-- 🔴 Check out 'The Real Story of January 6' documentary DVD here: https://ept.ms/3cxGVEO, use promo code “EpochTV” for 20% off!
🔴 "The Shadow State," a feature documentary by The Epoch Times, takes a deep dive inside the environmental, social, and governance (ESG) industry. ORDER DVD: https://ept.ms/3XxcWir
from an independent study team on Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena.
We have four speakers here today.
We have Bill Nelson, our NASA Administrator, Nikki Fox, the Associate Administrator for
the Science Mission Directorate, Dan Evans, the Assistant Deputy Associate Administrator
for Research within the Science Mission Directorate, and David Spurgill, who is the President of
the Simons Foundation, and was also the Chair of this particular independent study team.
I will ask everybody in the room to please silence your cell phones.
We will get started with everybody giving a few opening remarks, and then we will take
questions.
We will take questions both in the room and then from the phones.
And for now, I will hand it over to the Administrator.
Thanks so much, and thanks for coming today.
NASA searches for the unknown in air and space.
It's in our DNA.
From digging on Mars with the Perseverance rover in those little titanium tubes that
we intend to go back and pick up, digging in a dry lake bed near the mouth of a river,
now we're going up to the top of the cliff where the scientists feel that there could
be the best examples of if there were life there millions of years ago.
Whether we're dealing with Perseverance or the James Webb Space Telescope, which searches
for exoplanets with signs of habitability, we are looking for signs of life, past and
present.
And it's in our DNA to explore and to ask why things are the way they are.
In June of last year, NASA commissioned an independent study team to examine unidentified
anomalous phenomena.
We did so with a few goals in mind.
First to examine how NASA can use our expertise and instruments to study UAP from a scientific
perspective.
Second, shift the conversation about UAP from sensationalism to science.
And to make sure that whatever we find or whatever we recommend, to make sure that information
is shared transparently around the world.
There's a global fascination with UAP.
On my travels, one of the first questions I often get is about these sightings.
And much of that fascination is due to the unknown nature of it.
Think about it.
Most UAP sightings result in very limited data.
That makes it even more difficult to draw scientific conclusions about the nature of
UAP.
And so this independent study team brought together some of the world's leading scientists,
data and artificial intelligence experts, aerospace safety specialists, all with a specific
charge from me, which is to tell how to apply the full focus of science and data to UAP.
And this is the first time that NASA has taken concrete action to seriously look into
UAP.
And this independent study team was just that, independent.
Now NASA has a statutory authority to look for life in the universe.
And when you think of the universe and especially what we have learned from the James Webb Space
Telescope, how vast that it is, we knew before, and it was a NASA scientist, Dr. John Mather,
who got the Nobel that determined that the universe was 13.8 billion years old.
And over the years, particularly accelerated in the last century, we have an understanding
that, of course, ours is not the only galaxy.
And there are billions and billions of galaxies, and each of those galaxies, including our
own, have billions and billions of stars.
And with the James Webb looking at the exoplanets, we are now beginning to discover, and somewhere
out there, we will discover another medium-sized stony planet around a medium-sized sun or
star at just the right distance, not too far, not too close, with a tilt in its axis that
rotates, that has carbon, that will have a habitable atmosphere.
If you ask me, do I believe there's life in a universe that is so vast that it's hard
for me to comprehend how big it is, my personal answer is yes.
But I asked some of our scientists.
As a matter of fact, the Washington Post editorial board asked us to come down to the question,
what is the mathematical probability that there is life out there in the universe?
And if you calculate in billions of stars, in billions of galaxies, that there's replicated
what I just said, another stony planet, the answer was, what's the likelihood?
At least a trillion.
That's from our scientists.
So we start this without any preconceived notions, but understanding that we're in a
world of discovery.
And we have taken, we NASA, have taken for the first time concrete action to seriously
look into UAP.
And this independent study team is exactly that.
It's independent.
They work to develop recommendations about how NASA could better examine them from a
scientific perspective.
And the top takeaway from the study is that there is a lot more to learn.
The NASA independent study team did not find any evidence that UAP have an extraterrestrial
origin.
But we don't know what these UAP are.
That's why I'm announcing that NASA has appointed a NASA director of UAP research.
They are being tasked with developing and overseeing the implementation of NASA's vision
for UAP research.
We will use NASA's expertise to work with other agencies to analyze UAP.
We will use AI and machine learning to search the skies for anomalies as we have been searching
the heavens and will continue to search the heavens for habitability.
And NASA will do this transparently.
