Mechanics of Bone (Iwona Jasiuk)
Sep 5, 2023
Mechanics of Bone
Well, good afternoon.
It's wonderful to see here so many distinguished visitors.
Today, I will tell you,
so my talk will complement the earlier talks today about bone,
but it will take a little bit different perspective,
so I think it will be quite complementary.
As for more globally,
we are interested in really learning as much about bone as
possible so we can assess bone quality.
So we look at bone not only in the context of nano indentation,
but we look at structure,
we look at composition and properties at
different scales in order to predict and to assess bone quality.
Our long-term interest is in assessing bone quality non-invasively.
So just as a general introduction,
bone can be considered as
structural material and when healthy,
it has excellent properties,
it's strong, tough, and light.
These are due to bone's hierarchical structure,
which is assembled from atomic level up to the macro scale,
and also due to the fact that it is a composite.
So the main constituents are collagen and
other proteins which are soft and deformable,
but give bone toughness,
and minerals which give bone its stiffness,
and there are fluids present in pores.
Bone is also a biological material which changes due to
many factors, mechanical, biological, and chemical.
So I'll give a brief overview of
the hierarchical structure of bones so you
can see the importance of these different scales.
So I'll be looking at the interest here is in the cortical bone,
which is the outer shell of bone.
But bone consists of trabecular bone,
which is spongy bone,
and cortical bone, which is this outer shell, less porous.
When we look at the mesostructure of cortical bone,
it's a collection of asteons of concentric cylinders in a matrix,
which are all remnants of old asteons called interstitial bone.
There are circumferential bone on the outer layer,
and also resorption cavities,
which are osteons that are
resorbing and locations of new asteons forming.
Different regions of bone will have
different properties as Virginia already commented about.
So as seen, both osteonal bone,
interstitial bone, and circumferential bone,
there are all lamellar structures which involve lamella.
By lamella, we mean fibers that are preferential oriented,
and they are arranged in different ways,
could be orthogonal,
meaning they are perpendicular to each other.
So one layer has fibers perpendicular to
the next layer or twisted or rotated.
So there are these various geometrical patterns
present in bone in different locations.
So I refer to this scale as mesostructure level.
Then going down, next scale down,
it's a single lamella level referred here as submicrostructure.
So here, mineralized fibrils are preferentially oriented,
and this void here is lacuna,
where bone cells reside, osteocytes reside.
Single lamella, as mentioned already in previous talks,
is few microns thick,
which is important to
remember when we'll be discussing nano-indentation data.
Finally, the least understood scale is the nanostructure scale,
where you can clearly see the composite nature of bone.
So these tropocollagen molecules,
which are triple helix,
arranged in very special way with gap and
overlap zones giving this pattern,
and then there are crystals in between and outside.
So all that makes up this complex hierarchical structure of bone.
In the morning, there was mention of seven scales.
The scales are actually continuous.
So depending on one's choice,
one can introduce x number of scales to represent hierarchy in bone.
So we distinguish these scales.
Since the focus will be on cortical bone,
I'll refer to four scales.
Of course, there's atomic level also and the whole skeleton.
So the approach now is to characterize cortical bone.
Even though I mentioned that the main interest is
to understand differences between healthy and osteoporotic bone,
the results presented will be on age effect,
and more specifically, bone development.
Just animals don't get osteoporosis.
It's harder to get osteoporotic bone.
In animals, it has to be induced.
So this was an easier system to work with.
Also, children's bone is not well understood.
So looking at developing bone can shed light on that.
The animal choice data involves swine femurs.
This is a common model used
because of similar bone biology to human biology.
So the approach is to look at bone structure at different scales,
look at bone composition at different scales.
Here comes also chemistry and mechanical properties at different scales.
May I ask just a very basic question?
Is all of this about the extracellular matrix of bone?
No, all of it.
Where are the cells?
Good question.
They are in the cell, in these voids that I mentioned.
