Leo Tolstoy, What I Believe Chapter 11

Leo Tolstoy
70 followers
1 Video View·Aug 25, 2023
Chapter 11 The Doctrine of Christ Establishes the Kingdom
of God on Earth
To think that it is difficult to fulfill this doctrine is an error. It is not difficult.
Indeed, he who has once clearly understood it cannot do otherwise than fulfill it. And
the fulfilling of Christ's doctrine does not involve us in suffering. It really saves us
from nine-tenths of the suffering that we must bear for the world's sake.
And when I have understood this, I ask myself why I had never followed Christ's doctrine,
leads to salvation and happiness, but had followed a contrary teaching that had brought
me nothing but suffering. There could be but one answer to the question. The truth had
been hidden from me.
When Christ's doctrine first grew clear to me, I did not think my having understood it
would lend me to renounce the teaching of the Church. It seemed to me only that the
Church had not arrived at the conclusion that the doctrine of Christ leads to. But I did
not think that the new light, which was revealed to me and the conclusion I drew from it, would
separate me entirely from the Church. Not once did I try during my researches to discover
any error in the teaching of the Church. I intentionally closed my eyes to the views
that seemed strange and ambiguous to me, as long as they did not absolutely contradict
what I considered to be the basis of the Christian doctrine.
But the further I advanced in the study of the gospel and the clearer the purpose of
Christ's doctrine grew, the more inevitable it became for me to choose between a doctrine
of Christ which was rational, clear, and in harmony with my conscience, and a teaching
that was in direct opposition to it, and that gave me nothing but the conscience of my own
peril and that of others.
I could not help throwing each of the Churches of these aside, one after the other. I did
it most unwillingly, often struggling with my feeling, longing to soften discordance
between my reason and the teaching of the Church. But when I had ended my work, I saw
that however hard I might try to keep from something, at least, of Church teaching, nothing
really was left for me.
As I was drawing closer to the end of my work, it happened that my son, a boy, told me that
two of our servants, perfectly uneducated men who hardly knew how to read, had been
disputing about a passage in some book in which it was affirmed that it is no sin to
kill criminals or to kill men in war. I could not believe such a statement could have been
published and asked to see the book. It was an exposition of the Book of Prayer, 3rd edition,
Moscow, 1879. I read page 163.
Question. What is the sixth commandment?
Answer. You shall not kill.
Question. What does God forbid by this commandment?
Answer. He forbids our killing, that is, depriving a man of life.
Question. Is it a sin to punish a criminal by death, according to the law, or to kill
our enemies in war?
Answer. It is no sin to do so. A criminal is put to death in order to put a stop to
the evil that he does. Enemies are killed in war, in which we fight for our sovereign
and our country.
These are the only words that explain why this commandment is repealed. I could hardly
believe my own eyes. The disputants asked my opinion upon the subject. I said to the
one who maintained that the text was quite right, that the interpretation was incorrect.
Then how is it that incorrect statements are printed, he asked. I could give him no answer.
I kept the book and looked through it. The book contains 1. Prayers, whose instructions
concerning genuflections and the way the fingers are to be joined in making the sign of the
cross. 2. The interpretation of the Creed. 3. Extracts from the fifth chapter of Matthew,
with an explanation in which the sayings contained in the chapter are, for some unknown reason,
called the Beatitudes. 4. The Ten Commandments, with explanations that annul them. 5. Anthems
for feast days.
As I have said, I had not only tried to avoid finding fault with the teaching of the Church,
but I had tried to view it in its best light. I had not sought to discover its weaker point.
Though well acquainted with its academic literature, I was completely ignorant of its books for
the use of schools. The enormous circulation of a prayer book, which excited doubts and
even ignorant men, struck me. I could not believe that a prayer book, the contents of
which were quite pagan, was the Church teaching, propagated among the people. In order to see
if it was really the case, I bought all the books published by the Synod, or that it allowed
to be published, in which there were short explanations of the Church Creed for the use
of children and educated people, and I read them. The contents were almost new for me.
At the time when I learned the Bible history and the Catechism, these books did not exist.
