From the Archives: Joe Biden & Dr. Anthony Fauci, November 4, 2001

Face the Nation
17 followers
3 Video Views·Sep 9, 2023
Today on face the nation the anthrax scared are more people at risk. And what about the war in Afghanistan?
We'll cover it all in another expanded edition
Public health officials are vaccinating workers should there be an outbreak of smallpox now
We've got the latest on that Anthony Fauci of the National Institutes of Health
Massachusetts Senator Ted Kennedy who's pushing new
Bioterrorism legislation. Well American troops have to invade Afghanistan in force to find Osama bin Laden
The chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee Joe Biden and one of the committee's ranking Republicans Chuck Hagel
We'll talk about that. We'll get the view from the Arab world from the Egyptian ambassador Nabil Fahmy
We'll round out the broadcast with terrorism expert Brian Jenkins
investigative reporter Seymour Hirsch
former National Security Advisor Sandy Berger and Los Angeles Times Washington bureau chief Doyle McManus
Gloria Borgia is here and I'll have a final word on winning in Afghanistan
But we begin with the latest on anthrax on face the nation
Face the nation with chief Washington correspondent Bob Schieffer and now from CBS News in Washington Bob Schieffer
Good morning again, and we begin this morning with dr
Anthony Fauci who is here in the studio with us and Senator Ted Kennedy who's back home in Massachusetts
Dr. Fauci is the head of the infectious diseases
Institute at the National Institutes of Health. Dr. Fauci
Another report this morning of anthrax being found this time at the Veterans Hospital here in Washington
We're told is found in the mailroom five mail workers or being given antibiotics
Is it likely that any of the patients and there are two hundred and some odd patients?
They're likely that any of them could be exposed or infected
Extremely unlikely you still need to make sure the staff is aware to look for any
Unusual situations with regard to lesions that might crop up with regard to cutaneous anthrax
but it would be very very unusual for that to happen the VA facility as
Many people are aware of is a facility in Washington that receives mail from the Brentwood facility
which we're considering the primary facility from which
Contamination has occurred because the original letters that went to Senator Daschle passed through the Brentwood facility
So finding contamination to whatever degree very minor or what have you in the VA system is not totally surprising
That's the reason why the officials were heads up about looking for that now that they've identified it
They have a few of the mailroom people on antibiotics, but the broad hospital the patients themselves
Extraordinarily unlikely that there's any contamination there in the sense of they're being exposed
But you still have a high a high state of vigilance for that
Let me ask you about this woman in New Jersey who has shown up with with anthrax
And then of course we have the woman in New York who died of anthrax
It appears that they had nothing to do with the post office
Which raises the question is there is there a cross-contamination in other words?
Could they have received a letter that was in one of the facilities where some of these anthrax letters were and somehow it got from
One letter to another and that's what causes that certainly is conceivable
I think the New Jersey case of cutaneous anthrax and the woman at the Manhattan Hospital that was inhalation anthrax are two
Entirely different likely entirely different one. We'd have no idea really what's going on the woman in New Jersey
her her company received mail from the
Receives mail from the Hamilton facility that had also some contamination
The fact that she got cutaneous anthrax and that there was anthrax spores identified in the mail slot from which she received mail
Makes it likely not definitive
But likely that there was just what you're referring to that there was some degree of spores which got on a letter to which she
Had personal contact the idea of cutaneous anthrax is one that is perfectly compatible with that
The woman in the Manhattan Hospital has inhalation anthrax with really no way of tracking where that came from
So she still is an outlier case
And the question is is it an outlier of an already existing pattern namely some exposure to mail that hasn't been identified?
Or she is she the sentinel case in a new and evolving pattern if the latter were true
You would expect to see other similar cases without explanation. Thank goodness. We've not seen that right now
the mystery still remains
But we haven't seen something that was suggest that she was
Exposed by a way that had nothing to do with mail that may be in another environmental situation
Well saying that would we expect other cases to crop up soon?
Exactly. If in fact the thing you worry about tracer steps was she in a subway?
I mean one of the things we're concerned about is the release of anthrax in a situation where the
Aerosolized components could have a wider impact
so you look for where she had been with whom she had come into contact and see if there's any indication that there are
Other cases cropping up as of now none. That's the good news
The bad news is that we still have a mystery of how this happened and then let me go back to the woman in, New
Jersey
If in fact she got it off a letter that just happened to be in the post office where another anthrax letter was then
What does that tell us about how many people have been exposed?
