The History of Pizza is Deliciously Debatable

History Of Food
342 followers
68 Video Views·Jun 26, 2023
The history of pizza is a large pie, half margarita and half lies.
The most famous story about its origins, in which the classic tricolor pie was created
to honor Queen Margarita of Savoy, is a work of fiction.
U.S. soldiers did not fall in love with pizza en masse during their time fighting World
War II and bringing it back to the States.
And the pizza in New York is not good because of the magical tap water.
Hi, I'm Justin Dodd, and now that I've alienated half of the audience, I will attempt
to argue that the real, verifiable history of pizza is even cooler than the bunkum in
Boulder Dash that often passes in its place.
That's right, bunkum in Boulder Dash.
Here is an incomplete list of pizza styles we'll be covering today.
Neapolitan, New York, Sicilian, St. Louis, Ohio Valley, Real Thing, Montanara, and Fugazza
con Queso.
We'll find out why Kim Jong-il flew a pizzaiolo into North Korea, analyze why a pie is so
much cheaper in Naples, Italy than Naples, Florida, and even discuss why some people
think the invention of pizza should be credited not to the Italians, but to the Greeks.
Uh oh, Nona is coming at me with a wooden spoon, and I don't think it's because
she wants me to taste her ragu.
Let's just roll the intro.
In 2014, newly elected New York Mayor Bill de Blasio set off a small international incident
when he was photographed eating his pizza with a knife and fork.
Jon Stewart was one of many to come out against de Blasio's tidy choice, calling it the
greatest sin a New Yorker can commit.
And lest we be accused of pizza partisanship, please note that future President Donald Trump
was convicted in the Court of Public Opinion for the same cutlery crime back in 2011.
In de Blasio's case, he defended himself with an appeal to his Italian heritage, saying,
in my ancestral homeland, it's more typical to eat with a fork and knife.
Sure enough, if you sit down at a pizzeria in Naples, you'll be served an uncut pie
in the silverware to eat it with.
Still, according to a YouGov poll conducted in the wake of the mostly faux outrage over
de Blasio's dining habits, over 90% of Americans eat pizza with their hands.
So was the then-mayor wrong?
Right?
Both.
And that's because pizza is at once internationally recognizable and completely regional.
That's why some people look at a Hawaiian pie and see the greatest crime ever committed
to leavened bread, and others see a beautiful story about immigration, intercultural influence,
and innovation.
Or at least lunch.
Let's start with the Neapolitan pie, from what is often called the birthplace of pizza,
Naples, Italy.
That's where the Queen Margherita story I mentioned up top comes from.
It supposedly took place in 1889 at a pizzeria that was once called Pietro e Basta Cosi,
or Pietro and That's Enough.
Yes.
In the more dramatic version of the legend, the Savoyard Queen of newly unified Italy
helped bring the country together by eating the people's humble food, a food that conveniently
shared a color scheme with the flag that had ruled different parts of the country
since the late 18th century.
Sure enough, there once was a pizzeria with that name, although the establishment, still
making pies today, is now called Brandi.
There was a Queen Margherita, too, and she might have had what we now call a margherita
pie.
Pizzeria Brandi certainly has a plaque on their wall that attests to the fact that they
knew a plaque guy.
Unfortunately, the pizza now known as Margherita predates this supposedly royal birth.
As Neapolitan—human, not pizza—Giuseppe A. D'Angelo wrote for his website PizzaDixit,
we can find,
A pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and basil in the 1853 book Customs and Habits
from Naples Described and Depicted, translated in English.
We've linked to D'Angelo's website down below, by the way.
It is awesome.
Okay, so maybe the pizza wasn't invented for the Queen, but named in her honor?
That may be so, but it's not clear it happened at Pizzeria Brandi.
And if the name does date back to 1889, it doesn't exactly take the city by storm.
Even almost a hundred years after the Queen was supposedly honored with the pizza shout-out,
it doesn't seem like everyone knew what the margherita pie was, even in Naples.
D'Angelo links to a 1967 RAI broadcast, in which a TV reporter from Naples seems
confused about what a margherita pie is.
He thinks it has an egg in the middle.
The pizzaiolo, or pizza maker, he's talking to has to clarify,
Emphasis very much added.
We'll probably never know who invented the margherita pie, or its humble sibling, the
marinara, which is topped simply with tomatoes, oil, garlic, and salt, though it often has
oregano and can be relatively gussied up with anchovies.
