"Just last week, Whole Foods this like $10 million project to be built downtown…only open for a year just got up and left. And that's because they can't get a handle on crime."
Siyamak sits down with Joel Aylworth @JoelEvan former police officer with San Francisco Police Department. He will talk about why crime went out of control in San Francisco and what it is like to be a police officer in SFPD.
This episode is sponsored by Olde Country Soaps. Go to https://www.oldecountrysoap.com/ to purchase the soaps. Use promo code INSIDER
We've been hearing from people in San Francisco,
the police shortage and people not getting responses
from police on crime.
Just last week, Whole Foods,
this like $10 million project to be built downtown,
only open for a year, just got up and left.
And that's because they can't get a handle on crime.
They had SFPD working overtime,
standing a post in the supermarket
because it was getting so out of hand,
the theft and just drug addicts and just mental health,
people walking through, right?
Just show the devastation
that they cannot keep up with it.
My guest today is Joel Ellworth,
former police officer with San Francisco Police Department.
Today, he'll talk about why crime is out of control
in San Francisco these days
and how it is like to be a police officer in SFPD.
San Francisco, it was one of the most desirable
police departments to work for.
And now we're seeing in 2023, it's the complete opposite.
It seems like the politicians,
they throw you guys under the bus.
Nobody wants to do police work, number one.
And number two, nobody wants to do police work
in San Francisco.
You just kind of shrug your shoulders and go,
well, that's just the way it is.
I'm Siamak Khorrami, welcome to California Insider.
Joel, it's great to have you on, welcome.
Hey, thanks for having me.
You know, we want to talk to you about policing
and you are not in the police force anymore,
especially in San Francisco.
We want to talk to you about that.
You are free to speak on this topic.
A lot of police officers,
they're kind of not allowed to go to the media, right?
How does it work?
Yeah, I mean, that's fair to say, you know,
you had Sergeant Rich Trabadi on your show not too long ago.
And here's the thing, you know,
Rich still works for the San Francisco Police Department.
I thought he did a great interview,
but he can only say so much.
And I no longer work for anybody,
so I can say whatever you want to say
and whatever you want to know, I can speak freely.
So one of the things that has come to our attention
and we've been hearing from people in San Francisco
is the police responding or not responding on time.
So there was an incident at a bar
and the bar owner called the police at 1 p.m.
And then the police came at 3 a.m. after 13, 14 hours.
We're also hearing that the response time is a lot,
you know, they kind of don't want to come
after property crime.
Can you tell us what's going on behind the scenes?
All right, so, you know, in 2013,
when I lateraled from the Oakland Police Department
to San Francisco,
it was one of the most desirable police departments
to work for, especially on the West Coast.
And it was challenging to get in.
It was competitive.
Lots of people wanted to go there.
And in my class alone, there are about 20 laterals,
which is a huge class.
That's one of the biggest classes they've ever had
in terms of laterals,
guys leaving one department and laterally transferring.
So people wanted to go to San Francisco Police Department?
Yeah, 100%.
I mean, and for a lot of, like, I was working in Oakland,
so I was already working in a relatively, you know,
what they'd called a big city, you know, big city problems.
But a lot of people wanted to work in the so-called big city
or, you know, prove themselves.
I didn't need to prove myself,
but I just was looking for a better department
and a better environment to work in.
So it was very desirable.
And matter of fact, in my academy, there were four,
I was one of four Oakland police officers.
Two sergeants were in my class.
So it just shows you how desirable it was
for people leaving Oakland
and wanting to come to San Francisco.
Guys that were sergeants there left
and became officers all over again
just to work in San Francisco.
That was how desirable it was.
And now what we're seeing in 2020, 2023
is the complete opposite.
Nobody wants to work,
nobody wants to do police work, number one.
And number two,
nobody wants to do police work in San Francisco.
So that's a huge problem.
And they can't fill academies.
Back in 2013, we had about five academies
running throughout the entire year,
50 applicants in each academy.
Now you're seeing,
you're lucky to see two to three academies a year,
and you're probably yielding 10 to 20 officers.
I'm sorry, recruits.
Recruits.
So you don't even know how many of those
are gonna graduate.
Let's say 50% of those people fail out.
Now you're looking at 10.
It takes nine months for an academy from start to finish.
So you're looking at yielding 20 to 30 officers tops, maybe.
And then think about how many retirements you have.
200 a year, injuries, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
SF cannot fill this gap.
And that's why they're extremely below.
The staffing is terrible.
And I've talked to officers just recently,
and Mission Station where I used to work,
which was one of the busiest for 911 calls throughout the,
it was the busiest station for 911 calls
most of the time at lead in San Francisco.
And they had five people in their lineup
for swing watch, which is like three to,
you know, two in the morning.
So that's a pretty big, that's a very busy shift.
And they had five officers total.
Just to give that in context,
that's pretty low because there's about six sectors
or beats that officers will work.
And there's usually two people per beat.
