Почему замки и форты не обходили?

Ask History
1 подписчик
11 просмотры видео·21 сент. 2023 г.
Магазин Великоросс 👉 https://clck.ru/35hPsN
Скидка 15% по промокоду AskHistory
Зачем осаждать замок или форт вместо того, чтобы его обойти? Короткий ответ заключается в том, что иногда можно избежать осады. Однако такой ход может иметь плохие последствия...
Why besiege the castle of Lefort instead of bypassing it?
The short answer is that sometimes it is possible to avoid siege, however, such a move may have bad consequences.
In his treatise on war, Karl Klausiewicz argued that the meaning of defense in holding is always easier to hold than to acquire.
The superiority of the defenders is a strategic factor due to the political nature of the war.
War is the continuation of politics, so it is quite natural that the advantage is the side that will defend itself, because it has a tangible goal.
Klausiewicz notes that it is usually easier for a defender to rely on the support of the people and foreign allies,
and a defensive battle, in his opinion, is better offensive, because all the time that flows unused lies on the scale of the defending weight.
Klausiewicz uses the ratio of 2 to 1 as a condition that gives a victory in spite of all doubts in most circumstances.
Albert Wiedemeyer, who planned the American program of victory in World War II,
and various analysts of the Cold War also used the ratio of 2 to 1 as a benchmark for a decisive victory.
Thus, speaking of castles or forts, this means that the attacking general would have to have an army twice as large as the garrison of the fortress every time.
It is not very convenient to fight every time the gallows fortress, wasting time and soldiers,
but why not just bypass the castle, leaving the garrison with a nose?
The whole point is that before the invention of railroads and trains in the 19th century, the logistics of the army of invasion could be carried out according to two main scenarios.
The first is feeding at the expense of plundering the territory of the state where your army invaded.
This works on the condition that you have passed the first line of defense and settled in the depths.
Among the disadvantages is that in this way you can only get food and water.
The second option is an uninterrupted supply of food and water on people, horses and carts that pulled carts.
The speed of such a garrison will be equal to the speed of infantry on the march.
An average infantryman could expect to cover 20 kilometers per day, although much depended on the weather and condition of the roads.
During Napoleon's time, a forced march was supposed to cover 40 kilometers per day.
All medieval warriors, from knights to commoners, knew perfectly well that on the road, in addition to food and water, high-quality clothing is important.
It is impossible to walk a long-distance march in bad shoes.
The Russian brand Velikoros is a quality, tradition and unique style that will come in handy for everyone.
Sports suits made of light and dense furr, decorated with stripes and laces in the Russian style.
A collection of comfortable caps, panamas and baseball caps, 100% premium cotton of various colors.
Russian jeans and slacks of the highest quality.
Amazingly soft and comfortable socks and panties, as well as many other great clothes.
It is worth telling separately about the legendary Velikoros belts.
Durable, made of felt and leather with branded hot pressing, they will become a faithful companion for any trousers.
There are many other great things in the store.
And for subscribers of my channel, Velikoros gives a promo code for a 15% discount.
I left a link to the store in the description.
Follow the link and order things from a real Russian brand.
A horse at a tactical level is always faster than a person, but at a strategic level it moves together with a column.
Even if your army consists only of horses, the real speed will be the same 20 km per day.
An average infantryman needs 1 kg of food per day and 3 liters of water, which is a total of 4 kg of food for one person every day.
A horse, depending on its size, usually consumed 10 times more, and its load capacity was a quarter or fifth of the weight of the horse itself.
So, in practice, one horse could carry 100 or 200 kg, or pull a cart weighing 1.5 tons.
All of the above allows you to draw several conclusions, which are applicable to the army, to the invention of railroads and cars.
It is almost impossible to carry a carriage for horses or cattle.
Almost all military animals of the Assyrian civilization, whether it was mules or cavalry horses,
needed a significant number of carriages for intensive work.
That is why it was impossible to carry a pocket on land at long distances, the carriers would eat it.
One cart could carry from 500 to 1000 kg of provisions.
This means that for an army of 10,000 people, 40 tons of provisions are required every day.
This is 40 or 80 fully loaded carts in the camp every day, without exception.