They are there, but from mechanical perspective,
they are much, much softer than the stiff bone tissue,
which involves minerals.
So those are usually ignored for mechanical properties,
in mechanical properties considerations.
But if the cell is dying, what happens to the bone?
Well, bone dies.
Bone is constantly remodeling.
So there is a resorption and formation, resorption and formation.
Yes, it constantly happens.
Actually, in seven years,
the volume of bone equivalent to whole skeleton is replaced.
It doesn't mean that every piece is replaced.
Some pieces may be replaced more than once,
while others may not be replaced,
but it's a huge volume that is being replaced.
So when bone breaks, that process allows it to heal well.
But there are also bad, bad effects of it.
If someone is not using bone,
then there will be more resorption than formation and so on.
Did I answer your question?
Yes, thank you.
But that goes into biology of bone,
while the focus here is more on structural aspect of bone.
So I am not mentioning cells.
As mentioned, materials are porcine femurs.
Then we look at structural composition and properties.
One can look at these different scales
using these various techniques mentioned in the previous slide.
I'm not talking much about nanoscale.
It can be further characterized by AFM and so on.
But since the focus of this workshop is on nano indentation,
I wanted to put it more in perspective and just stop at that scale.
So I will outline briefly
what bone is like as imaged with these various techniques
and its composition is imaged
and also comment on mechanical properties
obtained using nano indentation
as well as micro indentation and tensile test
and how it all fits together.
So one thing to keep in mind
when studying bone, especially at lower scales,
is that bone is a heterogeneous material
and there are not only spatial variations
in a small region of bone,
but also changes depending on the location within bones.
So if you think of a cross-section,
for example, in mid-diaphysis,
the focus was on femurs just because they were the biggest bone.
So as one looks at different quadrants,
there is a plexiform bone as well as osteonal bone
depending on the quadrant.
So that's important when one does measurements of...
I mean, when one characterizes structure,
composition, and mechanical properties.
This is maybe more visible here.
So these are scanning electron microscopy images
as a function of age.
So for these four quadrants,
so for one month, really the bone doesn't look like bone.
There are many voids.
You do not really see osteons.
As bone matures, you can start seeing more osteons.
They are most visible for this bottom images.
Here, for younger bone, you still see more resorption cavities.
But these two quadrants are still having this plexiform bone.
Actually, another important thing to note
is that human bone does not have plexiform.
It only forms in large mammals,
which are growing rapidly,
and plexiform bone is easier to grow.
We used second harmonic generation microscopy
to look at bone structure in more detail.
So the top images,
these two top images are obtained
using scanning electron microscopy,
while the bottom two of the same region
are using second harmonic generation.
So the advantage of using second harmonic generation
is that one can see collagen,
febrile directions more clearly.
Another powerful technique that can shed light
on bone structure is tomography.
One can use it to take a more global view on bone,
but there is not much gain here
except for getting exact dimensions.
But things get more interesting
when one looks at smaller scales.
And Michel already showed some micro-CT images.
This is a similar image,
but the way to see it is that actually these are voids.
This is the porosity shown.
If we would show the solid part,
it would not be interesting.
It would be over 90 percent,
just a big, solid blob.
So porosity being around 10 percent
gives you this very interesting structure,
this illustration of internal porosity,
which is something to keep in mind when studying bone.
We are very lucky here to have several micro-CTs
allowing us to do imaging using different resolutions.
So the one on the left is an image
done with five micron resolution,
so you can see these canals,
which are present in plexiform bone.
This is done at higher resolution,
and to answer your question,
you can see these,
I don't know if you can see them,
but these are these little,
actually you can call them prolate spheroids.
That's where lacuna are,
and these are lacuna,
and that's where bone cells are.
Where do you see these pores?
What's there inside?
That's the osteocytes, bone-sensing,
the sensing cells.
Important part.
Yes, yes, yes.
So it's porosity filled by soft tissue.
So that information provides us with also porosity,
but important thing to keep in mind
that depending on location as shown from SEM images,
porosity and also internal structure
can be very different spatially.