So that'd be six times two is 12 and you had five.
So you had less than half filling those beats.
Yeah, their force is completely decimated right now.
Old country soaps are handcrafted, long lasting soap bars
made on a farm in South Dakota
with soothing natural ingredients
without harsh chemicals that can dry out your skin.
They can produce a creamy lather
unlike anything you've tried before.
Just a great American made product
that will leave your skin feeling soft
and smooth all day long.
The soap is multipurpose.
You can also use it for your hair.
It's great for shaving and safe for pets.
Every order comes with an exfoliating soap bag.
It can hold smaller pieces of soap
and can prevent soap bars from slipping out of the hand.
After each use, just leave the soap bar inside
and hang dry.
It will last a long time.
This company does not sell on Amazon.
So go to oldcountrysoap.com
and reward yourself and your loved ones.
Use promo code insider
and get an exclusive 20% off your order.
Let's support a company
that brings back traditional American values
and American manufacturing.
Now let's go back to the interview.
How does it work now?
Like do they, when they get all these calls
do they come late
or do they decide not to go to some of them?
How does the process work now?
Yeah, great question.
So the calls, first of all,
the calls just come in as they come in.
No one's deciding, well, hey, you called
and we're just gonna put that on the back burner.
As an officer, there's a screen,
we call it the CAD system
and it's in our computer
and I can look and see the calls
and the dispatcher who's dispatching me
to these 911 calls,
she sees the calls that I see too.
So nobody's playing favorites
or nobody's thinking, ah, should I go to this one
or this one?
No, they're all up there
but they're categorized by priority.
So there is an A priority,
meaning like the highest priority
is a B priority, which is your middle priority.
And then there's a C priority
which is the lowest priority.
So to give an example,
maybe a homeless person just blocking a doorway,
well, that might be a C priority.
He's not acting violent,
no one's life is in danger,
there's no immediate threat.
Okay, well, that call can sit on the board
for a long time.
And the same thing,
you gave an example with property crimes.
So again, if someone broke into your home
and the bad guy is gone now,
we can, hours have gone by,
you left your house,
you came back an hour or two hours later,
the house is broken into,
but nobody's in there.
That then gets downgraded to a low priority call
because you're not in any threat,
no one's being harmed
and that's how it works.
And so as an officer and dispatcher,
we're constantly prioritizing
what is of most importance.
I could be on my way to taking your report for your call
and then bam, an A priority comes out,
someone's being attacked,
someone's being robbed,
someone's car is actively getting broken into.
And now I have to divert from the call
that I was supposed to go,
take your report to something more
that's someone's life could be in danger
or there's just more of an immediate threat.
And so now you're seeing,
I don't know what this call was specifically
for someone at the bar,
but whatever had happened, had happened
and it must have been that.
Otherwise, I promise you,
they will do all they can to,
if they can't get me from mission.
If it's a really big one, they will come.
But what about property crime?
Is it fair to say that kind of the police
have somewhat given up on the property,
given that they're like short-staffed?
What do you guys think when you look at the property crime?
Because the laws also are not really helping, right?
Right.
So I don't want to say the police have given up.
I would say there's a whole bunch of things.
One is staffing, like I mentioned, is extremely low.
The second thing is we've been downgrading.
We've already been kind of downplaying property crime
for a while now.
We've moved to, hey, if it's less than $950,
why don't you just make the report online?
Again, do you have any suspect information?
Are there any fingerprints?
Is there any video evidence?
If there isn't, if it's just kind of a
quote unquote run-of-the-mill property crime,
where we don't think there's anything else to this crime
or we don't have any other evidence.
Like say, for example, your car gets broken into.
Okay, my question to you is going to be,
and the dispatcher will probably ask this too.
Did you see who did it?
No.
Is there any video surveillance?
No.
Do we think there's any fingerprints?
That's very hard to probably gather anyways.
So now you can just make that report online, right?
Do you really need an officer?
So we've been down,
and that's been happening for the last several years.
So we've been downplaying property crimes
and looking for ways to free up officers.
So that's been happening
for the last five years at least, okay?
Then, like I mentioned,
you don't have a force that can even handle it, right?
And then, I'm sorry,
then what was the last point that you were asking?
Just have we as officers?
Oh, I want-
So how do you guys look at it?
How do you see it?
So with crime being so rampant and property crime,
now remember, I lived there for 10 years in San Francisco.
So I've had my car broken into.
I've lived there and experienced it and felt it.
It's happening so much that I think you're right.
In some sense, officers,
we just kind of shrug our shoulders and just say,
well, what can we do?
And I think there is also a little bit of a blame
that officers might perceive like,
you know, citizens, you kind of voted for this, right?
With Prop 47, which if you look at,
that was one of the big crimes,
I'm sorry, one of the big propositions in California
to bring property theft or petty theft
and some of these thefts from $450 to 950.
So now, again, what used to be a more serious crime,
it needs to reach a value of 950 for it to be a felony.
