Turning The Tables

nature video
11 followers
Sep 5, 2023
The annual Nobel Laureate Meetings at Lindau feature many opportunities for young scientists to learn from some of the most successful scientists around today. Yet there are fewer chances for the laureates to find out about the challenges that young scientists face today, and what they feel is important. Nature Outlook organised a special event, called Turning the Tables, to redress this balance and in this film we bring you the highlights.
That was primarily about students and young scientists meeting Nobel laureates. This
event, Turning the Tables, we're reversing that. This is an opportunity for the laureates
to meet and question some students. This week, I don't know whether anyone saw this, a prominent
scientist described PhD students as serfs, which is somewhat controversial. So my question
is to the panel, is your experience that you have been treated like a serf and what
should the relationship between a student and a supervisor be?
I'm proud to be a serf. I'm proud to be the labourer of science. Because for me, my supervisor
is more delegating the things and I'm the one who is doing the research, writing the
codes, writing the papers. So from this respect, from a labour respect, I believe we are the
serfs, but it is a good thing. I mean, that's why I'm in science and I wouldn't give that
up. You can come and work for me anytime. I see.
I think for a scientist it's very important to feel freedom and independence. Sometimes
I see people that are working many, many hours, but they stop to enjoy very soon and they
just give data, experiments, results, but no ideas and no happiness. That's important.
I think the interaction between the supervisor and the student has to be a very close one,
but there has to be an element of freedom to find things that are interesting for you
and be able to follow them through without the supervisor telling you it's a stupid idea.
It might be a stupid idea, but out of the stupid ideas come the most brilliant sort
of breakthroughs. So I say, you know, it looks stupid to me, but do it because I know I'm
stupid as well.
Do any of you guys have negative experiences about the fact that you're on the road so
much or that you're not in good contact with your students?
I always feel that what you're doing with a student is you're bringing them through
this transition as a graduate student and as a postdoc where they're going to become
independent researchers themselves, and the more you can be independent, the more you
can give them confidence that you give them guidance. But if they think they did it all
themselves and they don't know why you're even their mentor, then you actually did a
good job because you give them confidence that they're going to be able to go forward
and do the research.
Some students do that extremely well. It's very natural for them. Some students actually
want their hand held, and it's difficult when you're travelling alone.
When you're an international student, as I think you all are, what are the criteria?
Does internationality figure in your choice of the next job that you apply for?
After a while, you become stateless. It has its advantages and it has its disadvantages.
You become ready to move anywhere possible because you want to do the thing you want
to do, but then you cannot really settle, which is not so pleasant if you're looking
for a career.
Some countries are a little bit behind in the infrastructure, and some of the people,
very talented, are actually brain draining their countries by not coming back. Internationality
has its different sides, and Russia is the same. I just visited Moscow, and people are
complaining non-stop. It's not ideal now in Russia as far as science support is going.
Yes, it's completely my case. I moved basically because in Russia I had to do my PhD, and
at the same time I was working as a full time teacher at school, at a state school. Of course
it takes a lot of energy, these teenagers, three days for nine hours, and I also have
a small daughter in the evenings, so the rest of like ten hours per week I was spending
for science. It was not enough.
I'm from Norway. I grew up in Norway. I was a mechanical engineer for Norway. If I stayed
in Norway, I would still be a mechanical engineer. So sometimes you have to go abroad to do something,
and I know you don't seem like you like to see...
I went to the United States because I liked MIT a lot, and I thought that it would add
to me a lot, and then I had to consider whether Israel would provide me with good enough infrastructure
that I would be able to continue. Maybe not on the level of MIT, but on a good enough
level, and in retrospect it was the right decision. But I understand the considerations
and they're very, very sensitive.
I think the bigger question is not just going back to our native countries, but to be able
to stay at one place when you need to do so many post-docs to get into the tenure position.
That's because the market has become much tougher. At my time, we used to do one of
three, four years and finished, and you got your first assistant professorship, which
typically was tenure track. So if you manage, you cross the tenure barrier, and then that's
it, and you're on the faculty. Nowadays, you're absolutely right. It becomes more and more
difficult. You have to wander around with many post-docs and resettle, and people have
families, and it becomes difficult to the spouse. Yes, we realize.
