Dissecting Trump's Answers to Megyn Kelly About Classified Docs Case, w/ Dave Aronberg & Mike Davis

Megyn Kelly
51 followers
20 Video Views·Sep 16, 2023
I want to talk to you about the Trump interview on Wednesday.
We aired it yesterday, Thursday,
and the media went nuts with it.
I mean, it was actually very interesting
to see what different people did with it.
You know, there was kind of something in there for everyone.
CoreMAGA loved certain parts,
DeSantis fans loved certain parts,
and of course the left loved the discussion
about the criminal indictments.
And I'll tell you something funny in just a second
about something that happened on MSNBC
that kind of amused me,
but I begin there with Lawrence O'Donnell,
who did, I think, 20 minutes on this at least.
I don't know, my team watched it.
And he had on Andrew Weissman.
Can I tell you, I've never heard Andrew Weissman
actually speak before.
I only read about most of my news I get via,
you know, reading it.
I've never heard him speak before.
Very odd way of speaking.
And then there was Neal Katyal, former Solicitor General,
and the other guy was, I don't know this other guy.
He's constantly on there talking about
how Trump is the devil.
Morris, Brandon, I can't remember.
You'll know him, Dave.
Brandon Moss-
Bradley Ross?
Moss, is it?
Oh, yeah, Moss.
You'll see him in this clip.
Bradley Moss.
Okay, there's a reason I'm taking time to say their names.
I'll get to it.
But here's their reaction to a piece of that interview.
Let's listen to more of Donald Trump's testimony today,
not under oath, in his own defense.
I'm allowed to have these documents.
I'm allowed to take these documents,
classified or not classified.
And frankly, when I have them, they become unclassified.
People think you have to go through a ritual.
You don't.
At least in my opinion, you don't.
But it's even beyond that,
because the Presidential Records Act
allows you to do, as president, only as president.
When you hear these interviews with him,
and I feel like these interviewers
almost have to issue him Miranda warnings now
before he does these interviews,
because he just keeps confessing.
He has to be able to put forward
this cockamamie legal theory he's got
about what the Presidential Records Act lets him do.
He's gonna take that all the way to the Supreme Court.
Basically, Trump's defense that you just heard
is a defense to the crimes of which he's charged,
the way that bleach is a defense to COVID, Larry Lawrence.
I mean, it's just ridiculous.
So they had a bit of a field day with it, Mike Davis,
saying he confessed on camera.
And if you watch a longer clip saying,
in fact, a bunch of pundits on the left
said this will be played in court.
Do you have a different view?
Well, first, I'm just very happy
that Neil Katyal made it out of the desert.
He was at a music fest and got stuck in the mud,
and he posted on Twitter how it,
you know, the agonizing eight hours
that he had to walk through the mud to get out.
It reminded me of people, like people in East Palestine
and, you know, people in Maui.
It was just devastating for Neil
that he had to walk for eight hours.
But I would say this.
They mocked this legal argument.
Now it's the same legal argument
that the President Clinton used
in the Clinton soccer case, and he won, right?
Under the Presidential Records Act,
any document created or received by the president
or his staff is a presidential record or received.
And that includes agency records
not subject to the Freedom of Information Act,
classified records from the CIA, the DOD.
These are subject to the Presidential Records Act.
And under the Presidential Records Act,
the president has access to his presidential records
any time he wants.
And under the Clinton soccer case,
the mere fact that President Clinton
took eight years of highly classified audio recordings,
79 tapes of his presidency,
including discussions with foreign leaders,
including discussions with his national security aides,
clearly born classified,
the most classified materials possible.
The mere fact that President Clinton took them with him
when he left office and did not turn them over
to the bureaucrats at the National Archives
makes them presidential records.
And it doesn't matter whether they're classified or not.
That's why Congress gives former presidents,
federally funded staff with security clearances,
secure office space, secret service protection.
I can see Dave actually wincing as you're talking.
He does not agree, why?
First of all, it's a real feat to get out of the mud,
walking eight hours.
And that's not easy.
So props to Neil Katyal.
And it's the Burning Man Festival.
So number one, Megan, before I forget,
you said in the previous segment,
you said the Department of Justice defended Clinton
when he was president.
Correct, they did it while he was president.
The difference is that Merrick Garland
was defending Donald Trump after he was president,
after he was no longer president.
So I think that's the difference.
That's just one little thing.
And if I can go back to what my friend Mike was saying,
you asked the right question.
It was an excellent interview all around.
And you asked the right question
because when former President Trump was saying
that the Presidential Records Act
essentially gives them immunity here,
you said, but you had a subpoena
and then you didn't comply with it.
So it's still obstruction.
The obstruction is obstruction.
It doesn't matter that you were president.
If you refuse to turn over documents
in response to a subpoena, that's a crime.
Willful retention of documents
is a crime under the Espionage Act.
