News from Hubble and Across the Universe! November 2013

Hubble Space Telescope
12 followers
Sep 5, 2023
This month, Dr. Frank Summers show us the latest on Comet ISON and a unique asteroid with six tails, along with a preview look at the most distant galaxies Hubble will ever image!
Okay, it says live, so we'll see what happens.
Okay, great. Hello everyone,
welcome to our latest Hubble Hangout. My name is Tony Darnell, I'm with the Space Telescope
Science Institute,
and with me today is Dr. Frank Summers and we're having our
monthly Hangout where we do our sort of live
Hubble news update. We're a little bit behind this month, about a
week behind than we usually do these. We usually do these the first Wednesday of
the month, but we couldn't last
week because of some scheduling conflicts, I believe. I don't know why we
couldn't do it. Do you know, Frank?
Well, because I didn't... I was doing the...
I gave the talk last Tuesday night, and so I was working on the major talk and I
didn't really have enough
together to do the news from the universe
last week. So I'm doing it now as a supplement to
what I did last week as giving the main talk. That's right, so the
what he's referring to is the Hubble... I'm sorry, not the Hubble...
Sorry, there's a distracting
background that I'm listening to. I hope you can't hear. I can't hear it, Tony.
You're coming through nice and clear over on this end. Okay, good.
So we're struggling a little bit with technology today. I do apologize. It's
been one of those days where things have just been
one snafu after another. So what Frank is referring to is the Hubble public
lecture series
that we do at the Institute each month, the first Tuesday of the month.
And last Tuesday, Frank, I guess it went really well, right?
It was actually our largest audience we've ever had
for the public lecture series. You had a packed house.
We had a packed house and... well, I mean, we did have a few empty seats, you know. We could have
fit a few more people,
but usually we only get 60 or 70 people
and last week we got about 130, 140 people.
So it was actually quite a lot of fun. Now, was that because of the
subject matter, do you think? What made that one
popular? What did you talk about last week?
I actually polled the audience before I started talking and
they didn't say it was the subject matter. They didn't say it was me as the
speaker. It just seemed to be
sort of happenstance to them. But what I did talk about was
the topical thing of comet ISON and comets in general
because, of course, comet ISON is going to make its perihelion passage
on Thanksgiving Day this month. That's right, and we're going to talk about that a little bit
in just a few minutes, but
let me remind everybody that in addition to
the normal ways we interact with you guys, I also have the
new Q&A feature that's been turned on, that they just added.
It seems like every time we do a Hangout, there is a...
they've rearranged everything and I have to relearn the entire interface.
Today, I'm activating this thing called Q&A. I hope
you get to... Uh-oh, it does say I've got an echo.
Thank you, Hugo. I will see if I can fix that as we go on.
Anyway, so Frank, why don't you start since you don't have an echo
and give us a brief summary of what you were talking about
last week. And I'm going to poke around my settings. Okay, I'm going to turn off the
speaker so
I can... I'm going to turn my speaker down so I can barely hear you.
Maybe that will help with the echo and things. Okay.
Let me see. Testing, testing, one, two, three. That is better.
It is better. Okay, great. So I can just barely hear you.
So I'm going to start my screen share. Okay, and can you see my first slide?
Because I can't see it just yet.
Tony, can you hear me? I can hear you just fine, loud and clear. Great, okay.
I just hadn't gotten any confirmation on that. Alright, so
my talk last week was called Great Comments from Humble Origins
and Eyes on ISON. The idea being, of course, that, you know,
I wanted to talk about comets in general
in case ISON wasn't going to be this fantastic comet that it
just might be. And so
what I talked about... I gave a whole talk about
where comets come from and the Kuiper belt and the Oort cloud.
Then went on to talk about the
things about comet ISON. And if you remember in our last
news from Hubble, we talked about observing ISON with
this instrument. This is the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter.
And how they were able to, as ISON flew past Mars,
take a picture of comet ISON.
And here is that picture. It is totally
underwhelming. But the point being that
comet ISON wasn't bigger than one pixel
in the MRO images. And so
that meant that it's actually really confirmed to be actually rather small.
And that's a little bit of a worry, because a larger object would
have a better chance of surviving perihelion passage.
And so we're kind of worried that it might end up like
this, that as it goes through the perihelion passage, and this is a
diagram showing you just how close it is going to get to the Sun. It's going to
get
2.7 solar radii from the center of the Sun.
And so it's really going to be
really close. And so
the question is whether it's going to survive.
And is it going to end up like this unfortunate comet,
which is comet Schwarzschild-Wachmann 3.
And this was observed by Hubble several years ago.
And you can see that the comet broke to pieces. And you can see that
with Hubble's fine resolution, we can really tell
if the comet is going to be,
if the comet has broken apart. Well, fortunately, and
the folks on this have probably seen this, Hubble got an image
on October 9th of this year and was able to definitively tell that
comet ISON looks like it's still intact.
We didn't see any of the telltale signs of a comet
breaking up. Matter of fact, there had been a paper on the
listserv of astronomy papers saying that
it looks like comet ISON is on track to break up.
