This episode is sponsored by Olde Country Soaps. Go to https://www.oldecountrysoap.com/ to purchase the soaps. Use promo code INSIDER
"I've never believed in my wildest dreams that we would see it get this bad. These aren't just people stealing property, it's now getting very serious and escalating to violence."
Siyamak sits down with John Kabateck with NFIB who represents many small businesses In California. Today he is going to tell us how businesses are impacted by Crime, And what the impacts are if California does not fix its laws.
In 2018, there were about 1,500 catalytic converter thefts in California.
Just the last year, we found a little north of 51,000 catalytic converter theft.
More than a thousand percent bump.
We are hearing statistics on crime, which we're not really sure what to believe.
I never, never believed in my wildest dreams that we would see it get this bad.
My guest today is John Cavitak with NFIB, which represents many small businesses in California.
Today, he's going to tell us how businesses are impacted by crime,
and what's going to happen if California doesn't fix its laws.
These aren't just people stealing property.
It's now getting very serious and escalating to violence.
In San Jose, as a teenage clerk was trying to stop somebody in a retail store
from walking out with one bottle of liquor.
That teenager was killed.
I'm Siamak Kourami.
Welcome to California Insider.
John, it's great to have you back on.
Welcome back.
It's always great to be back with you, Siamak.
Thank you so much.
Love this.
John, it's great to see you.
And I want to talk to you about a phenomenon that's happening in California.
You know, when I came here, when I would go to retail stores,
I would, it was just such a free environment where it's like you,
you wouldn't feel like people are watching you when you're shopping.
And coming from Iran, like there was a lot of shoplifting.
The shopkeepers would have to always watch out.
Here, it wasn't like that.
But recently, we see a lot of the stores are locking up items,
like small items that you would, you would wonder like,
why are they locking this item up?
Like batteries or certain items that are locked up.
And at the same time, we are hearing statistics on crime,
which we're not really sure what to believe.
You deal with a lot of small businesses,
and you deal with a lot of businesses and retailers.
You're seeing what's happening behind the scenes.
Can you tell us what you see out there in California now?
Yeah, and it's not pretty, I'll tell you.
First of all, though, I will say it's great to see you.
Great to be back.
And, you know, as the California director
of the National Federation of Independent Business,
we are the state's and the nation's leading small business advocacy group.
This is a real problem.
We are finding not just amongst our small business owners,
but just everyday small business owners,
and frankly, residents in communities that are finding this spike over the past,
probably three to five years of crime, retail crime,
crimes on porch piracies in neighborhoods,
really spiking to a point where, unfortunately,
now what we're finding is these aren't just people stealing property.
It's now getting very serious and escalating to violence
and interpersonal interactions where it's becoming very dangerous.
So it's not a good scene.
I can tell you, as we look out and see this,
you know, we have seen over the past year,
to give you an example,
in Sacramento County, we've seen a spike in crime
and property crime of over close to 17 percent.
In San Jose, nearly 17 percent.
San Francisco doesn't sound like a lot, but about 4.4 percent.
But we're seeing almost in all of the cities that we have looked at
a spike in property crimes.
People stealing property, but now this escalating now
to very dangerous situations.
Do you believe these statistics?
Because when I hear the 17 percent or 4 percent,
you know, it's like, would they lock up these items for 4 percent of increase?
Or is it that people have given up on reporting?
Because what's the purpose of reporting the crime
if you're a retailer and you're not going to get your merchandise back?
Well, and you're absolutely right.
I think the biggest thing that they're feeling right now
is that, you know, why should I even try and report this?
Why should I even call the police?
They won't come.
And that isn't directed at our law enforcement.
It's the fact that they there are so few of our law enforcement personnel out there
that your average small business owner feels helpless and hopeless
because they just don't know that there's a law enforcement
sufficient number to support them in their community.
They have faith in law enforcement.
They just don't have faith that our policymakers are doing enough
to fund enough to keep them protected.
Can you give us some examples of these businesses?
What kind of businesses are they?
Where are they?
It's very sad.
You know, I think we've seen so many incidents around the state.
You know, just well, you can you can take San Francisco,
very progressive San Francisco.
But even just in this past year, we have seen maybe on the bigger size.
We have seen some businesses like Nordstrom, In-N-Out Burger and Whole Foods
all decide in early 2023 that they're going to up and leave San Francisco.