Otherwise, it's just a misdemeanor and cite and release.
So again, going back, we've kind of downgraded
and downplayed a lot of these property crimes.
And I think there is a feeling of it's just so rampant,
it's becoming normalized, we're becoming desensitized.
And the citizens have voted for a lot of these policies.
And I think as an officer, I promise you,
officers wanna do the right thing.
They wanna capture the bad guy.
They wanna do their job to the fullest.
But if they feel like they can't,
there's a little bit of apathy there going,
I mean, what do you want me to do?
When you look at the statistics,
what we can see is the statistics like,
okay, there was 1800 police officers, now there's 1500.
There's a shortage of 20%.
And you mentioned that there is more to retire.
What do you think it's gonna look like,
this force in San Francisco based on what you see?
I think we're already seeing the impact right now, right?
I mean, just look at what the city,
the devastation that we've started to see.
I mean, just last week, Whole Foods,
this like $10 million project to be built downtown,
just only open for a year, just got up and left.
And that's because they can't get a handle on crime.
You gotta remember too, I just wanna say in Whole Foods,
just to use that as example,
they have officers that work overtime there.
It gets so bad.
So they already have,
they had their own police officers in there.
They had SFPD working overtime,
standing a post in the supermarket
because it was getting so out of hand,
the theft and just drug addicts and just mental health,
people walking through, right?
Causing whatever, aggressive behavior
and just causing all this nonsense and calamity.
SFPD was working overtime shifts there
and they still closed.
And that just shows you, I mean,
that's just, I think really a great highlight
to just show the devastation
that they cannot keep up with it.
Also, when you talk about staffing,
it's a complete joke
because the numbers you're throwing around
and not to say that your numbers,
the numbers you're being given, I should say.
Yes, these are the numbers we know.
We don't know what's going on.
Correct.
Maybe they say something to you like,
hey, and it makes their numbers look good
and they're at 1500.
I promise you they're way less than that.
And I think I saw a stat more from the inside,
not too long ago,
that the numbers are really closer to 800.
Now, 1500 might be, again,
they might be including civilian staff, right?
So these numbers are very deceptive.
When you hear the number 1500,
you think, well, that's a lot of police officers.
It's not because they're counting civilian staff.
They're counting all these other folks
that aren't on the street,
that are actual patrol officers
and are available for patrol.
Can you give us some examples
of how these regulation works?
How much are you guys regulated?
Very regulated, okay?
And I know because I came
from the Oakland Police Department,
which was also overseen by federal judge
and federal monitors.
When I came to SFPD, that wasn't the case.
Then in 2016, the DOJ, I believe, came in
and so we have massive oversight
and we are doing what the DOJ
or these federal organizations
would call 21st century policing.
And so we have a DOJ oversight.
We have a DPA,
which is our Department of Accountability.
They essentially are a citizen board
that takes complaints
and they are on top of our internal affairs.
So our internal affairs also looks
at officer complaints.
They're a citizen board
that looks at officer complaints.
And then we have a commission
and the commission is like, I don't know,
six to 10 elected officials
that also oversee the department.
So we have a ton of oversight
and a ton of people that are influencing
and implementing.
Their ideas of what they think
21st century policing is.
The problem is most of those people
have never been or nor are they police officers
and they're just so out of touch.
And one of the greatest examples I could give you
is even when we go to court as officers, right?
Judges and lawyers,
and I started to notice this trend,
the more, you know, I had almost 15 years
in law enforcement.
So the more I got involved,
the more I had been seasoned
and the more times I'd show up to court,
I would notice this.
Judges, they read about the law in books
and in theories and what they think sounds great,
but there's nobody that actually enforces the law
and actually breathes it to life
other than a law enforcement officer.
And so there's always a disconnect,
but that's why we have the courts,
we have lawyers, we have the police.
And so there's a huge disconnect.
Now, in terms of the regulation,
and you mentioned this,
we had a DA, we had a very malicious DA.
We had George Gascon before Chessa Boudin
and he really didn't do much.
And he was very soft on crime.
He looked at officers and he did scrutinize them,
but nowhere near this extent that Chessa Boudin did.
He maliciously went after them.
And I don't say that on hyperbole.
Like I saw the things that were happening to officers
and it was downright criminal,
which is what actually got him,
you know, he got ousted
because he had done criminal things.
I mean, there was a case
and I can give you the case right now.
So the case was an officer gets dispatched
to a call of a woman being dragged by her neck,
being strangled.
That's what the caller is saying.
She says, get the police out here.
This woman is being dragged.
And she gives the description.
Officers show up, they see the man and the woman.
At the time when the officers show up,
the man and the woman are having a conversation,
I think against a car.
He's not choking her, he's not assaulting her,
but he matches the description.
And it's only just those two in the near area
where they were described to be at.
Officer gets out of his car,
tells the man, get away from the woman.
The suspect responds like, what?
Like, what?