Well, it could possibly be sure if obviously met most of the letters
Many of the letters that have gotten into that facility had been intercepted and now have gone to Ohio for decontamination and then back
but still you have to be concerned that there might be some that come that that came out like it is
Possible that we've seen with this New Jersey person
The approach to that is if you look at the number of pieces of mail that have been distributed
Since this it's measured in the billions and we have one case of this woman who possibly and maybe likely had
Contamination through a secondary contamination of a letter
That means that the odds of that happening are very very low
From what we've been through over the past few weeks, even though it's very low
You have to stay real heads up
And that's the reason why the word is out people who might have had mail through those facilities
Should look for any unusual lesions on their hand whether they should be treated with antibiotics
Highly unlikely that we should do that because of the let me ask you about this other thing and that is this report this
Morning that we now have health public health officials being vaccinated against smallpox
In case there's an outbreak of smallpox, right? How worried should we be?
What is the likelihood of a smallpox outbreak? Well, I you know, you can't put a quantitation on how worried you should be
But what you can say if I might in response to your question, we must be prepared for this
We must be prepared for the use of smallpox as a bioterrorism weapon. The CDC what they're doing is classic
Appropriate public health approach you vaccinate what we call the first responders the people that are gonna have to go out into the field
Do the examination do the isolation do the quarantine? You've got to get them vaccinated
So the CDC is appropriately doing that now just in case there is a smallpox attack
At the same time is that we're building up very rapidly our stores of vaccine
So that if it comes to the point where we'll have to widely vaccinate we will be prepared to do that. All right, dr
Fauci, thank you so much and now to Hyannis Port, Massachusetts and Senator Edward Kennedy, Gloria
Senator Kennedy, let's talk some more about these smallpox vaccines that dr
Fauci has been talking about the health care workers are getting vaccinated
Vaccinated what about the rest of us? Are we moving too slowly in producing smallpox vaccines?
well, first of all, we ought we all Americans understand that we have a
Strategic petroleum reserve and the reason we have that in case we are going to have a national emergency
The prices of oil were going up through the roof or we are being denied
Petroleum. I think we need a strategic pharmaceutical
Reserve we ought to set precise times dates
Resources to make sure that we're going to be able to deal not only with the smallpox and anthrax
But for all the other likely bioterrorist threats
This is the kind of effort and energy that we've had at other times in in our history at the start of World War two
Franklin Roosevelt said we can produce
50,000 planes in one year. Everybody said we couldn't do it. We did it
We need that kind of determination to make sure that every single
American every single American is going to be given the kind of protection that we can give we have the best
Researchers in the world and we ought to put them to the test to make sure that every American is going to be protected against
Every likely possible threat from bioterrorism. Well senator, how do you get that done?
Should the federal government get in the business actually of producing these vaccines or should it go to private?
Pharmaceutical companies this has to be a partnership
the fact is that most of the pharmaceutical companies don't make this kind of these kinds of
vaccines or do a great deal of research in this area because it isn't a really a matter of
National urgency, but it is at a time of bioterrorist
Potential attack and therefore it has to be a partnership that can be worked out
We can take various steps to help the industry to move ahead
but the point is we want to protect every American the concern that
And we ought to do it in an appropriate public health way
That means that we have to follow where the science and where the research leads us. That's one of the reasons
I'd be very hopeful that dr. Satcher would stay on he is the leading public health
doctor in our country as the head as the as the surgeon general he's
Going to leave evidently in January
I would hope that the president Bush would
Invite him to stay and I would hope that he'd be willing to stay on we need the best in public health the best in
Terms of research, but most of all we need to set precise times
We have to have the resources available and we ought to do the research not only in anthrax smallpox
But the plague but in the other possible areas of bioterrorism. Well, Senator
Do you have anything or know anything to suggest that perhaps dr. Satcher who is the surgeon general we should point out is being pushed
out
No, he's his time is up at the after January and there's every indication that he would go to retire
I don't think we need it on the job learning at this particular time
He knows that the public health challenge and this is a public health challenge the danger of bioterrorism
Because one of the keys as dr
Fauci has pointed out is early detection and that is the public health system
We have to develop early detection
So then we have the skilled personnel that will be able to detect the nature of the bioterrorism
They'll be trained and then we'll have the vaccines to be able to treat it
So it's a combination of having the best in terms of public health
He is the public health doctor and he is an outstanding one. I would hope that he'd be asked to stay senator one prominent
Scientist was quoted last week as saying that we should protect every single buildings ventilation system with an armed guard
Are we really that vulnerable?
