Quan chức Mỹ lạc quan, Ukraina sẽ có đợt tấn công quan trọng nhất, Nga đang dần bị động?

Đại Kỷ Nguyên - Bình luận
4.1K người theo dõi
199 Lượt xem video·26 thg 9, 2023
------------
Quan chức Mỹ lạc quan, Ukraina sẽ có đợt tấn công quan trọng nhất, Nga đang dần bị động?
The U.S. officials are optimistic that Ukraine will have the most important attack, Russia is gradually moving away from it.
In September, Ukraine's counterattack continued to have explosions on both sides of the field, the east and the south, and even moved very close to the Russian military's main defense line in the Zaporizhzhya region, south of Ukraine.
Analysts believe that the Ukrainian army can carry out a direct attack at any time.
This could become the most fierce and important battle since Ukraine officially counterattacked.
The fact that Ukraine broke through the Russian military's southern defense line may be coming close. The Russian military is becoming extremely passive.
How does Guzakdai evaluate Ukraine's progress?
After three months of slow progress to the point of discomfort, Ukraine's counterattack is gaining momentum.
Near the southern village of Robotin, the Ukrainian army broke through the first defense line of three Russian defense lines. Now they are attacking the second defense line.
Chen Mon, Director of Analysis of the US Defense Intelligence Agency DIA, said in an interview with The Economist in early September that
if we had this conversation two weeks ago, I would be a little more pessimistic. Their breakthrough, the Ukrainian army on the second defense line, is really quite remarkable.
So, can Ukraine overcome it and defend the third line before the artillery becomes scarce and the winter is over?
The work of the DIA, where Mr. Mon works, is less well-known than the CIA, which performs military measures against US enemies.
This is often questioned, but the assessment is positive, such as the range of Iranian missiles or the size of China's fleet.
But the invisible is equally important. Mr. Mon emphasizes that the will to fight is an important and straightforward factor.
He admitted that his agency made a mistake in Iraq in 2014 and Afghanistan in 2021, where the US-built army collapsed almost overnight.
Mr. Mon said, we think the Afghans will fight until the end of the year and try to defend Kabul heroically.
Instead, basically, they withdrew quite quickly.
That experience, along with the withdrawal of the Iraqi army when facing the Islamic State group,
has made the DIA have to change many times when assessing how Ukraine will act when Russia invades last year.
He said, we also have similar thoughts on the paper that they will be overwhelmed.
Mr. Mon published a 40-page trade journal in January this year, in which he reviewed how the agency measured the will to fight of a country.
The report emphasized the national factors, such as Volodymyr Zelensky's determination to stay in Kyiv,
compared to the decision to flee Kabul of Ashraf Ghani, can affect the war.
It points to the importance of leadership on the front lines, the spirit of the army, the command and control of the army,
and whether the army has long-term medical and logistics support.
Such things have been ignored because people think that now the Ukrainian leadership will be overwhelmed and defeated quickly.
To prevent that mistake, DIA analysts have to go into a detailed table to help them think carefully about these factors
and how they can act in an unexpected way.
This method is very important when evaluating the coming weeks in Ukraine.
Mr. Mon said that DIA will monitor indicators that show that Russia can maintain the supply of artillery to the front
and maintain a leadership role at the local level.
He admitted that U.S. and Ukrainian officials did not assess Russia's high level of defense
and how difficult it would be for Ukraine to crush them with armored vehicles.
Ukrainian generals told The Guardian that 80% of Russia's efforts are for the construction of the first and second lines,
but Mr. Mon warned that most of Russia's troops are still in the third line.
In recent weeks, U.S. officials have secretly criticized Ukrainian commanders for their military strategy,
especially the decision to deploy units with experience in the east around Bakhmut,
instead of on the southern outpost of Tenchot.
Mr. Mon is more clever.
He said that there is still a debate as to whether Ukrainians have developed a strategy
that he hopes will achieve more positive benefits in a shorter period of time or not.