So the officer goes to put him in handcuffs,
which he's totally allowed to do.
The suspect at that point pushes off the officer.
The officer gets his baton out, strikes the suspect.
The suspect actually kicks the officer
and they end up getting him in custody.
Now, here's where the sensationalism comes.
You have a white officer and the suspect was black.
And so this was a perfect opportunity
for Chessa Boudin to take this and say,
hey, this officer within the color of his authority
abused his powers and did too much.
He used excessive force on this black man.
But, and so he used this as a talking point
to bring charges against the officer.
When that case went to court,
the district attorney who was overseeing
the charges of the officer got up on the stand
and said, started crying and said, I can't charge this case.
I'd be lying under oath
because Chessa Boudin told me
to take out exculpatory evidence,
which means in order to charge this officer,
he had to make a case.
So what he did was he purposely left out the part
where the suspect hit, or pushed,
at least pushed the officer, if I remember correctly,
pushed and kicked the officer.
He made it seem like the officer just got out of his car
and beat this guy with a stick.
Well, of course that's wrong, but that's not what happened.
And so he got a lot of air time
and a lot of time to bad mouth
the San Francisco Police Department for six months,
put this officer's career in jeopardy, right?
And then it was all, it was all for nothing.
And this officer, you know, he's out on,
he's out of the streets.
He doesn't know if he's gonna be fired.
He's gonna lose his mortgage, his house,
his wife, or whatever.
And he has to deal with that too.
Now, you think when that officer comes back,
you think he's gonna be just gung-ho
to go work for the San Francisco Police Department?
Probably not.
Do you think, what was going on in that officer's mind
when you're, as an officer, you get this call
that somebody's in trouble and you go there,
what does it look like?
What are you guys thinking about?
So it's changed a lot because I think,
so in the past, I would say you're always thinking
about officer safety number one, right?
How, okay, when I get there, what am I gonna do?
What are the steps I'm gonna do?
What if it's like this?
I'm always playing the what if game.
What if this happens?
What if that happens?
Because I wanna be prepared for any contingencies
or anything, I wanna have an alternate plan.
I'm always priming my brain.
What could possibly go wrong?
I wanna be ready for that.
Because obviously, when you train in the academy,
you always train for, this is how it's supposed to go
in a very sterile environment.
I tell you to put your hands up
or put your hands behind your back,
and you listen, I put you in handcuffs.
Easy, but that's not what happens.
That's not real life, right?
There can be some commotion
or there's always something different.
That's what makes police work such a unique job
because it's not black and white.
You're always operating in the gray.
Things are never as they seem.
So for me, the number one priority
is gonna be officer safety
and getting the victim and the suspect separated.
That's what I'm gonna be thinking the entire time.
Now, the other thing that we're plagued with, though,
that's a little bit different is officers are faced
with not only the tactics that they're approaching
when they're approaching this call,
but all the political ramifications
and policy restrictions
are probably gonna be going through my mind, too,
is, well, if this happens, can I do this?
I'm gonna be questioning myself and thinking about,
is my camera on?
And what is the effective amount of force that I can use?
So I'll just give you a quick example, too,
because it might, well, what do you mean by policy, Joel?
Well, here's an interesting fact, right?
The law, the actual law,
says that officers need to use force that is reasonable,
right, and then it gives examples
and it gives a rubric for that.
Now, the San Francisco Police Department
has put within their policy
that officers should use
the minimal amount of force necessary.
Now, in general, I think we do aim for that.
That's something we strive for.
But that's actually not in the law.
The law does not say that,
the law does not say
you have to use the minimal amount of force necessary.
It says what's reasonable.
So now, as an officer, I've gotta be thinking about,
well, is this reasonable?
Yeah, of course it's gotta be reasonable.
That's always my rubric.
But am I using, in real time, in real action,
if I grab you, it's very difficult for me to be thinking,
is this minimal?
Is this, because if anybody's ever been in a fight,
fights don't happen like they do in movies.
You don't throw a punch
and I just throw an outward strike block
and it just goes away.
Fights are messy and they're ugly and people get hurt
and really, it's like caveman fighting.
Even though you think, oh yeah,
I'm gonna do this special police ninja move I learned,
you're probably not.
You're probably gonna result to caveman tactics.
Why?
Because your amygdala, the part of your brain, is hijacked.
You're in fight or flight.
You're just trying to survive.
And so, all those tactics and training
probably goes out the window
and you end up doing club caveman tactics, right?
And so, for officers, you're asking them
in a high stress environment, which is why we do training,
but you're asking them to access
a different part of their brain,
like their prefrontal cortex,
that executive decision making,
because you want them to respond
from a higher functioning and make better sound decisions.
Now, you can do that with a lot of practice and training
and a lot of priming the brain before you get to that call.
So, these are all, it's important that officers do that,
but what I'm saying is, sometimes it's very difficult
to access some of that prefrontal cortex
executive functioning of your brain when-
While you're in the middle of-
While you're in the middle of just trying to survive, right?