And there was predictions that it would be fading relatively quickly.
Well, this Hubble image shows us that it is not breaking up.
And so we can look forward to comet ISON brightening.
And it has brightened since then. This is a plot from
someone who processes all the data that's submitted to the Minor Planet Center.
And this is the track of comet ISON over the past year or so.
Actually, they have, on the left-hand side, you can see some pre-discovery observations they got
to track its brightness. And it was following one track,
but it seems to have shifted to a second track. It's a little
fainter than we had expected.
Well, back up just a little. I guess you're going to go in. You're zooming in now.
I'm going to zoom in, yeah. I'm not going to cheat you on that one.
Okay, go ahead. Okay, so now when I zoom in, you can see somewhere around
April, they drew that red line in that drops a bit.
And that's the new track. They got the green track, which was the original track they
expected it to follow.
And then they overdraw this red track with this sort of drop down around April of
2013, saying, okay, this is the new track that they believe it's following.
And you can see as it's heading up towards perihelion and getting brighter,
it seems to have followed this new track quite well.
So we're pleased that we can actually feel like we're
have a relatively good prediction for it. And on this next slide,
you can see the peak around perihelion.
And again, this is just a prediction. We, you know, as they say,
comets are a lot like cats. They both have tails
and they do whatever the hell they want to do.
We don't really know what ISON will do, but
it's following this track reasonably well. And that
magical green line that I've drawn there at sixth magnitude
is the rough approximation for when it will become naked eye visible, where you can
see it
without a telescope.
Can you back up that? Well, no, I'll finish what you're saying and then I have another question.
Okay, and you can see that that only occurs for about a month
from around 1120
on to about 1220. Okay, so the 20th of November
to about the 20th of December is the only time it's going to be
naked eye visible, so it's really short. And actually,
in the first part, in November, we get full moon on November 17th,
so that's going to interfere with it and you're not really going to be able to see
much of it there. So if we're going to see it with the naked eye,
it's going to be in those first few weeks of December and the moon goes into
full moon, new moon,
on December 2nd. And so that will be the time that we'll be able to see it.
And the time of evening will be early morning or
late afternoon or what will be the best time of the evening to see it?
Perfect, perfect cue in for my next slides.
Okay, so before you do them,
can you back up to one more slide? I just want to go back to something that I remember.
Okay. So there's that red line, it's got that discontinuity there,
where it just suddenly shifts down. And this has to do with new observations
that they had taken that was starting to...
I think, really Tony, the shift down is just a recalibration.
They're just changing their minds and saying, oops, wait a minute, it isn't following that track,
so they dropped it down
a magnitude or so. Okay, so that was just an adjustment on their
algorithm or whatever model they were using to figure it out.
Exactly. Okay, alright. So it wasn't actually, no comet has ever predicted just to
drop a magnitude. No, no, I know that. That's why I wanted to go back to that. So I wanted to
sort of clarify, glitches like that are not a natural thing, so...
Right. I think, I guess, in April, they looked at it and said, you know,
it's really not following the original track.
Let's recalibrate and start from here again. Okay.
Yeah. Alright, thank you. So you led beautifully
into what we're going to get to next in terms of when we'll get to see it, but
actually I remember there's a couple really cool slides. This is a great
picture
from an English astrophotographer named Damien Peach.
Fantastic one. I think this has been on APOD. It's been all over the internet.
What's really cool about it is that you can see there is a green glow to the
head of the comet.
Okay. It's a cool green glow. Actually, a lot of comets do have this green glow.
It's due to cyanogen molecules
as well as diatomic carbon
that when exposed to the high energy of the Sun's light,
they actually glow green. And, of course, people wonder, what is cyanogen? That sounds
kind of strange.
It's actually in the cyanide family. Alright. You actually will have, it breaks
down and you can actually get hydrogen cyanide
in the tail of the comet. Sounds healthy. Yes.
And people, this of course alarms people.
It alarmed them so much in 1910 when we actually flew through the tail of Halley's
Comet
that some unscrupulous people sold people
anti-comet pills. Ah, yes. I made a fortune that day.
You can see they're selling them for only 25 cents
each, which, of course, 25 cents in 1910 money was actually a good amount of money.
They sold gas masks and anti-comet
umbrellas and all sorts of stuff.
It was amazing what people will fall for. Of course,
the density of the gas is so, so, so
rarefied that it poses absolutely no threat to us here
on Earth. But it's always fun to look back and see what
some people will believe. Yeah, well, you just didn't know.
So, where to look at on the
night sky? We have, this is a chart by Matthew Cook
that shows the constellations it goes through, which is
useful for those of us who study the night sky.
I put it up here for folks who actually are very familiar with the night
sky. It goes past, you know, perihelion is over here in Libra
and goes up through Serpens and Coron and Borealis. But that's not what most people want.
Most people want are
these viewing charts. And this first one here is from Sky and Telescope. This is
the most famous.
If you look, just do Comet ISON viewing chart. This is the one you'll find on the
Internet.
