Simultaneous Co-Fermentation of Mixed Sugars
Sep 5, 2023
March 28, 2013. BioEngineering Seminar Series. University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
"Simultaneous Co-Fermentation of Mixed Sugars: A Promising Strategy for Producing Cellulosic Biofuels and Chemicals"
Dr. Yong-Su Jin, Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition and IGB, UIUC
Thank you for the invitation, Dr. Lu.
This is a great pleasure to give a seminar.
This is a very short trip.
You know, actually, I was giving an invited seminar to University of Georgia this Tuesday,
actually the Tuesday, and I have to spend a whole day just visit there, and then I
have to spend a whole day to return.
But this is only like a 10-minute trip to the place, so this is a really great seminar.
I feel very happy.
So today I'm going to talk about metabolic engineering.
Actually, maybe some of you are very familiar with metabolic engineering and some of them
are not, so I'll try to explain what is metabolic engineering, and then I'm going
to talk about a couple of examples of using metabolic engineering for producing value-added
chemicals and fuels.
So why we do this metabolic engineering or fermentation?
We can do value-added biotransformation.
So using microbial cells, we can convert sugars into other value-added products.
Actually, this process or this practice is very popular in food science.
So probably you heard about making kimchi, which is actually the lactic acid fermentation,
or making wine, which is yeast fermentation, or making vinegar, which is acetic acid fermentation.
And also we can produce a food ingredient, probably you heard about xylitol, which is
a reduced alcohol of xylose.
We can use it as a sugar substitute.
When you buy gum or candy, they have xylitol, then it reduces the decay of the tooth.
So it's a functional food ingredient, and also we can produce amino acids.
You heard about monosodium glutamate, which is an amino acid that we use as a flavor enhancer.
We produce amino acids using microorganisms, and also we produce biomass, a yeast cell.
Probably if you bake at home, you know how to make the bread.
You add water to the flour, and then you add a little bit of sugar, and then you add yeast.
So we produce this yeast by fermentation.
So this is a very popular process in food science.
However, there are some limitations for using this process for other purposes.
For instance, we can produce lactic acid or ethanol, but let's say I want to produce aspartame.
You know, what is aspartame?
Which is an artificial sweetener.
But if we look at the structure of aspartame, it has aspartate and pennylalanine.
So in order to do so, we need to overproduce aspartate and pennylalanine.
There is no microorganism which overproduces aspartate or pennylalanine as it is.
We need to do some engineering, or we need to introduce a mutation, or we need to do
a genetic engineering to overproduce those components.
And also, if we want to overproduce some new pharmaceutical drug, usually the microbial
cell would not make that pharmaceutical drug as it is.
Then we need to do some metabolic engineering, or we need to do some genetic manipulation
to change the property of the cell.
So in a nutshell, metabolic engineering is a gene therapy of a microbial cell.
We do a gene therapy to change the health state of a human, right?
Same thing, we add genetic material to the microbial cell to change the behavior of the
microbial cell.
So we can do more than this food fermentation.
So these are the example.
These are the traditional food fermentation example.
But if you go to the market, now we see more and more of the product which is made by microbial
fermentation, and these are not food anymore.
These are the food ingredient, or nutraceutical, or the drug.
And among those examples, this is lysine, and coenzyme Q10.
In addition to this ingredient, biofuel is one big field that can be improved by metabolic
engineering.
So today I'm going to talk about two examples.
So first example is making cellulosic ethanol, and the other example is to produce human
milk oligosaccharide.
So I will tell you why we want to produce human milk oligosaccharide in detail a little
bit later.
So in order to do so, we need to use microbial cell.
So this is a chemical conversion.
So I intentionally showed the chemical structure of cellobiols and xylos, or lactose here.
But after doing this fermentation, we have a totally different chemical structure.
And then this is just another one-step reduction or oxidation.
This is a very complex series of the reaction.
As you see, we have this very complex structure, but now we have this one homogeneous molecule
through this process.
Same thing.
We have a very complex sugar attached to the sugar to the specific location.
It's very difficult to control by enzymatic reaction, but if we use a whole cell, which
is programmed by our genetic manipulation, we can do this fermentation or this conversion
in one step.
How do we do that?
We use metabolic engineering, which is a rational and strategic approach for strain improvement.
I'm going to show you a very simple example here.
So let's say we have a Y-type cell.
We have yeast cell or E. coli cell do some bioconversion.
And it produces the metabolite X and Y.
Somehow it produces two types of metabolite.
And we found that Y is very, very useful or very expensive, like 1,000 times more expensive
than X.
Then in this case, this is pretty good fermentation, but our kind of intention is to eliminate
the production of X.
Can we make just Y because Y is more useful and expensive?
Then with that intention, you may want to look at the metabolic pattern.
So we have this metabolic pattern.
Let's say we have that.
We know that.
Then by looking at this metabolic pattern, you can immediately think about a new idea.
Okay.
