"Face The Nation" Full Episode | September 17

Face the Nation
17 followers
Sep 19, 2023
I'm Margaret Brennan in Washington, and this week on Face the Nation, a historic strike
hits one of America's major industries.
PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP, U.S. PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES What are we?
CROWD 1, 2, 3, UAW.
PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP, U.S. PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES One more time.
CROWD 2, 3, UAW.
MARGARET BRENNAN President Biden's economic agenda is in the crosshairs as the United
auto workers go on strike against Detroit's big three automakers, demanding higher pay
and benefits.
PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP, U.S. PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES Auto workers help create
America's middle class.
How close is a deal that would end the strike, and will economic anxiety erode the
president's standing in key battleground states? We'll get the latest from UAW
President Sean Fain and Michigan Democratic Congresswoman Debbie Dingell.
And more bad news for Biden, as his son Hunter is indicted on gun charges and the House
GOP launches an impeachment inquiry alleging corruption by the president and his family.
I think he could do better. I think he's trying, but he's not – he's not strong enough.
Plus, we'll have new CBS poll data to gauge how voters are thinking about the
president's age and performance. Then, a prisoner swap with Iran is expected in the
coming days. We'll get the latest from Congressional Intelligence Chairs
Republican Congressman Mike Turner and Democratic Senator Mark Warner.
Finally, a conversation with actor and director Sean Penn about his new documentary
from the front lines of the war in Ukraine. It's all just ahead on Face the Nation.
And welcome to Face the Nation. We begin this morning with United
Auto Workers' simultaneous strike against Ford, General Motors, and Chrysler parent Stellantis.
Roughly 8 percent of the union's workers stopped work at plants in Ohio, Michigan,
and Missouri after their contracts expired Thursday night.
The union says if they don't get a deal, they'll walk out of additional plants.
Talks continued throughout the weekend and will resume with Stellantis tomorrow.
Senior transportation correspondent Chris Van Cleave is in Toledo, Ohio, with the latest.
Hitting automakers in their bottom line. For a third day, nearly 13,000 United
Auto Workers have pumped the brakes at plants in Michigan, Ohio, and Missouri,
striking after their union contract with the nation's big three automakers ran out.
I'm here for the long haul. Long haul. If I have to be out here, rain, sleet, snow,
thunderstorm, tornado. Striking. I'm here.
I don't think they're hunting for the CEOs.
And they're getting the backing of high-profile Democrats. Pennsylvania
Senator John Fetterman joined the picket line,
while Vermont's Bernie Sanders headlined a huge rally just feet from the Detroit auto show.
It is totally reasonable for auto workers to finally receive a fair
share of the record-breaking profits that their labor has produced.
About an hour south of Detroit, there are 10,000 auto workers here in Toledo. More than half of
them are now on strike at this Jeep plant. But that likely has more to do with what's built here,
the popular and lucrative Jeep Wrangler and Jeep Gladiator,
vehicles that could soon be in short supply on dealer lots.
Most of us can't even afford the vehicles that we're building.
Robert Vasquez has worked at the Toledo plant since 1997.
We're in it to the end. We want our fair share.
The union is seeking a 36 percent raise, with cost-of-living increases to counter inflation,
the unwinding of concessions made during the Great Recession, and worker protection,
as the companies transition to less labor-intensive electric vehicles.
They also want a four-day workweek and a return of pensions.
Both are non-starters for the automakers.
The big three are offering about a 20 percent raise.
It's a record from a gross wage increase perspective in our 115-year history.
Can GM be successful if you met all their demands?
Actually, no. The life of the contract, the initial demands were over $100 billion.
We still have a ways to go.
GM now expects to idle a plant in Kansas,
and Ford announced 600 temporary layoffs blamed on ripple effects from the strike.
That was Chris Van Cleve reporting from Toledo.
We turn now to United Auto Workers President Sean Fain.
Good morning to you, sir.
You have said that you had reasonably productive conversations with Ford yesterday.
Does that mean they're going to put a more generous offer on the table?
Good morning. Thanks for having us.
And, you know, that's up to them.
That's, you know, the reason we're in this situation right now
is because all three of the big three companies chose to wait.
They chose not to negotiate for the eight weeks we had.
We started this back in July, and we told them then,
don't wait until the last minute or you're going to find yourself in a bad position.
And unfortunately, they chose to wait until the last week
to get down and start talking, to get serious about this.
And that's where we are now.
And if we don't get better offers and we don't get down and take care of the members' needs,
we're going to amp this thing up even more.
Well, you said progress is slow.
Will you order strikes and additional plants this week?
Are you preparing for that?
We're prepared to do whatever we have to do.
So the membership is ready.
The membership is fed up.
We're fed up with falling behind.