And it shows that in the morning, before sunrise,
Comet ISON will slowly get higher
over the first two weeks or so. And you can see the scale bar of 10 degrees there.
So, in the first two weeks it'll rise 10, 20
and 30 degrees above the horizon in December. And that's when
our best chance we'll be able to see it. It actually rises higher
above the horizon in the morning.
But, it is also viewable in the evening.
So, here's another chart from a guy named,
who writes a blog. His name is Astrobob.
And this is the evening, shortly after sunset.
And the Comet, as I said, doesn't get quite as high in the evening.
So, you won't have as good a shot. But, if you have a really clear horizon,
you will be able to see the Comet both morning and
evening for looking at ISON.
So, this is assuming after Thanksgiving it makes it
past the Sun. What are the, any predictions, Frank? Do you think it's gonna,
do you think it's gonna make it?
Well, I have, I recently studied
Comet Lovejoy. In 2011, Comet Lovejoy came past the Sun.
And we were relatively convinced that Lovejoy was gonna break up.
Because Lovejoy, ISON,
Lovejoy went 1.2 solar radii
away from the center of the Sun. Which meant it was, you know, 20 percent of a solar radius
above the Sun. And that's really, really close.
This one is going to be 1.2 solar radii above the Sun,
1.7 solar radii above the surface of the Sun. So, it's gonna be,
you know, relatively far away compared to Lovejoy. Although, relatively close, it is a
Sun grazer comet.
So, given the results of Lovejoy,
I'm gonna say that ISON is gonna survive its perihelion. It's gonna make for a decent show,
but I don't think it's gonna make for a spectacular show.
The phrase, comet of the century, the great comets,
you know, the comets of the decade, maybe comet of the year,
but not necessarily comet of the decade for this one. That's my prediction.
Okay, well, that seems pretty reasonable. I'm
hearing that my echo's back. Frank, can I ask you to do me a quick favor? Can you
just mute for a second and let me see if the echo goes away?
Okay, so... Okay, so now I'm talking, but I have...
Oh, that one's gone away. My speaker totally turned off.
Okay. Okay. Okay, so anyway, I think the problem is that Frank just...
You know, we weren't able to get him some headphones for this one, and so I
think it's...
It's part of the speaker's coming out and going back into his
microphone. So, I do apologize. I will try and mitigate that as much as I can.
Like, right now, it's gone. So, that's a real...
So, that's... Hopefully, we'll stay that way for a little bit. I'm really sorry about
that, folks.
So, I guess
my next question is... I wanted to point out that there's going to be a hangout
done by the
folks at Goddard, at NASA Goddard on Comet ISON,
on Thanksgiving Day. They haven't posted the link to it yet,
but I want to let you guys know that it is... On Thanksgiving Day, what they're
going to do is have a hangout from the Solar Dynamics Observatory guys, where
they will
show live... Well,
by live, as soon as they get data off of the spacecraft,
and show Comet ISON as it passes
behind the Sun. So,
hopefully, that will be a spectacular sight. I didn't know, first of all,
that SDO could get things so quickly,
but yeah, apparently, they're going to be downloading data, and within
15 minutes, they're going to have
something to show. So, once I get the idea of when that event is, or when they
post it, I will
also post it on our Twitter channel and our Facebook pages, and things like that,
so you guys can find out about it.
Otherwise, I would provide a link for it right now, but that's Thanksgiving Day.
Hopefully, it'll be before you have to sit down, and
if you're in the States, that's a big holiday. If you're in another part of the
world,
then you don't really know what I'm talking about, probably, but
that'll be a really cool thing that I'm planning on taking some time out to
watch as well. So, I did want to let you guys know about that.
And, is one... Another
question that I had before we... Are we about to leave
Comet ISON, Frank? Because I see something... Yeah, we're ready to move on to the news and news.
Before we do, I want to ask you a couple quick questions that I get.
One of them we got in our ISON Hangout that we did a while back, and that is
this...
The flyby from Mars. Remember when it did that?
When the Comet ISON passed really close to Mars. We didn't get very good
pictures of it. Now, I know
that you mentioned, during our last Hangout, why that was. These were
cameras that weren't
designed to image... Weren't designed to image
up in the sky. They were designed to image bright things on the surface of Mars.
But, there was some
interesting ideas. I get... There was some interesting comments I'd like you to
respond to. One of them was,
why didn't we get... Why didn't we put more emphasis on this flyby, do you think?
Why didn't we hear more about it
from NASA?
In terms of the press coverage of the...
Yeah, I guess it was the sense, or I got this sense from people,
that there was not enough attention given to that Mars flyby. For example, why
didn't we have
telescopes in orbit? I would say simply because the government was shut down at the time.
When ISON flew by
Mars, the government was shut down and the official websites weren't actually
posting things.
Yeah, but I guess what I'm trying to get you to respond to is the
idea of the science... Was it a very scientifically
interesting thing to do? Let's say the government was open and let's say,
you know, all of that. Is there anything
that we could have gained from watching this flyby of Mars?