If we overexpress enzyme E3, then we may be able to shunt more carbon to this pathway
and we may get more metabolite Y.
So we can do that by genetic manipulation.
However, most of the time, if we do that, actually this is the outcome.
We have a little bit of improvement of metabolite Y production, but it's not drastic because
of unexpected amplification of this flux.
So always, metabolic engineering is very difficult because in the green street, we want to increase
the flow of the car in the green street, and we build up or we make a better kind of the
flow, the load condition for the green street.
But sometimes the car don't come to the green street.
For some reason, they just come to the Springfield.
So it's very difficult.
And although we have an idea how to control this, the cell has even higher capability
where they don't respond to our expectation.
So always, this is not a one-step perturbation.
We should do iterative engineering.
So in this case, we overexpress E3 first, and then we look at the flux.
So that's the key.
About 20 or 30 years ago, we had this idea, but we were not able to practice this idea
because at that time, we didn't have a tool to look at the flux.
But now we have a genomics and systems biology approach.
We can measure the transcript very accurately, all the gene.
We can measure the amount of the metabolite.
So we have a good idea how it...
I mean, here I was drawing this, but about 10 years ago, it was just a black circle.
But now we have an idea because of this analytical tool.
And then after doing this perturbation, we found this unexpected flux increase.
And then, okay, let's delete this reaction.
Then maybe next round, maybe the metabolite Y production would increase, or another unknown
reaction will happen and then steal the Y at the same level.
Then we should delete this reaction again.
So this is iterative engineering.
So sometimes we call this metabolic engineering.
Now it is evolved as systems metabolic engineering because in order to do so, you need to look
at everything at the system level.
So the first example with this idea, the first example I'd like to introduce is simultaneous
co-fermentation of mixed sugar for producing fuels and chemicals.
So probably you've heard about corn ethanol.
So this is a very simple process.
We harvest corn starch and use the enzyme to generate monomeric glucose, and we do yeast
fermentation.
We produce ethanol and carbon dioxide.
So this is heavily practiced in the United States.
We have more than 200 corn ethanol plants.
So we are making ethanol a lot from corn.
To tell the truth, more than 40% of the corn which is produced in this country are converted
into ethanol.
So it's good and bad because we replace gasoline.
If you go to the gas station, about 10% of your gas, gasoline, is actually ethanol.
So we use this as petroleum or gasoline replacement.
That's a good point.
However, the bad point is still in this world, there are many people who are starved because
of lack of food.
So making fuel from food is unethical.
So that's why there is some ethical issue.
So that's why we want to...
And also another thing is the corn is not sustainable.
People were thinking about making ethanol from corn was a great idea, but if we look
at very carefully, the story is not that great.
Because in order to cultivate corn, we need to use fertilizer, we need to use irrigation.
These are all energy consuming.
So in order to produce ethanol from corn, you need to consume a lot of gasoline.
So in terms of energy balance, although still we have some positive, but we need to use
a lot of energy input to produce corn ethanol.
So ethical issue and also an energy balance issue, and also another issue is the sustainability
issue.
Although this state is a pretty good state to grow the corn, Illinois is corn, but Alaska,
they cannot grow the corn.
So this corn ethanol is kind of temporary.
It's not sustainable for everybody, especially in the United States.
But think about a country like Korea, or Japan, or UK, they don't have enough land to cultivate
corn.
So this is not good.
That's why people thought about producing cellulosic ethanol.
You heard about cellulosic ethanol as a second generation.
So instead of using edible part, edible part of a plant, so this is a corn, we are using
only the grain.
But instead of using those grains, let's use the whole body of a plant.
Then we don't have to use only corn.
Any switchgrass, any grass, any wood material, we could use, because that cellulosic material,
if we hydrolyze, we get sugar.
Same.
Even this, I don't know if it is made by wood, if we hydrolyze this, we will be able to get
the sugar.
Then we don't have to worry about this ethical issue, and also the generation of plant material
from photosynthesis is sustainable.
Some of the crop, we don't have to provide fertilizer, or we don't have to provide irrigation.
So those are what we call energy crop.
And if you have a chance to travel to south part of our campus, we have energy farm, which
is made by EBI.
And if you go there, you will see like three or four meter tall grass.
You probably heard about Miscanthus giganteus, which is a big tall grass, can be grown into
that big with minimum management, which is a pretty good source for making sugar.
So the idea is to use the cellulosic biomass to produce sugar and then do the fermentation.
So basically the bottom part are the same.
But there are a couple of problems.
In order to do so, we need to extract the sugar or isolate the sugar from cellulosic
biomass.
Think about this.
Very difficult to, I mean, even though you leak, you cannot taste the sweet, right?
Because by the design, you know, think about the plant.
They have a stalk, or they have this very strong part.
That's for their physical stand, right?
And then the seed, like an apple or the grain, is for the next generation.
That's why it has sugar.