There was at the time, as far as I can remember, neither any explanation of the Beatitudes,
nor were we told that to kill a fellow creature is no sin. There is not to be found in any
old Russian Catechism of Platon, neither is it to be found in the Catechism of Peter Magula,
or of Balikov. It was an innovation made by Filaire, who likewise wrote a Catechism for
the military classes. The exposition of the Book of Prayer was taken from that very Catechism.
The book that serves as the basis is a complete Christian Catechism for the use of all Orthodox
Christians, published by order of His Imperial Majesty.
The book is divided into three parts, one faith, hope, and love. The first part contains
an analysis of the Nicene Creed. The second, an analysis of the Lord's Prayer, and of
the eight verses of the fifth chapter of Matthew, which form the introduction to the Sermon
on the Mount, and which are, for some unknown reason, termed Beatitudes. Both of these sections
treat the dogmas of the Church, prayers, and sacraments. The third part treats the duties
of a Christian. We do not find the commandments of Christ expounded in this part, but the
ten commandments of Moses. These commandments are expounded in a way that seems to enjoin
men to leave them unfulfilled, and to act contrary to them.
In reference to the first commandment, which enjoins us to worship God alone, the Catechism
teaches us to worship angels and saints, as well as the Virgin Mary and the three persons
of the Godhead. The complete Catechism, pages 107 and 108.
In reference to the second commandment, you shall not make for yourself any graven image,
the Catechism teaches us to worship images. In reference to the third commandment, you
shall not take the name of the Lord your God in vain, the Catechism tells men it is
their duty to take an oath every time the legal authorities may require it of them.
In reference to the fourth commandment, to keep holy the Saturday, the Catechism enjoins
us to keep Sunday holy as well as 13 great holidays and a number of smaller ones, and
to fast on Wednesdays and Fridays. In reference to the fifth commandment, honor
your father and mother, the Catechism tells it that it is our obligation and duty to honor
our sovereigns, our fatherland, our spiritual pastors, and all those who are put in authority
over us. And about three pages are taken up with the enumeration of the authorities we
are to honor, schoolmasters, civil commanders, judges, military commanders, masters for those
who serve and whose property they are. I cite from the 64th edition of the Catechism
published in 1880, 20 years have gone by since slavery has been abolished and no one has
taken the trouble to remove the sentence that was added to the commandment. Honor your father
and mother in order to uphold and justify slavery.
With regard to the sixth commandment, you shall not kill, men are taught from the very
first lines to kill. What does the sixth commandment forbid? Murder or taking away our neighbor's
life in any way. Is taking a man's life always illegal murder? Murder is not unlawful when
it is our duty to take away a man's life, for instance, when we punish a criminal by
death, when we kill the enemies in fighting for our sovereign and our native land, and
further on. What other instances can you cite for murder? When a man harbors a murder
or sets him free. And that is published in hundreds and thousands of copies and instilled
in the Russians by violence, by threats and fear of violence, under the pretense of it
being the Christian doctrine. This is taught to the whole Russian nation. This is taught
to innocent children, in speaking of whom Christ said, Allow little children to come
to me, for theirs is the kingdom of God. To children, whom ye must be like, in order to
enter into the kingdom of God. Like them, and knowing nothing of all this. To children,
in speaking of whom Christ said, Woe to him who tempts one of these little ones. And these
children are made to learn this. They are told that it is the sacred law of God.
Such things are not proclamations secretly propagated, under fear of being sent to hard
work in the minds, but they are proclamations, acting contrary to what leads men to hard
work in the minds. While I write, a chill creeps over me in my daring to say that I
must say, that we have no right to annihilate the commandments of God, which are written
in all His laws and in all our hearts, by adding such words as duty, or our sovereign,
our fatherland, etc., which explain nothing. Yes, what Christ warned us against has come
to pass. For He said, in Luke 11, 33-36, and Matthew 6, 23, Take heed that the light that
is in you is not darkened. If the light that is in you is darkness, how great is that darkness!
The light that is in us has indeed become darkness, and the darkness is an awful one.
Christ said, Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, for you shut up the kingdom of God against
men. For you neither go in yourselves, nor do you allow others to go in. Woe to you,
scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, for you devour widows' houses, and for a pretense
make long prayers, therefore you are still more guilty. Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees,
hypocrites, for you search seats and lands to make no one proselytize, and when you have
done so, you make him worse than you have seen him before. Woe to you, blind guides!
Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, because you build up the tombs of the prophets,
and garnish the sepulchres of the righteous. And you suppose that if you had lived in the
days when the prophets were martyred, you would not have joined in shedding their blood.
Then you are witness again yourselves, that you have no better than those who kill the
prophets. Fill up then the measure become by those like yourselves, and behold, I will
send to you wise prophets and scribes, and some of them you shall kill and crucify, and
some of them shall you scourge in your synagogue, and drive them from city to city. And may
all the righteous blood shed since the days of Abel fall back upon your hands.
Every blasphemy may be forgiven, but blasphemy against the Holy Ghost shall never be forgiven.
Isn't it as if this had been written only yesterday, against those who now force men
to accept their faith, and prosecute and destroy all those prophets and just men?
And I saw that though the Church calls its teaching a Christian doctrine, it is in truth
the very darkness against which Christ strove and enjoined His disciples to strive.
The doctrine of Christ has two parts. First, it bears upon the life of each individual,
and upon our social lives, or it has an ethical mission. Second, it points out why men ought
to live in a way that enjoins and not otherwise, or it has a metaphysical mission. One of its
effect end, and at the same time the cause of the other. Man must live thus, because
such is the purpose of his creation, or the purpose of his creation is such, and therefore
he must live like this. These two sides of every doctrine are befound in all the religions
of the world. Such is the religion of Brahma, Confucius, Buddha, and Moses, and such is
the religion of Christ. It teaches us how we are to live, and explains why we are to
live thus. But what befell all these other doctrines has befallen the doctrine of Christ
also. Men have turned aside from it, and there are many who try to justify their having done
so. Sitting down in Moses' seat, they explain the metaphysical part of the doctrine in a
way that makes the ethical requirements of the doctrine no longer obligatory, and they
replace them by outward worship, rites, and ceremonies. The same occurs in all religions,
but it appears to me that never has the evil influence been so striking as in Christianity.
It acted with peculiar force, because the doctrine of Christ is the most sublime of
all doctrines. It is the most sublime just because the metaphysical and ethical parts
of the doctrine are so indissolubly bound together, and so bear upon each other that
it is impossible to separate one from the other without depriving the whole doctrine
of its true sense. The doctrine of Christ is ultra-Protestantism, for it rejects not
only all the ritualistic observances of Judaism, but also every outward form of worship. This
rupture in Christianity could have no other effect than to completely pervert the doctrine
in private of all sense, and it did so. The rupture between the doctrine of life and the
exposition of how we are to live began with the sermon of Paul, who did not know the ethical
teaching expressed in the Gospel of Matthew, and who preached a metaphysically Kabbalistic
theory foreign to Christ. The rupture was definitely accomplished in the time of Constantine,
when it was found possible to array the whole pagan course of life in Christian clothing
without any change, and then call it Christianity. From the time of Constantine, the heathen
of heathens, whom the Church has canonized for all its vices and crimes, began councils,
and the center of gravity of Christianity was transferred to the metaphysical side
of the teaching alone. And this metaphysical teaching, with the rites that form part of
it, losing more and more of its fundamental sense, reached its present point. It has become
a teaching that explains the mysteries of life in heaven, and gives the most complicated
rites for divine worship, but at the same time gives no religious teaching at all concerning
life on earth. All religious creeds except that of the Christian Church enjoin, besides
the observance of certain rites, good deeds and forbearance from evil ones. Judaism requires
circumcision, the keeping of the Sabbath, the bestowing of alms, the keeping of the
year of Jubilee, and many other things. Islam requires circumcision, daily prayers five
times a day, the tenth part of a man's riches to be given to the poor, the adoration of
the tomb of the prophets, and so on. We find the same in all other religions. Be the duties
good or bad, they are deeds. Pseudo-Christianity alone exacts nothing of its followers. There
is nothing that is obligatory to a Christian if we exclude fast days and prayers, which
the Church itself does not consider as obligatory. There is nothing that he must refrain from.
All that is necessary for a pseudo-Christian is never to neglect the sacraments. But the
believer does not administer the sacraments to himself. Others administer them to him.
No obligation lies on the pseudo-Christian. The Church does all that is necessary for
him. He is baptized and anointed. The sacraments of holy communion and extreme unction are
administered to him. His confession is taken for granted if he is unable to make it orally.