So here is an illustration of bone at different ages.
You can see laminar bone and osteons.
Porosity is quite different.
This is just shown for one region for each bone type.
So then moving on to composition.
So one can use FTIR,
which was already mentioned by Virginia.
So from these peaks, similar to Raman peaks,
one can get more insight on both composition
and chemistry of bone,
and these are shown qualitatively,
but each color corresponds to numbers too,
just omitted here for simplicity.
So these are spatial images of small regions in bone,
and these differences in colors show
spatial heterogeneity for different ages
and abbreviations for different columns are shown here.
So that provides insight on composition,
which is important to note
when probing bone at smaller scales.
Other general observations are
that mineral content increases with age
and mineral to organic ratio
also increases as bone matures.
A typical method to assess bone
is bone mineral density,
and basically that's from x-rays.
One can see amount of mineral,
and there is an increase in mineral content with age.
Another very simple method to measure composition of bone
is water and content.
And ash content, basically weighing bone wet,
weighing bone dry, and then esching it,
meaning just putting it in hot enough oven
so organic part burns,
and measuring composition.
So the main message here is
that mineral content increases
and water content decreases with age.
And these are same message here,
just for more age groups.
So the main observations that we found in our study
was that there was a considerable decrease
in water content,
which is related to porosity,
increase in mineral content,
while collagen content was relatively stable.
So then nano-indentation.
I don't need to go through.
These are the most basic equations.
There was much more said already on nano-indentation,
but the main idea here was that
we wanted to measure bone properties,
and due to the resolution,
nano-indentation allows us to probe single lamella level.
Of course, it depends on the size of indenture.
We used Berkovits tip,
so it allowed us to probe single lamella.
And the method, basically as mentioned by George,
we need to have a very well-polished surface.
And another important thing was
that we did measurements using fluid tip.
So bone was fully wet in PBS.
So...
So you're always cutting them in the same direction?
I mean, the specimens are always...
Yeah, so one could cut them as one liked.
This particular data that I'm showing,
it was done perpendicular.
So if we cut bone, it was done on the surface perpendicular,
but one could cut it in different directions,
look at two different directions, and so on.
I'm just showing the one on the transverse,
results for transverse surface.
But yes, there would be an effect.
There would be an effect due to anisotropy of bone.
Bone fails, is it due to the compressor
or due to some shear?
Excellent question.
Could be to compression, could be to tension.
Also tension.
Bending, actually, a bone is actually bending.
There is bending involved.
If you hit someone sideways, it sort of bends,
so the top part will crack,
and then the bottom part will be compressed.
So even though we stand on it compressing it,
but some bending could be.
It could be twisting.
If somebody just skis and gets stuck,
and twists, and there are fractures
that are twist fractures.
If you Google fractures, there are...
Because it breaks before we hit the ground.
Well, it depends.
One is osteoporotic.
Yes, one can break before it hits the ground,
but usually one needs a big trauma to do it.
So, I mean, in general, if bone is healthy,
fall should not matter.
We should still be in one piece,
but depending on the fall, of course,
it can lead to fractures,
and that's why such research is important.
And I should also mention that fracture
is a multi-scale phenomenon.
Crack sees small, very small region,
and then it spreads to eventually break bones.
So such measurements at nanoscale,
and nano-indentation are very important
to shed light what happens,
how, I mean, why bone breaks.
So I already commented about the right slide
with the composition information.
Now looking at nano-indentation information,
so it's sort of superposed,
both modulus and actually hardness.
So there is an increase in both with age.
So what Michelle and what Virginia were focusing on,
they were focusing on local heterogeneity and so on.
Here I am taking bones that I'm averaging
all of these effects, just looking at age effect
for the illustration, for this presentation.
So the fact that modulus increases
and mineral content increases,
it's consistent with what we expect
from micromechanics and from modeling.
Is that human bone?
That was pig bone.