It's been decades of falling behind, and especially this past decade,
in the most wealthiest times in the history of these companies.
There is no excuse.
These companies have made a quarter of a trillion dollars in the last 10 years,
$21 billion in the last six months alone.
And our workers' wages and conditions have went backwards.
You're asking for 36 percent pay raises our reporter just laid out there.
Stellantis said they've offered 21 percent.
What are you expecting in tomorrow's negotiation with them?
That seems forward movement.
We've asked for 40 percent pay increases.
And the reason we ask for 40 percent pay increases is because in the last four years alone,
the CEO pay went up 40 percent.
They're already millionaires.
It's shameful that one of the leaders of one of the corporations
sitting in his second home in Acapulco while we're bargaining,
rather than being at the bargaining table.
And so our demands are just we're asking for our fair share in its economy
and the fruits of our labor.
So 21 percent is a no-go for you?
It's definitely a no-go.
And we've made that very clear to the companies.
Ford's CEO said last November that electric vehicles are going to require
40 percent less labor to produce than combustion vehicles.
I know it may not be the intention,
but I wonder how you think this transition to electric vehicles
may be eating away at your union strength.
Well, I don't believe it's eating away at our union strength.
It is the way it is right now.
Unfortunately, this is what's wrong with our economy
and this is what's wrong with America right now.
The billionaire class keeps taking more and more
and the working class keeps getting left behind.
And the unfortunate part in this transition right now,
like always, go back to the Great Recession.
The banks got bailed out by our taxpayer dollars
and they just kept on doing what they do
while working class people's homes got foreclosed on.
Automakers got bailed out too.
Go back to the, you know, yes, automakers got bailed out.
And again, the workers were unfairly blamed
for everything that was wrong with those companies.
It was bad decisions on the parts of the companies
that put us in that position.
And the sad reality is, you know,
the workers paid the price for that.
We made all the sacrifices.
And after a decade of massive profits,
the workers have went backwards.
Our wages have went backwards.
Our benefits have went backwards.
The majority of our members have zero retirement security now.
And meanwhile, it's insulting
that a CEO gets on air in the last few days
and says that her $29 million salary
is justified by her performance.
No, it's not.
It's justified by the performance of the worker
on the backs of the workers
and by paying them poverty wages.
And that's unacceptable in this country.
Well, I know.
You've also said, though, it's a shell game to talk about,
you know, CEOs handing back part of their money.
You're talking about something that's more fundamental
to the structure of this entire sector of the economy.
And that's why I'm asking you about the transition,
because many of the factories in this country
that make batteries for those electric vehicles
are not unionized.
And that is where the White House
is pushing the industry to go,
more towards those electric vehicles.
Isn't that part of this challenge for you, leverage-wise?
So the challenge is, you know,
where we're going to go as a country.
You know, again, I get back to this point.
Our tax dollars are financing a massive portion
of this transition to EV.
We believe in a green economy.
We have to have clean water.
We have to have clean air.
Anyone that doesn't believe global warming's happening
isn't paying attention.
But this transition has to be a just transition.
And a just transition means,
if our tax dollars are going to finance this transition,
then labor can't be left behind.
And as it stands right now,
the workers are being left behind.
The companies want to talk about being competitive.
It's not about being competitive.
Competitive is a code word for race to the bottom.
What they want is they want to pay us poverty wages
so they can keep on making billions more in profits,
and they can keep enriching the shareholders
and the CEOs and the corporate executives,
while the workers pay the price for it and get left behind.
It's got to stop in this country.
Ford has said that your demands
would more than double the labor costs,
which are already significantly higher
than the labor costs at Tesla, at Toyota,
and other foreign-owned automakers
who don't use union labor.
So how do you make the case that these automakers
need to keep investing in more expensive union shops
rather than move to these right-to-work states?
First off, labor costs are about 5%
of the cost of the vehicle.
They could double our wages
and not raise the price of the vehicles
and still make billions in profits.
It's a choice.
And the fact that they want to compare it
to how pitiful Tesla pays their workers
and other companies pay their workers,
that's what this whole argument's about.
Workers in this country got to decide
if they want a better life for themselves
instead of scraping to get by paycheck to paycheck
while everybody else walks away with the loot.
And when we bargain good contracts,
going back to the founding of this union,
people join the UAW because we set the standard.
People join unions because it's a better way of life.
And that's what we got to do.
We have to bargain a good contract
and then we're going to go organize these places
and bring these workers in
so they get their fair share of the economy
that they get nothing of right now.
Most of these workers in those companies
are scraping to get by
so that greedy CEOs and greedy people like Elon Musk
can build more rocket ships
and shoot theirself in outer space.
And that's unacceptable.
President Biden says
he's most pro-union president in American history,
but you haven't endorsed him.
