How to Cook Filet Mignon - Beef Tenderloin Recipes GRILL, PAN or OVEN!

Foozzt Do'food
956 followers
143 Video Views·Sep 22, 2023
Hey everybody, I'm Joey, and today we're going to talk about the beef tenderloin,
aka the filet mignon. Look, this cut of beef is often regaled as the king of steaks,
and when you go to any steakhouse, it will likely be one of the priciest steaks on the menu. But
guess what? You can make it right at home. In this video, we'll share tips, tricks, and recipes that
you can use to turn up the tasty right in your own kitchen. We'll show you how to take an entire
beef tenderloin and break it down into chateaubriand, roast, and other filet mignon cuts,
including a petite filet. We'll share recipes that show you how to make filet mignon in a
cast iron skillet, how to grill an entire roast, or use those petite filets for some incredible
steak and eggs. Talk about starting your morning off right. So follow me, and let's turn up the tasty.
I bought this nine pound behemoth from Costco, and I'll show you how to go from this bag of beef
to a dinner that will leave your guests raving. This large beef tenderloin produces many cuts of
beef, like the chateaubriand, and more commonly, the filet mignon. Now, this is a whole untrimmed
tenderloin, which I bought for about $12 a pound, and I'm going to trim it myself. Now, if you buy
the same tenderloin pre-cut into filets, you're going to pay north at $20 a pound. Now, the first
thing we need to do is get set up. I have a cutting board, a flat blade knife, some paper towels, and a
plate. Next, we want to get the beef out of the bag, and technique is important even here. If you
open this bag wrong, these juices will end up all over you, and you'll look like carry-on prom night.
So the first thing we're going to do is lay it flat, and pinch the top of the bag like this,
and make an incision all the way down. Once it's removed, I'm going to discard this bag with the
juices still in there, and use these paper towels to pat it dry. This just makes it easier to work
with by drying off some of that purge, that's that leftover juice that's in the bag. As you can see,
there is a lot of fat and silver skin on this cut. That silver skin is chewy and basically inedible.
This is not something we want on our final product, so we're going to remove it. We're going
to go ahead and clean it up. However, before we do that, we need to trim away the chain. It's this
part right here, and it has a lot of fat and connective tissue, so we need to remove it.
You can almost follow the line with your hands, and get in there with your knife, and just remove
this portion. This is really good meat, so don't discard it. Most people will tell you just to
grind it up for burgers, but if you don't have a grinder, you can trim it up for some awesome
Philly cheesesteaks or tacos. Just go ahead and set it aside for now. Next, we're going to continue
to clean it up. Now right here, this is all that silver skin I was talking about. As you can see,
it's right here. It's kind of shiny, kind of silver. That's where it gets its name, and what we're going
to do, we're just going to do the best we can. We're going to make a little incision
right down here at the end. Take some work, get in that silver skin, open it up like that. Now,
we're going to come the other way with that knife at the 45 degree angle.
Just do our best to remove as much as we can without removing the beef. As you can see, it's
nice and clean. Looks much more like a tender edible filet that we're used to seeing. Let's go ahead and
get the rest of this off. All right, now we have this totally cleaned up. As you can see, there's a
little bit of fat remaining. I don't try to get it all off. This is actually edible, but the silver
skin is removed. Now we have a decision to make. How many people are you going to cook for? You'll
need about a half pound per person, and you can cook this thing whole, clean, just like this, but
this thin end down here is going to cook much faster than this thick end over here. In order to
get it medium rare here, you're going to have it well done over here. Our solution is we're going
to tie this meat up so it cooks at an even temperature. Tying it up will bring those muscle
fibers together and allow it to cook, again, all very evenly. We're going to wrap this tail portion
underneath here just to create that even thickness throughout. So once we have it like that, we're
going to take this string right here, and we're going to begin to tie. I'm not going to show you
how to do a full butcher's tie. That can be a little bit complicated, but we're just going to do
a very simple tie, just like this. Wrap it around a few times, and then just bring that together
like so. Get it nice and tight. Just do a little double knot and repeat. Now this is an absolutely
gorgeous piece of meat, and it's going to look tremendous sitting on your dining room table
for all your guests. If you're cooking for a crowd, this is certainly the way to go, but we're cooking
for a little smaller crew today, so I'm going to show you how to cut this up into more manageable
serving sizes and have some leftover filet mignon for a nice dinner or some nice petite filets
for some steak and eggs. No matter which way you cook it, whole like this or trimmed up, the recipe
from here is going to be the exact same. So follow me and let's get started. In addition to the chain,
which I removed earlier, there's another muscle right here at the top on the thick end that is
separated by some fat. The first thing I'm going to do is just go ahead and remove this, and I'll
tell you what to do with this in just a moment. Do not throw it away. This is perfectly good meat.
