🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
"What we're seeing really is the end of multiculturalism as we know it."
Soeren Kern, a writing fellow at the Middle East Forum, joins me to discuss the current riots sweeping through France that have begun spilling into neighboring countries. Contrary to the mainstream media's narrative that the civil unrest is strictly a response to French racism and police brutality, Kern argues that the issue is far more complicated.
"Policymakers in Europe are still unwilling to acknowledge the problem at hand...which is the inability to assimilate or integrate millions and millions of people. So, what we saw in France is just the beginning - I think - of a great civil unrest here in Europe," says Mr. Kern.
He explains how after World War II, the general sentiment throughout western Europe was that nationalism was the cause of war, and that diluting national identities could reduce the chance of future war. This, argues Mr. Kern, has led to a misguided 40-year long migrant policy that is now eroding the fabric of several European nations.
"Many European countries are trying to bribe their citizens into having more children by paying them to have children," says Mr. Kern. "But I think the birth rates among the migrant populations in Europe are so far higher than the European ones, that this is really an impossible situation. So, my perspective is that Europe is going to be riddled with conflict for decades to come."
So what you have really is the inability or unwillingness of policy makers to really,
first of all, acknowledge that there is a problem, that multiculturalism has essentially
failed and second of all, there's an unwillingness to do something about it.
There's a lot of concern here in Europe because of low birth rates, that Europe needs to be
bringing in more migrants to keep the social welfare systems alive.
It's a question of demographics.
Then there's the other multicultural aspect of it, which really was after the end of the
Second World War.
There was a general feeling that nationalism is the cause of wars and if you can kind of
dilute what it means to be German and dilute what it means to be French, that would sort
of reduce the chances for war in the future.
So really have these failed policies and these failed premises that have been going on for
at least 50 years and policy makers in here in Europe are still unwilling to acknowledge
the problem at hand, the issue at hand, which is the inability to assimilate or integrate
millions and millions of people.
What we saw in France is just the beginning, I think, of a great civil unrest here in Europe.
There's really nothing that can be done to my mind at the moment because these people
are European citizens.
They were born here.
They can't be deported.
And even if they were deportable, European human rights laws makes it almost impossible.
You have millions and millions of immigrants who are coming to Europe over the past decade
or so illegally and they're committing crimes because they can't provide for themselves
in normal jobs.
So they go into drug dealing and they go into purse snatching and all sorts of petty crimes.
And these people are arrested and let go and arrested and let go because European human
rights laws makes it almost impossible to deport these people.
So you have really a long term problem that President Macron and others are just unwilling
to acknowledge.
Before we continue, Sorin, if you can kind of give me a picture, you've given us a ton
of information here.
I'd love it if our audience could understand where you're coming from, what your work has
been and why you're tracking this so closely.
Sure.
I've been tracking this for about the last 15 or 20 years.
I myself am a first generation American.
My parents moved to the United States from Germany after the Second World War.
I am now in Spain.
I lived most of my adult life actually here in Europe, in Germany, in France and in Spain.
So I'm very pro-migration.
I think migration is a great thing if it's done properly.
If it's done legally and if it's done in an orderly way.
So over the last 15 or 20 years, I've really been interested in the migration issue, but
also the Islam aspect of it.
A lot of the migrants that come to the United States from Latin America by and large are
Roman Catholic or they come from a certain Judeo-Christian background.
What you have here in Europe is millions of people coming from countries that are completely
opposed to the Judeo-Christian worldview, the liberties and the democratic freedoms
that we love and we cherish.
And many of these are coming from an Islamist background where you have the Sharia law.
It's a topic that is not going away.
It's a topic that policymakers really need to understand.
I think European citizens, ordinary citizens need to understand it as well, because if
you can't identify really accurately what the problem is, then there's not going to
be any hope for political solutions.
You just made me think about this.
I've heard reports that in certain of the suburbs of, for example, Paris, but this would
be a broader phenomenon, there's whole areas where the governance basically of the area
has changed and even police are reticent to actually wander into these areas in some cases
because it's basically like a different legal system.
If you could kind of break that down, is this true and how does it work, if so?
Sure, you're finding this in a lot of the large French cities, also in Berlin, to some
extent, larger German cities, to some extent in Madrid, in the capital, on the outskirts
of the capital, where you have very, very large numbers of immigrants, where the native
Europeans are now in the minority.
A lot of people have moved out.
And what happens is essentially that the norms of the countries of the migrants are the law
of the land.
In some cases, particularly in Germany and in France, you have Islamists that take advantage
of the despair of the youth and they offer them a brighter future through the future
of Islam.
So there's a radicalization that takes place and these people then obviously try to enforce
the Islamic law and the Sharia laws in their neighborhoods and their barrios.
What you have is a reluctance of police and fire departments, ambulances, any sort of
representative of the state.
There's a reluctance of these people to go into these areas because of the danger that
it presents. And so what set off these riots was the shooting of a 17-year-old Moroccan
Algerian who was at a police stop and he refused to stop.
And so the police shot him.
The problem is that the police, when they're working in these areas, their number one
perspective is self-survival.
And so they're assuming that everybody in these neighborhoods is a criminal.
And the migrants, they see these attitudes of the police and they see that as xenophobic
and as discriminatory.
And it just creates more hatred towards the state.
So what you have really is a cycle of self-preservation on the part of the police and on
increasing hatred on the part of the youth.
And that makes it these suburbs in your large European cities, essentially lawless zones
where either you have some form of Islamic law taking over or you have the law of the
jungle. It's a real challenge for policymakers.
There's so much pressure by the media and by the political systems to be lenient on
criminals and on wrongdoing for the sake of not being Islamophobic or not being anti
immigrant. And so there needs to be an equilibrium to my mind in which the police in
all these European countries are authorized by the political authorities to do their job
and enforce the law. And of course, if police are found to do a wrongdoing,
or brutality, they also need to be brought to justice.
And this is a really big problem in France because there's a reluctance on the part of
political authorities to hold police accountable.
Oftentimes, it's very hard to find proof or evidence of the motives of the police officer
at the time of the incidents.
So you have really sort of a breakdown in communications on many different levels.
That's really allowing it's making French law or German law or Spanish law
unenforceable in many parts of these large European cities, especially on the outskirts.
One of the causes that's being cited is racism, that this is all a product of racism.
And from what you've been telling me here, it seems like that's a more complicated
question than is immediately obvious.
Yeah, it is. I've lived here and I see a lot of racism in all these European countries.
It's particularly bad against Arabs and sub-Saharan Africans, people who look different.
I mean, you can't deny it.
It's there. On the other hand, you have kids who don't want to integrate or assimilate.
They don't want to get a job and they blame everybody else for their problems.
So it's like a perpetual victimhood.
It's very hard to tell exactly what the numbers are, but in my mind, roughly 70 percent of
the migrants in France are assimilated and they're integrated and they're working,
hardworking, they're contributing, French society, they're law abiding.
It's about, to my mind, around 30 percent of particularly male youths who are finding
it very hard to get out of the cycle of these living in these suburbs.
I should mention that these suburbs oftentimes are on the outskirts of the city, beyond
the highways. So it's very difficult to cross those borders, those natural borders,
to get from the suburbs into the city center.
So many spend their whole lives sort of in a part of France that is really completely
different from the rest of France.
So it's really a tragedy.
And this has basically been going on for many, many decades.
Many people have written books about this already in the 1990s and the early 2000s.