So this physical part, the non-edible part, has lignin, which is kind of a supporting
material.
Then lignin protects the sugar.
And then if this sugar can be used by this material easily, they cannot sustain.
You know, wood should stay, well, trees should stay like 20 years, even 100 years.
If the sugar is accessible and by easily, then the wood will decay immediately.
Because in the world, we have so many microorganisms.
Even in my hand, they are looking for sugar to grow.
So it would decay.
However, wood material has lignin.
So we cannot, it's very difficult to hydrolyze the wood material into the sugar.
So we need to use a very sophisticated pretreatment.
You heard about high temperature, high pressure, or acidic or alkalic condition to speed up
this degradation.
Even after that, we have a glucose and xylose mixture.
So in case of starch or sugarcane fermentation, we only get hexose, which is only glucose
or fructose.
It can be easily fermented by yeast.
And in case of cellulosic biomass, we get xylose, which is very difficult to ferment.
I'm going to talk about that a little bit later.
And also we get acetate, which is very toxic to the cell.
So if we hydrolyze cellulosic material, we get glucose, xylose, and acetate, which is
totally different from corn starch.
Just glucose.
So easy to ferment.
But now we have very recalcitrant and toxic sugar, which also this acetate fermentation
inhibitor killed the yeast, which is even worse.
So this is the problem.
So that's why, although we are talking about cellulosic ethanol for more than a decade,
frankly speaking, there is no cellulosic ethanol plant in the United States as of now.
So only at the laboratory level.
Nobody was able to commercialize cellulosic ethanol plant in this country, although we
spend billions of money for studying this problem.
So having said that, I'd like to talk about the strain.
We are using Saccharomyces cerevisiae for this fermentation.
So this is the strain we use for making beer and wine.
It's a very good strain to produce ethanol from glucose.
And also, the Saccharomyces cerevisiae was a model strain for eukaryotic biology.
So whoever studied eukaryotic molecular biology used Saccharomyces cerevisiae as a kind of
model system.
So that's why we have a very good genetic and genomics tool.
So we have overexpression and knockout tool, so very easy to manipulate the gene.
And also, we have a successful example of expressing heterozygous enzyme in this strain.
So there's no experimental bottleneck to manipulate the genome or gene in this strain.
However, this strain cannot use xylose.
I told you that if we hydrolyze cellulosic material, we get glucose and xylose mixture.
But the problem is this strain cannot use xylose.
So this is the problem.
And we want to solve this problem by metabolic engineering.
So fortunately, there is a strain.
There is a yeast strain which ferments xylose.
And we found that there is a xylose metabolic pathway.
But Saccharomyces cerevisiae do not have that xylose metabolic pathway.
So the basic idea is to clone those three enzymes and introduce into Saccharomyces cerevisiae.
Then our engineered strain should be able to ferment xylose.
However, it's very simple.
It looks very simple.
However, it is more complicated than what we expected.
And I spent about 10 years to engineer this pathway.
And then initially, we thought just introduction is enough for fermenting xylose.
However, at the end of the day, we realized that we need to optimize the expression level
of this enzyme in order to have efficient xylose fermentation.
In addition, we found that also we need to use some spontaneous mutation to speed up
the xylose fermentation.
So one idea is what we call laboratory evolution.
After we're generating xylose-fermenting strain, and we culture the strain, the resulting strain
in the xylose condition over and over, then we found that strains are using xylose a little
bit faster and faster and faster if we continue this culture.
So we repeated this culture more than 20 times.
And then we isolated a single colony.
And then we evaluate each single colony.
And we found one of the colony ferments xylose much better than others.
So although I cannot disclose the mutation, we did the genome sequencing to find out what
are the mutation cause of rapid xylose fermentation, and we identified the mutation.
We know the story.
I cannot disclose that right now, but we found that.
And actually, even I can tell because the paper has been published about two weeks ago.
And we found the mutation, which is a mutation in a phosphatase gene.
If we have a specific mutation, a sugar phosphatase, we certainly, we amazingly have a better xylose
fermentation.
So this is the result.
So this is an engineered saccharomyces cerevisiae, and this is the naturally existing xylose-fermenting
strain.
As you see now, our engineered strain consumes xylose very well and produces ethanol almost
as fast as this naturally existing system.
So now we have engineered strain which ferments xylose as well as the naturally existing strain.
Then maybe you ask a question, then why don't we just use this saccharomyces astipitis for
making ethanol?
But this strain has very low ethanol tolerance.
So up to like 3% or 4% ethanol, they make very well.
However, they cannot produce up to 10%.
And saccharomyces cerevisiae, the strain we are using for wine generation, winemaking,
they can produce ethanol up to 14%.
So if you look at the ethanol concentration in the beer and wine, the beer has about 5%
ethanol and wine has about 14% to 15% ethanol.
So saccharomyces cerevisiae will produce high ethanol, ethanol up to high concentration.
Can you also evolve like the left strain to increase their ethanol tolerance?