Well, there's a that has to be evaluated by the nature of the particular kind of a bioterrorist
Incident there are a series of different
of different challenges that we're facing in terms of
Bioterrorism and some spread through the airs others spread through food others spread in different other ways in terms of
Communication and we have to be able to develop the best kind of public health
Recommendations on the range of different kinds of likely threats
Well, how well we'll have to look at these in different kinds of ways
But we have to be reasonable and and how we're going to be able to do this, but we have the best
Individual researchers and health personnel and we can provide
Enormous protections for the American citizens and we ought to be about doing it. That means investing in our public health system
it means working with our
The medical schools and the American Medical Society
Senator Frist and I are working closely together on follow-on
Legislation and hopefully we'll be able to get that passed in the Senate before we reset senator
Let me follow up quickly on something. You just said you mentioned the food supply. Are you worried about the food supply becoming?
Contaminated. Well, first of all, we are only inspecting about 1% of
the food that enters the United States the amount of food that's entering the United States has
Escalated to dramatically over the period of recent two years
Historically, we were concerned about the pesticides herbicides and insecticides
That were being used on the food prior to coming into the United States and that presented some public health challenges
but now we know that there's a potential by a
bioterrorist if they want to contaminate the the food that that may be a way for them to do it and that is why
the it is extremely important that we are going to have the adequate kinds of inspection and
The work being done in order to protect the food supply
Secondly there's as the Journal of American Medical
Society has pointed out
we know that if cattle and poultry also take antibiotics then we can build up a
In order to help them grow and develop that there's now increasing evidence that that can pass on in the antibiotics
into human beings and therefore
the
New antibiotics which they use if they have anthrax might not be as effective
And so this presents some public health questions as well
We need to have the hearings, but we need to have policy
But the warning signals have been raised and this should have our full focus and attention as well
The Secretary Thompson has identified this and spoken about it and has made some important recommendations. All right, Senator Kennedy. Thank you so much
We're gonna be back in a minute with two key senators on the Foreign Relations Committee to talk about how the war is going in
Afghanistan in a minute
We turn now to the war overseas and joining us from Wilmington, Delaware
Senator Joe Biden the chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee here in the studio one of the ranking Republicans on that committee Chuck Hagel
Let me put it to you
Gentlemen, because I think this is the question that's going to be talked about and debated over the next coming weeks
Is the United States Senator Hagel going to have to put a large force of ground troops into Afghanistan to track down?
These people and bring them to justice
Well, I think all the options must be on the table here Bob
We certainly learned that over the last few years most recent experience
in the Balkans
What we always must remember is that the tools that the president has to conduct
War
Must never be sacrificed to any early options in or out. All those options should be there and if we
Early on take any of those options off the table
Then we hurt our cause so would you would you support that if it became necessary?
Well, it depends on what we what we're talking about here
I don't think there's any question in the minds of most of us that we're going to use ground forces
we're gonna have to use ground forces if we're serious about about
Accomplishing the object objectives that the president has laid out
I think they're going to have to be targeted and focused and probably special operations types of ground force activities
I don't see where you're gonna put a half a million men on the ground like we did in Vietnam
Or any of the large-scale efforts, but I think we have to be careful of one thing here that we should allow the president
And those charged with the responsibility of conducting this war to let these options play out
Consult with the Congress as they do as they are doing and and then and then let this play out a little bit
we I think run a risk here if we
Criticize and are too critical too early in the strategies and the tactics that the president is using
All right, Senator Biden. What about it?
Would would you support it if if a large force of American ground troops had to be put in there?
I'd support whatever the Pentagon says we need to win this war
The only thing I know for certain is we cannot lose but to make Chuck's point
I think it's much too premature to make the judgment of whether or not the initial strategy and tactics used by the administration
are a failure
That's what you're reading a lot about and hearing a lot about these days. I know I don't know
I believe the administration would like two things to happen one
To not use a significant amount of ground forces and to win this earlier rather than later
But it may very well be that as things move on
They have to insert or at least contemplate larger infusion of ground forces
But again, I really think Bob it's much too early. I think back to the Kosovo
War and the bombing and the second day of the bombing everyone declared it a failure
And and we persisted and it worked now again
I'm Chuck is much more experienced as a war hero and as a participant in the ground war to know
Whether or not that need exists. I just don't know but so far. I think it's premature to make a judgment
All right, senator Hagel. Do you have any problem with the way the government has handled these terrorist alerts?
