Determining Materials Properties from Non-Equilibrium Dynamics and Stress Measurements
Sep 5, 2023
Folarin Latinwo is a current Ph.D student working in the lab of Dr. Charles M. Schroeder at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. His research interests include the investigations of flexible polymers using Brownian dynamics simulation and non-equilibrium statistical mechanics.
Why should we even care about polymers in the first place?
The plastics or polymers industry
is estimated to be about half a trillion dollar industry
in the US alone.
And at the heart of this industry
are individual polymers whose properties can
be designed or manipulated to achieve
some bulk macroscopic behavior.
And these polymers are typically manipulated
in processes that involve things like injection mold, which
is used for making materials like your automobile
dashboard, the plastic extrusion,
which is used for making materials like pipes and tubing,
and the melt spinner, which is used
for making things like nylon.
But ultimately, these materials, even though they
have a particular bulk behavior, their bulk behavior
is determined by their equilibrium properties.
But all the processes I've described here
functions are not at equilibrium.
And these processes typically involve a flow situation.
So because the bulk properties that we
see is a function of equilibrium property,
it's important to understand at the most fundamental level
what the equilibrium properties of these materials are.
So how do people typically determine
what equilibrium properties are?
So people do single molecule measurements
where they tether a polymer chain.
In this case, DNA, to some active conservative field.
And this field can be optical in nature,
so like an optical tweezers where
a bead is tethered to the polymer,
and this bead is being controlled by a laser,
or a bead being controlled by magnetic tweezers,
or in case where you have a canceller that directly
manipulates the chain.
But the issue with this process is
it doesn't really correspond to the situation
that you see in processing, which involves flow.
And secondly, you have all these really big probes
on these molecules that are not necessarily
indicative of the properties of the polymer chain by itself.
So because of these issues, we start
to determine a new approach to determine
these equilibrium properties.
And basically, we use a device that
generates flow fields similar to what you see in industry
to deform your polymer chains under flow.
And based on the molecular stretching trajectories,
we can apply a non-equilibrium work relationship
named the Joursinski equality to get the equilibrium materials
properties.
So what is a non-equilibrium work relation?
Well, a non-equilibrium work relation
is refers to a general class of work relations
that allows you to determine properties at steady state
or at some final state based on fluctuations or work
distributions.
The Joursinski equality is arguably the most popular one.
And it allows you to determine equilibrium free energy
differences from work distributions.
And to illustrate this, I have a picture of a Maxwell demon
doing work in transitioning the system from state 1
to state 2.
State 1 refers to a slightly disordered system.
And state 2 is more ordered.
Now, this demon can do this work at different rates.
If the demon does the work at a slow enough rate,
the average work done by the demon
is equal to free energy change.
But if it does it at a finite rate,
then there are irreversibilities in the process.
And your average work is not necessarily
equal to your free energy change.
Well, the good thing about Joursinski's equality
is that it's valid regardless of the rate at which
you do the process or how far you are from equilibrium.
Now, since the equality has been derived,
it's been applied extensively in the field of biophysics
with over 1,500 citations.
But it hasn't really been applied to soft materials
or polymer dynamics.
Another class of non-equilibrium work relations
is Crook-Fulkerson theorem.
I wouldn't really go into this in the interest of time.
But I'll be happy to answer questions about it later.
So what does Joursinski's equality look like?
Well, it relates the exponential average
of a Boltzmann-weighted work to the free energy change.
And this equation is valid in the limit of infinite ensemble.
It's true regardless of your deformation rate.
And so since it's been developed,
it's been applied mainly where your system is being
deformed by conservative forces.
There have been some cool experiments
and computational work that have shown that this equality is
valid in different cases.
But because we want to use this equality
to study polymer dynamics and determine equilibrium
properties, we need to figure out
a way to capture the physics of polymer dynamics.
And to do this, we have a very simple model
for polymer dynamics, a coarse-grained model
where we model a polymer as beads connected on a spring.
The beads serve as contact points with the fluid.
And the spring represents the effect of elasticity
in the chain.
Now, this polymer is typically stretched in flow fields.
And I have two example flow fields here.
You can have an extensional flow where your polymer chain is
in a strongly stretched regime.