The thing that makes both labels so tricky to track is that pizza names weren't necessarily
a thing back in the 19th century.
According to food historian Tommaso Esposito, up until the mid-20th century, pizzas were
usually ordered by simply listing the ingredients you wanted on top.
Esposito wrote a book all about pizza songs, which, yes, that's a thing, from the 16th
century up until 1966, and found that none of the songs mentioned specific pizza types
by name.
It's true that the absence of proof is not the same thing as the proof of absence, but
it does seem notable that there's no written record of a margherita pizza being called
As evidence for their claim, Pizzeria Brandi points to a royal letter purportedly written
by Gali Camillo, the head of the table of the royal household, yet another career opportunity
I was unaware of when I picked college majors.
That letter, though, never refers to any particular pizza's name.
It certainly doesn't use the phrase pizza margherita.
It also might be a forgery, according to a piece by the Umber Institute's Zachary Novak.
There's no evidence of the letter in royal records, and it doesn't seem to match other
samples of Camillo's handwriting.
Novak also gets into the various types of royal seals Italian monarchs were and were
not known to use.
But at that point, we're getting so far into the weeds of food history that even I can't
go much deeper.
That's the thing about Neapolitan pizza, though.
It sort of encourages obsession.
The True Neapolitan Pizza Association publishes a set of what it calls international regulations,
and they aren't what you'd call loosey-goosey.
The AVPN permits, in the dough of its accredited pizza makers, a maximum of 20% regular flour,
as opposed to their preferred double-zero flour, which has an almost talcum powder-like
appearance, white, fine, and completely free of bran or germ.
They allow a 7 percentage point range in dough hydration, and have thoughts about your PL,
the balance between dough elasticity and plasticity, your fermentation process, and your tomatoes,
which preferably come from one of three places in Italy.
They are interested in only two types of pizza, margherita and marinara.
Let's touch on that second style briefly.
There are several popular stories for its name, which is Italian for mariner, so it
presumably meant something like sailor style.
One explanation says that's because sailors could bring the ingredients on long journeys.
I guess if the tomatoes were sun-dried, that makes sense.
Another story says that it was due to the humble ingredients which even low-paid sailors
could afford.
Whether that's true or not points to pizza's long-time role as a highly affordable meal.
Pizza in Italy likely started as an easy-to-make, cheap offering from bakers who could quickly
cook up the simple dough and then sell it on the street for pennies.
Neither of those two famous Neapolitan pie varieties would have been possible without
tomatoes.
They first appeared in Italian cookbooks in the late 17th century, but were introduced
to the continent a century earlier by the Spanish.
For those of you playing Food History Bingo, you can now mark off both the Columbian Exchange
and delicious dish that started as food for the poor.
When we think of pizza today, tomatoes, a crop the Aztecs had introduced to the Spanish,
often seem like an essential ingredient.
The Oxford English Dictionary, in fact, defines pizza as a dough baked with a topping of tomatoes,
cheese, and any of various other ingredients.
Anyone who's ever had a white pie might blanch at that definition.
The OED actually acknowledges, in an addendum, that some types of pizzas omit one or both
of the tomatoes and cheese.
That almost certainly includes the first pizzas ever called pizza.
There's a written record from Gaeta about 100 kilometers up the coast from Naples, dating
back to the end of the first millennium CE.
It lays out an agreement in which someone owes a local bishop 12 pizzas every Christmas
and Easter Sunday.
Remember, the closest tomatoes at that point were across the Atlantic Ocean.
We don't have any way to know exactly what that proto-pizza looked or tasted like, but
consider what the simplest version of a pre-Columbian exchange pizza might entail.
A simple Mediterranean flatbread, kinda like a pita.
Plenty of sources think this is no accident, and draw linguistic lines straight from pita
to pizza.
That's not the only possible etymology you'll find for the word, though.
Some claim it comes from the Germanic Lombards, related to their word bizzo, or bite.
A 1907 Italian etymology book ties it to pinza, which meant something like clamp.
Whichever is true, there's something revealing about the pita-pizza similarity.
People around the world have been making flatbreads of one type or another for thousands of years.
As we discussed in our episode about the most important foods of all time, the cultivation
of grains like wheat is inextricably linked to the rise of civilization, and it doesn't
take a little Caesar to put some tasty morsels on top of whatever simple bread you've got
around.