More importantly, the two important variables, Ukraine's ammunition storage,
are very important to maintain the artillery to create conditions for progress,
and the weather becomes warmer in the autumn.
An official of Mr. Biden's administration said that Ukraine only had about six to seven weeks to fight
before the attack reached its peak, and then retreated.
There were differences in the extent to which progress could be achieved during that time.
Some people believe that the Ukrainian army had evacuated most of the reserve forces
before the second line collapsed and suffered heavy casualties when trying to collapse it,
so they could not move on.
Mr. Mon is less pessimistic.
He noted that Sergei Sorovikin, the Russian general who built the defense lines,
and Evgeny Prigozhin, the leader of the Wagner mercenaries,
have achieved the most significant victories for Russia over the past year,
have all left the battlefield.
The former was evacuated, and the latter died in a plane crash.
Mr. Mon cautiously chose his own words, saying that Ukraine's recent successes
are noteworthy and bring their forces a real possibility,
with a 40-50% chance of breaking Russia's remaining lines by the end of the year.
The Ukrainian army's most fierce direct attack is coming.
In less than three months, the Ukrainian army will first need to conquer a few lines
of defense of the Russian army on the battlefield,
and only then will it be able to break through the entire line of defense of the Russian army.
On September 24, according to the Ukrainian General Staff,
Kyiv's forces advanced near the village of Vekbop in Zaporizhia,
and the Ukrainian army is also moving to the south,
to the city of Tokmak, a Russian town.
The ISW war research institute used the word
a tactical breakthrough in Vekbop, although it said the situation was still unstable.
The Ukrainian General Staff said on Sunday, September 24,
that the Ukrainian forces were pressuring the enemy and strengthening their positions
when talking about the advances in the occupied city of Melitopol.
In early September, the Ukrainian army revealed that
in the main attack direction in the southern region of Zaporizhia,
the lines of defense that their troops had to face were not as many as before,
and the thickest lines of defense had probably been cleared.
Over the past week, the war between Russia and Ukraine has become fierce.
The Ukrainian army is gradually approaching the second line of defense of the Russian army,
also known as the main line of defense.
In front of the main line of defense, there are usually minefields,
but the Russian soldiers also often leave retreat routes for themselves,
so not everywhere there are mines.
However, there will be obstacles, such as anti-tank and anti-aircraft guns in front,
to prevent the Ukrainian armored forces from advancing quickly.
The latest conditions show that the Ukrainian troops have reached the main line of defense of Russia.
There are many different signs that show that Ukraine can carry out a direct attack
on the main line of defense of the Russian army at any time.
The main line of defense of the Russian army is strictly guarded,
including thick minefields, some fortified fortifications and fortified posts
with weapons and can call for artillery support from behind.
If the Ukrainian army wants to penetrate this main line of defense,
it can be said that this will be a direct attack,
which is very likely to become a model of a modern offensive war,
with the risk of heavy casualties for both sides.
Recent intelligence information shows that the firepower of the Ukrainian artillery
has been able to cover the firepower of the Russian artillery
and is beginning to have some advantages in the ability to counter artillery.
Anti-aircraft radar and Excalibur smart artillery
provided by the U.S. military will play an increasingly important role.
This provides strong support to support the attack of the Ukrainian army.
The Ukrainian military's 2M artillery and missile systems
can also carry out massive attacks on the defense lines of the Russian army,
causing serious damage to the Russian military's radar equipment
while effectively blocking the use of Russian anti-tank weapons.
When large-scale armored vehicles of the Ukrainian army
begin to attack close range,
they will also use heavy firepower to fire continuously
in order to continue to occupy positions of the Russian army.
If the Ukrainian army clears the plain,
blocks the enemy, and breaks through the line of fire in time and effectively,
the armored forces will quickly move to the positions of the Russian army.
The Russian army can be captured or driven away.
The casualties of the Ukrainian army will also decrease a lot.
