"Freedom was just turned into this caricature…We kept hearing about 'freedumbs'…'Oh, those freedom lovers, they want to be able to get their sandwich at Arby's or get their nails done at the salon'—as though that's really what people were asking for."
Gabrielle Bauer, author of “Blindsight Is 2020: Reflections on Covid Policies from Dissident Scientists, Philosophers, Artists & More”
And I found that also disconcerting how, during the pandemic, freedom was just turned into this
caricature. You know how we kept hearing about free dumbs, D-U-M-B-S, and all these people were
mocking, oh, those free dumb lovers, they want to be able to get their sandwich at Arby's or get
their nails done at the salon, as though that's really what people were asking for. You know,
people died for our freedoms. The whole Western civilization has been built on this idea of
freedom. So it was so disconcerting to see just how most people were completely willing to give
it up in the name of some hypothetically greater safety, which didn't even turn out to be greater
safety. And protections of freedoms are there precisely for this type of situation. They're
for the situation where it's incredibly inconvenient. Exactly. Exactly. It's like we
say about freedom of speech. No one needs to have speech protected when what you're saying is, oh,
I believe in world peace. No, you need speech protected when you say controversial things that
are going to piss people off. So it's the same thing. It's for the hard times that you find out
what people think about freedom and that you find out what you think about it, whether it matters
or not. I counted. I think you have 11 American thought leaders. I think about a quarter of your
thought leaders. That means there's a lot of people in here that are of great, great interest
to me. Is there someone that particularly inspired you? I know a lot of people felt very alone.
The people that thought what they were seeing was crazy. You told me about this, if you feel
okay about it. You said you actually got therapy. How did that work? Was it over Zoom?
That's all that was available at the time. I called him Dr. Zoom, not to his face, but when
I was talking about him with my husband, I'd call him Dr. Zoom. I sought out therapy because I needed
to understand why everyone thought, the people around me, because largely I belong to middle
class and I have largely so-called progressive circle. I needed to understand why all this was
troubling me so much and not them. I was prone to doubting myself. I actually asked him at one
point, I said, so am I a sociopath? Is there really something wrong with me? He said, no,
there's no sociopath on earth that introspects as much as you do. You don't have to worry.
I'm partly joking, but I really did doubt myself at some point just because I was surrounded by
all these people that thought this was the way to go. He was great. He was perfect for the job.
We talked much more about philosophy than about psychotherapy. We talked about deontology and
consequentialism and all these postmodernists. He was great. He was very well educated.
What also made him unique is he was more mainstream than I was in terms of
adhering to the policies or believing in the policies, but he never, ever, ever shamed me.
I've heard from many people who went to see therapists also wanting to sort out some of
the stuff, and their therapist just said, I'm sorry, I can't go there with you.
You need to do this stuff for the greater good, so we can't really talk about it.
On lockdown skepticism, I've heard so many people report stories like that. I consider myself very
lucky that this Dr. Zoom had the breadth of mind to just listen and work through it with me.
I mean, shocking, right? Because you would think of the one area where you should be able to have
complete freedom to share whatever is on your mind, however crazy, right? In fact, that's the
reason that you're doing it. But not that shocking, because there was this, you call it a mind virus,
call it groupthink. So the theme that I've come across, the biggest theme is that I didn't grasp
at all prior to this pandemic, is just our need to belong as human beings. It's kind of
unbelievable to me how powerful or the converse of that. I had a recent guest on who kind of
goes to see the need to belong or the fear of ostracism, and how that can drive people to do
the craziest of things or say the most terrible things or to show that actually, no, I'm on the
Yeah, it's very primal. I think it's baked into our DNA, the fear of being shunned. And that was
really the tactics that the mainstream enforcers of the narrative did use. It was shunning.
Again, you were called the vilest names, like sociopath, sociopath, eugenicist. I mean,
those were the memes that they threw at you, if you dared to question in even the most polite ways,
what was going on. And those are thought stopping words that are designed to put people in their
place. And one of the chapters in the book is devoted to this Matthias Desmet, who talks about
that and really explores that whole idea of groupthink and mob psychology, which he calls
mass formation. That was a term that he coined for that. Other people later ran with the term
and tacked on the word psychosis, mass formation psychosis, but he doesn't actually use psychosis,
just mass formation, which is another way to say, just crazy mob psychology,
which people are vulnerable to when society is in a state of atomization, people are not really
connected, there isn't really a strong sense of communion, there's a lot of stress, a lot of
isolation. And that makes people vulnerable to these forces. And then they, they start connecting
to this, well, to the authorities, to this collective. And, you know, that is one step
toward the establishment of totalitarianism.