん【ゆっくり日本史解説】
52 フォロワー
ーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーー
ーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーー
にっぽんぽんTwitter 【制作の裏話など】
https://twitter.com/nipponppo/status/1514134672988848129?s=21&t=KfI4G3avdKpUcCTb1LflhQ
にっぽんぽんInstagram【偉人の名言】
https://www.instagram.com/p/CcP2FQDvaxa/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
歴史は何のために学ぶのか。この疑問を持ったことがある方は少なくないでしょう。仕事では直接使うことはほとんどないですよね。
過去を学ぶことで未来に活かせると私は考えています。教養という意味でも社会で必要な知識でしょう。
先人たちはどのような暮らしでなぜそのような文化が形成されたのか。面白いことばかりです。
こういった考えから、このチャンネルでは社会人の方が、ゆっくり楽しく歴史上の偉人のことを学べ、更に、そこから日常でも役立てられるような動画を作っています。
このチャンネルを通して学び、役立てられる人が1人でも多くなるようにチャンネル運営を頑張っていきます。応援してもらえると嬉しいです。
ほぼ毎日17時に動画を配信中 にっぽんぽん 運営 山本陽太
※動画内の素材はすべて引用であり、著作権や肖像権を侵害する目的はございません。
著作権などに関するお問い合わせはこちらのアドレスまでお願いします。
[email protected]
#ゆっくり #ゆっくり日本史 #ゆっくり解説
Yukkuri Reimu and
Yukkuri Marisa.
Now, TV, TV.
It's about to start.
Reimu, do you still watch dramas every week?
You like it, don't you?
Yeah.
I also watch Getsuku, and Nichiyou Gekijou.
I watch a lot of things.
I also watch NHK's so-called morning dramas.
I've been into Taiga dramas lately.
Oh.
I knew it. You watch a lot of things.
I didn't expect you to watch Taiga dramas.
Ieyasu Matsumoto Jun.
Isn't he cool?
Also, Sena-sama Arimura Kasumi is cute.
Oae-no-kata-sama Hirose Arisu is also nice.
Honda Tadakatsu Yamada Yuuki is also cool.
Masa Itagaki Rihito is also young and handsome.
I see. You're really into it.
I'm sorry to hear that.
What?
It looks like a historical fact, but it's a Taiga drama.
Do you know that it's quite different from the facts?
What?
Is that so?
Is there a story in it?
I can't believe it.
Then, this time, I will explain the lie of Taiga drama What to do Ieyasu.
Then, take your time.
But I'm surprised that Taiga drama What to do Ieyasu is quite different from the facts.
Is that so?
Even if you treat the same person as a Taiga drama, it's a completely different story, isn't it?
I see.
Come to think of it, that's right.
Well, not just Taiga dramas, but all historical dramas are like that.
Ha ha ha.
Is Taiga drama What to do Ieyasu's historical fact interpretation terrible?
NHK Taiga drama What to do Ieyasu is getting closer to the end, and it's getting a lot more exciting.
It's finally over.
However, from a historical expert, it's a storm of booing.
Even so far, there are many differences from the facts.
It's amazing that you're so pointed out by a historical expert.
Most of the characters in What to do Ieyasu are characters that have existed in Japanese history, but there are also characters that do not appear in the facts.
What?
Who?
Who are you talking about?
Well, I wonder if you can look into the details yourself.
In fact, Taiga dramas are NHK's signboard programs, but there is no place to capture them.
It's hard to tell how much of it is true and how much of it is a bluff.
It was the same for me, but there are a lot of viewers who think it's all true.
It's not a documentary, it's a drama, so I don't have to say that it needs to be directed.
I'm sure NHK is trying to respect the facts because it's asking researchers to negotiate the times next year.
In fact, the text that this drama is fiction based on facts is not shown except for the Ida Ten Tokyo Olimpic story.
What?
Is that so?
So, what else?
After the end of the fourth episode of What to do Ieyasu, the era negotiator said that this is all fiction.
What?
The era negotiator said that?
Every year, the blood of Taiga drama Yukari becomes a taboo in the tourism industry, and in fact, many tourists come to see it.