Even when the Ukrainian army can effectively limit the firepower of the Russian artillery,
large-scale attacks by the armored forces are still at great risk.
As long as the anti-tank mine is activated,
the vehicle can be intercepted and cannot move forward.
If it is temporarily blocked by a missile or an obstacle,
it will become a target for the Russian army's anti-tank weapons.
The Ukrainian army is probably getting ready for action,
trying to break through the main defense line of the Russian army in one fell swoop.
The Russian defense line soldiers may have to go through every day of worry,
and they are also trying to improve their combat ability.
The real victory of the Ukrainian army lies in how to achieve strategic goals
at a low cost or can be accepted.
The Russian army must try to avoid complete collapse.
Ukraine can launch a full-scale attack at any time.
Meanwhile, the Russian army is strengthening the defense line
and at the same time has to start building a new defense line behind the main defense line.
The Russian military command should realize
that the Ukrainian army's breakthrough is just a matter of time.
Behind the main defense line of Russia are command posts,
communication points, warehouses, artillery positions.
The defense force will be weak,
difficult to prevent the attack of the Ukrainian armored forces.
The Russian army will not place a large number of mines behind this defense line.
Once the minefield is dug on the main defense line of the Russian army,
the main force of the Ukrainian army will quickly advance behind the Russian army's defense line.
The Russian army may be defeated.
Most of the Russian army's armament is deployed
in the direction of the Ukrainian army's main attack.
They are trying to dig new trenches and anti-tank trenches
behind the main defense line and place a lot of mines,
but they also leave the retreat routes for themselves,
so those routes will not have mines.
It may be too late for the Russian army to rebuild its strong military,
which may prevent the Ukrainian army from advancing further,
but the actual effect is yet to be seen.
Judging by the current situation,
the Russian army cannot combine a large, effective combat force
to compete with the Ukrainian armored forces.
The Russian army will also have to try to prevent the Ukrainian army
from opening fire to the left and to the right along the main defense line after the explosion.
At that time, the attack can quickly turn into close combat in the minefield.
Ukrainian tanks and armored vehicles can move along the minefield,
support close firepower and support each soldier fighting in the minefield.
After the Ukrainian army penetrated the main defense line of the Russian army,
they will not only move forward to break the temporary new defense line of the Russian army,
but also widen the distance between the two sides.
When the distance is large enough,
the main force of the Ukrainian army will be able to choose
how to enter quickly into the back of the Russian army's south defense line,
destroy artillery positions, command posts and supply points of the Russian army,
causing the Russian army to be attacked from both sides.
It is possible that the Ukrainian army will penetrate the entire Russian defense position
in southern Ukraine before the end of 2023
Ukraine has confirmed 10 of the first 31 U.S. Abrams tanks
and 200 Ukrainian soldiers have recently completed training.
Abrams tanks may not immediately become the main force
in the attack of the Ukrainian army,
but they can play a surprising role in the next battles.
General Mark Milley,
Chairman of the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff Council about to retire,
said that there have been many discussions recently
about how slow this counterattack is.
The counterattack lasted about 90 days.
It took more time than a fake war.
But that's the difference between a war on paper and a real war.
Real people drive real cars, go through real fields,
get shot, get killed, get injured.
When this happens, both sides have a tendency to slow down.
This is not surprising.
The Ukrainian army has penetrated many defensive positions,
still maintaining its fighting power,
but absolutely no intention of stopping.
And they will continue to advance,
because for them this is a war to defend the country,
not an invasion war.
During the relatively slow counterattack,
in the early stages,
the Ukrainian army estimated
had invested 1-2 regional brigades
operating with small-scale troops,
with the support of artillery
and drones,
advancing every day to destroy mines,
while expanding the area on the side.
The Ukrainian army also carried out military operations in advance,
and at least half of the counterattack forces
may still not be brought in.