We have seen Target store in downtown San Francisco
experience about 10 to 20 thefts a day in that store.
And then most interestingly enough,
Mayor London Breed of San Francisco has recently admitted that her car was broken into.
So we ask, what does it take with policymakers,
even in a progressive city like San Francisco?
Hopefully, and fortunately, I think they are taking a look.
But then in this same period of time, the city,
the county supervisors are taking a look at actually disarming security guards.
So taking any law enforcement tools out of security guards
just at a time when San Francisco has experienced all of this.
In Southern California, there is a retail grocery store around the entire Southland
that have about 50 stores around the area.
They have reported approximately 200,
200 retail thefts per day amongst their 50 stores.
And then to bring it more closer to home.
And this is a grocery store.
This is a grocery store chain in Southern California.
They're locking up these items.
Absolutely.
You can only imagine why they have to do this.
And then to bring it a little closer to home and more of a family nature,
we have seen up in Oxnard, up in the Ventura County area,
we saw a little league team and a little actually a little league organization just up in Oxnard
had thousands of dollars stolen in baseball mitts and gloves and equipment for kids
that really rely on this as an after school sport or a weekend sport.
But thousands of dollars in equipment just from a community backyard.
And then even to top it all off,
what we're just seeing also is not just retail theft.
We're not just seeing small businesses,
but we have seen so much porch piracy happen.
In America for over the past year and a half,
we have seen 260 million claims of porch piracy across the country.
Wow.
So this is just delivery items.
Just delivery items to front doors.
And again, what's happening is not just these things being stolen.
You know, you're looking for that transistor radio.
Do they make transistors anymore?
But anything you're ordering from Amazon or from somebody who's delivering,
now people are actually coming face to face with the perpetrator.
And as I said, eight in 10 people that were surveyed recently
are finding that these issues and these crimes are escalating
to violent physical activity between the perpetrator and the person who's catching them.
Old country soaps are handcrafted, long-lasting soap bars
made on a farm in South Dakota with soothing natural ingredients
without harsh chemicals that can dry out your skin.
They can produce a creamy lather unlike anything you've tried before.
Just a great American-made product that will leave your skin
feeling soft and smooth all day long.
The soap is multi-purpose.
You can also use it for your hair.
It's great for shaving and safe for pets.
Every order comes with an exfoliating soap bag.
It can hold smaller pieces of soap and can prevent soap bars from slipping out of the hand.
After each use, just leave the soap bar inside and hang dry.
It will last a long time.
This company does not sell on Amazon.
So go to oldcountrysoap.com and reward yourself and your loved ones.
Use promo code INSIDER and get an exclusive 20% off your order.
Let's support a company that brings back traditional American values and American manufacturing.
John, do you have some specific stories that you can share with us on this?
Who are these business owners and what kind of events are happening to them?
Yeah, it's really sad.
I mean, we do have some specific ones.
You know, a guy who does my dry cleaning in the Sacramento area
had his store broken into during COVID.
It was a dry cleaning store and they took all of the stuff in his cash register.
They took a lot of the clothing items that belonged to customers.
And he just looked at me and he said, you know, I just feel hopeless and helpless.
You know, I keep calling law enforcement.
I keep calling folks in my own backyard, you know, the police department.
I have friends at the DA's and others and I just get lip service because
it's not that they don't care.
It's that they don't have the resources to come and really,
in a timely manner, file the report and do what they need to do.
So that's a frustrated dry cleaner in Sacramento.
Closer down to Southern California, you know, there's a guy who's an
NFIB member who has a retail and beverage store in North County.
And within one month, he was broken into three times.
People just shattering the door, the window, taking the product.
And one of those three times, the person walked in, they were setting up and
they basically grabbed everything and they said, try and stop me.
Try and stop me.
And they kind of, you know, flex some muscle at them.
So you've got small business owners who are terrified because they either,
you know, they know that law enforcement, there's not a sufficient number of resources
to protect them.
But then you also have criminals who are basically escalating these problems.
And you can even get sued, right?
If you try to stop them and they get injured.
There's some legal risk, too, in this process of trying to stop people, right?
Absolutely.
And we've also seen that where perpetrators in recent months have tried to, you know,
have been committing crimes in our communities or even around the country.
And when people try to stop them, they are now finding themselves in court
for apprehending that criminal the wrong way, not leaving it to law enforcement,
which is ironic because they're nowhere to be found.