What is it going to take for you to do that?
Our endorsements are going to be earned.
We've been very clear about that,
no matter what politician it is.
How does he earn it?
We expect action.
We expect action, not words.
And, you know, this fight we're in right now,
I mean, obviously, you know,
people are talking about them
trying to interject themselves into our negotiations.
You know, this negotiating,
our negotiators are fighting hard.
Our leadership's fighting hard.
It's going to be one at the negotiating table
with our negotiating teams,
with our members manning the picket lines
and our allies out there.
Who the president is now,
who the former president was
or the presidents before them
isn't going to win this fight.
This fight is all about one thing.
It's about workers winning their fair share
of economic justice
instead of being left behind
as they have been in the last decades.
We will be watching closely.
Sean Fenn, thank you for your time today.
And we did ask all of the big three automakers
to come on the show this morning,
and they declined.
We turn now to Democratic Congressman Debbie Dingell,
who has longtime ties to GM and the auto industry.
She represents Detroit
and is in Southfield, Michigan this morning.
Congresswoman, you have said
these are the most important negotiations
you witnessed in your lifetime.
You have longstanding ties to these automakers.
Is it really more significant
than when the Bush and Obama administrations
bailed out the automakers?
Yes, it's far more significant.
And I'll tell you why.
Those days were these companies
were facing bankruptcy.
And quite frankly,
it was because of management decisions
and the auto workers were scared for their jobs
and they stepped up
and they gave away their cost of living increases
to help.
They gave in 2008 and 2009.
Now the companies are back in a strong position,
but we're really where the rubber hits the road.
Margaret, we are in a transition of this industry.
We're competing in a world marketplace
that some of the countries in Europe,
you'll see in the last quarter,
the electric vehicle sales
are more than 50% of the sales.
That's what we're competing in.
And we have to make sure the worker
is part of this transition.
It should not be either or,
it needs to be both.
We got to make sure the worker
can afford to buy that electric vehicle,
that they're going to have the support that they do.
And we've got to make sure
we're paying a fair and decent wage.
And all workers,
everybody in this country benefits
when workers are paid well.
But those electric vehicle
battery manufacturing plants,
so many of them are joint ventures
that they are partially foreign owned.
They are not unionized.
That's a choice.
How do you reverse that?
Well, I mean,
that is something that's very real.
And on the table right now
is really there's probably only one
battery plant that may be
under the master agreement.
We've got to,
it's not an easy question.
It's not easy to deal with.
And I also want to say something else
that everybody doesn't understand.
Yeah, Tesla does have a huge discrepancy
in what they're paying their employees.
And most people in this country
can't afford a Tesla.
Even a lot of executives
can't afford to buy a Tesla.
But the fact of the matter
is that most at a Toyota,
I've looked at the studies,
almost all workers at auto plants
benefit from where these negotiations go.
This is where the rubber hits the road.
We've got to figure out
how we're going to do this transition,
how we're going to go from the transition
of an internal combustion engine,
and pay people who are making that battery
a decent wage,
similar to what they're making for ICE.
And they're going to be new jobs
and different jobs
that are going to come from this transition.
But it's not a talking point moment.
This is a real, intentional, hard moment.
President Biden said
he was sending his staff to Detroit.
They're not there right now.
You just heard Sean Fain say something
about the White House
injecting themselves into negotiations.
Do you think the president
White House should intervene?
First of all, I do not believe
that the president should intervene
or be at the negotiating table.
I've said that from the beginning.
But, you know, if anything,
that the pandemic has just taught us
is that, like, who's in an office
and who's working.
I talked to Gene Sperling
multiple times a day
and have all summer.
So there are,
I don't think they've got a role
at the negotiating table.
I think every one of us
that are policymakers
and other stakeholders
need to understand
what these issues are,
what we can do to support
those discussions at the table,
and what we need to do
coming out of these
to help make a strong, viable,
competitive industry
that's employing American jobs.
And I'm not going to let
these electric vehicles
be built in China,
even though someone else says
they want them built 100% in China.
I'm fighting to make sure
they're here with good
paying American jobs.
Well, you know, Michigan,
I don't have to tell you this,
that it is a competitive state.
We're going into an election year.
I just asked Sean Fain
what it would take for the union
to endorse President Biden,
who says he's the most
pro-union president ever.
And he said that has to be earned.
That's a pretty big statement.
Well, first of all,
he's also said that Donald Trump
would be a disaster,
and I could go into that at length.
But I really have to tell you
that I think that we've got
to keep these two issues
totally separate.
I'm really worried
about what's happening at the table
and that it's going to set,
it's going to,
it is going to determine
the future of the auto industry
in Michigan.