Yeah, definitely that's possible.
However, so that's a very interesting approach.
But the reason why we do metabolic engineering is we want to create engineered biological
system with comprehensive understanding.
Because for instance, saccharomyces cerevisiae, we know everything about stress response.
We know all the important protein and DNA interaction.
We know those.
But the problem of PKACPTs or the saccharomyces CPTs, we don't have that information.
So definitely we may be able to evolve this strain a little bit, but it's very difficult
to study because it's not well characterized.
So we had this xylose fermentation strain, but still there is a problem.
So after making this xylose fermenting strain, we tried to use glucose and xylose mixture
from cellulosic hydrolyzate.
And then we found there is a problem which is called catabolite repression.
So this has happened to everybody or any living system.
If you provide two substrates or two sugars to a living system, the living system is a
bacteria or a cell or animal, whatever, will use free-for-the-sugar first.
And then until the free-for-the-sugar is gone, they would not touch the second sugar.
This is like if I give ice cream and broccoli to my son.
My son would not touch broccoli until he, you know, eat the ice cream.
Always E. coli or yeast, whatever.
If you provide the glucose and lactose to the E. coli, E. coli will use glucose first,
and only when glucose is gone, they will touch lactose.
So this is a very well-known problem.
So that's why if we mix glucose and xylose because glucose represses xylose metabolism,
we have this type of sequential fermentation.
That means glucose will be used first.
During that time, xylose cannot be fermented at all.
And then xylose will be fermented later.
And also another problem is the rate of eating chocolate or ice cream by my son and the rate
of eating the broccoli.
If you think about it, my son will suck the ice cream immediately, but broccoli takes
the time.
So basically, the pre-produced sugar fermentation is very fast.
But the second sugar utilization will be very, very slow.
So this is the problem.
So we wanted to solve this problem.
And actually, this is the actual experimental data we got.
So this is the data from Purdue University.
They also generated a similar strain, and they did glucose and xylose co-fermentation,
and they found that there is a two-phase fermentation, like glucose-fermenting period and xylose-fermenting
period.
And glucose-fermenting period is very short, but xylose-fermenting period is very long.
So this is a big problem for commercialization.
Because if we do this fermentation for making ethanol, so let's just say we have this strain,
we have this process in the plant.
And if we look at the time, it takes about 60 hours, right?
Then it takes like two and a half days, or let's say three days.
So total fermentation is three days.
And we build a big bioreactor, and then we do this fermentation.
Then the maximum number of fermentation you can do in a year is about 120.
Because each fermentation takes three days.
So you can do only 120 times of fermentation a day.
But again, after you finish the fermentation, you clean the reactor, you sterilize, so that's
why the number of fermentation even reduced to 60 or 70, something like that.
So the fermentation time is very important.
Let's just say if we reduce this fermentation time to 20 hours, that means you can do 360
fermentation per year.
The same fermentation facility, like the A facility using this strain, the maximum throughput
is only 70 fermentation a year.
But another competitor has the same fermenter, but efficient strain, which finishes the
fermentation in 24 hours, can do more than 200 fermentations.
Then this is big money making.
So that's why the fermentation time is very, very important.
We really like to finish this fermentation within 24 hours.
Then we can produce ethanol in a more economically viable way.
However, in reality, we have this very good glucose fermentation and very slow xylose
fermentation.
So in order to solve this problem, we thought about co-fermentation.
Instead of using glucose and xylose separately, let's do a multitasking.
Let's ask the cell to use glucose and xylose at the same time.
It's very difficult.
Cell would not ferment glucose and xylose at the same time.
So we made a trick.
Suppose we are not making glucose.
We're getting glucose from polymeric form of the sugar.
In order to generate the glucose, we need to hydrolyze glucose polymer into glucose.
And the intermediate form is cellobiase, which is a dimeric sugar in between the hydrolytic
reaction.
Actually, we can stop the reaction here.
Instead of making glucose, we can produce cellobiase.
And we don't have to add beta-glucosidase.
So we add less enzyme, and we produce intermediate.
And then what we found was if we have this intermediate instead of glucose, intermediate,
the cellobiase, would not repress xylose fermentation.
So the previous diagram, as you see, glucose inhibits the xylose fermentation.
That's why we get this glucose and xylose sequential fermentation.
But if we hijack cellobiase, cellobiase and xylose can be co-consumed.
So that's the idea.
And if we do that, we can reduce the enzyme cost because we don't have to add the beta-glucosidase.
And also, as you see here, since the two sugars can be co-consumed, we can finish the fermentation
earlier.
And also, we can even implement a continuous process.
And also, by using this idea, we can also produce the chemical very rapidly.
I'm going to show you a couple of examples today.
In order to do so, we need cellobiase transporter and efficient xylose fermentation.
This is our topic.
We are studying xylose fermentation more than 10 years.