So this is a real problem that we're finding that people are worried,
especially in California, about being sued.
This lawsuit, legal event, illegal liability with small business owners,
but everyday Californians is another reason people may stand back and say, what can I do?
Do you think the business community has given up on this?
And they're just writing off the theft and saying,
fine, I'll just charge a little bit more to pay for the people that are stealing.
So the customer, you have to pay more if you want to come to my store.
And this is it.
Well, that's a really good question.
And I think that's what we are finding with the businesses that are not giving up.
And I think many of them are finding that with these kinds of thefts,
they have no choice but to close up shop.
That woman with the salons, right?
Yeah.
A hundred thousand dollars.
We had her on the show.
Yeah, right.
So, of course, but that's one example.
But we have found that for those who are willing to stick it out,
who really are willing to try and fight for this,
I think most of them are just trying to keep their head below radar, do what they can.
But what we've explained to the governor's team,
what we've explained to the attorney general's team and other policymakers is,
as we saw with the civil unrest in Los Angeles in the early 90s,
many of these business owners, many of them ethnic business owners,
Koreatown, Chinatown and Olvera Street area and just down in South Central,
many of them are taking the law into their own hands because this is all they've got.
They don't have a security guard.
They don't have anything.
But what they may have, and this should scare a lot of us, I've said,
weapons of their own, the ability where they will actually become vigilantes
to protect the livelihood of their store.
And what we've explained is we don't want to make violence create more violence.
And we want to make sure that, again, the real people who should be looking at this
and support it should be our law enforcement.
This shouldn't be in the hands of a guy who's behind a store
who has either a gun or a machete or whatever.
But we fear that those who do stick around
are going to become more vigilante business owners.
And that's the last thing any of us should want.
Let me give you an example.
Catalytic converter theft.
You're familiar with that, correct?
This is a very big topic.
The guy who works with me was bummed because he came in a couple hours late
because his catalytic converter was stolen
while he was trying to get on his way to work to work with us on retail theft issue.
There's a sad irony to that.
But to give you a perspective about how bad California has become in this,
it's just this area alone.
In 2018, there were about 1,500 catalytic converter thefts in California.
Just the last year in 2022,
we found about a little north of 51,000 catalytic converter thefts.
More than, we think, a thousand percent bump just in that alone.
And then across the nation,
we are finding that retailers have reported just over the past year
close to $94 billion in lost product due to these types of things.
So to answer your question,
Prop 47 is one thing that needs to be fixed.
But we also need to make sure that our law enforcement,
our local communities have more support
through better prosecuting opportunities.
Yes, security guards, law enforcement officers,
but also those tools.
Because I think what small businesses are feeling right now
is that they don't mean anything.
Did you ever think things will become like this in California?
Because you've been doing this for many years, right?
You've been advocating for these small businesses.
Did you ever think you have to do this for them on theft?
It's a really good question.
And I never thought that we'd have to address it
to the level that it has needed to be addressed.
I think we always knew that crime and small business crime exists,
and there's always a need to fix it.
But when we start to see stories like I said,
you know, where we found a woman who owns a beauty salon in Los Angeles,
she had five stores,
but she was robbed more than a half a dozen,
no, more than a dozen times
to where she's now had to close all five stores.
She just $100,000 to a small business owner like that lady
just isn't sustainable.
So no, I never believed in my wildest dreams
that we would see it get this bad.
But we ask our policymakers in Sacramento,
what are you doing to fix this?
And what happens when you ask that question?
Do they acknowledge there is a problem?
Do they not acknowledge?
Do they think this is okay?
What do you see when you talk to them?
Yes, I think my back is getting sore
from so many people patting me on the back
saying we're the backbone of the economy
and then doing nothing about it.
You know, again, what we have found is a lot of talk,
a lot of hyperbole about small businesses
and Main Street being the engine of our economy,
especially in election years.
But when it comes to those committee hearings
and when there's some real specific but realistic policy
that would help both rehabilitate
and move forward with accountability,
something just gets in the way.
And I think what gets in the way
is just more of this liberal philosophy,
which that, you know,
we just have a law enforcement community out there
that needs to be held more accountable than the criminal.
And I don't know what it takes,
but I will tell you that NFIB over this past year
was proud to join a coalition
of about 150 of the leading statewide business groups,
regional groups,
most of the crime victim advocates.