I want to keep presidential
politics out of this
and do what's right
from a policy perspective.
Then we can talk about
the presidential election.
Michigan's a competitive state.
I keep telling you all
it's a purple state.
It's not a blue state.
But when we get a good agreement
that keeps America strong,
keeps our workers strong,
then I think they'll know
who they're going to support.
And they're going to support
someone that supports
the American worker.
Sure.
But Democrats love to say
that they are the,
that doesn't care about.
Yeah, go ahead.
Sorry.
Well, no, I mean,
you know, everybody's like
Donald Trump says
he's going to swoop in
and do a picket line.
He doesn't care about
their pay raises.
He doesn't care about COLA.
He doesn't care about
retirement.
He doesn't care about
pensions.
He doesn't care.
I mean, last time he
campaigned in Michigan,
he told the companies
they should move to
other states where they
pay people less money.
So I think that we all
as policymakers
need to understand
the issues.
How do we support
this transition
so that we are staying
competitive in this country?
But I want to do
presidential politics
after this is done
at the table
and we are keeping
a strong,
viable industry,
which is make the workers
part of the success.
Yeah.
Debbie Dingell,
Congresswoman,
I appreciate your insight.
Face the Nation will be
back in a minute.
Stay with us.
Our latest CBS News poll
shows President Biden
in a precarious position
as he seeks reelection,
down one point,
within the margin of error,
in a hypothetical match-up
with the Republican
frontrunner,
former President Trump,
whom he beat by
7 million votes in 2020.
Questions about Mr. Biden's
age seem to be
taking the toll.
Only one-third of voters
think he would definitely
finish a second term
if reelected.
As for Trump,
just over half are sure
he'd finish his term
if returned to the White House.
Joining us now to discuss it
is our elections
and surveys director,
Anthony Salvato.
Anthony, good to have you here.
The Vice President,
Kamala Harris,
told me last week
Joe Biden
is going to be just fine.
It doesn't seem like
voters are convinced.
They're not entirely convinced,
and there is concern,
and that speaks to uncertainty
in this way.
When people don't think
that a candidate
is going to finish
a second term,
they're less likely
to vote for that candidate,
and that's certainly happening
in the case of Joe Biden.
It's also happening
with Donald Trump.
Now, there's also
a component here
when people are asked,
do you think these candidates
are physically fit enough,
are mentally,
cognitively fit enough?
And neither one of them
inspires overwhelming
confidence here.
But it's not accruing well
for the president right now.
You see a substantial number
of voters who aren't sure
that he is,
and that is helping
Donald Trump,
those voters switching.
And, you know,
even in the case
of Donald Trump,
you don't have an overwhelming
number of voters
who think he is
physically fit
or cognitively fit.
The reason that all speaks
to uncertainty is that,
well, people don't like
uncertainty,
but when they're making
a presidential vote,
you're thinking about,
well, if this person
isn't going to finish
their second term,
then what am I going to get
for my vote?
And that creates a new wrinkle
in the decision process.
So what else do voters say
they want from a president?
Well, this is important
because you start
with Joe Biden.
Voters have always told us
they think he is calm.
They think he's predictable.
Those qualities really met
the moment in 2020,
during the pandemic,
when he was running
against then-President Trump.
Well, today, they want more.
They want someone
that they think is tough.
They want someone
that they think is energetic.
And those are qualities
they do not ascribe to Joe Biden.
But Donald Trump does do better
on those qualities.
And that's important.
And then there's this.
Donald Trump's voters
overwhelmingly say
one reason they're voting for him
is they think things
were better under him.
And that relates to the economy.
It relates to people's finances.
I mentioned the pandemic.
We look at whether people
say they're doing better
or worse now than they were
before the pandemic.
And people say they are not.
By two to one,
they say that they are still worse
off than better.
And those people are voting
for Donald Trump.
That's kind of classic.
If you're not better off,
you vote for the out party.
It's interesting people are focused
on those first years
of the Trump presidency
rather than the pandemic years
of the Trump presidency.
But we're really early
in this, Anthony.
Why are you polling
when we don't officially
have a Republican nominee,
a head-to-head race?
Yes, it is very early.
But number one,
you have Donald Trump
so far out in front
in the Republican primaries.
The indictments haven't hurt him.
They've only really helped him.
So you have this presumption
that we're going to get a rematch.
And that is unusual.
And look, anytime you have
something that's unusual,
you want to understand it
as soon as possible.
Another point for context here,
right?
Democrats are going to look
at this.
That is a shift, as you said,
from Biden's fairly comfortable
2020 win to where it is now.
In the summer of 1995,
Bill Clinton was down to Bob Dole.
In the summer of 2011,
Barack Obama's disapproval rating
was hitting all-time highs.
Both of them turned it around
and got reelected.