Since we're cooking for that small crew today, I'm going to cut some of this into filets,
and I'll leave this center cut roast for throwing on the grill. This is going to be about a three
pound roast, and it tastes just tremendous. We're using this smaller cut, as I mentioned earlier, but
you could use the whole roast uncut and tied. The recipe is exactly the same. As you can see, this
looks just like a perfect store-bought beef tenderloin, its whole form. Look at that. It's easy
to see where the filets come from, and that's just what we're going to do now. We're going to cut off
some eight ounce filets. Now, as you can see, we have some nicely cut filets over here. These are
about eight ounces. This is about six ounces, and right here, this is that muscle I removed. As you
can see, this is incredibly good meat. Next thing we're going to do is, just like we did with the
whole filets, we're just going to tie this up just to bind those muscle fibers closer together, allow
for some nice even cooking. Once this is tied up, we're going to go ahead and get this in a bag to
marinate. All right, now that this is cut, it's ready to go. The next thing I want to do is I want
to marinate this for at least two hours, preferably overnight if I have the time. So I'm going to get
it in a gallon bag here, and then wash my hands before I touch this bottle. Food safety is no
accident, ladies and gentlemen. So here I have a marinade that I bought from my local butcher.
You can use whatever you like or make your own marinade using some red wine, garlic, and Worcestershire
or Serser. It will turn out great, but again, I like to get this here in the bag so we can let
this marinate for about two hours. And then I'm going to go ahead and get it right in the fridge,
but the important thing is you want to remove this and let this sit at room temperature
for about an hour before cooking it. That will help promote nice even cooking throughout. So
I'm going to get this in the fridge and we'll be right back to finish it up and get this tender,
tasty cut of meat on the grill. Okay, so this was marinating in the fridge for about two hours.
We pulled it out and it's been sitting here on this plate resting for an additional hour, just
like I told you. We're going to get some additional seasoning on it, but before we do, I just want to
go ahead and pat this a little bit dry. Get some of that off because we're going to use some oil
and we really want it to stick on there. So get that. All right, now we're ready to season. In
here I have about two tablespoons of chopped rosemary, a tablespoon of thyme, and two tablespoons
of chopped minced garlic. We're going to add about two tablespoons of olive oil and let's go
ahead and get this mixed up and on to this tenderloin. Look at that. That looks absolutely
fantastic. I'm just going to spoon this over and get our hands a little bit messy here as we get
this on all sides. All right, I don't know if we cut it all on film, but I have been washing my
hands a lot throughout this video. So we're about ready to get this on the grill. We're just going
to hit it with a little bit of our Big Tasty Steak Rub. This is a simple rub we created using common
ingredients found in most kitchens, probably yours too. We've included a link in the description
below. You can use this or season it with whatever you like, but we're going to go ahead and apply
this thoroughly on both sides. Give it that nice crust as it cooks and add a lot of additional
flavor. Let's go ahead and get it in there. All right, one final wash of the hands and then we're
going to get this on the grill. Food safety is no accident, ladies and gentlemen. You guys hear that at home?
That right there is a sound of tasty. So I want to talk a little bit about what we got going on here.
We have a two zone fire. This is a thick cut, so it can't cook over direct heat the entire time.