And our group is called
Californians Against Retail and Residential Theft or CART.
And we didn't plan the acronym to say CART,
like a cart in a shopping,
but our CART coalition is the one group
that is raising awareness about the impact this has
on small and ethnic businesses
and families in our neighborhoods.
A few policy makers in Sacramento,
we believe are just checking the box
by focusing on, due respect,
the Walmarts, the CVS Health, the Saks Fifth Avenue,
but they're doing nothing to address
the most vulnerable.
And let's not fool ourselves.
Your average little neighborhood retail store owner
can't afford security cameras, security guards.
They can't afford to reach out to a distribution center
to have stuff restocked overnight.
These are mom and pop stores.
They can't do it.
They will go under.
And unfortunately, many of them are.
So our coalition positive note is
we're not only urging our policy makers
to focus on our most vulnerable,
but we're also recognizing communities
like the city of Lakewood here in Southern California
that are doing cool things,
doing great things to abate and address retail crime
and residential crime.
Do you think this Proposition 47
is a root cause of all of this?
What are your thoughts?
Well, I don't think it's the root cause
of all of the problem,
but it is certainly not helped
and it is certainly not ameliorating the problem
that needs to be addressed.
And I will tell you that
when we saw this happen, though,
it wasn't a right wing, left wing organization
that decided to do a survey on it.
The California Independent Nonpartisan
Public Policy Institute of California
did a survey in the wake of Prop 47
and found that a significant increase
was directly correlated to Prop 47,
an increase in property crimes across the state.
So I think they saw even in the first year,
it was about a 9% increase.
And that was back in 2014.
But over the years,
the PPIC study has shown that our organization,
NFIB, amongst our small business members,
we asked them what needs to be done.
90% of our small business members,
it was about 14,000 in California,
90% of our responding members said,
we need to fix Prop 47.
It's not the only root.
I will say that, again,
we've had very lax laws
as it relates to things
that are making it easier
for reduced sentences for criminals
in our public institutions.
We have seen a lot of problems.
But one of the things I will tell you
is a lot of the problems we're finding
are in our state senate
and assembly public safety committees.
Can you tell us,
you are dealing with this, right?
You are actually talking to the state leaders
on these issues
on behalf of these businesses, right?
You're trying to...
And what is going on there?
What do they think?
What do they tell you?
Well, unfortunately,
what we're finding
amongst our policy makers in Sacramento
is there still seems to be an aversion
to do anything to touch Prop 47.
Again, Prop 47 has been found
by non-partisan organizations
to be tied to the problem
in retail crimes and property thefts.
So what I figured out about Prop 47
is it removes the fact
that if you do it multiple times,
before you get,
it will be a felony
and you go to prison, right?
And now if you can do it
as many times as you want,
as long as it's under $950,
you get a ticket, right?
Is that...
That's correct.
And it's not aggregated.
You're not aggregating
the number of these crimes
that are committed into that value.
So there's no reason
and it's no surprise
that a small retailer,
restaurant owner,
liquor store owner,
toy store owner,
you name it, right?
Is watching these criminals come in,
take the item
that's under that $950 value
and basically be able
to steal there,
go across the street,
steal again.
We have actually found,
talking to law enforcement officials,
that there are people
who actually in the Bay Area
actually take BART,
you know, the rapid transit system.
And they have a system
where they will go
from one city to the other
and take up to $950
in a day's period.
But the biggest problem
is we have policymakers
that are still not listening
and not waking up to fixing 47,
providing more funding
for our local law enforcement.
And we ask,
what does it take to do that?
Last, in 2022,
there were 17 pieces of legislation,
many authored by Democrats
and Republicans alike
that included diversion,
rehabilitation programs,
plus accountability for the crime.
None got out of committee.
None got out of our committee.
And this is like bills
by Democrats and Republicans or?
Correct.
Bills that would either,
you know, aggregate the crime
and include some
diversion rehabilitation programs,
because I think what you'll find
is many, if not most, agree
there's opportunity
to rehabilitate many people out there.
Absolutely.
Many criminals are just simply
not going to be rehabilitated,
but there is a zeal and a desire
to really try and do that.
So even bills that are legislation
that's authored by Democrats
and Republicans,
but Democrats,
the reigning House
and party in Sacramento
have tried bills
even this year in 2023
to reduce that number
back down to $400,
but include diversion programs,
include a chance
to rehabilitate these criminals.