What are you guys most concerned about right now? So from Bayer, we're hearing he's concerned
about how is he going to land and build a life, because he's ready to build the rest
of his life. He's found the scientific opportunity, and now he wants to find the life opportunity.
Is that the most serious concern you guys have?
I'd say my biggest concern probably has to do outside of science and those who have a
lot of influence on science, politicians. And I think that we should have more politicians
who have been scientists before. Does anyone here have the nerve to consider
a career in politics? I have considered a career in politics, but
I have also stopped considering a career in politics.
Give an example. Why? It's not like science. There is no search
for truth. It's actually kind of a search for the best, most saleable why, and I don't
like that as much. I'm not very good at why. That's a beautiful way of putting it.
Scientific method can be used. Politics can be done, because there is some kind of a reality.
If you're concerned about people, and if you're convinced that the cause is this and that
because of this data, then I think it could be done.
Well, it is necessary. There's no doubt that society does need to have some people interacting.
The problem is the interface between, say, the philosophy that really is based on evidence.
And we see that specifically in the case of, say, climate change, where there's this massive
political backlash against the scientific community, because they just do not understand
how science works. In democratic societies, politicians are elected
based on what they say, and they're saying what people want to hear. If you put a scientist
into politics, and he stood up there and said, we're all doomed. Climate change is going
to cause a lot. He won't get elected. The problem is encapsulated by Truman, who
was responsible for dropping the bomb on Hiroshima. And he said, give me a one-armed scientist.
Why is that? And they can't say, on the other hand. And it encapsulates the problem, because
no one has used the products of science more effectively, if you wish, than Truman. That
was something that the scientific community really had tremendous problems with, because
they didn't realize it wasn't built for that particular purpose, or they didn't work for
that particular purpose. I wanted to say that I think the interaction
of science and politics is really important. I've taken a little bit of my Nobel money
to start summer internships for physics students to work with the politicians that we have
in Washington. And we have three legislators who are physicists, actually. And so I think
it's possible, although some people doubt it, that a scientist can be a good politician.
I think some of them are. And I actually chipped in to help elect one of those physicists.
So I thought, this is really cool. He worked at Fermilab, and he's a good scientist. So
I think, as a point, I advise people not to give up too easily. I personally think
I'm not a good politician. I'm saying that. I don't have the right personality. But some
people do. And I want people to take this as a serious possibility.
I think we shouldn't burden them too much. I mean, we heard that they are really involved
in basic problems of where to settle, how to develop their career. I think that the
only thing is, one, not to be cynical, because the politicians are important. They represent
the public. They are elected by the public. And we are living in the public. We are living
on the taxpayers' money at the end of the day. And the politicians decide about the
fate of science and higher education. So the idea is really not to be cynical. It doesn't
mean that we have to be involved in politics. And the idea for you, I think, is to be aware
about the interfaces. I don't think that you really, we need to ask you now to go to politics
when you haven't even graduated. And you have to think of your postdoc and your position
and the grants and furthermore. But to be aware that there are many interfaces between
science and society. So being aware of it, putting it in the back of your minds, I think
that this is the right way to do it.
I think the easiest way for us to affect politics is to communicate and to educate. Because
that is the easiest way for individuals to influence their politicians and pressure them
to make changes.
Well, a couple of years ago there were, in Italy, a change in the government. The government
started a series of cuts on budgets to the universities. Basically, the students with
the professors decided to give a series of lessons in the squares of the city. We were
in front of the Dome of Milan. And there were a lot of people that stopped there just to
listen to what we were doing. But it was very, very nice to see that when we move
away from our buildings, when we go in the middle of the squares, people are interested
in it. We had a similar experience yesterday with the people of Lindau. There were a lot
of families and they started to interact with them, to speak with them. And you can see
that they were happy to talk with us. We started to speak about science and then we move on
speaking about our lives, our cultures and so on. It was a dream yesterday.
On that note, thank you all for attending. Thank you to the students and thank you to
the laureates.
