Science from the ivory tower

nature video
11 followers
Sep 5, 2023
Nobel laureate William E. Moerner believes scientists should defend science more vigorously. But faced with contentious topics like genetically modified organisms, who’s best placed to get the right messages about science to the public?
A sponsor message from Mars, Incorporated – partner of the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings – follows the credits.
In the coming 30 years, if a young researcher like me is to get a Nobel Prize for, what
do you think it would be?
It would be for something that you're passionate for.
Each year at the Lindau meetings in Germany, young researchers come together to learn from
Nobel Prize winners as well as from each other.
I work with tiny marine organisms and look at how fluid flow affects their dynamics.
It's fascinating to see how things at such tiny scales can have such global climatic
implications.
I want to cure malaria, and to do this we need early detection methods, and this is
an assay I'm trying to develop currently.
But there's much more to the meetings in Lindau than seeking scientific collaboration.
They also inspire discussion about wider questions in science.
The use of genetically modified organisms in food production has been the source of
many communication problems for scientists, according to one Nobel laureate.
One problem is food, and having enough food.
There was a lecture this morning about GMO, how GMO should be used and should not be thwarted
in terms of being able to provide rice that's far more nutritious to people in Africa, for
example, that really could have an impact.
He used golden rice as an example, where they just engineered this rice to have beta carotene
in the grain of the rice.
There were documented evidence that the amount of this golden rice that you need to take
care of children at an early age, for especially vitamin A deficiency, it was proposed that
it's something like over some kilograms of them you need to, yeah, take care of it.
Yeah, but that was a stupid lie, that wasn't actually a cure at all.
As a matter of fact, it's just, what, a few hundred grams, 150 grams that you need.
It's less than what they're already eating.
Exactly, so there is a very conscious effort to really misguide people.
So what about GMOs in Europe, because they're a ban.
I mean, in the US we have so many GMOs everywhere.
And this makes me angry because it makes people fearful of them.
Exactly.
And there is nothing to be fearful about.
That's not a good message.
If you ask the general public, do you want GMOs in your food, they'll say no.
Or do you want antibiotics in your food?
But if you say, what's a GMO, they'll be like, um, green, magical.
Something that needs to be labelled because it's not safe.
So this is what happens when politics get mixed up in science.
But then maybe this needs to be ingrained, even from an early stage, say at school level,
that okay, these are alternatives, so that people need to be educated about...
See, I think it's our job as scientists to do that.
Scientists themselves ought to work to be able to explain their work in an understandable
way to a broad audience.
And we also rely on the other media, et cetera, to publicise work.
But there's some concerns about that.
Much of the media today give equal time to a very valid scientific approach that's been
validated and is correct 99% of the time.
They give equal time to that and also to some things that are completely at odds with
the consensus of science.
Many people all over the world now, and in the United States, for example, don't believe
in fluoridation, even though it's good, are worried about vaccines, even though they save
lives, don't believe in climate change, even though it's basically happening, and so on.
And we have to ask ourselves, why do people have these different points of view?
And we have a challenge to explain that properly.
We have to keep putting it out there.
That's why I tweet.
I tweet so that my information about that things like this are safe is going into the
public domain.
And eventually, if enough scientists do that, then...
Yeah, I think that there needs to be more scientists that are vocal about their research,
other people's research, just talking about science.
Should this be like a main career?
I don't think it should be a whole career, though.
No, like how, you know, there's some scientists that are editors of papers or something.
Like, this should actually be a profession, you're a scientist, but all you do is PR work
and you...
But I don't think you should...
But that's another aspect of science, I would say.
I don't think we should have communicators and scientists.
I think we should have scientists who are communicators.
Lindau is not an ivory tower.
On the contrary, Lindau is paving the way to show how science can be communicated for
a general benefit and well-being for the society.
I think we had some very interesting discussions about how a mutual interaction can do a lot
better to the society than what we are actually doing now.
It's extremely beneficial when we can apply this to society, right?
Just getting lab results and keeping them published on a paper or something doesn't
really benefit the community as a whole.
And so it's much better if we're able to communicate what our findings mean and its implications
on society.
The beautiful baobab tree, or tree of life, is an African icon.
The baobab fruit contains four times the potassium of banana, three times the vitamin
C of an orange, and twice the calcium of spinach.
But the baobab is an orphan.
Science has paid little attention to this tree... until now.
The African Orphan Crops Consortium is harnessing the power of genetics for orphan crops.
The baobab tree is the first of 101 plants to have its genome sequence assembled and
annotated, and the information will be made available to all, unrestricted.
Where millions of people are malnourished, this genetic data will help farmers provide
the food they need.
The genomes will guide African plant breeders so they can create crops that are higher yielding,
water and nutrient use sufficient, resilient to climate change, and full of nutrition,
triggering a huge leap forward for the diversity and sustainability of the continent's agriculture.