Based on the results, it doesn't look like
that we got anything amazingly interesting.
These repurposing of an instrument
to do something that wasn't intended to do is always risky.
It's always a chance. Maybe you'll get, you know,
what you hoped for. Maybe you'll get more than you hoped for. But I think if you're
managing expectations,
you don't want to put a lot of emphasis on something and then have it be a dud.
And since you really didn't know
what was going to come from this, I can't imagine really...
I can see how they wouldn't have tried to make a big deal
out of it. That they would have just said, okay, we're going to do it.
We'll see what we get and try to keep it relatively quiet.
Until if they got something amazing, then it's easier to,
you know, trumpet it afterwards than it is if you trumpet it too much in advance and
then you end up looking even worse.
Okay, so as a test of the Q&A feature, Scott Lewis, who is
watching this with us right now, has asked a question on the Q&A thing
that I'd like to see if you can respond to. It says, what is
the resolution of the camera of MRO, the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter,
compared to the angular size of ISON from its perspective?
Okay, the number of pixels in that image looked like it was around
1024 pixels. That's just
my impression of it. But I do know that ISON,
at the distance ISON was when it took the image,
one pixel was, it's either 8 miles or 8 kilometers. I can't remember.
I always get mixed up in terms of miles and kilometers because
as a scientist I work in kilometers but as someone in public outreach I work in miles.
I know 8 was the number I remember but
probably it was 8 miles.
So the size of ISON was not larger than one pixel
and that confirmed that the previous estimates that its size was, you know,
three to five
miles in size was probably correct.
Right, okay, thank you. So I'm, this is kind of a neat little thing I'm
using here. Okay, so I guess that,
okay, so I guess that's it for the ISON topic. I just wanted to get to those
questions so I guess we can go to the next
part here. Okay, let me
get my screen share going again. Okay. There we go.
The echo seems better so that's good. Okay.
Alright, so first story tonight
is related to comets but I understand you're going to have a hangout on this soon so I
won't take too much
on this but Chasing Tails.
So this on the left hand side here
is the nucleus of comet Borale.
And you can see that it resembles to a certain extent
the object on the right which is the asteroid Gaspra.
When you actually get down to what the heart of a comet really is
it's just an irregularly shaped ice ball
as opposed to an asteroid which is an irregularly shaped rock.
To try and make it very simple
we like to say that comet nuclei are ice with some rock
and that asteroids are rocks with some ice because of course we have seen
ice on some asteroids. But
comets at their heart really
look a bit like asteroids but asteroids can sometimes look like comets.
And a couple years ago, two years ago I believe, we released this
image and it has a cometary name
P2010A2 where the P means it's periodic
2010 is the year it was discovered and A2 means it was discovered
it was the second comet discovered in the first half of January. That's what that A2
designation is. But something with a tail like this
looks like a comet. It's given a cometary designation but
if you zoom in on the front of it
you can see it definitely doesn't look like a comet. It's got that
bright dot and then it's got this sort of X-shaped pattern of things going on there.
And what we believe happened here
is that two asteroids
collided and they smashed together and
created plumes of dust. And those dust plumes create this sort of
X-shaped pattern you see here. And then that dust
also then gets swept back by radiation pressure from the Sun
and becomes that big long tail that
is apparent in the previous image here.
So Frank, does that X mark
the spot where the collision occurred, do you think? Or is that just
that it drifted further back? I would have a tough time
trying to pull out the orbital dynamics of that from
a 2D image. Oh really? Okay.
You definitely see that there are some plumes, some denser plumes there that
sort of
form that X. But as to whether that would be
where the collision occurred, I
kind of doubt it because we're taking a whole lot of 3D space and smashing it
into 2D here.
But I had not used the X marks the spot idea previously.
I'll have to think about that. That's kind of difficult.
So it's important for people to realize that when things in space collide
they tend to, you know, what the bits and pieces that were created tend to
follow along
some combined trajectory that they make after the collision. So
the lot of the stuff, whatever it collided with, is probably still
following around in the same general path, right?
Exactly. Some of it gets blown away
like the tails of the comets by the radiation pressure of the Sun.
But the denser, smaller and denser pieces
just continue on standard orbital trajectories around the Sun
which they're following mostly the same trajectory that they had
going into the collision. They just get spread out on the dispersion of the path.
That's awesome. So we have seen some of these objects
but we have never, ever,
ever seen an object like the one we released last week.
Last Thursday we released this image of an object called P2013-P5.
Again, it's got a cometary designation
but it's actually an asteroid.
And we've never seen something like this. Now if you look carefully in this
image, they tell me you can count six different tails.
I can easily see five. Trying to pick out where the sixth tail is
is a little bit difficult but I trust them.
I trust the astronomers who did the analysis.
And this is just totally crazy.
You've got five plumes of dust coming off
of this object, going off in different directions.
And, you know, it's actually the whole thing is rotating relatively quickly and
moving around the sky.
So you can see in 13 days the perspective on it changed.
I think the geometry of the six different tails didn't change
but the perspective on the object and its rotation did change.