So while today is a significant step for NASA, it's certainly not our final step.
And we're going to share more with you.
And I want to introduce you to Dr. Nikki Fox, who is the head of our science mission directorate.
Nikki.
Good morning.
And thank you so much, Administrator Nelson.
It's always tough to follow Bill.
He's such a great speaker.
But I want to thank the independent study team for their amazing service on the study
and for their continued contributions towards the advancement of our nation's understanding
of unidentified anomalous phenomena.
UAP, as Bill just eloquently said, UAP are one of our planet's greatest mysteries.
And it's really due to the limited number of high quality data that surrounds such incidents
and often renders them unidentifiable.
While there are numerous eyewitness accounts and visuals associated with UAP, they're not
consistent, they're not detailed, and they're not curated observations that can be used
to make definitive scientific conclusions about the nature and the origin of UAP.
The language of scientists is data, and data points towards a scientific conclusion to
what the nature and the origin of UAP could be.
That leads us to why we're here today.
The independent study team's report is now public, and it can be found at science.nasa.gov
slash UAP.
While NASA is still working to evaluate the report and to assess the independent study
team's findings and recommendations, NASA is committed to immediately contributing to
the federal government's unified UAP effort.
And as you heard, we have appointed a director of UAP research.
In their role, they will centralize communications, resources, and data analytical capabilities
across the federal government to establish a robust database for the evaluation of any
future data.
Additionally, our director of UAP research will also leverage NASA's expertise in artificial
intelligence, machine learning, and space-based observation tools that will support and enhance
the broader government initiative into UAP.
They will serve as NASA's point of contact for government entities, but especially for
the All Domain Anomaly Resolution Office, or ARRO.
And this will ensure our coordinated efforts and effective communication channels.
Beyond our director of UAP research, NASA will also advance citizen reporting by working
with the public and commercial pilots to collect a broader set of data to add to the vast data
repositories to not only contribute to a broader, more reliable data set for future UAP incidents,
but to also contribute to the destigmatization of the important study of UAPs.
And with that, it is my great pleasure to hand over to Dr. Dan Evans, who is the NASA
official responsible for supporting this amazing study.
Good morning.
I'd like to begin by expressing my sincere thanks to NASA Administrator Bill Nelson for
directing this study.
We at NASA believe that understanding UAP is vital for several reasons.
First and foremost, it provides an opportunity for us to expand our understanding of the
world around us.
At NASA, we are committed to charting the uncharted.
So this work aligns with who we are.
Secondly, this study aims to enhance situational awareness.
The presence of UAP raises serious concerns about the safety of our skies, and it's this
nation's obligation to determine whether these phenomena pose any potential risks to
airspace safety.
Let's not forget that the first A in NASA is aeronautics.
So by understanding the nature of UAP, we can ensure that our skies remain a safe space
for all.
Administrator Nelson directed us to put together an independent and external team of world-leading
experts to produce a report containing a roadmap with a series of recommendations that
describe how NASA could best help in the cross-government response to UAP.
Months of meticulous fact-finding, cross-disciplinary collaboration, and scientific rigor gave the
team insights that will greatly enhance our nation's understanding of UAP going forward.
The team's report, now available on NASA's website, stands as a testament to NASA's and
the team's commitment to transparency, to the power of science, and to the unwavering
quest for knowledge.
We at NASA believe that studying UAP represents an exciting step forward in our journey to
uncover the mysteries of the world around us.
By embracing a scientific lens, we have ensured that our work is evidence-based and data-driven,
and by valuing transparency and openness, we have aimed to foster trust and collaboration
with the public.
I'd like to conclude by extending my deepest gratitude to the team for their incredible
dedication and service.
Their efforts have been instrumental, and I truly appreciate the expertise and commitment
that each of them have brought to this endeavor.
And with that, I'll pass over to Dr. David Spurgill, who chaired our study.
First and foremost, I'd like to extend our sincere gratitude to the NASA Administrator
for entrusting us with this pivotal study.
Your faith in our capabilities has been a driving force behind the panel's approach.
The panel's comprehensive study into unidentified anomalous phenomena, or UAP, has led to several
crucial findings, and I'd like to elucidate on our methodology and those findings this morning.
We began by rigorously assessing the current state of UAP data.
Our goal was not to repeat the work of the Arrow, but to understand the nature of the reports.
Our goal was to produce a roadmap for NASA to contribute to the understanding of the
nature of UAP events.
We looked at NASA's assets.
