New Views of the Pillars of Creation Presented by Dr. Frank Summers, Space Telescope Science Institute
One of Hubble's most famous images was taken in 1995. The iconic "Pillars of Creation" shows the tall and beautiful gaseous pillar structures that can form inside star-forming regions. Within these dark clouds, stars are being born. Hubble kicked off its 25th anniversary year in 2015 with some images that used its improved cameras to revisit these beautiful pillars. This larger, higher resolution, and expanded wavelength examination uncovered new details, new features, and new perspectives on a classic image.
-- Most will remember that there was an initial flaw in Hubble's mirror that was corrected in 1993. After that repair mission, it took some time for the public to recognize just how amazing Hubble's views of the universe really were. The 'Pillars of Creation' image, released in November 1995, was a watershed in that regard. The image was shown on television news and reproduced in newspapers and magazines everywhere. The widespread attention helped certify Hubble's status to the public as the pre-eminent observatory of our time.
-- The "teapot" in Sagittarius is not the full constellation. It is a star pattern, called an "asterism," within the larger collection of connected stars that makes up the entire constellation. One can search online to see the full Sagittarius constellation as it depicts the archer. A similar asterism is the Big Dipper, which is a star pattern within the constellation of Ursa Major.
-- The visible and infrared views of astronomical objects are generally similar enough that one can identify common structures between the views. When using other wavelengths, like X-rays or radio waves, it can be very hard to identify how the two different wavelength views correspond. Astronomers must record the exact sky coordinates of an image in order to be able to precisely compare against views by other telescopes and in other wavelengths.
Welcome to Hubble's Universe Unfiltered.
I'm Dr. Frank Summers.
In this episode, we're going to explore a classic Hubble image.
One of the Hubble images that first brought the attention
of Hubble's amazing imagery to the public, and one that is
still one of the favorites today. It is this image
called the Pillars of Creation, and in it you can see
three dark gas pillars that are brightly highlighted
by this yellow ionization front around those pillars.
And inside those pillars, stars are forming.
So that's why they're called the Pillars of Creation.
Beautiful pillars, but they have star formation going on inside.
And we have some new images of these that reveal details
on both small and large scales. Let's start with the largest
of scales. Let's show you where it is on the night sky.
This is an image directed toward the constellation of Sagittarius.
And although mythology may tell you that Sagittarius is the archer,
if you know the star pattern, well, Sagittarius, it's a little
teapot. It's short, and it's stout.
Here is its handle, and here is its spout.
Now that spout points toward the center of our galaxy, which is
located approximately here. So when we view the constellation
of Sagittarius, we're looking toward the center of our galaxy, and we have a very
rich field. There are a lot of star clusters and nebulae.
The ones denoted here with these M numbers are Messier
objects. These Messier objects are generally the star clusters
and the nebulae, or sometimes they're both. The Eagle Nebula
is also known as Messier 16, and it's located
here, well to the left of the galactic center. If we
zoom in on the Eagle Nebula, you can see the structure of it. Here, I suppose,
is the head of the eagle, and here is its body with its wings extending out
to either side. Now, I know, you've got to sort of squint your eyes
and use your imagination to see it, but this is actually better than most of
them. Let's zoom in a little bit further, and you can see what's happening
inside the nebula. There is this bright cluster of stars,
and it is the energetic radiation and the stellar winds from these
bright stars that have created a cavity in the gas cloud.
If I overlay the Hubble image, you can see that the pillars
are pointed directly toward that star cluster. Again,
it is the energetic radiation streaming down that blows
away all the low-density gas, leaving behind only the high-density
gas of the pillars. So this Hubble image is from
20 years ago, and it was taken with an instrument called the Wide-field
Planetary Camera 2. You can tell because it has this characteristic
stair step. In Wide-field Planetary Camera 2, there are
three wide-field chips, the upper left, the lower left,
and the lower right, and one chip that's called the Planetary Camera
in the upper right. Now, the Planetary Camera chip has
twice the resolution on the sky as the other chips,
and therefore it only covers one quarter of the area on the sky.