We're searing it over this blazing hot fire on this side for two minutes per side, and I'm
saying that there's four sides. We're going to rotate it four times and then we're going to move
it over here to this indirect heat and allow it to finish its cooking. So we have these blazing hot
rockwood charcoals. They light fast and burn hot. And to impart a little additional flavor, I added
some smoked, some soaked apple chips, which will add a nice smoky note to this as it cooks. All right,
now we're ready for our first flip. Okay, that fire's going a little bit hotter than I want it, so I'm
going to go ahead and close the lid to get that flame down just a little bit. We're going to let
it cook for two minutes real nice and hot. As you can see, that high flame really seared the top of
it, but that's not really burnt. That just creates some nice additional flavor that will meld into
the steak as it cooks over indirect here. Because those flames are a little higher than I want,
I'm just going to go ahead and close this up for about another minute. Just bring the temperature
down just slightly. All right, look at that smoke. This has been cooking for a total of eight minutes,
two minutes per side. So we're going to flip it over here to the indirect heat. Oh, look at that.
That looks fantastic. So that had an internal temperature of about 60 degrees. We really need
to get that to 125 to 130 degrees for that perfectly cooked medium rare temperature. We
don't want this overcooked. So we're going to come back and check it every seven or ten minutes.
Usually takes about 30 to 40 minutes to get it done. It really all just depends upon how
hot the fire is. So on these grates right here, I have them about halfway open. It's starting to
real hot. Feels like it's about 400 degrees right now, but because the Weber isn't grated holding
heat for a prolonged period of time, that temperature is going to come down as it cooks
closer to about 300. That's totally fine. Again, the main thing is we want the internal temperature
of that roast at 125, 130 degrees. So grab a beer, throw in some sports bets, watch the big game,
and we'll be right back. All right. So this cooked to an internal temperature of 130 degrees.
We pulled it off and it's been resting here for about 10 minutes. Now we're going to cut it open,
cut it into thin little slices, about a quarter inch thick. And it's so good, your guests are
going to be very impressed with your cooking skills. Actually, the hardest part is going to
be leaving some of this leftover for some of them to eat and not taking it all yourself. But let's
see how it looks. I'm going to go ahead and cut this real thin. Look at that. It's got an awesome color.
Look at all that juice coming out of there. That is fantastic. So look at that. Great color on the
inside a little bit. We got a little bit of heat over here, a little bit more well done over there.
But this is going to be a very tender and flavorful cut of steak. Let's check it out.
Wow. That is absolutely fantastic. This is absolutely going to knock the socks off your guests.
I've been eating eggs for nearly 40 years. Scrambled, fried, sunny side up, sunny side down,
poached, omelets, hard boiled, you name it, I've had it and you probably have too. The one thing
that the egg lacks is flavor. They're bland and that's the bad news. The good news is that it
pairs well with a variety of flavor profiles and can be used as a blank canvas to turn up the tasty.
But again, more bad news here because despite their versatility, most people only use salt and
pepper for seasoning and S&P is the lazy man's option. Throw a dash on in the morning, eat your
bland eggs, call it a day and head out for another boring day at the office. But not me. No sir, I
won't be satisfied with the status quo. I want to set myself free from the shackles of mediocrity
and I want to free you too. But before we get to the eggs, let's start with this steak. There's a
lot of videos out there showing you a huge steak with two eggs and that's not really practical if
you're feeding people or if you're actually looking to stay awake after breakfast. Now,
we recently published a video showing you how to break down an entire beef tenderloin. When you
watch that video, you'll see that there are several petite fillets that come from the trimming. Now,
these petite fillets really are little giants, so to speak, and they're perfect for steak and eggs.
They're lean and just so, so tender. And if you don't have fillet, well, just use another tender
steak. Cut it into strips about a half inch thick fajita style for smaller portions and quicker
cooking. But now let's get to the seasoning. The first thing we're going to do is season these
steaks with a big tasty steak rub. It's a simple rub we created ourselves using common ingredients
found in most kitchens, probably yours too. We've included the link in the description below.
We want to get these seasoned thoroughly on both sides. Okay, so I added one tablespoon of olive
oil, one tablespoon of butter. I've let that melt. And as you can see at home, it's nice and hot.