While they provide a comprehensive picture of the ocean, the Earth's surface and atmosphere
for studying our evolving planet, they typically do not have the resolution needed for UAP events.
However, by providing data on environmental conditions, they can complement other data on UAP.
The current approach to UAP data collection has led to a limited sample of events and
limited data.
Stigma has limited reporting by pilots, both civilian and military, so we know there's
missing data.
For its analysis in other areas, NASA always takes a scientific approach of systematic
data collection that involves calibrating instruments, multiple measurements, and ensuring
sensor metadata.
Most UAP events lack this quality of data.
One of NASA's contributions to the broader governmental effort to bring these methodologies
to create a data set is to bring these methodologies to create a data set that's both reliable
and extensive.
And once we have a large sample of well-characterized events, AI and ML tools, which are proving
to be powerful in so many other applications, will likely prove helpful in identifying
interesting anomalies.
It is essential to clarify, based on our current findings and methodology, that we
find no evidence to suggest that UAP are extraterrestrial in origin.
Our focus in understanding the phenomenon, however, regardless of the source, and previous
work from the IRO, has shown that most events are explainable as planes, balloons, drones,
weather phenomenon, and instrument features.
And in any search for interesting anomalies, the first step is to eliminate the chaff of
conventional events before moving on to identify novel phenomena.
In this, the public's role cannot be overstated.
The panel envisioned a framework that leverages crowdsourcing, possibly via smartphone applications,
to capture a broader spectrum of data, ensuring more eyes and ears on the ground.
Lastly, we delved into the safety concerns UAP present within U.S. airspace.
By integrating UAP collection within our current aviation reporting system, the panel believes
we can provide insights into potential safety risks.
NASA can reduce the stigma associated with pilots reporting anomalies.
And fundamentally, by studying events we don't understand, we advance our understanding.
So in conclusion, with a rigorous methodology, collaborative efforts, public engagement,
NASA can be a key player in the whole-of-government approach to understanding UAP.
Thank you.
Thank you so much to all of our speakers.
We will start taking questions.
For those in the room, we have a microphone over here that we would ask you to speak into.
We will also be alternating with questions from those on the phone line.
For those of you who are in the phone line, please press star 1 to get onto the queue.
We will try to answer as many as we can today.
We'll see how it goes.
Please, sir.
Thank you very much.
This is directed to Mr. Nelson.
Thank you for being here.
Two quick questions.
One is, how can we make the determination of what something isn't when we don't know
what it is?
And B, after a careful review of the data, if it's determined that some, underline the
word some, 10 times, UFOs or UAP originate from a non-human intelligence, what's the
plan to disclose that to the public?
And can you identify yourself, please?
James Fox.
Thank you.
I'm sorry, on what outlet?
Independent media.
Well, let me repeat.
It's on.
Let me repeat what I said.
I think it's important that you hear this word for word.
The NASA independent study team did not find any evidence that UAP have an extraterrestrial
origin, but we don't know what these UAP are.
The mission of NASA is to find out the unknown.
I've said several times in my comments here today that we, NASA, deal openly and we will
be transparent on this.
And we're trying to address the question of there's so much concern that there's something
locked up, classified, and that the American government is not being open.
Well, we are the American government and we are open and we're going to be open about
this.
We don't, again, I'm going to repeat that statement, but we don't know what these UAP
are, but we're going to try to find out.
Thank you very much.
And is there a plan in place, if it is determined that some of them represent or originate from
a non-human intelligence, to tell the public?
Is there a plan?
If we are what I said we intend to be, which is transparent, you bet your boots.
We will say that.
And I've tried to set the table for you by telling you what I personally believe in a
universe that is so vast that could there be a replication of life on Earth elsewhere
in another solar system that is so big?
Of course I believe that.
The distances, it would have to be a very advanced civilization.
The distances, you know, light years, hundreds of light years, billions of light years.
But whatever we find, we're going to tell you.
Thank you very much.
Great.
And we'll move on to the next question.
Please do identify yourself.
Thanks.
This is Joey Roulette from Reuters.
Question for Bill Nelson or any of the other panelists.
So you've appointed a director of UAP research.
Have you named someone to that role?
And what kind of investment are you considering making in this?
Is this going to be a new program office?
Have you thought of funding figures, et cetera?
Thanks.
Yes, we have.
We've already appointed the person.
They've been working there for a while now, like during the study, to help be a point
of contact.
And any budget discussions, of course, are part of a very intricate federal budget request,
and so they're not something that we discuss openly.
But we will certainly look at what resources need to be allocated.
Can you name the official who's in the room?