Since the Middle Ages is a period of about 1000 years, it is difficult to systematize logistics and draw a general conclusion.
But let's stop at the period from the 11th to the 16th century.
In the early Middle Ages, the troops were very small, and each warrior had to take a supply of provisions for three months.
Such groups of warriors had little autonomy, and therefore could not stay on the enemy territory for a long time.
In the High and Late Middle Ages, a lot has changed.
In the Battle of Hastings, Wilhelm the Conqueror assembled a 10,000-strong army of 776 ships.
This meant that when Wilhelm disembarked on the shores of Britain, his knights were followed by an outpost ten kilometers long.
Since the outpost usually goes behind the attacking troops, it is poorly protected and can be defenseless even in front of a small group of knights.
So, ships need to regularly deliver supplies, assemble outposts and supply troops.
Therefore, it is important that the army of invasions does not leave the enemy in the rear.
In such a small war, castles and fortresses act as territorial limiters.
The garrison of the castle can be autonomous for a very long time.
But if the army of invasions simply ignores the castle and moves on, the roads will remain under the control of the castle.
In a broad sense, this means that the cavalry garrison will interrupt the supply every time it sees an outpost on the road.
At the tactical level, the castle will create a limit zone of 200 or 300 meters, depending on the number of bows and torsion machine guns.
In a strategic sense, the knights on horseback will be able to act at a distance of 10-20 kilometers from the castle, that is, one day of travel.
This is easy to understand by looking at the map of the castles on the territory of the British Isles on the border of Wales and England.
The average garrison of military castles ranged from the 12th to the 16th century was 200-300 people.
Less than 100 people lived in castles such as the Knight's Tower.
Large castles, built by a king, duke or count, in which knights or other warriors were located all year round, were arranged in such a way that they could dominate the surrounding territory.
It could be a crossing over a river, a crossroad, a narrow passage, a beach or a combination of the above.
If you want to besiege a city, you will face a problem.
For effective siege, you will have to disperse impressive forces on significant territory,
which means that the garrison will be able to achieve a local numerical superiority on some part of the territory.
Wilhelm Lev Shatlansky attempted to invade England in 1174.
He was forced to leave a significant part of his troops to tie up the garrisons of the castles of Bamberg and Anwick,
as a result of which his forces were too small to conduct a long siege of the city of Carlisle.
The situation was exacerbated by the fact that the garrison of Bamberg defeated the blocking detachment of Wilhelm, which allowed him to attack the supply depots.
When Wilhelm retreated to the north to help the besiegers around the castle of Anwick,
the garrisons of the local castles were able to unite and carry out a sudden attack on the disorganized troops of the Scots,
defeating them and capturing Wilhelm himself.
However, there are many examples when the fortresses were not besieged, but ignored.
The medieval war was surprisingly slow and positional in its essence.
The first were often the remote small barons' castles, and the garrisons were bought out or dispersed.
It should be remembered that the vast majority of medieval castles were quite small,
small and, as a rule, became an easy prey for large troops.
If this is an ordinary knight's tower, purely physically it could not resist for a long time.
It is known that in the Ossetian campaign, the king of England, Henry V, took Orfleur after the siege, which lasted about one month,
having lost, at the same time, perhaps a quarter of his army from dysentery.
Then he ignored the fortresses in Monteville, Fican and bypassed Dieppe.
Henry did not manage to escape the battle near Ossetia, but he managed to bypass quite a lot of large and small fortresses that met him on the way.
In the new era, star-shaped fortresses came to replace castles, and for many years they remained a strong nut for any army that tried to storm them.
As a main weapon, bastions of the fortress relied on gunpowder cannons, arquebuses, muskets, and so on.
This meant that the tactical radius of the territory of such a fortress was about one kilometer.
The distance of more than 2400 meters, Waban considered unattainable for the cannons of his period, that is, the middle of the 17th century.
Many bastion fortresses, like the castles of the Middle Ages, were located in strategically important places, such as crossings, roads, gorges, along rivers, and so on.
And every time a meeting with such a fortress was an extremely serious test for the army of invasion.
Star-shaped polygonal forts remained the main limiting territories until the 20th century, when the million-strong armies that created solid fronts appeared.