We've got some steam coming right off the pan. That tells me it's time to go ahead and drop these
steaks in the pan. They won't take long to cook at all, maybe about two minutes per side. And just
like with any filet mignon, we want to make sure we don't overcook them. So let's go ahead and drop
them in now. Oh, now you guys know if you've watched these videos, that right there is the
sound of tasty. And we have a couple of different size filets. I mean, these are just really petite
filets left over from the trimmings of our full beef tenderloin. And I mentioned that because
they're all a little bit different shapes and sizes. You may have to pull one or two of them
off before the other ones are done. So now that we got those in there, we're going to let those cook.
Now, if I were making this at home without making a video, I'd actually be doing the steak
and the eggs at the same time. But for ease of filming, I'm going to go ahead and get these
cooked all the way through first, and then we'll jump over and I'll show you how to make some
change your life eggs. All right, we cook these steaks here for a total of about five minutes,
and we're just going to let them cool and we're going to make the eggs. All right, set those to
the side. Now, here's the bottom line with eggs. You're going to need some fresh herbs to really
bring up the flavor profile of those eggs. We recently published a video on how to make chimichurri
sauce. It's a flavorful sauce with a little bit of a quirky name, but we've included a link in the
description below. This is absolutely necessary to create really flavorful eggs. And if you do this,
you'll become the CEO of your company and you'll be wallpapering your house in $100 bills every
weekend. I promise. So let's go ahead and get started on these eggs. We already got this
heating up just a little bit, but the first thing I like to do is just get a little bit of salted
butter and just get it in there. Let it melt down a little bit. All right. Now, what we're going to
do is we're going to wait. I'm only using one side of the pan, so that's all I'm going to butter.
I'm going to turn up the heat. Get that nice and hot. All right. While that's heating, we're going
to take a little bit of this chimichurri sauce right here, and we're just going to throw it down.
Get that right on top of the butter, right like that. When we crack the eggs, we're going to crack
them on this side, right on top of the chimichurri. It's going to be absolutely fantastic. Now, you can
really make whatever kind of eggs you like to make. We're going to go with sunny side up, but you can
go sunny side down, even scrambled omelets. This works well any way you're going to make your eggs.
All right. So here we have two eggs. I'm going to take them now that we got this going nice and hot
like you can hear it bubbling. Actually, I'm going to turn it a little bit too hot. So I'm going to
turn that down now to about a 7 out of 10. We're going to go ahead and we're going to get these
cracked and right in there. Look at that. Are you guys getting hungry yet? I mean, this is the
breakfast of champions, as they say. Next, we're going to go ahead and get this egg in here.
All right. And we're just going to go ahead and let those cook. And what I like to do is you'll
see in order to promote even cooking, I just like to break them up where they're a little bit thick.
Let them get nice and thin all the way around. All right. We're going to let those cook for just
about a minute. I'm going to wash my hands and I'll be right back. Also, I'm not going to avoid
the salt and pepper here. I'm just adding the chimichurri in addition to it. So a little bit of
salt and excuse me, a little bit of pepper. Now you can see these are all these are getting ready
to get done. So here's what I like to do next for sunny side up. I'm going to take them and I'm just
going to inject just a little bit of water here like so and then close it up and let that steam
cook those eggs sunny side up. So good. All right. Now we're done. Turn that off,
open it away from you so you don't get any of that popping oil. Get these here on a plate
just like that. Look at that. Perfect sunny side up. All that chimichurri, which has some awesome
garlic based right in there. But we're not going to stop there because remember we have the steak.
So follow me. All right, guys. So we're almost done. The eggs are right here. They look absolutely
fantastic. And now I know some of you like to see how the steak is done. So let's cut into it
and check the final temperature. Look at that. An incredible medium rare. That looks absolutely
fantastic. But we're not going to stop there. See, we have this chimichurri. What we're going
to do is we're just going to get a little bit on top of our steak here. Look at that. You know
what the heck? We're going to go with a little bit more on top of our eggs just for fun. Look at that.
So good. Now let's see how it tastes. We're going to do a little bit of the steak right here. That's
a huge bite. Go a little bit smaller so you don't have to watch me talk with my mouth full the entire
time. And look at these eggs. Oh, man, I can't wait. The garlic inside this chimichurri tastes
absolutely phenomenal. Get them together just like that. Wow. All that flavor from the chimichurri
into the eggs and the steak is absolutely tremendous. Like I said, when you make this,
you're going to go from minimum wage to top wage in no time.