Like Reimu, many viewers think it's a drama based on facts.
However, facts are also a habit.
What?
What do you mean?
There are many inconsistencies and differences in views, and what was thought to be correct is overturned when research progresses.
I see, it's not always true that it's a fact at some point.
You don't pay much attention to history books and materials?
It's kind of a weird story from the beginning.
The compromise is something like this.
It's like saying that while respecting the facts and the latest research results, it also includes the interpretation of the script, and in the unknown part, it illuminates the facts to add realism.
I see.
After all, such a compromise is necessary.
Otherwise, it will become a document.
Reimu also thinks that viewers are reflected in Taiga drama, so in other words, since NHK makes viewers think so, I don't think we should lose the attitude of getting closer to the facts.
That's right.
You can't get too far from the facts.
In that respect, what should Ieyasu do is a series of surprises.
Perhaps Mr. Ryota Furusawa, the scriptwriter, checked Tokugawa Ieyasu's dramas, movies, and novels, but did not pay attention to history books and materials.
What?
Is that possible?
After this, I will check the parts that seem to be different from the facts one by one.
Hinawaju's series is strange?
First of all, it's about the treatment of Hinawaju.
Hinawaju is a guy who is called Tanegashima, right?
What should Ieyasu do is that Akihiro Matsudaira, a relative of the Seika Matsudaira family of Tokugawa Ieyasu, aims for the position of the head of Matsudaira Ichimon and opposes Tokugawa Ieyasu.
That's right. I can't forgive you for aiming at Ieyasu.
Matsudaira Masahisa.
In this scene, a gunman named Matsudaira Masahisa, who was hiding in a car, suddenly appears and shoots Hinawaju at Tokugawa Ieyasu and Kashin-dan.
The fact that this gunfight scene seemed to be shooting at Hinawaju may be a contradiction.
What?
Was there a problem with that scene?
It was a powerful scene.
The time setting of Ieyasu at this time is just after the battle between Okehazama in 1560 and A63.
It is said that it was transmitted to Japan in 1543, the 12th year of Tenmon, so it is not a mistake for Hinawaju to appear.
I see. At that time, there was already a Hinawaju situation.
However, in order to shoot Hinawaju, I had to follow several steps as follows.
I see. What kind of steps are there?
Then I will explain in order.
1. Ignite Hinawa.
2. Put gunpowder and bullets from the gun barrel and put the center of gravity in the back with a stick.
3. Put gunpowder on the surface of the fire and close the lid.
4. Open the lid and determine the aim.
5. Fix the Hinawa with tweezers.
6. Pull the trigger and shoot.
7. Put the next gunpowder and bullets from the gun barrel and repeat 2 to 6.
It's a good procedure.
It seems to take time.
That's right.
In this way, Hinawaju can only be fired one shot at a time, and once it is fired, it takes about 30 seconds to prepare for the next firing, so it is thought that it was not possible to fire in a row like in the drama.
30 seconds, it takes a long time to fire one Hinawaju.
In addition, there is a scene where Oda Nobunaga Okada Junichi threatens Nobumoto Terashima of Oji Mizuno of Tokugawa Ieyasu with a Hinawaju, and there is a scene where two Hinawaju are fired in a row.
I see.
Actually, it takes 20 to 30 seconds to shoot one shot.
This was a depiction of a cold-blooded character in the drama of Oda Nobunaga, but if you actually want to do this, prepare a loaded Hinawaju, fire the first Hinawaju, and then you have to hurry and bring it back.
What did Ieyasu do that he couldn't do if it were true?
Kiyosu Castle is Shikin Castle?
Next, I will explain the lies about Kiyosu Castle.
Kiyosu Castle is famous for being the residence of Oda Nobunaga.
It became the residence of Masanori Fukushima during the time of Hideyoshi.
Kiyosu Castle is a castle in Aichi Prefecture, Kiyosu City.
The kanji for Kiyosu is different, though.
Oh, that's right, the characters are different.
What should Ieyasu do?
Tokugawa Ieyasu turned to Kiyosu Castle, the residence of Oda Nobunaga, and met Oda Nobunaga.