We will not give his name out, no.
Okay.
Thanks.
Thank you.
We'll take another one from in the room.
Hello.
I'm Dan Rivers from British Broadcaster ITV News.
I heard the word stigma mentioned several times, that you want to remove the stigma.
Is your message to pilots and other people that this is no longer the preserve of cranks
and that you won't be laughed at and that you will take them seriously?
Is that the takeaway?
That is exactly the message.
I mean, at NASA, we're scientists.
We love data.
We love all data.
But if there is something that needs to be reported, we want people to be able to feel
that they can report that.
We spoke in the open hearing that we had here just a few months ago.
Dan, remind me when it was.
May 31st.
And we actually talked then about we wanted to remove the stigma, and we also did not
tolerate any of the abuse that some of our members of the panel were receiving, particularly
on social media, for doing this really important scientific study.
So, absolutely.
We want pilots and both, as Bill said, both private pilots, commercial pilots, military
pilots to feel that if they see something, they need to report it.
I want to say, and I want to repeat the way I said it.
We want to shift the conversation about UAPs from sensationalism to science.
I think of this in terms of the signs we see around for security, which say, if you
see something, say something.
I think in this context, we would summarize it as, if you see something, collect high
quality data on it, because then we can learn.
If I may, I just noticed in the report, the GoFast incident was one that was picked out
and that had been held up as an example of a very credible sighting that you seem to
be pouring doubt on.
Can you just talk to that?
We looked at that as one example, and I think this is something that Arrow has actually
done a very good job of going through the events, and most events are going to turn
out, even if there are some events that in the end turn out to be something novel, most
events are going to turn out to be conventional things, balloons, airplanes, and so on.
I think of the process of discovery of anomalies as looking for a needle in a haystack, and
if you want to find a needle in a haystack, you've got two choices.
Either you know exactly what the needle looks like, and you design a very good filter to
look for the needle.
It's called match filtering in sort of AI work, machine learning and state of processing.
You don't know what you're looking for, and with anomalies, that's really the case we're
in.
We're looking for things we don't understand.
So if you want to find something strange in a haystack, you better know exactly what hay
looks like, and you better be able to characterize that really well.
And that's why in a process like this, and this is something that I think we bring to
this as we look for anomalies, is you need to know what typical regular things look like
under all conditions.
You need to know what balloons look like when pilots see them, so under usual conditions,
so that you can eliminate those events.
And that's why in identifying anomalies, understanding the normal is a very important part of it,
and understanding that under different observing conditions, and collecting data in a uniform
way.
And this is what we do when we study anomalies in space science, or other areas of science,
and what we're trying to do is bring this approach to this field by saying collect high
quality data, understand the normal events, and that's how we move things forward.
Thank you.
We'll move on to the next question, please.
Hello, I'm Nomia Iqbal from BBC News.
Just to follow up on the stigma question, UAP, that term has been used in part to de-stigmatize
UFOs.
The fact is, most people use UFOs, most of the American public, most of the world use
that term.
So I wonder how much is the stigma still a problem for you, and what are you practically
doing about it, really, to convince people?
And my second question, in your report, I noticed that you said AI is a very essential
tool for identifying rare occurrences.
Yesterday, we were at this big AI summit, where you had 100 senators meeting all the
big tech tycoons, Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, and, you know, speaking to some senators afterwards,
they said we are concerned about AI, we need it to be regulated.
Does that concern you?
Are you worried that it might hamper your work?
Thank you very much.
Well, two big questions.
First of all, do I personally believe that AI needs to have some boundaries?
The answer to that, for our existentialism, yes.
Can you do that within the appropriate bounds, so that, as I said in my remarks, that we're
going to utilize AI as one of the tools as we search for what is an answer to the UAP?
And so, no, I don't think that any attempts to, that the Congress has underway to try
to write a law that would appropriately put guardrails around AI for other reasons is
in any way going to inhibit us from utilizing the tools of AI to help us in our quest on
this specific issue.
Now, what was your other question?
Just how do you de-stigmatize the whole thing?
Because I know you call it UAPs, but, you know, people don't refer it to in that way.
Yeah.
Well, you know, there's a mindset.
We all are entertained by Indiana Jones in the Amazon and finding the crystal skull.
So there's a lot of folklore out there.
That's why we entered the stage, the arena, to try to get into this from a science point.
I think you can blame the X-Files for a lot of this as well.
That possibly too, but just remember what I said.
We, NASA, are trying to shift it from sensationalism to science.
Okay.
Thank you very much.
Yes, ma'am.