And then at the time, I was very lucky to have a collaboration with Jamie Cate at UC
Berkeley.
They published a paper in Science in 2010.
They found cellobiase transporter and intracellular beta-glucosidase.
And they said, we can do cellobiase fermentation.
And I immediately thought, oh, maybe it would be possible to combine these two research
in order to do cellobiase and xylose co-fermentation.
So we made a strain which has cellobiase pathway and xylose pathway at the same time.
And we did the fermentation.
So this is the initial experimental result.
We added 20 gram per liter of cellobiase and 20 gram per liter of xylose.
And two sugars can be co-consumed.
And we even increased the concentration, also co-consumed.
And even 40 and 40 can be co-consumed.
So regardless of the sugar amount, cell consumes cellobiase and xylose at the same time.
So if I emphasize the impact of this fermentation, again, by this graph.
So we have xylose fermentation with 40 gram per liter.
It takes 48 hours.
And cellobiase fermentation takes another 48 hours.
But if we mix those two, still we can finish the fermentation at 48 hours.
So this is like one pot fermentation for two fermentations.
So this is a big commercial impact.
Now we don't have to do two fermentations.
We just do one fermentation, but still we get the same amount of ethanol.
We can process same amount of sugar.
And in reality, we don't have 40 and 40 gram per liter.
In reality, we have 80 gram per liter of cellobiase.
If we hydrolyze the energy cane, and we get the sugar concentration like this, 80 gram
per liter of cellobiase, 40 gram per liter of xylose, and about 10 gram per liter of
glucose.
And we found that still our strain was able to co-consume these sugars and produce ethanol
very efficiently.
This is the naturally existing strain.
The cephalomyces stipides, although it ferments cellobiase and xylose, as you see, very poor.
Now this engineered biological system performs better than naturally existing system.
And still the fermentation takes 48 hours.
I told you that I'd really like to finish this within 24 hours.
So we used the engineered industrial strain.
Usually the laboratory strain and industrial strain has a different performance.
And we found that industrial strain performed better.
After introducing cellobiase and xylose metabolic pathway into industrial strain, we were able
to finish the fermentation within 24 hours.
So now we are satisfying the goal.
When they started this vision, they said the productivity should be more than two gram
per liter per hour, and then our strain was able to produce ethanol at that level.
So I was very excited, and then BP was very excited about this approach.
So they wanted to build the big commercial plant using these ideas.
I'm not sure if they usually decided, but anyway, they were planning to build a big
plant in Florida.
But suddenly last year, November, they canceled the plan.
So everybody was thinking, oh, we may be able to see cellulosic ethanol in the United States
within a couple of years, but BP canceled the plan.
So we need to wait another couple of years.
Why did they cancel it?
So a couple of things.
So they tell, you know, we had some discussion.
They said technology is okay.
We have a technology.
However, the kind of economic environment, because in order to do so, they need to invest
$500 million.
And then right now, BP thinks they can do better if they use $500 million for other
purpose.
So they want to wait.
So this is a co-fermentation idea.
And also, when I was in Korea, I was doing a similar study, but in Korea, they had a
different idea, because there is no biomass or energy crop in Korea.
But they have a lot of this seaweed.
So they were thinking about, let's use seaweed as a substrate, as a starting material, and
let's produce ethanol.
Because seaweed grow very well.
It's very easy to mass produce.
And also, the biggest thing is seaweed do not have lignin.
You know, if you know the shape of the seaweed, it's very flexible.
So they don't have lignin.
It's very easy to hydrolyze or depolymerize.
And also, why we do this?
Because we want to reduce the carbon dioxide production in the air.
We are thinking about global climate change, because by using more and more petroleum,
we produce more and more CO2 gas, and then cause a big impact.
So if we do that, seaweed capture the CO2 better than terrestrial biomass.
So this is a great idea.
However, if we hydrolyze seaweed, we get a mixture of glucose and galactose.
And galactose fermentation is also a very good example for regulation.
You know, if glucose is present, yeast would not touch galactose.
You know, it's a transcriptional, translational, illustrative, very complex regulation.
This is one of the big topics for the systems biologists.
This is a seminar paper by Trey Edecker.
They study, like, the gene expression level or protein content and flux in the galactose
fermentation.
It's very complex.
So if glucose is present, galactose cannot be used.
So same situation.
So we wanted to bypass this by cellulose and galactose fermentation.
Because seaweed has cellulose and galactose, or galactone.
So if we stop the hydrolysis reaction at the level of cellulose, cellulose and galactose
can be co-consumed.
So we made a strain, and then we found that cellulose and galactose can be co-consumed,
as we saw in the cellulose and galactose mixture.
And this is a comparison.
If we use glucose and galactose mixture, sorry, the glucose and galactose mixture, glucose
can be consumed very rapidly, and galactose consumption will follow very slowly.
So if we use our engineered strain, we can consume galactose and cellulose at the same
time.
So this co-fermentation is very promising for using other sugar mixtures.