The appearance of Kiyosu Castle in this scene was a castle with a vast front with a stone floor, so it became a hot topic as if it were the former Kiyosu Castle in China.
Isn't Kiyosu Castle like a Chinese castle?
Tokugawa Ieyasu is guided by Oda Nobunaga's younger sister, Keiko Kitagawa, and climbs a hill that overlooks the entire view of Kiyosu Castle.
There is a scene that is surprising for the first time in the history of Chōka Town, but it seems that the local viewers said that Kiyosu City does not have such a high-rise building.
Oichi-sama, it was beautiful.
However, it is not good to make a hill that does not actually exist in Kiyosu City.
Also, it is said that the Kiyosu Castle in the time of Oda Nobunaga was Hirayadate.
The current Kiyosu Castle is equipped with four storehouses, and it is far from Ieyasu's Kiyosu Castle.
However, this is a reconstruction of the concrete building reproduced as a model of the castle wall of the Momoyama period in 1989,
and it seems that it is not the appearance of Kiyosu Castle in the Sengoku period, the background of Nobunaga's survival.
It is thought that there were no storehouses in Kiyosu Castle when Oda Nobunaga was the main base,
but in that respect, it can be said that the Kiyosu Castle that appeared in the early days of Ieyasu is closer to the truth than the current reconstruction.
I see, it means that it was true that there were no storehouses.
However, it seems that the Kiyosu Castle in the drama was drawn in computer graphics,
and it seems that there were few viewers who felt that it was a fantastic finish and that it was separated from reality.
It was certainly beautiful, but it was also true that it didn't look like the Sengoku period.
In the fourth episode of Ieyasu, Tokugawa Ieyasu was afraid to face Oda Nobunaga, who was destroying the enemy forces one after another,
and he was told not to become a weakling from his friend Kashin.
Yeah, yeah. You were pretty scared, Lord Ieyasu.
Oda Nobunaga's strong political will and economic policy overwhelmed him with the fact that he was developing Kiyosu Castle into a big city.
The Kiyosu Castle, like the Shikinjo in the drama, and the Jouka Town, which he overlooked from Kakuu no Oka,
may be perceived as a psychological depiction that Tokugawa Ieyasu, who was afraid of Oda Nobunaga, was reflected in such a large scale.
I see. Ieyasu's psychology is not about his actual appearance, but about how amazing he felt.
Between Sena and Tokugawa Ieyasu?
Next is Ieyasu's first personality, Sena.
Sena is also known as Tsukiyama-dono's nickname.
In Dousuru Ieyasu, it is depicted as if Ieyasu and his wife, Sena Tsukiyama-dono, were a loving couple.
Is it true that they were not a loving couple?
This is Tokugawa Ieyasu in the NHK Taiga drama broadcast in 1983.
It is very different from the historical drama depicting Ieyasu's long-term drama, which was made at the end of the year in other cultures.
In the drama dealing with Tokugawa Ieyasu, were Ieyasu and Sena not a loving couple?
In Dousuru Ieyasu's Sena, it is depicted as a very bright woman, full of self-love, who encourages Tokugawa Ieyasu, who is a young and gentle person, and is also loved by the Kashindan.
However, the image of Sena's character has been said to have a strong image of a villain who looks down on Tokugawa Ieyasu, who was a hostage of the Imagawa family, and that the couple was also cold.
From the image of Dousuru Ieyasu, I can't believe that Sena was a villain and the couple was cold.
It is said that Sena and Tokugawa Ieyasu had a long separation life, and that Tokugawa Ieyasu was subject to a lot of torture during his immediate death, and that Sena had a normal end due to Tokugawa Ieyasu's decision, etc.
I see. Based on the facts, it is natural to think that the relationship between Ieyasu and Sena was not good.
In Dousuru Ieyasu, it is said that Tokugawa Ieyasu was a lover who had been in love before marriage,
but in fact, it is thought that Tokugawa Ieyasu was selected by Yoshimoto Imagawa, the great leader, and Tokugawa Ieyasu was selected by Yoshimoto Imagawa.
At that time, there were many conspiracy marriages between the great leaders.