OK, maybe that gives
Democrats hope,
but this certainly is a shift
from what we saw in 2020.
So what is it that people think
is at stake?
Well, I should also say,
we're pulling on a race people
don't seem to want.
Which is to say,
when we ask people how they feel
about getting this rematch,
they said that they think
that means politics in the U.S.
is broken.
And yeah, but look,
having said that,
they also see really high stakes
here.
And they say that not only
is democracy and rule of law
potentially at stake,
but maybe in a sign of the times,
it's only going to be safe
if their guy wins.
Anthony Salvato,
thank you for sharing
your insights.
We'll be back with a lot more
Face the Nation,
so stay with us.
Welcome back to Face the Nation.
We are joined now by
the Republican chairman
of the House Intelligence
Committee, Mike Turner.
Good to have you here.
Good morning.
Thanks for having me.
A lot to get to with you,
but I want to start on
what's happening within
the next eight days.
We may be facing
a government shutdown.
Back in June,
it took Democratic votes
to push through
that debt ceiling deal.
The speaker announced
an impeachment inquiry.
Isn't this going to make it
harder for you to work
across the aisle
and to do something like
avoid a government shutdown?
No, not really.
There are a number of things,
obviously, where there's
bipartisan consensus,
one of which,
as you indicated,
was the budget debt deal.
Kevin led in that.
The American public
wanted a change
from the Biden policies
of spending,
working on closing the border,
addressing the issues of China,
and he delivered.
And the American public
have given the House,
with a small margin,
Republicans in control,
the Senate,
Democrats in control,
small margin.
They expect bipartisan solutions.
Kevin has led in delivering those.
This is certainly one
where everyone wants
the government to be functioning.
We want to adhere to the deal.
You got eight days.
Move the country.
Yes.
So what do we do here?
I mean, is this a continuing
resolution situation?
Because it doesn't seem like
House Republicans
are on the same page.
Well, as you just said,
it's probably going to result,
in the end,
in a bipartisan solution.
We're going to pass a spending bill.
That's what is going to be required,
and we're going to do it.
But it will require Democrats.
You don't think the impeachment inquiry
will cost you?
Well, again, there are things
that are important to the country
and for which people
come together.
And I think this is one of those.
The country came together
on the debt budget deal.
And at that time,
investigations were already ongoing
into the Biden family businesses.
And I think that's certainly
something that's expected
that will continue.
One of the issues
for some members of your caucus
is the continued support for Ukraine.
And we know President Zelensky
is going to be here this week.
Can you meet with him and tell him
he's going to get the $13 billion
that the White House is asking for?
Can you get your caucus to support it?
Well, the House certainly,
and certainly the Republican caucus,
overwhelmingly supports aid for Ukraine.
There will be issues
over what the administration has asked for
and what Congress ultimately gives.
Speaker McCarthy has made it clear
that the White House
should have come to us
and worked on what the package was
and not just sent it to Capitol Hill
for dispensation.
But at the same time,
Zelensky is a great spokesperson.
He really makes the case
better than anyone
that this is a fight for democracy
and that Putin's goals
are well beyond Ukraine,
into Eastern Europe
and into the Baltics.
Having him here
is going to be very, very persuasive.
The last time we had votes
on the House floor
on the issue of aid for Ukraine,
nearly 300 members
voted in an affirmative out of 435.
A majority of the Republicans
voted in the affirmative,
and I think that will continue.
But this is not going to complicate
the vote to keep
the government funded and open.
Again, this is another essential item
that we have to do.
And this was not included
in the budget debt limit deal.
With an understanding, though,
because everyone knew,
I mean, this is on your TV
sets every day.
Everyone knows this is ongoing
and this is going to require
U.S. support.
Zelensky has higher approval rating
in the United States
than any nationally elected official.
Him coming here,
I think will be very persuasive.
Even to the more conservative
members of your caucus?
Well, not everyone has to vote yes.
If you get 300 out of 435,
that's certainly overwhelming.
I think we're going to be
back there again.
So do I hear you saying
no government shutdown?
I didn't say that.
I said we're going to pass
a spending bill.
We'll just have to see when.
So what?
OK.
Stay tuned.
The White House is going to announce
additional capabilities.
They've said that.
Do they get the long-range
missiles to Ukraine
that they're asking for,
the ATACMs?
I hope they do.
I mean, the administration
has consistently said no
to everything Ukraine has said
multiple times publicly
and then ultimately recanted
and provided them.
What we know from this era
of the conflict,
Ukraine is still on the offensive,
which was the goal
of the offensive.
Russia is on the defensive.
There are a number of impediments
that are making it difficult
for that offensive
to push Russia out.
