Meatball Throwndown with Bobby Flay

Bobby Flay
372 followers
20 Video Views·Aug 26, 2023
Got it, love it.
On this episode of Throwdown.
Don't get nervous, it's just a meatball.
Yeah.
I head to North Port Long Island
to take on Italian superstar Mike Marroni
and his grandma's meatballs.
Even people that don't like meatballs eat these.
Mike thinks he's being featured
on a Food Network show called The Family Table.
From my family to yours.
But guess who's coming to dinner?
I should've brought my bathing suit, I knew it.
Do I have what it takes to match Mike's meatballs?
You're gonna put a chipotle pepper in them, Bobby.
Or will it take the luck of the Irish to win this one?
You know, there's great spaghetti and meatballs
in Dublin, don't forget it.
My name is Bobby Flay.
My mission, to find the best of the best.
My objective, perfecting their signature dish.
The plan of attack, I'm showing up to challenge them,
but they don't know it.
I may win, I might even lose, it's anybody's game.
It's the ultimate throwdown.
Here are the books you need to sign, Bobby.
Thank you very much.
For the next throwdown, meatballs.
I'm Mike Maroni, this is my restaurant, Maroni Cuisine.
My guess is that he's Italian.
Claim to fame, Maroni Cuisine has scored
one of the highest Zagat ratings possible
and has a huge following of loyal customers.
My meatballs really are succulent, it's meat,
they're not hard, they don't taste like a hamburger.
Here's the setup, Mike thinks the Food Network
is filming a series called The Family Table,
celebrating traditional family meals across the country.
Food Network, you're watching The Family Table.
So he's invited our crew to join his Italian dinner party
where he'll cook up his outstanding spaghetti and meatballs.
Spaghetti and meatballs, don't forget.
Don't get nervous, it's just a meatball.
Mike credits his grandmother
for his famous meatball recipe.
It's a century old tradition
that's stood the taste buds of time.
My grandmother made the best meatballs,
you thought you died and went to heaven.
Your mission is to perfect a meatball recipe
and deliver it to the Maroni Family Table
to see who's the real meatball master, cook or be cooked.
All right, Mike, be sure to leave me a seat at the table
because I'm coming over.
North Port, New York is a quaint waterfront town
with killer views and killer meatballs.
Thanks to local chef, Mike Maroni.
Awesome.
Mike's been dishing out Italian eats his way
since he and his wife, Maria,
opened their restaurant in 2001.
Here at Maroni's, there's no menus.
People just come in, we get a general profile of you.
Do you like oysters?
Do you like caviar?
Are you allergic to anything?
And then we just go.
The cuisine might not always be traditional.
I think his ideas are crazy,
but they're always a home run, so.
The food at Maroni Cuisine is chef style.
It's the way he prepares it, the way it should be done,
and it's up to him to do it.
So you either eat it or you don't.
And when it comes to his meatballs, forget about it.
Meatballs are simple, like mama made them.
The meatballs, they just have tremendous flavor.
Nice little spices with the sauce, flavorful, tender.
Mike's meatballs are so popular
that people buy them by the potful.
We serve the food hot in this pot for takeout.
We probably sell about 500 to 600 pots a week.
It's not just the meatballs
that draw crowds to Maroni Cuisine.
Well, I like Maroni's
because it's not just coming out for a meal,
or it's kind of like you're coming to visit people.
It's a family business,
and we treat the customers like they're guests in our home.
So we feed them, we give them lots of wine,
and we take very good care of them,
and we have fun doing it.
Tomorrow, Mike and Maria will be entertaining
friends and family at an intimate gathering in their home.
We have some beautiful antipasta that Mike is preparing,
and we are going to have
our classic spaghetti and meatball dinner,
and everybody's very excited for it.
How will they feel when I show up for dinner?
Cheers.
Okay, here's the strategy for my meatballs.
Three meats, veal, beef, and pork,
and I'm going to a great butcher.
This is Otto Minelli and Sons,
and my friend, Frank Ottominelli.
Hey, Frank, how you doing?
Hey, how you doing?
Good to see you today.
So what's you got tonight?
Meatballs.
Meatballs slow down.
You know what I need?
I need three kinds of meat.
I need some ground sirloin, some ground veal,
and some ground pork.
We got it.
I mean, that's the classic, right?
That's the way to go.
Right.
The beef is obviously for some rich flavor.
The veal is going to actually be a lighter flavor,
and then the pork is going to add what I like to say
is flavor from the fats of the beef.