So I think what the former president is doing
is talking about something that he's allowed to do,
to access the documents
under the Presidential Records Act.
But once he's no longer president,
he cannot keep those documents any more
than he could keep Air Force One.
And even if you say, as Mike says,
he can still keep them,
once you receive a subpoena to get them back,
you can't keep them.
You have to turn them over or else it's obstruction.
That's, I mean, that's where the president's the weakest
on the obstruction because I've,
we've been debating this for how long now, guys?
You know, all of us since the Mar-a-Lago raid
about whether he had the right to the documents
to begin with, that's one question.
And then irrespective of whether he had that right,
whether he needed to turn them over once he got a subpoena.
I mean, I've got tons of documents in my files here.
I have a unquestioned right to all of them,
but if somebody serves me a subpoena,
if the feds serve me a subpoena to turn them over,
I have to, the question of ownership is now irrelevant.
It's irrelevant, it's not about ownership.
It's about, is it responsive to the subpoena or isn't it?
A judge has to issue the subpoena.
This is the full power of the court saying, turn it over.
And I have to, and then we'll argue
about what the other issues are.
But that's the problem for him, Mike,
is that the allegations are that when faced
with that subpoena, whether he had the rights
to the documents or not, he didn't comply.
He kept the documents.
That's why the feds found, I don't know,
they only made an issue out of 30 of them,
but some hundred documents
that still had the markings classified on them
when they raided Mar-a-Lago.
I would say this, there is no criminal component
to the Presidential Records Act, right?
And so what was the criminal predicate for this subpoena?
Right, and that's the issue is as if it's unlawful.
Okay, but if there isn't one, so yes,
so take it, so let's say for argument's sake,
there wasn't one, that they failed to state a crime
that would have justified that subpoena.
What does that do?
What does that mean?
Well, I mean, it means the subpoena is not lawful.
And so that the issue is,
is if you're issuing an unlawful subpoena
because there's not a criminal predicate,
how can you obstruct justice for an unlawful subpoena?
There's a 2019 memo from the Office of Legal Counsel
that is binding on the executive branch.
It is the Office of Legal Counsel
is the general counsel for the executive branch.
And this was during the Mueller probe.
And essentially this OLC memo says you can't obstruct
justice into investigations of non-crimes
with very few exceptions.
So if they are investigating the non-crime
of a former president having his presidential records,
which is allowed by the Presidential Records Act,
how can Trump have obstructed justice by being a jerk
and not responding to the subpoena
when the subpoena was issued pursuant to a non-crime, right?
Why didn't-
So Dave's a prosecutor, he's a prosecutor.
What's the answer to that?
Do you agree with that?
No, I don't.
I think Mike might be conflating the search warrant
with the subpoena.
The search warrant, yes,
you need to have evidence that there's a crime there.
But when you send out a subpoena, that's different.
I mean, how else would the government
get these nuclear secrets back just by asking politely?
They did that.
So if you can't send out a subpoena
to require them to be turned over,
how else could you ever get them to be turned over?
Well, what's the predicate crime?
I mean, you think the government could just issue subpoenas
to American citizens without an underlying crime?
I mean, that seems like a problem.
There has to be an underlying crime
and there's not an underlying crime.
We carve out exceptions-
Okay, wait, let him answer.
This is interesting.
Let him answer, go ahead, Dave.
I would say the underlying crime,
if you need an underlying crime,
it would be the violation of the Espionage Act,
the unlawful retention.
Once you're no longer president,
you can't keep nuclear secrets.
And so that's the underlying crime.
And if you say, well, that statute doesn't apply,
well, they have a good faith basis to believe it does.
And I would submit that
because of national security reasons,
you don't need to have the crime
if someone has some sensitive documents
that they will not turn over,
you can send them a subpoena.
But regardless, either way, he got the subpoena
and he admits that he just thought
he didn't have to respond to it.
So that's where he's really in a lot of trouble
because obstruction is the big whammy here,
punishable by up to 20 years in prison.
It is the big whammy.
It's definitely where he's most vulnerable.
Convicting a murderer is a new 10-part
true crime docuseries from Daily Wire Plus
hosted by Candace Owens
that dives deep into the infamous case of Stephen Avery.
Making a murderer popularized the Stephen Avery case
and portrayed him as an innocent victim
of corrupt law enforcement.
But is there more to the story?
In this series, Candace unveils startling evidence,
uncovers edited phone calls and testimony,
and unravels a narrative that stands in stark contrast
to the portrayal you might believe.
Episodes one and two are available to stream for free
on Daily Wire Plus.
Episode three is also available now,
but you gotta be a member of Daily Wire Plus to watch it.
New episodes air every Thursday.
Just check out this link, dwplus.watch.kelly.
dwplus.watch.kelly.
To start watching episode one for free now.
Hey, thanks so much for watching.
If you like what you just saw,
hit the subscribe button for more clips and full episodes.