And so this summarizes that the results already shown,
so that water content decreases with age,
collagen is pretty stable,
mineral increases and modulus, elastic modulus increases.
But, yeah, but if we take a location,
different locations, there will be difference
between different types of bone microstructures.
But the general trend is that there is local increase,
that there is increase in properties with age,
but these increases differ depending
on the type of microstructure that one considers.
How did you see the differences with age
with the second harmonic generation
where collagen doesn't change?
The second harmonic generation was just
to illustrate collagen orientation.
And what's happening in bone,
which I sort of skimmed through,
is that it's believed that crystals are aligned
in the direction of collagen.
So there should be, you know, material should be more stiff.
So one outstanding issue actually is
when one probes on bone is to understand
which way is the orientation of the fibers
because that influences properties.
And the bad news is that we can only,
we see it two-dimensionally,
so we don't see, you know, the orientation,
we just see the cross-section.
So such, you know, if we can see
on the plane orientation of collagen,
that can help us to infer orientation in a lamella.
So what I said, that amount of collagen is not changing,
but possibly there could be others.
So just, again, this was already discussed in much detail,
but this is SEM backscattered image,
different gray levels means different mineral contents,
lighter looks, lighter is more minerals,
and then one can do a grid and report the data.
Here it's an SEM image to prepare SEM,
one needs to dry bone,
so these cracks are actually due to drying.
Another important, so now we go up the scale,
and so we used a micro-indentation,
and so there are various versions of micro-indentation.
The one that particularly piqued my interest
was micro-indentation method
that is referred to as reference point indentation.
So basically the idea is similar, it involves indentation,
but actually it has the outer probe
that rests on bone,
and then the inner probe is what's doing the indentation.
So the idea is that it could potentially be done on people,
on moving person, or an animal.
And in addition, the idea is that one can do
a number of cycles to get more information
about the material through a cyclic loading.
So the typical number of cycles is about 20,
this is just shown a couple of cycles.
It's still an open issue what these various quantities
that can be obtained from such cyclic curve mean,
but one can get unloading curve,
one can get other things from it.
Another thing is the indentation depth,
changing indentation depth.
So the idea is that if you keep on indenting the same area,
the easier it is for the probe to go into the material
in consecutive indents,
the bone should be weaker and fracture more easily.
And then one can obtain stiffness from unloading curves.
So we get increase in stiffness with age
and decrease in indentation distance increase with age,
which implies a stiffer and stronger material.
And so this is just illustration of possibilities
that this method offers.
And finally, we did tensile testing of bone.
The challenge was small samples,
but one could do that.
And again, trends were consistent
with increase in stiffness and strength.
So in conclusion, we use multiple techniques
and to characterize bone structure chemistry
and mechanical properties
and nano indentation results were consistent
with other techniques, mechanical measurements.
The numbers were not exactly the same
because we are probing different regions,
as mentioned, less porosity and so on.
What I have not described here,
we are also doing and have done simulations
and simulations were in very good agreement
with these measurements at different scales.
So all this characterization was needed.
We needed to know mineral content to put in the models.
We needed to know porosity at different scales
to put in models.
We needed collagen orientation to include in the models
and so on.
And we could extract properties
or compute properties at different scales
and then validate them by experiments.
So that concludes my presentation.
I would like to acknowledge my students
who contributed and collaborators
and some images here of buildings
that you have seen already
or if not, you'll see during your visit.
Thank you very much for your attention.
So I have a question about reference point indentation.
So I don't know if it's useful for you
to maybe describe first how it works to the group.
Of course.
Because my question, I think it might help.
Great, great, great.
So yeah, so this is a technique that involves,
although there are two versions of that technique,
but the one that I have used involves a tube
that is supposed to rest on bone
and then an inner part that will be indenting.
So actually a reference point indentation
means that the formations are measured
with respect to that outer probe.
So the idea is if one wants to reference indentation
on a horse that is moving,
you can do that as opposed to doing indentation,
putting all day, making sure
that there are no vibrations and so on.