If we define pizza as a flatbread with toppings, we can imagine it being invented more or less
independently by the ancient Greeks, Egyptians, and Natufians from modern-day Jordan, who
were apparently making bread more than 14,000 years ago.
It's difficult to say how it ended up in Naples, precisely, but I will note, in a tentative
nod towards the pita-pizza hypothesis, that the Italian city was originally founded by
the Greeks, who gave it the name Neapolis around 600 BCE.
In Italy today, you can find different versions of tomato-less and or cheese-less pizza.
The most famous may be the Roman pizza bianca, which looks a lot like focaccia bread.
It's prepared differently than focaccia, though, and cooked in a hotter oven.
It's said to have a lighter and crunchier crust.
Pizza bianca is often split in half and stuffed with tasty fillings like mortadella, cheese,
or vegetables.
The idea of putting something delicious inside a pizza-like bread likely dates back thousands
of years.
According to Franceso Duccio's La Romanesca, enslaved people in ancient Rome used figs
for this purpose.
Figs might seem like an odd choice for a poverty food, but if you've ever had a neighbor with
a fig tree, you'll understand how they could grow to be abundant on Roman streets, which
they reportedly were in antiquity.
Even today, there's an Italian expression, mica pizza e fichi, literally, not pizza and
figs, that can be used to say something is valuable, or not totally simple.
Eventually, pizza with figs became popular beyond those who ate it out of economic necessity.
Wealthier eaters embellished the simple dish with prosciutto, creating a new variation
that harkens back to pizza's historical roots and remains popular today.
Its flavors are a study in contrast.
The sugar in the figs counteracts the fat of the ham, creating a delicious, salty-sweet
synergy.
On a completely unrelated note, Hawaiian pizza is the worst thing that's ever happened to
anybody.
Okay, I'm not gonna lie, fresh figs and delicious prosciutto does sound a little more appealing
than canned pineapples and American ham, but the similarities between the two salty-sweet
pies should, perhaps, cause culinary snobs to reconsider their pizza prejudice.
The Hawaiian pie was invented in 1962, according to most accounts, by Sam Panopoulos, a restaurateur
living in Ontario.
Sam was originally from Greece, and the boat he left on stopped fortuitously in Naples,
where he first became acquainted with pizza.
Sam did not then spend years perfecting a perfectly authentic Neapolitan pie.
His restaurants weren't pizzerias at all.
They served middle-of-the-road fare like hamburgers and pancakes.
Pizza, especially the Hawaiian pizza, was offered as a way to stand out from the crowd
to bring in business.
At the time, pizza didn't have much of a profile in Canada.
As Panopoulos said, even Toronto didn't know anything about pizza in those days.
The only place you could have pizza was in Detroit.
That has a little something to do with Gus Guerra, who is sometimes looked at as the
father of Detroit-style pizza.
This is my favorite style of pizza, for the record.
It's said to date back to the 1940s.
A Detroit pie looks a lot like Sicilian, but, according to tradition, is baked in a blue
steel pan like the ones that used to hold nuts and bolts in auto-manufacturing plants.
Whether or not Detroit-style pizzerias continue to employ that nod to the city's automobile
industry, the ideal Detroit pie has a lighter dough than its Chicago counterpart and crispy
cheese around the sides.
That delicious border is the result of the cheese, often a Wisconsin brick cheese, being
sprinkled over the dough edge to edge.
It then caramelizes in the oven.
Chicago-style pizza is usually traced back to 1943 at Pizzeria Uno.
The super-cheesy pies cooked for up to an hour and made use of a high-sided buttery
pastry shell crust.
Additional fat is provided by the olive oil that the pizza is generally cooked in, creating
a sort of fried outer crunch.
To protect the cheese, during that long bake time, the pie is usually constructed with
the sauce on top of the mozzarella.
A different approach to that same long cook time may have given us Ohio Valley-style pizza,
One of its defining features is the last-minute additions of cold toppings, including the
cheese.
Chicago-style pizza is sometimes called deep dish pizza, but even though it's cooked in
a pan, it's not usually called pan pizza.
That distinction belongs to its thicker, crusted cousin, which generally puts the cheese back
on top of the sauce.
If that sounds a little bit like something you can get at Pizza Hut, that is no accident.
The chain helped popularize what is often called pan pizza today.
Brothers Dan and Frank Carney started their chain in Wichita, Kansas, during the middle
of the previous century.
All of these thicker pizzas have a connection, if not historical, then at least spiritual,
with what many in the States call Sicilian pizza.