Today, we're combining one of the most desirable cuts of beef available, the filet mignon, with
one of the most versatile pans in the kitchen, the cast iron skillet. The cast iron is so versatile
because it can be used on any number of heat sources, everything from the campfire to the
grill to the stove and to the oven. And as a matter of fact, we'll be using both the stove
and the oven to cook this steak perfectly today. As I've said before, if you don't already own a
cast iron skillet, well, you should pause this video right now and go buy one from our store
at redmeatlover.com. You'll be glad you did. If you don't know what a filet mignon is, well,
you've really been missing out. It's one of the most tender steaks available, like melt in your
mouth tender. It's so tender, the filet comes from a larger cut known as the tender loin,
which is a pretty creative name, right? It's also a very lean steak. There's not a lot of fat
or marbling, but remember, that's where steak gets its flavor. So if you buy this steak at a
restaurant, it's not uncommon to see it served with a sauce or gravy to promote some additional
flavor. If you buy it at the store like I did, it's not uncommon to see the steak wrapped in
bacon like it is right here. And that bacon fat will help promote some additional flavor
as this steak cooks. We've talked about the filet mignon before in our porterhouse video.
As you'll remember, the filet portion comprises one side of a porterhouse or a T-bone steak,
this side right here. As a matter of fact, the only difference between a porterhouse
and a T-bone steak is that the porterhouse has a noticeably larger filet portion.
This filet mignon is simply this part of the steak cut away from the bone.
Now, before we get started, there's a couple other tips to remember about cooking your steak,
the one I say every single video. Be sure to let your steak rest for at least 20 to 30 minutes at
room temperature prior to cooking. And guys, this is such an easy step. It literally takes no work.
There's no reason why you should skip it. Allowing your steak to rest will promote an
evenly cooked steak that will provide more predictable and consistent results every time
you cook. The other thing is about seasoning. Today, we're going to go ahead and season this
steak with our Big Tasty Steak Rub. Our Big Tasty Steak Rub is a simple combination of
spices commonly found in most kitchens, including garlic and onion powder, kosher salt,
coarse ground pepper, some paprika, and even some beef bouillon, which will promote some
additional flavor as this steak cooks. Not only will it add some additional flavor, but
this seasoning will help promote a brown, crusted, and tasty exterior as this steak sears
in the cast iron skillet. So now that we've explained what the filet mignon is, we're ready
to cook. The very first thing you need to do is preheat your oven to 435 degrees and let that
achieve temperature before starting anything else. As I said, we're going to use both the cast iron
on the stove and then we're going to transfer it to the oven to let it cook. The next thing that
you need to do is add a tablespoon of oil to your pan and let that get nice and hot. If you bought
your steak bacon wrapped as I did, what you can do is you can remove the bacon and let it cook first,
and then use the remaining lard that's in there to sear the steak in that instead of using the oil.
Either way, I don't cook my steak with the bacon on, and the reason I don't is because
I like crispy bacon. I've tried cooking this enough with the bacon on to know that it will
just never get crispy, so what I'm going to do is I'm going to cook the bacon first. I'm actually
going to reserve that bacon to make a compound butter for the steak, which I'll show you in a
different video. Let's get started. All right, while this bacon is cooking, I'm going to go ahead and
season the steak. First of all, there's no need for this toothpick anymore now that the bacon is in the
skillet, and next we're just going to go ahead and season this liberally on both sides. Again,
the seasoning, the liberal seasoning, will help promote a nice brown, crusted, and tasty exterior
as this steak cooks. We want to go ahead and leave all that awesome bacon grease in the pan
because we're going to use that to help sear the steak, add some additional flavor as it cooks.