Prayers are said for him and he is saved. From the time of Constantine, the Church never
required any deeds of its members. It never even enjoined a man to refrain from anything.
The Christian Church acknowledged and consecrated all that existed in the pagan world. It acknowledged
and consecrated divorce, slavery, courts of law, and all the powers that existed before,
such as war and persecution, and only required evil to be renounced and worded baptism. The
Church acknowledged the doctrine of Christ in word, but denied it in deed.
Instead of pointing out to the world what life ought to be, the Church expounded the
metaphysical part of the Christian doctrine in a way that required no duties, and did
not hinder people from living on as they had lived before. The Church, having once given
way to the world, followed it ever after. The world organized its existence in direct
opposition to the doctrine of Christ, and the Church invented metaphors, according to
which it appeared that men, who really lived contrary to the law of Christ, lived in accordance
with it. And the world began to lead a life that rapidly grew worse than that of the pagans,
and the Church began to justify this way of living and to affirm it, that it was strictly
in accordance with the doctrine of Christ. But a time came when the light of true doctrine,
which lies in the gospel, penetrated among the people in spite of the Church, which had
tried to conceal the doctrine by forbidding the translation of the Bible. The time came
when this light penetrated among the people through so-called sectarians, and even through
free thinkers. And then the falsity of the Church teaching grew evident to all, and men
began to change their former lives and live up to that doctrine of Christ that had reached
them independently of the Church. Thus men annihilated slavery, which had been justified
by the Church, annihilated religious executions, which had been sanctified by the Church, annihilated
the power of sovereigns and popes, which had been consecrated by the Church, and now the
turn of property and kingdom has come. The Church never rose in defense of anything and
cannot do so, because the annihilation of these false principles of life is based on
the Christian doctrine that the Church has preached and still preaches. The doctrine
of life has emancipated itself from the Church and has established itself independently of
it. The Church retains the right to interpret Christ's doctrine, but what interpretation
can it give? The metaphysical explanation of the doctrine has weight only when it explains
what life is or ought to be. But no such teaching is left to the Church. It could only speak
of the life that it had organized of old, which is now no more. If any of our old interpretations
remain, as, for instance, when the Catechism tells us that we must kill when it is our
duty to do so, nobody believes them, and nothing is left to the Church but its temples, images,
brocades, and words. The Church has carried the light of the Christian
doctrine of life through eighteen centuries, and while trial to conceal and enshrinement,
it has been burnt itself in a light. The world, with its social adjustments consecrated by
the Church, has now thrown the Church aside in the name of the same Christian truth that
the Church unwillingly carried along with it, and the world now lives without it. The
Church is done with, and it is impossible to conceal the fact. All those who really
live, and do not really vegetate in our European world, have left the Church. All churches,
whether Catholic, Orthodox, or Protestant, are like sentimental keeping guard over a
captive, while the captive has escaped and even walks around among the sentinels. All
that now forms true life in the world—socialism, communism, theories of political economy,
utilitarianism, liberty, and equality—all the moral opinions of men, all that governs
the world, and that the Church considers to be inimical to it, is a part of the very doctrine
the same Church unwittingly brought in together with the doctrine of Christ that it tried
to conceal. The life of the world in our time follows
its own course, independently of the teaching of the Church. That teaching has remained
so far behind that men of the world hearken no more to the voice of the Teacher, and indeed
there is nothing worth listening to, because the Church only gives explanations that the
world has already grown tired of, explanations of an organization that has rapidly decayed.
Certain men set out in a boat while a man at the helm steered. He was a skillful pilot,
and the boat glided rapidly on. But a time came when a less skillful helmsman took the
place. Finding the latter incapable of steering well, those in the boat first ridiculed him,
and then drove him away. That would not have mattered much if the men had not forgotten,
in their anger against the useless helmsman, that without one they would not know in what
direction they were going. So it was with our Christian world. The Church does not stand
at the helm any more. We roll rapidly on, and all the progress of knowledge on which
our nineteenth century prides itself, is only the result of our floating without a helmsman.
We do not know where we are going. We go on leading our present lives absolutely without
knowing why we do so. And yet it is unreasonable to live without knowing why we do so, and
is set off in a boat without knowing as to where we are bound.