So, that's some of the difficult challenges
that are being posed to officers, I think, now,
more than ever.
If you were involved in an officer involved shooting,
how was it?
What was the experience like?
What happens?
Yeah, so this actually happened to me
when I was in Oakland,
when I was working for the Oakland Police Department,
about a year and a half into my job,
I was driving with my partner late at night,
three in the morning,
we see a car driving kind of recklessly.
And so, we go to pull it over and he pulls over
and then he flips a U-turn and the chase is on.
So, we chase him, his car kind of peels out
and there's no one on the road.
It's three, like I said,
it's like three, 3.30 in the morning in downtown
off of Fruitvale Avenue.
And the guy then, he looks like his car
kind of becomes disabled
and he's trying to like maneuver the gearshift.
I can see it, I'm the driver,
my partner's in the passenger seat.
Finally, the driver jumps out of the car
and starts to run across the hood of the car.
So, he's actually running towards my direction,
towards the driver's side,
which is a little odd
because most suspects will run away from you
and he had a clear path to do so, but he didn't.
Don't know why, we'll never know why.
And at that point, he reached down into his waistband
and my partner interpreted that as a threat
that he was reaching possibly for a weapon.
He opened fire.
I had just gotten out of the car,
I had taken my gun out
and had come out on target on the suspect,
but I heard shots coming out.
Now, they talk about this phenomenon in law enforcement
and it's called parasympathetic trigger response,
which means when you hear gunfire,
you will probably fire as well.
I promise you, that is a real phenomenon.
I never not, I didn't not,
I don't wanna say I didn't believe it,
but until you really experienced it,
like hearing gunfire next to you,
I wanted to pull the trigger so bad, but I didn't.
And I continued to just hold on this.
Everything's slowing down in real time.
I'm looking, I can see this guy's hands clearly
and I'm hearing shots go out
and I can see kind of the suspect reacting,
which I guess are the bullets.
And I'm thinking I should be shooting.
I mean, I must be behind the curve.
I must be missing something.
What am I missing?
I'm asking myself in this like split second time
and everything's slowing down.
And I reacquire the target again
and I'm like getting ready to fire again.
I'm like, I must be missing something.
And I pulled the trigger back to the wall.
They call it, that's what they call it,
the wall on a Glock anyways and every gun actually.
And I pulled the trigger back to the wall.
After you hit the wall,
you can feel there's a little tension
in the gun on the trigger.
After that, the gun will go off.
And then I stopped because I didn't see a threat,
but it was hard.
I'm telling you, it was so, so hard not to do that.
And I can imagine if other officers
that have been put in that situation
or military where we've been taught
these parasympathetic response,
it's real and I'm so happy I didn't
because I didn't see a weapon on the suspect from my angle.
My partner had a different angle.
He couldn't see one of the hands, I believe.
And that's why he chose to fire.
Suspect drops pretty much dead in front of me.
At the time, I didn't know he was dead,
but he's agonizing, breathing kind of, right?
I'm giving him command still
because I'm still trying to process what happened.
He's not listening.
How could he?
He'd just been shot.
My partner and I quickly handcuff him.
And then we realized we didn't look at the car.
Who else is in the car?
So we run to go clear the car.
There was a woman in there.
I guess it was his girlfriend.
Now, here's what we didn't know.
That suspect had just done a robbery
earlier in East Oakland that night.
We had no idea.
That robbery went bad.
He ended up murdering that guy.
He probably thought that we knew this.
We had no idea.
He was high.
Later, toxicology report comes out.
He was high on cocaine, meth,
complete eight ball of just drugs.
So he wasn't probably thinking very clearly.
He had a rap sheet, very long,
wanted for multiple carjackings and assaults.
He wasn't the nicest person.
That's not to say he deserved to die.
Just letting you know kind of the history of this person.
And my partner ended up losing his job.
They fired him for that shooting
because they said, this is your second shooting.
This person was unarmed.
You didn't have the right to shoot.
I was investigated seriously.
Even though I did not shoot,
there was still like, hey,
did you put your partner in a bad situation
by driving a certain way or all these things, right?
So at one point I was the suspect of an investigation.
Later, I was deemed not to be a suspect
and only to be a witness.
But as a kid, I was 26, 27 years old,
only a year and a half on the job.
That was a lot of stress for me to deal with.
And also the idea that maybe,
Joel, you're a coward.
Why didn't you shoot, right?
So I had to, I was internalizing all these things.
Nobody ever said to me, hey, I think you're a coward.
But I always wondered like-
You felt like it, right?
I felt like it.
Like, you know, you should have,
why didn't you shoot, you know?
And it just, it was my own internal like,
maybe people think that, you know,
I was soft or whatever for some reason.
In hindsight, listen, I'm so happy I didn't shoot.
And it was the right thing not to.
And I've had other people come up to me and say,
looking at that, that was the right thing not to do.