And you end up with quite a
crazy idea of an asteroid with six tails.
So the idea here is possibly
that this asteroid is rotating so quickly
it's been torqued up by radiation pressure from the Sun.
It's now rotating so quickly that material is actually streaming off of it.
That's the hypothesis right now. It's
really not well in terms of this.
But that's the best guess that
the astronomer Dave Jewett can come up with.
And Dave Jewett is a really good astronomer.
If you've never heard of him, we astronomers have definitely heard of him.
He's one of the
most famous solar system astronomers out there.
So his best guess is going to be much better than my best guess.
So Tony, you're doing a hangout about this sometime soon, aren't you?
That's correct. I was just going to bring that up.
If you want to learn more about this particular observation and this
body,
we're going to have a hangout tomorrow with Dr. Jewett.
Max Musher will be there as well as
the other co-hosts that we usually have with the Hubble Hangouts to talk
about this some more.
So we invite you definitely to check it out. It's tomorrow
at 4 p.m. Eastern Time. So the event's already out. So I would encourage you to
check it out if you want to learn more about this. I have a question here
from somebody, Judy Schmidt,
who is asking, why hasn't P2010A2 been given a new name since it's not
a comet?
I'm not a solar system astronomer, so I don't
totally know why,
but anything with a tail, anything that has a tail
gets a cometary designation. And maybe it keeps that cometary designation as
well as keeping
its minor planet number. Asteroids are generally just
given numbers, so it probably has a dual designation
of both a cometary designation of this as well as
a minor planet number for its asteroid
designation. So I know you're getting ready to go on to another topic real quick,
but before we do, I just
I want to ask you to pick your brain on something here, which is
when we were doing the Comet ISON, there were some
interviews being done with video on a recent
workshop that was held over here in Baltimore.
And one of the questions that was being asked of the
cometary scientists at the time, and I thought was a very interesting one,
and I'd like to get your opinion on this, Frank. It turns out that I think most
planetary scientists believe that comets pose a greater threat
to the Earth than asteroids. At least that's what many of them said.
Can you comment on what you think about that? Because I found that that,
you know, I hadn't really thought about that before. I was actually
discussing this with some folks the other night, because
when I did my talk, I showed all of the
Earth-crossing asteroids, and
then I over plotted all of the periodic comets that also
well, all of the periodic comets, and I zoomed in on that to show the ones that
also cross Earth's orbit. And
at least from the periodic comets, it didn't seem like there was a lot
that threatened Earth. I didn't
find anything that worried me about those.
The ones we know about, perhaps, but aren't there
these Oort cloud comets like ISON that come out of nowhere that we don't know
about?
Right, and that's the thing that I'm trying to
move on to, is that
actually for the short-period comets
and for the asteroids, they have
had their orbits relatively circularized to a certain extent, and maybe
elliptical to a certain amount,
but they're going to change their orbits relatively slowly.
They aren't going to have these drastic appearances.
We had an appearance in the sky of Comet Lovejoy, not the great comet of 2011,
Lovejoy, but a brand new one discovered by the same guy, Terry Lovejoy,
and it is now the brightest comet in the night sky.
It was only discovered in September.
So, this is two months later, less than two months later,
that we've got the brightest comet in the morning sky.
It's approaching human eye visibility.
It's not quite, it's like 8th magnitude or so, but it's a little brighter
than Comet ISON, which we've been anticipating for over a year.
So, the point being that these comets that come in on these really
elongated orbits are coming from all directions on the sky.
We can't do targeted searches, because we have to search the whole sky,
and they can approach us relatively
stealthily, such that they can become rather bright and
view it in just a few months.
So, I guess I would have to agree in that sense
that a comet could pose a greater threat, because
it's generally unknown. We can search along the ecliptic and above,
you know, 20-30 degrees above and below the ecliptic,
and get a good handle on the short period comets and most of the asteroids,
but it's these comets that come in from the Oort Cloud, that come in from every single
direction,
that you have to keep continuously scanning for those.
Yeah, I found that incredibly interesting question to ask, and I wasn't, I was
really surprised at the answer.
And can you, I know, we'll move on here just briefly, but I want to touch on one
more thing, and that is
the Near Earth Object Program that NASA runs has a pretty good handle on the
asteroids, right? At least the larger ones that we,
they've been cataloged. And so, the only real uncertainty when it comes to
asteroids, as I understand it, are just, we don't have all the small ones down,
right? The ones that are, like, just a few hundred feet across.
Right, I mean, we have asteroids
I remember looking and seeing some of them, just a few of them,
are down as small as five meters across, that we've
tracked. Of course, we lose track of those relatively easily.
Most of the ones we're tracking are a hundred meters
across or larger. And so, the small category,
which we are, as they get smaller, we're progressively less
complete on those. Those are the ones that,
you know, a hundred meters or smaller. If we're talking
the kind of asteroid that, the 20 kilometer size ones,
that, you know, can cause global extinctions,
I think we've got a relatively complete catalog of those. Now, there can always be
something coming from
a crazy direction in the sky or something gets
torqued by Jupiter, but of the ones
in the asteroid belt larger than, you know, kilometers or so,
I think we're pretty good on those. It will be more the smaller ones.