And at the same time,
Ukraine has to get
additional ground
and or longer-range weapons
to put Crimea at risk,
which is where some of the assaults
are coming from that are
killing Ukrainians.
So it's incredibly important
that we provide them
this capability.
Your committee was briefed
by the White House
within the past week
about this expected prisoner
swap with Iran.
Their diplomatic mission
shared with us
the list of Iranians
they expect President Biden
to pardon.
Are you comfortable
with this swap?
Well, I mean,
when we received our briefing
at the committee,
obviously we made known
our concerns.
I mean, whenever you put a price
on American heads,
you get an incentive for people
to take more hostages.
These are billions and billions
of dollars,
and so that's a concern.
The administration says
we're really only giving them
their own money,
but it's still money
that they didn't have.
The other aspect is,
is that these monies can be used
to support terrorist organizations,
Hezbollah, Hamas,
and, you know,
avengersome actions of Iran.
The administration says
this is limited to humanitarian aid,
but they also acknowledge
that funds are fungible,
which means they can
move them around
and will aid them
in being able to do other things.
So people are very concerned
as to what this is
as a pattern.
The administration's answer
is people shouldn't go to Iran.
I certainly want to echo that also.
People should not be going to Iran.
You're not moving on a ban,
a travel ban, though.
No, not at this time,
but I think that people
in seeing this should know
that they're at risk
and they shouldn't go to Iran.
I want to ask you,
because you've made clear
in the past you've been disappointed
by the level to which
the intelligence community
has shared with you
their assessment
of the classified documents
investigations into
both the current
and former presidents.
Do you have any updates
on that?
Are you any more satisfied now?
What they have done,
they've shown us
probably an equal amount
of both Biden-classified documents
and Trump-classified documents.
And what you can see
from looking at those
is both have egregious items in them.
None of these documents
should have been out
of a controlled environment,
both the Biden documents
and the Trump documents.
We don't know the status
of the Biden special counsel,
although, as you know,
the Trump matter
is currently moving in court.
It's certainly curious
that we don't know
what's going on
in the Biden matter.
They have limited
the amount of documents
that we have seen
that they would suggest
are not subject
to executive privilege
or the type of documents
that we would normally see.
We want to see them all.
There are already documents
that are listed
in the Trump court pleadings
that are described in detail
that we have not yet seen.
And we are pushing
to make certain
that they provide those to Congress.
But you have no reason to believe
that they are in any way
on equal footing
in terms of the level
of classification of documents?
Or do you have any indication?
I can tell you
from the ones I've seen,
they are equally egregious
and equal classification issues
that both Biden documents
and Trump documents
have the equal concern and threat
and equal classification.
I have so much more
to ask you about,
but I have to leave it there right now
to go to this commercial break.
Thank you, Congressman.
We'll be right back.
We turn now to Virginia Democrat
Mark Warner.
He is the chairman
of the Senate Intelligence Committee.
Great to have you here.
I have to pick up
where your Republican colleague
just left off.
Are the Trump and Biden
classified documents
that were in their personal possession
and not in controlled areas
equally egregious?
Margaret, three things quickly.
One, the administration
took way too long
to get us these documents.
Two, Mike and I have
a great working relationship.
I believe based
on the documents I've seen
that there is a difference
in terms of the potential abuse
that came from the Trump documents.
And third, it's one of the reasons
why I've got bipartisan legislation
that would reform
the whole classification process.
We way over classify.
We frankly should have
a process in place
so that no president
or vice president
ever takes documents
after they leave office.
That is kind of lowest common fruit.
We've got to get that passed.
We've got part of that
in the Intel Authorization Bill
and hope it becomes
the law of the land
so we can prevent this
from happening going forward.
You said based on documents
you've seen,
but you want to see more documents.
We have actually,
I'm about at 98% satisfaction
at this point.
98% satisfaction.
There's a lot more
on the national security front
that we're tracking right now
including this potential prisoner swap
with Iran to bring
five Americans home.
Are you comfortable with the trade?
I've not gotten the brief.
The Senate Intel Committee
has not gotten the brief.
We will be getting it shortly.
Wasn't the staff briefed?
Well, I can say I have not
been personally briefed.
OK.
I think we need to start
with the premise.
It's always the policy
of our country
to try to bring back
Americans who are held hostage.
That was not only under Biden.
It was Trump.
It was Obama, Bush.
I want to hear
what kind of constraints
are being put on in this exchange
in terms of what has been reported
of the $6 billion
that was South Korean
payments to Iran
that would be released.
I want to hear that
and get those details
before I weigh in further.
Because you have concern
that money is fungible.
Obviously, money is fungible.
The administration has said
there are guardrails.
I want to get a better description
of those guardrails first.
You have been very active
on artificial intelligence
and we talked about this
back in January.