And I'm glad I didn't because it didn't merit,
it didn't merit a shooting for me,
at least for my people.
And that was just a random day, right?
Was it kind of like, is it like that?
That was a Friday, by the way.
You never, Fridays,
why, I should not have been pulling over cars at three.
I was going to get off at 5 a.m.
And it was 3.30 or something when that stop happens.
So now I ended up being awake for another, you know,
15 hours because I had to get interviewed
and all this stuff.
So that, that was a long day.
One of the things I want to tell you though,
because you asked me kind of like,
what is it that officers go for?
Go through.
And something that maybe a lot of people don't know,
but after that shooting,
I came back to work maybe two weeks later, okay?
And I remember maybe for about a good six months,
my hand would be shaking
when I would go stop cars or suspects
or just detain people
that I didn't know if they were wanted or not.
I would just, you know,
if somebody committed a crime or a violation,
or if I wanted to go stop them and I say,
hey, what's your name, date of birth,
you know, the standard stuff
that you'd write people's information down on a card.
And my hand would just be shaking uncontrollably.
And I would look,
I would even look down at my hand and be like,
stop, like stop.
And it didn't even, when I was looking at it,
it didn't even look like it was moving.
And I would be looking at suspects and others.
I'm like, do they see this happening?
I would stop people
and I would just walk away from the stop
because I could not legitimately write down their,
my handwriting was so bad.
I couldn't even, I couldn't, it was just gibberish.
And that I attribute probably just to some micro PTSD trauma.
Yeah.
Did you feel like other people may do that too?
Like every now, every, every stop could become like that.
Is it like that?
Do you feel?
That's a good question.
I didn't get hypervigilant to the point where I thought,
oh man, everyone's out to get me.
I never, I never felt like that.
I did, I don't know what my,
my body was obviously in a hyper arousal state more so
than I normally, than my baseline state.
Cause as a police officer,
always on a little bit of a raise,
you have to be a little bit of a hypervigilant.
You've gotta be alert and ready
and you gotta be alert and ready
to defend yourself and protect yourself.
Cause you can get ambushed or anything.
You don't, you don't know.
So there was obviously I was in a more of a rouse state,
but I never like consciously thought like, you know,
this, this car, if I pull this person over,
he's going to get me.
I think there was just some trauma, some, some micro PTSD.
I didn't know how to deal with it either.
I didn't seek out people.
I hid it.
I didn't want people to know.
Cause I thought I was weak for having it.
And I was just praying that, you know,
one day this would just kind of go away.
And it, and it did over time.
And I would even go out on stops in my head
to like prove myself, like go out and stop three people.
I mean, of course they were doing something,
gambling or drinking or something, right?
But I go, go out and stop three people and prove yourself.
And I, and I, and I, and I would still be shaking.
And eventually that went away, but you know,
when you're talking about the trauma and stuff, it's real.
I know officers who weren't even in shootings.
They just maybe went to a call of, you know,
a suicide or something like that.
And it messed them up so much,
just that one call that they ended up retiring.
I mean, it was just the, the trauma they faced.
And a lot of the officers would say, oh, come on, man.
Like, that's the only call you could go to.
Like, I've been to like 20 of those.
Well, for that person, maybe he was faking it.
Maybe he wasn't.
But you know, you see people, that happens often
where they just retire off of something like that.
We want to get into what's the solution
to SFPD or recruiting.
But before we get into that,
we are hearing from a lot of our audience
that what the problem with the police force is
that they actually cover for the bad police
within the departments.
Have you seen that?
Absolutely.
I, listen, I think it happens.
I think it happens in every organization.
And matter of fact, it does.
So let me just, I want to give an example
and then I'll come back to the police.
But the police are, the police are so,
at least in San Francisco and Oakland, I can tell you this.
And because I worked for both organizations,
I would see the media aggrandizes
and embellishes a lot of things that the police do
that in my head, I'm like, that's not newsworthy.
And matter of fact, I know that incident,
but you're only telling 50% of the story
to generate sensationalism and news.
Now there's some other stories where I can think,
well, yeah, that officer was probably in trouble
and nothing ever, nothing really came of it, right?
And I'm going to give you some examples in a second.
But remember, I just want to remind the public
that we focus, because the media and the focus
has been so narrowly focused on the police,
it's such a distraction.
It really is.
And you've got people like Jeff Adachi, right?
Who was the former public defender
for the San, in San Francisco.
This guy was an absolute criminal.
I'm sorry, this is not me.
This is not for me.
I could care less.
I have no ego in this and I know who I am.
And so it doesn't matter to me.
But this guy, his wife called 911 multiple times
to commit suicide because he was having an affair
with the tennis coach or whatever.
And when his last stint to my understanding
was when he died, he had a heart attack
and it got covered up by the news
and the liberal press in San Francisco.
He just had a heart attack.
No guys, he had a drug overdose
and he was with a prostitute out of Columbia
or something like that in San Francisco.