And also, because we have this co-fermenting capability.
So this is like a multitasking capability.
I don't know when you begin to use a computer, but maybe, you know, when I was learning how
to use a personal computer, we had Windows 3.1.
I'm talking about very primitive operating software, the system.
You may know, like, Windows 95.
Before the Windows 95, we had Windows 3.0.
At the time, everybody was so crazy because we can do multitasking.
Like when we were using MS-DOS, it was like a command line, just one thing.
If you do something, you cannot do other.
When we had Windows 3.0, we had two windows running those command lines.
It's so cool.
So same thing.
Now we can use two sugars at the same time.
So we can do many things.
So one of the kind of ideas was to use this concept for making Xylitol.
And Xylitol is a very popular sugar substitute in Asian countries.
At the same time, Xylitol is a very promising chemical for making other building blocks.
Once we make Xylitol, using a simple chemical conversion step, we can produce other important
chemical that can be used for industrial process.
So this is the current process.
So we use glucose and xylose mixture.
And then we convert the xylose into Xylitol.
But we have a problem.
Glucose inhibits xylose transport.
So in order to solve this problem, we need to add glucose very slowly.
So one way is they add the xylose, and then they feed the glucose a little bit, and then
wait until glucose is gone.
Then xylose will be converted into Xylitol.
And then they add glucose a little bit.
Because if they add glucose a lot, cell would not convert the xylose into Xylitol.
They just use glucose.
You know, if you want to do something with the broccoli, you need to feed the ice cream
little bit, little bit.
Otherwise, if I give a lot of ice cream, my son would not touch broccoli at all.
So that's the kind of trick.
But we don't have to do that, because if we use the cellobiose and xylose, we can feed
the cellobiose and xylose, and then cell will use two sugars at the same time.
So the idea was to use the cellobiose and xylose mixture to produce Xylitol.
And then we did a fermentation experiment after constructing the strain.
I mean, since it is not a biology, I mean, this is because you guys are all engineers.
I skip all the details of a strain construction.
But in a nutshell, we engineered the strain for converting xylose into Xylitol, and then
with the cellobiose consumption.
And then we did the fermentation.
This is a comparison with glucose and xylose.
As you see, glucose will be consumed very fast, and xylose will be used very slowly.
But if we feed the cellobiose and xylose, cell will use the xylose and cellobiose at
the same time.
It will produce Xylitol very well.
So at the 24-hour, the previous system only produced 13 gram per liter of Xylitol, but
we were able to make almost 19 gram per liter of Xylitol.
One more example is that we are doing this in a bioreactor.
In case of glucose and xylose mixture, when glucose is consumed, cell cannot convert the
xylose into Xylitol.
In our case, we are consuming the xylose from the initial point, and then this is the rate
of the Xylitol production.
If we use the cellobiose and xylose mixture, we have a much higher rate of Xylitol production.
In addition, we also wanted to further improve this process because in order to produce Xylitol,
we need NADPH as a reducing power because the xylose to Xylitol is a reduction.
So something should be oxidized.
So NADPH is a cofactor.
In order to overproduce NADPH, we overexpress three enzymes, which is GWF, which is one
of the enzymes that produces NADPH, or ALD6, and also IDP2.
So in order to produce more NADPH, we overexpress this enzyme, and we look at the effect of
this enzyme for Xylitol production, and we found that IDP2 has the highest impact.
But still, all the overexpression has resulted in a better Xylitol production.
However, if we do the same thing with the glucose and xylose mixture, we cannot see
that effect.
Although we have a higher NADPH production, xylose uptake will be limited by glucose.
So we cannot see the effect in case of glucose and xylose mixture, but with the cellulose
and xylose mixture, we see the impact very well.
So using this co-fermentation and overexpression of enzyme for making NADPH, we are able to
produce Xylitol much faster and efficient than the existing process using this idea.
So the basic idea is this is a conventional fermentation process.
We use glucose or sucrose, and we produce fuels and chemicals.
But now we extend the substrate using cellulosic hydrolyzate.
In addition, we can use multiple sugars at the same time.
We can use cellulose and xylose mixture at the same time, sucrose and xylose at the same
time, or cellulose and galactose.
So by using cheaper, non-edible substrate, we can do better because we have simultaneous
co-fermentation of mixed sugar.
That's the one idea, and then maybe I can spend another five minutes to explain another
very interesting example of metabolic engineering.
So the next thing is the production of 2-FL, probably you are not familiar with this sugar.
So this is oligosaccharide.
And why we want to produce 2-FL?
All the idea came from the breast milk-fed baby and formula milk-fed baby.
For some reason, the baby had breast milk.
So healthier, they are stronger than the formula milk-fed baby.
Then they found that somehow the milk-fed baby has higher contents of bifidobacterium
in their gut.
The formula-fed baby has lower bifidobacterium.
So maybe gut microorganisms do something.