We've had two of them so far
Some of them sending contradictory
messages as we saw this week when Governor Gray Davis of
California said that there was a problem with the bridges there and the government said that wasn't a credible threat
How do you think they're handling this? I think overall they're handling it just about right. These are tough calls
These are line calls. These are subjective calls. I think we're probably better off to
to allow
the judgment of our Attorney General and FBI director in these kinds of
Situations where if they feel that in fact the best interest of our country is served by alerting the American public to some general threat
Okay
but again
They recognize as we all do
If you lay that out too many times if you roll that out too many times and nothing happens
Then of course, you know the old wolf story, but right now I think the government is handling something
That that is unprecedented in the history of this country in a way that's that's just right last thing
I would point out here. We're we're making this up as we go Gloria
There's no roadmap. No, no blueprint here as to how to handle something like this
well
Senator Biden is speaking as of kind of making it up as we go along and I think everybody kind of agrees that
Because we haven't faced anything quite like this
But one of the things an underlining worry and all of this is in Pakistan itself where people are worried about nuclear weapons
How worried should we be about the Taliban or somebody else getting a hold of the weapons that Pakistan has right now?
I am not too worried about that for two reasons. Mr. Arif seems to have control
He is knows he has our availability to help and if in fact he needs to maintain control
The ability to get the kind of weapons that they have available to them
That is the Pakistani government and use them is very difficult. But should we be aware of it?
Yes, we should be aware of it and we should be prepared to help the Pakistanis
but in my discussions with the intelligence community and
with the with the State Department
there is a high degree of confidence that Mr. Arif is in full control and
Able to maintain control of the nuclear arsenal possessed by Pakistan
Senator Hagel, are you worried about our intelligence on the ground in Afghanistan?
Say we do send an infusion of ground troops. Do you worry we'd be sending them into traps?
Well, that's always a risk that that you face anytime
You are applying ground troops in war
Now with that said I don't think you ever have enough intelligence one of the criticisms and I think it's been
It's been valid over the last few years, especially in the last couple of months is that our human intelligence network?
has essentially eroded and maybe in some cases evaporated over the years and that's a
Debate probably for another day as to why but the fact is we don't have enough good human intelligence on the ground
in Afghanistan
Intelligence in this kind of war is critical like any war
But but this kind of war when they're all over the place you need good intelligence gentlemen. Thank you very much when we come back
I'll round out this half hour with our weekly comment
When people asked last week, are we winning this war?
I thought back to Vietnam when people asked that a lot what it took us a while to
Understand back then was that when we have to ask we are not winning winning is apparent
We'll know we're winning when Osama bin Laden is dead or behind bars and those people in the caves come out with their hands up
And when we can open a letter without wondering if it's going to kill us. No, we're not winning not yet
Anyway, nor is this some adult version of are we there yet?
And the government shouldn't try to treat it that way by pacifying us with soothing syrup
We don't need to keep hearing that everybody in the government has done everything, right?
what we need to know is that people are doing the best they can and those who weren't have been moved out and
That whatever the cost will hang in there until things go our way and they will this country is just too big too strong
Too resourceful and has always shown too much resolve for it to come out
Otherwise, they say the president's pondering what to tell the country this week
How about a little of that and then a realistic assessment of just how hard this is going to be?
Remind us to that. This isn't Vietnam or about trying to help someone else
It is about an attack on us that left thousands of our people dead if we keep that one fact foremost in mind
We'll eventually find a way to get this done back in a moment
And welcome back now to page two of face the nation joining us now the Egyptian ambassador to the United States Nabil Fahmy
Mr. Fahmy and mr. Ambassador. Welcome to face the nation. Thank you
Yesterday Osama bin Laden put out another of his propaganda tapes and he said everybody that belongs to the United Nations
Arab Muslim Christian, whatever all of them are infidels
Egypt is a member of the United Nations. What's your response to Osama bin Laden?
I draw a very interesting conclusion from what he said frankly
This is a campaign that the international community as a whole has to take on
Terrorism is a threat against all of us and in many respects the UN is where it is the forum where we all gather
So this is another confirmation
He feels that the threat is coming that the response is coming from the community
And that's why he's nervous and angry
And I think we should continue to do what needs to be done to deal with Osama bin Laden
He is he is taking this he's trying to turn this into a war on Islam. Is he not?
He's been trying to take advantage of Islam
distort Islam to
Take on moderate regimes in the Middle East take on civilized society in the West and different parts of the world
But it's a distortion. I don't agree with the argument
Islam has nothing to do with what he's propagating but
International community as a whole has to work together
We've been facing this for 10 years before and we solved it domestically, but it remained around us
whether in Europe in Asia or
Wherever we cannot do it alone. We have to work together to solve this once and for all. Mr. Ambassador
The Bush administration has made it very clear that it does not intend to stop the bombing
During Ramadan. Do you believe that's a good idea or a mistake to deal with terrorism?
you will have to deal with security issues political issues social and economic issues and
Juridic issues legal issues. It's not going to be a one element campaign
In terms of dealing with the public the public in the Middle East
Will feel sensitive about bombings in in Ramadan that being said one has to factor in and balance
How much you gain how much you lose by continuing the campaign the major campaign during Ramadan whether you should do it or not?
