Hubble 3D: The interview

nature video
11 followers
Sep 5, 2023
Astronaut Scott Altman and director Toni Myers discuss their latest 3-D IMAX film documenting the 2009 repair of the Hubble Space Telescope. Watch more videos from Scientific American here: www.scientificamerican.com/video
In May 2009, seven astronauts flew to the Hubble Space Telescope aboard Space Shuttle Atlantis,
bringing to the alien observatory new batteries, a new camera, and spare parts to fix broken hardware.
It was the fifth servicing mission to Hubble and the final planned repair opportunity for the telescope.
The astronauts brought more than replacement parts with them, however.
They also carried an IMAX camera to space to document their mission.
Just a month before Hubble's 20th birthday comes Hubble 3D, a new documentary film directed by Tony Myers.
Here to discuss the film is Tony Myers and the mission's commander, Scott Altman.
Thank you both for joining us.
It's great to be here.
Our pleasure.
So, Tony, what about this mission appealed to you as a filmmaker?
Well, first of all, I wanted to make a film about Hubble that told the life story of Hubble,
or as much of it as we could do in our time frame.
And, of course, this was the final service mission,
and I knew that there were a lot of interesting spacewalks and really challenging,
in fact, the most challenging spacewalks ever to be performed were going to happen on it,
so I knew it was going to be exciting.
And, Scott, this is your fourth trip into space.
Yes.
Was there anything different for you this time in terms of feeling added pressure
because the scientific stakes were so high and everyone was watching from the ground?
I think that's the key point.
We knew on my last mission that there were future servicing missions planned,
and while there's always a challenge to get stuff done,
you thought, well, someone else could finish if we had to.
On this one, we knew it was the final trip, last chance.
Hubble's been such an incredible instrument.
We all wanted to do as much as we could to put it in as great a shape as it could be
for it to continue its voyage of discovery.
And, Tony, if you would talk about some of the challenges that you faced as a filmmaker
for whom so many of the shots are out of your control, you're on the ground,
the telescope is in the hands of the astronauts,
I'm sorry, the camera's in the hands of the astronauts.
We do train about eight months out from the flight, and we develop a scene list,
a kind of wish list of shots based on our observations
of their training for the spacewalks in the pool.
And the challenges really are only the timeline.
Of course, there's a sunrise and sunset every 90 minutes, and we know that.
If they get behind on this tightly scripted script,
then our best shots may wind up being in the dark where we can't shoot.
But we also know that's a possibility, so we do contingency planning in the list as well.
And, no, I totally trust them.
We train them to be cinematographers and directors,
and we also say if an alien flies up and puts his face in the window
just because it's not on the list, don't not shoot it.
You're the directors, and ultimately the decisions are in your hands.
And in terms of working in 3D, how does that change the process of shooting film?
Is there an actual technical difference?
Well, there is a technical difference, a big one,
in the case of the camera we flew in the cargo bay, which is the IMAX 3D cargo bay camera.
That carries a mile of film.
It's a single load. You can't change it out in the vacuum.
And that yields eight minutes of 3D film.
That's because it's shooting both the left eye and the right eye for 3D
that are normally on two strips on one piece of film.
And so that's not a lot.
Eight minutes, you have to plan it out very carefully.
All the footage in the film that we see that's the payload bay camera,
that's taken from eight minutes of raw footage?
That's correct.
Wow.
Yeah.
A lot of pressure not to leave too much on the cutting room floor when you're shooting it.
No, no, absolutely.
They did a bad pun, but a stellar job.
And Tony, in the film there are some very wonderful three-dimensional fly-throughs.
If you would just talk a little bit about how those were made
and how much emphasis was put on keeping those scientifically accurate.
I wanted to do two things.
I wanted to explore a phenomenon that was familiar to most people in the night sky,
even if they're only part-time stargazers.
And that turned out to be the Orion Nebula
because most people are familiar with Orion's Belt as something.
So I wanted to start there.
And that also turned out to be a very huge data set of Hubble's.
It's actually, when you combine the three data sets that we used,
it's a billion pixels worth of information.
And so that was one, and we used one for the approach
and then another data set in the interior for the trapezium region
where all the little baby solar systems are,
and a third for the accretion disk.
And we combined all of those with a software program called VIRTR,
Virtual Director, that allows you to plot a flight path through the data.
But it's all real data.
There isn't any, you know, just straight phony CGI in there.
And the other concluding sequence is one that I wanted to do
to try and convey in the simplest way possible the scale of the universe.
And so in that one we fly from the Milky Way out past Andromeda
and then into the Virgo Cluster.
Each time we pass something,
we're going from a dozen galaxies to 2,000 galaxies to a billion galaxies.
Now in the film, partly because of the scale, it's very easy to,
I mean, you and your fellow astronauts are up on the screen in huge proportions,
and you look like people who are about to do something very serious and possibly dangerous.
And that's not a side of spaceflight that we get to see very often.
Is that, are there a lot of nerves before you launch?
Well, I think everybody is focused.
That's what I talk to folks.
I want to put our game face on.
We're going out to do something.
We want to make sure we're all ready to meet this challenge head on.
It's going to take a lot of concentration and focus to get up there,
to get to the telescope, and then to do the spacewalks.
There's also a time to relax and sort of recharge your batteries,
but I think it's important that we're all ready to go and we got there.
And as a veteran of four spaceflights,
would you like to see the space shuttle's life extended beyond its current,
I suppose, four more launches?
Four more flights right now.
The shuttle is an amazing, amazing vehicle.
It's capability to be reusable, to take so much payload to orbit
and bring it home, something that doesn't exist anywhere else on the planet right now.
Transitions are always hard when you move from something you know
to something that you don't,
but they're also important to make progress, to add capability.
And I'm hopeful that we can make that transition safely
and find a new path both to low Earth orbit and beyond,
to go back to the moon and on to Mars.
And if space tourism becomes a reality anytime soon,
would you be itching to get back up there?
You know, John Grunsfeld says he's happier in space than anywhere else,
and you can see it in the movie with the big grin on his face
when he comes in from a spacewalk.
I feel that way a lot myself, too.
It is an incredible adventure, and I'd love to be a part of it again.
Maybe next time take my wife and kids along.
Me too, please.
Yeah, and Tony too, which is a great thing about IMAX
because it gives you the chance to share that experience
with people who can't go, my family.
To be there sitting in the movie theater with my wife and son sitting next to me
was really a special experience for me last night.
Thank you very much.
Oh, great.
Thank you.
It's been a pleasure talking to both of you.
I enjoyed it.
It was fun for us.