But, you know, smaller ones can still do some damage, too. Yes, yes, but as you
pointed out, the ones that can cause these
extinction events are the ones that are the scariest, and I think
many of the real danger there might be from these ore cloud comets. Okay, so
I just wanted to touch on that a little bit. Thanks, Frank. Right.
Let me just also note that, you know, asteroids, because they're going through
a chaotic field of other asteroids and other things,
they can have encounters that change their orbits that we, of course, can't track.
That's correct. So, the asteroid monitoring, once you find an asteroid and
you can't say, oh, it's always going to be on that path, always going to be on that orbit.
Neptune's not really going to change its orbit very much over
the years, but asteroids actually can change their orbit
a certain amount, and the average period of an asteroid is around, you know,
seven, five, seven years type of its orbit. So,
it can change its orbit to a certain amount. We do have to continually keep monitoring.
Alright, should we go back to the next story? Yes, go ahead. You sure can.
Okay, let me get back to the screen share on that. There we go.
Okay, so the next story I have for you
is exploring the frontiers of the Universe, and this
is a story that's actually going to get, we're going to hit it again
in January when we get the first data from it, but it's just sort of an announcement
of some really cool stuff that Hubble has begun.
And Hubble has done a lot of these deep fields.
Alright, it looked very deeply into the Earth, trying to reach out and see objects
out in the most distant part of the Universe, and the first one of that was the
Hubble Deep Field in 1996.
This was basically staring at a blank spot in the sky,
and we ended up seeing 3,000 galaxies stretched across
space out to as deep as Hubble could see back then.
Well, in 2002, we put in a new camera in Hubble, the Advanced Camera for Surveys,
and with that, we said, hey, let's do another deep field,
let's see a little bit deeper. We just can't call it the Deep Field, we had to call it the
Hubble Ultra Deep Field, because it went a little bit further.
And so in 2004, this image was released, where we're seeing
even more, and this image here has about 10,000 galaxies
in it. It's a little bit larger, so it should have more galaxies, but it also goes deeper.
And it's looking out in galaxies across space, but also across time,
because as you look further out into space, you're looking further back in time, of course.
And so you're seeing galaxies back to, you know, getting
out to, you know, a few billion years after the Big Bang.
I think in this image, we really do get out to about a billion years or so after the Big Bang.
And then in 2009, we had another servicing mission on Hubble.
We installed Wide Field Camera 3, and Wide Field Camera 3 had
enhanced infrared capabilities. And these galaxies that,
whose light has been traveling across the Universe for so long,
the expansion of the Universe has stretched their light
into infrared wavelengths. So, in 2009,
to do more infrared, we're going to have to wait for the James Webb Space Telescope to launch in 2018.
Because the light of galaxies even further
has been stretched further, so far into the infrared, that Hubble
can't see them. So, can we actually still go further?
And the answer has actually been yes, if we use
a trick of nature. Because Einstein's theory of general relativity
says that light, that mass
warps space, and that light traveling through warped space
actually curves. And so this diagram here,
these gray blobby things in the center are supposed to represent a galaxy cluster.
And the idea is that a light from a very distant galaxy
that passes by this galaxy cluster, its light can
warp, can change direction,
and we can see it at Earth from several different directions.
And the mass of the cluster actually
acts like a lens, like a glass lens in the same way,
the same way that light is bent by a glass lens, the light can be bent by the mass
of the galaxy cluster. So we've done this many times,
we've looked at these giant galaxy clusters, this is one called
Abel 1689, and you can see all the galaxies there,
all the combined mass of those galaxies and the dark matter around it
have actually warped space, and
if we zoom in on certain regions, these six images show you some of these
strange
images of background galaxies. And all those long, streaky,
archy things are background galaxies
whose light is passed through the warped space around that cluster
and become stretched out into these gravitationally lensed
arcs. So a cluster of galaxies can act as a gravitational lens,
but you know what a lens does? It not
only changes the shape of it, but it also magnifies it.
And so using this gravitational lens, we can use nature's lens
to see fainter galaxies than Hubble otherwise could see.
And so this one is a candidate for the most
distant object ever seen in the Universe.
This is a galaxy cluster that just has its catalog name
Max J0647, but that
little red dot is a lensed object that has been magnified,
something that Hubble couldn't see normally,
but with the galaxy cluster in the way acting as the lens
to magnify it, make it brighter,
Hubble has been able to see it. So
what if we took these deep fields
and combine those deep fields with nature's lens,
the clusters, could we extend our deep fields even further?