It's a difficult call
If I had a choice
I would not but I would have to look at all the facts and all the figures before making a determination
So you're saying from the American point of view
It may not be a mistake
You would not but if you were President Bush
What I said is that if I had a choice
But but if I had all the facts before me if I knew exactly what had what had been done in the campaign
How far we've achieved in the intelligence corporation, for example and other things one would make a determination. I'm not even sure
Anybody is ready to say without looking at all the facts that it is right to do it or right not to do it
So it's a very difficult call and I think we have to be sensitive to the public
But the the threat is there and we have to continue this campaign
Mr. Ambassador, how do you characterize feelings in the Middle East right now in states like Egypt toward this war?
Does the man on the street in Egypt?
Think that this has been an attack on the United States that it's a terrorist attack
Or do they do they buy what bin Laden is saying that this is an attack on a religion?
No, not at all. They use the same argument with us and we are basically the majority is a Muslim Muslim country
So they use the same argument with us that we were infidels that we were not Muslims. We were not true believers
That's nonsense people in the street are totally against terrorism
Where you see occasionally criticism of the u.s. It does not relate to the campaign against terrorism
It is a function of other policies which can be debated legitimately, but not with bin Laden
What if the United States does have to put a large force of ground troops into Afghanistan will Egypt support that?
We have supported what the u.s. Has done so far which includes a military campaign against Afghanistan
Because we know the threat of terrorism this will have to continue but it will have to be coupled with other measures
The decision on whether to go with ground forces special forces or bombing is a military one one for the military advisors to decide
Mr. Ambassador, what if this war were to broaden and widen say to Iraq? Would you still be with us?
Issue is we're pursuing terrorists. We're not pursuing other issues as long as we're pursuing terrorism. We will be out there
Straight in the front. We were there before you on terrorists. Let's not pile up agendas
Let's keep the focus on what the issue is
Well, that doesn't answer though if we were to believe that that we would take the war on terrorism to Iraq
The point is how best to deal with the problem you have the terrorists who came to the u.s
We're living in Europe was a solution to that bombing Europe. How do you deal with this?
You deal with the problem in the way it's brought forward to you. Bombing is not the solution to all of the
Aspects of dealing with terrorism you would have had to bomb Germany bomb Great Britain and I would not recommend that
But you definitely have to work with them in making sure that civil society in these countries is not taken advantage of by terrorists
And that was our call ten years ago, mr. Ambassador, thank you very much for articulating that view today. Thank you for having me
We're going to continue our expanded coverage on face the nation after this short break
And as we continue to go at this story from every conceivable angle in Los Angeles this morning terrorism expert Brian Jenkins
Mr. Jenkins, thank you for coming here in the studio Seymour Hirsch of the New Yorker
So I want to start with you because this morning
Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld said
and this is not a direct quote, but the thrust of what he said was is that the Taliban has ceased to function as a
Government in Afghanistan now you have just written a piece in the New Yorker
which suggests that the first foray that we made in there with ground troops was
Almost a disaster as you put it get do you believe and from what you're talking to the people you're talking to that the Taliban
Is no longer functioning as a government in Afghanistan
Maybe not as a government
But certainly as a military force they exist and the article you're talking about simply made the point that our secret
I'll attempt to go invade the home of Mullah Amma the head of
The Taliban government was a near disaster as you say we came in hot and heavy with an awful lot of special forces did it?
By the book I guess with instead of going in the Delta forces our secret unit the most secret unit in the government
And they're very competent
They know how to hurt people and they like to operate by themselves and small teams instead the way we did
It was you know General Motors style hundreds of people 16 helicopters shoot them up
And when they got into the building where they hoped to either find the Mullah or his some of his documents
There was nothing there when they came out they got hit very heavily a big counter-attack, and it was a mess 12 serious injuries
three very serious and
All of this was kept from the American people there was a great deal of anger among the Delta force
I write about that. They're not sure they they want to operate this way mr.
Hirsch this morning though the chairman of the Joint Chiefs
Chairman Myers said that this from his point of view this this mission quote went
Flawlessly there was a total denial of your report and
Particularly when you had written that they were not properly prepared
He said nothing could be further from the truth, so how do you respond to that well?