If men did nothing themselves, but were placed in a position they occupy by some outward
power, then they might answer the question, Why are you in such a position? by saying
that they did not know why. But men make their own positions for themselves, for each other,
and especially for their children. And they must, therefore, be able to answer when asked
why they assemble into armies, to cripple and to kill each other, why they waste immense
strength of millions and erect in useless and pernicious cities, why they organize their
petty courts of law and send men whom they call criminals out of France to Cayenne, out
of Russia to Siberia, and out of England to Australia, while knowing that it is senseless
to act thus. When they asked why they leave the fields and woods they love to work in
factories and swat shops that they hate, why they bring up their children to lead the same
lives though they disapprove of them, they ought to be able to give some reason for their
conduct. Even if all this were pleasant, men should be able to give their reasons. But
when it is the hardest possible work, when men have grown over it, how can they go on
acting in any way without trying to find adequate reason? Men never have lived without trying
to solve these questions. Men cannot live without making the attempt. The Jew lived
as he lived. He made war. He executed men. He built temples. He organized his life thus
and not otherwise, because it was enjoined him by the law, which, according to his conviction,
came from God Himself. It is thus likewise with the Hindus and the Chinese. It was thus
with the Romans and the Muslims. It was thus with the Christians a hundred years ago, and
it is thus now with the ignorant crowd. The unthoughtful Christian now solves these questions
in this way. Soldiery, war, courts of law, and executions exist according to the commandments
of God transmitted to us by the Church. The Church teaches that the world as we know it
is a lost world. All the evil it fills exists only by the will of God as a punishment for
the sins of men, and therefore we must submit to it. We can only save our souls by faith,
by the sacrament, by prayer, and by the submission to the will of God. The Church teaches us
that each must submit to the Sovereign, who is the inaugurative God, and to those who
are in authority over us, that each must defend his own property by violence, make war, and
execute or be executed according to the will of the authorities placed over him by God.
It does not matter if this explanation good or bad. It formally explained all the various
phases of life to the believing Christian, and man did not renounce his own reason while
living according to the law that he acknowledged as divine. But now the time has come when
only the most ignorant believe in this, and even their number decreases with every day
and every hour of the day. There is no possibility of stopping this progression. All eagerly
follow those who are in front, and all will soon reach the point where the foremost now
stand. But the foremost are standing upon the brink of an abyss. The position of the
foremost is an awful one. They point out the path to those who are to follow them, and
are themselves completely ignorant, both of what they are doing and of the things that
impel them to act as they do. There is not one man among them who could not now answer
the direct question, Why do you lead the life that you lead? Why do you do what you do?
I have answered such questions to hundreds of men, and never received a direct reply.
Instead of a plain answer to the question, I have always received an answer to some question
that I had not asked. Whenever I asked a Catholic, Protestant, or Orthodox believer why he lived
as he did, so contrary to the doctrine of Christ, which he professed, instead of a direct
answer, each would begin to talk of the lamentable want of faith of the present generation, of
the wicked men who propagate irreligion, and of what awaited the Church in the future.
But the answer, why the man did not do what his creed enjoined, was never given to me.
Instead of answering about himself, he would speak of the general state of mankind, and
of the Church, as if his own life was of no importance whatever, and as if he were engrossed
by the idea of saving all mankind, and especially the institution called the Church. A philosopher,
whether an idealist, a spiritualist, a pessimist, or a positivist, would answer the question
of why he did not live according to his own philosophical teaching, by taking on the progress
of mankind, and of the historical law of what progress, thanks to which mankind was
rapidly advancing toward perfect happiness. But he would never give a direct answer to
the question, why he himself, in his own life, did not fulfill what he considered rational.
The philosopher, like the believer, seems to be taken up with observing the general
laws of all humanity, rather than with the order of his own individual life. If you ask
an average man, a representative of the great majority of the civilized men who are half
believers, half unbelievers, and who are all, without a single exception, dissatisfied
with their own lives, and with their own social adjustment, and who always foresee approaching
ruin, such is an average man, and be asked why he leads a life that he himself finds
fault with, and why he does nothing to improve it, never gives you a direct answer, and never
speaks for himself, but turns the conversation to some general question about justice, trade,
the state, or civilization. If he is a policeman, or an attorney, he will say, And how are things
to go on, if, in order to better my own life, I take no part in the affairs of the country?