And that's the idea that NASA's great observatories are following in. That's the
Hubble Space Telescope, on the bottom is the Chandra X-ray Observatory,
and on the right is the Spitzer Space Telescope. All three of the telescopes
are going to be looking at these 12
fields on the sky, where we've got
one field that's doing a galaxy cluster, and then we've got a parallel field
that's looking at a blank part of the sky. And so we're going to get these six galaxy
clusters to be able to see really deep objects
and extend the deep fields even further into the Universe,
but we're also going to get six blank fields
and we're going to be able to see, increase our statistical knowledge
of extending the deep fields, because we've only done so many deep fields
and the more deep fields that you do, the more statistics you get in terms of
characterizing things.
And so you can also think of these parallel fields as acting
as a check on to what you're seeing.
Here's what you would see in a blank field, here's what you see in a field with a galaxy
cluster in front of it,
and you're able to norm out your statistics for this.
So we released this image last month
of the four of the galaxy clusters that we're going to be looking at
as part of what they call the Frontier Fields Program.
They're actually six of the galaxy clusters and we will be using these to
extend
Hubble's vision and extend it just that little bit further
while we're waiting for JWST, which will take us even further than that
when it launches in 2018. I just love that idea,
I just love that idea that you can take these galaxies, these big massive
jumbles of things in between us and distant galaxies and use them as lenses
with
that can amplify the signal
that Hubble would not otherwise be able to see. I just think this is a
great use
of not only relativity, but you know just sort of pushing Hubble
further than we've ever pushed it before. So I think this is amazing, this is
really going to be great.
So the one graphic that you showed, I think it was the last slide,
you showed there were two squares, one red, the other one green, and then
yeah, or blue. This,
explain this a little bit. These are two cameras
when one of them in red or blue is looking at an area of the sky, the
other camera is looking
adjacent to it, correct? Right, yeah.
I was going to skip that, but we've got a great audience here, I'm sure they're interested in this.
The point is that Hubble,
its focal plane is larger than the size of one camera.
Multiple cameras
can take data at the same time on Hubble. So this
is the Wide Field Camera 3 and the Advanced Camera
for Surveys. I think the blue is ACS and the red
is WFC3 and these,
both of these cameras can be observing at the same time. So
in one orientation, ACS will be looking at the cluster
and WFC3 will be looking at the parallel field. And then six months later
they're going to swap the orientation
and have, I guess, ACS looking at the parallel field
and WFC3 looking at the cluster. So by combining the two of them,
they'll get the best of both instruments and they'll be able to get
deeper images for both of the
fields. So they'll be able to take the cluster and the parallel fields
together, or in parallel, which is why they call them
the parallel fields. So the cluster field and the blank field will be done,
the observations will be done in parallel. Yeah, thank you Frank. I wanted to point that out just because it's an
important part of the science we're going to be doing with frontier fields and I just wanted to
show that the Hubble is going to be doing two things at once here
at various times. So this program is pretty unprecedented, right? I mean
this has got a huge number of orbits assigned to it
and it's going to be taking place over how long? It's going to be taking place
over three years. They're going to do two clusters,
two fields each year for the next three years
and be releasing the data relatively soon after they get it
for this because what has become tradition with Hubble
is that for these giant programs, these programs get a lot of telescope time
that they don't ask for proprietary periods on the data,
that they share the data with all the other astronomers. So if you're going to use
this many orbits on Hubble, you're going to make the data available to
all of the astronomical community and this is one way that astronomers really
have developed a sharing process. When you're using
an instrument as valuable as Hubble and that you're able to then share all your
information with the other astronomers, you actually get more science done with it
and Hubble has been,
it's become a standard part of these giant programs
that they share their data relatively quickly with the rest of the community.
Yes, I'm glad you brought that up because this is something that's going to be
pretty important. Anybody can get the data as soon as it gets processed and
made available on the archives. So you can do science with it right away.
Okay, I got one last story for you. Okay, let's go.
Alright, and this one is just a fun one.
Every month I like to do one just sort of image type story.
Are you going to sing for us, Frank? You've got to sing the song.
I do have my sweater here so I can use it.
It's actually funny because I came into my office one day
and I put down my coat and my briefcase and I then put on my sweater and I said,
holy hell, I'm Fred Rogers.
I didn't change my shoes.
But yes, won't you be my neighbor.
Okay, we're talking about our neighboring stars.
And in my presentations I got this image
from Noel Cramer about five years ago.
Maybe it's almost 10 years ago now. He's an astrophotographer
and he got an image of the bright star at the bottom is Alpha Centauri,
which is four and a quarter light years away.
And the bright star at the top is Beta Centauri.
And this is, of course, a Southern Hemisphere
view and we're here in the Northern Hemisphere so I've never seen these two
stars
with the naked eye. You can see them with the naked eye. But I got it from him
because not only did he get Alpha and Beta Centauri
but he was able to go in and find Proxima Centauri.
Oh no.
Oh gosh, I'm sorry about that folks. Frank, I had to
mute you there because we're getting some really
loud noise from your
microphone so I'm really sorry about that folks. That was exactly the problem we
were having
prior to the hangout and I'm not quite sure what the source of it is.
So let me just try getting him
one more time. Okay, so I brought him back. Frank, can you
hear us?
Hello?
Alright folks, I'm really sorry about the technical problems this time around.