We just have to ask you know we have to wait and see what happens
You know I've been there done it you and I Bob go back to the Vietnam War. Oh my God here
We are b-52s again, and they didn't work then. I'm not sure that
The facts are that as I described them it was a mess it was even more than that
I described the we all watched on television as we saw our Rangers parachute on you know remember the footage of that and
I write to that a lot of people were upset about that because before the Rangers went in we sent a special
Pathfinder team a little scout unit into the airfield with that they were attacking and the military command was told there was no soldiers
There no Taliban there. I think people who are not reporters always wonder
Where does this kind of information come from my suspicion is that this came from people?
The the people that talked to you were kind of upset about
How this had gone, and and they wanted people to know about that. I'm not asking you to disclose sources, but
What makes you think this is this is true?
I mean you wouldn't have written it if you had not thought it to be at a correct account
And also as you people know in the business the New Yorker has this incredible checking apparatus where the people I talked to actually
Independently talked to by the New Yorker staff to make sure we have no factual serious factual errors sure
Delta Force is mad Delta Force is so mad that
They think
The language is that this time we lost 12 next time if they do it again the same way we're gonna lose
You know dozens we can't operate that way we operate by ourselves independently not not that not that messy
Yeah, we didn't lose 12 people
12 people were injured now general Myers
And who was a general Frank's the head of the command over there says when you report 12 people were wounded
He said well it depends on what you count as a wound
Do you mean those were people that were shot or do you mean they were hurt most of them had shrapnel injuries nine was?
Nine were not that serious three were very seriously injured
Most had shrapnel most just got there was a lot the Taliban fired a lot of grenades at us and in the counter
They say none of them were injured in return fire from the Taliban
Okay, well we've had that before
All right, let's shift a little bit and talk a little bit about terrorism
Brian Jenkins you you've been following and and studying terrorism for a long long time out there on the west coast this week
Governor Davis comes out and said that the bridges out there the Golden Gate the Bay Bridge some of the others were targets of
terrorist attacks
He said he had gotten this information from law enforcement officials, and then they said well it wasn't quite that specific
I take it the bridges are still out there
But what's going on here with all of these?
Threats and alerts that we're getting and how seriously do you as a terrorism expert take these things?
Well as of this morning the bridges are still standing, and they're still busy
But the issue is as you point out the how we deal with these threats
We certainly in the wake of September 11th are hearing a lot more about
threats that probably we wouldn't have heard about before people have to understand that there's a high volume of
noise and terrorism
threats reports from intelligence
sources
warnings
And a lot of these most of these in fact almost all these turn out to be just that a lot of noise
But a decision has been made in a number of cases since September 11th that in fact we're going to share some of this noise
with the public
Is that the right thing to do or not I mean when people think they have a credible threat
I think the public would demand that that be communicated to them
The government is going to become more adept as time goes on and communicating this threat information
But the more important thing is that we as citizens are going to have to become more adept in dealing with it
Mr.. Jenkins as a terrorism expert. Let me just ask you bluntly. How hard is it to take out a bridge?
It is extremely difficult if we're talking about actually dropping the bridge and some of the more lurid
speculation
Of scenarios of that type it is extremely difficult can one set off a bomb on a bridge of course one can
But to actually topple a bridge takes a great deal of effort not easily done
Mr.. Jenkins, let me ask you about a report that was done by a Houston law firm
Which has a Washington office Bracewell and Patterson they have a lot of energy clients, and they've done a study
on the threat to our
Energy infrastructure, let me just read you a couple of things here
They say since September 11th there have been credible threats to the trans Alaska
Pipeline and the nuclear power plant at Three Mile Island
They say there is no overall federal security requirement for the trans Alaska pipeline or any other pipeline
They say a well-designed terrorist attack hitting several energy facilities at once has the potential of causing entire
regional power grids to fail
That sounds like pretty serious business to me it
Clearly is serious in fact this was a topic of recent hearings that a at a Senate hearing at which
Senator Biden presided where we were looking at the security of critical infrastructure in this country
The problem we have is if we are going to catalog all of the vulnerabilities in our society
we're going to end up with 50 volumes before we get off of the east coast a
Lot of things in our society are very very vulnerable to sophisticated and determined terrorist attacks
Clearly security is going to have to be increased around these most
Critical components of our infrastructure that is something that we have to do now
We probably are not realistically going to be able to deal with every single vulnerability. They are infinite
Well sigh hurts. Where does that leave us?