How will trade progress? If he is a merchant, he will say, What progress will civilization
make, if I do not cooperate in its advancement? Each speaks as if the problem of his life
did not lie in attaining the happiness toward which he strives, but in serving the state,
commerce, or civilization. The average man answers exactly as the believer
and philosopher do. He answers a personal question by a general one, and the reason
why the believer, the philosopher, and the average man retort by a general question,
is that not one of them has any true notion of life, and each of them really feels ashamed
of his ignorance. It is only in our Christian world that, instead of the doctrine of life,
the explanation of what our life ought to be, which is religion, there is only the explanation
of why life must be such as it was of old, and the name of religion is given to a teaching
that nobody needs. Nor is that all. Science acknowledges the same fortuitousness, defective
position of society as the law of all mankind. Learned men, such as Tillett, Spencer, and
others, argue very seriously about religion, understanding by the word the metaphysical
teaching of the origin of all. Without suspecting that, instead of speaking of religion as a
whole, they speak of only a part of it. The result of all this is that, in our century,
we see wise and learned men who are naively convinced that they are devoid of all religion,
only because they do not acknowledge the correctness of this metaphysical explanation that were,
in some time past, given as explanation of life. The idea of it never occurs to them
that they must live in some way or another, that they do live in some way or other, and
that it is exactly the principle on which their lives are based that is their religion.
These men imagine that they have a very elevated conviction in no faith, but whatever they
may say, they have faith if they accomplish any rational work, because rational work is
always the result of faith. We may live according to the teaching of the world. We may lead
an animal life without acknowledging anything higher and more obligatory than a decrees
of the existing authorities. But he who lives thus cannot be said to live rationally. Before
saying that we live rationally, we must answer the question, which doctrine of life do we
consider as a rational one? Miserable beings that we are, we have no such other doctrine.
We have even lost all consciousness of the necessity for gaining any rational doctrine
of life. Ask the men of our day, whether they are believers
or unbelievers, what doctrine they follow. They will be obliged to confess that they
follow only the laws written by the officials of the second section, or by the legislative
assembly, and put in practice by the police. This is the only teaching that our European
world acknowledges. They know that this teaching does not come either from heaven or from the
prophets, neither was it taught by the sages. They blame the regulations of these officials
and the legislative assemblies, but submit to the executors, who are the police, and
obey the most barbarous exactions without a manner. The legislative assemblies have
decreed, and officials have written, that each young man must be ready to submit insult,
death, and murder, and all the fathers and mothers who have grown up sons obey that law.
But all notions of there being a law that is undoubtedly rational, and that each feels
in his inmost to be obligatory, are so lost in our world that the existence of the law
among the Hebrews, which defined the whole order of life for them, a law that has rendered
obligatory by the moral feeling of each, is considered as existing exclusively among the
Hebrews. It is regarded as a peculiarity of the Hebrew nation that they obeyed what they
consider in their inmost souls to be the indubitable truth received directly from God, and they
knew it to be such, because it was in unison with their conscience. The position of an
educated man, a Christian, is considered to be a normal and natural one when he obeys
what he knows was only written by despised men and is enforced by policemen—that is,
when he obeys what he feels to be unjust and contrary to his conscience. It was in vain
that I looked into our civilized world for some moral principles of life that should
be clearly expressed. There are none. There is even no consciousness of such principles
being necessary. There is even a firm conviction that moral principles are unnecessary, and
that religion only consists in words about a future life, about God, about certain rights
that, as some say, are necessary for salvation, while others consider them as totally unnecessary
and say that life goes on independently of all rules, that all that is necessary is to
obey passively. The main points of faith are the doctrine of life and the explanation of
what life is and ought to be. Of these, the first is considered as unimportant as having
nothing to do with faith, while the second is only an explanation of the life that was,
in some past time, together with some conjectures about the historical progress of life, and
this is considered as the most important and serious point. In all that really enters into
the life of man, for instance, how he is to live, is he to commit murder or not, is he
to condemn his fellow creatures or not, in what way is he to bring up his children, men
submit without a murmur to the rule of others who know no more than they themselves do,
why they themselves live as they do, and why they insist upon others living the same way.