And nothing has even moved again this year.
Why do you think it doesn't move?
Like what's going on?
How does this process work?
It's very frustrating.
We're truly trying to understand
what's inside the head
of many of these leaders.
I think we've, you know,
we've spoken with leadership
of the public safety committees.
Which is five members
of Senate and Assembly, right?
Correct.
There's a few more in the Assembly,
but you're right.
In the Assembly, there's more.
So each bill has to go through them, right?
Correct.
Anything that has to do
with public safety,
they have to say yes or no
before the Senators
or Assemblymen can vote on them, right?
That's correct.
And we've met with them
either by Zoom,
but we brought their own constituents
to meet with them.
They're constituents
who have been victims.
We brought in representatives
from the NAACP and ethnic groups
to talk to them about the problem.
Because it's also important to remember
many of these crimes,
be they property or violent
or what have you,
or residential,
have been, you know,
a number of them have been minorities
attacking their own fellow minorities
or other ethnic business owners.
So this is not a white versus black issue,
a racial issue.
These are Californians across the board
who are falling prey
to too much of this problem.
And it is a philosophical issue
with our leadership.
It is a philosophical.
Many of them believe
that the family will just
slap them on the wrist,
that they will get the message
by having their aunt or their mother
keeping an eye on them
and reining them in at a young age.
But it's not happening.
It is not happening.
So many of these are latchkey kids.
So we do need to do a better job
of making sure that
there's better programs
in our communities.
But we have to hold these criminals
100% accountable.
Why do you think,
so you're mentioning
this is a philosophical issue.
Is it because these people were involved?
Because in the Pop 47,
there is a lot of people
that are part of the current government.
They actually wrote or helped writing, right?
I think there are still many
who believe that
our correctional system
is a little bloated
in terms of people
who are behind bars
that shouldn't be
or could be out sooner,
that we need to really put
real criminals behind bars.
But the problem is
a lot of these shoplifters,
retail thieves,
and others who are now escalating
into greater physical crimes
are the ones who are going behind bars.
But even they believe
that those people should be out
in a short while.
They believe in zero,
many believe in zero bail
in a bail system
that should not exist in California.
But at the end of the day,
there is a feeling that really
we need to hug the criminal.
We need to give the perpetrator
more attention and care.
And nobody's disagreeing
that rehabilitation is important.
But the problem is
we are finding small business owners
who are falling prey to this.
If you were in charge,
how would you fix it?
Well, if I were in charge,
I would, first of all,
one of the things
the governor has a real opportunity
to do and our policymakers
is to convene a summit
on retail and residential crimes.
This is a problem
and Rome is burning.
California is burning, but Rome...
So we have to acknowledge this,
but the media is not doing that.
Because the percentages that we have
and the data that we're getting
is not really true data, right?
Well, it's been very difficult
to obtain data.
You know, so I think
one of the things that
fortunately, at least,
I think the attorney general
and the administration
are looking at is
how can we gather better data
from district attorneys,
sheriff's departments,
police departments.
There's been very poor.
There's a consensus for sure
that there's been a poor process
of the gathering
and assessing concrete data.
But when we talk about
some of these numbers
in terms of the spike
in crime over these years,
those are from the Federal
Bureau of Investigation.
I like to think the FBI
doesn't like to get...
doesn't lie and doesn't try to...
or I should say
doesn't become poetic justice
with what they report.
Those numbers are real numbers
from the FBI
in what they're finding
the crimes are happening right here
and across the nation.
We got to fix it.
So if I were in charge
to answer your question,
we would convene a summit.
I think it really is important
for our policymakers
to have a thoughtful discussion
with all the parties involved
about how to address this
and address it for small
and ethnic businesses
who are the most vulnerable
and families.
But I would also make sure
that we looked at a more
serious commitment to funding
local law enforcement
and our communities
and our cities
with better ability
and better tools
to protect the people
that they serve.
And then on top of that,
I think we're really looking
at no other option
than to really need
to address Prop 47
at the ballot box.
And maybe in 2024,
maybe after that.
But I would be calling upon
and I do call upon
the business community
to take a very serious look
at reforming Prop 47
and putting that investment
where it counts right now
so that their members,
but that also most
of our small businesses
and customers
and employees
are not feeling vulnerable.