well
we have to simply prepare for a long war and we have to go to the root the root of the evil seems to me to
Be we've got to get we've got to figure out some way to stop fundamentalism
We've got to make conditions for the average person in the Arab world better
Too many suffer too many go to these kind of extreme actions because they have no chance
There's no life for many of them in in Egypt in Saudi Arabia in Kuwait. The money doesn't flow down. There's no trickle-down
Mr. Hirst doesn't that doesn't this all come down really to a matter of our human intelligence on the ground in Afghanistan as well as even
Here at home. Do we have a real intelligence gathering problem in this country? No, we have terrible problems
You know, we have an FBI that needs to be retrained and how to do terrorism
We have a CIA that's been diminished in terms of its ability to collect human intelligence right now
Everybody talks about no Pashto speakers. We're using Israelis
We've recently recruited some Israelis to work to help us translate documents in Pashto the native tongue of the Taliban
So we have a big huge problem. We will solve it as somebody said to me in the article
I just wrote it's like you read a 600 page mystery the last two pages tell you the end
But you have to read 598 pages to get there. Well, we're on page 15. We'll get there
It's just gonna take a long time Brian Jenkins a final thought from you
What do we need to do to improve our intelligence gathering?
Are we is in bad shape as Cy Hirst says we are well intelligence is never adequate unless you're absolutely confident
but you'll be able to identify every terrorist cell in the world and and
Predict and thwart every conceivable threat, so it's never going to be adequate. It's it's always a challenge
But the fact is September 11th has awakened us to the fact that it is an extremely dangerous world for a decade
We have pretended to believe that it is not that with the end of the Cold War the collapse of the Soviet Union
That all we needed to do was basically
Commit ourselves to accumulating wealth and spreading prosperity
Ignoring the fact that there are real threats out there. This has awakened us
All right, I want to thank both of you to get your perspective on all of this
We're going to continue our expanded coverage and we'll talk to Sandy Berger who was President Clinton's National Security Advisor in a minute
As we continue now our roundtable with Sandy Berger who was the former National Security Advisor to President Clinton Doyle McManus
Our old friend from the Los Angeles Times
Mr. Berger, let me ask you first about what happened in Israel this morning
We had a Palestinian gunman and other of these incidents open fire on a busload of Israeli citizens
We know of some deaths many injuries and now the Israeli government is saying it may review its
Decision made earlier to pull back from one of the West Bank towns where it had Israeli troops
How serious is this and what what needs to happen here another outrageous act of terrorism against innocent people?
riding a bus
I think the situation is very dangerous and very precarious
I don't believe that the two sides here can break this death grip by themselves, Bob
I think the international community led by the United States
is going to have to
exercise all the moral authority
that we have
To press them to implement the steps that they have agreed to
to achieve
De-escalation. Well, you've been there and you know how difficult this is. You can't just say please don't do it
I mean, please let's get together. What what are the steps that need to be taken here? How do you get this?
Well, they've agreed that they have agreed to the steps
That have to be taken step by step
what we need now is
seven days of accountability or or two weeks of accountability in which the international community is there with a
spotlight and a stopwatch
Putting the pressure on both sides to do what they've said
They've said they would do in the absence of
Breaking this cycle. We're facing a very very dangerous descent in the Middle East
Which is going to complicate
Not only disasters for the Middle East but complicate the larger situation we face
Speaking of the larger situation Doyle you heard the ambassador here talk about
bombing
Bombing during during Ramadan. Do you think that will make any difference in terms of our already tenuous coalition?
I think it will Gloria what the ambassador was talking about was in a sense the front
We're paying not enough attention to which is the war for opinion within
The Muslim world and that really requires the United States to do what it can on
Israel on Ramadan what I am hearing from the White House is that while they've been saying this week
There's not going to be a bombing halt through the whole month
They are sending signals that there will be
Pauses at the most sacred times of Ramadan the first night the last night on the 27th night of Ramadan
These are the important holidays that month
They do want to send a gesture of sensitivity to the Muslim world for domestic political consumption
Particularly among conservative Republicans who are calling for absolutely no halt. Isn't that gonna cause them a domestic political problem?
Well, the point they're gonna make is this isn't a bombing pause for the whole war and the war can survive a couple of nights
of rest
Sandy Berger you have been involved in the past in dealing with terrorism. You've seen these terrorism alerts
We've been going through two so far in this country. Can you tell us a little bit about how?
How the White House decides to go with something or not to go with something?
Well, there's an enormous amount of threat information some of it more credible than others you act on everything
The question is what do you warn?