And we do have a long line in the room, but I want to give a couple chances to some people
on the phone line.
So I'm going to go to the phone for our first question there.
Please do introduce yourself and ask a question on the phone.
Can you hear me?
Our first question is from Marsha Dunn with the Associated Press.
Your line is open.
Yes.
Hi.
Marsha Dunn, AP.
I'm already receiving emails on Area 51 in Roswell, so I would like to ask Mr. Spurkle,
how much were you and your fellow panel members hassled or bombarded by this sort of thing
during the course of your study?
And for NASA, are you not naming the director of UAP research for this very reason so that
they're not hassled and bombarded by the fringe element?
Thanks.
I would divide emails and tweets into two types.
There's some where people honestly are curious about things they've seen, they've heard.
There are things that are hard to respond to, like my uncle who's dead saw something
strange, and you get a report.
That's not useful, but that's harmless.
On the other hand, one of the things that happened during the study, and this may be
part of a bigger discussion of cultural behavior on social media, where people behave badly,
and I would say harassed some of our panel members, and that I think was very inappropriate
behavior, behavior one doesn't want to see.
Sadly, I think it's part of a deeper problem when people somehow feel on the web, on social
media, they can be nasty and hostile, and sadly, some of our panel members experience
that.
Yeah, I would just simply add to that to say that not only were some of the things that
our panel members received during the course of this study simple trolling, some of them
actually rose to actual threats.
And as a result, we at NASA take the sanctity of the scientific process and the security
and safety of our team extremely seriously, and yes, that's in part why we are not splashing
the name of our new director out there, because science needs to be free.
Science needs to undergo a real and rigorous and rational process, and you need the freedom
of thought to be able to do that.
Some of the threats and the harassment have been beyond the pale, quite frankly, towards
some of our panelists, and yes, it's important that science be free as part of that process.
Thank you so much.
We will go to another question on the phone, please.
Please go ahead and introduce yourself.
Our next question comes from Tom Clark with Sky News London.
Your line is open.
Oh, hi there.
Thank you very much for taking my question.
I want to understand whether and how much, you won't give us an idea of money, but how
many assets or new research programs will be devoted to this by the administration.
Because it strikes me that although the argument for aviation safety is clear, there are other
departments and agencies responsible for that particular thing.
And as the report concludes, the likelihood of there being extraterrestrial explanations
or truly scientific explanations for many of these phenomena is very, very small.
Shouldn't NASA devote its research budgets and its efforts to those much more likely
and tangible signs of extraterrestrial life through things like the JPLF space telescope
or extrasolar planet detection?
Yeah, thank you for that question.
So yes, obviously we don't discuss budget openly, but we are committed to supporting
the whole of government study into UAP.
All of our data are open.
In fact, if you look at the report, you'll see a very large sort of background material
or supplemental material in there.
Because we literally released everything, because that's what we do at NASA.
We do have our key agency goals.
We have obviously our goals in the science mission directorate, our themes that we follow.
And one of those, as the administrator described, is the search for life elsewhere.
And we do that, and he described the research beautifully.
I think he may be going for my job, actually.
He described the research so well that what we need to find is a rocky planet around a
hospitable star that isn't too violent, that is in just that right place, that has signatures
of water and signatures of carbon, so the bouldering blocks of life.
And we continue to strive to do that.
We do that with the James Webb telescope.
We'll be doing that when we launch the Nancy Grace Roman telescope that even has a coronagraph
around it to block out the light of the neighboring stars and really let us look at those possible
planets.
And then beyond that, the next big telescope recommended by the astrophysics decadal is
the Habitable Worlds Observatory, actually a mission designed to look for hospitable
and find like Earth 2.0 in another stellar system.
And so they really are in the forefront of our goals at NASA.
So thanks so much for the question.
Just to jump in to clarify something, will you be devoting any new resource or research
projects to this particular area, given that's where the interesting questions really are,
should we spend, should NASA spend time and budget pursuing the much less likely task
of finding signs of extraterrestrial life in small objects within or close to the Earth's
atmosphere?
I mean, most of our, obviously our instruments are designed to look for the phenomena that
we study at NASA.
If any of our data are useful, if any of our data are applicable, then we absolutely will
be devoting that and turning that over through our liaison to the whole of government approach.
We are not at this time intending to design a mission to do this.
That is not part of our kind of overarching NASA direction.
We are looking at providing some research support.
So if somebody wants to write a research proposal, send it in through the regular channels.
We will be looking for ways to do that.