Since then, we have replaced the Wide-field Planetary Camera
2. In 2009, we installed the Wide-field
Camera 3, or I will sometimes call that WF-C3,
and the other one WF-PIC2. WF-C3 took advantage of a
decade and a half of improvements and has higher resolution,
larger field of view, and better technology in its optics.
With WF-C3, we were able to revisit the pillars
in Eagle Nebula, and we got that image.
Now, the original was stunning when it came out, but I think this is
even more dramatic. And if I overlay the original image,
you can see that it covers a much larger region on the sky, about six times
the area on the sky as covered in the new image. And because of the higher
resolution of the detectors, it has about 20 times more pixels.
So let's take a look at the comparison between the old and the new.
We're going to start with the top of the middle pillar. This
in the old image is the Planetary Camera chip. So this has the
higher resolution in WF-PIC2, and that resolution is roughly
similar to the resolution of WF-C3. So the difference
between these two images really shows the difference in the detection
technology. And you can see that there are similar features in the
old image as in the new image, but they're just a little bit clearer, a little bit
finer in the new image. The other thing you notice
is that around the tops of the pillar, you can see sort of a speckling.
We call this noise. This is the low-level brightness of an image,
and we can see noise in it. There is noise in the WF-C3 image, but it's at much
lower level. It looks a lot smoother. This region
is in the middle of the tall pillar on the left, and
here the resolutions of the detectors are different. So you can see a
fuzziness in the old image and a clearer view in the
new image. One particularly interesting feature is that these
ionization fronts, that yellow region along the edge of the dark gas,
that was unresolved in the original image.
It is also unresolved in the new image, which means this is a
very thin layer on the edge of the dark nebula where the
ionization is happening. The other thing you notice is these
regions here where there are two stars forming. One of them is sort of
in a cavity inside the nebula, and the other one is sort of at the top of
a small pillar that sort of resembles a smokestack to me.
You may also notice these artifacts up here.
They're kind of streaks. Well, what they are are actually just the diffraction spikes
of a bright star that's located off this region of the
image. If we move to the top of the tall pillar,
we can definitely see again the difference in
the resolution. There's a fuzziness to this image that becomes much
more clear in looking at the new image. And I love this region
of the image because it's got all these small fingers of dark
gas, and they're brightly silhouetted by the ionization fronts.
And these fingers could have really dense
gas inside them, and they could have stars forming inside them. We do see
evidence of one star forming down here
because when stars form, they often give off these energetic jets
of radiation, oppositely directed jets.
And here you can see the jet coming from a newborn star right in
there. And these jets are moving away from the star at about
half a million miles an hour. And if we compare
them carefully, we can actually see the motion of those jets.
So here is the 1995 image and the 2014
image, and the arrows indicate the end of the jet
between those two epochs. Over 19
years, that jet traveled 60 billion
miles. Not much changes in a human lifetime in the universe,
but here we can actually observe something changing on our timescales.
Those are the direct comparisons of the old versus the new,
but having a larger image provides us some other interesting details to look
at. For example, let's just take a look at this
middle pillar. You can see that the top of it is what we saw in the old
image, but then we had a relatively cut off view here.
When we extend it, you can see the gas flowing off the end of it.
This really drives home the point that it's the radiation and winds
from those stars that are blowing back the gas and getting rid of the
low density gas. It also, according to a friend of mine,
makes it the Dementor Pillar, because it
resembles the computer graphics effect used for the Dementors
in the Harry Potter films. There's another cool region down here
in the lower right of the image. If I blow that up to full screen,
you can see that we've got some tiny little pillars. These are individual
small pillars that are very much like those fingers that we saw at the top of the tall pillar.
However, these are isolated, and I would guess that these
would evaporate away relatively quickly sometime in the future.
There are a lot more details. There's lots of cool stuff all throughout
this image, and if you go to our website, you can download all
60 million pixels of it. You can go through it and explore it to
your heart's content. Here, I'm going to go in a different direction,
because WFC3 not only improved our ability
to observe in visible light, it also improved our ability to observe
in infrared light. So using the infrared detectors on WFC3,
we were able to get this image. Let me go back.