So we're going to have a little bit more
of a fattiness in the pork,
and it's going to help to add moisture.
So you have three meats making one delicious flavor.
We got the perfect mix, Bob.
Okay.
It's great.
And now we're good to go.
All right.
Okay, buddy.
Good luck with the trail down.
We'll see you again.
Thanks so much, Frank.
Thank you.
All right, great.
See you later.
See you guys.
Mike's grandmother handed down an award-winning recipe.
And I've been making these meatballs
for about 32 years, 33 years.
My heritage may be working against me.
Every good Italian cook has a grandmother's recipe, right?
My grandmother made sour product.
Just do not look at the camera.
Mike Maroney is about to whip up the dish
that's made him famous.
Let's go make some meatballs.
While Mike works on his grandma's recipe on Long Island,
I'll be working on a recipe of my own
in the Food Network Test Kitchens.
Okay, I have my trusty assistants, Miriam and Stephanie.
It's all about the meatballs.
That's lovely.
I've decided the best defense to Mike's grandmother's recipe
is another old family recipe from Stephanie's Italian mother.
Rosa Pizzapella.
What's up, Rosa?
That's her stage name.
No, her name is Rose, but we call her Pizzapella.
Okay, we're gonna talk about some awesome meatballs
and how to prepare them.
We're gonna start with a pound of ground chuck.
I don't use pork, I don't use veal.
I like to use chuck because I believe
that that's the most flavorful meats that you can use.
So we have the pork, the veal, and the beef.
And basically what's gonna happen
is we're gonna actually flavor this meat.
Stephanie's mom uses about one egg per pound of meat.
I think that's pretty standard.
That's a good rule of thumb, I guess.
Some nice, large, fresh eggs.
Fourth of the pound is what I use.
It sounds like a lot, it's not.
I am introducing an Italian quiche inside this meatball.
Any other way, you're eating a freaking hamburger
that doesn't taste too good.
We like to put Parmesan cheese
because we like the saltiness of it.
You can obviously use Romano cheese if you'd like.
Four ounces of Pecorino Romano.
Pecorino just is a lot more pungent,
just has a lot more flavor, and it's just a lot better.
I finish off my meatballs with sauteed garlic,
some parsley, and breadcrumbs.
Fresh, white breadcrumbs.
Some people say stale bread, this bread.
Who cares?
Use bread.
Garlic, very important.
Parsley, onions.
Sometimes I grate them.
Today, I wasn't in the mood, so I didn't.
All right, let's see what this looks like.
No, don't mash it like that.
Remember, you wanna keep it nice and light.
You can use your hands.
Can I?
Yeah, of course.
I think, you don't wanna overwork it,
but you can certainly, oh, light, light, light.
Take it easy.
I got 10 to meatballs.
Okay, now it's time to form the meatballs.
I like, some people, you know, you go to these restaurants
and they got a, like a shot put, you know,
like they got a meatball this friggin' big.
I can't understand, I can't comprehend it.
One and a half ounce meatball,
it's about the size of a large egg
or a fat golf ball on steroids, possibly.
That's what you want.
How's that look for size?
It's a little big, but it's good.
Once the meatballs are formed,
they are sauteed in a hot pan with a little olive oil
until they turn golden brown.
Don't overcook these.
I know.
Okay, the way that I cook my meatballs
is I bake them in a hot oven.
Cooking them in the oven saves a lot of their flavor
and it blows up and that egg and that bread
gets to stay in the meatball.
In the oven, simple.
Let's go make some sauce.
Now, we're gonna actually use a version of your mom's sauce.
Right.
So we have onions and garlic
that we sauteed with some olive oil.
Beautiful.
Now, let's add some of our tomatoes.
These are crushed, all-purpose, whole peeled tomatoes.
And then we have tomato paste, whole canned tomatoes,
and a Cubano pepper, some crushed red peppers.
Parsley.
And some parsley, that's it.
I'm gonna bring this to a simmer.
This sauce does not need to cook.
It needs to simmer for no more than 10 minutes, 15 minutes.
Nothing is exact.
We let the sauce simmer for 15 minutes
until it has thickened nicely.
Now, the meatballs and the sauce are gonna become friends.
All right, our meatballs just came out of the oven.
We're gonna introduce them to the sauce
and then we're gonna have a party.
I'm serving my meatballs
with their traditional counterpart, spaghetti.
And I'm topping it all
with some grated Parmesan cheese and fresh basil.