This technology is
obviously we're at the mercy of it. So
Frank was going to be talking about the Proxima Centauri
story. Let me see if he's coming back.
Hello?
No. I'm sorry but it's back to that
noise he was generating before. So we're gonna work these out
before the next time I promise you. This happened half an hour before we got
started. So my apologies for this everybody.
I wanted to point out that tomorrow, as I already did, we're
having the
asteroid, the six-tailed asteroid hangout. We're also going to have another one
on Tuesday to talk about the
not the largest but the farthest confirmed galaxy
that was discovered using two different telescopes. One the Hubble and another
the Keck Space Telescope. I talked about this on Space Fan News on Friday
and that hangout is going to happen Tuesday at three o'clock. I will
post that on this page as well as soon as I create the event. I haven't created the
event yet because I was still waiting on confirmation from people. I've gotten
that now
and so Tuesday at three o'clock we're gonna have Dr. Steven
Finkelstein with us as well as Dan Coe. Both of these guys have records for the
most distant galaxies ever discovered.
So we're gonna talk about gravitational lensing some more. We're gonna talk about
high Z galaxies
and what the difference is between the galaxies that are discovered
via the gravitational lensing technique as well as the one that's done
spectroscopically. So
we're gonna have those as well on Tuesday. So that's what's coming up
and so please watch for those hangouts. Again I apologize for the
technical difficulties on this one.
Let me see if I can get to a couple of questions here.
This is from Carol Bellinger
on YouTube and asks, why can't Hubble get a clear picture of ISON?
They see every bump on Mars but they don't see any close-ups
of ISON. The answer is
they do get close views of ISON.
These are fuzzy objects by nature and so
I think that when you're imaging something like
distant galaxies or distant stars and things like that
the nature of those things have details, they have features.
But what's a comet? A comet is this big fuzzy
outgassing of ice and other chemicals.
Hubble does get the most detailed image of ISON that one can get.
If there's any features in it then it would also pick those out. Just use the
example of these
asteroids that we had before. You could see, that Frank showed earlier in the
Hangout, that one
asteroid with the, you know, X marks the spot kind of thing. There were
details in there. There were features in there. There were blobs.
And Hubble is able to see those. So these are things that Hubble can pick out.
It's not like...
So I guess my answer to your question is the nature of what is being
imaged. Comets are fuzzy. They don't have a lot of detail in them.
And if things like jets were in them or if there were some feature that was
inherently a part of the object
and it was emitted in a light that Hubble is sensitive to when it filters,
then it would be able to see those.
I'm gonna see if Frank has got a headset on. Let me see
if he's back. Hi Frank, can you hear us?
No. Sorry. Sorry, I had to cut you off there again.
So I hope you don't think, or I hope there's not this sense that, you know,
that Hubble is just trying to hide things from you. It's simply not the
case. It's just that
the nature of it is such that it won't...
there's not a lot of detail to see there.
So Sam D. asks, also on YouTube, what's up with the experimental coma
images like Widmer-Arban that show regularly spaced dark images
around the nucleus? If these are unnatural
camera flaws, why show them?
So I'm not sure if you're talking about ISON images or what, but
so you have to understand that the Hubble images of ISON, we only got two
the last time we did it. They had one orbit to take
two images and they took it in two different filters. That's not enough by
itself to remove all the image artifacts. To remove all the
artifact from an image, you have to take several
exposures and move the camera around to get
different parts of the CCD chip image
onto the object. And then when you combine all that stuff, the artifacts
that are in one image are not in another
and those can be removed. But if you only have two to work with,
it's hard to get rid of all of them. Like, for example, the star trails in
the last
ISON image was very difficult to remove because
we only had two of them. The answer to your question is that sometimes it's not possible to
remove all the artifacts
and yet we still want to release the image. As long as we're clear on what the
artifacts
are, then
and we know and we've identified what those artifacts are, then we release the
images and I think that's a fair thing to do.
So I think that's about it for
oh, here's one from Willa Moon on YouTube.
The tail is probably in front of it as it goes around the Sun because of the
Sun's pool.
But I agree, why can't we get any close-ups of ISON?
I think I just answered that one.
Sorry about that. What about ISON's
recent outburst? This is from Andreas Vosnakis.
I don't know what you're referring to.
The last images we've shown
don't necessarily show any outbursts from
ISON, so I really can't respond to that right now.
And also we have from Hambone Dodge, also on the
Q&A thing, a new type of quasar
bursts in the universe that come from material falling into black holes and
the accretion disks of black holes and they
let out these bursts of gamma rays and other high-energy particles
and these are these jets that you always see coming out of black holes.
Well, if one of those jets happens to be pointed toward the Earth,
we see it very brightly and in
the co-eyes on the paper that came out, we will take all your questions on that
object
as well as, I'm sure you'll have ISON questions too. We'll be happy to
answer those as well.
So see you tomorrow. Thank you very much
and that's it for now, Hubble huggers.
I know you hate that, Scott, but I can't help it.
Thank you all for watching and as always, keep
looking up.