Now, I just bring this to light
because imagine if a police officer did that.
Oh, I know for a fact that would be all over the news.
But because we hold this Jeff Adachi character
up to be a godlike figure,
the press refuses to acknowledge it or cover it.
And that's just ridiculous.
I have no problem being transparent as a police officer,
but I want the same transparency
that should happen to Adachi, London Breed
and the other politicians in the city.
You wanna bring on the heat to me, no problem.
We deserve, you deserve, the public deserves
to have that transparency.
Because you have a lot of power of force, right?
You guys do that.
100%.
Think about this too.
Think about what other job do you know
where you walk around with a camera all day
and you're just being videoed of what you're doing.
I'm sure there's plenty of times.
You and I were talking offline
before your own spiritual journey of just like,
sometimes I felt like I wasn't being true.
At work I might be being true, but at family I'm not.
Well, that happens to officers too
because we're human, right?
We're human.
And so I might say something off the cuff,
but maybe I don't really mean it,
but it's just like I'm frustrated
or I have my own problems too, like we all do.
And it gets caught on camera.
And then that gets exposed and embellished.
So we are really one of the only professions
where you see such, you see so much of us, right?
And by the way, we've seen an acceleration of this.
Think back just maybe five years ago,
body-worn cameras weren't really that prominent.
And so I think another phenomenon that's happened
other than that the news media
has really diminished the police officer
and made this noble force
to be nothing noble and salacious.
If you look back to old articles in San Francisco
of like police officers, they were praising them
like so-and-so foot beat officer,
so-and-so nabs another suspect.
You don't see that now.
It's always like officer points gun at naked man in car.
I just saw one in San Jose recently.
Okay, the guy was driving a stolen vehicle,
but yes, he happened to be naked.
Again, does the headline say that?
No, it's doing things to sell papers.
So again, but think about that.
So the body-worn cameras I wanted to mention
because over the last five years, the public has,
even when you and I are talking right now,
and you're asking me,
Joel, what is it like to be a police officer?
I wanna know, like I really wanna understand
because you don't know.
You don't live in-
We don't know.
We don't know, right?
What it takes.
And then they don't talk to the media
because they can't, right?
Because they can't.
And with the onset of body-worn cameras,
for the first time, the public is like,
oh my God, you guys kill people?
It's raw.
And it's a lot for, I think, the public to take in,
like, this is happening?
And so with that new onset of the body-worn cameras
and just people being exposed to this level of violence,
it is kind of like taken back, right?
And I don't think people wanna accept it.
And listen, I don't wanna be violent at all.
I don't wanna have,
I would, we always talk about this in law enforcement.
We would love to just go home every day
and not get in a fight.
It's too much paperwork.
And I guarantee one of us usually gets hurt too.
So I would, and the scrutiny that comes,
you know, the shooting that I mentioned that I was in,
that got taken by a very prolific lawyer.
And I was deposed and in civil court.
It was a huge, it was a stressful, stressful time
in my life.
I thought I might get sued myself.
So no officer wants to go through that.
I promise you, there's no talk, a locker room talk of,
yeah, I hope I get in a shooting today.
It's just not happening.
And that does not, they don't wanna do that.
But again, we are, we're in a profession
that's very unique, right?
Because we represent so much.
We represent, I was talking to a friend,
we represent the state.
We represent everything that is like kind of going around.
The police, whatever, like the political or the tempo
or the energies at the time,
the police kind of take that on.
And so if a police officer, let's say,
does something that's racist,
then it's a reflection of everybody
and the actual state of affairs.
And so it's a huge burden for sure for officers,
but it's a really unique profession where, like I said,
you don't see that in other professions
and you're not walking around with a body wearing camera,
your staff's not doing it.
And so we're fallible,
we're human beings just like anyone else.
So from what you're saying,
you're actually the frontline of the legal system
of the whole, you have to implement the law, right?
But then it seems like the politicians,
they throw you guys under the bus here and there, right?
Is that, and the laws that they have,
they're not really for you guys,
or they might not get your input in the laws.
San Francisco's problem, right,
has been faced with DAs, district attorneys
that are soft on crime and have not been charging anybody
for such a, or for just even serious crimes.
No one's getting the stick, if you will.
So no one's getting slapped on the wrist
for any of their bad deeds.
So you have a soft crime,
you've got anti-police rhetoric
that has been from the mouth of the,
again, we go back to leadership,
from the mayor's mouth and the chief of police
also not backing his cops and not standing strong
and saying, my officers don't do that, here's what we do.
So you have anti-police rhetoric
that has been, what's the word,
fulminating for such a long, fomenting.
Fomenting for such a long time.
That's a big word for me.
I know, I was like, I know the word,
I just can't think of it.
You got this police anti-rhetoric
and then that really came to a height
during the BLM protests and stuff
that lasted for about a year.
And you've got the lack of just police staffing.
Those three things have now culminated
into the SF San Francisco experiment, if you will,
and now we're seeing it in real time
that things aren't working.