Microsoft just announced
a few days ago
that China has a new capability
to automatically generate images
for use in influence operations
to mimic American voters
across the political spectrum
and create controversy
along racial, economic
and ideological lines.
How much of a risk is this
to our upcoming election?
It's an enormous risk.
And artificial intelligence,
I've spent as much time on this,
I think, as any member of the Senate.
And I never spent something
where the more time I spend,
in certain ways,
the more confused I get.
The whole economics
around these large language models,
which used to be,
you know, who had the most data,
who had the most compute power would win.
That fundamentally changed
after Facebook released
its so-called llama model
into the wild in the spring.
We just had a major session
Leader Schumer put together,
had the kind of the
who's who in the room.
And what I'm concerned at
is even the AI leaders
who say they want rules, guardrails,
I'm concerned that
when you actually put words on paper,
will those major tech companies
support that?
Because you've seen,
we in social media have done zero.
Now, in terms of China,
China is a major player in AI.
And where I think we ought to start,
where AI tools,
whether it comes from China
or domestically,
could have the most immediate effect
would be the public space
in our elections.
Right.
Which Microsoft just cited.
Hear me out on this.
But the other area beyond elections
is faith in our public markets.
These same tools could
completely disrupt
the confidence in our public markets
by using these same deepfake tools.
So I believe we ought to start,
if we could put together an alliance
between the capitalists
and the small D Democrats,
we might at least get guardrails
coming in next year with the elections
and with the concern about our markets.
You're concerned not just about spooking,
you know, the stock market.
We're talking about misleading people
going into an election.
Congress isn't going to legislate
ahead of the election, are they?
I think this is the most difficult thing
we've ever understood.
This is why the notion
of trying to solve it all,
the bias questions,
the whole question around deepfakes,
the questions around
what's called hallucination,
where you get answers
that have no relationship
to what the question was asked.
But we ought to at least start
with some guardrails around
trust in our public elections
and trust in our public markets.
There, I think we can move
before our elections.
I think it'll be bipartisan.
Let's start on that framing point.
I think we can all agree
there could be huge disruption
in both of those areas.
And that's where I'm focused my time.
You may have heard our CBS polling
there at the top of the program.
And one of the data points
I want to show you here says,
when people compare their finances now
to how they were before the pandemic,
by two to one, they say they're worse,
not better.
And when they feel worse,
they tell us they're voting
for Donald Trump.
How can President Biden
win over those voters?
Well, I think we've seen
from President Biden's actual record,
record amounts of job growth
coming again after COVID.
We've seen major legislation,
there's now law and infrastructure
and so-called chip spill
and transition in our energy economy.
And most of that has only been
about 10 cents on every dollar spent out.
So I think the positive effects
of that will really continue
to penetrate.
Do the people in Virginia feel that
that you talk to?
I think there is a general feeling,
oh my gosh, everybody seems
to be at each other's throats
here in Washington.
The notion that we're going to potentially
go into a government shutdown.
Mike Turner and I work
very closely together.
But I do think, I wish the House leadership
would be spending a little more time
on what would happen
with a government shutdown,
which makes us look bad around the world.
And frankly, in a state like mine
in Virginia, where we have
so many government workers,
government contractors,
it will be a disaster.
And yet the attention coming out
of the House leadership is on impeachment
and putting forward things they know
will not ever pass the Senate
in any kind of bipartisan fashion.
And I think that is part
of the underlying unease
that voters feel.
So you believe we are headed
for a government shutdown?
I would like to say no,
but we're eight or nine days away
and we've not even been able
to see the House pass
the most basic defense
appropriations bills.
I hope and pray that Speaker McCarthy
will say, hey, I'm going to throw
over the far right
and I'm going to put together
a bipartisan effort
with the Democrats
and mainstream Republicans
to keep the government funding.
I think that would get, again,
350, 400 votes.
Senator, good to have you here
in person.
We'll be back in a moment.
Actor and director Sean Penn
is a co-director of a new documentary
called Superpower.
It's about President Zelensky
and the war in Ukraine.
Zelensky agreed to meet with Penn
in person for the first time
on camera on the same day
Russia launched its full scale
invasion of Ukraine.
To be here at this time
in this country with you,
with your countrymen,
I mean, it's such,
there's so much inspiration
he had here.
We spoke with Penn on Friday
about his new film.
In one of the clips,
Andrei Yermak,
one of the top advisors
to President Zelensky,
says to you, you know,
the U.S. position should be stronger
if the United States and Joe Biden
doesn't do something now.
Essentially, he says America's over.
That followed with a pretty robust
financial investment
by the United States,
more than $50 billion,
pledges of weapons.
But from what I've heard you say,
you think the United States
isn't doing enough.