Then they wanted to look at what is the difference between cow's milk and human's milk.
And they found that human milk has very unique oligosaccharide.
This is what we call human milk oligosaccharide.
And most of them has a fucose unit.
Probably you don't know what is a fucose.
Fucose is a 5-carbon sugar.
It's a rare sugar.
But human milk has oligosaccharide, the fucose lactose.
So this is a lactose unit, which is also very abundant in cow's milk.
But human milk has a fucose lactose.
So now they suspect that maybe this fucose lactose, when we had the milk, caused the
growth of the bifidobacterium or good bacteria.
That's why we get healthier.
So that's the hypothesis.
So the reason why I wanted to study was because I'm in the food science department.
And my colleague wanted to study this.
He said, oh, Dr. Jin, I'd like to study the effect of 2-FL adding to the food.
So he wanted to design the experiment, like he has two pigs, piglet model.
So he wanted to feed the normal diet.
He wanted to feed the 2-FL-enriched diet.
And he wanted to look at the changes of gut microorganisms in the pig system.
In order to do so, he needed to feed the 2-FL.
And he checked the price of this sugar is like $100 per milligram.
In order to feed the piglet, he needed to have several grams or even 100 grams of sugar.
Then it cost him like a million dollars just to buy sugar.
And I thought, maybe we can do something.
So I checked the current scheme.
And then they do a 2-FL isolation from human milk, which is possible, but it's not a good
way.
So I did some chemical synthesis.
And I found that there is enzymatic synthesis of 2-FL synthesis.
So in a nutshell, so there is a 2-FL producing pathway in E. coli.
By engineering this 2-FL pathway, we can produce this sugar in E. coli.
So we engineered GDP-pure glucose pathway.
And then in order to attach this GDP-pure glucose into lactose, we overexpressed the
pure glucose transferase from helicobacter pylori.
So we made a strain, which produced 2-FL.
Then we did a fermentation.
As you see, this is lactose consumption.
We feed the lactose, which is very, very cheap sugar.
And we produce 2-pure glucose lactose up to 1 gram per liter.
So each fermentation, I was talking to my student, like, you know, if they do a small
flask fermentation, it has a value of $50,000.
If we purify, I mean, even though we don't purify, if we purify, if we sell it in the
market.
And then she did also a fat batch type fermentation to further increase the 2-FL concentration.
You know, we feed the sugar, feed the sugar, we've gone, and then we were able to produce
2-FL up to 4.5 gram per liter.
In this case, you know, one big batch will cost $1 million.
You know, we can make it.
So we made this sugar.
So now we are trying to purify the sugar, and then my colleague is going to use that
sugar for doing animal experiment.
And the goal is if everything looks fine, and if everything works as we imagine, we
want to produce 2-FL, and we want to enrich into human-infant formula to make a healthy
baby.
And also another kind of concern, okay, are you making really 2-FL?
So we did the mass spec analysis, and we found that the fragmentation of this mass
spectrum is identical to chemically synthesized 2-FL.
So it makes sure that we are making 2-FL.
So in summary, I show you the two examples.
Using this metabolic engineering concept, we can produce the fuels and chemical, or
we can produce this very high-value nutraceutical compound.
And I'd like to thank my group members, like Seokjin Ha, who did all the cellulose fermentation
study, and also Wonhong Lee, he did the fucozylactose 2-FL study.
And these are the group members, the blue names are the person who did all the experiment.
And also I'd like to thank my collaborator at UC Berkeley, Jamie Kate, who provided the
cellulose bioutilization cassette.
And also we had a very close collaboration with the BP scientists.
Whenever we develop a new process, whenever we design a new fermentation process, we consult
with them to have a more realistic concentration.
And also I'd like to thank our funding source, Energy Bioscience Institute.
For your information, this is a non-profit bioenergy science institute in this university,
and also in UC Berkeley, which is funded by BP.
BP promised to invest $500 million to this institute.
So this is the fifth year, they already spent $250 million.
The exact speaking, they pledged to spend $500 million, but only $350 million goes to
UIUC and UC Berkeley, $150 goes to BP research.
So they already spent $150 million for bioenergy research, and they will continue to support
to bioenergy science research.
So I'm getting the fund from them.
And having said that, I'd like to thank all for your attention.
So if you have any questions, I would be happy to answer.
A very interesting talk.
That chair.
Yes.
When you were talking about the co-fermentation, and then the one time you added the, you're
changing the substrate, the concentrations, in one of them you add like a small amount
of glucose alongside the cellulose, so at what point does that start inhibiting, or
does that, or is there still like a small lag where it'll quickly consume the glucose
and then start the rest?
So frankly speaking, glucose will be consumed first.
Because it's so small, it looks like a co-fermentation, but in reality, glucose will be consumed within
a couple of minutes.
That amount can be consumed within a couple of minutes.
So that's why, but we had the sampling point after 10 hours, that's why it looks like this,
but in reality, glucose is still used first, and cellulose will be used later.