When you talk to these lawmakers,
what do they tell you?
Do they just listen
and not or do they,
do they, what do they do?
Well, some of them
really are looking
to take this seriously.
And, you know,
so when we speak
with a guy like Al Marazzucci,
who's from the Manhattan Beach,
Redondo Beach area,
he was very serious.
I'm here to author
some legislation
that will really
both aggregate the crime,
but also look at some,
you know,
rehabilitation avenues for people.
We've seen others
like Roger Nilo,
a Republican senator.
You know, Marazzucci is a Democrat,
Republican,
but a moderate
up in Sacramento,
Roger Nilo,
who looked at really
looking at more accountability
that if you commit
that third retail theft crime,
you should have,
there should be more accountability
in terms of jail time.
But so we don't get
just lip service
from a number of them.
But from where we do feel
we get lip service
is from our policymakers
on those public safety committees
who say we are here to protect.
But at the end of the day,
the public safety
that they're protecting
are the people
who are out there
stealing the property,
taking the stereos,
taking the catalytic converters.
Oh, and then on top of that,
injuring or sometimes
killing people
who are trying to,
you know,
get in the way of that.
I'll tell you one real sad story
in San Jose
is a teenage clerk
was trying to stop
somebody in a retail store
from walking out
with one bottle of liquor.
And that teenager was killed.
It was since the first of this year.
A teenage clerk
who was just trying to stop.
We've also seen
with a larger store,
CVS Health, Walmart,
but also other stores,
people trying to ask them
for their receipt,
people walking out with the goods
and getting pistol whipped.
Seniors who are volunteering
to be a Walmart greeter.
We have we've seen footage
of seeing people like that
getting pistol whipped
by merely just trying to stop
the customer to ask for a receipt.
It's a real problem.
Our policymakers are not realizing
what needs to be done.
Our CART coalition,
Californians Against Retail
and Residential Theft at CART.org,
C-A-R-R-T dot org.
My egregious plug time
of the discussion.
But I will tell you
that that is where
people feel there's
what we're hoping to do
is turn up the noise,
make sure that our policymakers
are hearing about
these kinds of crimes
every day in their backyard,
that they feel uncomfortable enough
to actually want to make
some good happen
and protect us.
So, John,
if you had a few minutes
with the policymakers,
what would you tell them?
I would urge them to convene
a town hall discussion
with real experts on this
to do something to stop
and really address and fix
the issue of retail
and residential theft in California.
Number two,
I would really call upon
our public safety committees
to take a careful look and listen
and get a few realistic things passed
that would help us move forward,
at least that would combine
diversion with accountability,
which has come before.
So diversion meaning
not putting people in jail,
but just getting them.
Diversion, yeah,
or rehabilitation.
Yeah, there is a punishment
and you look at the person,
you know, there's some punishment.
And then I think third is for sure
is making sure our policymakers
who are who have been
still are underway
with the budget discussions
as we do this segment here
in May of 2023,
there is still an opportunity
to infuse some significant dollars
to protect our communities.
More tools, resources,
you know, ability for law enforcement
to really take this seriously
in our community
and to have the protections
that small and ethnic businesses
and families need.
Don't make your complete focus
the big box stores,
which again are a big problem
because a lot of people
are finding bigger volume
dollar thefts and crimes
that they can do there
and then resell them on retail
because that's another issue
they'll take the stuff
and sell it online.
But I would implore
and we have continued
to implore our leaders
to focus on those
who are the most vulnerable
who are our minority business owners,
our small business owners
and again, families and communities
that are these porch piracy
and catalytic converter victims
for which they feel
there is nobody there
to give them that help.
But CART, our coalition
is there to make sure
they have a voice
and that we are going
to get some things done.
I'm confident this year.
John Kabatack,
president of NFIB
for small businesses
representing small businesses
of California.
It was great to have you
on California Insider.
Always enjoy it.
It's always good to see you.
Thank you so much.
If you like the show
and our content,
you should go to InsiderCA.com
and sign up to our newsletter
because we never know
what can happen
with social media
and other platforms
in terms of distributing
our content.
If you like to come on the show
and be an insider,
you can reach out to us
at cainsider
at epochtimesca.com
Again, it's cainsider
at epochtimesca.com
We would love to have you
on the show to tell us
what's going on in your field
in California.
Thank you for watching.