Visible light, infrared light.
Really cool how it looks so different in infrared light.
The first thing you notice is that there's a tremendous number of stars
in the image that you don't see in the visible light.
Well, that's because infrared light has longer wavelengths. The longer wavelengths
can penetrate through the gas and the dust better, allowing you to see the stars
both inside the nebula and the innumerable
stars that are behind the nebula. You also notice that
there are the pillars' structures are here, but they look
kind of ghostly. They aren't really that solid in infrared
light as they are in visible light. Again, this is because
the infrared light will penetrate through some of that gas and dust.
Let's explore some of those comparisons, but this time doing visible
light versus infrared light. We go back to the top of the middle
pillar, and the first thing I notice about this is that how
opaque the gas is in infrared light.
This indicates it must be really dense gas in here.
Also notice that there is star formation going on
inside the pillar. Here in the visible light image, you see a little bit of red
that indicates star formation. But in the infrared,
you're looking through some of that gas into the cavity inside the pillar
in which you can see stars that are forming. Now, I know
it's not perfectly clear, but infrared has a lower resolution
than visible light. That's again because of the wavelengths.
The resolution of a telescope is proportional to the wavelength that you're
observing. If you wanted to get this type of
visible light equivalent resolution in the infrared, you'd need a larger
mirror to the telescope. That will come with the James Webb Space Telescope
launching in 2018. Until that time, we're going to
have to deal that our infrared images are a little bit lower resolution than our visible light
images. If we move to this region, which is the one in the
middle of the tall pillar on the left, we can see that again
we have some dark, dense gas here. But in the lower left,
you can actually see through the gas to see stars beyond the nebula.
That indicates that it's lower density and it's somewhat
transparent in infrared light. We can also see
that that star at the top of what I call the smokestack is very bright
in the infrared. At the top of the large pillar,
we get to the region where we have those fingers. And here's where you can see the
ghostliness of it. Because the fingers are brightly silhouetted
and prominent in the visible light image, but
they're very nebulous in the infrared image. That indicates
that they aren't that high density. It doesn't look like we'll have stars forming
in this finger up here because otherwise there would be a dense knot
of gas that would be opaque to infrared radiation.
We can also see another region of star formation. There's only a hint
of it in the visible light image with that tiny little bit of red. But here
we can see the big white region that again stars in formation
inside the pillar. If we pull back to take a look at the top half
of the large pillar, we get to see just how
ghostly it really is. In visible light, it looks like a relatively
solid pillar. But in infrared light, you can see that the middle section
is actually low density gas. And this is a very important
point about these pillars. What they are, are these dense
regions up here that create the pillars by the shadow
in visible light. Infrared light shows
them to be relatively transparent. You can see a lot of, if you look at this image
in detail, you can see a lot of these dense regions that
don't have dense regions behind them, but in visible light they look
as if they're dense because they are in shadow. There's one other cool
region I want to talk about, and it's actually at the bottom of the smallest pillar.
Now when I zoom that up to full screen, you might look at this and say
well, those aren't the same regions, but I assure you they are.
See, you can see that those two stars there in the visible light image
appear here in the infrared image. Almost
all the other stars don't appear in the visible light image. And in particular
you've got these four really bright stars in the infrared
that are hardly visible at all. Matter of fact, when I went through, I went very
carefully through it, and those two very faint stars in the visible light
image are the left two stars here in the infrared image.
Whereas these ones, they don't appear at all in the visible light image.
These must be very low mass stars, because
while a star like the sun emits most of its light in visible light,
the very smaller stars, the lower mass stars, emit most of their
light in infrared radiation. So here we are looking at
two very low mass stars, very bright, and it shows you just the
difference you can get by using multi-wavelength astronomy.
Here are that trio of images of Hubble's views of the
pillars in the Eagle Nebula. The original 1995 image,
the 2014 visible light, and the 2014
infrared. These images show off
how Hubble has improved its detectors over the years, how we
can get larger fields of view, how we can get higher resolution,
and how we benefit from using multi-wavelength astronomy
to explore the universe. Thanks for watching, I'm Dr. Frank
Summers.