And men consider such a life as rational and are not ashamed of it. This state of things
would be awful were it universal. Fortunately there are men in our days, the best men of
our time, who are dissatisfied with such a creed, have a creed of their own concerning
the life that we ought to lead. These men are considered as pernicious and dangerous
unbelievers, and yet they are the only believers. They are believers in the doctrine of Christ,
or at least in part of it. These men often do not know the whole doctrine of Christ,
they do not properly understand it, and indeed they often reject the chief basis of the Christian
faith, which is non-resistance of evil. But their faith in what life ought to be is derived
from the doctrine of Christ. However these men may be persecuted and slandered, they
are the only men who are not passively submitting to all that they are ordered to do, and therefore
they are the only men who do not vegetate, but lead a rational life, and they are the
only true believers. The link between the world and the church
grew weaker and weaker according as its teaching flowed more and more into the world. And now
the last link, which bound us to the church, is breaking, and an independent process of
life is beginning. The teaching of the church with its dogmas, councils, and hierarchy is
unquestionably bound up with the doctrine of Christ. Our European world, outwardly,
so self-confident, bold, and decided, and yet in the depth of its consciousness, so
terrified and confused, is undergoing what a newborn baby does. It tosses about, turning
from side to side, crying, and not knowing what it is to do. It feels as if the source
of its former nourishment has dried up, but what does not yet but to look for a new one?
It is thus with our European world. See what a complicated, seemingly rational, energetic
life there is in our European world. Art, science, trade, and social activity are all
full of life, but all this only lives because its mother has recently fed it. The church
brought the rational doctrine of Christ into the world. It has done its business, and now
it is withered away. All the organs of the world are full of life, but the source of
their former nourishment has stopped, and they have not found a new one. They seek it
everywhere. The world now has to comprehend that the former unconscious process of nourishment
has outlived its time, and that a new conscious process of nourishment is necessary. This
new process consists of admitting these truths of the Christian doctrine that had formerly
flowed into the world through the medium of the church, and that they are the sources
of life. Men must again lift up that light that was hidden from them, and they must place
it high before themselves and others, and consciously live in that light. The doctrine
of Christ was a religion that defines life, and gives an explanation of human life, stands
now as it did 1,800 years ago, before the world. But before, the world had the interpretation
of the church, which, while hiding the doctrine from their eyes, seemed to suffice for its
life. But now the time has come when the church has served its time, and the world has no
one to explain to it the problem of its new life, the feeling its helplessness, must accept
the doctrine of Christ. Christ teaches us, first of all, to believe
in the light where the light is in us. Christ teaches men to place this light of reason
above all else, to live up to it, and not to do what they themselves acknowledge to
be irrational. If you consider it irrational to kill Turks or Germans, do not do so. If
you consider it irrational to force poor creatures to work hard in order that you may wear fine
hats or have fine drying rooms, do not do so. If you find it an irrational proceeding
to shut up those who have been depraved of idleness in a prison, in this way to condemn
them to the worst possible company and to complete idleness, then do not do so. If you
think it irrational to live in an infected town where you can live in a fresh field,
do not do so. If you consider it irrational to make your children study the dead languages
more than they do anything else, then do not do so.
The doctrine of Christ is light. The light shines. It is impossible not to accept the
light when it shines. It is impossible to struggle against it. It is impossible to refuse
to accept it. It is impossible to refuse the doctrine of Christ because it encompasses
all the eras in which men live. And like the ether, which those who study the philosophy
of nature speak of, it penetrates all. The doctrine of Christ is essential for each,
whatever position he may be in. Christ's doctrine must be accepted by men, not because it is
impossible to deny the metaphysical explanation of life that it gives. We may deny all we
choose, but because it alone gives us rules of life, without which mankind cannot live,
if at least they wish to live as rational beings. The power of Christ's doctrine does
not lie in the explanation it gives of the sense of life, but in the doctrine of life
that flows out of it. The metaphysical teaching of Christ is not new. It is a teaching that
is written in the hearts of men, and that all the truly wise men of the world preach.
