1.5 Billion Pounds of Cheese: Let's Discuss The US Cheese Stockpile

History Of Food
342 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 21, 2023
Did you know that there are currently 1.5 billion pounds of cheese being stored by the U.S. government
in various locations across the U.S.? This is what's referred to as the U.S. cheese stockpile
and today we're going to be delving in, diving in to those cheese caves deep underground and
discussing why they exist and what has happened throughout history to bring us to this point today
Just like with so many topics on my channel, we have to go back in history to understand
why we have come to this point where we have 1.5 billion pounds of cheese that seemingly nobody
wants. So let's do that. The U.S. government has been propping up and supporting the dairy industry
for over a century and it stems back to post-World War I when there was a surplus of milk. Now if you
go on to the U.S. Department of Agriculture's website, they actually have a whole page dedicated
to the dairy industry and the ways in which the government officially supports the dairy industry.
In the Aubrey Plaza Got Milk video, we talked about the dairy research and promotion programs
pretty extensively, but that is just one of the programs. There are so many other ones and I could
go through every single program, but that would just take up an entire video in and of itself.
So I am just showing you on the screen what some of them are and I will include a link to this page
below so you can read more about them if you'd like. In 1946, President Truman enacted the National
School Lunch Act, which required milk to be part of every school lunch and milk is still required
to be offered in school lunches. We're going to talk about this school lunch program a little
later, but here's the point in history at which that started. In 1949, the USDA and President
Truman enacted the Dairy Product Price Support Program, which maintains a minimum farm price for
milk used in the manufacture of dairy products. Through this program, the USDA indirectly assures
a minimum price for milk by purchasing any cheddar cheese, non-fat dry milk, and butter offered to it
by dairy processors at stated prices. These purchase prices are set high enough to enable
dairy processors to pay farmers at least the support price for the milk they use in manufacturing
these products. This essentially guaranteed dairy farmers that they would always get money for their
product amid unstable markets. In the 1970s, there was a national dairy shortage which resulted in a
30% price inflation on dairy products. In 1977, President Carter decided to step in and the
government provided $2 billion in subsidies to the dairy industry over the next four years.
As a result, dairy farmers were incentivized to produce as much as possible because they knew that
the government would be buying up any excess. So while this was designed to be helpful to dairy
farmers in the short term, it quickly had the inverse effect because now there was this
overproduction problem. All this excess milk that the government was buying was converted to
cheese because cheese has a longer shelf life and so it made it easier to store than liquid milk. By
the early 1980s, the U.S. government owned over 500 million pounds of cheese. While it was mostly
stored as cheese, some of the dairy was also stored as butter and powdered milk. And I don't know
about you, but this sort of immediately made me think of the sort of long-time vegan adage or
frustration about milk powder being added into everything. Things that you would not think would
need milk powder like some random chips at the store or crackers that aren't supposed to be
cheesy at all. There's been so many vegan memes and comments about this and I just sort of now
wonder how much of that is because of the government trying to get rid of powdered milk. So like,
here, have some milk powder for your whole wheat crackers. Okay, so now we have hundreds of millions
of pounds of cheese being stored by the government. What do we do with it? In 1981, Ronald Reagan decides
let's distribute this cheese to the public. That year, then Secretary of Agriculture John R. Block
showed up at the White House with a molding five-pound block of cheese and told reporters,
we've got 60 million of these that the government owns. It's moldy, it's deteriorating, we can't find
a market for it, we can't sell it, and we're looking to give some of it away. Sounds delicious and
nutritious. The cheese ended up getting distributed to low-income communities through the Temporary
Emergency Food Assistance Program and this became known as government cheese. Government cheese
became a totem of American culture, signaling both class and nostalgia. So I had never heard
about government cheese and I'm going to talk about why in a little bit, but it was clearly
very culturally significant in the U.S. There are a lot of references to government cheese in rap
music.
There's even a segment in a Martha Stewart and Snoop Dogg cooking show in which Snoop Dogg
introduces Martha to government cheese.