Now we're ready to drop the steak, and I follow very strict timing guidelines for searing the
steak. I'm going to cook it for three minutes on one side, and I'm going to flip it and cook it for
one minute on the other side. Can you hear that at home? Can you hear that steak sear? If delicious
could make a sound, that would be it. All right, the steak is cooked on this side for three minutes,
so I'm going to flip it now and let it cook on the other side for just one minute. Look at that
great, crusted, tasty exterior on that steak. That's going to provide some nice crunch once
we bite into it. Now that the steak is seared on this side for one minute, I'm going to go
ahead and take this pan and transfer it over to the oven, where again, I have this oven heating
at 435 degrees. We've placed that steak in the middle rack, and we're going to allow it to cook
in there for about another six or eight minutes. As I mentioned earlier, there's absolutely no need
to flip the steak as it cooks. So why are we using the oven today? Well, while we're cooking a filet,
this method works well for any thick cut steak, any steak that's an inch and a half thick or
greater. The reason we can't just cook it on the stovetop is because of the thickness. If we only
cooked it there, what would happen is it would take, A, a very long time, and B, the exterior
would become actually burnt. And once it burns, it will provide a really bitter flavor. And trust
me, I know I've messed a few up in my time. So what we're going to do for really thick steaks is,
again, put them on the stovetop, move them to the oven. This method works really well with
filets like we're cooking today, porterhouse, t-bones, and ribeyes, just to name a few.
All right, so we're going to pull the steak out. This steak's been in the oven for about 10 minutes.
If you're comfortable with the feel method, you can try using that, or you can never go wrong
with an instant read thermometer. I suggest pulling the steak out of here at about 140 degrees.
And once you remove the steak, you'll let it cool for about 5 to 10 minutes or let it rest.
During that resting period, the temperature of the steak will actually rise an additional 5 to
10 degrees. Before I put the steak in the oven, I thought it might take 6 to 8 minutes, but you
need to know at home that not all ovens cook at the same temperature, even if they say the same
degree on the outside. So this steak took a little bit longer than what I anticipated, but we'll be
back in about 5 minutes and we'll cut it open and see how it looks. Okay, so this steak has now cooled
for 5 minutes. Let's cut it open and see what it looks like. Look at that right there. It's a
perfectly cooked medium to medium rare color. As I've said before, there's absolutely no need to
spend $50 at a steakhouse when you can make this right in your own kitchen. The filet mignon is
often known as the king of steaks. And what do kings do? They battle for supremacy. And while
there is no actual gold at stake here today, we'll throw down the gauntlet cooking three-way
filet mignon. This is a thick cut, so we'll need both direct and indirect heat, but we're bringing
that heat a few different ways. First, we'll use the traditional method to grill over high heat and
then finish with indirect heat. For the second method, we're using the sous vide machine with
the steak in a vacuum sealed bag underwater, then quickly seared. And the third method, we'll use
the traditional reverse sear using indirect heat from the oven and then searing over high heat.
These three kings are going to battle for supremacy and I alone will decide their fate.
Why? Because I'm king of this kitchen. You didn't think this was a democracy, did you?
We recently purchased an entire nine pound beef tenderloin and broke it down into filets. We've
included the link for that video in the description below. Food safety is no accident, ladies and
gentlemen. If you buy a filet in the store, you're going to pay over $20 a pound. But if you buy it
and break it down yourself, you'll pay closer to $12 a pound. We've trimmed these into eight
ounce filets. Now, the first thing we're going to do, all these are going to touch olive oil at
some point, but for this steak going on the grill right here, we'll apply that first. Now, we want
to season them all the same way so the armies are evenly matched. We're using our Big Tasty
Steak Rub to season all three. It's a rub we created and the recipe can be found in the
description below and on our website. Also, you'll notice that these are all tied to help them cook
evenly. However, the butcher's twine used for the grill should be soaked in water first to prevent
it from burning. This one right here will be placed over a screaming hot fire and cook for
about two minutes per side and then move to the indirect heat to finish the temperature,
which will take about 10 minutes. Next, we're going to get this one in a bag, vacuum seal it,
and cook it under water using our sous vide machine for two hours at 131 degrees Fahrenheit.
After two hours, we'll sear it in a cast iron skillet for 30 seconds a side.