But the power of Christ's doctrine lies in the practical application of this metaphysical
teaching to life. The metaphysical foundation of the teaching of the ancient Hebrews, and
of that of Christ, is the same. Love to God, and love to our neighbor. But the application
of this doctrine to life, according to Moses, and according to the law of Christ, is very
different. According to the law of Moses, it was necessary to fulfill 613 commandments,
including some most senseless and cruel ones, all based upon the authority of the Scripture.
According to the law of Christ, the teaching that flows out of the same metaphysical basis
is expressed in five rational commandments, which carry their own meaning, and their own
justification along with them, and which embrace the life of all mankind.
The doctrine of Christ would not be rejected either by Jews, Buddhists, Muslims, or others,
even if they doubted the truth of their own creed. Still less can be rejected by our own
Christian world, which is no other moral law. The doctrine of Christ does not disagree with
men in respect to their views of life, but including it, gives them what is wanting in
it, what is indispensable. It points out to them a path that is not a new one, but one
familiar to them from their childhood. You are a believer, whatever creed you may
profess. You believe in the creation of the world, in the Trinity, in the fall and the
redemption of man, in the sacraments, in the efficacy of prayer, or in the Church.
Christ's doctrine does not tell you that your creed is wrong. It only gives it what is wanting.
While you keep to your present creed, you feel that the life of the world and your own
life are full of evil, and you see no way of escaping that evil.
The doctrine of Christ, obligatory to you, being the teaching of your God, gives you
simple rules that will deliver you and others from that evil.
Believe in resurrection from the dead. Believe in paradise, in hell, in the Pope, in the
Church. Pray as your creed enjoins you to do. Keep the fast. Sing psalms. And all this
does not prevent you from fulfilling what Christ tells you to do in order to attain
true happiness, namely, avoid anger, do not commit adultery, do not swear, do not defend
yourself by violence, and never make war. It may, perhaps, happen that you will not
always fulfill all of this. You will yield to temptation and transgress one of these
laws just as you violate the rules of the civil law or the laws of a good breeding.
You will, perhaps, in a moment of impulse, swerve from the rules laid down by Christ.
But in your calmer moments, do not act as you do now. Do not organize your life in a
way that renders it difficult to avoid anger and adultery, to abstain from swearing and
using violence or making war, but organize it in a way that should all make things difficult
to do. You must admit the duty of acting thus, for these are the commandments of God.
You are, perhaps, an unbeliever or a philosopher. You say that all goes on in the world according
to the law that you have discovered. The doctrine of Christ fully acknowledges the law that
you have discovered. But independent of this law, which will bring good to mankind after
thousands of years, is your own individual life. Now you have no rules at all for your
own individual life except those written by men whom you despise and enforce by the police.
The doctrine of Christ gives you rules that decidedly agree with your law, for your law
of altruism is nothing but a bad preface for the doctrine of Christ. Or you are neither
a believer nor an unbeliever. You have no time to seek the purpose of life, and you
have no definite creed. It is enough for you that you act as all others do. The Christ
doctrine says in effect to you, you are unable to verify the truth of the doctrine that is
preached to you. You find it easier to follow the example of those around you. But however
humble you may be in mind, you have to judge in your heart who sometimes makes you feel
that you have acted rightly, and at other times shows that you are wrong. However modest
your lot may be, you cannot help someone asking yourself, ought I to act as all around me
do, or according to my own feeling? And no sooner does the question arise in your mind
than the precepts of Christ are found to answer both your reason and your conscience.
If you are more a believer than an unbeliever, you act accordingly to the will of God by
following the precepts of Christ. If you are more a free thinker than a believer, by obeying
God's precepts you follow the most rational laws that ever existed in the world, as you
will ever see yourself, because the precepts of Christ bear their own justification in
themselves. Christ says, John 12, 31, Now is the judgment of this world, now shall the
prince of this world be cast out. He says likewise, John 16, 33, These things I have
spoken to you, that in me you might have peace. In a world you shall have tribulation, but
be of good cheer, I have overcome the world. And it is in this way that the world, or the
evil that is in this world, is overcome. If a world of evil still exists, it exists only
as something that is dead. It lives only by inertia. There is no force of life in it.
It does not exist for him who believes in the commandments of Christ. It is conquered
by the rational consciousness of the Son of Man. For whatever is born of God overcomes
the world. The victory that overcomes the world is your faith. 1 John 5, 4
The faith that overcomes the world is faith in the teaching of Christ.