At that time, Yoshimoto Imagawa spread the Tokai region widely and took Tokugawa Ieyasu as a hostage, and extended his power to the country of Mikawa, the origin of the country.
Mikawa is now in the east of Aichi Prefecture.
In addition, it is said that he married Sena, his wife, and Tokugawa Ieyasu and tried to consolidate the rule of Mikawa.
Sena was originally the daughter of the Sekiguchi family, a relative of Yoshimoto Imagawa, and was shot by Yoshimoto Imagawa in the Battle of Okehazama.
Since Yoshimoto's son Ujizane was incompetent, Ieyasu knew that the Imagawa family would be weakened,
so Ieyasu stopped being a member of the Imagawa family after the Battle of Okehazama and allied with Nobunaga Oda, who shot Yoshimoto Imagawa, and became independent from the Imagawa family as the main base of Okazaki Castle.
This should have been very unforgivable for Sena, who was the daughter of the Imagawa family.
It means that the family is an enemy type.
Well, it's hard to do.
In addition, the Sekiguchi family, which is the family of Sena, became independent after Tokugawa Ieyasu allied with Nobunaga Oda,
and the Imagawa family was overthrown by Ujizane and the family collapsed.
There is even a theory that the father and mother were self-injured.
If your parents were self-injured, it would be painful.
Because Sena had such a background, as depicted in the drama, after the Battle of Okehazama,
there is also a theory that Ieyasu, who allied with Nobunaga Oda, and Ieyasu did not get along very well even if they were in the same Okazaki Castle, and there is even a theory that Sena is evil.
That Sena is evil.
I can't believe it.
I mentioned it before, but it's because Sena is a member of the Imagawa family.
It is said that it is more unreasonable to say that he was a good couple with his husband, who allied with Nobunaga Oda, who sold Yoshimoto.
Sena hates Ieyasu, who became independent from the Imagawa family because he has a strong loyalty to the Imagawa family.
In addition, she also hates Nobunaga Oda, who sold Yoshimoto in the Battle of Okehazama.
From Katsuyori Takeda there.
If there is a story about allying and trying to defeat Ieyasu and Nobunaga, it may be inevitable that they got on board.
I see.
Originally, there was a feeling that they would somehow bring down Ieyasu.
Tokugawa Ieyasu, who was a hostage of the Imagawa family, participated in the Battle of Okehazama as a Imagawa member, but
when Yoshimoto Imagawa was shot in this battle, Sena and his wife, who were in the Imagawa family, returned to the original Okazaki Castle.
No matter what Ieyasu did, they were separated.
By the way, Sunpu is now in Shizuoka Prefecture, Shizuoka City.
Okazaki Castle is in Okazaki City, Aichi Prefecture.
Sena and her parents were imprisoned in the Imagawa family.
Later, Sena was transferred to Okazaki as a hostage exchange, but Sena's parents were told that they were not allowed.
For this reason, Sena was deeply hurt, and it would not be strange if she could no longer trust her husband Tokugawa Ieyasu.
Nobuyasu, the eldest son born between Sena and Tokugawa Ieyasu, was excellent at literature, and Sena adored Nobuyasu.
However, it is said that Tokuhime, who was the daughter of Oda Nobunaga, was not in good terms with him.
It seems that there were many reasons for this, but one of them is that Sena made Nobuyasu jealous because Nobuyasu and Tokuhime could not have a son.
Oda Nobunaga, who learned of Tokuhime's dissatisfaction as a daughter, was angry and ordered Tokugawa Ieyasu to dispose of Nobuyasu and Sena.
As a result, Nobuyasu surrendered and Sena was murdered by Tokugawa Ieyasu's henchman.
Whether it's a poem or a drama, Sena and Nobuyasu are at odds with each other.
Poor Sena.
Sena's fantasy philosophy?
There are many other things about Sena.
For example, what is the difference between a poem and a drama?
The main point was that it was a fantasy that was hard to believe in the 24th Tsukiyama Etsudo.
Along with Sena and Nobuyasu Hosodakanata, she called many mercenaries to the Tsukiyama on the hillside where she lives, in addition to the center of Takeda City, which is a host city.