After the Ukrainian army penetrated
the main defensive line of the Russian army,
they can expand from 6 to 8 brigades
conducting deep-range strikes
to defeat the entire southern defensive line
of the Russian army as soon as possible.
General Milley also revealed
that the US military
still maintains contact with the Ukrainian army.
He said he was very satisfied
with the level of consultation
and clarity with Ukraine.
He also believes that the United States and NATO
have provided millions of artillery,
thousands of armored vehicles
and other vehicles
for Ukraine.
This has directly affected
the current war.
All the different training activities
provided have shown to be effective.
The Ukrainian army said
the counterattack would continue
until the end of 2023.
Cold and humid weather
will affect,
but will not prevent the war.
General Milley said
heavy rain in season
and thick fog at the end of autumn
will make the war more difficult.
But the counterattack
will not end.
Ukraine will go through
a harsh winter,
making the soil more suitable
for mechanized warfare.
The move to the east
plays an important role.
The success of the Ukrainian army
in the direction of the main attack
in the south is also benefited
from the support attack in the east.
The Ukrainian army continues
to fight in the east.
The Russian army
has paid a high price
to occupy this place
and has promoted very strongly
on the political side
that Russia will not easily give up
and must invest reserve forces
to defend this area.
The Russian army
also tried to carry out
an attack in the east
to contain the Ukrainian army
but failed.
The main defense line
in the south
is in danger.
The Russian army
quickly mobilized
relatively small forces
from the east
to the south
to strengthen defense.
The Russian Airborne
or Airborne Troops
are now being deployed
in battles in the east
and south
and Russia's troops
are being thinned out.
The Russian soldiers
in the battle of Ukraine
said that the Russian troops
in the battleship
were weaker
but the Russian assault
was stronger.
Those who participated
in the attack
in the south
must be special forces
and relatively elite troops
to ensure
the safe movement
of large-scale troops.
After the Russian Airborne Troops
initially deployed in Bakhmut
were moved south to Prussia
the defense line in Bakhmut
was weakened.
The Ukrainian army
took advantage of the situation
to launch a fierce attack
and made significant progress.
On September 18,
the Ukrainian army
and the Russian Airborne Troops
were deployed in Bakhmut.
The Russian defense
in the south
and east
was weakened.
A Russian military blogger
revealed that the Russian soldiers
dropped their military equipment
on the battlefield.
The Russian military
organized the attack
including many different forces
but did not provide enough ammunition
The Russian soldiers believed
that the defense positions were not ready
and could only use small weapons.
On the contrary,
the Ukrainian army seemed to benefit
from the artillery.
On September 15,
the Ukrainian army
occupied two villages
about 8 km south of Bakhmut town
near the T-0513 highway,
one of the main
supply lines of the Russian army.
Russian military bloggers
even said that the Ukrainian army
had an advantage
in the air reconnaissance system
and electronic warfare.
The synchronized progress of the Ukrainian army
in the east and south
showed the ability to effectively
cooperate in combat,
the ability to fire artillery
and electronic warfare accurately,
showed that the Ukrainian army
not only had a high fighting spirit
but was also well-trained,
had enough ammunition
and the Russian military
lacked coordination
and power.
In conclusion,
the Russian army has recently
carried out a large-scale,
rare air strike
with missiles and drones.
It can be seen that
the main counterattack
of the Ukrainian army
in the south is coming,
so Russia is trying
to destroy Ukraine's rear.
The Ukrainian army
continues to attack
in the eastern battlefield
and continues
to carry out
small-scale
and long-range
attacks
along the Dnieper River
in the Kherson region.
The Russian army
has to face
too long of a confrontation
problem and
how many people
can participate
in the Ukrainian war
before the end of this year.
Russia is lacking artillery
and is trying to
save North Korea,
but it is not clear
how many aid will be received.
According to Western experts,
the combat effectiveness
of the Russian army
has decreased by 50%.
South Ukraine is
preparing for a
major military
confrontation
in the future.