This is a little bit of fresh basil.
Now, what we're gonna do,
I'm gonna take a little bit of the tomato sauce.
This is a very important technique.
So what you wanna do is you wanna take your fork
and you wanna lift up the pasta
so all that sauce that you put on top
goes right to the bottom.
Then you take four meatballs, put them on top,
a little bit more tomato sauce.
Again, more Romano.
If this isn't the best bowl of pasta you've had,
it's certainly one of them.
I would say the meatballs are good, but they're not perfect.
They need to cook a little longer to get moist.
They need to stew.
We need fattier meat.
I think you can even tell when you cut it
that the meatball's a little dry.
And I think it needs to cook longer,
but I also think it's a fattier cut of meat.
The sauce is great.
The sauce is fantastic, I love it.
The flavor's great though, don't you think?
Yeah, it's really good.
Flavor's perfect, yeah.
I could eat this all day long.
Think about it, a meatball,
properly made spaghetti and meatball.
Guaranteed, major hit.
All right, Mike Maroni, we're coming at you
with Rosa Pizzapella's meatballs.
They can't be beat.
The table is set at the Maroni house
for their al fresco dinner party.
Outside, cooking some nice meatballs,
some tomato sauce, good friends.
What else is there?
Oh, I can think of something else.
We're out here in Long Island, New York,
and we're going to Mike Maroni's house,
and then hopefully we're gonna get our meatball throwdown on
and see what happens.
I'm starving.
Cheers, everybody, and thank you
for coming to the family table.
We have a lot of nice food.
We have some meatballs and any pasta.
Salute.
I am, I'm Italian, I'm ready.
I think we're gonna win.
All right, we're gonna make some meatballs again today.
Okay, here we are, Mike Maroni's neighborhood.
Would you like to be my assistant?
Oh, no.
Honey, pass me the parsley.
Don't get sauce on my dress, that's all.
Don't get nervous, it's just a meatball.
Man, does it smell good in here?
Oh, my God.
Yeah!
What's up, guys?
Mr. Maroni?
How are you?
Very good.
Hi, how are you?
Very nice to meet you.
Welcome to our home.
I am so hungry.
I mean, I can smell the food like two miles away.
I should've brought my bathing suit.
I knew it.
I got bathing.
Anything you need.
No problem.
I like that.
Anything you need.
I got a great idea.
Okay.
How about a meatball throwdown?
Let's do it.
Yeah?
Let's do it.
The man is confident.
He's ready.
Thank you.
Thank you so much.
Nice to meet you.
Yeah, Mike.
Throwdown in Northport.
The Italian versus the Irishman.
I rolled up on Mike Maroni
and offered him a throwdown challenge.
May the best man win.
I'm using Stephanie's mother's recipe for this battle,
but will it be enough
to topple Mike's 100-year-old family recipe?
These things are screaming Italian.
Time to find out.
My meatballs were dry in the test kitchen,
so I swapped my sirloin for a fattier cut.
You have three minutes.
Some ground chuck, some veal and some pork.
We have some very lightly sautéed garlic
that we just crushed and sautéed
in just a little bit of olive oil.
And then some fresh parsley, a little bit of breadcrumb,
some Parmesan cheese, some black pepper, some salt.
I know my meatballs have got the flavor,
but I'm not sure how they'll stack up with texture.
Mike uses four eggs to my one.
All right, all finished.
I can make these in my sleep.
Mike's finishing his meatballs in the oven.
Looks like he knows what he's doing.
Looks like he can handle himself with an Italian meatball.
We'll see who's better though.
I'm sautéing my meatballs, and we can't forget the sauce.
Onions and garlic and plum tomatoes
and red chili flakes and cabana chilies,
parsley and basil, that's it.
I'm just letting it reduce
so Bobby can start adding the meatballs to it.
There's his pepper.
Bobby can't make anything without a pepper.
My tomato sauce is definitely made
to complement the meatballs.
It has to have enough sodium,
has to have enough sweetness from the tomato,
not from sugar or honey.
Bobby.
As for the pasta, I'm sticking with spaghetti,
while Mike has decided to use bite-sized rigatoni.
But before we add the pasta,
it's time to sauce the meatballs.
These might be good.
We might get lucky, I don't know.
They smell good.
They do smell good, I'll give him that.
Honey, put a lot of basil in, I like that.
Irish boy.
So they're a potato, okay.
See what she said to me?