That square pie seems to descend from a Sicilian sfincione, a mozzarella-free offering that
is still popular in Sicily today.
It's usually topped with tomatoes and onions, and can also include anchovies and grated
caciocavolo cheese.
Sfincione translates to something like thick sponge.
Finally, a sponge I can eat free of judgment.
The so-called Sicilian pie, in places like New York, seems to be the result of immigrants
from Sicily getting cheap access to mozzarella, perhaps influenced by their Neapolitan neighbors.
On the opposite end of the crust continuum, we have St. Louis-style pizza.
This version uses an unleavened dough, creating a crisp, cracker-like texture.
It's usually topped with provolone, a processed cheese that combines qualities of provolone,
Swiss, and cheddar.
Instead of big square slices or familiar triangles, St. Louis pies are often cut tavern-style,
a ready-to-share presentation that can be found throughout the Midwest.
And of course, the United States isn't the only place Italian immigrants have influenced
the local cuisine.
In Argentina, people eat fugasa con queso, a pizza with onion and cheese whose name derives
from a version of the word focaccia.
In Italy, you can order pizza montanara, a fried variation of Neapolitan style.
Pizzaiolos drop the plain dough into hot oil to fry up, take it out, top it, and then finish
it quickly in a traditional oven.
That's not to be confused with pizza fritta, which is widely available in Naples.
In this version of fried pizza, the non-dough ingredients aren't toppings but fillings.
Everything gets folded into the dough and then fried up.
Many say this variation came about, or at least got popular, during food shortages of
World War II as a way to make otherwise undesirable ingredients palatable.
Those food shortages, incidentally, are why experts are dubious about the popular folk
history that says pizza became popular in America after G.I.s tried it during the war.
As food historian Simone Cinotto said, there were no ingredients for making pizza and many
of the ovens were actually destroyed by the bombings.
Most American servicemen never ended up on the Italian mainland and would most likely
have had to sample pizza in conflict-ravaged Naples since it wasn't popular throughout
the country.
That's not an impossibility, but probably not the primary cause of pizza's worldwide
domination in the next half century.
Sure enough, in 1947, two years after the war had concluded, the New York Times lamented
that pizza could be as popular a snack as the hamburger if Americans only knew more
about it.
In the case of pizza fritta, the war and its attendant challenges may have contributed
to the dish's spread, but it certainly wasn't the first fried dough in Italian cuisine.
There are examples dating back to the 1500s, including an early version of zeppole, which
can be sweet or savory.
Anyone who's been to the Feast of San Gennaro in Little Italy knows that New Yorkers happily
adopted zeppole.
And, of course, they put their own spin on pizza.
Lombardi's is often called the United States' first pizzeria.
Gennaro Lombardi opened it in Little Italy back in 1905, according to the restaurant's
website.
Lombardi, like most of the first American pizzaiolos, learned his craft in Naples.
So how did New York develop its own signature style?
According to a piece written by Ed Levine for Serious Eats, technology played a big
part.
In fact, early 20th century New York pizza parlors used coal-fired ovens, which could
reach the kind of rip-roaring temperatures found in Naples' wood-fired analogues.
They had the added benefit of saving space and money, since they burned more efficiently.
The result was not an exact replication of Neapolitan pizza, but was close enough that
it was generally served in the same fashion, in whole pies and eaten immediately.
When Italian-American immigrant Frank Mastro developed and began successfully selling a
gas-burning pizza oven a few decades later, its temperature maxed out around 550 degrees
Fahrenheit, as opposed to the 800 degrees or more achievable with coal and wood.
It might not have the ephemeral airiness of a great Neapolitan pie, but that drier pizza
does have a longer shelf life.
As pizza historian Scott Wiener said, pizza by the slices has to be reheated most of the
time.
So that oven is a big deal.
In the ensuing decades, iconic slice shops started to proliferate throughout the five
Though the oven may play a big role in New York-style pizza, the water, despite what
you might hear, probably doesn't.
People say that New York tap water contains the perfect amount of trace minerals to create
an ideal dough.
There's actually a certain amount of logic to this claim.
Relatively soft water, like New York's, can taste different than hard water, and elements
like calcium and magnesium can theoretically affect the gluten structure in bread, creating
a tougher final product.
In practice, though, when J. Kenji Lopez-Alt designed a semi-scientific experiment to test
the effect of water hardness on the quality of pizza dough, he found no direct relationship
between total dissolved solids in the water and final crust quality.