And we also talked about supporting sort of the citizen science and the broader like repository
of data.
Dan, do you want to add to that?
NASA's data are free and publicly accessible for the entire world to download.
And we pride ourselves on that fact.
And it's this openness of data and our approach, which is why we're all here today.
To answer your specific question about devoting research budgets to the potentially truly
interesting ones, well, I think as David said, you have to understand the chaff in order
to really understand and pinpoint the potentially interesting ones.
So we are in such a data poor regime at the moment that we need to turn it into a data
rich one to do that.
We employ NASA's assets, many other partners' assets as well in that quest.
And if your question suggests, and I do not know that it does, but if it suggests that
NASA ought to keep its nose out of this, well, let me tell you, NASA is not a place that's
going to hide its head in the sand.
Now, is there interest in this phenomenon in other agencies?
In my previous life in the Senate, I was privy to talk to the Navy pilots and to see the
video of what they encountered off the coast of California in 2004.
That was in a classified setting then.
But this is now.
And you have now seen that video.
And you have heard from those former Navy pilots.
Is that of a concern to the Department of Defense?
Of course it is.
And therefore, we're going to continue our search from a scientific point of view.
It's going to be, if those other agencies continue their search, we're going to be glad
to join in with them.
But our stuff is going to be open.
Great.
I'm going to take one more from the phone before we go back to the floor.
We have a lot of questions.
I'm going to hope we can stick to sort of one per person and see how many we can get
through.
So one more from the phone, please.
Our next question comes from Jeff Faust with Space News.
Your line is open.
Hi.
I know the press release states that NASA is still evaluating the independent study
team's report and its recommendations.
Does NASA plan to publish a formal response to the report and its recommendations?
And if so, what timeline can we expect to see that?
So let me give you a quick preview about how this works.
So we have only very, very recently received the report.
And what you have seen today in our press release represents our initial actions in
recognition of the urgency of this matter.
And yes, we will be following up as appropriate with additional actions.
But of course, we need additional time to fully ingest the recommendations and act on
them in light of budget and many other priorities.
But we'll be announcing more in the future.
Great.
Thank you.
Please, back to the room.
Identify yourself, too, please.
Good morning.
Sam Cabral with BBC News Digital.
We've been talking a lot about this shift from sensationalism to science today.
Has NASA been in touch with the Mexican authorities about the rather sensational revelations earlier
this week of two allegedly non-human corpses?
And what of any importance do you attach to these discoveries?
I think David had to prep for that one.
Well, you know, this is something that I know I've only seen on Twitter.
So it's, you know, when you have unusual things, you want to make data public.
I think of this as like NASA has one of the most valuable samples from outer space, lunar
rocks.
What do we do?
We make them available to any scientists who want to work on this.
We don't know the nature of those samples that were shown in front of them.
If I was the Mexican government, I would write our banking recommendations to the Mexican
government.
That's not our charge here.
We're doing this for NASA.
My recommendation was if you have something strange, make samples available to the world
scientific community and we'll see what's there.
I'll just add that one of the main goals of what we're trying to do here today is to move
conjecture and conspiracy towards science and sanity.
And you do that with data, as David says.
And that's the whole purpose of this study and this roadmap.
Thank you.
Hi, Brandy Vincent from Defense Scoop.
Thank you all for doing this.
I actually have two lines of questions, if it's okay.
First for Ms. Fox, what's the timeline and immediate actions that NASA is pursuing specifically
with Aero now that the report has been completed?
And what mechanisms are NASA and DOD really using to share information and collaborate
securely?
And do you see more coming?
And then separately for Mr. Spergel, I noticed in the final report, a lot of the images and
media that were added were from DOD, snapshots that we'd previously seen from DOD data.
Not much from FAA, if anything, not from other agencies.
Can you speak to why that is and what all you used beyond DOD to inform your report?
Dr. Fox, Dr. Spergel, I'll pass it to you guys.
Sure.
So yes, our immediate actions, I think there was such a lot in those questions.
So the immediate actions we've established are our director of UAP research.
They're working across the whole of government.
They're working very closely with Aero.
They are the sort of central point for all of the collaboration.
I'm not sure what else you asked, I'm sorry.
What mechanisms are you using to share data and information with the Defense Department?
All mechanisms available to us.
As Dan eloquently said, all of our data are open and public.
So actually, I mean, we share everything with everybody.
So everybody can access our NASA data.
I mean, do you have like a specific repository or mechanism or channel specifically with
DOD where you're sharing information?
Can you just expand a little on how Aero and NASA are working so deeply to share things?