She told me that I'm treating them like potatoes,
not like meatballs.
She's my player, my Irish heritage, and I'm proud of.
You know, there's great spaghetti and meatballs in Dublin,
don't forget it.
I'm ready.
I'm ready, baby.
Time to feed this hungry crowd at the family table.
Good thing you're wearing the brown shirt.
I'm ready.
Grandma would be proud.
Not only do I cook, but I serve as well.
I'm sorry.
That's why I'm not a waiter.
All right, Mike, you wanna taste one of my meatballs?
Absolutely.
All right, pass it down.
You want to taste one of mine?
Absolutely, bring it on.
Pass that one.
Here we go.
That's awesome.
Texture's fine, but it wouldn't pass for my meatball.
I think it tastes like an Irish meatball.
I'm eating Bobby's meatballs.
They're very good.
They're a little bit spicy, which is up my alley.
It's one of those things that no matter who you are,
when you hear there's gonna be meatballs at the table,
it's gotta make you hungry.
That's right.
Do you like it?
I just had Bobby's meatball.
A little bit more dense than my Uncle Mike's,
but very good.
I just had a Mike Moroni meatball,
and I've had about 46 pots of them personally on my own,
so unquestionably, it was Mike's meatball.
I love them today, and I always love them.
I just had Mike's meatball,
and I think my plate pretty much says it all.
It's amazing.
Yours has a much finer texture than mine.
Our sauces look totally different.
I really like the way your sauce is.
I like the color of it.
It has a really good, rich tomato flavor,
which is what it should have.
Very nice.
Cheers, Bobby.
I'm starting to feel like part of the family,
but at a throwdown, the judges decide
who's at the head of the table.
I'm Richard J. Sholem.
I wrote the a la carte column in the Long Island edition
of the New York Times for 14 years.
I'm Julia Vegary.
My family owns Raphael Vineyard
on the North Fork of Long Island.
I like rustic, peasant-y meatballs with rich sauce,
and they remind me of the ones my grandma made.
What I look for in a meatball is a soft texture,
a rich flavor, and a well-rounded sauce.
I'm ready to eat some meatballs.
Yeah, let's go.
Bring it on.
It's been a meatball marathon in North Port, Long Island,
where I took on local chef Mike Maroney.
Friends and family have already picked
their favorite meatballs,
and now it's time to hear from our judges.
Food critic Richard J. Sholem and Julie Vegary
from Raphael Vineyard.
The criteria for today's throwdown are taste,
texture, and a combination of meatballs with the sauce.
Julie, why don't we start with dish A?
Okay, Richard.
Dish A is Mike's meatballs with rigatoni.
Delicious texture, very nice, very good.
I'm not saying yet.
Let's put it this way.
I like it very much, I think it's an excellent meatball.
And I think it's someplace between refined and rustic.
Next, they try dish B, my meatballs with spaghetti.
Dig in?
Yeah, dig in.
Okay.
It's a nice texture on this one, too.
Yeah, this is a more rustic texture.
Both very nice flavors.
If you like garlic, you'll like these.
And I'm from the never-too-much-garlic school.
These are very different meatballs.
Very different.
I like both.
I do, too.
For different reasons.
Me, too.
We have some conferring to do.
Yes.
That's right, you got it going.
Okay, this was as close to a tie.
This is like rating a good hitter and a good pitcher.
They do different things, you know?
And this is a traditional and a refined.
We felt that both of the meatballs
and the sauces complemented each other.
We were both very satisfied with each other.
One a little more on the spice note,
one a little on the traditional side,
like a kind of grandma's meatballs.
But after all was said and done,
and we argued a little bit,
we chose A.
Yeah!
Well, first of all, I want to thank Mike
and your wife, of course, and your family,
and your friends, and you know,
you opened up your home to me, and I appreciate that.
Great wine, great food, and great people.
And you know what?
A meatball, you know, brings the world together.
That's right.
So I appreciate that very much.
Eat meatballs, live longer.
I kind of figured I had it in the bag
as soon as I tasted his.
Honestly, I thought that they were delicious,
but they weren't.
They weren't Italian.
He made spaghetti and meatballs his way.
And I know, I at least know mine's Italian, you know?
I lost.
But I was proud to lose this one.
And they were, you know, they were just great.
I was hungry when I got here, and now I'm full.
Oh, I'm stuffed.
So to all you awesome cooks out there,
keep doing what you do.
But ask yourself this.
Are you ready for a throwdown?
Let's go!