Kashin and the others found out and told Ieyasu that Saishi was connected to the host city, but Ieyasu and the others stepped into the Tsukiyama just because Nobunaga found out.
By the way, why do we fight, Sena?
On the other hand, since Ieyasu was born, this world has been full of wars.
Have you ever thought about it?
Because it's poor.
If the people suffer, they have no choice but to take it from the neighboring countries.
Then Sena said, it's not about taking it from each other, it's about giving it to each other.
If you complement each other's shortcomings in neighboring countries and connect them with the heart of self-love instead of force, there will be no war.
I think that was a good poem.
In a way, Sena talks about ideals.
The problem is whether that ideal has any meaning in the world of Sengoku.
In the first place, why did Sengoku Daimyo continue the war?
There are historians and researchers like this.
In order to protect their country from external threats and maintain peace, they chose war as a solution.
In particular, the boundaries of Ryogoku were always exposed to the threat of the enemy, and if they did not fight, it was a situation where they could only allow the invasion of the enemy.
If you don't fight and show the will to maintain peace, the country, including the fishermen, will immediately rebel.
That was the custom of the Sengoku period, and it was an indisputable reality.
Of course, Ieyasu knew that.
If he hadn't thought about why he was going to fight, he would have been destroyed by the Daimyo of the neighboring countries.
I see.
I can't say anything like Sena-sama in the drama.
However, in Ieyasu's case, both Ieyasu and Jyushin sympathized with Sena's fantasy and accepted it.
Finally, he was forced to pretend to fight with Takeda.
It's true that it's hard to believe that it's true.
Unless it's a flower garden.
In the end, Nobunaga found out that Sena and Nobuyasu were in contact with Takeda, and the two were killed.
So, what did Sena actually do?
In 1575, in the third year of the Tenshō period, Okazaki's vassals tried to welcome Takeda Katsuyori to Okazaki Castle, but found out beforehand.
It was the Okayashiro Incident.
This was a major incident that could only destroy the Tokugawa family, and in the 20th episode of Okazaki Coup d'etat,
Sena was said to be the victim, but in reality, he was one of the main killers.
Sena-sama was also one of the main killers.
Was Yoshiyuki Ashikaga really the culprit?
In addition, it is said that the depiction of the person is one-sided and shallow.
For example, who is it about?
As an example, it is the way of drawing Yoshiyuki Ashikaga, the 15th general of Muromachi, who appeared in the 13th episode of Ieyasu, going to the capital.
Yoshiyuki Ashikaga was certainly depicted as a useless general.
When Ieyasu, who landed in Kyoto, saw it, he appeared with his bloody feet while gagging, and began to sleep while talking.
In addition, it was written to the point of snoring, and Ieyasu finally got it for the last time.
He wanted a rare southern snack, Confeito Confeito, and ate it on the spot.
In other words, it can be said that he was depicted as a useless idiot.
That was terrible.
It was really like Shimura Kenka Komeda Yuka.
Ha ha ha
The reason for this was found in the 14th episode of Kanegasaki.
I think that Nobunaga worships a general like Yoshiyuki because Mikoshi is lighter.
This is because Ishikawa Kazumasa Matsushige Yutaka, the center of Ieyasu, said it, but was Yoshiyuki really a general?
In What to Do Ieyasu, it was clearly a general.
Yoshiyuki was young and ugly, but when Yoshiteru Gassen 565, who was the 13th general, was killed in A68,
Yoshiyuki continued to call for help from the leaders of various places.
As a result, after receiving Nobunaga's support, he landed in September 1568, A61, and was appointed as a general by the emperor.
All of this flow was carried out by Yoshiyuki.
Huh? I have an image that Yoshiyuki was in charge of a good job.
After that, it is said that Yoshiyuki was basically in charge of both the lowest and military people in Kyoto.
In other words, the central part of the Kinki region, which was called Tenka at that time, was not a foreign government until the confrontation with Nobunaga in 1573.
That is the common view of researchers today.
Oh? Isn't it a general who can do it?
I can't believe that Yoshiyuki, who was able to communicate with Nobunaga in this way, was a light Mikoshi who was good at expression and speech.