Where do you buy government cheese says so much. Obviously, someone's familiarity with
government cheese is going to vary based on their socioeconomic status and also their age. I actually
think it's kind of cool that they did this segment on the show and brought awareness to it, but I
think just sort of the disparity between Snoop Dogg and Wendy Williams' knowledge of and familiarity
with government cheese versus Martha Stewart, it says a lot about our culture and wealth disparity.
It's a bit uncomfortable to watch and just a reminder of how people's experiences of culture
and food can vary so greatly depending on their socioeconomic status. Government cheese is also
referenced in a few comedy sketch shows from the 90s, particularly in Living Color but also in SNL.
You're gonna end up eating a steady diet of government cheese and living in a van down by
the river. You know, it's clear that references to government cheese are correlated with race and
social class. In this SNL clip, the worst case scenario for these white kids would be to end up
having to eat government cheese. You know, it's almost used as sort of a morality signifier, like
if you're good you'll be over here, but if you're bad you'll be over here and have to eat government
cheese. My personal favorite, green eggs and the government cheese. I will not eat green eggs and
government cheese. I will not eat it because it makes me wheeze. I will not eat green eggs and
government cheese because it keeps me from going to the toilet with ease. Come on baby, now don't
worry. This is America. Land of milk and honey. We can always eat that government cheese. Oh,
that's right. I forgot about the government cheese. What again? But this is the fifth time
in a row. Please mama, don't eat the government cheese. It's really fucked up when you think
about who were the recipients of this assistance. You know, this low in nutrition, high in cholesterol,
high in fat, high in sodium help from the government. Of course for people who are food
insecure, it was very helpful to them and a lot of people talk about it in a way that they're very
grateful that their family had access to it. But this is something that Andrew Novakovic, who is a
professor of agricultural economics at Cornell, said in an interview with CNBC. People talk about
food assistance programs as if they were created to help poor people out. And you know, yes that's
true, but almost all of the major food assistance programs were ideas that came from agriculture
because we had too much of something. People of color have a higher incidence of lactose
intolerance. 75% of African Americans, 51% of Latinos, and 80% of Asian Americans are lactose
intolerant versus the 21% of Caucasians. As this Vox article points out, because minorities
historically have been heavily represented in welfare programs, the government wasn't really
doing them any favors for their health. This letter from the Physicians Committee for Responsible
Medicine to the USDA and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services details how dairy can
have disproportionately negative health effects on communities of color, specifically Black and
Hispanic communities. And like I said, I think that a lot of people were really grateful to have this
help. It probably helped a lot of people feed their families, but that wasn't the primary purpose of
it, right? The primary purpose of it was to get rid of it. It started in a way to help out the dairy
industry. It wasn't really to help welfare populations, that was just sort of like an added
benefit. I had a hard time finding an exact timeline of specifically when this government
cheese program stopped, but it seems like by the 90s it had largely gone away. But there was still
a cheese surplus. So in the 90s is when the Clinton administration formed Dairy Management Inc.
Now we talked about Dairy Management Inc. super extensively in my Aubrey Plaza Got Milk video,
but here we can see it contextualized as really a way for the government to try to continue getting
rid of that cheese through mainly through partnerships with fast food restaurants.
Legal scholar and food oppression expert Andrea Freeman stated that DMI's efforts
quote, impose health costs on Americans generally, but disproportionately harm low-income African
Americans and Latinas, Latinos who live in urban centers dominated by fast food restaurants. And
again we have you know largely communities of color being affected by this decision. So if we
fast forward to today, we still have a cheese stockpile. It continues to grow year after year.