I
Think we're in a situation now where the American people are on the heightened state of alert
We look around every room we walk in we look at every parcel
So my own view is that we ought now when unless we have specific information that can actually help people
Make decisions we ought to say to the American people. Listen, we're living in a more dangerous world
We're going to be attacked by terrorism again. We're doing everything we can on the security side. And here's what we're doing
We're doing everything we can to fight terrorism if we learn anything
That is actually going to help you make a decision about what to do where to go. We'll tell you otherwise
You are on alert
So no more enough general alert
I think it's a it's a tough call because no one wants to be sitting on a piece of intelligence
The day after something terrible happens, but we are all already as a people on a heightened state of alert
We're almost at a hyper heightened state of alert, and I think again it goes to the utility of the information
but these are very very tough calls and and
And they have to be made ultimately on a case-by-case, but what does it mean when they say we have intercepts
It means we've heard a conversation, but let me let me just tell you another part of this Bob
Again, if we have something specific that can help people that's fine. But in a sense we empower people
This is now telephone terrorism in a sense that we've empowered
All all of bin Laden's operatives have to do now is have a chit-chat on the phone
and
That's a that suddenly get sounds
Begins at a kind of a shockwave through the system. So we have to I think
Continually recalibrate. I think the administration is doing that every day
Clearly the American people need to know what
Generally what is useful to them, but I'm not sure the kind of continuing
The next 24 hours something's gonna happen is terribly helpful. Don't well, what do you think is gonna happen?
What is the president gonna talk about? What is he think he needs to talk to the American people about this week?
well
clearly what has happened over the last week Bob is that the
The message has slipped away a little bit from the White House
as the story shifted from the war an issue on which the president was quite effective during the first three weeks to
Anthrax an issue on which White House officials not openly but privately to us said we really don't want to put the president in the
Position of answering questions that we don't have the answer to you want to keep a president away from bad news
That's just good politics. Well, the focus has shifted away
We have not had the sense of presidential leadership and indeed in the Middle East
There's been the sense that Osama bin Laden somehow has a better propaganda apparatus than we do
I think that's a transitory thing. He is going to go back to the basics
He is gonna go back to the basics of why this war started why we're in it
He's gonna try and preach patience again the fact that we're only four weeks into the war and that doesn't mean we're in a quagmire
Yeah, you know that raises an interesting question just from the standpoint of public relations and and the president's credibility
It seems to me that the great
the credibility that Franklin Roosevelt had was that he told the American people what the bad news was and then when he had some good
News to announce I think that helped them to believe it
I mean after all it was President Roosevelt who announced what had happened at Pearl Harbor
He didn't have a lower-level official do that
And I wonder Sandy is this president going to have to start telling people the bad news as well as the good news
We're in the early stages of this Bob
And I think that we this is the question is whether a democracy can fight a shadowy war under continuing public
Scrutiny and I do think in this next phase the president needs to help bring the American people a sense up the learning curve
There's a tremendous desire for context. I think among the American people and
Listen, this is a terribly complex
Problem administration is managing. I think they're doing a good job managing. It's a it's a
multi-front war, but I think
bringing the American people along so they understand the complexity of this not sugarcoating it but
Helping them understand
This I think is an important part of the leadership at this point
The next step of bringing the American people along may be making the case for ground troops Doyle
Has the president done that or is that what he is also gonna have to do in this next week?
He hasn't done that yet Gloria and it seems the signals we're getting from the White House is he has no
inclination to do that in this coming week simply because he and his advisors in the Pentagon think it is as I think senator Hagel
Said way premature
To get into that. I don't think we're gonna hear a lot about ground troops from the president to me
The fascinating thing is only four weeks into this war. We've got a very lively debate in the Senate on it
The question is on the table. Are we willing to put substantial troops on the ground to fight this war?
Well, I mean I think what's going on is the Senate that most senators say if you need to do it
We're ready to go along with you
And that's one reason I wonder why the president doesn't say look I may have to do this down the line because he's got a
Lot of people on record right now. They're saying they'd be willing to support it
Well, I think there would be support and we're clearly we're gonna have to use ground forces, but let's step back a second here Bob
We're five or six weeks into this. There's no problem free strategy here in the last week
We've had the administration has been criticized for bombing too too early not letting the Taliban foment
Furman I guess is a better word bombing not early enough
Not putting in enough ground troops
Preparing us for a quagmire. There's no problem free strategy here
We're in the early stages
And I think it's a little too early to start second-guessing sound like you're speaking like a former national security adviser who's in there
It's a lot easier
When you don't have to make decisions
All right, I would say that one thing I think speaking of spin where there's been one mistake made perhaps
It was made by Osama bin Laden
He seems to have isolated himself by accusing all the other Arabs who are in the United Nations of being infidels
It seems to me. He'd be trying to bring them together
I'm not one to give him any advice, but I think he may have messed up on that one gentlemen. Thank you very much
That's our broadcast for today. Thanks for watching face the nation. We'll see you next week