Sure.
Do you want to take that?
Yeah, sure.
I'm happy to handle that.
So as Nikki beautifully said, all of NASA's data is open and accessible to the public.
If DOD on a specific instance need to tap our expertise, then there are obviously secure
ways of doing that.
And we've done that by appointing our liaison officer.
And yes, we know how to talk to DOD in a classified space.
But again, most of what we do is unclassified and for good reason.
And the answer is actually straightforward.
That Aero is the lead agency in the government.
So FAA reported events go to Aero.
So they're the central collection agency.
And that actually, if you go to the Aero site, they have a pretty complete list of things
they've analyzed and are trying to make public.
Though with Aero, and this is just something I think is worth repeating in the context
of looking at images that come from military satellites intelligence community, it's important
to remember that images taken by military instruments are classified, not because of
what's in the image, but because of the nature of the measuring instrument.
And I think this is one of the unique things that NASA brings here, is NASA is about openness
and transparency.
When NASA makes measurements, NASA has, across all of it does, this program of making its
data open and available.
And of course, it's not making measurements with classified instruments that enables it
to do this.
And that's one of the things that NASA brings to this space.
Thank you.
And just a really quick clarification, because I think it's important, the NASA Aero liaison,
is that official the same as your new UAP head of research?
Yes.
Okay.
Thank you.
All right.
One more in the room before we go back to the phones for a couple.
Thank you.
My name is Jacob Jensen.
I work for a Danish newspaper called Berlinski.
My question is for Mr. Nelson.
You said at the beginning of the meeting that NASA will be transparent.
Well, a month and a half ago, Mr. David Grush said under oath in Congress that the U.S.
government is in possession of UAPs and extraterrestrial life.
How can you be sure at NASA that other parts of the U.S. government is being transparent?
I don't speak for other parts of the government, but I can tell you NASA, which I speak for,
is open and transparent with our data.
Do you believe what Mr. David Grush said, or is he lying?
You would want me to give a personal opinion of what he said.
What he said, if I recall having seen this on the nightly news, was that he had a friend
that knew where a warehouse was that had a UFO locked up in a warehouse.
He also said he had another friend that said that he had parts of an alien.
Whatever he said, where's the evidence, is my response.
He also said that he did interview over 40 employees at the Pentagon.
Long time ago there was a TV show, Jack Friday, and he used to say, just the facts, just the
facts.
Show me the evidence.
Thank you, sir.
All right, we will go to the phones again.
I know people have lots of questions, but I'm going to try to keep us to just to one
for each person.
And so next person on the phone, go ahead and introduce yourself.
Next question comes from Gina Ciceri with ABC News.
Your line is open.
This is for Senator Nelson.
Your report mentioned that AI could be very useful in helping in this investigation.
How do you see that, sir?
Well, why limit us in anything in interpretation of data?
And AI is just coming on the scene to be explored in all areas.
So why should we limit any technological tool in analyzing data that we have?
I said AI was one of the things that we were going to employ.
I mean, we actually we use AI or artificial intelligence and machine learning throughout
our NASA science portfolio.
It is an amazing tool for helping us to actually find often signatures that signatures that
are sort of buried in data.
And so a lot of our data are just sort of wiggly line plots.
We get excited about wiggly line plots, by the way.
But sometimes you see the wiggles and you miss a signal in there.
And by using artificial intelligence, we can often find signatures.
So one example we've had is to be able to find signatures of super storms using very
old data that really is before sort of like routine scientific satellite data.
And it's amazing.
And so just being able to use those techniques often can allow us to find things to actually
find the needle.
As David so eloquently said, once you've actually really...
It also helps us to really characterize the hay.
And so you can start subtracting the hay and look for the needles behind.
So let me just take this moment to say to try demystify AI and ML.
Thank you.
So when, as scientists, and probably many of you in high school were trained to do this,
we had some data.
You took your data, you drew a graph, you put a line through it.
You had data in two dimensions, X and Y.
Right now, much of our data is in a much higher dimensional space.
And if you're working with something like Chats GPT, it's in a high dimensional space
of language or tokens, if you want to get technical with 12,000 tokens in the Chats
GPT 3.5, for example.
And machine learning is a powerful tool for representing functions in high dimensional
space.
That means we get to work with data in a high dimensional space.
AI is very powerful, but it's no more powerful than the data you give it.
It's a way of...
We've got...
This is why it's very powerful, say, with NASA's weather and climate data.
We've got an incredible amount of data.
And it's data that you want to do more with than just put a line on a graph.