The magical New York tap water theory also takes a hit when you take into account the
incredible pizza you can get in locations as far-flung as Naples, Italy and Phoenix,
Arizona.
The latter is where Chris Bianco opened his first renowned pizzeria, helping to set off
a nationwide interest in Neapolitan, sometimes called Neo-Neapolitan pizza, made with high-quality
ingredients in wood-fired ovens.
In 2003, Bianco became the first pizzaiolo to win the James Beard Award for Best Chef
Southwest.
About 15 months later, BBC Radio 3 documented a very different honor bestowed upon a pizza
maker and culinary instructor named Armano Ferlanes.
He was flown from Italy to North Korea, under rather opaque circumstances, to teach military
officers about making pizza.
It's hard to independently confirm the details of Ferlanes' account, for obvious reasons,
but it is true that North Korea's then-Supreme Leader Kim Jong-il was known to be a gourmand.
He actually opened the famine-ravaged country's first pizzeria in 2009.
Ferlanes' story includes one incident in which his attentive pupils even asked to count
the number of olives on one of his pies and measure the distance between them.
It's a funny detail with potentially sinister sociopolitical undertones.
But in a way, measuring olive distance isn't so far removed from the quest for authenticity
that countless cooks have put themselves through.
I think today, the prevailing attitude of people in the food world towards authenticity
is one of reservation, if not outright rejection.
This series certainly speaks to how slippery the notion of authentic is, given how much
food and the way we relate to it is constantly changing.
But pizza, I think, speaks simultaneously to both sides of this debate.
On the one hand, it took a healthy disrespect of tradition to invent delicious new creations
like deep-dish pizza or even a white pie with prosciutto and figs.
But on the other hand, there's something beautiful about spending countless hours tinkering
with just the few variables to create the perfectly authentic Neapolitan pie.
Even if we acknowledge that the rather strict definition of an authentic Neapolitan pie
was invented by a non-profit organization founded in 1984.
No two days for a pizzaiolo are ever the same.
The yeast is alive.
The fire might as well be.
Temperature and humidity change.
There's something poetic about the almost Sisyphean task of trying to hit so many moving
targets at once.
In this context, authenticity has the potential to be more than an outdated marketing buzzword.
It can refer to the meditative act of paying attention, pursuing perfection, reaching for
an ideal that might only live in your own mind.
For my money, the best pizza in New York today can be found at Lucali in Carroll Gardens,
Brooklyn, and that's no small amount of money.
Pies there start at $30 a pop.
In Naples, meanwhile, an equally delicious offering can be purchased for about $6.
Part of that difference can be attributed to real estate.
A two-bedroom apartment on the same block as Lucali sold in 2021 for almost $1.5 million.
A similarly-sized place in Naples can go for a quarter of that price.
Part of it comes down to cooking style.
A true Neapolitan pie is made from a ball of dough between 200 and 280 grams and topped
sparingly.
When a New York Times writer weighed a single slice from rays of Greenwich Village, it clocked
in at about 240 grams.
Lucali was started by Mark Iacono, a Brooklyn-born marble worker who had never made pizza professionally
or even been to Italy before he opened his shop.
It's true that the high prices at Lucali owe a debt to effective, no-frills marketing
and presumably unpaid celebrity endorsements from the likes of Beyonce and David Beckham.
But Iacono, for all his plaudits, seems caught between two worlds.
His pizza is practically fine dining.
And yet, he once said, a good New York slice trumps every kind of pizza.
Iacono's love for the humble slice is no doubt genuine.
But to achieve the kind of pizza perfection he's still churning out requires the kind
of monastic devotion great pizzaiolos around the world have long exhibited.
After he signed his lease, it took Iacono more than two years of practicing his craft
in anonymity before he felt he was ready to open up to the public.
His delicious plain pie refers, indirectly, tangentially, almost mythically, to the most
traditional Neapolitan pizza.
But he doesn't call it a margarita because, as a 2015 profile in the New York Times said,
Carol Gardens isn't Naples.
Neapolitan is the one true pizza.
And there is no one true pizza.
A plain pie should be a simple, affordable, working-class food.
And it should be celebrated for its artistry and valued accordingly.
Half margarita, half lies.
Let us know your personal favorite pizza place in the comments below.
Let's celebrate pizza's hyper-regionality, wherever you're tuning in from.
Thanks for watching, and we'll see you next time.