So this allows for vibrations.
But yeah, and then the idea,
and then the way the program works
is that one can do one cycle or one can do 20 cycles.
The recommended is 20 cycles or roughly about 20.
There is not much difference afterwards.
And it's a pretty new technique.
First papers were a few years ago
up to about a year or two ago.
The first papers started appearing by people,
others than the group that invented the technique.
And yeah, it's still an open issue what that means.
The software can extract about 10 parameters.
They are called RPI parameters.
It's still a very open issue what they all mean.
One challenging thing is, for example,
that may be a foot for thought,
is that even unloading curve is in question
what it really means because there's actually
damage done in bone because it's a larger load.
So it's not fully elastic unloading.
There is already some damage in it and so on.
But in short, one can get various types.
This loading is cyclic.
The main parameter that is of interest
is what's the change in how much the probe
goes into bone from the initial one to the final one.
And then one can get also, because of cyclic loading,
one can get hysteresis loops and so on.
So the reason why I was asking is because
you know I was just at the Oil and Gas
meeting this weekend.
And it's a pseudo indentation test, right?
And I guess having just reviewed a couple of papers
where people used either the other technique,
the osteoprobe or the technologies that you used,
it really makes me wonder what is it measuring?
Because if you measure multiple cycles,
it's a progressive damage test on a material
that only gets damaged once in the body.
And so the consensus at this meeting I was just at,
which I know you couldn't make this year,
but from a lot of people, a lot of talks were talking
about how you can't really get any useful information
on anything but the first cycle.
But then they couldn't even quantify,
with all of these experts and mechanics in the room,
what the parameter was.
So I'm wondering what is the parameter?
It's not a material property.
It's not a fracture property.
Like how would you explain the utility?
Because I feel like I still need to be convinced.
It's not, to me it seems in some ways
like it's a poorly controlled indentation experiment
on a live subject.
But I want to be convinced that it's actually useful.
And there's a lot of papers coming out.
And this isn't to diminish your work.
I just want somebody to try and convince me
that it's a usable piece of information
that we can do something with from a valid,
well-controlled research tool.
Yeah, so I mean, it's an excellent question.
So there are about 10 or 11 parameters
that the software extracts.
And then the question is what it all means.
So early work involved basically experimental studies.
Like let's see who broke their leg.
And actually the first human studies
were done in a hospital, Spanish hospital.
And they took patients who just broke their hip
due to osteoporosis.
And then some other people who were perfectly fine
and were in hospital for other reasons.
And then they did the indents
and tried to correlate that data.
But yeah, it's still not fully clear what it links to.
But various studies compare it with nano-indentation,
with bending test, and so on.
But none of these parameters can be directly called
fracture toughness or strength.
So these are not mechanical properties,
as we know of stiffness, yield strength,
stress, fracture toughness, right?
So yeah, it's still an open issue what it really means.
And the most, of course, important thing here
is not really to extract stiffness,
but to extract bone's ability or inability to fracture, right?
So it's really we are after fracture properties
or strength properties to make it useful clinically.
The beauty, of course, of the technique
is that it could be used on humans.
I mean, it involves a small indent,
so that one can say it's still pretty, pretty drastic.
But it's better than taking a piece of bone
and polishing it, you know, putting in isotron
or some other equipment and doing the tests.
So that potential is great.
But I don't know what's the latest from ORS meeting,
but it's very much an open issue,
so people are still trying to figure it out.
Actually, what we are doing also,
we are doing computer simulations for it,
basically trying to simulate by finite elements
and having the data, trying to see,
and varying parameters, stiffness,
not stiffness, stress-strain curve parameters,
you know, infer what it means.
However, bone is not just elastic.
It's, you know, elastoplastic, viscoelastic,
all of these things, poroelastic.
So the question is, you know,
which is the right constitutive law to match the data,
and it's very hard to match the data.
Thank you very much.