You want to extract all that information or more information in that high dimensional
space.
And I think we're just really discovering the power of that tool.
And it's one of the tools NASA and, you know, not just scientists, but I think a lot of
people in a lot of different industries are using to learn new things about high dimensional
data.
And it always comes back to the data you feed into your analysis, whether it's a line on
a graph paper or a high dimensional space explored with machine learning.
And if you don't got good data, you're not going to learn things.
I'm going to add one sentence.
Sorry.
High dimensional does not mean high space dimensions, not interdimensional travel.
We're talking about multiple parameters here.
Okay.
All right.
Great.
We are coming close to time.
I want to get two more questions, and we're going to do one on the phone and one more
in the room.
And hopefully if we keep our questions short and our answers short, we'll get to those
two.
For anybody who's here who hasn't had a chance to ask a question, you are more than welcome
to send an email, and we will try to get you questions as answers as quickly as possible.
So one more on the phone, please.
Yes.
Our next question comes from Peggy Holliger with Financial Times.
Your line is open.
Thank you very much.
And thank you for allowing me to ask a question.
I'm curious about you saying here that you want to work in crowdsourcing, but also you
speak specifically about the potential of using commercial assets as well as your own.
And I'm curious about, can you just give me a bit more detail how you will do that?
Will that be through commercial contracts, or will you ask for voluntary reporting for
citing?
And also, I think that's a good question.
I think that's a good question.
So you talk a lot about the importance of center, I'm going to use the word harmonization,
because there's no kind of harmonization between the way the centers work.
Presumably, that would be the same for the use of commercial assets.
How does that use of commercial assets and crowdsourcing square with the center harmonization
that you talk about?
And who's going to pay for all this?
Thank you.
So let me just say a little bit about crowdsourcing.
Much of what we have in mind is taking advantage of the fact that there's several billion of
these floating around.
I'm holding up a cell phone for those on the radio.
They take high quality images, have high quality metadata, record local magnetic field, sound,
gravitational field.
There's a wealth of data that a cell phone takes.
And you can imagine designing apps that make the images relatively tamper-free.
You can at least make it hard to do.
And I think if we have a collection where interesting events are collected by citizens,
hosted, and you have multiple images of the same event, we'll be able to learn a lot.
And one of the things NASA supports is citizen science.
And I think that the idea that if you see something you don't understand, collect data,
we aggregate the data and we learn from it, is important in this context.
And just, I think, in some ways, an opportunity to engage the broader public in doing science.
Great.
Our last question, please, from the floor.
Thank you all for doing this.
Joe Khalil with News Nation.
My first question is, you've described harassment of some of the panelists.
While that is horrible and never a good thing, it does sort of come with the nature of public officials.
You know, Mr. Nelson, as Senator, lawmakers get that kind of thing all the time.
Is that the justification for keeping this new position, Director of UAP Research, private?
Do you plan on doing that forever?
Is that a temporary thing?
Because it seems to cut against the dedication to being open and transparent if this person forever is not going to be revealed,
their identity, who they are.
Yeah, okay.
So, at the time, yes, we are withholding that name.
Let's not forget that we've only just received this report.
And what we need to do now as an agency is come together and provide a cohesive and coherent response to it
that addresses multiple findings and recommendations, okay?
We're only announcing initial actions today.
Will that person's name be disclosed to answer your specific question?
Potentially, yes.
But, again, we need to ensure that the scientific process and method is free, okay?
That's my response.
And just lastly, the report says that you relied on unclassified material.
You've given a very understandable description for why the DOD classifies certain images and videos.
Why did you all not have access to classified material?
And could you have, you know, done that?
I have.
So just understand that.
Let the committee speak for themselves.
So one of the reasons that we restricted ourselves, this study, to unclassified data is because we can speak openly about it.
And in so doing, we're aiming, again, to alter the discourse from sensationalism to science, as Administrator Nelson beautifully said.
NASA personnel, as appropriate, know how to talk to DOD on a classified basis.
But the purpose of this study was to tell us what open data we could use, in combination with the power of science, to move our understanding forward, okay?
That was the purpose, and we're speaking about it openly today.
And so one of the challenges you talked about...
And I'm afraid we do have to wrap up.
We are at time.
So thank you, everybody, for being here today.
Again, for those people who were not able to get questions, I do apologize for not doing it in the room.
However, please send an e-mail based on our press release.
You will have information to access, and we will try to get you the answers we can.
And with that, we are concluding today's press briefing, and thank you very much for being here.
Thank you.