But since the glucose contamination is not that high, we can disregard the glucose repression.
That explain your question?
I was curious, how is the cellulosic material served to the cell, do you homogenize it,
or how is it actually delivered?
Cellulosic material, so maybe, so we have a powder.
So usually we harvest the cell, harvest the plant, and we make the powder, and we do pre-treatment,
like acid and high-temperature treatment, and we get the slurry.
Then we add enzyme, then the slurry becomes a kind of a sore gel type thing, and we dilute,
and we add a medium, and we add the cell, and we do the fermentation.
So still it's not that clean, it's like, even at the end of the fermentation, it's like
a slurry type.
But it's very thin slurry at the fermentation, but before the fermentation, it's very thick
slurry.
Did you answer your question?
I have two questions.
So what's the current cost for making the biofuel with cellulose compared with gasoline?
You mean the cost?
Cost, like how much is it?
I'm not an expert in cost analysis, but if I just give you the ballpark number, I think
it's still very expensive to make cellulosic ethanol, or cellulosic fuel.
So what I was told was, kind of an easy way, if the petroleum price stays more than $200
per barrel, then we have competitiveness.
What I'm saying is, making cellulosic fuel makes sense only if the price of petroleum
is more than $200 per barrel.
If right now it's $100 per barrel, maybe $80, then, frankly speaking, this doesn't make
sense.
But it could have space to improve the efficiency.
And also, it's not about the money.
Our winning argument is global climate change.
It's not because of the money.
The reason why we want to produce biofuel is because of the weather.
Not weather, the global climate.
By using more and more petroleum-based resources, we accumulate more and more CO2 in nature.
But if we do that, even though it is more expensive, it is carbon neutral.
Because although the burning of ethanol produces CO2, this CO2 will be captured by the plant
again.
In general, in a net cycle, it's the zero, the CO2 cycle.
So it's not all about the money.
It's all about the environmental impact.
Another question.
I know that even for biofuel production, there are other alternative approaches, like using
algae.
I think they were kind of reaching an equal to converting the solar energy to hydrogen.
So all different approaches for producing biofuel.
Can you comment on the pros and cons of those approaches?
That's true.
We have a lot of approaches.
That's good, because we should try a lot of things.
So this is a conventional process to make a carbon source, or get the sugar and do the
fermentation.
And also another approach is, let's bypass agriculture.
So right now, in order to do so, we need agriculture.
You need to grow the energy crop, corn, whatever.
Then you extract the sugar, you do the fermentation.
Actually, as a faculty member who is in the College of Agriculture, I like that idea.
But there are some people who want to bypass this step, which is algae.
And algae, there is no agriculture.
You have a bioreactor, you give the sunlight, and then you make the fuel without agriculture.
So that's one idea.
But what I was told was, it looks good.
However, the biggest problem with the microalgae technology is dewatering.
After you grow the algae in the water system, your fuel, the product, is only inside of
the cell.
You need to separate water from the cell.
That's very energy intensive.
And also the water.
You need a lot of water to do this.
So that's why the National Research Council, NRC, made a report last year.
They comprehensively reviewed all the process for microalgae, and then their conclusion
was water may be a problem.
Can they grow in seawater, right?
So that's why they made the major suggestion.
If they use the seawater, maybe that would be okay.
But the problem is, some asymmetry between sunlight and seawater availability.
Wherever we have a strong sunlight, desert, we don't have water.
Wherever we have a good water availability, like some South Pole, North Pole, we don't
have good sunlight.
Some asymmetry is a problem.
If we have good water in a good sunlight area, that would be great.
So that's why water is a big problem.
And then we don't have a good place to have a boat.
And the last one is making sunlight into hydrogen.
Then hydrogen is also a very interesting approach.
When we are thinking about alternative energy, there are wind energy, solar energy, and many
other things.
But the reason why we want to do this bioenergy or biofuel production is, if you look at the
energy consumption in the United States or in the world, all the energy consumption sector
is using the same amount of energy as compared to 10 years ago, except for transportation.
We have enough energy for other sectors, only transportation, like a vehicle.
We have a very rapid increase in the energy consumption.
So in order to satisfy that demand, we need to have portable fuel.
But electricity is not portable.
That's why people are studying the battery.
In order to use a battery for transportation, we need a good battery.
So that's a problem.
And people are thinking about hydrogen.
But as you know, safety issue and things.
So that's why hydrogen would be a good idea in the long term.
But in the short term, it's very risky to use, because of storage problem.
The generation of hydrogen is pretty easy.
There are many ways to generate cheap hydrogen, but storage and usage is very risky.
So that's why if we use biofuel, we can use existing infrastructure.
We don't have to change the car.
We don't have to change the gas stage.
We don't have to change anything.
It's the same liquid fuel.
But this electricity or wind energy, solar energy, hydrogen, we need to change all the
infrastructure.