And kappa is the velocity gradient
tensor describing the flow field.
And you can have shear flow.
Now, the equations describing the behavior
of this polymer in flow is given by a Fokker-Planck equation
for the configuration distribution function.
But for the case of our simulations,
we want to solve the equivalent stochastic differential
equation to model the behavior of the polymer in flow.
And the key ingredients that go into this system
is the flow velocity or the fluid flow,
which is responsible for driving the process,
the diffusion tensor, which describes
the mobility of the chain, the elasticity, which
describes the properties of the chain,
and also the Wiener process, which
is descriptive of thermal motion and fluctuations.
So we know how to model the system.
To apply Jouzinski's equality, we
need to determine what the work is.
So we did some theory by using the equality
of the Taunus-Sasa equality.
And we were able to determine what the work definition is
for polymeric systems.
And based on this work definition,
we can apply this expression, which is just
the Jouzinski's equality in flow.
So we can now use our simulations
to test our expression and Jouzinski's equality.
So what we do is that we transition a polymer chain
from a particular extension to a higher extension
by increasing a particular flow rate.
And you repeat this process a bunch of times
to get a work distribution.
And based on each trajectory, you
have a particular distribution.
Well, the black line here shows the average molecular stretch
as a function of time.
So based on this individual distribution
and the equation above, we can actually
compute what the work distribution is
and apply Jouzinski's equality.
And what we see by applying Jouzinski's equality
is that we can determine what the equilibrium free energy
changes to within 1 kT of what the analytic value would be.
We find that this is remarkable because although you
have a really large dissipated amount of work, almost 120 kT,
you can still determine what the equilibrium free energy change
is.
So we've done this in a bunch of flows,
extensional flow, teleuniform flow.
And by increasing the velocity over time,
you can actually map out the entire free energy
landscape of your molecule.
So after determining the free energy landscape of a molecule,
we can go ahead and determine the elasticity
by taking a derivative of your free energy
with respect to extension.
And by doing that, we can actually
determine what the elasticity is in the chain
is from dynamic flow data.
We've done this not only for biopolymers
like double-stranded DNA, but we've also
done it for synthetic polymers like polystyrene.
But the results I've shown you so far
have been results of the idealized case, so a case
where you have your polymer represented by two beads
and where the diffusion tensor is constant.
But in reality, we know that the diffusion tensor is not always
constant.
And for us to transition into an experimental framework,
we want to capture the physics entirely.
So we put in the case.
We also decided to consider the case where your diffusion
tensor is no longer constant to test our framework
to see if it works.
And it does work.
Although the equations of motion are slightly different
because you have multiplicative stochasticity because
of the diffusion tensor varying with the configuration
of the chain, you can actually go ahead and calculate
what the equilibrium free energy landscape of the molecule
is from flow data.
So we're pleased with this.
And this motivated us to go ahead and consider
test this framework in an actual experiment or experimental
data.
So we obtained previously published experimental data
of polymer molecules, image using
single fluorescence microscopy in an extensional flow.
And based on the stretching trajectory
and our previous equations for the work,
we can actually derive what the work done on the molecule
is in different regimes of the chain.
We note that the polymer chain transitions
from a coiled state, where it behaves
like an effective sphere, to a slender state.
We have an image showing that, where
it behaves like a slender body.
So by using this definition, we can actually
determine what the work done on the chain by the fluid is.
So using this work relation, this work expressions,
and applying Jouzovsky's equality,
we went ahead and determined what the free energy
landscape of the molecule is.
And by using our approach, we can actually
determine the free energy landscape,
despite the huge amount of dissipator work from flow data.
And I was pretty shocked by the result, I must say.
Because the simulations typically
required a larger number of trajectories
for convergence to the free energy landscape.
But in reality, in the experiments,
you have a more realistic system.
So you typically require a lower number of molecules
to determine the free energy.
So in conclusion, I hope I have convinced you
that non-equilibrium work relations can
be applied to polymer systems, and can
be used to determine equilibrium properties from highly
non-equilibrium flows.
And based on this equilibrium properties,
we can determine the stored elastic energy
and the elasticity in the chain.
Thank you.
Well, thank you.
All right.
And this concludes this session.
We have a small break now, then we have a poster session.