Finally, we're going to place this one on a rack and get it in the oven at about 265 degrees until
it reaches that internal temperature of 130 degrees. Then, we're going to sear it for 30
seconds a side. This is going to be a bit of a balancing act to get them to finish all at the
same time, but some good planning and a little video magic will help get the trick done. Now,
there's advantages for each method. Cooking over direct heat is the fastest way to get the food
from this cutting board right into my belly. The next, using the traditional reverse sear allows
for more even cooking throughout, but takes a little bit longer than direct heat. Finally,
the sous vide method is a true set it and forget it method. We're going to try to cook all of these
to an internal temperature of 130 degrees, so follow me and let's get started to see who reigns
supreme. Anyway. Salud. We're almost done. We have the one on the grill done. We're just going
to drop these two here in for 30 seconds. As you can see, 30 seconds per side. As you can see,
I'm enjoying a nice cold brew. Nothing goes better with a steak than one of these bad boys.
We're waiting for this butter and olive oil mixture to get nice and hot. We're going to
get this pan screaming hot before we drop these in. Okay. This is the reverse sear going in right
here, and this is our sous vide going in right here. I got my timer going, so I know when it's
cooked for 30 seconds per side. These are already cooked to temperature on the interior, so
we're just doing this step to bring that nice color, that nice
Maillard effect to the exterior of these steaks, make them real nice and pretty.
Okay, so all these steaks are done cooking. We got them done at really close to about the same
time. We tried to hit an internal temperature of 130 degrees, and before I cut them open,
I just want to bring your attention to just the coloration difference. Here's the one that we
cooked over fire, and as you can see, that has a real nice mahogany color all around it. This too,
this is our reverse sear. This has a real rich, nice brown color on the exterior of it,
and this over here is our sous vide filet, and this doesn't have as good of a color. As you can
see, some of the plastic from the vacuum seal really got imprinted into that steak, so it
doesn't look as pretty. I did sear both of these over a high heat for 30 seconds, and this one just
did not caramelize as nicely as our reverse sear did, so let's cut them open and see what they
look like on the inside. First, we're going to start with this one, which was, again,
cooked over direct heat first. Let's take a look. Look at that. We have some really nice color on
that. That one looks fantastic, so before I test these, we're going to cut into all three of them.
Let's take a look here. Here we go. This is our traditional reverse sear in the oven, and then
over the hot skillet, again, another great steak. Look at that color. That looks absolutely
phenomenal. That's just what you want, and that color on both of these looks fantastic. Now,
this one doesn't look as good on the outside as I mentioned, but let's see how it looks on the
inside. Oh, it's super soft and tender. I can tell you that already. All right, and again, not as pretty
on the outside, but that feels just so soft, so let's dig in. I'll start over here with the one
over fire. I'll try to do small bites so I can actually talk after eating this. Let's go. It's a
damn good steak. It's really good. You can taste a lot of the flavor, both from the rub
and from the fire. It has some good deep smoky notes. Now, here's our traditional reverse sear. Let's
check it out. Again, this one has a great crust. I was really surprised by the great crust that this
one has. No one's going to complain about either one of these steaks. These are two phenomenal
steaks. You've got to remember, we're dealing with the kings here, and as long as you don't overcook them,
they're going to be tender and tasty. I think one thing I want to bring your attention to is, you'll
notice this one is a little bit more done around the exterior. That would be expected when you're
cooking over fire. It's going to get the exterior a little bit more done, and as you can see, this
one's more pink end to end, and you'll see the same is true with this one. Now, this one took over
two hours to cook. It doesn't look as good on the outside, but let's see how it tastes. All right,
that's going to be too big. Let's cut that in half. Wow, the sous vide is the most tender. I mean,
we're dealing with some tender steaks here, and even among the tender steaks, this one wins. I
think the one over fire wins on absolute flavor profile. I think the fire and the reverse sear
are pretty closely tied when it comes to look, but when it comes to tenderness, absolutely. Our sous
vide wins, so it's really hard to pick a champion here. If I had to, I'm going to go with the old
fire seared steak. It's quick. This took about 15 minutes to get cooked all the way through as
opposed to two hours over here. Again, the nice thing about this is that you can really set it and
forget it. I mean, that's the really beautiful thing. You don't have to worry about internal
temperature, so even though this one is not the most tender, I'm going to crown our direct seared
and then indirect cooked filet mignon. I'm going to crown that king of this tender.