How does all this make you feel
as a former SFPD police officer seeing what's going on?
You know what, it's a little bit,
it's a little bit, it goes, my emotions vary.
Sometimes it's anger, it's like,
because I know it could be better, right?
And having been a resident there for 10 years,
when you feel like you can change and influence
and enroll people and actually make change,
but the powers that be won't let you do that,
it's frustrating, you get frustrated.
But then there's this point,
and this is probably one of the worst points
you can get into an officer's career
is when it becomes apathetic
and you just kind of shrug your shoulders and go,
well, that's just the way it is.
And I've heard that phrase
throughout the San Francisco Police Department for ages.
Well, that's just the way it is.
There's nothing you can change.
That kind of brings out this hopelessness, and that's sad.
And when that happens, there's no courage,
and no one's gonna be bold, no one's gonna take action,
and nothing's gonna happen.
Everyone's just gonna be looking and passing the buck
and pointing fingers at the next person.
And I mean, really, that's what we're seeing.
That's what we're seeing.
We're seeing leaders, back to leadership,
we're seeing leaders that they don't really embody
these true values.
You and I are big on truth and aligning with the truth
and embodying that, and these people don't.
They're papier-mâché tigers,
and they, let me tell you what they are, actually.
I really thought about this the other day,
is that they are just wearing masks, okay?
It's their persona.
And when you think about persona, it's a personality.
And they're all just acting in this theater,
like, oh, what mask am I gonna wear today, right?
Which is why two years ago,
when Mayor London Breed put on the,
I'm gonna put on the defund the police mask,
or Hilary Ronan, the councilor, said the same thing,
defund the police.
Well, that was two years ago,
because she was acting out her persona.
And now-
Based on the polls, right?
The mask is made from the polls, like-
That's right.
And it's actually, what's even more sad is,
I just have a podcast, and I just interviewed
and read Jennifer Say's book.
She was the CEO of Levi's, okay?
And she just got ousted.
By the way, you should have her on our show.
She just got ousted from Levi's.
She was set to be the CEO.
She just got ousted because she was tweeting
during the pandemic that schools should be open.
That was it.
That was all she tweeted.
But because it didn't go along with the cultural line,
they fired her.
That's what we're seeing right now.
We're seeing that this very small vocal minority
is getting busy on Twitter, which is not the real world.
They're getting busy, and they're getting active.
And the leaders are kowtowing to this,
because you know why?
They're not true.
They don't know who they are.
And so they just kowtow to everybody
because they wanna stuff their pockets
and they wanna keep their power.
The true leaders, and you look at people
like the Netflix CEO and Spotify,
Joe Rogan, for example, right?
Got a lot of heat in the pandemic.
And when the Spotify CEO said,
this is what we're gonna do,
and Joe's not going anywhere, people backed down
because they had a leader that stood in the forefront.
And when people galvanize and they get together,
magic happens.
One of my favorite quotes that Tony Blauer,
who's a self-defense expert, said is,
fear is contagious, but so is courage.
So do you think San Francisco can solve this problem
with its leaders?
What do the leaders need to do to solve this problem?
The police shortage and people not getting responses
from police on crime.
Listen, everything's solvable.
I think there's hope when there's courage,
when there's hope, anything is possible.
When there's fear, lack, scarcity,
you're not gonna have, it's not gonna be,
it's not possible.
So I think I always have the mentality
of the glass is half full
and I think they can turn it around.
It's just gonna take time.
This problem didn't get here from just overnight.
It came from radical policies
that slowly fomented, if you will, over time.
The new word for me.
So these policies just show,
they didn't show up overnight.
And so it's gonna take time.
The pendulum always swings
and it's just gonna take time.
They're gonna have to do a lot.
I think they're gonna need, to be honest,
I think they're gonna need an entirely new leadership team
from all the ranks of the city
and maybe even the governor, right?
Again, I say top down.
It needs to come from everybody
and then it's gonna take, we're seeing it right now,
the citizens are fed up.
Just, I believe, two days ago,
San Francisco had a big rally called Save the Streets
and they wanna take their streets back,
not in a vigilante kind of way,
but just empower grassroots way
and that's the only way it's gonna change
is through this grassroots way.
And everybody working together.
Don't get me wrong.
I'm not foolish enough to realize
that the police are not gonna solve the problem.
We're not gonna arrest our way out of this problem,
but there do need to be a handful of changes.
Joel Elworth, former SFPD officer.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you so much, man.
I can't wait to come back.
Thank you.
Excellent, good to meet you.
If you like the show and our content,
you should go to insiderca.com and sign up to our newsletter
because we never know what can happen
with social media and other platforms
in terms of distributing our content.
If you'd like to come on the show and be an insider,
you can reach out to us at cainsider at epochtimesca.com.
Again, it's cainsider at epochtimesca.com.
We'd love to have you on the show
to tell us what's going on in your field in California.
Thank you for watching.