It is currently at almost 1.5 billion pounds. Now there's something I was pretty confused by
because a lot of headlines and reports that I see refer to this as this is the government
stockpile. This is being paid for by the U.S. government, therefore by our tax dollars, but it
turns out that the stockpile for the most part is not owned by the government anymore. Only about
300 million pounds of it belongs to the USDA. The rest is owned by private companies and stored by
the USDA. So technically it's the property of companies like Kraft, Hilmar, Sopra, and other
sort of big dairy companies. But if you look at this cold storage report from the USDA, it shows
you know here's how much cheese we have in the stockpile and indeed it is almost 1.5 billion
pounds. So the government and therefore our tax dollars are certainly involved in the refrigeration
of the cheese, but exactly how the financials work, I don't think that information is readily
available to the public. So why does the surplus keep growing and growing? American milk consumption
has dropped from 275 pounds per capita in 1975 to 149 pounds per capita in 2017. But even though
the demand for milk is falling, the production keeps rising. And this is something important to
note that although liquid milk consumption is down and keeps decreasing, solid dairy consumption
keeps rising. So things like yogurt and cheese are actually increasing as you can see in this very
headache-inducing spreadsheet from the USDA. But the bottom line is that the dairy industry is not
doing great overall. In fact, 42 percent of dairy revenue came from government support in 2018.
That's almost 50 percent of the dairy industry's revenue from 2018. In 2020 the USDA purchased
120 million dollars worth of excess milk. After that, the coronavirus food assistance program
provided 2.9 billion dollars more in direct payments to dairy farmers. Current bailout is
more than double the funds received by any other agricultural product. If U.S. agricultural
products were all one big family, the dairy industry is clearly the favorite child and also
the problem child who continues needing to be bailed out over and over again. To the tune of
43 billion dollars in 2016 and 36 billion dollars in 2017. In 2016 the dairy industry dumped 43
million gallons of milk into fields, animal feed, and anaerobic legumes. This same year dairy farmers
requested that the USDA buy more than 90 million pounds of cheese to cut the country's quote
mountain of excess dairy. This is an excerpt from a 2016 opinion piece in Forbes. The United States
through the USDA is going to buy 11 million pounds or 20 million dollars worth of cheese.
The stated reason is so that taxpayers must pay for the fact that no one wants to buy the cheese
that America's dairy industry is making. But we don't want to bolster dairy farms. We want some
people to stop being dairy farmers in the face of a glut. That's what the price system does for us.
As the price of whatever produced declines, then fewer people are willing to produce it.
That's the whole point of this system. It's self-balancing. Our intervention into a market
in this manner defeats the entire point of using markets in the first place. There's also a culture
of dependency argument of farmers getting too used to having the government step in and make
surpluses go away. At some point you start asking the question are farmers making milk just so they
can sell it to some government program. Being bailed out by the government was historically just
good business for the dairy industry. Let's not forget that these are not loans. Farmers will
never repay this handout. This money goes straight from the taxpayer to the dairy industry
whether said taxpayer agrees or not. As I said the stockpile continues to grow steadily other than a
dip in 2021 which was a result of the pandemic as you can see in this visual capitalist infographic.
So this is showing if the U.S. stockpile of cheese was a giant cheese wedge or what is it called
cheese round cheese wheel. That's it. This is what it would look like and it shows it in comparison
to other enormous landmarks that we'd be familiar with. One of the things that kept coming up in my
research was one of the biggest problems with the stockpiled cheese is that it is a heavily processed
American style cheese and Americans ironically really don't like American cheese that much
anymore. In August of 2020 the USDA announced the cheese purchase program for the national school
lunch program and other federal food assistance programs like food banks. Toward the end of the
Trump administration they scaled back the nutrition regulations for school lunches.