Certainly, in Yoshiyuki Ashikaga, who came out to Ieyasu, it is a totally impossible story.
Ministers who act in support?
Ministers who appear in Ieyasu tend to act in support.
Support?
Certainly, I feel like there were many such episodes.
In the 27th broadcast, Ieyasu made a plan.
It is Nobunaga's loyalists who get in the way of Nobunaga.
Hashiba Hideyoshi Murotsuyoshi is in China, Shibata Katsuie Yoshihara Mitsuo is in the north, etc.
Akechi Mitsuhide Sakouyoshi is in Kinai.
However, since he was just serving as Ieyasu's lord on the ground, when Mitsuhide fell in love with Yodo, Ieyasu deliberately cared about the smell.
When Nobunaga said, if you want to smell it, stop it, Mitsuhide said that it shouldn't smell, but the rest was as Ieyasu intended.
Nobunaga rebelled and turned Zen upside down and beat Mitsuhide many times.
As a result, Mitsuhide was fired from the throne and ordered the help of Hideyoshi's Mouri attack, but Mitsuhide's grudges against Nobunaga and Ieyasu piled up, and on June 2, 1582, the Honnoji incident occurred.
I couldn't stand watching that. Mitsuhide is so pitiful.
Even so, Ieyasu's plan is nonsense.
And it's also nonsense to draw such support as the cause of the Honnoji incident.
In the Edo period, there is a rumor that Mitsuhide prepared raw fish for Ieyasu's marriage, and Nobunaga killed him.
Kawasumi Taikouki is low in credibility, ha ha ha.
However, the story that Mitsuhide failed to be a strong king is not written in any reliable documents.
No matter which drama you watch, there are stories about failing to be a strong king.
Why Tokugawa Ieyasu in Taiga?
What should I do? Ieyasu is not a successful man who won the Sengoku period with his wisdom and patience, but a growing story that treats him as a weak prince who has neither military power nor child support.
Certainly, even if I look at it, I felt that it was different from other Tokugawa Ieyasu dramas.
It is expected that Tokugawa Ieyasu will continue to create a new Tokugawa Ieyasu image while saving the shaking movement of people's hearts that did not remain in history.
It may be one of the ways to enjoy Taiga dramas that is different from historical facts every time.
In that sense, the number of times it gets excited may be more than other dramas.
Ha ha ha.
I thought, but I think the current situation is more about how to do Taiga dramas than how to do Ieyasu.
In fact, Tokugawa Ieyasu has appeared in Taiga dramas 5 times in the past 10 years, and I can't underestimate the feeling of being completely out of story.
Sanada Yukimura, Akechi Mitsuhide, Ii Naotora, and Kuroda Kanbei's dramas also had Ieyasu in them.
Come to think of it, that's right.
And it's an important role that can't be left out.
Well, in the Sengoku period, Azuchi Momoyama period, Edo period, Tokugawa Ieyasu is an indispensable person.
When I heard that the main character of the Taiga drama in 2023 was Tokugawa Ieyasu,
I thought, is it Tokugawa Ieyasu again?
Isn't Taiga drama really out of story?
I think many people have realized that.
However, there is a tradition that NHK Taiga dramas cannot gain viewership unless they are based on the Sengoku period or Bakumatsu.
In that case, you can only make dramas of Sengoku or Bakumatsu.
After all, when I watch Taiga dramas, I feel that the Sengoku period and Bakumatsu are interesting.
After all, it can't be helped that Nobunaga Oda, Hideyoshi Toyotomi, and Ieyasu Tokugawa appear in Taiga dramas more often.
Taiga dramas cannot gain viewership unless they are based on the Sengoku period or Bakumatsu, so it may be over soon.
Or rather, it's not strange that Taiga dramas are out of story, so even if they end next year.
I think it won't end next year because the production has already been announced by next year.
This time, I talked about the lie of Ieyasu in Taiga dramas, but how was it?
I was surprised to find out that Ieyasu has a lot of content that is quite different from the truth.
So that's it for this explanation.
Please watch it again next time.
Please also subscribe to the channel and rate it highly.
Thank you for watching.