It is my absolute feeling
that the caution
with which the United States
has pledged support,
which seemed, in my reading
of February 2022,
was a, like a lean on
in the fear of nuclear conflict.
Something I think all of us
should look very carefully at
and understand it,
of course, is possible.
And that's to be concerning.
The likelihood is extremely low.
And as one of our witnesses
in the film says,
you know, are we going to let
a gangster with nuclear weapons
dictate the way we live?
So I think that,
and that the Ukrainians
won't let him do that.
In the documentary,
you spoke with a Ukrainian fighter
pilot named Juice,
who I understand was killed later
in a training incident.
Was your personal connection to him
and the case he made to you
part of why you are pushing
this point on F-16s so strongly?
I was pushing it when I was with Juice
and he was alive.
He dreamt of flying F-16s.
I think that he was a man
who was born into a time
where he had to do
this extreme thing
and he did it with poise
and skill and focus
and compassion.
So he had come to Washington
to lobby for the F-16s
and also was buying helmets
for his helicopter pilot friends
on eBay here to bring back.
So it was like that.
And then I suppose now,
was it July that it was announced
that there would now be
an F-16 program,
those resources?
Eventually, yeah.
Yeah, over a long period of time.
And a couple of weeks later,
I got the message
that he'd been killed.
I think not only would Juice
be alive today
if we had been as bold
as we like to claim to be
historically as a country
with our principles,
with our Republicans
and our Democrats,
with our leadership,
the citizenry too,
while we're putting
all those Ukrainian flags out,
we should have been
as demand decisiveness
in this case,
because at some point,
caution becomes cowardice.
But there's still an opportunity
for us to do the right thing.
58% of Americans
polled by CBS disapprove
of the way Joe Biden
is handling the situation
with Russia and Ukraine.
And I'm getting the sense from you,
you're disappointed too.
Yeah, I respect President Biden
very much.
There have been a couple of things
that I think have been disasters
up to this point.
There should be
an implicit understanding
between private citizens
and leaders in government
that there are things
that I don't know
about things that should be,
need to remain classified.
Right.
So every day,
even when I was with Juice,
I was privately thinking,
yes, it's our job
to fight this fight.
But privately, I was thinking,
but maybe they are doing it
behind closed doors.
And tomorrow,
we're going to wake up
to that squadron.
Enough time has passed.
I think it's been, to date,
a tragic mistake.
And I hope and encourage
this president
that he deserves the legacy
of doing this properly.
Polling also shows
big majorities of Americans
continue to support
economic sanctions on Russia.
61% of Republicans, though,
say the U.S. should not
send weapons to Ukraine.
50% say the U.S. should not
send aid and supplies
to Ukraine.
That is a big shift
from where the Republican Party
was in terms of, in the past,
being very strong on Russia.
But some of it,
in terms of the rhetoric,
reflects this sense that
America needs to fix itself
at home.
How do you respond
to that thinking?
I think there's more
than a compelling argument
that would change those minds.
And I understand
why they're confused.
I mean, I'm hoping,
in its little way,
that this film
can help context.
I would be confused
if I hadn't had
the opportunity to do this.
Better communication of the why
and the justification
for the billions of dollars
of American spend.
If the current leadership
would just do one thing now,
it would be the president
saying to his cabinet,
we are not spinning the story
on Ukraine anymore.
So, if it's about
what are they capable of,
we're going to let
our commanders in Fresno,
at the Cal National Guard,
that's been doing
joint military exercises
with them for 30 years,
tell us what their capability is.
And we're going to say it
unfiltered to the American people.
You end the documentary
talking about this feeling
of unity you had
when you were in Ukraine,
and you compare it
to what you see here at home.
And you actually end
on the images
of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez,
the congresswoman,
and Marjorie Taylor Greene
of Georgia.
And you say,
we're going backwards.
Why do you think
they symbolize that?
I think that we've come
to a point where
we as the voters,
we as the citizens
have to look at our politicians
and say, look, you're very smart.
We agree with your policy.
Why would you want
to call it socialist?
Why would you want to put up
a middle finger to people
who have a reaction to that?
You're a leader.
Just get the policy across.
I'm not interested
in these people
self-celebrating
or grandstanding.
Jerks like me do enough of that.
Leaders can't do that anymore.
And so on the right,
on the left,
we have to demand
that people actually
are accountable
and ourselves
for the division that we have
and break it.
Thank you, Sean Penn,
for sharing your work with us.
And Superpower debuts
on Paramount Plus on Monday.
We'll be right back.
That's it for us today.
Thank you for watching.
Tune in to 60 Minutes tonight
for its season premiere
or an interview
with Ukraine's President Zelensky
right after football.
Until next week.
For Basin Nation,
I'm Margaret Brennan.