This included decreasing the sodium limits and reducing the whole grain requirements. The cheese
purchase program directly led to schools adding more cheese into their lunches. According to the
CNBC video 40% of dairy consumed in the U.S. comes from children ages 2 to 17. I found that statistic
really disturbing because that is this age range at which kids have basically no agency over what
they eat. They're basically just eating whatever their parents or schools provide for them and this
inevitably leads to them developing this early taste for and dependence on dairy that is really
difficult to unlearn. As many of us know dairy is scientifically addicting. We're not like giving
all this excess cheese to kids because it's good for them. We're doing it because we need something
to do with it. But to be honest the entire school lunch program is pretty corrupt. There's a whole
CNBC video about it that is really eye-opening. On top of all of this dairy farming itself has
become an increasingly stressful profession. Small and medium-sized dairy farms in particular are
really struggling amid the decreased demand. These farms are often producing and selling at
a complete loss. The smaller dairy farms are oftentimes in contract with these bigger dairy
producers and a lot of times they're in this crippling debt that it's pretty much impossible
to get out of. According to CNBC 3% of dairy farms are producing 50% of the country's milk.
So it's just totally stacked against the smaller farms in general. More and more dairy farms are
filing for bankruptcy and as a result there's this growing mental health crisis among dairy
farmers. I think a lot of dairy farmers they're not evil people. They're just doing what in many
cases generations of their family before them have done. For a lot of people this is their family's
legacy. This is their inheritance. This is what they've been given and they have to try to figure
out a way to make it work. Instead of the U.S. government continuing to bail them out why aren't
their policies in place to help them transition to whatever is next? It just seems like the way
that we've been helping them is not actually helping. We're just pushing this problem along
and the only thing we're helping them to do is getting them further and further into debt. And
I don't pretend that it is easy or even feasible in many cases for a dairy farm to just transition
to crop farming. Obviously we have these heartwarming stories of dairy farms that have
done that. In October California's oldest dairy farm Giacomasi Dairy closed down after 125 years
to grow almonds. Instead three years earlier Elmhurst Dairy in New York shut down its dairy
plant and shifted to offering vegan nut-based milk instead of cow's milk. I remember that being a huge
deal when Elmhurst transitioned and this just reminds me to support Elmhurst products more. I
oftentimes don't buy their products because they are really expensive because they're super high
quality nut milks and they also don't have you know thickeners in them so it's harder to froth
them up for something like a cappuccino but this is just a reminder of like support Elmhurst more.
They did something that's pretty incredible and gotta put our money where our mouth is and if
we're encouraging them to make these transitions let's reward the ones who have done so. There are
some farms even that are still producing dairy but then they have also started growing something else
like oats. I know that isn't the perfect solution but I think that could be a really great step
just sort of committing to transitioning one small piece of the farm and seeing how it goes
and hopefully there will be more programs like this to help farmers but this is what we need
right? Instead of like a 40 billion dollar government bailout in one year how about we
allocate even a fraction of that to helping farmers transition if this is something that
they want to do? The whole thing about protecting the dairy industry is especially ridiculous when
you consider that this is a product that is entirely unnecessary for humans to consume.
We're protecting this industry like it's our lifeblood like it's the key to humanity's survival
when really it's the complete opposite of that in many ways. The dairy industry is destroying the
planet, it's terrible for human health, it's horrific for the animals and not only that but
the writing is on the wall. People are eating less and less of it and it's going to continue
trending in that direction. You just have to wonder at what point are elected officials going
to put their feet down and say no more? It's not actually fixing the problem it's just very
temporary relief and it's actually all but guaranteeing that the problem will continue to
occur. Thank you guys so much for watching. I was planning for this video to be mostly about the
cheese caves but then any research or articles that I stumbled upon about the cheese caves
really everything just led back to the history and obviously that is really important and
something I think we need to learn from moving forward. It's easy to feel really helpless
with these situations but I did see some quote I don't know if it was a comment on reddit or if it
was a quote from an article I've done so much reading for this video but it was saying that
this is actually an area where consumers really do have a direct impact like we can choose not
to consume dairy. Consumer demand shifting is really what has exacerbated this problem for
the dairy industry and so I feel like we're doing our part hopefully the government will start doing
its part by addressing this problem differently in the future in a more meaningful and effective
way. Thanks for checking out this video. I hope you enjoyed it, found it informative, give it a
thumbs up if you did, subscribe for more of my videos and make sure to tap the bell so you'll
be notified when I upload and I'll see you again soon. Bye!
